Unsuspected rejection episodes on routine surveillance endomyocardial biopsy post-heart transplant in paediatric patients

Decreasing Endomyocardial Biopsy Frequency in Pediatric Heart Transplantation Using A Rejection Risk Prediction Score-A Single Center Study

BACKGROUND

Rejection remains an important cause of morbidity and mortality after pediatric heart transplantation (HT). Endomyocardial biopsy (EMB) is the gold standard for rejection diagnosis, but it comes with procedural risk. The frequency of EMB varies significantly across centers. Since April 2018, our center's surveillance EMB schedule is based on a rejection risk prediction score employing age, pre-HT diagnosis, and panel reactive antibodies (PRA). We aimed to evaluate outcomes in the 1st year post-HT before and after risk score implementation.

METHODS

Patients who underwent HT at our center at ≤ 18 years of age from January 2015 to December 2020 were reviewed. The primary endpoint was rejection-free survival at 1 year-post- HT. Clinical characteristics were compared for patients transplanted in Era 1 (January 2015-April 2018) and Era 2 (April 2018-December 2020). Cumulative 1-year survival free from rejection and from rejection with hemodynamic compromise (RHC) was compared between eras using Kaplan-Meier survival analysis.

RESULTS

115 patients underwent HT during our study period (52 in Era 1 and 63 in Era 2). There was an increase in VAD utilization between eras (19% in Era 1 vs. 40% in Era 2, p = 0.025), but otherwise no significant difference in demographic or clinical variables between the two eras. No statistically significant difference in freedom from rejection or freedom from RHC was identified between the two eras. There was a 60% reduction in the median number of EMB per patient in the first year post-HT after employing the score (5 in Era 1 vs. 2 in Era 2, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

After employing a rejection risk prediction score, our center decreased the frequency of EMB without worsening early post-HT outcomes, thus establishing the clinical applicability of this tool.

Rejection surveillance in pediatric heart transplant recipients: Critical reflection on the role of frequent and long-term routine surveillance endomyocardial biopsies and comprehensive review of non-invasive rejection screening tools

BACKGROUND

Despite significant medical advances in the field of pediatric heart transplantation (HT), acute rejection remains an important cause of morbidity and mortality. Endomyocardial biopsy (EMB) remains the gold-standard method for diagnosing rejection but is an invasive, expensive, and stressful process. Given the potential adverse consequences of rejection, routine post-transplant rejection surveillance protocols incorporating EMB are widely employed to detect asymptomatic rejection. Each center employs their own specific routine rejection surveillance protocol, with no consensus on the optimal approach and with high inter-center variability. The utility of high-frequency and long-term routine surveillance biopsies (RSB) in pediatric HT has been called into question.

METHODS

Sources for this comprehensive review were primarily identified through searches in biomedical databases including MEDLINE and Embase.

RESULTS

The available literature suggests that the diagnostic yield of RSB is low beyond the first year post-HT and that a reduction in RSB intensity from high-frequency to low-frequency can be done safely with no impact on early and mid-term survival. Though there are emerging non-invasive methods of detecting asymptomatic rejection, the evidence is not yet strong enough for any test to replace EMB.

CONCLUSION

Overall, pediatric HT centers in North America should likely be doing fewer RSB than are currently performed. Risk factors for rejection should be considered when designing the optimal rejection surveillance strategy. Noninvasive testing including emerging biomarkers may have a complementary role to aid in safely reducing the need for RSB.

Impact of institutional routine surveillance endomyocardial biopsy frequency in the first year on rejection and graft survival in pediatric heart transplantation

BACKGROUND

Routine surveillance biopsy (RSB) is performed to detect asymptomatic acute rejection (AR) after heart transplantation (HT). Variation in pediatric RSB across institutions is high. We examined center-based variation in RSB and its relationship to graft loss, AR, coronary artery vasculopathy (CAV), and cost of care during the first year post-HT.

METHODS

We linked the Pediatric Health Information System (PHIS) and Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients (SRTR, 2002-2016), including all primary-HT aged 0-21 years. We characterized centers by RSB frequency (defined as median biopsies performed among recipients aged ≥12 months without rejection in the first year). We adjusted for potential confounders and center effects with mixed-effects regression analysis.

RESULTS

We analyzed 2867 patients at 29 centers. After adjusting for patient and center differences, increasing RSB frequency was associated with diagnosed AR (OR 1.15 p = 0.004), a trend toward treated AR (OR 1.09 p = 0.083), and higher hospital-based cost (US$390 315 vs. $313 248, p < 0.001) but no difference in graft survival (HR 1.00, p = 0.970) or CAV (SHR 1.04, p = 0.757) over median follow-up 3.9 years. Center RSB-frequency threshold of ≥2/year was associated with increased unadjusted rates of treated AR, but no association was found at thresholds greater than this.

CONCLUSION

Center RSB frequency is positively associated with increased diagnosis of AR at 1 year post-HT. Graft survival and CAV appear similar at medium-term follow-up. We speculate that higher frequency RSB centers may have increased detection of clinically less important AR, though further study of the relationship between center RSB frequency and differences in treated AR is necessary.

Left Atrial Strain Correlates with Elevated Filling Pressures in Pediatric Heart Transplantation Recipients

BACKGROUND

Noninvasive assessment of diastolic function in pediatric heart transplantation (PHTx) patients is important for monitoring of rejection, cardiac allograft vasculopathy, and nonspecific graft failure. We hypothesized that left atrial strain (LAS) would correlate with pulmonary capillary wedge pressure (PCWP) and that cutoff values to identify elevated left ventricular (LV) filling pressure could be derived for clinical practice and future testing.

METHODS

This was a secondary analysis of a prospectively collected cohort of PHTx patients undergoing same-day cardiac catheterization with biopsy and transthoracic echo. There were 70 patients with 85 clinical encounters. Traditional mitral inflow Doppler, LAS, LV diastolic strain and strain rate, and ratios for mitral E to LV diastolic strain and strain rate were assessed. Correlation with PCWP was performed, and receiver operator characteristic curves were generated for an elevated mean PCWP, acute rejection, and cardiac allograft vasculopathy.

RESULTS

Decreased LAS during the atrial reservoir phase (Ɛres) correlated with higher invasively measured PCWP (r = -0.40, P < .001). An Ɛres cutoff of 14.5% had good discriminatory ability for an elevated PCWP (sensitivity 75%, specificity 82%), and Ɛres > 22.0% had 100% negative predictive value; Ɛres was superior to other measures of diastolic function. Subanalyses for recent acute rejection (n = 9) showed good discriminatory ability for Ɛres of 14.5% (sensitivity 89%, specificity 74%).

CONCLUSIONS

LAS correlates with invasively measured PCWP and can identify elevated pressures better than traditional and other advanced diastolic function parameters. Use of LAS in PHTx patients may aid in noninvasive monitoring for rejection and nonspecific graft dysfunction.

Impact of routine surveillance biopsy intensity on the diagnosis of moderate to severe cellular rejection and survival after pediatric heart transplantation

Data are lacking on RSB intensity and outcomes after pediatric heart transplantation. PHTS centers received a survey on RSB practices from 2005 to present. PHTS data were obtained for 2010-2013 and integrated with center-matched survey responses for analysis. Survey response rate was 82.6% (38/46). Centers were classified as low-, moderate-, and high-intensity programs based on RSB frequency (0-more than 8 RSB/y). RSB intensity decreased with increasing time from HT. Age at HT impacted RSB intensity mostly in year 1, with little to no impact in later years. Most centers have not replaced RSB with non-invasive methods, but many added ECHO and biomarker monitoring. Higher RSB intensity was not associated with decreased 4-year mortality (P=.63) or earlier detection of moderate to severe (ISHLT grade 2R/3R) cellular rejection (RSBMSR) in the first year (P=.87). First-year RSBMSR incidence did not differ with intensity or age at HT. Significant variability exists in RSB intensity, but with no impact on timing and incidence of RSBMSR or 4-year mortality. Reduction in RSB frequency may be safe in certain patients after pediatric HT.

Impact of age on incidence and prevalence of moderate-to-severe cellular rejection detected by routine surveillance biopsy in pediatric heart transplantation

BACKGROUND

The effect of age at transplant on rejection detected by routine surveillance biopsy (RSB) in pediatric heart transplant (HT) recipients is unknown. We hypothesized there would be low diagnostic yield and decreased prevalence of rejection detected on RSB in infants (age <1 year) when compared with children (age 1 to 9 years) and adolescents (age 10 to 18 years).

METHODS

We utilized Pediatric Heart Transplant Study (PHTS) data from 2010 to 2013 to analyze moderate-to-severe (ISHLT Grade 2R/3R) cellular rejection (MSR) detected only on RSB (RSBMSR).

RESULTS

RSB detected 280 of 343 (81.6%) episodes of MSR. RSBMSR was detected in all age groups even >5 years after HT. Infant RSBMSR had a greater proportion (p = 0.0025) occurring >5 years after HT (39.2 vs 18.4 vs 10.8%) and a lower proportion (p = 0.0009) occurring in the first year after HT (25.5 vs 60.6 vs 51.7%) compared with children and adolescents, respectively. Freedom from RSBMSR was 87 ± 7% in infants, 76 ± 6% in children and 73 ± 7% in adolescents 4 years after HT. In 1-year survivors who had RSBMSR in the first year after HT, the risk of RSBMSR occurring in Years 2 to 4 was significantly (p < 0.0001) greater than patients without RSBMSR in the first year (hazard ratio 21.28, 95% confidence interval 10.87 to 41.66), regardless of recipient age.

CONCLUSIONS

RSBMSR exists in all age groups after pediatric HT with long-term follow-up. The prevalence in infant recipients is highest >5 years after HT. Those with RSBMSR in the first year after HT are at a high risk for recurrent rejection regardless of age at HT.

ECLS for children with late (post-discharge) rejection after heart transplantation

Rejection with acute hemodynamic compromise after OHT is rare in children, and is associated with poor survival. We retrospectively reviewed the management, course and outcome of recipients with late (following initial hospital discharge) rejection with acute hemodynamic compromise who were supported on ECLS. Of 197 consecutive children undergoing OHT (84 male; mean [SD] age 8.3 [5.7] [range 0.1-18.8 yr]) between 2/2002 and 10/2012, 187 children survived and were discharged from hospital. Mean (SD) follow-up was 5.0 (3.1) (range 0.1-10.6) yr. During follow-up, seven presented with severe hemodynamic compromise after transplantation (of whom one patient had been transplanted elsewhere). All seven children, who presented in hemodynamic collapse with poor cardiac function refractory to inotropic support, were placed on ECLS-two following in-hospital cardiac arrest. The median duration of ECLS was 6 (range 5-15) days. All survived to decannulation, with one death from overwhelming sepsis 20 days after presentation. The median (range) duration (in days) of inotropic requirement post ECLS was 11 (5-27), the median ventilation time was 8 (7-30), median ICU length of stay was 14 (10-54), and median hospitalization was 24 (19-118). In all, ventricular function normalized (FS >28%) within 10 (7-22) days. There was significant short-term morbidity; however, over a median follow-up of 5.9 (range 0.7-9.2) yr, all survivors have good functional status with no significant apparent neurological sequelae. ECLS thus appears to be a good rescue therapy for children with severe acute rejection post OHT, refractory to conventional treatment, leading to good medium-term outcome.

Endomyocardial biopsy and selective coronary angiography are low-risk procedures in pediatric heart transplant recipients: results of a multicenter experience

BACKGROUND

No prior reports documenting the safety and diagnostic yield of cardiac catheterization and endomyocardial biopsy (EMB) in heart transplant recipients include multicenter data.

METHODS

Data on the safety and diagnostic yield of EMB procedures performed in heart transplant recipients were recorded in the Congenital Cardiac Catheterization Outcomes Project database at 8 pediatric centers during a 3-year period. Adverse events (AEs) were classified according to a 5-level severity scale. Generalized estimating equation models identified risk factors for high-severity AEs (HSAEs; Levels 3-5) and non-diagnostic biopsy samples.

RESULTS

A total of 2,665 EMB cases were performed in 744 pediatric heart transplant recipients (median age, 12 years [interquartile range, 4.8, 16.7]; 54% male). AEs occurred in 88 cases (3.3%), of which 28 (1.1%) were HSAEs. AEs attributable to EMB included tricuspid valve injury, transient complete heart block, and right bundle branch block. Amongst 822 cases involving coronary angiography, 10 (1.2%) resulted in a coronary-related AE. There were no myocardial perforations or deaths. Multivariable risk factors for HSAEs included fewer prior catheterizations (p = 0.006) and longer case length (p < 0.001). EMB yielded sufficient tissue for diagnosis in 99% of cases. Longer time since heart transplant was the most significant predictor of a non-diagnostic biopsy sample (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

In the current era, cardiac catheterizations involving EMB can be performed in pediatric heart transplant recipients with a low AE rate and high diagnostic yield. Risk of HSAEs is increased in early post-transplant biopsies and with longer case length. Longer time since heart transplant is associated with non-diagnostic EMB samples.