Profile of epilepsy in a developing country: a study of 1,000 patients based on the international classification

Epilepsy in India I: Epidemiology and public health

Of the 70 million persons with epilepsy (PWE) worldwide, nearly 12 million PWE are expected to reside in India; which contributes to nearly one-sixth of the global burden. This paper (first of the two part series) provides an in-depth understanding of the epidemiological aspects of epilepsy in India for developing effective public health prevention and control programs. The overall prevalence (3.0-11.9 per 1,000 population) and incidence (0.2-0.6 per 1,000 population per year) data from recent studies in India on general population are comparable to the rates of high-income countries (HICs) despite marked variations in population characteristics and study methodologies. There is a differential distribution of epilepsy among various sociodemographic and economic groups with higher rates reported for the male gender, rural population, and low socioeconomic status. A changing pattern in the age-specific occurrence of epilepsy with preponderance towards the older age group is noticed due to sociodemographic and epidemiological transition. Neuroinfections, neurocysticercosis (NCC), and neurotrauma along with birth injuries have emerged as major risk factors for secondary epilepsy. Despite its varied etiology (unknown and known), majority of the epilepsy are manageable in nature. This paper emphasizes the need for focused and targeted programs based on a life-course perspective and calls for a stronger public health approach based on equity for prevention, control, and management of epilepsy in India.

Malnutrition and childhood epilepsy in developing countries

A high prevalence of epilepsy in children is frequently found in developing countries. Though high rates of acquired brain injury may contribute, the possibility that malnutrition may lower seizure threshold has rarely been examined. This review suggests potential biochemical mechanisms that could adversely affect seizure threshold, particularly the effect of malnutrition on inhibitory neurotransmitters and electrolytes. Supporting evidence from animal research and epidemiological findings in children are discussed.

The syndromic classification of the International League Against Epilepsy: a hospital-based study from South India

PURPOSE

To determine the distribution of various epilepsies and epileptic syndromes in the epileptic population treated in a university hospital in a developing country.

METHODS

Data concerning 2,531 patients with epilepsy seen between January 1989 and June 1994 were analyzed using the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) classification.

RESULTS

Of 2,531 cases, 48% fell into ILAE categories 1.3, 3.2, or 4.1 (cryptogenic, without unequivocal generalized or focal seizures; or situation-related seizures, respectively). Localization-related epilepsies (LREs) and epileptic syndromes (1.1, 1.2, 1.3) were found in 1,591 (62.9%) patients; of these patients, symptomatic localization-related epilepsies totaled 62.7%. and idiopathic localization-related epilepsies accounted for only 0.7%. Juvenile myoclonic epilepsy was the most common type of idiopathic generalized epilepsy (IGE), comprising 4.9% of the total study population and 7.7% of patients registered in the epilepsy clinic. A combination of childhood and juvenile absence epilepsies were found in only 0.4% of the total study population. Single computed tomography (CT) enhancing lesion (SCTEL) and focal cerebral calcification (FCC) accounted for 22% of the etiologic factors for localization-related epilepsies. Neurologic deficits were found in 9.5% of patients with SCTEL; none were found with FCC. None of the patients with these lesions had any history of antecedent events that suggested CNS involvement. In patients with localization-related epilepsies with unremarkable clinical data, the proportion of CT scans showing SCTELs was 39 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.35-0.43) and 0.18 (95% CI, 15-0.21) for FCCs. The proportion for both lesions together was 0.57 (95% CI, 0.53-0.61). Seizures did not recur once the lesion resolved in patients with SCTELs. In patients with FCCs, seizure remission was 71.5% (95% CI, 53.7-85.4) at 3 years.

CONCLUSIONS

This study illustrates the rarity in one patient population of some of the syndromes and categories described in the ILAE classification. Childhood and juvenile absence epilepsies together formed a small proportion. SCTEL and FCC were important etiologic factors for localization related epilepsies. The epilepsy associated with SCTEL was a form of benign epilepsy; epilepsy associated with FCC had remission rates similar to other remote symptomatic epilepsies. Without neuroimaging evidence, these 2 lesions would have been missed and the patients might have been grouped under cryptogenic localization related epilepsy. For this reason, we emphasize the need for neuroimaging in patients with localization related epilepsies with unremarkable clinical findings, before classification into the cryptogenic category. In the absence of neuroimaging, such patients should be classified as "probably cryptogenic."

Evaluation of epilepsy management in a developing country: a prospective study of 407 patients

407 patients (248 men, 159 women) of epilepsy attending the neurology clinic were evaluated to find out the profile of epilepsy, cost-effectiveness of various investigations, therapeutic regimens and efficacy of referring physicians in a developing country. At the time of onset of seizures 67.2% of patients were in the second and third decade. Generalised tonic clonic seizures were the commonest seizure type seen. Specific aetiology was established in 20.8% cases only. Neurocysticercosis was the commonest cause observed. The main source of referral (50.1%) was general practitioners. Referral diagnosis was incomplete in 52.8% of the cases. Investigations did not alter the diagnosis in 62.5% cases. The EEG was useful in the management of 15.1% cases of epilepsy. The skull x-ray and chest x-ray were abnormal in 1.7% and 2% cases respectively. CT scan revealed abnormality in 39.4% cases. Most of the patients were treated with monotherapy. Phenytoin, phenobarbitone and carbamazepine were the common drug used. Out of 246 cases who were started on anticonvulsant therapy prior to referral, the choice of drug was wrong in 78 (31.7%) cases and dose was inappropriate in 121 (49.2%) cases. It was concluded that most important factor for cost effective management of epilepsy is proper clinical evaluation and education of general physicians in this direction.

Relations of genetic and environmental factors in the etiology of epilepsy

We assessed the relations of genetic and environmental factors in the etiology of epilepsy. The study population comprised 9,705 first-degree relatives of 1,951 adults with epilepsy ascertained from voluntary organizations. We calculated standardized morbidity ratios for specific etiologies of epilepsy in the relatives of probands with the same etiologies, using population incidence rates from Rochester, MN, as the reference. Relatives of probands with idiopathic/cryptogenic epilepsy had increased risk for idiopathic/cryptogenic epilepsy and for epilepsy associated with neurological deficit presumed present at birth (cerebral palsy or mental retardation) but not for symptomatic epilepsy associated with postnatal central nervous system insults. Relatives of probands with neurodeficits had increased risks for idiopathic/cryptogenic epilepsy. Risk for epilepsy was not increased among relatives of probands with postnatal symptomatic epilepsy. The degree of increased risk of idiopathic/cryptogenic epilepsy in relatives of probands with idiopathic/cryptogenic epilepsy diminished with increasing age of the relatives; risk was not increased at age 35 or older. These findings support the possibility of shared genetic susceptibility to epilepsy and cerebral palsy, and suggest that the genetic contributions to postnatal symptomatic epilepsy are minimal.

Likelihood of pregnancy in individuals with idiopathic/cryptogenic epilepsy: social and biologic influences

We interviewed 1,558 adults with idiopathic/cryptogenic epilepsy ascertained from voluntary organizations and 316 of their siblings without epilepsy to determine their personal history of marriage and pregnancy. We examined the effects of seizure type, age at onset, and family history of epilepsy on the sex-specific likelihood of pregnancy in individuals with idiopathic/cryptogenic epilepsy as compared with their same-sex siblings. Overall, men with idiopathic/cryptogenic epilepsy were only 36% as likely as male unaffected siblings ever to have fathered a pregnancy. In men, the reduced likelihood of fathering a pregnancy was associated with partial-onset seizures, early age at onset (< 20 years), and a negative family history of epilepsy, and the effects of these epilepsy characteristics appeared to be mediated through reduced marriage rates. Among men with epilepsy who had ever been married, reproductive disadvantage was confined to those with early-onset (< 10 years) partial epilepsy. Overall, women with idiopathic/cryptogenic epilepsy were only 37% as likely ever to have had a pregnancy as female unaffected siblings; this effect was not strongly influenced by seizure type, age at onset, or family history of epilepsy. In women who had ever been married, unlike in men, reduced likelihood of pregnancy persisted, regardless of seizure type, age at onset, or family history of epilepsy.

Classification of epileptic seizures: a hospital-based study of 1,250 patients in a developing country

The 1981 International Classification of Epileptic Seizures (ICES) was used to study the distribution of seizure types in 1,250 patients attending an Epilepsy Clinic in Sri Lanka. Based on seizure symptomatology 94.6% of the cases could be classified, and by adding the routine interictal EEG findings the percentage of classifiable seizures increased to 97%. Partial seizures (73.8% cases) were three times as common as generalized seizures (23.3% cases). Of the partial seizures, simple partial seizures (SPS) accounted for only 0.4% cases, and complex partial seizures (CPS) for 8.8%, whereas partial seizures secondarily generalized (PSGS) accounted for 64.6%. PSGS had simple onset in 12.5% and complex onset in 34.8% of cases. Myoclonic seizures were the commonest of the generalized seizures, accounting for 14.6% of all cases. Tonic-clonic seizures accounted for 7.4% of cases; absence seizures accounted for only 1.3%. The study showed the 1981 ICES to be relevant and applicable in a clinical setting with limited investigatory facilities. Difficulties encountered with regard to certain subcategories could be overcome with minor modifications which made the classification operative. Routine EEG confirmed the diagnosis in a significant number of cases but changed the diagnosis in only a few, confirming that a good standardized questionnaire is the key instrument for classifying epileptic seizures.

Data collection strategies in genetic epidemiology: The Epilepsy Family Study of Columbia University

A large-scale study of genetic influences on seizure disorders is described here as a primer of tested methods for collection of family history data. 1957 adult probands with epilepsy were ascertained from voluntary organizations. Personal and family history data were obtained from probands in semistructured telephone interviews. To increase sensitivity, an independent family history was obtained from a second family informant in a similar interview. To increase specificity and diagnostic detail, family members reported to be affected were interviewed, and medical records of probands and affected relatives were collected. Participation rates for probands were 84-90%. Interviews were completed with second informants in 67% of families, and with 51% of eligible affected relatives. The main reasons for non-interview were lack of permission from probands and difficulties in locating relatives. Although 90% of probands gave verbal permission for medical record review, only 75% of these signed and returned consent forms for this purpose. Physicians returned 87% of the records requested. The resulting proportion of probands with medical records was 59%. These findings illustrate the complexity involved in assembling useful databases in genetic epidemiology.

Prognosis of epilepsy in newly referred patients: a multicenter prospective study of the effects of monotherapy on the long-term course of epilepsy. Collaborative Group for the Study of Epilepsy

A cohort of 280 previously untreated epilepsy subjects (159 men and 121 women aged 2-81 years) recruited in 14 Italian centers were treated with antiepileptic drug (AED) monotherapy and followed for a median period of 48 months to investigate the rates of seizure remission (i.e., complete control), in general and with reference to various prognostic factors. The cumulative probability of achieving 1-year remission was 62% by 1 year after onset of treatment, 81% by 2 years, 92% by 3 years, and 98% by 5 years. The corresponding figures for 2- and 3-year remission at 5 years were 92 and 78%, respectively. Sixty-two patients (22.1%) had no remission period with monotherapy. Remission rates were significantly lower among patients with two or more seizure types and were inversely correlated to the number of seizures before treatment. The rate of seizure relapses during the first year of follow-up appear to correlate to the risk of developing refractory epilepsy (i.e., with no remission).

Etiology of epilepsy. A prospective study of 210 cases

The objective of this study was to establish the etiology of epilepsy in 210 chronic epileptics (110 female, 100 male), aged 14-82 years (34.2 +/- 13.3). Patients less than 10 years-old and alcoholism were excluded. All underwent neurological examination, routine blood tests, EEG and CT-scan. Twenty patients (10.5%) were submitted to spinal tap for CSF examination. Neurological examination was abnormal in 26 (12.4%), the EEG in 68 (45.5%), and CT-scan in 93 (44.3%). According to the International Classification of Epileptic Seizures (1981), 101 (48.1%) have generalized seizures, 66 (31.4%) partial seizures secondarily generalized, 25 (11.8%) simple partial and complex partial seizures, and 14 (6.6%) generalized and partial seizures. Four patients (2.0%) could not be classified. In 125 (59.5%) patients the etiology was unknown. Neurocysticercosis accounted for 57 (27.1%) of cases, followed by cerebrovascular disease 8 (3.8%), perinatal damage 5 (2.4%), familial epilepsy 4 (1.9%), head injury 4 (1.9%), infective 1 (0.5%), and miscelanea 6 (2.8%).

Descriptive epidemiologic study of epilepsy syndromes in a district of northwest Tuscany, Italy

To evaluate the prevalence of epilepsy syndromes in a district in Northwest Tuscany (Vecchiano, 9,952 inhabitants) we identified all suspected cases (probable epilepsy) from several information sources: files of local doctors, prescriptions of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs), hospital files from the center for epilepsy at the University of Pisa, medical files from university and hospital departments in Pisa, and files of the school doctors and social workers in the district of Vecchiano. All persons suspected of having epilepsy were examined; 51 cases of epilepsy were found, i.e., a prevalence rate of 5.1 in 1,000. During a previous study performed in the same district with the "house-to-house" method, a lower rate was found. Our study confirms that use of different epidemiologic investigational methods can produce different results.

Clinical and electroencephalographic characteristics of epilepsy in rural Ethiopia: a community-based study

A community-based epidemiological study of neurological disorders was performed in a rural area in Ethiopia. The most prevalent neurological disorder identified was epilepsy, found in 316 persons. The prevalence of epilepsy was 5.2/1000 inhabitants at risk, 5.8 for males, 4.6 for females. The highest age-specific prevalence was found for ages 10-19 years. Generalized tonic-clonic seizures were the most common seizure type and occurred in 81%. On clinical grounds, partial seizures occurred in 20% and in 29% of these secondary generalization followed. During seizures, 8.5% had been injured by burns and 5.7% by trauma. Eighty-four percent had seizures at least monthly. Seizures occurred in 4.8% of siblings. Traditional treatment with local herbs, holy water and amulets was the most common. Only 1.6% had been treated with recognized antiepileptic drugs. Mental retardation was the most common associated disorder, found in 7.9% of the persons with epilepsy. During a period of 2 years, 8 persons died of status epilepticus and 1 from severe burns as a result of falling into a domestic fire during a seizure. EEG was recorded in 73%. Epileptiform activity occurred in 18%.

Epidemiology of epilepsy in Guaymi Indians from Bocas del Toro Province, Republic of Panama

This cross-sectional study was conducted to describe the epidemiology of epilepsy in Guaymi Indians residing in Changuinola, a small town on Panama's Caribbean coast near Costa Rica. We randomly selected households and attempted to enroll all residents aged less than or equal to 1 year; 337 eligible subjects agreed to participate (93% response rate). We administered a standard neurologic disease screening examination to all subjects and, if any abnormality was found, we administered a standard neurologic evaluation. We detected 19 cases of active epilepsy; the mean age at onset was 12 years, and generalized tonic-clonic seizures were the most common diagnosis (10 of 19, 53%). The prevalence of active epilepsy among Caribbean coastal Guaymi (57/1000) is considerably greater than that in lower class Panama City populations (22/1000) or in other parts of the world. To identify risk factors for epilepsy, we collected epidemiologic data and serum (for Cysticercus antibody) from subjects with active epilepsy and from 44 age/sex-matched controls. Significantly more cases (47%) than controls (6%) had other family members with epilepsy (relative risk, RR = 14); 44% of cases and 13% of controls reported a history of febrile seizures during childhood (RR = 6).

Incidence and prevalence of epilepsy in adults in eastern Finland

In Finland, only limited data exist on the epidemiology of epilepsy in adults. This prompted us to study the incidence and prevalence of epilepsy in a population over 15 years of age, residing in Eastern Finland. In a retrospective study, various medical data sources were used to identify and reexamine all patients with established or suspected epileptic seizures during 1960-1979. A total of 1,233 patients with active epilepsy were identified. Mean annual incidence of epilepsy was 24/100,000. Age-specific incidence ratios tended to increase with advancing age. Prevalence of active epilepsy was 629/100,000. Both prevalence and incidence were higher in males than in females. Age-specific prevalence of active epilepsy increased until 40-50 years of age, and declined in the oldest age groups. Of the various seizure types, highest prevalence ratios were observed for partial secondarily generalized seizures, complex partial seizures, and tonic-clonic seizures. Prevalence of partial seizures and generalized seizures had a different age-related pattern.

Retrospective analysis of drug treatment in epileptic patients

An epidemiological analysis was performed of the adult, out-patient epilepsy clinic population of a university hospital during the period from 1 January 1981 through 30 June 1985. The number of patients that could be traced amounted to 590. An at random sample of 207 were retrospectively analysed. Gender distribution was male:female = 1.46. The mean age was 37.4 years. The diagnoses were classified according to the classification of the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE). A preponderance of partial seizures was present, reflecting the selection in a university out-patient clinic of more difficult to treat forms of epilepsy. Antiepileptic drugs used in the treatment varied; monotherapy was obtained in 46% of the cases and carbamazepine was the most frequently prescribed drug (49%). Changes in seizure severity and factors associated with epilepsy are described. A discrepancy was found between the suspected drug levels, based upon the physician's judgement, and the plasma level measured in those patients in whom drug levels were monitored; factors interfering with clinical judgement are discussed.

Severe epilepsy: diagnostic and epidemiological aspects

Epidemiological parameters of epilepsy have been estimated in a large number of studies. Reported annual incidence rates for recurrent seizures vary between 30 and 50/100,000, and prevalence rates in most studies between 500 and 1000/100,000. Varying findings are mostly due to different case ascertainment methods and definitions of epilepsy applied in different surveys. These aspects will be discussed in this paper. A special emphasis is laid on differential diagnosis of seizure disorders, and on the prevalence and causes of complex partial epilepsy. This epileptic disorder is one of the most common forms of epilepsy, and also difficult to treat in many cases. Many recent reports show that prognosis of seizures in patients with epilepsy is better than suggested in earlier studies. However, 25-30% of epileptics seem to have frequent (greater than 1/month) seizures. Our own study, in accordance with earlier findings suggests that prevalence of patients with severe complex partial epilepsy is about 80-90/100,000. Available literature provides several predictive factors for the prognosis of seizures and assessment of prognosis is possible quite early after the onset of seizures. Treatment choices for patients with intractable epilepsy will be discussed.

Classifications of epileptic syndromes: advantages and limitations for evaluation of childhood epileptic syndromes in clinical practice

The advantages and limitations of the two most recent International League Against Epilepsy classifications of the epilepsies and epileptic syndromes have been assessed after examining the clinical records of 645 consecutive outpatients aged 1 month to 15 years followed at the Children's Epilepsy Center of the University of Milan, Italy, from 1977 through 1985. The percentage of cases that could be classified according to the 1970 and 1985 proposals for classification were 94.1 and 98.1%, respectively. According to the 1985 proposal, partial epilepsies (PE) and generalized epilepsies (GE) were almost equally represented (45.0 vs. 47.2%). Among PE, symptomatic epilepsies were the commonest variety. In the group of GE, idiopathic and/or symptomatic epilepsies were most common. Childhood absence epilepsy was the largest subgroup among idiopathic GE. Newly diagnosed patients, a less biased sample of the epileptic population represented 38.9% of the entire sample, and a proper classification was possible in 96% of cases. Idiopathic epilepsies were about twice as frequent and idiopathic and/or symptomatic GE less frequent in newly diagnosed patients when compared with the remainder. Marked differences in the frequency of the epilepsies were found in comparison with other reports in the literature which used the 1970 classification. This finding probably depends on different diagnostic assessment, selection bias, and different geographic and ethnic components, but it can also reflect the variable interpretation of the clinical and EEG features of a patient with epilepsy in the light of the artifactual categories of the classification.

Distribution of seizure types in an epileptic population

The distribution of seizure types was investigated in an epidemiological survey of 1,220 patients over 15 years of age. Classification of clinically dominant seizure type according to the International Classification of Epileptic Seizures (ICES) was possible in 1,005 cases (82.5%). Fifty-six percent of patients had partial seizures and 26.5% had generalized seizures. Subclassification of partial seizures revealed simple partial seizures (SPS) in 7.5% of the cases, complex partial seizures (CPS) in 23%, and partial secondarily generalized seizures (PSGS) in 25.5% of the cases. Simple partial onset was seen in 56% of the patients with CPS, and impairment of consciousness at the onset occurred in the remaining 44%. PSGS started with simple partial onset in 92% of the cases and the remaining 8% started with a complex partial phase. Tonic-clonic seizures were the most common type of generalized seizures, accounting for 23% of all and 88% of generalized seizures. Absence seizures were seen in 1% of the cases. A single seizure type was observed in 737 patients (60%) and the remaining 40% had multiple seizure types. SPS, CPS, and absence seizures were most commonly combined with other seizure types. The study revealed that distribution of seizure type varies as a function of age. Although the present study finds ICES relevant, difficulties in its utilization in epidemiological context are demonstrated.

Prevalence of the epilepsies in Nigerian Africans: a community-based study

A door-to-door survey to detect commonly occurring neurologic diseases was carried out in Igbo-Ora, a large Nigerian town with a population of approximately 20,000. Effective health care facilities have been operating in the community since 1963. Primary health care workers and nondoctor personnel administered a complete census, a screening questionnaire, and a simple screening neurologic examination. The pretested screening questionnaire had been shown in a pilot study to have a sensitivity of 95% for identifying those with epilepsy. Individuals positive on the screening phase of the survey were evaluated by neurologists and neurosurgeons, who used well-defined criteria to make the diagnosis. There were 101 (48 males and 53 females) who suffered from active epilepsy (5.3 cases/1,000) on prevalence day. The highest age-specific prevalence ratios occurred in those below age 20. The most common of the identifiable seizure types was complex partial seizures (52 cases). The prevalence ratio of epilepsy in this Nigerian town (with an effective health care system) is similar to that reported in some developed countries and several times lower than figures derived from studies in developing countries. These data suggest that an improved health care system would probably reduce the prevalence and burden of epilepsy in developing countries.

Epilepsy in general practice: the Dutch situation

Treatment and supervision of epileptic patients is part of specialist medicine. A possible change in the role of specialists and general practitioners in the care of these patients was explored by a questionnaire mailed to all Dutch neurologists and a random sample of general practitioners. Patients were also asked their opinion. The real situation was studied in a group of patients retrieved from the registers of general practitioners. Demographic, psychosocial, and epilepsy characteristics were sampled. Specialists tend not to want a change in their role; general practitioners desire a change. At present, patients do not want a change, but in future a change might be acceptable to them. More patients than expected were supervised by their general practitioner only. Their demographic and psychosocial characteristics did not differ from those in the population at large. Epilepsy characteristics corresponded with those in other studies.

Identification of neuropsychological deficits in epilepsy using the Luria-Nebraska Neuropsychological Battery: a replication attempt

Using the Luria-Nebraska Neuropsychological Battery (LNNB), Berg and Golden (1981) assessed 40 patients with epilepsy and reported a hit rate of 77.3% for idiopathic epilepsy and 88.9% for symptomatic epilepsy (82.5% overall). The purpose of this investigation was to attempt to replicate their important findings. A consecutive series of 31 patients with epilepsy was administered the LNNB and we obtained a hit rate of 47% for idiopathic epilepsy and 30% for symptomatic epilepsy (41% overall). Four possible methodological reasons for these disparate findings were offered.

Classification of the epilepsies: an investigation of 945 patients in a developing country

The present study classified epilepsies in Nigerians and compared them with the profile of epilepsies as found in other countries: India, France, and Denmark. Partial epilepsy formed the largest group (76.6%) in this study and in that in India (80%), but these incidences were higher than that found in France (62%), owing to a higher frequency of birth injury, CNS infections, and childhood febrile convulsions in developing countries. In contrast to our study and that in France, where partial epilepsy with complex symptomatology formed the largest subgroup, partial epilepsy with elementary symptomatology formed the largest subgroup in India. The reason for this is not totally clear, though etiological factors and criteria for categorization are contributory. The incidence of partial epilepsy was lower in children than in adults owing to a relatively lower incidence of partial epilepsy with elementary symptomatology in children in the present series and a lower incidence of complex symptomatology in children in France and Denmark. Nigerian children seem more vulnerable to complex symptomatology owing to a high incidence of febrile illness (e.g., from malaria) and febrile convulsions. The incidence of generalized epilepsies in children was higher than in adults. Grand mal formed the largest subgroup of generalized epilepsies in children in this series and in Denmark, whereas petit mal formed the largest subgroup in France and India. Petit mal was relatively rare in children in our series (2.5%) compared with children in the French study (17.5%). Secondary generalized epilepsy was peculiar to children in all the series.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

A descriptive study of epilepsy in the district of Copparo, Italy, 1964-1978

Worldwide investigation of the epidemiology of epilepsy has suggested wide variations in the frequency of convulsive disorders. However, descriptive studies in general populations cannot be completely comparable because of a remarkable methodological dishomogeneity in definition of epilepsy, classification of seizures, and ascertainment, collection, and selection of the cases. The position with regard to the Mediterranean people was still little known, and the few studies presently available from Italy offer underestimates of epilepsy frequency owing to incompleteness in case-collection practices and lack of information about the incidence of the disease. Therefore, to verify the true frequency of epilepsy in our country, we performed a community-based epidemiologic study of convulsive disorders in the district of Copparo (population 45,153) in northern Italy. Based on 278 accepted cases with "active" epilepsy, the prevalence per 1,000 population on December 31, 1978, was 6.2 (6.4 if standardized to the Italian population). The average annual incidence for the period 1964 through 1978 was 33.1 per 100,000 (38.3 if standardized). These results, similar to those found in other Western countries, support the view that the frequency of epilepsy in Italy as a whole is higher than that indicated by the Italian studies previously published, and suggest that epilepsy is evenly distributed in Europe and the United States. Antecedents which could be considered potential causes of epilepsy were found in 39.6%, and in 39.1% of the prevalence and incidence cases, respectively; for both prevalence and incidence groups, perinatal brain injuries were the most frequent event. This high proportion of epileptic cases with underlying causes emphasizes the urgency of planning precautionary measures in Italy to improve prenatal and perinatal medical care.

[Clinical study of catamenial epilepsy: clinical types of epileptic crises]

Four hundred thirty one epileptic patients, aged 10 years or more old, have been studied in the neurology clinic of Hospital das Clínicas da Faculdade de Medicina de Ribeirão Preto da U.S.P., from February to July, 1981. The authors selected 119 patients aged between 13 to 45 years, that presented periodic menstrual bleeding and at least, one epileptic seizure a month. The patients were divided in two groups, the first constituted of 36 patients with catamenial seizures and the second one with 83 patients showing non catamenial seizures. It was determined a prevalence coefficient of 105.9/1000. The authors classify the clinical types of epileptic seizures found in patients with catamenial epilepsy and compare them with those occurred in a group of patients on menacme. The statistical analysis shows that there are no differences between the two groups.

Classification of partial epilepsies according to the symptomatology of seizures: practical value and prognostic implications

Among 1,000 outpatient epileptics who visited the Epilepsy Center of Bologna consecutively from 1974 to 1978, 596 cases of partial epilepsy (PE) were chosen, representing 62.9% of all cases classified according to the International Classification of epilepsies. Fifty-four of these cases (5.7%) of those classifiable) that were affected by benign infantile epilepsy with rolandic spikes were not analyzed further. The remaining cases were divided up into three groups based on the symptomatology of the seizures: (1) partial elementary epilepsy (PEE), 102 cases (10.8%); (2) partial complex epilepsy (PCE), 332 cases (35%); and (3) partial secondarily generalized epilepsy (PSGE), 108 cases (11.4%). The three groups were compared according to the parameters that distinguish recognized epileptic syndromes, in order to see whether they constitute autonomous nosographic entities. Among the three groups, significant differences did not arise with regard to the incidence of single lesional etiological factors, the age of onset of the epilepsy, the neurological context, and the general features of interictal EEG. PSGE instead differs significantly from the other two forms for the minor severity of the epilepsy at first examination and for its more favorable course: after at least 2 years of follow-up under treatment, the epilepsy appeared to be controlled in 60.6% of the cases with PSGE, in 31.6% of those with PEE, and in 37.5% of those with PCE (p less than 0.05). For those with PE, globally considered, only three parameters have a favorable prognostic value: the brief duration of the epilepsy at the first observation, the rarity of the seizures, and the presence of only one type of seizure.

Partial epilepsy in childhood: clinical and EEG study of 261 cases

A prospective clinical and EEG study is presented based on 261 children affected by partial seizures with or without focal EEG abnormalities, or by generalized seizures with focal EEG disturbances. From the clinical point of view, the partial seizures were most frequently elementary and motor, quite often associated with generalized seizures (64.36%), appearing in the majority of the cases during the first year of life, with rare frequency (less than 1 seizure/6 months). Perinatal disturbances appear to be the most important etiological factor. Partial epilepsy is often included within a previous neurological syndrome (secondary epilepsy). The clinical outcome is most frequently favorable (71.72%) with therapeutic treatment, especially with respect to the cases of primary epilepsy, characterized by rare seizures, which appear after the first year of life. From the EEG point of view, we noted specific monofocal abnormalities (72.79%), most frequently with temporal and rolandic localisation; during the follow-up the EEG abnormalities presented modifications in 58.89% of the cases, with normalisation in 22.98%.

Quality of care of epilepsy in Italy: multi-hospital survey of diagnosis and treatment of 1104 epileptic patients

We surveyed the treatment of 1104 patients admitted to 27 out of the 46 departments of neurology (64.5%), neurosurgery (23.0%), and child neurology (12.5%) of Lombardy, the largest Italian Region (population, 9,000,000). Our main aim was to assess the penetration of correct diagnostic and clinicopharmacological information into routine practice. A detailed analysis and discussion are given to data concerning reasons for hospital admission (therapeutic adjustment accounting for 27.3%; diagnostic ascertainment, 53.8%); characteristics of the disease, in terms of duration, clinical manifestations, and pattern of seizures; associated disorders; prevalence and criteria for the use of instrumental diagnostic procedures (EEG, brain scan, computed tomography, etc.); pattern of prescriptions of anticonvulsant drugs at admission and at discharge, with particular emphasis on specific drug choices by specialty; prevalence of single-drug therapy (41% at admission and 47.0% at discharge) versus polytherapy; degree of correspondence between recommended and observed dosage regimens (undertreatment being a more common problem than excessive dosing); and reporting of side effects. Although some of the findings of some recent studies are confirmed, this report documents the feasibility of a regular audit program of the performance of an entire health care system in the treatment of epilepsy.

Hospitalization rates for epilepsy in the United States, 1973-1976

Data on numbers of admissions and admission rates for all-listed and first-listed epilepsy in nonfederal short-stay hospitals are presented. These statistics are based on 232,000 hospital discharge records from a probability sample of approximately 7,000 hospitals. The patterns of admission rates for epilepsy are compared with the prevalence of epilepsy and trends of admission rates for all conditions.

Classification of the epilepsies. An investigation of 1,508 consecutive adult patients

The relative frequency of different types of epilepsy in accordance with the International Classification of Epilepsies is reported, concerning 1,508 consecutive outpatients with epilepsy, who at the time of investigation were at age 15 years and above. The investigation showed a marked preponderance for partial epilepsies as against generalized epilepsies; partial epilepsies with complex symptomatology were especially frequent, contributing by more than one third of all cases.