Comparison of the effects of liquid medium repair and the incorporation of catalase in MacConkey type media on the recovery of Enterobacteriaceae sublethally stressed by freezing

Stressed salmonella are exposed to reactive oxygen species from two independent sources during recovery in conventional culture media

Previously, Stephens et al. [J. Appl. Microbiol. 83 (1997) 445-455] developed a sensitive technique for studying the resuscitation of low levels of stressed Salmonella. Using this technique the influence on recovery performance of the peptone component of buffered peptone water was investigated. Within 12 different peptone types as much as 3.5 log10 cells/ml difference was observed between the best and worst performing formulations. Poor recovery performance was linked to reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation through auto-oxidation of reducing sugars and photo-sensitisation of sensitive components such as riboflavin. Supplementary recovery agents were explored with only Oxyrase, which has both enzymes to degrade ROS and the ability to rapidly turn a medium anaerobic, having any significant effect. It improved the speed of recovery and increased, by up to 100-fold, the number of stressed cells recovered. Stressed cells were further studied by flow cytometry with cell sorting, based on the staining pattern from a novel fluorochrome combination, into good and poor recovery media. It was identified that within a stressed population the removal of all oxygen protected actively respiring cells the most by forcing them to generate energy from anaerobic metabolism thus avoiding any risk from accidental endogenous ROS generation. The recognition of two independent sources of oxidative stress in the routine use of conventional culture media is discussed in relation to pathogen detection and other areas of food microbiology.

Selective enrichment with a resuscitation step for isolation of freeze-injured Escherichia coli O157:H7 from foods

We studied injury of Escherichia coli O157:H7 cells in 11 food items during freeze storage and methods of isolating freeze-injured E. coli O157:H7 cells from foods. Food samples inoculated with E. coli O157:H7 were stored for 16 weeks at -20 degrees C in a freezer. Noninjured and injured cells were counted by using tryptic soy agar and sorbitol MacConkey agar supplemented with cefixime and potassium tellurite. Large populations of E. coli O157:H7 cells were injured in salted cabbage, grated radish, seaweed, and tomato samples. In an experiment to detect E. coli O157:H7 in food samples artificially contaminated with freeze-injured E. coli O157:H7 cells, the organism was recovered most efficiently after the samples were incubated in modified E. coli broth without bile salts at 25 degrees C for 2 h and then selectively enriched at 42 degrees C for 18 h by adding bile salts and novobiocin. Our enrichment method was further evaluated by isolating E. coli O157:H7 from frozen foods inoculated with the organism prior to freezing. Two hours of resuscitation at 25 degrees C in nonselective broth improved recovery of E. coli O157:H7 from frozen grated radishes and strawberries, demonstrating that the resuscitation step is very effective for isolating E. coli O157:H7 from frozen foods contaminated with injured E. coli O157:H7 cells.

Bacterial viability and culturability

Renewed interest in the relationships between viability and culturability in bacteria stems from three sources: (1) the recognition that there are many bacteria in the biosphere that have never been propagated or characterized in laboratory culture; (2) the proposal that some readily culturable bacteria may respond to certain stimuli by entering a temporarily non-culturable state termed 'viable but non-culturable' (VBNC) by some authors; and (3) the development of new techniques that facilitate demonstration of activity, integrity and composition of non-culturable bacterial cells. We review the background to these areas of interest emphasizing the view that, in an operational context, the term VBNC is self-contradictory (Kell et al., 1998) and the likely distinctions between temporarily non-culturable bacteria and those that have never been cultured. We consider developments in our knowledge of physiological processes in bacteria that may influence the outcome of a culturability test (injury and recovery, ageing, adaptation and differentiation, substrate-accelerated death and other forms of metabolic self-destruction, prophages, toxin-antitoxin systems and cell-to-cell communication). Finally, we discuss whether it is appropriate to consider the viability of individual bacteria or whether, in some circumstances, it may be more appropriate to consider viability as a property of a community of bacteria.

Evaluation of enrichment broths for their ability to recover heat-injured Listeria monocytogenes

Listeria selective enrichment broth (LEB), University of Vermont (UVM) broth, modified UVM (MUVM) broth and Fraser broth (FB) were compared for their ability to recover cells of L. monocytogenes from heated tryptose phosphate broth. Three strains of L. monocytogenes were heated at 54 degrees C for 30 min, inoculated into enrichment broths supplemented with 400 micrograms catalase ml-1, and incubated for 8 h at 30 degrees C. After incubation for 4 h, the total viable cell populations either decreased or did not change, whereas the number of healthy (non-injured) cells of all strains increased significantly in all broths except FB inoculated with the LCDC strain. With an increase in incubation time to 8 h, the number of healthy cells of all strains increased in all broths. At 8 h, the difference between populations of total (injured plus healthy cells) and healthy cells detected in LEB inoculated with two strains was not significant. Overall, recovery of heat-treated cells was significantly higher in LEB, followed by MUVM broth, UVM broth and FB. The addition of catalase to enrichment broths significantly enhanced recovery of heat-injured cells. A slight reduction of catalase activity of heated cells of all test strains in all enrichment broths except FB was observed by extending the incubation period from 4 to 8 h. A test strain that produces relatively higher catalase activity compared to the other strains exhibited the greatest resistance to exogenous hydrogen peroxide. Enumeration of viable L. monocytogenes cells in heated foods should be done using LEB supplemented with 400 micrograms catalase ml-1 to maximize the recovery of injured cells.

Prevalence of campylobacter in pigs during fattening; an epidemiological study

Numerous epidemiological reports implicate foods of animal origin as vehicles of human campylobacteriosis. Pigs are probably an important reservoir of campylobacter and a potential source of human infection. In order to improve our knowledge of the epidemiology of campylobacter in pigs, the prevalence of campylobacter and its contamination of feed were monitored in eight pig farms. Faeces samples of pigs aged 11 and 22 weeks, and samples of rectal, ileal and gastric content at a slaughterhouse were collected for bacteriological examination. On 5 farms, subsequent groups of pigs housed in the same stalls was sampled, too. A selection of the campylobacter isolates was characterized with a genetic typing method (RFLP). More than 85% of the sampled porkers were shown to be intestinal carriers of campylobacter at all stages of fattening. Subsequent groups of pigs housed in the same stalls were all carriers, too. The level of campylobacters in the faeces tended to decrease as the pigs got older. There was no difference in the frequency and level of infection with campylobacter between porkers on different farms. The feeding system (wet feed versus dry pellets) did not seem to influence the prevalence of campylobacter although wet feed gave lower counts of Enterobacteriaceae in the faeces. RFLP-typing showed a high diversity of campylobacter strains at each sampling on the farm. Similarities were seen between strains isolated during two subsequent samplings of the same group of pigs, but not between strains isolated on the same farm from subsequent groups of pigs housed in the same stall. This suggests that the piglets were already infected at a young age on the breeding farm.

Microbial and nutritional aspects of feeding fermented feed (poultry by-products) to pigs

Broiler by-products (heads, feet, and viscera) mixed with 4% dextrose were pasteurized for 4 min at 90 degrees C core temperature, cooled to 20 degrees C, and fermented with Lactobacillus plantarum as starter culture. These fermented poultry by-products were fed to 12 individually housed fattening pigs as part (17.6% of the dry matter) of their fattening ration, the remainder composed of compound pig feed. Control pigs received a compound pig feed only. Both groups of pigs were fed restrictively on the basis of body weight. The technical results of the pigs fed the experimental diet showed a significantly improved feed:gain ratio (2.46 vs 2.57), a significantly higher carcass weight (86.1 vs 81.8 kg), a lower meat percentage (50.9 vs 52.5%) and an increased backfat thickness (21.5 vs 18.7%). The bacterial flora in the intestinal tract of the pigs fed the experimental diet differed significantly from the control animals. Decreased colony counts of mesophilic aerobic bacteria, Enterobacteriaceae, enterococci and lactobacilli were found in the rectal content and the prevalence of salmonella was lower. It is suggested that the improved feed:gain ratio and the reduced bacterial activity of the measured groups of bacteria is a result of 1) the higher energy content of the diet, and(or) 2) an assumed enhanced digestibility of nutritional components in the diet, and(or) 3) the lower incidence of diarrhea in the pigs fed with fermented poultry by-products. This resulted in a lower contamination level of enteropathogenic bacteria like, salmonella and Escherichia coli, in the gastro-intestinal tract of the pigs fed fermented poultry by-products.

Repair and enterotoxin synthesis by Staphylococcus aureus after thermal shock

To study repair and enterotoxin synthesis, four staphylococcal strains (FRI-100, FRI-137, FRI-472, and S6) were subjected to sublethal heat treatment, transferred to four liquid repair media (1% powdered skim milk in distilled water, complex medium, M9 minimal salt medium, and saline solution), and then incubated at different temperatures. Powdered skim milk proved to be the most efficient medium for promoting the repair of injured cells, particularly at 37 degrees C. Minimal salt medium also gave good results. Salt tolerance also increased at 4 degrees C, although it did not reach normal values. After 6 h of incubation at 37 degrees C in powdered skim milk, strain FRI-100 synthesized detectable amounts of enterotoxin A. After 10 h of incubation in the same medium at the same temperature, enterotoxins were detected in all of the strains.

Microcolony epifluorescence microscopy for selective enumeration of injured bacteria in frozen and heat-treated foods

A rapid (less than 6 h) method for selectively enumerating coliforms, pseudomonads, and staphylococci has been developed which involves counting microcolonies grown on the surface of polycarbonate membranes under selective conditions. The method was not directly applicable to foods containing injured bacteria due to the poor formation of or an inability to form microcolonies under selective conditions. However, the introduction of a 3- to 5-h resuscitation step in tryptone soya broth allowed the method to give reliable estimates of these organisms in a variety of frozen and heat-processed foods. Under nonselective conditions, i.e., for total counts, the microcolony method enabled a rapid count to be made of viable bacteria in heat-treated foods, but these results were also made more consistent by the introduction of a resuscitation step. This method makes results from these foods available far faster than conventional enumeration methods.

Bacteriological quality of broiler carcasses as affected by in-plant lactic acid decontamination

In an attempt to improve the bacteriological quality of broiler carcasses the bactericidal effect of treatments with 1% and 2% lactic acid was investigated. Bacterial colonisation was determined immediately after treatment, after the carcasses had been chilled and during storage at 0 degrees C. Examination included numbers of mesophilic aerobic and psychrotrophic aerobic colony-forming units (CFU), CFU of Enterobacteriaceae at 37 degrees C and CFU of Staphylococcus aureus. Immediately after treatment colonisation per gram skin was generally reduced by about 1 log. Initially 2% lactic acid was not found significantly more effective in reducing colony counts than 1%. However, treatment with 2% lactic acid suppressed post-decontamination colonisation with Enterobacteriaceae more effectively than 1% lactic acid, as determined after 15-18 days storage at about 0 degrees C. Lactic acid treatment was most effective when applied shortly before chilling. Successive treatment at three different stages during slaughtering did not increase reduction of colony counts. It is concluded that decontamination with 1-2% lactic acid at pH 2, when applied shortly before chilling, will markedly improve the bacterial safety and increase the refrigerated shelf life of broiler carcasses.

Bacteriological quality assurance (BQA) of mechanically deboned meat (MDM)

Adequacy of bacteriological quality assurance during the commercial production of mechanically deboned meat (MDM) was assessed. Lax standards of hygiene during production were observed, resulting in high numbers of Staphylococcus aureus, viz. 10(4) to 10(5) cfu g(-1), and severe contamination with Enterobacteriaceae: 10(5) to 10(6) cfu g(-1). These data indicate that measures of hygiene observed during boning of carcasses and during collection, storage and transport of bones or poultry parts should be markedly tightened, while conditions of refrigerated storage of raw materials and MDM should be improved. Use of bones of poor sensory quality (discoloration, abnormal smell) generally resulted in MDM of inferior bacteriological quality. Phage typing, biotyping and assessment of enterotoxin production was carried out with 136 St. aureus cultures, isolates from mechanically deboned pork produced at one plant. Fifty-five per cent of the isolates was not typable, 28% was typable with human phages, 8% with bovine phages. The majority of the strains could not be explicitly assigned to any Meyer and/or Hájek and Marŝálek types. Applying the simplified system of Devriese to eighteen strains isolated in our investigation, ten were found to belong to the poultry ecovar, one to the bovine ecovar, while seven strains were non-host specific. None of the isolates produced enterotoxins A-E. Microbiological inspection of end products is recommended as part of an integrated quality assurance system. The following reference values for the final product (maximal colony counts to be expected under GMP conditions expressed as 95th percentile) were calculated: Pig MDM: log(10) mesophilic colony count 6·8 and log(10) cfu mesophilic Enterobacteriaceae g(-1) 4·8; Poultry MDM: log(10) mesophilic colony count 6·6 and log(10) cfu mesophilic Enterobacteriaceae g(-1) 4·7.

The enumeration of thermotrophic types amongst the Enterobacteriaceae colonizing perishable foods

A total of 41 pure cultures of Enterobacteriaceae, comprising 32 thermotrophic and nine psychrotrophic strains, pathogens or marker organisms, were examined for numbers of colony forming units obtained at 37 degrees and 42.5 degrees C (thermotrophs) and 30 degrees C (psychrotrophs), when surface-plated on a rich infusion agar and violet red bile agar. In addition 42 food and water samples, collected in a rural area of the Philippines, were examined by surface inoculating violet red bile AIPC (agar immersion plating and contact; 'dip') slides and incubating at 37 degrees and 42.5 degrees C. At 42.5 degrees C there was almost total recovery of the thermotrophic Enterobacteriaceae, whereas the psychrotrophic strains were completely suppressed. At 37 degrees C the psychrotrophs were only slightly inhibited. The Philippine foods, predominantly cooked meals, milk and drinking water, appeared to be significantly colonized by thermotrophic Enterobacteriaceae. It is concluded that incubation at 42.5 degrees C satisfactorily selects enteropathogenic and other enteric Enterobacteriaceae while suppressing the psychrotrophic types which are mainly of vegetable origin. It is emphasized that, regardless of the temperature used, a resuscitation procedure for Enterobacteriaceae populations that have incurred sublethal injury in food has to precede counts on or in the usual selective media.

Hygienic aspects of porcine gullets

In an attempt to elaborate good manufacturing practices, including the collection, processing and storage of porcine gullets, their bacterial condition immediately after collection (100 samples), as well as that of deep frozen gullets just before incorporation into meat products (40 samples), was assessed. Fresh gullets were found to be contaminated to a high degree: poured plate colony count at 30°C (PPCC) approximately 10(6) to 10(7) and Enterobacteriaceae approximately 10(3) to 10(4) cfu g(-1). Deep frozen gullets showed even higher counts: PPCC approximately 10(7) to 10(8) and Enterobacteriaceae approximately 10(4) to 10(5) cfu g(-1). Hygiene during collection was visually assessed in six abattoirs and found to be satisfactory in two, moderate in three and poor in one. The effects of processing, by cleaning or removal of the mucus membrane, on bacterial condition, pH, colour and odour were assessed before and during storage at 4°C and 20°C. Both cleaning and removal of the mucus membrane resulted in up to approximately a tenfold reduction of colony counts. After 7 days' storage at 4°C these were significantly lower than those of unprocessed gullets (P < 0·01). Processed gullets stored at 4°C were no longer fit for consumption after 4 days' storage. It being impossible to achieve a marked improvement in the bacteriological condition of gullets, the incorporation of these products into sausages should be discouraged and their use in petfoods only allowed under reasonable conditions of hygiene and chilling.

A centenary of academic and less learned food microbiology. Pitfalls of the past and promises for the future

A review is presented of the development of Food Microbiology from its roots in different disciplines - including human and animal medicine, general microbiology, agricultural science and food chemistry - to an autonomous science with the main vocation to provide the knowledge allowing providing food that is wholesome, of high quality and acceptable in the microbiological sense. This evolution entailed a change in approach from mere, and often rather primitive inspection of end-products to intervention by (i) identification of hazard points ("critical points" or CPs) by ecological studies; (ii) elimination of CPs by elaboration of Good Manufacturing and Distribution Practices (GMPs); (iii) validation of GMPs by monitoring production lines and final products at point of sale and gauging the results by Risk Analysis. It is emphasized, that although advanced and ecologically sound techniques have become available, it will still require extensive education and training at all levels before the scientific advances outlined in this review will have been fully integrated in day-to-day food production and catering in developed as well developing areas of the world. Interdisciplinary instruction and co-operation cannot be missed in attempts to reach this goal.

A note on catalase enhanced recovery of acid injured cells of gram negative bacteria and its consequences for the assessment of the lethality of L-lactic acid decontamination of raw meat surfaces

Addition of catalase (150 units/ml) to a rich infusion agar used for solid medium repair of acid injured pathogenic Enterobacteriaceae increased the recovery of such populations by 1-2 log cycles entailing an equal size reduction in the true lethality of this mode of processing for safety.