Cross-cultural comparison of depression and depressive symptoms in older people

[Depressive symptoms in elderly women. The influence of gender]

OBJECTIVE

To examine gender differences in depressive symptoms in people over 75 years of age in the community.

METHODS

This is a descriptive cross-sectional study. The data was obtained from the study of frailty in Lleida (FRALLE survey). Depressive symptoms were measured using the Centre for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D). Logistic regression were used to analyse the relationship of gender with depressive symptoms.

RESULTS

The prevalence of depressive symptoms was 33.1%; 22.8% for men and 40.3% for women. In the total population, gender was statistically significant in all three models constructed. Thus, women have nearly double the prevalence rates for depression compared to men, even after adjusting for social and demographic factors and the health status.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that women have a higher risk of depressive symptoms than men, and the protective factors of depressive symptoms are higher education in women, and the presence of a partner in men.

Cancers: Progress and Challenges in the Elderly

Cancer is a growing concern in the long-term care facility. The most common cancers long-term staff are apt to encounter include breast, lung, bladder, prostate, brain, and colorectal. Each cancer subtype and its treatment options are reviewed; they will vary with patients' level of functioning and tolerability. Since treatment guidelines were developed for younger cohorts, issues and side effects unique to elders require an ongoing alliance with oncology specialists. Screening guidelines and end-of-life issues are discussed.

Sexual activity, sexual dysfunction and associated help-seeking behaviours in middle-aged and older adults in Spain: a population survey

To study sexual activity, the prevalence of sexual dysfunction and related help-seeking behaviours among mature adults in Spain, a telephone survey was conducted in Spain in 2001-2002. This was completed by 750 men and 750 women aged 40-80 years. Eighty-eight percent of men and 66% of women had engaged in sexual intercourse during the 12 months preceding the interview. Early ejaculation (31%) and lack of sexual interest (17%) were the most common male sexual problems. A lack of sexual interest (36%) and an inability to reach orgasm (28%) were the most common female sexual problems. Approximately 80% of men and women with a sexual problem had not sought help from a health professional. Many men and women in Spain report continued sexual interest and activity into middle age and beyond. Although a number of sexual problems are highly prevalent, few people seek medical help.

Psychiatric issues in older cancer patients

Although many patients are surviving longer than in the past, a cancer diagnosis may shatter the dream of a dignified old age for elderly patients. Cancer diagnosis and treatment often produce psychologic stresses resulting from the actual symptoms of the disease, as well as perceptions of the disease and its stigma. Concerns related to cancer have particular meaning for aging individuals who undergo these situations in the context of retirement, widowhood, other medical disabilities and other losses. Today, patients and families are more interested in treatment issues, and quality of life, both during and after treatment. In this article we discuss late life depression, anxiety and delirium as they relate to elderly patients coping with cancer.

Late-life depression: its oral health significance

Late-life depression (LLD) initially occurs after age 65 and is a major public health concern because elderly people who are at high risk constitute an ever-expanding segment of the population. LLD is a mental illness in which mood, thought content, and behavioural patterns are impaired, causing individual distress, compromising social function and impairing self-maintenance skills (e.g. bathing, dressing, hygiene). It is characterised by marked sadness, or a loss of interest or pleasure in daily activities and may be accompanied by weight change, sleep disturbance, fatigue, difficulty concentrating, and high suicide rate. Individuals under treatment for LLD and those whose illness has not been diagnosed or treated often present to the dentist with significant oral disease. LLD is frequently associated with a disinterest in performing oral hygiene, a cariogenic diet, diminished salivary flow, rampant dental decay, advanced periodontal disease, and oral dysesthesias. Many medications used to treat the disease magnify the xerostomia and increase the incidence of dental disease. Appropriate dental management necessitates a vigorous preventive dental education programme, the use of artificial salivary products, antiseptic mouthwash, daily fluoride mouthrinse and special precautions when administering local anaesthetics with vasoconstrictors and prescribing analgesics.

Validation of the Spanish version of the geriatric depression scale (GDS) in primary care

OBJECTIVE

To estimate the predictive value of the 30-question Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS) in Spanish and calculate the most adequate cut-point for its use in Primary Health Care consultations.

METHOD

218 patients over the age of 64 treated at three health centers of Area 10 in Madrid were selected. In the first phase, the subjects completed the GDS, the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) and a questionnaire on health and socio-demographic variables. They were later interviewed using the Geriatric Mental Schedule (GMS), used as the gold standard by doctors who were unaware of the results of the GDS. Two categories were contemplated according to the results of the GMS: cases of depression (diagnosis of psychotic or neurotic depression) and non-psychiatric cases (no psychiatric diagnosis, although isolated symptoms could be present).

RESULTS

192 aged subjects were interviewed using the GDS and the GMS. Of these, 103 were considered "non-cases of depression" and 60 others made up the "cases of psychotic/neurotic depression" group. For the most effective cut-point (9/10), sensitivity was 86.7% and specificity 63.1%. Considering a prevalence of depression of 30%, the predictive value for positives was 50.2% and for negatives 91.7%. The Cronbach alpha coefficient was 0.82, and the area below the ROC curve obtained was 0.85. Those patients with cognitive deterioration had a mean GDS score similar to those that did not present deterioration (11.16 vs 10.52; p > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The Geriatric Depression Scale is valid as a screening test in Primary Care consultations due to its high sensitivity and negative predictive value. The most effective Spanish GDS cut-point (9/10) is lower than that obtained in the original English version (10/11).

Gender differences of depressive symptoms in depressed and nondepressed elderly persons

OBJECTIVES

Women suffer more frequently from major depression and depressive symptoms than men. The somatic and the atypical subtype of depression seem to be more prevalent in women. However, few studies investigated gender differences of depressive symptoms in the elderly. These gender differences in the elderly will be investigated in the present study.

METHODS

In the course of a family study 236 subjects with a lifetime diagnosis of major depression aged > 50 years and 357 control subjects from the general population matched for age and gender were questioned using the Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI). Chi-square tests were used to compare the individual depressive symptoms between men and women and logistic regression analyses were performed to account for the subjects' age, cognitive performance, family and employment status.

RESULTS

Women in the general population suffered from more depressive symptoms than men and had more appetite disturbance and joylessness. These gender differences could be entirely explained by gender differences in the family and the employment status. Men and women with a major depressive disorder presented with a distinct profile of symptoms that could not be explained by psychosocial factors: elderly depressed women presented with more appetite disturbances and elderly depressed men with more agitation.

CONCLUSION

Major depression in the elderly presents with partially different symptoms in men and women. The results suggest that the gender differences in the symptoms of major depression in the elderly reflect gender differences in the perception and the expression of depressive syndromes.

Mortality and mental disorders in a Spanish elderly population

OBJECTIVE

To analyse the relationship between mental disorders and mortality rates in the elderly community of Zaragoza, Spain.

METHODS

Baseline, cross-sectional study (two-stage screening) of a representative, stratified sample (N=1080) of the elderly (65+ years) living in the community. Follow-up study (4.5 years).

INSTRUMENTS

Spanish versions of Geriatric Mental State, AGECAT computerized diagnostic program and Mini-Mental Status Examination.

RESULTS

Two hundred and sixteen subjects died during the follow-up period (global mortality rate 4.8% per year). Using a logistic regression model with sex, age, educational level, physical illness and AGECAT diagnoses as explanatory variables and alive/dead as response, the following odds ratios (95% confidence intervals in parentheses) were obtained (reference group: non-cases): 'subcases' 1.3 (0.9-2.0), 'organic' (dementia) 3.7 (2.0-6.7), global depression 3.0 (1.7-5.3), 'psychotic' depression (melancholic type) 3.7 (1.7-8. 4), 'neurotic' depression 2.7 (1.4-5.3) and 'neuroses' 0.8 (0.2-3.6). Both pure 'organic' and pure 'depressed' cases had higher mortality when compared with comorbidity cases.

CONCLUSION

There is a significant association between psychiatric morbidity and mortality in the elderly living in a Spanish community. Mortality risk in psychiatric cases are higher than previously reported in the literature.

Religious climate and geographical distribution of depressive symptoms in older Dutch citizens

This study examines whether the degree of conservatism of the religious climate affects the geographical distribution of late life depressive symptoms. A U-shaped relationship is hypothesized: high levels of depressive symptoms at the extremes (both a-religious and hyperconservative), and a low level in the middle (moderate-conservative). Subjects are 3051 older Dutch citizens (55-85 years), living in 11 municipalities. Depressive symptoms are assessed using the CES-D. Religious climate is estimated on the municipality level, using percentages votes on political parties with a Christian background (moderate-conservative versus hyperconservative). Using multi-level analysis, the results support the U-curve hypothesis.

Prevalence and correlates of Capgras syndrome in Alzheimer's disease

OBJECTIVES

This study examined the prevalence and clinical correlates of Capgras syndrome (CS) in Alzheimer's disease.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study of elderly patients evaluated at an outpatient memory disorders clinic classified according to the presence or absence of CS.

SUBJECTS

One hundred and fifty-one consecutive patients diagnosed with probable (N=110) or possible (N=48) Alzheimer's disease (AD) utilizing NINCDS-ADRDA diagnostic criteria.

MATERIALS

The Behavioral Pathology in Alzheimer's Disease Rating Scale (BEHAVE-AD), Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) and Blessed Dementia Scale (BDS).

RESULTS

CS was observed in 10% of the sample (N=16). Associated factors included other delusions, lower MMSE scores and higher BDS scores. The relation between CS and both cognitive and functional status remained significant after controlling for other delusions.

CONCLUSION

CS was prevalent in approximately 10% of our community-dwelling AD sample. This syndrome was more common at the later stages of the illness and showed relations with increased functional impairment and other psychotic symptomatology.

Depression of older age. Origins of the study

BACKGROUND

The EURODEP collaboration was formed to take advantage of existing studies of random community samples of older people in Europe, using GMS-AGECAT for case identification and diagnosis. Later, other centres joined, and the EURO-D scale was developed to harmonise the different methods used with the GMS. Previous studies had revealed different levels of depression in Europe but had been confounded by the use of unreconcilable methods. These studies attempt to overcome this problem.

AIMS

To introduce the first set of publications from the EURODEP collaboration.

METHOD, RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Presented in five accompanying papers (pp. 307-345, this issue).

Cross-cultural comparison of depressive symptoms in Europe does not support stereotypes of ageing

BACKGROUND

Stereotypes of older people suggest that they are depressed.

AIMS

To examine depression symptoms among people aged > or = 65 in the general population and to ask the following questions. Are there high proportions of depressive symptoms among otherwise well people? Do these levels reflect the prevalence of depression? Do key symptoms vary with age and do they confirm stereotypes?

METHOD

Nine centres contributed data from community-based random samples, using standardised methods (GMS-AGECAT package).

RESULTS

Proportions of depressive symptoms varied between centres. Some often associated with ageing were rare. Many were more common in women. Low-prevalence centres tended to have fewer symptoms among 'well' people, but there were inconsistencies. Low levels of symptoms among the well population of a centre did not necessarily predict lower levels in the depressed.

CONCLUSIONS

Variations in the prevalence of depressive symptoms occurred between centres, not always related to levels of illness. There was no consistent relationship between proportions of symptoms in well persons and cases for all centres. Few symptoms were present in > 60% of the older population--stereotypes of old age were not upheld.

Depression in Europe. Geographical distribution among older people

BACKGROUND

This is the first report of results from the EURODEP Programme.

AIMS

To assess the prevalence of depression judged suitable for intervention in randomised samples of those aged > or = 65 in nine European centres.

METHOD

The GMS-AGECAT package.

RESULTS

Differences in prevalence are apparent, 8.8% (Iceland) to 236% (Munich). When sub-cases and cases are added together, five high- and four low-scoring centres emerge. Women predominated over men. Proportions of sub-cases to cases revealed striking differences but did not explain prevalence. There was no constant association between prevalence and age. A meta-analysis (n = 13,808) gave an overall prevalence of 12.3%, 14.1% for women and 8.6% for men.

CONCLUSIONS

Considerable variation occurs in the levels of depression across Europe, the cause for which is not immediately obvious. Case and sub-case levels taken together show greater variability, suggesting that it is not a matter of case/sub-case selection criteria, which were standardised by computer. Substantial levels of depression are shown but 62-82% of persons had no depressive level. Opportunities for treatment exist.

The behavioral pathology in Alzheimer's Disease Scale (BEHAVE-AD): factor structure among community-dwelling Alzheimer's disease patients

OBJECTIVE

The aims of this study were to (a) determine the factor structure of the Behavioral Pathology in Alzheimer's Disease Scale (BEHAVE-AD), and (b) examine the associations of the observed factors to the level of cognitive impairment.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study of geriatric patients evaluated at an outpatient memory disorders clinic.

SAMPLE

One hundred and fifty-one consecutive patients diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease (AD) according to NINCDS-ADRDA diagnostic criteria.

RESULTS

Principal factors analysis with Varimax rotation resulted in a five-factor solution that accounted for 40.0% of the common variance. The factors included agitation/anxiety (agitation, anxiety of upcoming events; other anxiety), psychosis (delusions of theft, suspiciousness/paranoia; visual hallucinations), aggression (verbal aggressiveness; physical threats/violence; fear of being left alone; other delusions), depression (tearfulness; depressed mood) and activity disturbance (wandering; delusion one's house is not one's home). Several factors were associated with level of cognitive impairment as assessed by the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE).

CONCLUSION

The results of this study suggest that the BEHAVE-AD measures a wide range of behavioral pathology that can be empirically represented by five independent symptom clusters among outpatient AD patients.

Increased incidence of depressive symptoms in men with erectile dysfunction

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the hypothesis that men with erectile dysfunction (ED) have a higher incidence of depressive symptoms compared with age-matched control subjects. We also hypothesized that depressive symptoms impact on the level of libido and on the success of treatment of ED.

METHODS

One hundred twenty men with ED or benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) were divided into three groups. Group 1 had ED only, group 2 had BPH only, and group 3 had both ED and BPH. Patients were screened for depressive symptoms using the Primary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders and the Beck Depression Inventory. They were also surveyed for comorbidity, marital status, severity of ED, level of libido, prior ED treatment choice (if any), success of treatment, and others.

RESULTS

One hundred patients completed the questionnaires. Depressive symptoms were reported by 26 (54%) of 48 men with ED alone, 10 (56%) of 18 men with ED and BPH, and 7 (21 %) of 34 men with BPH alone. Patients with ED were 2.6 times more likely to report depressive symptoms than men with BPH alone (P < 0.005). Patients with depressive symptoms reported lower libido than other patients (P < 0.0001). Severity of comorbidities did not differ among the three groups. A total of 33 patients with ED had prior treatment for ED using penile injections or vacuum devices. All 15 (100%) patients with ED only continued treatment and were satisfied with its outcome, whereas only 7 (38.9%) of 18 patients with ED and depressive symptoms continued treatment (P < 0.00021).

CONCLUSIONS

ED is associated with high incidence of depressive symptoms, regardless of age, marital status, or comorbidities. Patients with ED have a decreased libido compared with control subjects. In addition, patients with depressive symptoms have a lower libido than patients without depressive symptoms. Patients with ED and depressive symptoms are more likely to discontinue treatment for ED than other patients with ED. These data emphasize the importance of a multidisciplinary approach to the treatment of erectile dysfunction.

Prevalence of depression in an aged population in Finland

The prevalence of depression by sex, age and certain sociodemographic variables was investigated among elderly Finns (65 years or over) living in the semi-industrialized town of Ahtäri (n = 1225). The prevalence of depression, determined using the DSM-III criteria, was 16.5% for the total population, 14.4% for the men and 17.9% for the women. Dysthymic disorder was the commonest category of depression in both sexes, with atypical depression the second most common category among the men and major depression among the women. A few cases of cyclothymic disorder were diagnosed in each sex, but no cases of bipolar depression. The occurrence of depression was not associated with sex, but it was related to older age, widowhood and lower educational level in the men, although not in the women. In both sexes, a high risk of depression was associated with being in long-term institutional care and receiving home nursing and/or a home help. The occurrence of depression was not related to earlier occupation.

The prevalence of depression in elderly medical inpatients

To estimate the point-prevalence of major depression in elderly medical inpatients according to a computerized diagnostic system, a two-phase design was carried out. A consecutive series of 198 elderly medical inpatients completed two self-rating scales for depression (Beck Depression Inventory, Geriatric Depression Scale) and the Mini-Mental State Examination. According to these screening instruments, 69 'probable cases' were identified and were referred for psychiatric evaluation using the Geriatric Mental State Schedule. Only 10 patients were identified as diagnostic cases of depression according to the GMS-AGECAT package. The estimated prevalence rate for depression according to AGECAT in this population was 5.9% (95% confidence limits 2.3-9.3%). This is lower than has been found in previous studies in elderly medical inpatients. Possible reasons for this finding are discussed.

Depression in old age. Is there a real decrease in prevalence? A review

The discrepancy between the constancy or increase of the prevalence of depressive symptoms and dysphoria in old age on one hand, and the decrease in the prevalence of the DSM-III diagnoses of major depression and dysthymia on the other, is discussed in light of the most frequent explanatory hypotheses such as memory defects, interpretation of depressive as somatic symptoms, higher risk of institutionalization as well as higher mortality of depressives and a mitigated course of depression in old age. We conclude that higher mortality, mitigation and the rarity of true late-onset depression are arguments for a real decline in prevalence, which occurs in accordance with the decline in all psychiatric disorders that are connected with emotional upheavals and substance ingestion. On the other hand, the connection of depressive states with somatic illness is strengthened, and according to preliminary validation studies, clinically relevant depressive states not reaching the threshold of DSM-III diagnoses may be typical for the depressive psychopathology of old age.

Cross-national comparison of prevalence of symptoms of neurotic disorders in older people in two community samples

The objective of this research was to compare the prevalence of symptoms characteristic of neurotic disorders in two different cultural settings. The design was two random community samples in Liverpool (United Kingdom) and Zaragoza (Spain), of 1070 and 1080 people aged 65 and over. The main outcome measures were the rating of symptoms on the Geriatric Mental State and syndrome levels using the Automated Geriatric Examination for Computer Assisted Taxonomy. The results showed substantial differences between the two cities in the symptomatic pattern of phobias, but both the symptomatic and syndrome presentation of obsessional, hypochrondriacal and anxiety disorders were much more similar.