Variations in nursing home discharge rates for urban and rural nursing facility residents with hip fracture

A Scoping Literature Review of Rural Institutional Elder Care

Under circumstances of pervasive global aging combined with weakened traditional family elder care, an incremental demand for institutional elder care is generated. This has led to a surge in research regarding institutional elder care. Rural residents' institutional elder care is receiving more attention as a major theme in social sciences and humanities research. Based on 94 articles related to rural institutional elder care, this study identified the most influential articles, journals and countries in rural institutional elder care research since 1995. This was done using science mapping methods through a three-step workflow consisting of bibliometric retrieval, scoping analysis and qualitative discussion. Keywords revealed five research mainstreams in this field: (1) the cognition and mental state of aged populations, (2) the nursing quality and service supply of aged care institutions, (3) the aged care management systems' establishment and improvements, (4) the risk factors of admission and discharge of aged care institutions, and (5) deathbed matters regarding the aged population. A qualitative discussion is also provided for 39 urban and rural comparative research papers and 55 pure rural research papers, summarizing the current research progress status regarding institutional elder care systems in rural areas. Gaps within existing research are also identified to indicate future research trends (such as the multi-dimensional and in-depth comparative research on institutional elder care, new rural institutional elder care model and technology, and correlative policy planning and development), which provides a multi-disciplinary guide for future research.

Sustainers: Hospitals with sustained superior performance

PURPOSE

The purpose of this article was to investigate the organizational and market-level variables associated with sustained superior hospital performance on Value-Based Purchasing total performance scores (TPS).

METHODOLOGY

TPS for 2014 through 2017 was obtained from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Hospital Compare website. Market-level data were from the 2017 Area Health Resource File, and hospital-level data were from the 2014 American Hospital Association Annual Survey database. We specified a logistic regression model to identify significant predictors of hospitals with sustained superior performance on TPS, that is, "sustainers."

PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

Only 8.4% of hospitals were classified as sustainers. Hospitals located in rural markets with a high Medicare Advantage penetration had a higher likelihood of being classified as sustainers. High RN staffing levels, lower Medicare share of inpatient days, not-for-profit ownership, and small size were all significant organizational predictors of sustained superior performance.

CONCLUSIONS

Both modifiable characteristics, such as nurse staffing levels, and nonmodifiable characteristics, such as rural markets and small hospital size, are associated with the likelihood of hospitals sustaining superior performance over time.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

Managers need to carefully examine their staffing levels as they pursue interventions to sustain high TPS overtime. Moreover, factors such as Medicare share of inpatient days and size need to be considered when understanding barriers to sustained performance on Value-Based Purchasing domains.

Rural-Urban Differences in Nursing Home Risk-adjusted Rates of Emergency Department Visits: A Decomposition Analysis

BACKGROUND

Higher risk-adjusted rate of emergency department (ED) visits might reflect poor quality of nursing home (NH) care; however, existing evidence is limited regarding rural-urban differences in ED rates of NHs, especially for long-stay residents.

OBJECTIVES

To determine and quantify sources of rural-urban differences in NH risk-adjusted rates of any ED visit, ED without hospitalization or observation stay (outpatient ED), and potentially avoidable ED visits (PAED) of long-stay residents.

RESEARCH DESIGN

We calculated quarterly NH risk-adjusted rates using 2011-2013 national Medicare claims and Minimum Data Set 3.0, and then implemented Generalized Estimating Equation models to examine rural-urban differences in ED rates and Blinder-Oaxaca decomposition to quantify the contributions of NH and market factors.

SUBJECTS

Privately owned, free-standing NHs in the United States (N=13,260).

RESULTS

Over the study period, risk-adjusted rates averaged 9.8% for any ED, 3.3% for outpatient ED, and 3.2% for PAED. Compared with urban NHs, rural NHs were associated with significantly lower rates of any ED, outpatient ED, and PAED (β=-1.67%, -0.44%, and -0.28%; all P<0.01). Observable differences in market factors (nursing home bed concentration, hospital beds, and the existence of a critical access hospital) explained about half of the rural-urban differences in rates of any ED and PAED, but not outpatient ED.

CONCLUSIONS

Decomposition analyses suggested that lower ED rates in rural NHs appear to be related to market availability of hospital resources. Policymakers may focus on not only reducing unnecessary ED visits but also ensuring equitable hospital access in rural areas.

Improved outcome in hip fracture patients in the aging population following co-managed care compared to conventional surgical treatment: a retrospective, dual-center cohort study

BACKGROUND

Hip fracture patients in the aging population frequently present with various comorbidities, whilst preservation of independency and activities of daily living can be challenging. Thus, an interdisciplinary orthogeriatric treatment of these patients has recognized a growing acceptance in the last years. As there is still limited data on the impact of this approach, the present study aimed to evaluate the long-term outcome in elderly hip fracture patients, by comparing the treatment of a hospital with integrated orthogeriatric care (OGC) with a conventional trauma care (CTC).

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective, two-center, cohort study. In two maximum care hospitals all patients presenting with a hip fracture at the age of ≥ 70 years were consecutively assigned within a 1 year period and underwent follow-up examination 12 months after surgery. Patients treated in hospital site A were treated with an interdisciplinary orthogeriatric approach (co-managed care), patients treated in hospital B underwent conventional trauma care. Main outcome parameters were 1 year mortality, readmission rate, requirement of care (RC) and personal activities of daily living (ADL).

RESULTS

A total of 436 patients were included (219 with OGC / 217 with CTC). The mean age was 83.55 (66-99) years for OGC and 83.50 (70-103) years for CTC (76.7 and 75.6% of the patients respectively were female). One year mortality rates were 22.8% (OGC) and 28.1% (CTC; p = 0.029), readmission rates were 25.7% for OGC compared to 39.7% for CTC (p = 0.014). Inconsistent data were found for activities of daily living. After 1 year, 7.8% (OGC) and 13.8% (CTC) of the patients were lost to follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Interdisciplinary orthogeriatric management revealed encouraging impact on the long-term outcome of hip fracture patients in the aging population. The observed reduction of mortality, requirements of care and readmission rates to hospital clearly support the health-economic impact of an interdisciplinary orthogeriatric care on specialized wards.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

The study was approved and registered by the bavarian medical council (BLAEK: 7/11192) and the local ethics committee of munich university (Reg. No. 234-16) and was conducted as a two-center, cohort study at a hospital with integrated orthogeriatric care and a hospital with conventional trauma care.

Market and organizational factors associated with hospital vertical integration into sub-acute care

BACKGROUND

Changes in payment models incentivize hospitals to vertically integrate into sub-acute care (SAC) services. Through vertical integration into SAC, hospitals have the potential to reduce the transaction costs associated with moving patients throughout the care continuum and reduce the likelihood that patients will be readmitted.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to examine the correlates of hospital vertical integration into SAC.

METHODOLOGY/APPROACH

Using panel data of U.S. acute care hospitals (2008-2012), we conducted logit regression models to examine environmental and organizational factors associated with hospital vertical integration. Results are reported as average marginal effects.

FINDINGS

Among 3,775 unique hospitals (16,269 hospital-year observations), 25.7% vertically integrated into skilled nursing facilities during at least 1 year of the study period. One measure of complexity, the availability of skilled nursing facilities in a county (ME = -1.780, p < .001), was negatively associated with hospital vertical integration into SAC. Measures of munificence, percentage of the county population eligible for Medicare (ME = 0.018, p < .001) and rural geographic location (ME = 0.069, p < .001), were positively associated with hospital vertical integration into SAC. Dynamism, when measured as the change county population between 2008 and 2011 (ME = 1.19e-06, p < .001), was positively associated with hospital vertical integration into SAC. Organizational resources, when measured as swing beds (ME = 0.069, p < .001), were positively associated with hospital vertical integration into SAC. Organizational resources, when measured as investor owned (ME = -0.052, p < .1) and system affiliation (ME = -0.041, p < .1), were negatively associated with hospital vertical integration into SAC.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

Hospital adaption to the changing health care landscape through vertical integration varies across market and organizational conditions. Current Centers for Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement programs do not take these factors into consideration. Vertical integration strategy into SAC may be more appropriate under certain market conditions. Hospital leaders may consider how to best align their organization's SAC strategy with their operating environment.

Association Between Therapy Intensity and Discharge Outcomes in Aged Medicare Skilled Nursing Facilities Admissions

OBJECTIVES

To determine the association between therapy intensity and discharge outcomes for aged Medicare skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) fee-for-service beneficiaries and to determine the association between therapy intensity and time to community discharge.

DESIGN

Retrospective observational design.

SETTING

SNFs.

PARTICIPANTS

Aged Medicare fee-for-service beneficiaries (N=311,338) in 3605 SNFs.

INTERVENTIONS

The total minutes of physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech therapy per day were divided into intensity groups: high (≥60min); medium-high (45-<60min); medium-low (30-<45min); and low (<30min).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Four discharge outcomes-community, hospitalization, permanent placement, and death-were examined using a multivariate competing hazards model. For those associated with community discharge, a Poisson multivariate model was used to determine whether length of stay differed by intensity.

RESULTS

High intensity therapy was associated with more community discharges in comparison to the remaining intensity groups (hazard ratio, .84, .68, and .433 for medium-high, medium-low, and low intensity groups, respectively). More hospitalizations and deaths were found as therapy intensity decreased. Only high intensity therapy was associated with a 2-day shorter length of stay (incident rate ratio, .95).

CONCLUSIONS

High intensity therapy was associated with desirable discharge outcomes and may shorten SNF length of stay. Despite growing reimbursements to SNFs for rehabilitation services, there may be desirable benefits to beneficiaries who receive high intensity therapy.

Rehabilitation of Older Adults with Dementia After Hip Fracture

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the effects of postoperative rehabilitation on the outcomes of older adults with dementia who experienced hip fracture.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

Ontario, Canada.

PARTICIPANTS

Community-dwelling adults with dementia who underwent hip fracture surgery between 2003 and 2011. Participants were categorized as no rehabilitation, complex continuing care (CCC), home-care based rehabilitation (HCR), and inpatient rehabilitation (IPR).

MEASUREMENTS

Time to long-term care (LTC) placement, mortality, and risk of repeat hip fracture and falls.

RESULTS

Of 11,200 individuals with dementia who experienced a hip fracture during the study period, 4,494 (40.1%) received no rehabilitation, 2,474 (22.1%) were admitted to CCC, 1,157 (10.3%) received HCR, and 3,075 (27.4%) received IPR. HCR and IPR were associated with less risk of LTC admission after discharge from hospital than no rehabilitation. All three forms of rehabilitation were associated with lower risk of mortality than no rehabilitation, with the greatest effect observed with IPR. HCR was associated with a higher risk of falls than no rehabilitation (P=.03); there were no other significant between-group differences in risk of falls or repeat fractures (P>.05).

CONCLUSION

Postfracture rehabilitation for older adults with dementia is associated with lower risk of LTC placement and mortality. Improving access to rehabilitation services for this vulnerable population may improve postfracture outcomes.

Effects of municipality factors on care transitions

Aims: To analyse whether transitions between care settings differ between municipalities in the last 2 years of life among older people in Finland. Methods: Data were derived from Finnish national registers, and include all those who died in 2002 and 2003 at the age of 70 or older except those living in very small municipalities ( n=67,027). Data include admissions and discharges from health and social care facilities (university hospitals, general hospitals, health centres, residential care facilities) and time spent outside care facilities for 730 days prior to death. Three-level negative binomial regression analyses were performed to study the effect of municipal factors on (1) the total number of all care transitions, (2) the number of transitions between home and different care facilities, and (3) transitions between different care facilities. Results: The municipality of residence had only a minor effect on the total number of care transitions, but greater variation between municipalities was found when different types of care transition were examined separately. Largest differences were found in care transitions involving specialised care. Age structure, urbanity, and economic situation of the municipality had an impact on several different care transitions. Conclusion: The total number of care transitions in 2 final years of life was approximately similar irrespective of the municipality of residence, but the findings imply differences in transitioning specialised care. Potentially, this may suggest inequality between the municipalities, but more detailed studies are needed to confirm the factors underlying these differences.

Rurality and nursing home quality: evidence from the 2004 National Nursing Home Survey

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY

To evaluate the impact of rural geographic location on nursing home quality of care in the United States.

DESIGN AND METHODS

The study used cross-sectional observational design. We obtained resident- and facility-level data from 12,507 residents in 1,174 nursing homes from the 2004 National Nursing Home Survey. We used multilevel regression models to predict risk-adjusted rates of hospitalization, influenza and pneumococcal vaccination, and moderate to severe pain while controlling for resident and facility characteristics.

RESULTS

Adjusting for covariates, residents in rural facilities were more likely to experience hospitalization (odds ratio [OR] = 1.50, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.16-1.94) and moderate to severe pain (OR = 1.68, 95% CI = 1.35-2.09). Significant facility-level predictors of higher quality included higher percentage of Medicaid beneficiaries, accreditation status, and special care programs. Medicare payment findings were mixed. Significant resident-level predictors included dementia diagnosis and being a "long-stay" resident.

IMPLICATIONS

Rural residents were more likely to reside in facilities without accreditations or special care programs, factors that increased their odds of receiving poorer quality of care. Policy efforts to enhance Medicare payment approaches as well as increase rural facilities' accreditation status and provision of special care programs will likely reduce quality of care disparities in facilities.

Early implementation of medicare part D in urban and rural nursing facilities

OBJECTIVE

To determine if differences occurred in the early implementation of Medicare Part D (prescription drug program) between urban and rural nursing facilities.

DESIGN

Nursing facility demographic data, obtained from the Nursing Facility Compare Medicare Web site, were used to create matched pairs of rural and urban facilities. On-site interviews were conducted in June and July 2006 with one designated representative from each nursing facility. Details for each prescription drug plan (PDP), identified by the facility representatives, were obtained from the PDP's Web site.

SETTING

A prospective pilot field study of rural and urban nursing facilities was created from among 40 facilities in the 26-county Texas Panhandle. Five rural/urban nursing facilities of identical ownership and of similar perceived quality (number of cited deficiencies) and staffing (total nursing staff time per resident) were used for the pilot study.

PARTICIPANTS

Nursing facility employees charged with overseeing Part D implementation and trained interviewers.

INTERVENTION

None.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Number of PDPs per nursing facility and distribution of persons providing enrollment decision support.

RESULTS

Rural facilities used more PDPs (7.4 +/- 3.9) than did urban facilities (4.6 +/- 3.8, NSS). Independent samples Student's t-test determined that there was a significant difference in the average number of drugs per resident. Rural residents received fewer medications (8.2 +/- 1.9) than urban residents (11.2 +/- 2.2; P = 0.049, t = 2.32).

CONCLUSIONS

These early findings suggest that rural nursing facilities interact with more PDPs than urban facilities and that Medicare Part D enrollment decisions are more likely to be aided by family members in rural facilities than in urban nursing facilities.

Utilization of Medical Services at the End of Life in Older Adults with Cognitive Impairment: Focus on Outliers

BACKGROUND

The use of intensive medical care near end of life is often questioned because of potential burden to patients, their families, and society. Efforts to moderate intensive end-of-life care may be facilitated by early identification of those at greatest risk for receiving such care.

OBJECTIVE

To examine factors associated with intensive end-of-life medical care utilization in nursing home residents with severe cognitive impairment.

DESIGN

Retrospective review of existing Medicare data: 1998-2001 Minimum Data Set (MDS), Medicare Denominator, MedPAR, and hospice files.

METHODS

Subjects were Minnesota and Texas nursing home residents from rural and urban counties (USDA metro-nonmetro continuum codes: 0-2 urban, 6-9 rural), who had severe cognitive impairment and who died during 2000-2001. Hospice and managed care enrollees were excluded. High medical care users were defined as subjects with 7+ intensive care unit (ICU) days in the last 90 days of life. Measures of end-of-life medical care utilization intensity included tube feeding on the last MDS report, number of hospital and ICU days, and total hospital charges during the study period.

RESULTS

The study population included 1494 nursing home residents who were hospitalized within 90 days prior to death; 82 (5%) met the high medical care user criteria. In multivariable analysis: urban location (p < 0.001), lack of do-not-resuscitate directive (p = 0.002), non-white race (p = 0.021), and having 3+ comorbidities (p = 0.021) were independently associated with high medical care utilization.

CONCLUSIONS

Urban nursing home location and lack of do-not-resuscitate directives were the strongest predictors of high medical care utilization near the end of life.

Predictors of resident outcome improvement in nursing homes

The effects of contextual characteristics and nursing-related factors on the overall quality improvement of resident outcomes, measured by a weighted index in incidents of pressure ulcers, physical restraints, and catheter use in nursing homes, were investigated by autoregressive latent trajectory modeling of panel data (1997-2003). Findings show that in the initial study period, nursing homes with a smaller bed size, being for-profit, caring for more Medicare residents, having residents with lower acuity levels, being located elsewhere than the South, having a high level of nurse staffing, and certified with lower frequencies of nursing care deficiencies had better quality. The intercept factor, representing the baseline of quality, was well predicted by six of the eight contextual and facility characteristics variables, and the slope trajectory of quality was only weakly predicted by them. The improved quality in resident outcomes was associated with facilities having fewer nursing care deficiency citations than their counterparts.

Outcomes and reimbursement of inpatient rehabilitation facilities and subacute rehabilitation programs for Medicare beneficiaries with hip fracture

OBJECTIVE

We sought to assess whether outcomes and reimbursement differ for Medicare beneficiaries with hip fracture when treated in an inpatient rehabilitation facility (IRF) compared with a skilled nursing facility (SNF) subacute rehabilitation program.

PARTICIPANTS

Clinical data were linked with Medicare claims for 29,793 Medicare fee-for-service beneficiaries with a recent hip fracture who completed treatment in 1996 or 1997 in rehabilitation facilities that subscribed to the Uniform Data System for Medical Rehabilitation.

OUTCOME MEASURES

We measured discharge destination, change in motor FIM rating, and Medicare Part A reimbursement.

RESULTS

For patients with moderate-to-severe and severe disabilities, case mix groups (CMGs) 704 and 705, the percentage of patients discharged to the community from IRFs was lower than for patients treated in subacute rehabilitation SNFs, after controlling for covariates. Adjusted odds ratios were 0.71 (95% confidence interval 0.55-0.92) for CMG 704 and 0.72 (95% confidence interval 0.63-0.83) for CMG 705. For patients in the 3 other CMGs, no significant differences were detected. Improvement in motor functional status was roughly equivalent for patients treated in IRFs and those treated in the subacute rehabilitation programs across all 5 CMGs, after controlling for covariates. Medicare Part A payments for IRFs were significantly higher than SNF payments across all CMGs.

CONCLUSION

SNF-based subacute rehabilitation was less costly and outcomes were in most, but not all, instances similar or better than IRF-based rehabilitation for Medicare fee-for-service beneficiaries who had a recent hip fracture.

Rurality and nursing home quality: results from a national sample of nursing home admissions

OBJECTIVES

We examined differences in quality of care among nursing homes in locales of varying degrees of rurality.

METHODS

We classified locales into 4 classes according to rurality. We analyzed a 10% sample of nursing home admissions in the United States in 2000 (n=198613) to estimate survival models for 9 quality indicators.

RESULTS

For postacute admissions, we observed significant differences in rates of decline for residents in facilities in large towns compared with urban areas, but differences in quality were both negative and positive. Among admissions for long-term or chronic care, rates of decline in 2 of 9 quality areas were lower for residents in isolated areas.

CONCLUSIONS

We observed significant differences in a number of quality indicators among different classes of nursing home locations, but differences varied dramatically according to type of admission. These differences did not exhibit the monotonicity that we would have expected had they derived solely from rurality. Also, quality indicators exhibited more similarities than differences across the 4 classes of locales. The results underscore the importance, in some instances, of emphasizing the effects of specific settings rather than some continuum of rurality and of moving beyond the assumption that nursing home residents constitute a homogeneous population.

Measuring Rural Hospital Quality

CONTEXT

Increased interest in the measurement of hospital quality has been stimulated by accrediting bodies, purchaser coalitions, government agencies, and other entities.

PURPOSE

This paper examines quality measurement for hospitals in rural settings. We seek to identify rural hospital quality measures that reflect quality in all hospitals and that are sensitive to the rural hospital context.

METHODS

We develop a conceptual model for measuring rural hospital quality, with a focus on the special issues posed by the rural hospital context for quality measurement. With the assistance of a panel of rural hospital and hospital quality measurement experts, we review hospital quality measures from national and rural organizations for their fit to rural hospitals.

FINDINGS

Based on this analysis, we recommend an initial core set of quality measures relevant for rural hospitals with less than 50 beds. This core set of 20 measures includes 11 core measures from the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO) related to community acquired pneumonia, heart failure, and acute myocardial infarction; 1 measure related to infection control; 3 measures related to medication dispensing and teaching; 2 procedure-related measures; 1 financial measure; and 2 other measures related to the use of advance directives and emergency department monitoring of trauma vital signs.

CONCLUSION

Based on the special measurement needs posed by the rural hospital context, we suggest avenues for future quality measure development for core rural hospital functions (eg, triage, stabilization, and transfer, and emergency care) not considered in existing quality measurement sets.