Expression of X-linked phosphoglycerate kinase in early mouse embryos homozygous at the Xce locus

A long noncoding RNA influences the choice of the X chromosome to be inactivated

X chromosome inactivation (XCI) is the process of silencing one of the X chromosomes in cells of the female mammal which ensures dosage compensation between the sexes. Although theoretically random in somatic tissues, the choice of which X chromosome is chosen to be inactivated can be biased in mice by genetic element(s) associated with the so-called X-controlling element (Xce). Although the Xce was first described and genetically localized nearly 40 y ago, its mode of action remains elusive. In the approach presented here, we identify a single long noncoding RNA (lncRNA) within the Xce locus, Lppnx, which may be the driving factor in the choice of which X chromosome will be inactivated in the developing female mouse embryo. Comparing weak and strong Xce alleles we show that Lppnx modulates the expression of Xist lncRNA, one of the key factors in XCI, by controlling the occupancy of pluripotency factors at Intron1 of Xist. This effect is counteracted by enhanced binding of Rex1 in DxPas34, another key element in XCI regulating the activity of Tsix lncRNA, the main antagonist of Xist, in the strong but not in the weak Xce allele. These results suggest that the different susceptibility for XCI observed in weak and strong Xce alleles results from differential transcription factor binding of Xist Intron 1 and DxPas34, and that Lppnx represents a decisive factor in explaining the action of the Xce.

Genetic architecture of skewed X inactivation in the laboratory mouse

X chromosome inactivation (XCI) is the mammalian mechanism of dosage compensation that balances X-linked gene expression between the sexes. Early during female development, each cell of the embryo proper independently inactivates one of its two parental X-chromosomes. In mice, the choice of which X chromosome is inactivated is affected by the genotype of a cis-acting locus, the X-chromosome controlling element (Xce). Xce has been localized to a 1.9 Mb interval within the X-inactivation center (Xic), yet its molecular identity and mechanism of action remain unknown. We combined genotype and sequence data for mouse stocks with detailed phenotyping of ten inbred strains and with the development of a statistical model that incorporates phenotyping data from multiple sources to disentangle sources of XCI phenotypic variance in natural female populations on X inactivation. We have reduced the Xce candidate 10-fold to a 176 kb region located approximately 500 kb proximal to Xist. We propose that structural variation in this interval explains the presence of multiple functional Xce alleles in the genus Mus. We have identified a new allele, Xce^e present in Mus musculus and a possible sixth functional allele in Mus spicilegus. We have also confirmed a parent-of-origin effect on X inactivation choice and provide evidence that maternal inheritance magnifies the skewing associated with strong Xce alleles. Based on the phylogenetic analysis of 155 laboratory strains and wild mice we conclude that Xce^a is either a derived allele that arose concurrently with the domestication of fancy mice but prior the derivation of most classical inbred strains or a rare allele in the wild. Furthermore, we have found that despite the presence of multiple haplotypes in the wild Mus musculus domesticus has only one functional Xce allele, Xce^b. Lastly, we conclude that each mouse taxa examined has a different functional Xce allele.

Although mammalian females have two X chromosomes in each cell, only one is functional, while gene expression from the other is silenced through a process called X chromosome inactivation. Little is known about the early stages of this process including how one parental X chromosome is inactivated over the other on a cell-by-cell basis. It has been shown, however, that certain inbred mouse strains are functionally different at a locus that controls this choice that provides an opportunity to identify the locus and determine its molecular mechanism. This has been the goal of many researchers over the past 40 years with incremental success. Here we took advantage of new mouse genotype and whole genome sequencing data to pinpoint the locus controlling choice. Our results identified a smaller region on the X chromosome that contains large duplicated sequences. We propose an explanation for multiple functional alleles in mouse and provide insight into the possible molecular mechanism of X chromosome inactivation choice. Our evolutionary analysis reveals why functional diversity at this locus appears to be common in laboratory mice and offers an explanation as to why we do not see this level of diversity in humans.

X-inactivation analysis of embryonic lethality in Ocrl wt/-; Inpp5b-/- mice

Mutations in the human OCRL gene, which encodes a phosphatidylinositol(4,5)bisphosphate 5-phosphatase, result in the X-linked oculocerebrorenal syndrome of Lowe. Mice with a targeted disruption of Ocrl have no phenotypic abnormalities. Targeted disruption of its closest paralog, Inpp5b, causes male infertility in the 129S6 background. Mice with disruptions of both genes are lost in utero prior to 9.5-10.5 dpc, indicating that there is a functional overlap between the two paralogs early in development. We analyzed the pattern of X-inactivation in four tissues of distinct embryonic origin from Ocrl (wt/-);Inpp5b (-/-) females to explore the timing and tissue distribution of the functional overlap. X-inactivation was strongly skewed against the disrupted Ocrl (-) allele being on the active X chromosome in all four tissues tested, indicating that there is early selection against cell lineages lacking both Ocrl and Inpp5b. Extraembryonic tissue was also involved in the lethality because there were never any live-born Ocrl (wt/-);Inpp5b (-/-) females when the functional Ocrl (wt ) allele was on the paternal X chromosome, which is preferentially inactivated in trophoblast-derived extraembryonic tissues. Live-born Ocrl (wt/-);Inpp5b (-/-) females were found when the functional Ocrl (wt) allele was maternal, although in fewer numbers than expected. The importance of the extraembryonic tissues in the early embryonic lethality of embryos lacking both Ocrl and Inpp5b is reinforced by the successful isolation of a viable 40,XX Ocrl (-/-);Inpp5b (-/-) embryonic stem cell from the inner cell mass of a 3.5-dpc blastocyst prior to implantation. These results indicate a functional overlap of Ocrl and Inpp5b in most cell lineages, especially in extraembryonic tissues.

Genetic control of X chromosome inactivation in mice: definition of the Xce candidate interval

In early mammalian development, one of the two X chromosomes is silenced in each female cell as a result of X chromosome inactivation, the mammalian dosage compensation mechanism. In the mouse epiblast, the choice of which chromosome is inactivated is essentially random, but can be biased by alleles at the X-linked X controlling element (Xce). Although this locus was first described nearly four decades ago, the identity and precise genomic localization of Xce remains elusive. Within the X inactivation center region of the X chromosome, previous linkage disequilibrium studies comparing strains of known Xce genotypes have suggested that Xce is physically distinct from Xist, although this has not yet been established by genetic mapping or progeny testing. In this report, we used quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping strategies to define the minimal Xce candidate interval. Subsequent analysis of recombinant chromosomes allowed for the establishment of a maximum 1.85-Mb candidate region for the Xce locus. Finally, we use QTL approaches in an effort to identify additional modifiers of the X chromosome choice, as we have previously demonstrated that choice in Xce heterozygous females is significantly influenced by genetic variation present on autosomes (Chadwick and Willard 2005). We did not identify any autosomal loci with significant associations and thus show conclusively that Xce is the only major locus to influence X inactivation patterns in the crosses analyzed. This study provides a foundation for future analyses into the genetic control of X chromosome inactivation and defines a 1.85-Mb interval encompassing all the major elements of the Xce locus.

Genetic and parent-of-origin influences on X chromosome choice in Xce heterozygous mice

X chromosome inactivation is unique among dosage compensation mechanisms in that the two X chromosomes in females are treated differently within the same cell; one X chromosome is stably silenced while the other remains active. It is widely believed that, when X inactivation is initiated, each cell makes a random choice of which X chromosome will be silenced. In mice, only one genetic locus, the X-linked X controlling element (X ce), is known to influence this choice, because animals that are heterozygous at X ce have X-inactivation patterns that differ markedly from a mean of 0.50. To document other genetic and epigenetic influences on choice, we have performed a population-based study of the effect of X ce genotype on X-inactivation patterns. In B 6 CAST F(1) females (X ce(b)/X ce(c)), the X-inactivation pattern followed a symmetric distribution with a mean of 0.29 (SD=0.08). Surprisingly, however, in a population of X ce(b)/X ce(c) heterozygous B 6 CAST F(2) females, we observed significant differences in both the mean (p=0.004) and variance (p=0.004) of the X-inactivation patterns. This finding is incompatible with a single-locus model and suggests that additional genetic factors also influence X chromosome choice. We show that both parent-of-origin and naturally occurring genetic variation at autosomal loci contribute to these differences. Taken together, these data reveal further genetic complexity in this epigenetic control pathway.

Imprinted X-chromosome inactivation: enlightenment from embryos in vivo

There are two forms of X chromosome inactivation (XCI) in the laboratory mouse, random XCI in the fetus and imprinted paternal XCI limited to the extraembryonic tissues supporting the fetal life in utero. Imprinted XCI has been studied extensively because it takes place first in embryogenesis and it may hold clues to the mechanism of control of XCI in general and to the evolution of random' XCI. Classical microscopic and biochemical studies of embryos in vivo provide a basis for interpreting the multifaceted information yielded by various inventive approaches and for planning further experiments.

Evidence that mutations in the X-linked DDP gene cause incompletely penetrant and variable skewed X inactivation

X chromosome inactivation results in the random transcriptional silencing of one of the two X chromosomes early in female development. After random inactivation, certain deleterious X-linked mutations can create a selective disadvantage for cells in which the mutation is on the active X chromosome, leading to X inactivation patterns with the mutation on the inactive X chromosome in nearly 100% of the individual's cells. In contrast to the homogeneous patterns of complete skewed inactivation noted for many X-linked disorders, here we describe a family segregating a mutation in the dystonia-deafness peptide (DDP) gene, in which female carriers show incompletely penetrant and variable X inactivation patterns in peripheral blood leukocytes, ranging between 50:50 and >95:5. To address the genetic basis for the unusual pattern of skewing in this family, we first mapped the locus responsible for the variable skewing to the proximal long arm (Xq12-q22) of the X chromosome (Z=5. 7, P=.002, LOD score 3.57), a region that includes both the DDP and the XIST genes. Examination of multiple cell types from women carrying a DDP mutation and of peripheral blood leukocytes from women from two unrelated families who carry different mutations in the DDP gene suggests that the skewed X inactivation is the result of selection against cells containing the mutant DDP gene on the active X chromosome, although skewing is apparently not as severe as that seen for many other deleterious X-linked mutations. Thus, DDP is an example of an X-linked gene for which mutations cause partial cell selection and thus incompletely skewed X inactivation in peripheral blood leukocytes.

Expression of an X-linked HMG-lacZ transgene in mouse embryos: implication of chromosomal imprinting and lineage-specific X-chromosome activity

X-chromosome activity in female mouse embryos was studied at the cellular level using an X-linked lacZ transgene which encodes beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal). Translation of maternal RNA in oocytes is seen as beta-Gal activity that persists into early cleavage-stages. Zygotic transcription of the transgene from the maternal X chromosome (Xm) is first found at about the 8-cell stage. By contrast, expression of the lacZ transgene on the paternal X chromosome (Xp) is not seen until later at the 16-32-cell stage. Preferential inactivation of Xp occurs in the mural trophectoderm, the primitive endoderm, and derivatives of the polar trophectoderm, but a small number of cells in these lineages may still retain an active paternal X chromosome. X inactivation begins at 3.5 days in the inner cell mass but contrary to previous findings the process is not completed in the embryonic ectoderm by 5.5 to 6.0 days. Regional variation in beta-Gal activity is also observed in the embryonic ectoderm during gastrulation which may be related to the specification of cell fates. Random inactivation of Xp and Xm ensues in all somatic tissues but the process is completed at different times in different tissues. The slower progression of X inactivation in tissues such as the notochord, the heart, and the embryonic gut is primarily due to the persistent maintenance of two active X chromosomes in a significant fraction of cells in these tissues. Recent findings on the methylation of endogenous X-linked genes suggest that the prolonged expression of beta-Gal might also be due to the different rate of spreading of inactivation along the X chromosome to the lacZ transgene locus in different tissues.

Parental imprinting studied by allele-specific primer extension after PCR: paternal X chromosome-linked genes are transcribed prior to preferential paternal X chromosome inactivation

The preferential inactivation of the paternal X chromosome in extraembryonic cells during early mouse development is an example of parental imprinting, but it has not been studied at the transcriptional level because standard methods of measuring RNA levels do not allow detection of allele-specific RNAs in individual early embryos. We sought to determine whether the paternal allele of the X chromosome-linked gene for 3-phosphoglycerate kinase 1 (Pgk-1), which is located very near the center of X chromosome inactivation, is transcribed prior to differentiation of extraembryonic lineages. Previous reports indicated that in heterozygous embryos there is a delay in the appearance of the phosphoglycerate kinase 1 allozyme encoded by the paternal X chromosome until 2 days after the appearance of the corresponding maternal allozyme. We report results obtained by use of a reverse transcription/PCR-based method which allows the quantitative measurement of allele-specific RNA. The assay is sensitive enough for the quantitative analysis in single embryos of allele-specific transcripts differing by only one nucleotide. We have used this assay to analyze mouse embryos heterozygous at the Pgk-1 and Hprt [hypoxanthine (guanine) phosphoribosyltransferase] loci, and we find that individual 8-cell and blastocyst embryos express both Hprt and Pgk-1 paternal transcripts, as do pooled 2- to 4-cell embryos. These results are discussed in view of the apparent temporal delay in paternal expression of the Pgk-1 gene at the enzyme level.

Imprinting of phosphoribosyltransferases during preimplantation development of the mouse mutant, Hprtb-m3

The measurement of the activity of the X-linked enzyme HPRT has been widely used as an indicator of X-chromosome activity during preimplantation development in the mouse. More recently, the concomitant measurement of the activity of the autosomally-encoded enzyme APRT has been used in an attempt to decrease the variability inherent in the measurement of enzyme activity from minute samples such as preimplantation embryos. In this study the use of the HPRT-deficient mouse mutant, Hprtb-m3, allowed the unequivocal identification of the parental origin of HPRT activity measured in embryos derived from crosses between wild-type mice, and mice which were homozygous or hemizygous for the Hprtb-m3 allele. Results were similar to those of a previous study, where oocyte-encoded HPRT activity accounted for about 10% of total HPRT activity at 76 hours post human chorionic gonadotrophin injection and the paternally-derived Hprt allele was shown to be transcriptionally active by the late 2-cell stage. In contrast to other studies, differential expression of the two Hprt alleles was detected during the preimplantation period, in embryos derived from crosses between wild-type and HPRT-deficient mice. Evidence was also found for the existence of an X-linked locus which influences the amount of APRT activity in the unfertilized oocyte. We propose that the expression pattern of this locus may be influenced by its parental origin.

Further evidence for the importance of parental source of the Xce allele in X chromosome inactivation

Using mice that were mosaics for both Xce and phosphoglycerate kinase (Pgk-1) alleles, we present further evidence that the parental source of the X chromosome may affect the probability of that X chromosome remaining active. The reciprocal cross differences in PGK-1 activity described here are intermediate between those published previously for other alleles of Xce.

Sequential expression of maternally inherited phosphoglycerate kinase-1 in the early mouse embryo

Enzyme activities of X-linked phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK-1) and autosomal glucose phosphate isomerase (GPI-1) were determined in intact mouse blastocysts and isolated inner cell masses (ICMs). Blastocysts were recovered from the uterus on day 4 of gestation and cultured overnight in vitro. ICMs were isolated by treatment with calcium ionophore A23187. On day 4, approximately 35% of the total activity of both PGK-1 and GPI-1 was located in the ICM. After overnight culture, the PGK-1 activity of the whole blastocyst nearly doubled, due to the activation of only the maternally derived gene coding for PGK-1. In the ICM, however, a pronounced decrease of PGK-1 activity was measured: only 10% of the total PGK-1 activity was measured in the ICM on day 5. In contrast to PGK-1, GPI-1 activity of the intact blastocyst remained stable from day 4 to day 5. In the ICM, the GPI-1 activity did decline, but to a lesser extent than PGK-1 activity: 20% of total GPI-1 activity was found in the ICM on day 5. These results, when compared with the data of Handyside and Hunter, suggest that the decline in GPI-1 activity in the ICM is due to a change in the ratio of trophectoderm (TE) to ICM cells. The greater reduction of PGK-1 activity in the ICM cannot, however, be explained solely by this mechanism. To explain the observed additional decrease, we postulate that Pgk-1 is not activated in the ICM prior to day 6. This implies that on day 4 maternal Pgk-1 is activated in the TE exclusively.