Is there heterozygote expression of growth hormone receptor deficiency?

Growth Hormone Receptor (Ghr) 6ω Pseudoexon Activation: A Novel Cause Of Severe Growth Hormone Insensitivity (Ghi)

CONTEXT

Severe forms of Growth Hormone Insensitivity (GHI) are characterized by extreme short stature, dysmorphism and metabolic anomalies.

OBJECTIVE

Identification of the genetic cause of growth failure in 3 'classical' GHI subjects.

DESIGN

A novel intronic GHR variant was identified, and in vitro splicing assays confirmed aberrant splicing. A 6Ω pseudoexon GHR vector and patient fibroblast analysis assessed the consequences of the novel pseudoexon inclusion and the impact on GHR function.

RESULTS

We identified a novel homozygous intronic GHR variant (g.5:42700940T>G, c.618 + 836T> G), 44bp downstream of the previously recognized intronic 6Ψ GHR pseudoexon mutation in the index patient. Two siblings also harbored the novel intronic 6Ω pseudoexon GHR variant in compound heterozygosity with the known GHR c.181C>T (R43X) mutation. In vitro splicing analysis confirmed inclusion of a 151bp mutant 6Ω pseudoexon not identified in wild-type constructs. Inclusion of the 6Ω pseudoexon causes a frameshift resulting in a non-functional truncated GHR lacking the transmembrane and intracellular domains. The truncated 6Ω pseudoexon protein demonstrated extracellular accumulation and diminished activation of STAT5B signaling following growth hormone stimulation.

CONCLUSION

Novel GHR 6Ω pseudoexon inclusion results in loss of GHR function consistent with a severe GHI phenotype. This represents a novel mechanism of Laron syndrome and is the first deep intronic variant identified causing severe postnatal growth failure. The 2 kindreds originate from the same town in Campania, Southern Italy, implying common ancestry. Our findings highlight the importance of studying variation in deep intronic regions as a cause of monogenic disorders.

Nonclassical GH Insensitivity: Characterization of Mild Abnormalities of GH Action

GH insensitivity (GHI) presents in childhood with growth failure and in its severe form is associated with extreme short stature and dysmorphic and metabolic abnormalities. In recent years, the clinical, biochemical, and genetic characteristics of GHI and other overlapping short stature syndromes have rapidly expanded. This can be attributed to advancing genetic techniques and a greater awareness of this group of disorders. We review this important spectrum of defects, which present with phenotypes at the milder end of the GHI continuum. We discuss their clinical, biochemical, and genetic characteristics. The objective of this review is to clarify the definition, identification, and investigation of this clinically relevant group of growth defects. We also review the therapeutic challenges of mild GHI.

Genetic control of growth

The application of the powerful tool molecular biology has made it possible to ask questions not only about hormone production and action but also to characterize many of the receptor molecules that initiate responses to the hormones. We are beginning to understand how cells may regulate the expression of genes and how hormones intervene in regulatory processes to adjust the expression of individual genes. In addition, great strides have been made in understanding how individual cells talk to each other through locally released factors to coordinate growth, differentiation, secretion, and other responses within a tissue. In this review I (1) focus on developmental aspects of the pituitary gland, (2) focus on the different components of the growth hormone axis and (3) examine the different altered genes and their related growth factors and/or regulatory systems that play an important physiological and pathophysiological role in growth. Further, as we have already entered the 'post-genomic' area, in which not only a defect at the molecular level becomes important but also its functional impact at the cellular level, I concentrate in the last part on some of the most important aspects of cell biology and secretion.

A novel heterozygous T51I mutation of growth hormone receptor is not associated with short stature

A novel missense mutation of the growth hormone receptor (GHR) gene was identified in a Japanese short boy with GH insensitivity. The analysis of the GHR gene revealed a novel heterozygous T51I mutation in exon 4. To clarify the effect of this mutation on GH signaling, the mutant GHR was expressed in CHO cells and its functional properties were investigated. The signal transducer and activator of transcription 5 (STAT5)-mediated transcriptional activation in mutant GHR (GHR-T51I)-expressing cells was significantly reduced as compared with wild-type GHR (GHR-wt)-expressing cells. The CHO cells co-expressing the GHR-T51I and GHR-wt, however, revealed no functional differences as compared with cells expressing GHR-wt alone, indicating that the T51I mutation does not exert the dominant negative effect. In addition, the mother and the elder brother of the proband, whose heights were normal, possessed the same heterozygous mutation. These results suggest that the heterozygous T51I mutation of GHR does not inhibit the signal transduction of GH and is not responsible for GH insensitivity.

Stature in Ecuadorians heterozygous for growth hormone receptor gene E180 splice mutation does not differ from that of homozygous normal relatives

Heterozygosity for certain mutations of the GH receptor (GHR) gene has been proposed as the cause of partial resistance to GH, and there has been a recent demonstration of a dominant-negative effect of such a mutation in a mother and child. To examine the effect of heterozygosity in a large genetically homogeneous population with GHR deficiency, in which a substantial number of heterozygous (carrier) subjects and homozygous normal individuals can be compared, we studied a population in Ecuador in which 70 individuals with GHR deficiency were homozygous for the E180 splice mutation. We found that 58 heterozygous relatives of probands were not significantly shorter than 37 homozygous normal relatives [SD score (SDS) for height -1.85 +/- 1.04 (SD) vs. -1.55 +/- 0.96, P > 0.10]. When only those families with both homozygous normals and carriers were compared, the 33 heterozygous and 29 normal relatives did not differ significantly in height SDS (-1.98 +/- 1.07 vs. -1.77 +/- 0.91, P > 0.3). If heterozygosity for the E180 splice mutation were to influence stature, heights of heterozygous parents of probands would be expected to correlate with those of probands and of carriers who are their offspring and not with heights of their homozygous normal children. Parental height SDS did not correlate with height SDS of affected offspring (r = 0.24). For unaffected siblings as a group or analyzed separately as normals or carriers, there was a strong correlation between parental and offspring SDS for height (P < 0.01 for all comparisons). Thus, the effect of homozygosity for the GHR mutation was so profound as to abolish parental influence on height, and there was no difference in the influence of parental stature between carrier and noncarrier offspring. These findings demonstrate no meaningful effect on stature of heterozygosity for the E180 splice mutation of the GHR, which is a functional null mutation and, in the homozygous state, results in profound short stature from severe insulin-like growth factor-I deficiency.

Growth hormone insensitivity

Growth hormone insensitivity (GHI) may be primary, caused by defects in the GH receptor, or further along the GH-insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) axis, or secondary, resulting from a variety of illnesses or malnutrition affecting various steps in the pathway from the GH binding to IGF-I action. GH receptor deficiency, although rare, with only 229 cases reported, is the most common cause of primary GHI. Most patients are of Jewish, Arab, or other Mediterranean origin, the largest cohort being Catholics of Jewish origin coming from a small area in southern Ecuador, who account for one third of known cases. This large cohort has provided insight into the clinical features, growth characteristics, biochemical features, and effects of treatment with recombinant IGF-I. The Ecuadorian patients share a splice site mutation in the GH receptor gene with at least one Israeli patient of Iberian origin; 27 other mutations and a major deletion have been described in other affected patients.

Partial growth hormone insensitivity in childhood

There appears to be a continuum of GH-responsiveness, ranging from complete GH-resistance in Laron syndrome to normal GH-sensitivity. Partial GHI is suggested by findings at both ends of this spectrum; some patients with Laron-type dwarfism are less severely affected by their GHI than others (Savage et al, 1993; for a review, see Savage et al, 1995) and some short, non-GH-deficient, children have reduced responsiveness to GH. Among children with ISS, we have identified a subgroup where defects at the level of the GH receptor lead to a partial-GHI syndrome (Carlsson et al, 1994; Attie et al, 1995; Goddard et al, 1995). Partial-GHI may explain the growth failure in some children who do not meet the criteria for GHD. So far, the clinical evaluation of short children has been focused on the exclusion or demonstration of GHD. The diagnosis of GHD at present requires that stimulated or spontaneous GH concentrations should fail to reach a certain, arbitrarily determined level. This assumes that GH-sensitivity is equal in all subjects, with the exception of rare cases with Laron syndrome. The diagnosis of GHD is in itself controversial, and it has been suggested that GH testing should be supplemented by other measures such as auxological evaluation and measurement of other components of the GH/IGF-I axis (Rosenfeld et al, 1995). However, the fact that some short children have partial-GHI suggests that both GH secretion and GH responsiveness should be taken into consideration when investigating the cause of short stature (Figure 5). Many short children do not have GHD per se, but may be short due to inadequate GH stimulation because of reduced GH-sensitivity.

Insulin-like growth factor binding protein-3 generation: an index of growth hormone insensitivity

GH insensitivity may be an inherited condition or may arise as a consequence of disease of malnutrition. Laron syndrome is the most severe form of GH insensitivity, arising from an absent or defective GH receptor. Less severe forms of GH insensitivity, however, may exist, resulting in short stature but in few other features of Laron syndrome. We have identified a heterogeneous group of children with short stature and either high basal (> 10 mU/L) or high peak GH levels (> 40 mU/L) on GH provocation testing, to examine biochemical markers of GH sensitivity. These children received 4 d of GH (0.1 U/kg) and the increment in IGF-I, IGF binding protein (BP)-3, and GHBP was determined. Eight GHD children, commencing GH therapy, were recruited as positive controls. The two groups could not be differentiated by age, height SDS (SD score), height velocity SDS, or body mass index. IGF-I and IGFBP-3 generation were correlated in all children (delta SDS IGF-I versus delta SDS IGFBP-3, r = 0.49, p = 0.03). Neither basal GHBP levels or the increment in GHBP were predictive of the IGF-I or IGFBP-3 response to GH. The GHI group had a significantly reduced IGFBP-3 response to stimulation with 4 d of GH (median percent increment in IGFBP-3, 26%, versus 72% in the GHD group, P = 0.03); their IGF-I response to GH was also reduced (median % increment in IGF-I 75% versus 144% in the GH deficient group), but this did not achieve significance, p = 0.06. In all children, the percentage rise or delta SDS in both IGF-I and IGFBP-3 inversely correlated with the GH peak obtained on provocation testing, the latter being the most significant determinant of GH peak. We propose that the "IGF generation test", in particular IGFBP-3 generation, can be used in the investigation of partial GH insensitivity. Further work, however, is required to establish diagnostic criteria for partial GH insensitivity.

Mutations of the growth hormone receptor in children with idiopathic short stature. The Growth Hormone Insensitivity Study Group

BACKGROUND

Short stature in children who are not deficient in growth hormone (GH) is probably caused by a variety of defects. Some children with idiopathic short stature have low serum concentrations of GH-binding protein, which is derived from the GH receptor. The possibility that low serum concentrations of GH-binding protein might indicate partial insensitivity to GH led us to investigate possible defects in the gene for the GH receptor in children with idiopathic short stature and low serum concentrations of GH-binding protein.

METHODS

We studied 14 children with idiopathic short stature who were selected on the basis of normal GH secretion and low serum concentrations of GH-binding protein. Analysis of single-strand conformation polymorphisms and DNA sequencing were both used to identify mutations in the GH-receptor gene.

RESULTS

Mutations in the region of the GH-receptor gene that codes for the extracellular domain of the receptor were found in 4 of the 14 children, but in none of 24 normal subjects. One of the four children with mutations was a compound heterozygote, with one mutation that reduced the affinity of the receptor for GH and a second mutation that may affect a function other than ligand binding. The remaining three children had single mutations in one allele of the gene. One mutation introduced a premature termination codon, and two caused substitutions of single amino acids in a structurally conserved domain of the receptor.

CONCLUSIONS

Some children with idiopathic short stature may have partial insensitivity to GH due to mutations in the GH-receptor gene.

Growth in growth hormone insensitivity

Primary GH insensitivity due to GH receptor deficiency (GHRD) provides a model for studying the discrete effects of severe IGF-I deficiency on growth and body composition. Growth failure in utero is doubtful, but postpartum growth proceeds at rates that result in adult statures 4-12 standard deviations (SDs) below the normal mean. Wide variability in statural effect, even in a genetically homogeneous population, is partly explained by correlation of SD score with biochemical measures of GH effect (IGF-I, IGF-II, and IGFBP-3). Growth and changes in body composition (decreased fat/lean) in patients with GHRD in response to exogenous IGF-I indicate that direct local effects of GH are not necessary for these responses.