Comparison of the inactivation of Bacillus subtilis spores and MS2 bacteriophage by MIOX, ClorTec and hypochlorite

Boosting hypochlorite's disinfection power through pH modulation

PURPOSE

Hypochlorite-based formulations are widely used for surface disinfection. However, the efficacy of hypochlorite against spore-forming bacteria varies significantly in the literature. Although neutral or low pH hypochlorite solutions are effective sporicides due to the formation of hypochlorous acid (HOCl), their optimal conditions and the specific role of pH in disinfection remain unclear. These conditions also increase the solution's corrosiveness and compromise its shelf life. Therefore, further research is needed to identify the pH conditions that balance solution stability and effective hypochlorite-based spore disinfection.

RESULTS

This study investigates the impact of neutral to alkaline pH on the sporicidal efficiency of hypochlorite against a pathogenic Bacillus cereus strain. We apply a 5,000 ppm hypochlorite formulation for 10-min across a pH range of 7.0-12.0, simulating common surface decontamination practices. Our results demonstrate that hypochlorite is largely ineffective at pH levels above 11.0, showing less than 1-log reduction in spore viability. However, there is a significant increase in sporicidal efficiency between pH 11.0 and 9.5, with a 4-log reduction in viability. This pH level corresponds to 2 - 55 ppm of the HOCl ionic form of hypochlorite. Further reduction in pH slightly improves the disinfection efficacy. However, the shelf life of hypochlorite solution decreases exponentially below pH 8.5. To explore the pH-dependent efficacy of hypochlorite, Raman spectroscopy and fluorescence imaging were used to investigate the biochemical mechanisms of spore decontamination. Results showed that lower pH enhances spore permeability and promotes calcium dipicolinic acid (CaDPA) release from the core.

CONCLUSION

Our results highlight the complex relationship between pH, sporicidal efficacy of hypochlorite, and its shelf life. While lower pH enhances the sporicidal efficiency, it compromises the solution's shelf life. A pH of 9.5 offers a balance, significantly improving shelf life compared to previously suggested pH ranges 7.0-8.0 while maintaining effective spore inactivation. Our findings challenge the common practice of diluting sodium hypochlorite with water to a 5,000 ppm solution, as this highly alkaline solution (pH of 11.9), is insufficient for eliminating B. cereus spores, even after a 10-min exposure. These findings are critical for improving disinfection practices, highlighting the importance of optimizing sodium hypochlorite effectiveness through pH adjustments before application.

The virus removal in UV irradiation, ozonation and chlorination

The COVID-19 pandemic draws much attention to virus inactivation since the SARS-CoV-2 was detected in miscellaneous environments and the wastewater can be a potential transmitting pathway. UV irradiation, ozonation and chlorination are widely used disinfection processes in water treatment. In this review, the mechanisms and applications of three disinfection processes are introduced, and their inactivation effects on virus as well as other microorganisms are compared and discussed. The resistance of viruses to UV irradiation is generally stronger than that of bacteria. 4-log inactivation of bacteria can be easily obtained within a UV dose of 10 ​mJ/cm². However, the doses to reach the same virus removal rate vary greatly from 10 to 140 ​mJ/cm². The coronaviruses have even stronger UV resistance. Comparatively, ozonation and chlorination are effective methods to inactivate viruses, and the CT values of 4-log removal for most viruses concerned are lower than 1 ​mg·min/L and 10 ​mg·min/L, respectively. Protozoa, fungal spores and bacterial spores are more resistant to disinfection. Temperature, pH, organic matters, turbidity and other parameters all have influences on the disinfection. With a 10 ​°C decrease in temperature, the CT value required for certain removal rates doubles. Generally low pH promotes disinfection and high pH is against it. In drinking water and wastewater treatment process, the resistance properties of microorganisms and other influence parameters should be taken into consideration when choosing disinfection technologies.