Challenges and future directions of SUDEP models

Sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP) is the leading cause of death among patients with epilepsy, causing a global public health burden. The underlying mechanisms of SUDEP remain elusive, and effective prevention or treatment strategies require further investigation. A major challenge in current SUDEP research is the lack of an ideal model that maximally mimics the human condition. Animal models are important for revealing the potential pathogenesis of SUDEP and preventing its occurrence; however, they have potential limitations due to species differences that prevent them from precisely replicating the intricate physiological and pathological processes of human disease. This Review provides a comprehensive overview of several available SUDEP animal models, highlighting their pros and cons. More importantly, we further propose the establishment of an ideal model based on brain-computer interfaces and artificial intelligence, hoping to offer new insights into potential advancements in SUDEP research. In doing so, we hope to provide valuable information for SUDEP researchers, offer new insights into the pathogenesis of SUDEP and open new avenues for the development of strategies to prevent SUDEP.

The mechanism of sudden unexpected death in epilepsy: A mini review

Sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP) is defined as a sudden, unexpected, non-traumatic, non-drowning death in a person with epilepsy. SUDEP is generally considered to result from seizure-related cardiac dysfunction, respiratory depression, autonomic nervous dysfunction, or brain dysfunction. Frequency of generalized tonic clonic seizures (GTCS), prone posture, and refractory epilepsy are considered risk factors. SUDEP has also been associated with inherited cardiac ion channel disease and severe obstructive sleep apnea. Most previous studies of SUDEP mechanisms have focused on cardiac and respiratory dysfunction and imbalance of the neural regulatory system. Cardiac-related mechanisms include reduction in heart rate variability and prolongation of QT interval, which can lead to arrhythmias. Laryngospasm and amygdala activation may cause obstructive and central apnea, respectively. Neural mechanisms include impairment of 5-HT and adenosine neuromodulation. The research to date regarding molecular mechanisms of SUDEP is relatively limited. Most studies have focused on p-glycoprotein, catecholamines, potassium channels, and the renin-angiotensin system, all of which affect cardiac and respiratory function.

The Translational Benefits of Sheep as Large Animal Models of Human Neurological Disorders

The past two decades have seen a considerable rise in the use of sheep to model human neurological disorders. While each animal model has its merits, sheep have many advantages over small animal models when it comes to studies on the brain. In particular, sheep have brains more comparable in size and structure to the human brain. They also have much longer life spans and are docile animals, making them useful for a wide range of in vivo studies. Sheep are amenable to regular blood and cerebrospinal fluid sampling which aids in biomarker discovery and monitoring of treatment efficacy. Several neurological diseases have been found to occur naturally in sheep, however sheep can also be genetically engineered or experimentally manipulated to recapitulate disease or injury. Many of these types of sheep models are currently being used for pre-clinical therapeutic trials, particularly gene therapy, with studies from several models culminating in potential treatments moving into clinical trials. This review will provide an overview of the benefits of using sheep to model neurological conditions, and highlight naturally occurring and experimentally induced sheep models that have demonstrated translational validity.

Scurrying to Understand Sudden Expected Death in Epilepsy: Insights From Animal Models

Sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP) is the leading cause of death in patients with refractory epilepsy, accounting for up to 17% of deaths in patients with epilepsy. The pathophysiology of SUDEP has remained unclear, largely because it is unpredictable and commonly unwitnessed. This poses a great challenge to studies in patients. Recently, there has been an increase in animal studies to try to better understand the pathophysiology of SUDEP. In this current review, we focus on developments through seizure-induced death models and the preventative strategies they may reveal.

Expansion of pulmonary arteriovenous malformations after grand mal seizures and other circumstances of PAVM growth

A woman with asymptomatic pulmonary arteriovenous malformation (PAVM) discovered incidentally on admission developed recurrent generalised seizures. Immediately after, the PAVM demonstrated marked expansion, and was safely resected. Congenital PAVMs (associated with hereditary haemorrhagic telangiectasia or sporadic) are considered stable lesions that exhibit very slow growth if at all. A review of the literature reveals all circumstances of accelerated growth of PAVM (puberty, pregnancy, postpartum, pulmonary hypertension) and suggests a novel mechanism of seizure-associated expansion. This is important because the size and rapid growth of PAVMs correlate with the potential for rupture and other ominous complications such as right to left shunt and paradoxical emboli. The new seizures-PAVM progression association mandates recognition since the risk of seizures in patients with PAVM is substantial. Our observations strongly suggest the need to monitor PAVM in patients with or without haemorrhagic telangiectasis by repeated imaging after generalised seizures to evaluate potential expansion and risk.

Furthering our understanding of SUDEP: the role of animal models

Sudden and unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP) is the most common type of death among patients with epilepsy. Here, we address the importance of the experimental models in search of the mechanisms underlying SUDEP. Most studies have investigated the cardiovascular responses in animal models of epilepsy. However, there are few proposed SUDEP models in literature. Hypoventilation, apnea, respiratory distress, pulmonary hypertension, autonomic dysregulation and arrhythmia are common findings in epilepsy models. Impairments on adenosinergic and serotonergic systems, brainstem spreading depolarization, seizure-activation of neural substrates related to cardiorespiratory control, altered autonomic control, and mutations on sodium and potassium channels are hypothesis suggested. Overall, current research highlights the evident multifactorial nature of SUDEP, which involves acute and chronic aspects ranging from systemic to molecular alterations. Thus, we are convinced that elucidation and prevention of SUDEP can be achieved only through the interaction between basic and clinical science.

Changes in Baroreflex Responses of Kindled Rats

PURPOSE

This study was planned to investigate the baroreflex responses (BRs) in kindled rats during seizure-free period to put forward new data on cardiac autonomic changes in epilepsy.

METHODS

Male Wistar rats were randomized into sham-operated (SO) and kindled groups where stimulation and recording electrodes were implanted stereotaxically into the basolateral amygdala and the cortex, respectively. For kindling process, rats were stimulated twice daily at their afterdischarge threshold current and accepted as being kindled after 10 grade 5 seizures. Six to 8 weeks after the establishment of the kindled state, mean arterial pressure (MAP) and heart rate (HR) were evaluated. BR was defined as the ratio of HR response to changes in MAP induced by i.v. nitroprusside (10, 25 microg/kg) or i.v. phenylephrine (10, 25 microg/kg). The sympathetic or parasympathetic component of the BR was evaluated in rats pretreated with atropine or atenolol where phenylephrine or nitroprusside was administered at 25 microg/kg.

RESULTS

Basal MAP and HR values were found to be similar in SO and kindled rats. Phenylephrine increased MAP more in the kindled group (p < 0.05), but the HR decreased similarly in both groups. Nitroprusside decreased MAP at similar rates, but the increase in HR was higher in the kindled rats (p < 0.05). BRs to phenylephrine and nitroprusside were abolished after pretreatment with atenolol and atropine, whereas phenylephrine- and nitroprusside-induced changes in MAP remained unchanged in both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

These results may indicate that amygdaloid kindling affects BRs in long-term seizure-free periods.

Does epilepsy surgery lower the mortality of drug-resistant epilepsy?

Drug-resistant epilepsy has proved to be associated with an increased standardized mortality ratio (SMR), primarily due to seizure-related fatalities including sudden unexpected death (SUDEP). Recent studies have suggested that the surgical cure of temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) was likely to normalize the SMR of patients suffering from refractory TLE. However, these studies raise a number of methodological issues, which have not always been fully addressed. Some conclusions have relied on previously reported data, indicating a SMR of approximately 5, and a SUDEP incidence of 9/1000 patient-years in drug-resistant epilepsy. In fact, as shown in this review, SMR varied considerably, from 2 to 16, in the various series of patients with refractory epilepsy, whereas the average SUDEP incidence in the same populations was calculated at 3.7/1000 patient-years. Other conclusions were based on the comparison of either surgically and medically treated patients, or cured and non-cured operated patients. In both situations, the two groups included a different proportion of excellent and poor surgical candidates. The biological differences that distinguish these two populations might explain part of the differences observed in their mortality rate, regardless of the effect of surgery. In particular, temporal-plus epilepsies involving the insula, the frontal orbital, or the frontal operculum region, might favour ictal arrhythmias, central apnoea and secondary generalization, which in turn would increase the risk of SUDEP. Future studies are thus warranted to specifically address these issues.

Magnetic resonance imaging predicts neuropathology from soman-mediated seizures in the rodent

Intoxication by the organophosphate compound soman causes prolonged seizures that lead to neuropathology in the brain. This MRI-based study describes the temporal and spatial evolution of brain pathology that follows soman-induced convulsions. We observed significant decreases in apparent diffusion coefficients (ADC; 23% below control) of the hippocampus and thalamus by 12 h after soman treatment. The ADC then returned to near normal values in all regions at 24 h but declined again during the next 7 days. These data suggest that the initial cellular degradation may be resolved but is ultimately followed by regional cellular remodeling. T2 relaxation values declined significantly at 12 h (37% decrease) returning to near normal values by 24 h. These data lend detail to the model suggesting that injured tissues experience an edematous influx that is resolved by 24 h. The imaging data was fully supported by histopathological comparisons where moderate cell loss and swelling within the hippocampus and piriform cortex was observed. This is the first report providing excellenttemporal and spatial resolution of emerging soman-mediated, seizure-induced neuropathology using MRI with histological correlation.

[Bradycardia as an epileptic manifestation in temporal epilepsy: report of a case]

We describe a patient who had cardiac arrhythmia as epileptic manifestation. In a 34-year-old woman who had many episodes of loss of consciousness, the simultaneous ECG and video-EEG monitoring recorded bradycardia with a short episode of asystole (4 seconds) and left temporal rhythmic theta activity on EEG. MRI showed a small mass lesion in the left parahippocampal gyrus. Alterations in cardiac rhythm have been reported in epileptic seizures and tachycardia is the most common finding associated with them; bradyarrhythmia during seizures was uncommon. Many interconnections among insular cortex, limbic system and hypothalamus, may be responsible for vegetative manifestations in temporal lobe epilepsy.

Sudden unexplained death and injury in epilepsy

Seizures may be associated with risk of injury or death. Injuries are common in patients with epilepsy, with up to 30% of patients reporting injuries, most commonly blunt trauma and lacerations. Seizures associated with falls increase the risk of injury, but any seizure that is associated with alteration in consciousness may cause injury. Patients with seizures may injure others, especially by causing motor vehicle accidents. Each state has restrictions on driving, requiring seizure-free intervals that range from 3 to 18 months. Mortality is increased in patients with epilepsy. The standardized mortality ratio is increased two to three times in epilepsy cohorts. Sudden unexplained death in epilepsy (SUDEP) is responsible for 2% to 17% of all deaths in patients with epilepsy, depending on the cohort studied. Population-based studies of SUDEP show a lower overall SUDEP rate compared with clinical trials or epilepsy referral center cohorts. Overall, the risk of sudden death is increased in the epilepsy population by 24 times compared with the general population. Risk factors for SUDEP may include poorly controlled seizures, early onset of epilepsy, and generalized tonic-clonic seizures. The pathophysiology of SUDEP is unknown, but animal data suggest apnea may be the initial factor that results in sudden death.

Seizure control and mortality in epilepsy

Mortality rates are increased among people with epilepsy, and may be highest in those with uncontrolled seizures. Because epilepsy surgery eliminates seizures in some people, we used an epilepsy surgery population to examine how seizure control influences mortality. We tested the hypothesis that patients with complete seizure relief after surgery would have a lower mortality rate than those who had persistent seizures. Three hundred ninety-three patients who had epilepsy surgery between January 1986 and January 1996 were followed after surgery to assess long-term survival; 347 had focal resection or transection, and 46 had anterior or complete corpus callosotomy. A multivariate survival analysis was performed, contrasting survival in those who had seizure recurrence with survival of those who remained seizure free. Standardized mortality ratios and 95% confidence intervals were calculated. Overall, seizure-free patients had a lower mortality rate than those with persistent seizures. This was true for the subset of patients with localized resection or multiple subpial transection. No patients died among 199 with no seizure recurrence, whereas of 194 patients with seizure recurrence, 11 died. Six of the deaths were sudden and unexplained. Most patients who died had a substantial reduction in postoperative seizure frequency. The standardized mortality ratio for patients with recurrent seizures was 4.69, and the risk of death in these patients was 1.37 in 100 person-years, whereas among patients who became seizure free, there was no difference in mortality rate compared with the age- and sex-matched population of the United States. Elimination of seizures after surgery reduces mortality rates in people with epilepsy to a level indistinguishable from that of the general population, whereas patients with recurrent seizures continue to suffer from high mortality rates. This suggests that uncontrolled seizures are a major risk factor for excess mortality in epilepsy. Achieving complete seizure control with epilepsy surgery in refractory patients reduces the risk of death, so the long-term risk of continuing medical treatment appears to be higher than the risk of epilepsy surgery in suitable candidates.