Lymphocytes from chronically inflamed human gingiva. I. Cell recovery and characterization in vitro

Allan William Cripps: a mucosal immunologist and mentor from beginning to end

Allan Cripps was internationally recognized in the field of mucosal immunology, in particular the relationship between respiratory diseases and mucosal immunization strategies. Allan's career spanned scientific and applied research, commercialization, health education, and evolved into leadership roles in public-health and academic administration. Allan published over 400 papers and mentored over 40 research higher degree candidates. Allan was renowned for his mentorship, that did not end with the awarding of a PhD or Master's degree, but continued across a lifetime of professional engagement. Allan's key contributions to immunology included characterizing the ontogeny of the human mucosal immune system, understanding the impact of respiratory infections and otitis media in children, developing diagnostic technologies and mucosal vaccine strategies, and identifying the roles of the common mucosal immune system in human health. In this biography for the 100th anniversary of the Journal, we follow his journey of discovery and contributions to immunological research.

Generation of gingival T cell lines/clones specific with Porphyromonas gingivalis pulsed dendritic cells from periodontitis patients

OBJECTIVES AND BACKGROUND

It is well documented that in periodontitis lesions, most infiltrated gingival T cells are antigen-specific memory T cells. These cells play an important role as regulators and effector cells in the pathogenesis of periodontitis. In this study, we used dendritic cells (DCs) as antigen-presenting cells to generate human gingival T cell lines and clones specific for Porphyromonas gingivalis from periodontitis patients.

METHODS

Autologous DCs were derived from the patients' adherent monocytes using granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor and interleukin (IL)-4. Lymphocytes were isolated from gingival biopsies using collagenase enzyme digestion and the number was increased by subsequent culturing in IL-2-containing medium. T cells were then negatively sorted using flow cytometry, cocultured with P. gingivalis-pulsed DCs and subsequently expanded in the culture medium containing IL-2. T cells were kept viable and active by periodic exposure to antigen-pulsed DCs. The specificity of the T cell lines was tested against four plaque bacteria: P. gingivalis, Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans, Prevotella intermedia and Actinomyces viscosus. The established T cell lines were then cloned. Three P. gingivalis-specific T cell lines and 12 gingival T cell clones were generated. They all showed good specificity against P. gingivalis but not to other plaque bacteria.

RESULTS

All T cell clones were positive for CD4 and the majority of them produced interferon gamma, but a minimal or negligible amount of IL-5.

CONCLUSIONS

The data obtained clearly showed that monocyte-derived DCs could be used as powerful antigen-presenting cells to generate antigen-specific T cells from periodontitis tissues.

Upregulation of co-stimulatory molecule expression and dendritic cell marker (CD83) on B cells in periodontal disease

T cells and their cytokines are well known for their important role in the pathogenesis of periodontitis. To date, the role of antigen presenting cells (APCs), which are known to be critical in the regulation of T cell response, has been poorly investigated in periodontitis. In this study, we analyzed the expression of co-stimulatory molecules (CD80 and CD86) and CD83, which is a marker of mature dendritic cells, on gingival cells that were isolated from severe periodontitis tissues, with the use of flow cytometry. Significant upregulation of CD86 and CD83 expression was detected in periodontitis lesions, and most of this occurred on B cells. In vitro peripheral blood mononuclear cell cultures showed that stimulation with different periodontopathic bacteria, that included Porphyromonas gingivalis, Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans, Prevotella intermedia, and Actinomyces viscosus, upregulated both CD86 and CD83 expression on B cells. Therefore, the presence of plaque bacteria may be responsible for the enhanced expression seen in vivo on gingival B cells. APC function by bacterial-activated B cells was further investigated using allogeneic mixed leukocyte reactions. After 24 h culture with either A. actinomycetemcomitans or P. gingivalis, these activated B cells performed as potent APCs in mixed leukocyte reactions, and they stimulated T cells to produce high levels of gamma interferon and minimal interleukin-5. In conclusion, periodontopathic bacterial-induced B cell activation with upregulation of CD86 and CD83 may be associated with enhanced APC function. The results of this study suggest, therefore, that infiltrated gingival B cells have a possible role as APCs in the regulation and maintenance of local T cell response in periodontitis.

Nicotine and smokeless tobacco effects on gingival and peripheral blood mononuclear cells

The pathogenesis of tobacco-related periodontal diseases is not well understood. The purpose of this study was therefore to investigate smokeless tobacco extract (ST) and nicotine effects on prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) and interleukin-1beta (IL-1beta) secretion by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC, consisting of monocytes and lymphocytes) and gingival mononuclear cells (GMC). Both peripheral blood and gingival tissue adjacent to the alveolar crest were taken from non-smoking adult periodontitis patients. Gingival tissue was treated with collagenase and deoxyribonuclease and GMC and PBMC were isolated by Ficoll-Hypaque centrifugation. GMC and PBMC (100,000 cells/200 microl) were cultured for 24 hours in supplemented RPMI 1640 alone (control), or in supplemented RPMI 1640 containing 1% ST, 100 microg/ml nicotine, 1 microg/ml Porphyromonas gingivalis LPS, or 1 microg/ml P. gingivalis LPS and either 100 microg/ml nicotine or 1% ST. Enzyme immunoassays were used to quantify PGE2 and IL-1beta. Treatments were compared by repeated measures ANOVA. 100 microg/ml nicotine (7-fold, p<0.02) and 1% ST (3.5-fold, p<0.004) significantly increased secretion of PGE2 by PBMC relative to control cultures. 100 microg/ml nicotine and 1% ST, however, had no effect on IL-1beta secretion by PBMC. Enhanced PGE2 secretion also was seen when PBMC were treated with P. gingivalis LPS+ 100 microg/ml nicotine relative to P. gingivalis LPS alone (p<0.007). In contrast, 100 microg/ml nicotine significantly downregulated IL-1beta secretion by GMC relative to medium alone (p<0.008) and had no effect on PGE2 secretion by GMC. These data indicate that while nicotine and ST can stimulate PBMC to secrete PGE2, they cannot activate further mononuclear cells extracted from gingiva, possibly due to maximal previous stimulation in the periodontitis lesion.

CD29 expression on CD4+ gingival lymphocytes supports migration of activated memory T lymphocytes to diseased periodontal tissue

The cell surface phenotypes of CD+ cells extracted from inflammatory periodontal disease tissues were analyzed using two- and three-color immunofluorescence and flow cytometry. Cells extracted from both adult periodontal and localized juvenile periodontitis lesions showed a depressed CD4/CD8 ratio (1.0 +/- 0.1 adult periodontitis and 1.1 +/- 0.1 localized juvenile periodontitis) compared with cells recovered from normal/marginal gingivitis tissue (1.8 +/- 0.2) or with normal peripheral blood cells (2.1 +/- 0.1) or periodontal disease blood cells (2.1 +/- 0.1 and 1.7 +/- 0.1 for adult periodontitis and juvenile periodontitis, respectively). The monoclonal antibodies anti-2H4 and anti-4B4 were used to identify the CD45RA and CD29 antigens respectively on CD4+ T cells from the periodontal disease lesions. In peripheral blood. CD29+ cells accounted for 66-77% of the CD4+ population, and CD45RA+ cells accounted for 22-27% of the CD4+ subset. No differences in expression were found between peripheral blood lymphocytes from normal subjects and from periodontal disease patients. Two-color analyses of lymphocytes from periodontal diseased tissues showed that 87-89% of the CD4+ population were CD29+ and that 70-79% of the CD4+ cells were CD45RA+. Normal tissues contained significantly fewer CD4+CD29+ cells (56 +/- 4%) and CD4+CD45RA+ cells (40 +/- 4%) on average, and few, if any double-labelled cells could be accounted for. These data implied that a significant percentage of the CD4+ cells from the diseased tissues were both CD29+ and CD45RA+ and that these populations are found in quite different proportions in diseased periodontal tissue than in peripheral blood or nondiseased tissue. In further analyses using three-color cytometry the mean percentage of CD4+ CD29+ CD45RA+ lymphocytes extracted from periodontal disease lesions was 43 +/- 9% of the CD4+ population. These results suggest that CD4+ T lymphocytes in periodontal disease not only demonstrate varying levels of maturity but also that the accumulation of CD4+ T cells within the periodontal tissues may be a result of increased adhesion and transendothelial migration.

Gingival cell IL-2 and IL-4 in early-onset periodontitis

The purpose of this study was to compare, using cell blot analysis, the association of gingival tissue mononuclear cells (GTMC) isolated from lesions displaying histories of early-onset periodontitis (EOP; typically B-lymphocyte dominated) and gingivitis (typically T-lymphocyte dominated) with the B-cell stimulating cytokine, interleukin (IL)-4, and the T-cell stimulating cytokine, IL-2. Eleven EOP patients and 11 age- and gender-similar gingivitis control (GC) subjects participated. Gingival tissue adjacent to the alveolar crest normally removed during surgery was digested in collagenase-containing media and GTMC were isolated by density gradient centrifugation. Cells were separated into four aliquots. One was left unstimulated; the remainder were stimulated for 2 hours with Porphyromonas gingivalis outer membrane protein, mitogen Concanavalin A, or common antigen tetanus toxoid. Cells then were centrifuged onto transfer membranes and incubated in RPMI 1640 media for 6 hours to allow absorption of secreted cytokine. Membranes were treated with monoclonal anti-IL-2 or anti-IL-4, followed by a biotin-conjugated second layer, streptavidin-alkaline phosphatase and nitro blue tetrazolium/5-bromo-4-chloro-indolyl-phosphate (NBT/BCIP) color development. A higher percentage of GTMC from EOP patients were IL-2+ when stimulated with P. gingivalis compared with GTMC from GC patients (20 +/- 2% vs. 12 +/- 2%, P < 0.003). A higher percentage of non-stimulated GTMC from EOP patients produced IL-4 than from GC (22 +/- 4% vs. 6 +/- 3%, P < 0.00007), as well as when stimulated with P. gingivalis (22 +/- 3% vs. 13 +/- 2%, P < 0.01).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Determination of lymphocyte populations and subpopulations extracted from chronically inflamed human periodontal tissues

The lymphocyte populations and subpopulations extracted from inflamed periodontal tissues of patients with adult periodontitis were determined. 34 patients were grouped according to the gingival index score (GI) of 1, 2 and 3. Gingival tissue from 2 involved teeth was excised, treated with collagenase, and infiltrating cells were isolated and identified using monoclonal antibodies for lymphocyte sets and subsets. The % of CD3+ cells was about 54.5% in all 3 patient groups, but the percentage of CD22+ cells increased from 28.9 +/- 3.3% in the group with GI = 1 to 33 +/- 1.2% in the group with GI = 3. %s of CD4+ cells and activated CD4+ cells increased from 30.2 +/- 2.1% and 4.7 +/- 1.7% in the group with GI = 1 to 38.4 +/- 1.2% and 16.0 +/- 3.4% in the group with GI = 3, respectively, while in the same groups, the % of CD8+ cells decreased from 24.9 +/- 2.0% to 17.7 +/- 1.6%. These data indicate a possible importance of activated CD4+ cells in pathogenetic mechanisms of periodontitis.

Chemotaxis of germinal center B cells in response to C5a

An infiltrate of B cells and plasma cells is characteristic of certain chronic inflammatory lesions. However, mechanisms involved in the local accumulation of these cells have not been established. Efforts to demonstrate that B cells from normal animals can migrate in response to inflammation-induced chemoattractants have been inconclusive. The objective of this study was to determine if murine germinal center (GC) B cells could respond chemotactically to a C5a gradient. On successive days after secondary immunization, draining lymph nodes were harvested and the activated GC B cells isolated. These GC B cells were placed in modified Boyden chambers, incubated for 3 h and the distance the leading front of cells migrated through the filters was determined. The results show that GC B cells migrated to factors in zymosan- and lipopolysaccharide-activated serum. The migratory response demonstrated distinct kinetics. Cells isolated between 2 to 4 days after secondary immunization migrated, whereas cells isolated at day 0 and beyond day 6 did not. Checkerboard analysis revealed that the migratory response was attributable to both chemokinesis and chemotaxis. Anti-C5 inhibited the migration of day-3 GC B cells implicating C5 in the migration mechanism. Studies using recombinant C5a established that this C5 fragment was chemotactically active. In conclusion, GC B cells generally were not chemotactically active. However, at a particular stage of maturation B cells in the GC become responsive to C5a as a chemotactic agent. Thus, B cells from normal animals may respond chemotactically, and C5a may play a role in recruitment of recently activated B cells into inflammatory sites.

Stereological observations on long-term experimental gingivitis in man

The purpose of the present investigation was to study stereologically the histopathologic changes in the gingiva during 6 months of abolished oral hygiene and to study the development of chronic gingivitis in man. After a thorough prophylaxis procedure, 5 dental students performed optimal oral hygiene under supervision for a period of 3 weeks. At the end of this pre-experimental phase, they were asked to abolish all oral hygiene procedures for 4 (2 individuals) to 6 months (3 individuals). At day 21, and after 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 months, the gingival exudate flow rate and the gingival index were assessed, and buccal gingival biopsies taken. Semi-thin histologic sections were stained with basic fuchsine and methylene blue. By point counting at 2 different levels of magnification, the volume densities of epithelium, infiltrated (ICT) and non-infiltrated connective tissue, and collagen were estimated. The %s of fibroblasts, PMN's lymphocytes, plasma cells and macrophages were estimated in a predetermined standardized area close to the apical termination of the junctional epithelium. With increasing time, the volume densities of the ICT rose concomitantly with a decrease in the volume densities of the collagen. In spite of great interindividual variations, a slow shift in the proportions of some cell populations was consistently observed. While the fraction of PMN's, lymphocytes and macrophages remained stable, a decrease of fibro-blasts (57 to 39%) and an increase of plasma cells (0.2 to 10%) was observed. This study has, therefore, demonstrated that, in 6 months of plaque accumulation, a chronic gingivitis with a predominance of PMN's and lymphocytes develops.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

In situ lymphocyte subpopulations from active versus stable periodontal sites

The purpose of this study was to evaluate lymphocyte subset densities and distributions within gingival biopsies from active sites (greater than or equal to 2 mm clinical attachment loss within three months of biopsy) versus clinically similar but stable or healthy sites. Small interproximal gingival biopsies representing at least one of each of the above categories were obtained from each of 20 periodontal maintenance patients. Serial cryostat sections displaying a cross section of the gingiva were labeled with monoclonal antibodies for (1) pan T cells, (2) T cytotoxic/suppressor cells, (3) T helper/inducer cells and (4) pan B cells and were developed using an avidin-biotin-peroxidase system. Lymphocyte populations were enumerated in repeatable fields from the sulcular, middle and oral one-third of each section. Relative proportions of the same lymphocyte subsets were analyzed in peripheral blood samples from the same patients using direct immunofluorescence. Pan B cells were significantly more prevalent in infiltrates from active sites than in stable (P less than 0.05) or healthy (P less than 0.01) sites. The T/B cell ratio was also significantly lower in active than stable biopsies (P less than 0.05), and in active biopsies versus blood (P less than 0.05). The T helper/T suppressor cell ratio did not vary significantly between blood and any gingival tissue disease group or location, but a trend toward lower relative numbers of T helper cells in the sulcular infiltrates of active sites was noted. These results support the premise that active periodontal sites display elevated B cell populations and abnormal immune regulation possibly involving the T helper cell subset.

HNK-1+ (Leu-7) cells and natural killer cell activity in inflamed human gingival tissue

The presence of HNK-1 (Leu-7)-positive cells and natural killer (NK) cell activity was determined in human periodontal tissues. Gingival tissues obtained from 25 adult patients were processed for analysis utilizing a HNK-1 (Leu-7) mouse monoclonal antibody. A subpopulation of non-adherent lymphoid cells obtained by collagenase digestion of inflamed gingival tissues from 10 patients was examined for the presence of large granular lymphocytes (LGL) by May-Grünwald-Giemsa staining and for NK cell activity against K562 cells by a 51Cr release cytotoxicity assay. HNK-1+ cells were identified in gingival tissue sections of 21 patients, and were present in or close to discrete foci of plasma cells. HNK-1+ cells were scarce in mildly inflamed or uninflamed tissues sections. LGL were identified in 9 of 10 gingival single-cell suspensions and constituted approximately 5% of the gingival cell population. NK cell-mediated cytolysis, at varying effector/target cell ratios, was observed for 3 of 4 enriched gingival mononuclear cell populations. Gamma-interferon (INF-gamma) preincubation of enriched gingival effector cells from 5 additional patients resulted in a 43% increase in NK cell activity. The finding of increased HNK-1+ cells with gingival inflammation suggests that these cells may play a role in tissue damage, as well as in modulation of B cell activity, in gingivae of patients with periodontal disease.

Phenotypic and functional analysis of T cells extracted from chronically inflamed human periodontal tissues

T-cell subsets extracted from chronically inflamed periodontal tissues were identified using monoclonal antibodies, and their functional activity was analysed using the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR). Tissue was obtained from a total of 33 adult periodontitis (AP) patients and 6 normal/marginal gingivitis (N/MG) patients. All AP patients had received repeated oral hygiene instruction and root planing prior to the surgery, and the majority (30 out of 33) had at least one site with greater than 6 mm loss of attachment from the cementoenamel junction within the surgical field. The N/MG patients had no loss of attachment, and probing depths were less than 3 mm. Single cell suspensions were obtained following collagenase digestion (90 minutes at 37 degrees C) and mechanical disruption of the tissue. T-cell subsets were identified using an indirect immunofluorescence assay on cells obtained from 19 AP patients and the 6 N/MG patients. The mean (+/- standard error) helper:suppressor (T4:T8) ratio for the AP patients was found to be 0.94 +/- 0.48 compared with 1.65 +/- 0.16 for the N/MG group and 1.51 +/- 0.12 for peripheral blood controls. HLA-DR positive macrophages were identified and were found to include both acid phosphatase (AcP) positive and adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) positive populations. Functional analysis was carried out using cells extracted from the remaining 14 AP patients. Cells from six of these 14 patients were found to be capable of spontaneous proliferation. Co-culture experiments using autologous T and non-T populations revealed that cells from only four patients were able to respond in an AMLR while those from only one of the 14 patients were able to stimulate the AMLR.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Phenotypic analyses of mononuclear cells recovered from healthy and diseased human periodontal tissues

Mononuclear cells were recovered from the gingival tissues of normal individuals and from patients with periodontal disease. Lymphocyte phenotypic markers were identified by immunofluorescence after reaction with monoclonal antibodies to T-cell subset markers. The normal tissues exhibited T4/T8 ratios almost identical to those in the peripheral blood. The diseased tissue cell ratios were significantly reduced, in both the adult periodontitis and the juvenile periodontitis groups (P less than 0.01 and P less than 0.02, respectively), indicating alterations in the T-cell subset distribution in these tissues. Each diseased patient showed a much decreased T4/T8 ratio in the gingival lymphocytes when these were compared with the peripheral blood ratio from the same patient. The T4/T8 ratios of the more severe sites were significantly lower than those of the less severe sites in the same disease category. The decreases in subset ratios could be attributed to statistically significant reductions in T4+-lymphocyte recoveries relative to peripheral blood and also to slight relative increases in T8+ lymphocytes. A highly significant (P less than 0.001) correlation between the average probeable periodontal pocket depth and the T4/T8 ratio of each disease category was demonstrated. The relative recoveries of B cells from the various tissues did not differ between diseased and normal tissues. It is suggested that T-cell regulatory expression in gingival tissues is distinct from peripheral blood regulatory expression and that there is a local immunoregulatory imbalance in periodontal disease.

Possible mechanisms involved in the immunoregulation of chronic inflammatory periodontal disease

It is generally agreed that immunological mechanisms are involved in the pathogenesis of periodontal disease; however, regulation of these mechanisms has hitherto received scant attention. Regulatory networks exist at both a cellular and a molecular level. At the cellular level, the existence of helper (T4-positive) and suppressor (T8-positive) T lymphocytes, the expression of Class II major histocompatibility complex antigens, and the heterogeneity of macrophage subpopulations are central to an understanding of the regulatory mechanisms involved. It is only recently that studies of these separate components, in both humans and experimental animals, have begun to provide a basis for understanding the complex interactions occurring in periodontal disease. Studies using the human experimental gingivitis model have shown an immunoregulatory picture consistent with a controlled immunological reaction with an essentially normal T4:T8 ratio of 2.0. In contrast, studies utilizing cells extracted from adult periodontitis lesions have shown a reduced T4:T8 ratio (approximately 1.0) and an inability to respond in, or to stimulate, an autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction. Animal studies using athymic nude rats have supported the concept of a central role for T-cell control in periodontal disease and the possibility of an imbalance in this control with disease progression. These results are reviewed and areas of future research explored.

Gingivitis

Gingivitis is caused by substances derived from microbial plaque accumulating at or near the gingival sulcus; all other suspected local and systemic etiologic factors either enhance plaque accumulation or retention, or enhance the susceptibility of the gingival tissue to microbial attack. Microbial species specifically associated with gingival health include Streptococcus sanguis 1, S. D-7, and Fusobacterium naviforme. Bacteria involved in the etiology of gingivitis include specific species of Streptococcus, Fusobacterium, Actinomyces, Veillonella, and Treponema and possibly Bacteroides, Capnocytophaga, and Eikenella. Microbial colonization and participation is sequential, with the complexity of the associated flora increasing with time. The pathogenesis has been separated into the initial, early, and established stages, each with characteristic features. The initial lesion is an acute inflammation which can be induced experimentally by application of extracts of plaque bacteria to normal gingiva. The early lesion is characterized by a lymphoid cell infiltrate predominated by T lymphocytes, characteristic of lesions seen at sites of cell-mediated hypersensitivity reactions. The early lesion can be induced by application of purified contact antigens to the gingival tissues of previously sensitized animals. As the clinical condition worsens, the established lesion appears, predominated by B lymphocytes and plasma cells. Established lesions may remain stable for indefinite periods of time, they may revert, or they may progress. Periodontal destruction does not result from the conversion of a predominantly T cell to a predominantly B cell lesion as has been suggested, but rather from episodes of acute inflammation. Clinical manifestations of gingivitis are episodic phenomena characterized by discontinuous bursts of acute inflammation. Most lesions are transient or persistent but not progressive. Attachment loss may precede alveolar bone loss and may occur without the manifestations of a concurrent or a precursor gingivitis. On the other hand, the evidence indicates that a portion of gingivitis lesions can and does progress to periodontitis. Gingivitis and the periodontal microflora differ in children and adults. Clinical signs of gingivitis either do not appear as plaque accumulates, or they are greatly delayed in children, and the inflammatory infiltrate consists mostly of T lymphocytes. The conversion to a B cell lesion does not appear to occur. The evidence supports the conclusion that gingivitis is a disease, and that control and prevention is a worthwhile goal and a health benefit.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Interleukin-2 production and bone-resorption activity in vitro by unstimulated lymphocytes extracted from chronically-inflamed human periodontal tissues

Lymphocytes isolated from chronically-inflamed tissues were assessed for their ability to produce lymphokines without further stimulation in vitro. Cells were extracted from tissue obtained from 42 patients undergoing periodontal surgery. Cultures were set up in triplicate and supernatants collected after 48 h were assayed for interleukin-2 (IL-2) or bone-resorptive activity. IL-2 was assayed in the cultured supernatants from 20 patients using a previously-standardized T-cell growth assay, with maximally-stimulated peripheral blood-lymphocytes as a positive control. Bone-resorptive activity (BRA) was assessed in culture supernatants from another 22 patients using an in-vitro mouse-calvaria culture-system in which calcium release was measured with a calcium analyser. IL-2 was detected in 12 out of the 20 unstimulated cultures; BRA was detected in 14 of the 22 unstimulated cultures. There appeared to be no relationship between IL-2 production and BRA and the severity of the disease as assessed by loss of attachment. Nevertheless, it seems that most of the cells extracted from chronically-inflamed tissue were producing lymphokines which may indicate stimulation in vivo prior to cell extraction.