Transvitreal retino-choroidal biopsy of suspected malignant lesions of the choroid. Follow-up of cases over 7 years

Instrument Gauge and Type in Uveal Melanoma Fine Needle Biopsy: Implications for Diagnostic Yield and Molecular Prognostication

PURPOSE

To systematically evaluate and compare the effects of using small-gauge needles and vitrectors on the ability to obtain adequate diagnostic and prognostic uveal melanoma biopsy specimens.

DESIGN

Comparative evaluation of biopsy instruments.

METHODS

Survival of uveal melanoma cells was evaluated in vitro following needle aspiration. Five therapeutically enucleated eyes were sampled in triplicate for ex vivo diagnostic biopsy experiments with 25 gauge (25 G) needle, 27 gauge (27 G) needle, and 27 G vitrector. During surgery in 8 patients, paired diagnostic transscleral fine needle aspiration biopsies were performed using both 25 G and 27 G needles. A review of cytologic specimens was performed by a panel of 3 expert cytopathologists. A retrospective chart review was performed to evaluate 100 consecutive tumors undergoing prognostic biopsy for gene expression profiling to assess the relationship between needle gauge and prognostic adequacy.

RESULTS

No significant cell shearing of uveal melanoma cells occurred in vitro with 25 G, 27 G, or 30 G needles. For ex vivo biopsy samples, diagnostic yield was 100% using 25 G needle (5/5) or 27 G vitrector (5/5) but 60% using a 27 G needle (3/5). For in vivo samples, no difference in diagnostic yield was found between 25 G (75%, 6/8) or 27 G (75%, 6/8) needle sizes. Of 100 molecular prognostic biopsy samples evaluated, 65 were obtained using 27 G needles; for these biopsies, the prognostic yield was 65/65 (100%).

CONCLUSIONS

For diagnostic biopsy of uveal melanoma, a larger-gauge needle or a 27 G vitrector may have better overall cellularity and diagnostic yield when compared to a 27 G needle. However, for much more common molecular prognostic testing, a 27 G needle provided adequate sample in 100% (65/65) of cases, and a larger needle provided no additional benefit.

Long-Term Metastatic Risk after Biopsy of Posterior Uveal Melanoma

PURPOSE

Biopsy of posterior uveal melanoma continues to be intensely debated in terms of the clinical benefits and safety profile. Although several studies have reported a low frequency of ocular complications after tumor biopsy, the potential long-term risk of iatrogenic dissemination remains unresolved. The purpose of this study was to assess the risk of metastatic disease after biopsy of posterior uveal melanoma.

DESIGN

Retrospective nationwide cohort study linking clinical and histopathologic records to pathology, cancer, and mortality registries.

PARTICIPANTS

All patients with posterior uveal melanoma treated in Denmark between January 1985 and December 2016.

METHODS

For each patient, we recorded detailed information on age, gender, tumor characteristics, and diagnostic and therapeutic measures, including tumor biopsy, if any, and the primary treating hospital. Absolute risk of melanoma-specific death was presented by cumulative incidence curves that accounted for competing risks. Cox regression models were used to estimate crude and adjusted hazard ratios (HRs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for all-cause and melanoma-specific mortality of patients who underwent biopsy during primary treatment compared with nonbiopsied patients through November 1, 2017. Fine and Gray risk regression was used as a sensitivity analysis to evaluate the impact of competing risks.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

All-cause and melanoma-specific mortality.

RESULTS

Among 1637 patients, 567 (35%) underwent biopsy during primary treatment. At diagnosis, biopsied patients exhibited better prognostic characteristics, including smaller tumor size (P < 0.001) and younger age (P < 0.001), than nonbiopsied patients. In the adjusted analyses, we observed no apparent differences in all-cause mortality (HR, 1.07; 95% CI, 0.89-1.26; P = 0.47) or melanoma-specific mortality (HR, 1.11; 95% CI, 0.89-1.39; P = 0.35) among biopsied patients compared with nonbiopsied patients.

CONCLUSIONS

All-cause and melanoma-specific mortality after primary treatment were similar among biopsied and nonbiopsied patients with posterior uveal melanoma. Our findings do not support an increased metastatic risk after intraocular tumor biopsy.

The Role of Chorioretinal Biopsy in the Diagnosis of Intraocular Lymphoma

PURPOSE

To assess the clinical usefulness of chorioretinal biopsy in establishing a definitive diagnosis in intraocular lymphomas.

DESIGN

Retrospective, noncomparative, consecutive diagnostic case series.

METHODS

setting: Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, United Kingdom.

PATIENTS

Twenty-nine consecutive patients presenting with severe uveitis that required an intraocular biopsy where underlying lymphoma was suspected.

OBSERVATION PROCEDURE

A retrospective review of a 15-year period (1999-2014) was undertaken of all patients that have undergone chorioretinal biopsy for suspected lymphoma at Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, United Kingdom. Patients were identified on the hospital's computerized database.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Effectiveness of chorioretinal biopsy in establishing a definitive diagnosis or in excluding malignancy.

RESULTS

A specific histologic diagnosis was made in 17 cases (59%) while in 9 cases the biopsy combined with clinical data was effective in excluding malignancy. In the 3 remaining cases, no specific diagnosis was made. No intraoperative complications were reported. Postoperative complications other than cataract included 2 vitreous hemorrhages and 2 retinal detachments. Of the 17 cases with a histologic diagnosis, 15 were obtained in eyes with marked vitritis, as opposed to 2 with minimal vitritis.

CONCLUSIONS

Chorioretinal biopsy provided a definitive diagnosis of lymphoma in 59% of cases and assisted in exclusion of a further 31% in this series. The level of vitritis appears to act as a strong index of likelihood in achieving a definitive histologic diagnosis.

[Value of transretinal tumor biopsy as diagnostic and predictive instrument]

Transretinal biopsy of intraocular tumors plays a decisive role as a diagnostic tool in ocular oncology. A biopsy is indicated to confirm a clinical diagnosis before treatment and allows identification of high risk melanomas of the uvea with a high potential of metastasis by molecular genetic evaluation of the specimen. This review will focus on the various biopsy techniques and indications for this method.

Fine-needle aspiration biopsy and other biopsies in suspected intraocular malignant disease: a review

Ocular oncologists require a strong indication for intraocular biopsy before the procedure can be performed because it carries a risk for serious eye complications and the dissemination of malignant cells. The purpose of this review is to evaluate the extent to which this restricted practice is supported by evidence from previous reports and to outline our main indications and contraindications. The different intraocular biopsy techniques in the anterior and posterior segment are discussed with a focus on our preferred method, fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB). In the literature, complications are typically under-reported, which reduces the possibilities of evaluating the risks correctly and of making fair comparisons with other biopsy methods. In FNAB, the exact placement of the needle is critical, as is an accurate assessment of the size of the lesion. Fine-needle aspiration biopsy is usually not a reliable diagnostic tool in lesions < 2 mm in thickness. It is very advantageous to have a cytopathologist present in the operating theatre or close by. This ensures adequate sampling and encourages repeated biopsy attempts if necessary. This approach reduces false negative results to < 3%. Adjunct immunocytochemistry is documented to increase specificity and is essential for diagnosis and management in about 10% of cases. In some rare pathological processes the diagnosis depends ultimately on the identification of specific cell markers. An accurate diagnosis may have a decisive influence on prognosis. The cytogenetic prognostications made possible after FNAB are reliable. Biopsy by FNA has a low complication rate. The calculated risk for retinal detachment is < 4%. Intraocular haemorrhage is frequently observed, but clears spontaneously in nearly all cases. Only a single case of epibulbar seeding of malignant cells at the scleral pars plana puncture site of transvitreal FNAB has been documented. Endophthalmitis has been reported and adequate standard preoperative preparation is obligatory. An open biopsy is still an option in the anterior segment, but has been abandoned in the posterior segment. Although vitrectomy-based procedures are becoming increasingly popular, we recommend using FNAB as part of a stepwise approach. A vitrectomy-assisted biopsy should be considered in cases where FNAB fails. In any adult patient with suspected intraocular malignancy in which enucleation is not the obvious treatment, the clinician should strive for a diagnosis based on biopsy. When the lesion is too small for biopsy or the risks related to the procedure are too great, it is reasonable to be reluctant to biopsy. The standards applied in the treatment of intraocular malignant diseases should be equivalent to those in other fields of oncology. Our view is controversial and contrary to opinion that supports current standards of care for this group of patients.

Fluorescent in situ hybridization for monosomy 3 via 30-gauge fine-needle aspiration biopsy of choroidal melanoma in vivo

OBJECTIVE

To report the feasibility of intraoperative transscleral fine-needle aspiration biopsy at plaque surgery to obtain cells for monosomy 3 analysis in patients with choroidal melanoma.

DESIGN

Consecutive interventional case series.

PARTICIPANTS

Eighteen patients (18 eyes) with choroidal melanoma who had fine-needle aspiration biopsy performed with a 30-gauge needle at time of iodine 125 plaque placement.

INTERVENTION

Cytology and cytogenetic analysis for monosomy 3 were obtained from biopsy specimens.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Cytology, cytogenetic analysis for monosomy 3, and complications and feasibility of transscleral fine-needle aspiration biopsy of choroidal melanoma in vivo.

RESULTS

Fine-needle aspiration biopsy was diagnostic of choroidal melanoma in 14 of 18 cases and resulted in viable cell cultures for fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis in 9 cases. Fluorescent in situ hybridization for monosomy 3 was positive in 4 of the 9 cases. One patient had a mild vitreous hemorrhage. Tumors between 2 and 3 mm in height and those that yielded cells that did not attach in culture were most likely to have insufficient growth for FISH analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

Transscleral fine-needle aspiration biopsy and FISH for monosomy 3 may provide important prognostic information on patients who undergo plaque radiotherapy for choroidal melanoma.

Clinicopathologic findings in choroidal melanomas after failed transpupillary thermotherapy

PURPOSE

To review the clinicopathologic features of eyes enucleated after failed transpupillary thermotherapy.

DESIGN

Retrospective review.

METHODS

Pathology reports in the L.F. Montgomery Laboratory between 1998 and 2002 were searched for enucleated eyes with choroidal melanoma that had been treated only by transpupillary thermotherapy (TTT) prior to enucleation. The clinical features of the patients, including ultrasonography examination, were reviewed and compared with the pathologic findings.

RESULTS

Seven eyes from seven patients had been enucleated, representing 8% of eyes treated with TTT at our institute during the period studied. The primary indication for enucleation was tumor growth. The melanomas tended to grow laterally, with minimal if any increase in thickness. Five of the seven eyes histologically demonstrated extrascleral extension, which was detected by ultrasonography prior to enucleation in only one of those eyes.

CONCLUSIONS

Choroidal melanoma may continue to grow along a path of least resistance after TTT. The melanoma may extend laterally in the choroid and through emissary canals. Early extrascleral extension may be difficult to detect by ultrasonography.