Avoidance of BIPP allergy hypersensitivity reactions following ear surgery

Review of endoscopic myringoplasty success: comparisons of intra-operative graft material and post-operative packing in terms of graft failure rate

Background

Myringoplasty success rate is estimated to be between 60 and 90 per cent. Factors predicting success include the choice of graft and use of auditory canal packing. This study aimed to determine the intra-operative factors associated with endoscopic myringoplasty success.

Methods

A retrospective review of all endoscopic myringoplasty cases between January 2017 and January 2020 was undertaken. Data were collected on: patient demographics, tympanic membrane perforation size, intra-operative details, audiology and post-operative outcomes.

Results

There was no significant difference in graft success rates between cases using bismuth iodoform paraffin paste and Spongostan packing (86.7 per cent vs 84.9 per cent, respectively). Conchal cartilage graft had a higher success rate (100.0 per cent) compared with Biodesign grafting biomaterial (66.7 per cent), but was not superior to tragal cartilage (84.6 per cent) or temporalis fat or fascia (80.0 per cent).

Conclusion

Spongostan packing is equivalent to bismuth iodoform paraffin paste in terms of endoscopic myringoplasty success rate. Although conchal cartilage graft had higher success rates, it was not statistically significantly different from tragal cartilage.

A safe and comparable alternative to BIPP packing following tympanoplasty for tympanic membrane perforation

PURPOSE

To compare two post-operative ear packing methods following tympanoplasty for tympanic membrane perforation.

METHODS

A prospective study of patients undergoing tympanoplasty for tympanic membrane perforation over a 2-year period was undertaken across two district general hospitals. Data, including demographics, pre-operative ear state, and graft type used for repair were recorded. Ears were packed using one of two distinct methods. Pack A: gelatin sponge, chloramphenicol ointment and an antibiotic-soaked ear wick. Pack B: antibiotic-soaked gelatin sponge, bismuth iodoform paraffin paste (BIPP) impregnated gauze dressing. The primary outcome measure was post-operative complications associated with each packing method RESULTS: One hundred and fifty-three tympanoplasties were performed during this period: 68 underwent Pack A and 85 underwent Pack B. Chi squared test showed no significant association between pack type and complication rate (p = 0.572). Univariate analysis suggested that age (p = 0.047) and concurrent bony canaloplasty (p = 0.006) significantly increased complication rates. Pre-operative ear status, indication, graft type and gender did not affect complication rate.

CONCLUSIONS

BIPP-impregnated ribbon gauze and chloramphenicol/wick are both comparable methods for packing an ear following tympanoplasty for tympanic membrane perforation. This is useful information both for surgeons who commonly use BIPP and have a patient with a known iodine allergy, or who is not known to be allergic to iodine but has been packed with BIPP previously, and for those who do not have access to BIPP and wish to use a pack with comparable success.

A pilot randomized controlled trial comparing bismuth iodine paraffin paste external ear pack and no ear pack after middle ear surgery

To pilot a substantive randomized control trial comparing post-operative external ear canal pack with no ear pack after middle ear surgery, 32 adults undergoing primary posterior bony canal wall preserving middle ear surgery were randomized to have either a bismuth iodoform paraffin paste pack or no ear pack post-operatively. Outcome measures included clinician- and patient-recorded visual analogue scale scores for ear signs and symptoms at 3 weeks and 3 months and audiometric findings at 3 months post-operatively. There was no statistically significant inter-group difference in 3-week clinician and patient cumulative scores for ear signs and symptoms. There was also no significant difference in graft take rate, appearance of ear canals and audiometric results in either group at 3 months. No difference in ear symptoms, clinician findings or hearing was demonstrated between patients with a post-operative pack compared to those without a pack following middle ear surgery in this pilot study.

Bismuth iodoform paraffin paste hypersensitivity reactions in mastoid cavities following isolation of mucosal lining: a series of 587 patients

AIM

(1) To assess hypersensitivity to bismuth iodoform paraffin paste impregnated ribbon gauze following its use in packing canal wall down mastoidectomy cavities; (2) to determine if isolation of the skin and mucosa from the pack, using thin Silastic sheeting and Cortisporin ointment, reduces hypersensitivity reactions, compared with a previous series; and (3) to review the literature and to determine if bismuth iodoform paraffin paste hypersensitivity precludes the consumption of seafood (due to its high iodine content).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

All patients undergoing canal wall down mastoidectomy with intra-operative bismuth iodoform paraffin paste packing between 1985 and 2009 were identified and reviewed.

RESULTS

Of 587 patients identified, the overall bismuth iodoform paraffin paste reaction rate was 1 per cent. All reactions were in patients undergoing revision mastoidectomy procedures, giving a reaction rate for revision procedures of 2.4 per cent.

CONCLUSION

Reactions are an uncommon event following post-operative mastoid cavity packing using bismuth iodoform paraffin paste. Reaction rates may be lowered by preparing the cavity with Silastic sheeting and Cortisporin ointment prior to packing, thus isolating the skin and mucosal surfaces. Development of such a reaction does not preclude the consumption of seafood.

Toward safer practice in otology: a report on 15 years of clinical negligence claims

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

To determine the characteristics of medical negligence claims arising from otological practice.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective analysis of medical negligence claims contained in the National Health Service Litigation Authority (NHSLA) database.

METHODS

Claims relating to otology and neurotology between 1995 and 2010 were obtained from the NHSLA database and analyzed for cause of injury, type of injury, outcome of claim and costs.

RESULTS

Over 15 years there were 137 claims in otology, representing 26% of all the claims in otolaryngology. Of these, 116 have been closed, and 84% of closed claims resulted in payment. Of the 97 successful claims, 63 were related to operative complications. This included six cases of wrong side/site surgery, and 15 cases of inadequate informed consent. The most common injuries claimed were hearing loss, facial paralysis, and additional/unnecessary surgery. Middle ear ventilation and mastoid surgery were the procedures most commonly associated with a successful claim. There were 15 successful claims of misdiagnosis/delayed diagnosis, with chronic suppurative otitis media the condition most frequently missed. There were nine successful claims related to outpatient procedures, of which seven were for aural toilet and six claims of medical mismanagement, including three cases of ototoxicity from topical medications. There were also four successful claims for morbidity due to delayed surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study to report outcomes of negligence claims in otology. Claims in otology are associated with a high success rate. A significant proportion of claims are not related to surgery and represent areas where safety should also be addressed.

Bismuth iodoform paraffin paste: a review

Introduction:

This article reviews the literature pertaining to bismuth iodoform paraffin paste.

Overview:

Bismuth iodoform paraffin paste is used in most otolaryngology departments on a daily basis. Questions about its properties are common in postgraduate otolaryngology examinations. This article reviews bismuth iodoform paraffin paste's current and historical usage, constituents, properties, side effects, and radiographic properties, and its alternatives in otological and rhinological practice.

Allergic Reaction to Bismuth-lodoform-Paraffin Paste (BIPP) Following Ear Surgery

Bismuth Iodoform Paraffin Paste (BIPP) impregnated ribbon gauze is one of the most commonly used packs after external and middle ear surgery. Allergic reaction to BIPP is rare. We report two cases of hypersensitive BIPP reaction following tympanoplasty surgery. To our knowledge no such cases have been reported previously in Qatar. We reviewed the literature and discuss the management and its prevention.