Artificial heart and assist devices: directions, needs, costs, societal and ethical issues

Statistics of heart failure and mechanical circulatory support in 2020

Heart failure is increasing in prevalence, with approximately 26 million patients affected worldwide. This represents a significant cause of morbidity and mortality. Statistics regarding heart failure patient age, hospitalization likelihood, and mortality differ significantly by country. Heart failure patients are typically classified by ejection fraction, with distinct phenotypes associated with reduced ejection fraction (rEF) or preserved ejection fraction (pEF). Heart failure has a significant financial impact related to hospitalization, medication, and procedural expenses. The costs of heart failure also extend to the reduced quality of life conferred by heart failure symptoms. Management of heart failure includes a variety of interventions, including mechanical circulatory support (MCS). MCS, including left ventricular assist devices (LVADs), right ventricular assist devices (RVADs) and extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO), has been a means of managing end stage heart failure. Given the relative scarcity of transplant organs, the utilization of MCS, particularly as a bridge to transplantation (BTT) has grown significantly. In this review, we discuss statistics related to heart failure and MCS. We evaluate how patients are classified and examine global trends and regional differences. We then address MCS therapies, the costs associated with heart failure, the impact of heart failure on patient quality of life, and data regarding morbidity and mortality.

Advanced heart failure with reduced ejection fraction

Patients suffering advanced heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF) account for a large portion of patients admitted to hospitals worldwide. Mortality and 30-day readmission rates for HFrEF are now a focus of value-based payment models, making management of this disease a priority for hospitals, physicians, and payers alike. Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors have been the cornerstone of therapy for decades. However, with treatment, the prognosis for patients with advanced HFrEF remains poor. Fortunately, advances in medical therapy and mechanical support offer some patients improvement in both survival and quality of life. We review advances in short- and long-term mechanical support and explore changes to organ allocation for cardiac transplantation. In addition, we provide a guide to facilitate appropriate referral to an advanced heart failure team.

Assessing emerging technologies—The case of organ replacement technologies: Volume, durability, cost

Objectives:The aim of this study was to estimate thresholds for production volume, durability, and cost of care for the cost-effective adoption of liver organ replacement technologies (ORTs).

Methods:We constructed a discrete-event simulation model of the liver allocation system in the United States. The model was calibrated against UNOS data (1994–2000). Into this model, we introduced ORTs with varying durability (time to failure), cost of care, and production volume. Primary outputs of interest were time to 5 percent reduction in the waiting list and time to 5 percent increase in expected transplant volume.

Results:Model output for both calibration and validation phases closely matched published data: waiting list length (±2 percent), number of transplants (±2 percent), deaths while waiting (±5 percent), and time to transplant (±11 percent). Reducing the waiting list was dependent on both ORT durability and production volume. The longer the durability, the less production volume needed to reduce the waiting list and vice versa. However, below 250 ORT/year, durability needed to be >2 years for any significant change to be seen in the waiting list. For base-case costs, all ORT production volume and durability scenarios result in more transplants per year at less total cost of care/patient than the current system. ORTs remain cost saving until manufacturing costs are >5 times base-case costs, production is less 500 ORT/year, and durability <6 months.

Conclusions:Although there remain many technical challenges to overcome, as long as ORTs can meet these threshold criteria, they have the potential of transforming the world of end-stage liver disease.

Improvement of the hydrodynamic response of a ventricular assist device: a false auricle solution

We propose a new design of the auricular cannula in ventricular assist devices (VADs), consisting of a collapsible large cannula with a capacity approximately equal to the ejection volume of the VAD. The device works as a false auricle and filters the negative pressure that occurs during diastole. We show that the use of this type of cannula improves the hydrodynamic efficiency and the stability of the working conditions. Moreover, during chronic implantation in sheep, hemolysis stays well below pathological levels. These improvements result in much better controllability of the whole VAD.

In vitro evaluation of an implantable left ventricular assist device

The development of implantable left ventricular assist devices (LVADs) has almost reached the stage of providing permanent circulatory support in patients who are unsuitable for, or denied, the transplant option. As part of our ongoing haemodynamic evaluation of the Thermo Cardiosystems Inc. (Boston, USA) Mark 14 pneumatic LVAD, pressure-volume loops have been produced from in vitro studies using a modified National Heart Lung and Blood Institute (NHLBI, USA) mock circulatory loop. These studies have demonstrated that during certain phases of the pump cycle non-physiologically high and low pressures are generated within the LVAD. Such abnormal pressures may damage either the bioprosthetic valves in the LVAD or the native heart, and may have adverse effects on cardiovascular control mechanisms.

Estimating costs in the economic evaluation of medical technologies

The complexities and nuances of evaluating the costs associated with providing medical technologies are often underestimated by analysts engaged in economic evaluations. This article describes the theoretical underpinnings of cost estimation, emphasizing the importance of accounting for opportunity costs and marginal costs. The various types of costs that should be considered in an analysis are described; a listing of specific cost elements may provide a helpful guide to analysis. The process of identifying and estimating costs is detailed, and practical recommendations for handling the challenges of cost estimation are provided. The roles of sensitivity analysis and discounting are characterized, as are determinants of the types of costs to include in an analysis. Finally, common problems facing the analyst are enumerated with suggestions for managing these problems.

Replacement of the failing heart

Heart transplantation is an effective means of treating patients with severe congestive heart failure. Following heart transplantation, the 1-year survival rate is now greater than 80%, and the 5-year survival rate is more than 60% at major medical centers. More than 1,200 heart transplants were performed in more than nine countries worldwide in 1985. The failure of medicare to pay for this procedure is no longer defensible on medical grounds. The argument in favor of medicare funding for heart transplantation is at least as compelling as that for kidney dialysis, the treatment of cancer, or AIDS. The limited availability of donor organs (at most, 1300-2000/year) is likely to place a finite constraint on the number of heart transplants that can and will be performed. Although combined heart-lung transplantation is feasible therapy for certain patients with severe pulmonary hypertension, the availability of suitable donors poses an even greater restriction on this procedure. Totally implantable ventricular assist devices are on the horizon. These devices have the potential for helping 17,000 to 35,000 patients annually at an estimated cost to society of $2.5 to $5 billion per annum. The development and use of such extremely expensive technology poses major socioeconomic and ethical questions for society.