Surgical mortality in the elderly

Validation of risk assessment scoring systems for an audit of elective surgery for gastrointestinal cancer in elderly patients: an audit

The goal of this study was to validate the usefulness of risk assessment scoring systems for a surgical audit in elective digestive surgery for elderly patients. The validated scoring systems used were the Physiological and Operative Severity Score for enUmeration of Mortality and morbidity (POSSUM) and the Portsmouth predictor equation for mortality (P-POSSUM). This study involved 153 consecutive patients aged 75 years and older who underwent elective gastric or colorectal surgery between July 2004 and June 2006. A retrospective analysis was performed on data collected prior to each surgery. The predicted mortality and morbidity risks were calculated using each of the scoring systems and were used to obtain the observed/predicted (O/E) mortality and morbidity ratios. New logistic regression equations for morbidity and mortality were then calculated using the scores from the POSSUM system and applied retrospectively. The O/E ratio for morbidity obtained from POSSUM score was 0.23. The O/E ratios for mortality from the POSSUM score and the P-POSSUM were 0.15 and 0.38, respectively. Utilizing the new equations using scores from the POSSUM, the O/E ratio increased to 0.88. Both the POSSUM and P-POSSUM over-predicted the morbidity and mortality in elective gastrointestinal surgery for malignant tumors in elderly patients. However, if a surgical unit makes appropriate calculations using its own patient series and updates these equations, the POSSUM system can be useful in the risk assessment for surgery in elderly patients.

Experiences with microsurgical tissue transfers in elderly patients

The combination of advances in microsurgery and the improvement of anesthetic management with increased understanding of the physiology of preoperative and postoperative care has significantly raised the upper age limit for free-flap transfer in elderly patients. Despite pessimistic opinions regarding elderly patients who have poor recovery potential and decreased physiological reserves, the unique feature of free-tissue transfer is that it allows the transfer of well-vascularized tissue to defects in a single-stage procedure, and leads to improved quality of life. In this report, a retrospective analysis of 55 patients aged 50 and older who underwent microsurgical tissue transfer is presented. Hospital and our own records were used to review various parameters. The preoperative medical status of each patient was assessed using the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) Classification of Physical Status. Each patient's preoperative medical records, age, sex, transferred tissue type, and length of operation were outlined. Postoperative recorded parameters were the fate of flaps and the short-term postoperative outcome, including surgical complications, medical morbidity, and death within 30 days of surgery. Fifty-eight microvascular tissue transfers were performed in 55 consecutive patients. The study comprised 38 male and 17 female patients, with a mean age of 64.8 years. ASA classification status was class 1 for 15 patients, class 2 for 26 patients, and class 3 for 14 patients. Twenty-five flaps were used for lower extremity reconstruction, 32 flaps were used for head and neck reconstruction, and 1 was used for breast reconstruction. The average operative time was 5.7 h, ranging between 2-13 h. There were 14 major medical complications, resulting in an overall medical complication rate of 25%. There were 3 deaths within 30 days postoperatively. Thus, the overall surgical mortality rate was 5.4%. The longer operation times were associated with the development of postoperative total medical and surgical complications (P = 0.008). While the relationship between ASA class and medical complications was significant (P = 0.0007), no significant relation was determined between ASA class and surgical complications (P = 0.66). It was revealed that the greater the age group, the greater the occurrence of postoperative medical complications (P = 0.0001). The relationship between postoperative surgical complications and age groups was not significant (P = 0.07). It was also demonstrated that the advanced age of patients was associated with a higher ASA class (P = 0.0017). Eleven flaps required reoperation for vascular compromise. While 10 of these were salvaged with vascular anastomosis revisions, one flap was lost. Thus the overall flap success rate was 98.3%. In conclusion, if a patient's medical problems do not constitute a handicap, age itself should not be considered a barrier to free-flap transfer. It is important to be familiar with preoperative medical problems and possible postoperative medical complications in order to achieve a successful outcome. Contrary to what is generally suggested, surgical complications do not constitute a special consideration in older patients.

Predicting adverse postoperative outcomes in patients aged 80 years or older

OBJECTIVE

The identification of reversible factors that are associated with postoperative morbidity in geriatric surgical patients is critical to improving perioperative outcomes in such patients. Our study aimed to compare the relative importance of intraoperative versus preoperative factors in predicting adverse postoperative outcomes in geriatric patients.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study of consecutive patients undergoing noncardiac surgery in 1995.

SETTING

Two University of California, San Francisco, teaching hospitals--Moffitt/Long and Mount Zion medical centers.

PARTICIPANTS

All men and women 80 years of age or older undergoing noncardiac surgery.

MEASUREMENTS

Medical records of all patients were reviewed to measure predefined pre- and intraoperative risk factors and postoperative outcomes. Predictors of postoperative outcomes were identified by multivariate logistic regression analyses.

RESULTS

Three hundred sixty-seven patients were studied. The most prevalent preoperative risk factors were a history of hypertension and coronary artery, pulmonary, and neurologic diseases. Postoperative in-hospital mortality rate was 4.6%, and 25% of patients developed adverse postoperative outcomes, of which neurological and cardiovascular complications were the leading causes of morbidity (15% and 12%, respectively). By multivariate logistic regression, a history of neurological disease (odds ratio [OR] 4.0, 95% confidence interval [CI] 2.3 - 6.9, P = .0001), congestive heart failure (OR 2.7, 95% CI 1.4 - 5.3, P = .004), and a history of arrhythmia (OR 2.3, 95% CI 1.2 - 4.3, P = .01) increased the odds of adverse postoperative events. The only intraoperative event shown to be predictive of postoperative complications was the use of vasoactive agents (OR 8.0, 95% CI 1.6 - 40.5, P = .009).

CONCLUSIONS

In this group of geriatric surgical patients, the overall postoperative in-hospital mortality rate was 4.6%, and 25% of the patients developed adverse postoperative outcomes involving either the neurological, cardiovascular, or pulmonary systems. Intraoperative events appeared to be less important than preoperative comorbidities in predicting adverse postoperative outcomes.

Special problems in the elderly

With aging, the heart, kidneys, liver, lungs, and brain lose mass. While not inherently impaired, the reserve capacity of the older individual to compensate for stress, metabolic derangement, and drug metabolism is increasingly limited. Functional disability occurs faster and takes longer to remediate, necessitating early preventive interventions.

Assessment of cardiovascular risks and overall risks for noncardiac surgery

Appropriate care of the elderly patient requires a concerted multi-disciplinary approach before, during, and after surgery to optimize functional outcomes, with the principal focus placed on improving quality of life and strategies for risk reduction. Perioperative physicians must be able to assess the biologic, not the chronologic, age of geriatric patients and their capacity for independent function. Physicians need to understand alterations in the physiology of elderly patients attributable to the normal aging process as well as the prevalence of concurrent pathologic conditions that necessitate special precautions. Maintaining autonomy and function as a result of an acute surgical intervention may be the most important outcome to the elderly patient. Most of the data available and guidelines promulgated do not specifically address the elderly population. It is important to collect data prospectively and use sophisticated methods for analyses to develop better management algorithms for these (often complicated) clinical issues in the elderly.

Elective surgery for gastrointestinal tumours in the elderly

The geriatric population is expanding and clinical decision-making is often complicated by the effects of ageing. Age should not be the only parameter considered when addressing medical problems. Elderly subjects have been denied surgery because of their presumed higher mortality and morbidity. The present review summarises the physiology of the aged and discusses operative risks, mortality and morbidity rates as well as therapeutic results for the different gastrointestinal sites when affected by cancer. Reports on surgical treatments are revisited and compared to the same procedures delivered to younger patients in the context of the ethical issue of offering the best care to every patient. Elective operations by surgical oncologists are found to be safe with the exception of major liver resections. Complication rates and mean hospital stay do not differ between the two age groups provided the procedure is conducted with the best-known technique in expert hands. A drop in operative morbidity has occurred in the past three decades. Several investigators have emphasised the marked increase in morbidity and mortality experienced by elderly patients when undergoing emergency procedures. Associated diseases have to be properly assessed, as the elderly have a frail physiological balance with a reduced capacity for recovery from traumatic events including major surgical procedures. Careful preoperative evaluation, intraoperative conduct and postoperative care are presently achieved in almost every major hospital. Good clinical practice is based on the balance between probability of cure and toxic effects. Treatment of the elderly should no longer be based on untested beliefs and personal opinions. The elderly should be accrued for prospective clinical evaluation and should not be denied optimal surgical treatment.

Preoperative assessment of older adults

Caring for older patients who need surgery presents challenging medical situations. The clinical paradigm involves identifying coexisting disease, defining the urgency of the intervention, and predicting postoperative complications based on the type of surgery planned. The prime function of the medical consultant is searching for correctable medical conditions. The consultant must carefully identify coexisting and comorbid conditions. Emergency surgery should be avoided, if possible, by elective planning. The risk of surgery varies with the procedure. Non-body cavity surgery, with the exception of hip fracture repair, is usually tolerated well. Age is a risk factor for surgery, but coexisting disease is more important than age alone. The net effect of improvements in surgical outcome advances the age at which surgical risk becomes prohibitive.

Validity of major cancer operations in elderly patients

BACKGROUND

As the population ages, more elderly individuals will be at risk for the development of gastrointestinal malignancies traditionally treated with radical operation. In the past, many major cancer operations were reserved for patients < 65 or 70 years of age, but as the life expectancy for a 70-year-old has improved, this policy has been questioned.

METHODS

We examined the records of 124 consecutive patients who underwent one of three major operations (esophagogastrectomy, major liver resection, pancreatoduodenectomy) for gastrointestinal cancer during the past 6 years to determine if preoperative risk factors, operative mortality, length of stay, length of procedure, estimated blood loss, rate of major complication, or Kaplan-Meier survival was different for patients > or = 70 years of age as compared with younger patients.

RESULTS

For patients at our institution undergoing esophagogastrectomy, major liver resection, or pancreatoduodenectomy, we found no significant difference in any of the parameters measured. There was no significant difference in any parameter when comparing patients > or = 70 versus < 70 years of age.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that patients > or = 70 years of age are not necessarily less suitable candidates for major cancer operations than are those < 70 years of age if other risk factors are acceptable. Elderly patients should be included in clinical trials.

Major surgery in nursing home patients: procedures, morbidity, and mortality in the frailest of the frail elderly

OBJECTIVE

To determine the surgical procedures being done on long-term care (level 2) nursing home residents and the resultant in-hospital morbidity and mortality.

DESIGN

A retrospective chart review of inpatient medical records from two hospitals, identified by computerized search of medical records and/or referral by directors of nursing of area nursing homes.

SETTING

Patients originated in skilled-care nursing homes in New Castle County, Delaware, USA. Surgery was performed in the area's two major hospitals, one a 1000-bed regional referral and teaching hospital, and the other a 300-bed community hospital.

PATIENTS

Residents of skilled-care nursing homes (level 2) who underwent major surgery between January 1979 and December 1989.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Eighty procedures were performed in 74 patients. Many different types of procedures were done. After primary repair of hip fracture the most common procedures were non-orthopedic extremity and abdominal surgeries. Three deaths occurred (mortality 3.8%), and all were in patients undergoing emergency surgery who were classified above American Society of Anesthesiology Class 3. Serious complications occurred in 43% of the procedures and were most commonly cardiopulmonary and psychiatric, including profound depression in four. Antibiotic-associated colitis occurred in three patients and required a second surgical procedure in one. Fewer adverse outcomes were seen in patients undergoing elective surgical procedures with spinal or local anesthesia than in patients receiving general anesthesia.

CONCLUSIONS

Although retrospective and limited to inpatient data, in-hospital surgical mortality in this very frail population was low, comparable to series in unselected geriatric populations. However, major complications were very common. Primary hip surgery repair may have been too frequently done. A multi-institution, prospective trial would be useful to assess functional outcome of surgery in this population.

Preoperative considerations in the geriatric patient

Because of the "graying" of the population, the increasing availability of surgeons, and the improvement of surgical techniques and intensive care, more and more surgery will be done on geriatric patients. Sometimes, however, surgery will not be considered in a geriatric patient because of mistaken underestimation of life expectancy. The medical consultant is charged with confirming that surgery represents the consequence of the patient's informed decision, a task that is usually time consuming and often difficult. The medical consultant next identifies patient-related and procedure-related factors that affect surgical morbidity and mortality. General physiologic declines in all organ systems are characteristic of aging, but the most important ones affecting surgical risk are those of cardiovascular, pulmonary, immunologic, and central nervous systems. These systems must be assessed by an orderly preoperative evaluation that aims to optimize the patient's status and anticipate and minimize postoperative complication.

Influence of age on mortality of colon surgery

The geriatric population continues to grow and surgical decision making is often confused by the effect of aging. This study is part of an ongoing effort to determine surgical risk in the elderly population and to identify the significant factors affecting outcomes which could be used to plan surgical procedures. Records of 163 patients over 70 years of age with elective or emergency surgery (133 patients and 30 patients, respectively) were reviewed. There were 17 deaths. All deaths in a cohort of patients under 70 were examined as well. Ninety-five variables were explored to seek differences between groups. The patients who died, independent of age, were similar. Patients over 70 years of age who died differed from the survivors in many ways, both physiologically and in terms of disease state. Survivors were younger; did not have congestive heart failure; had better hepatic, renal, and pulmonary function; less extensive involvement if malignant disease was present; and fewer postoperative complications. If these factors were removed and only apparently normal physiologic characteristics considered, there were no differences in mortality between the patients over 70 years of age and younger patients. Age was less of a factor than physiologic status.

The medical evaluation and management of the elderly surgical patient

Contrary to earlier findings, elderly patients are not at significantly greater risk of perioperative morbidity or mortality than younger patients simply because of advanced age. Increased risk, when present, is attributable to pathologic changes that are not uniformly seen in all geriatric patients. Most perioperative morbidity is caused by cardiovascular and pulmonary complications. The author discusses an appropriate preoperative evaluation and recommends selective ancillary tests to screen for high-risk patients.

Head and neck surgery in the aged

This study was carried out to determine the perioperative mortality rate of patients over the age of 65 years who are undergoing major head and neck resections under general anesthesia. The total number of patients was 810 and the perioperative mortality rate (death within 30 days of operation) was 3.5 percent (29 of 810). This rate is relatively low when compared with the rate for patients undergoing similar procedures during the same period in the 35 to 65 years age group. Since 1975 reports of other types of surgery in the elderly have given perioperative mortality rates of from 4.8 to 26 percent. Previous studies of head and neck surgery in the elderly have given perioperative mortality rates of from 1.3 to 13.6 percent. Head and neck surgery in the elderly continues to be a safe procedure when compared with other types of surgery. As the portion of patients in the population over the age of 65 continues to increase, advanced age alone should not be a deterrent to performing aggressive surgical therapy for head and neck cancer.

Optimism in the management of hip fracture in elderly patients

The present generation of those past age 70 grew up with the idea that a fractured hip meant "the beginning of the end" for the elderly. The results reported here on the treatment of 50 consecutive patients over 70 years of age who had sustained a fractured hip indicate that in this situation the orthopedic surgeon can be an important partner in geriatric medicine. He can improve the functioning and health of this special group of elderly trauma victims through reassuring them that the fracture usually can be successfully treated without undue risk to life. The present improved state of the art of anesthesiology, surgery, and pre- and postoperative medical care makes the surgical risk tolerable, and helps to prevent many of the complications that used to occur in elderly patients confined to bed for long periods following hip fracture.

Analysis of geriatric surgical experience in a veterans home

Surgical experience at the hospital of a State Veterans Home is reviewed over a period of two and half years (1973-1975). The average age of the patients was 74 years, and many had severe pulmonary or cardiac disease. Of the operations performed, 283 were major and 301 were minor. For the major operations (including emergencies) the mortality rate was 4.2 percent, for the minor procedures the rate was zero, and for all types of procedures the overall mortality rate was 2 percent. Emergency operations increased the expected mortality tenfold. Colonic and biliary-tract operations bore the highest mortality. The incidence of malignant lesions was high. In the elderly, indicated surgical procedures are justified, provided they are carried out by an organized, highly trained health team.