Two-step transplantation for primary hyperoxaluria: cadaveric liver followed by living donor related kidney transplantation

Effect of liver transplantation with primary hyperoxaluria type 1: Five case reports and review of literature

BACKGROUND

Primary hyperoxaluria type 1 (PH1) is a rare autosomal recessive disease stemming from a deficiency in liver-specific alanine-glyoxylate aminotransferase, resulting in increased endogenous oxalate deposition and end-stage renal disease. Organ transplantation is the only effective treatment. However, its approach and timing remain controversial.

CASE SUMMARY

We retrospectively analyzed 5 patients diagnosed with PH1 from the Liver Transplant Center of the Beijing Friendship Hospital from March 2017 to December 2020. Our cohort included 4 males and 1 female. The median age at onset was 4.0 years (range: 1.0-5.0), age at diagnosis was 12.2 years (range: 6.7-23.5), age at liver transplantation (LT) was 12.2 years (range: 7.0-25.1), and the follow-up time was 26.3 mo (range: 12.8-40.1). All patients had delayed diagnosis, and 3 patients had progressed to end-stage renal disease by the time they were diagnosed. Two patients received preemptive LT; their estimated glomerular filtration rate was maintained at > 120 mL/min/1.73 m², indicating a better prognosis. Three patients received sequential liver and kidney transplantation. After transplantation, serum and urinary oxalate decreased, and liver function recovered. At the last follow-up, the estimated glomerular filtration rates of the latter 3 patients were 179, 52 and 21 mL/min/1.73 m².

CONCLUSION

Different transplantation strategies should be adopted for patients based on their renal function stage. Preemptive-LT offers a good therapeutic approach for PH1.

The Struggling Odyssey of Infantile Primary Hyperoxaluria

Introduction: Oxalate overproduction in Primary Hyperoxaluria type I (PH1) leads to progressive renal failure and systemic oxalate deposition. In severe infantile forms of PH1 (IPH1), end-stage renal disease (ESRD) occurs in the first years of life. Usually, the management of these infantile forms is challenging and consists in an intensive dialysis regimen followed by a liver-kidney transplantation (combined or sequential). Methods: Medical records of all infants with IPH1 reaching ESRD within the first year of life, diagnosed and followed between 2005 and 2018 in two pediatric nephrology departments in Brussels and Paris, have been reviewed. Results: Seven patients were included. They reached ESRD at a median age of 3.5 (2-7) months. Dialysis was started at a median age of 4 (2-10 months). Peritoneal dialysis (PD) was the initial treatment for 6 patients and hemodialysis (HD) for one patient. Liver transplantation (LT) was performed in all patients and kidney transplantation (KT) in six of them. A sequential strategy has been chosen in 5 patients, a combined in one. The kidney transplanted as part of the combined strategy was lost. Median age at LT and KT was 25 (10-41) months and 32.5 (26-75) months, respectively. No death occurred in the series. At the end of a median follow-up of 3 years, mean eGFR was 64 ± 29 ml/min/1.73 m². All patients presented retinal and bone lesions and five patients presented bones fractures. Conclusion: Despite encouraging survival figures, the morbidity in IPH1 patients remains extremely heavy and its management presents a huge challenge. Thanks to the newly developed RNA-interference drug, the future holds brighter prospects.

Schwangerschaft nach sequenzieller Leber-Nieren-Transplantation bei Hyperoxalurie Typ I: Was ist daran anders als sonst?

Schwangerschaft nach Nierentransplantation ist immer ein Risiko sowohl für Mutter und Kind als auch für das Nierentransplantat. Wir beschreiben den Fall einer jungen Frau mit primärer Hyperoxalurie Typ 1 und dadurch bedingtem terminalem Nierenversagen durch Nephrokalzinose. Sie hatte als 10-jähriges Kind eine Lebertransplantation durch Fremdspende erhalten zur Behebung des Enzymdefektes in der Leber sowie 2 Monate später eine Nierentransplantation durch Nierenspende der Mutter. Die Immunsuppression erfolgte durch Cyclosporin, Mycophenolatmofetil und Prednisolon. Das Lebertransplantat hatte 3 Abstoßungen, jeweils behandelt mit Steroidboli. Das Nierentransplantat zeigte eine langsame Funktionsverschlechterung über die Jahre, Entwicklung einer Proteinurie von 1 Gramm Protein pro 1 Gramm Kreatinin sowie eine mittelschwere Hypertonie. Trotzdem hatte die Frau einen persistierenden dringenden Kinderwunsch und setzte sich damit durch. Der Artikel beschreibt die speziellen Probleme dieses Falles: (1) das allgemeine Problem, Patienten mit Hyperoxalurie Typ 1 überhaupt zu transplantieren; (2) das spezielle Problem der Schwangerschaft dieser 31-jährigen Frau mit genetisch bedingter Nierenerkrankung und vorangehender Transplantation von 2 soliden Organen vor 18 Jahren; (3) die mit einem immunologisch instabilen Lebertransplantat und einem Nierentransplantat einhergehende langsam progrediente Funktionsverschlechterung und ansteigende Proteinurie. Die generellen Richtlinien für eine Schwangerschaft nach Nierentransplantation werden aufgezeigt im Vergleich zu dem hier beschriebenen Fall einer Schwangerschaft, bei der fast alle Parameter außerhalb der Richtlinien liegen bei persistierend starkem Kinderwunsch dieser Frau.

KDIGO Clinical Practice Guideline on the Evaluation and Management of Candidates for Kidney Transplantation

The 2020 Kidney Disease: Improving Global Outcomes (KDIGO) Clinical Practice Guideline on the Evaluation and Management of Candidates for Kidney Transplantation is intended to assist health care professionals worldwide who evaluate and manage potential candidates for deceased or living donor kidney transplantation. This guideline addresses general candidacy issues such as access to transplantation, patient demographic and health status factors, and immunological and psychosocial assessment. The roles of various risk factors and comorbid conditions governing an individual's suitability for transplantation such as adherence, tobacco use, diabetes, obesity, perioperative issues, causes of kidney failure, infections, malignancy, pulmonary disease, cardiac and peripheral arterial disease, neurologic disease, gastrointestinal and liver disease, hematologic disease, and bone and mineral disorder are also addressed. This guideline provides recommendations for evaluation of individual aspects of a candidate's profile such that each risk factor and comorbidity are considered separately. The goal is to assist the clinical team to assimilate all data relevant to an individual, consider this within their local health context, and make an overall judgment on candidacy for transplantation. The guideline development process followed the Grades of Recommendation Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) approach. Guideline recommendations are primarily based on systematic reviews of relevant studies and our assessment of the quality of that evidence, and the strengths of recommendations are provided. Limitations of the evidence are discussed with differences from previous guidelines noted and suggestions for future research are also provided.

Bilateral native nephrectomy to reduce oxalate stores in children at the time of combined liver-kidney transplantation for primary hyperoxaluria type 1

OBJECTIVE

Primary hyperoxaluria type-1 (PH-1) is a rare genetic disorder in which normal hepatic metabolism of glyoxylate is disrupted resulting in diffuse oxalate deposition and end-stage renal disease (ESRD). While most centers agree that combined liver-kidney transplant (CLKT) is the appropriate treatment for PH-1, perioperative strategies for minimizing recurrent oxalate-related injury to the transplanted kidney remain unclear. We present our management of children with PH-1 and ESRD on hemodialysis (HD) who underwent CLKT at our institution from 2005 to 2015.

METHODS

On chart review, three patients (2 girls, 1 boy) met study criteria. Two patients received deceased-donor split-liver grafts, while one patient received a whole liver graft. All patients underwent bilateral native nephrectomy at transplant to minimize the total body oxalate load. Median preoperative serum oxalate was 72 μmol/L (range 17.8-100). All patients received HD postoperatively until predialysis serum oxalate levels fell <20 μmol/L. All patients, at a median of 7.5 years of follow-up (range 6.5-8.9), demonstrated stable liver and kidney function.

CONCLUSIONS

While CLKT remains the definitive treatment for PH-1, bilateral native nephrectomy at the time of transplant reduces postoperative oxalate stores and may mitigate damage to the renal allograft.

Calcified Double J Stent after Sequential Liver and Renal Transplantation Associated to Primary Oxalosis: Case Report

Hyperoxaluria type I (HPI) is a metabolic disorder secondary to liver alanine glyoxylate aminotransferase deficiency. Renal failure occurs due to the excessive production and precipitation of oxalate in the kidney. Combined liver-renal transplantation is the correct treatment for this condition when end-stage renal failure occurs since in renal transplantation alone the risk of recurrence of the same pathology in the transplanted kidney would be high.

We determined the calcification surrounding the double J stent inserted to the transplant ureter in a short time in a 22-year-old patient who underwent sequential liver and renal transplantation with the diagnoses of oxalosis. In the literature we have not found papers on calcification of double J stent following combined or sequential transplantation. Although after the sequential transplantation the calcification, nephrocalcinosis, and renal stones were practically not of great concern, these patients should be followed up more carefully in terms of stent calcification during the early post-transplant period.

Pediatric combined liver-kidney transplantation: a 2015 update

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The experience of combined liver-kidney transplantation (CLKT) is limited in pediatric populations. This strategy is, however, required in specific diseases such as metabolic diseases (namely primary hyperoxaluria type one and methylmalonic acidemia), autosomal recessive polycystic kidney disease, miscellaneous ciliopathies and atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome.

RECENT FINDINGS

Different series and registry studies have confirmed the feasibility of pediatric CLKT with encouraging results in the long term, even in the youngest and smallest patients, provided that highly trained multidisciplinary teams are involved in this global management. As such, the long-term outcomes after CLKT are currently comparable to that of isolated liver or kidney transplantations, even though the immediate postoperative period remains challenging.

SUMMARY

Some questions remain nevertheless unanswered, such as the respective place of combined versus sequential liver-kidney transplantation, especially in primary hyperoxaluria and autosomal recessive polycystic kidney disease. The aim of this review was therefore to provide a 2015 update on pediatric CLKT. In the future, international collaborative studies and registries may help to improve our knowledge of this rare and still highly challenging technique.

Primary hyperoxaluria complicated with liver cirrhosis: A case report

Primary hyperoxaluria (PH) is a rare, autosomal recessive disorder characterized by overproduction of oxalate caused by a deficiency in a hepatic enzyme. The excess oxalate combines with calcium in the kidneys to form deposits of calcium oxalate, which can lead to nephrocalcinosis and renal failure. PH type 1 (PH1), the most common form of this disease, is caused by a deficiency of the liver-specific enzyme alanine/glyoxylate aminotransferase (AGT). Liver transplantation is performed as a definitive therapy for PH to correct the enzyme defect. Usually, liver depositions are limited and liver function is normal without fibrosis. Here, we report an adult case of liver cirrhosis caused by PH1. A 28-year-old woman was admitted to our hospital under suspicion of PH1 and the presence of nephrocalcinosis. The patient had suffered from kidney stone recurrences from 17 years of age, and was initiated on hemodialysis due to renal failure at the age of 27 years. The serum level of oxalic acid was high, whereas the AGT level in the liver tissue was decreased. Thus, the patient was definitively diagnosed with PH1. Although she had normal liver function, surface nodularity and splenomegaly were detected by computed tomography, suggesting liver cirrhosis. The native liver showed micronodular cirrhosis and portal fibrosis. Several arterioles were filled with rhomboid and polyhedral refractile oxalate crystals and various portal tracts showed these crystals. Our case suggests that long-term oxalosis can lead to liver cirrhosis; thus, PH should be considered one of the causes of liver cirrhosis.

Recurrence of crystalline nephropathy after kidney transplantation in APRT deficiency and primary hyperoxaluria

Purpose of review

To provide transplant physicians with a summary of the pathogenesis and diagnosis of adenine phosphoribosyl transferase (APRT) deficiency and primary hyperoxaluria and, focussed on kidney transplantation, and to discuss interventions aimed at preventing and treating the recurrence of crystalline nephropathy in renal transplant recipients.

Source of information

Pubmed literature search.

Setting

Primary hyperoxaluria and APRT deficiency are rare inborn errors of human metabolism. The hallmark of these diseases is the overproduction and urinary excretion of compounds (2,8 dihydroxyadenine in APRT deficiency, oxalate in primary hyperoxaluria) that form urinary crystals. Although recurrent urolithiasis represents the main clinical feature of these diseases, kidney injury can occur as a result of crystal precipitation within the tubules and interstitium, a condition referred to as crystalline nephropathy. Some patients develop end-stage renal disease (ESRD) and may become candidates for kidney transplantation. Since kidney transplantation does not correct the underlying metabolic defect, transplant recipients have a high risk of recurrence of crystalline nephropathy, which can lead to graft loss. In some instances, the disease remains undiagnosed until after the occurrence of ESRD or even after kidney transplantation.

Key messages

Patients with APRT deficiency or primary hyperoxaluria may develop ESRD as a result of crystalline nephropathy. In the absence of diagnosis and adequate management, the disease is likely to recur after kidney transplantation, which often leads to rapid loss of renal allograft function. Primary hyperoxaluria, but not APRT deficiency, becomes a systemic disease at low GFR with oxalate deposition leading to malfunction in non-renal organs (systemic oxalosis). We suggest that these diagnoses should be considered in patients with low glomerular filtration rate (GFR) and a history of kidney stones. In APRT deficiency, stones may be confused with uric acid stones, unless specialized techniques are used (infrared spectroscopy or X-ray crystallography for urinary crystals or stone analysis; Fourier transform infrared microscopy for crystals in kidney biopsy). Where these are unavailable, and for confirmation, the diagnosis can be made by measurement of enzyme activity in red blood cell lysates or by genetic testing. In patients with primary hyperoxaluria, levels of urinary and plasma oxalate; and the presence of nearly pure calcium oxalate monohydrate in stones, which often also have an unusually pale colour and unorganized structure, increase diagnostic suspicion. Molecular genetic testing is the criterion measure. Lifelong allopurinol therapy, with high fluid intake if appropriate, may stabilize kidney function in APRT deficiency; if ESRD has occurred or is near, results with kidney transplantation after initiation of allopurinol are excellent. In primary hyperoxaluria recognized before ESRD, pyridoxine treatment and high fluid intake may lead to a substantial decrease in urinary calcium oxalate supersaturation and prevent renal failure. In non-responsive patients or those recognized later in their disease, liver transplantation cures the underlying defect and should be considered when the GFR falls below 30 ml/min/1.73 m²; in those which or near ESRD, liver transplantation and intensive dialysis before kidney transplantation may be considered to reduce the total body oxalate burden before kidney transplantation.

Limitations

The availability of diagnostic tests varies between countries and centres. Data on long term outcomes after kidney transplantation are limited, especially for APRT deficiency patients.

Implications

Increasing transplant physicians knowledge of APRT deficiency and primary hyperoxaluria should enable them to implement adequate diagnostic and therapeutic interventions, thereby achieving good outcomes after kidney transplantation.

Primary disease recurrence—effects on paediatric renal transplantation outcomes

Primary disease recurrence after renal transplantation is mainly diagnosed by examination of biopsy samples, but can also be associated with clinical symptoms. In some patients, recurrence can lead to graft loss (7-8% of all graft losses). Primary disease recurrence is generally associated with a high risk of graft loss in patients with focal segmental glomerulosclerosis, membranous proliferative glomerulonephritis, primary hyperoxaluria or atypical haemolytic uraemic syndrome. By contrast, disease recurrence is associated with a limited risk of graft loss in patients with IgA nephropathy, renal involvement associated with Henoch-Schönlein purpura, antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody-associated glomerulonephritis or lupus nephritis. The presence of systemic diseases that affect the kidneys, such as sickle cell anaemia and diabetes mellitus, also increases the risk of delayed graft loss. This Review provides an overview of the epidemiology, pathophysiology and management of primary disease recurrence in paediatric renal graft recipients, and describes the overall effect on graft survival of each of the primary diseases listed above. With appropriate management, few paediatric patients should be excluded from renal transplantation programmes because of an increased risk of recurrence.

Two-step transplantation for primary hyperoxaluria: a winning strategy to prevent progression of systemic oxalosis in early onset renal insufficiency cases

Several transplant strategies for PH1 have been proposed, and LT is performed to correct the metabolic defects. The patients with PH1 often suffer from ESRD and require simultaneous LKT, which leads to a long wait due to the shortage of suitable organ donors. Five patients with PH1 underwent LDLT at our institute. Three of the five patients were under dialysis before LDLT, while the other two patients were categorized as CKD stage 3. An isolated LDLT was successfully performed in all but our first case, who had complicated postoperative courses and consequently died due to sepsis after retransplantation. The renal function of the patients with CKD stage 3 was preserved after LDLT. On the other hand, our second case with ESRD underwent successful LDKT six months after LDLT, and our infant case is waiting for the subsequent KT without any post-LDLT complications after the early establishment of PD. In conclusion, a two-step transplant strategy may be needed as a life-saving option for patients with PH1 and may be possible even in small infants with systemic oxalosis. While waiting for a subsequent KT, an early resumption of PD should be considered from the perspective of the long-term requirement of RRT.

Primary hyperoxaluria type 1: practical and ethical issues

Primary hyperoxaluria type 1 (PH1) is a rare inborn error of glyoxylate metabolism of autosomal recessive inheritance, leading to progressive systemic oxalate storage (named 'oxalosis') with a high rate of morbidity and mortality, as well as an unacceptable quality of life for most patients. The adverse outcome, however, is partly due to issues that can be overcome. First, the diagnosis of PH is often delayed due to a general lack of knowledge of the disease among physicians. This accounts specifically for patients with pyridoxine sensitive PH, a group that is paradoxically most easy to treat. Second, lack of adherence to a strict conduction of conservative treatment and optimal urological management may enhance an adverse outcome of the disease. Third, specific techniques to establish PH1 and specific therapies are currently often not available in several low-resources countries with a high prevalence of PH. The management of patients with advanced disease is extremely difficult and warrants a tailor-made approach in most cases. Comprehensive programs for education of local physicians, installation of national centers of expertise, European support of low-resources countries for the management of PH patients and intensified international collaboration on the management of current patients, as well as on conduction of clinical studies, may further improve outcome of PH.

Adult with primary hyperoxaluria type 1 regrets not receiving preemptive liver transplantation during childhood: report of a case

A 32-year-old male was suspected to have primary hyperoxaluria type 1 (PH1) and eventually underwent liver transplantation (LT). He was diagnosed with nephrolithiasis at 9 years of age. Right heminephrectomy was performed for a staghorn calculus. He underwent urethrotomy for urinary retention at 12 years of age. Percutaneous nephrolithotomy was performed for nephrolithiasis when he was 16 years of age. He underwent frequent extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy for recurrent nephrolithiasis from 18 to 24 years of age. PH1 was suspected at 32 years of age, and pharmacological therapy was also initiated. He developed renal failure at 36 years of age, which was treated with intensive hemodialysis. A definitive diagnosis of PH1 was made based on a liver needle biopsy 1 month later. He received a living-donor LT at 38 years of age, and a living-donor kidney transplant from the same donor 8 months later. Though he made a good recovery, an early diagnosis and preemptive LT are important for PH1 patients.

Liver transplantation for primary hyperoxaluria type 1: a single-center experience during two decades in Japan

BACKGROUND

Primary hyperoxaluria type-1 (PH1) is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by impaired activity of hepatic peroxisomal alanine-glyoxylate aminotransferase that leads to end-stage renal disease (ESRD). A definitive diagnosis is often delayed until ESRD appears. Based on the etiology, liver transplantation (LT) seems to be the definitive treatment.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Three PH1 patients underwent LT at our institution during two decades.

RESULTS

Two of the patients had family histories of cryptogenic ESRD. All three showed disease onset in childhood, but the definitive diagnosis was delayed in two cases (17 and 37 years of age). These delayed cases resulted in ESRD, and hemodialysis (HD) had been introduced before LT. One patient received domino LT, and the other two underwent living-donor LT (LDLT). One patient finally died of sepsis, and was unable to receive a kidney transplantation (KT) after the domino LT. One patient did not show ESRD, and did not have to undergo KT after LDLT, although extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy was required for residual ureterolithiasis (8 years after LDLT). The third patient had an uneventful course after LDLT and received living-donor KT from the same donor 8 months after LDLT. Subsequently, HD was successfully withdrawn.

CONCLUSIONS

Establishment of a definitive diagnosis of PH1 is essential. If a methodology for early diagnosis and an intensive care strategy for neonates and infants during the waiting time become well-established, a timely and preemptive LT alone can provide a good chance of cure for PH1 patients.

Primary hyperoxaluria

Primary hyperoxalurias (PH) are inborn errors in the metabolism of glyoxylate and oxalate. PH type 1, the most common form, is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by a deficiency of the liver-specific enzyme alanine, glyoxylate aminotransferase (AGT) resulting in overproduction and excessive urinary excretion of oxalate. Recurrent urolithiasis and nephrocalcinosis are the hallmarks of the disease. As glomerular filtration rate decreases due to progressive renal damage, oxalate accumulates leading to systemic oxalosis. Diagnosis is often delayed and is based on clinical and sonographic findings, urinary oxalate assessment, DNA analysis, and, if necessary, direct AGT activity measurement in liver biopsy tissue. Early initiation of conservative treatment, including high fluid intake, inhibitors of calcium oxalate crystallization, and pyridoxine in responsive cases, can help to maintain renal function in compliant subjects. In end-stage renal disease patients, the best outcomes have been achieved with combined liver-kidney transplantation which corrects the enzyme defect.

[Primary hyperoxaluria]

Primary hyperoxalurias are rare recessive inherited inborn errors of glyoxylate metabolism. They are responsible for progressive renal involvement, which further lead to systemic oxalate deposition, which can even occur in infants. Primary hyperoxaluria type 1 is the most common form in Europe and is due to alanine-glyoxylate aminostransferase deficiency, a hepatic peroxisomal pyridoxin-dependent enzyme. Therefore primary hyperoxaluria type 1 is responsible for hyperoxaluria leading to aggressive stone formation and nephrocalcinosis. As glomerular filtration rate decreases, systemic oxalate storage occurs throughout all the body, and mainly in the skeleton. The diagnosis is first based on urine oxalate measurement, then on genotyping, which may also allow prenatal diagnosis to be proposed. Conservative measures - including hydration, crystallization inhibitors and pyridoxine - are safe and may allow long lasting renal survival, provided it is given as soon as the diagnosis has been even suspected. No dialysis procedure can remove enough oxalate to compensate oxalate overproduction from the sick liver, therefore a combined liver and kidney transplantation should be planned before advanced renal disease has occurred, in order to limit/avoid systemic oxalate deposition. In the future, primary hyperoxaluria type 1 may benefit from hepatocyte transplantation, chaperone molecules, etc.

Paediatric liver transplantation for metabolic disorders. Part 1: Liver-based metabolic disorders without liver lesions

Liver-based metabolic disorders account for 10 to 15% of the indications for paediatric liver transplantation. In the last three decades, important progress has been made in the understanding of these diseases, and new therapies have emerged. Concomitantly, medical and surgical innovations have lead to improved results of paediatric liver transplantation, patient survival nowadays exceeding 80% 10-year after surgery with close to normal quality of life in most survivors. This review is a practical update on medical therapy, indications and results of liver transplantation, and potential future therapies, for the main liver-based metabolic disorders in which paediatric liver transplantation may be considered. Part 1 focuses on metabolic based liver disorders without liver lesions, and part 2 on metabolic liver diseases with liver lesions.

Liver transplantation for inherited metabolic disorders of the liver

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Liver transplantation is curative, life saving or both for a range of inherited diseases affecting the liver. Indications, timing and outcome of transplantation for these diseases are the focus of this review.

RECENT FINDINGS

Liver transplant represents a mode of gene replacement therapy for several disorders, including Wilson disease, hemochromatosis, tyrosinemia, urea cycle defects and hypercholesterolemia in which the primary defect residing in the liver results in hepatic complications or severe extrahepatic disease. Liver transplant is also an important therapeutic modality in multisystemic genetic disorders with major hepatic disease such as glycogen storage disease types I, III and IV and porphyria. For familial amyloidosis and primary hyperoxaluria, liver replacement eliminates the source of the injurious products that results in extrahepatic disease. Innovations in medical and surgical management of these patients have led to improved outcomes providing an important benchmark for future gene therapy of these disorders.

SUMMARY

Recent developments have refined the indications for liver transplant in the treatment of inherited metabolic diseases. The full potential of liver transplant in these disorders can be harnessed by careful patient selection, optimizing timing and perioperative metabolic management of these patients.