Sleep in people with and without intellectual disabilities: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Associations between sleep habits and different impulsivity facets in adolescence

BACKGROUND

Sleep patterns change during adolescence due to physiological maturation and psychosocial factors, leading to progressively higher eveningness, sleep deprivation and social jetlag (SJL). These sleep changes are associated with impulsivity, a common behavioral trait in adolescence which can make those with developmental disabilities more vulnerable to behavioral, cognitive and clinical difficulties. However, it is unclear which aspects of sleep and what types of impulsivity are involved.

AIMS

To investigate the relationships between sleep/circadian variables and self-reported impulsivity.

METHODS AND PROCEDURES

Three sleep/circadian variables (time in bed on weekdays, eveningness and SJL) and five dissociable facets of self-reported impulsivity (UPPS-P scale) were answered by 389 healthy 9-17-year-olds (225 girls).

OUTCOMES AND RESULTS

A significant (but small) association between eveningness and a multivariate composed of the five facets of impulsivity (5 % of variance explained) was found and negative urgency was the main driver (4 %) of this relationship.

CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATIONS

Typically developing adolescents with high eveningness traits display slight difficulty controlling their behavior when in a state of negative affect. This finding deserves an in-depth investigation in youth with neurodevelopmental disabilities, who are more prone to presenting sleep/circadian changes, externalizing problems like impulsiveness and internalizing one such as mood alterations.

Challenges in Using Parent-Reported Bed and Wake Times for Actigraphy Scoring in Rett-Related Syndromes

Sleep problems are common in Rett syndrome and other neurogenetic syndromes. Actigraphy is a cost-effective, objective method for measuring sleep. Current guidelines require caregiver-reported bed and wake times to facilitate actigraphy data scoring. The current study examined missingness and consistency of caregiver-reported bed and wake times from paper sleep diaries and actigraphy event mark button presses in a sample of 38 individuals with Rett and related syndromes (aged 2-36 years, mean = 13.1) across two 14-day collection time points. Rates of missingness and discrepancy between the 2 sources were relatively high and correlated with clinical severity and quality of life. Overall, the results suggest a need for alternative actigraphy scoring methods that do not rely on caregiver report in this population.

Sleep-disordered breathing in children and adults with intellectual disability: mind the gap!

BACKGROUND

In adults and children with intellectual disability (ID), sleep -disordered breathing (SDB) is thought to be common. However, large epidemiological studies are lacking, and there are few studies on optimal methods of investigation and even fewer randomised, controlled intervention trials of treatment.

METHOD

Peer-reviewed publications from various databases were examined in line with search terms relevant to ID and SDB spanning the years 200-2024.

RESULTS

Findings suggest that, due to comorbid conditions, children and adults with ID may experience both an increased risk of SDB, as well as lower frequency of diagnosis. SDB can compromise the emotional, physical and mental health of individuals with ID. Appropriate treatment when tolerated leads to an improvement in health and well-being and several studies emphasized the importance of consistent follow-up of people with ID - something that is not universally occurring during childhood, in the transition to adulthood and during adulthood itself. As the most frequently occurring form of ID worldwide, we use Down syndrome as a specific example of how diagnosing and treating SDB can lead to improved outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

This review highlights the importance of identifying SDB in this heterogenous population, recognising the multi-faceted, deleterious consequences of untreated SDB in people with ID, and presents some strategies that can be harnessed to improve diagnosis and management. Until further ID-specific research is available, we urge flexibility in the approach to people with ID and SDB based in guidelines and standard practice developed for the typically developing population.

Sleep Disorders in Adults with Intellectual Disability: Current Status and Future Directions

Purpose of Review

We performed a narrative review of the current knowledge in epidemiology, mechanisms, clinical presentation, and treatment of sleep disorders in adults with intellectual disability.

Recent Findings

Adults with Intellectual disability face significant mental and physical health disparities, including in sleep medicine. Despite sleep disorders having been identified as adversely affecting the health and quality of life of both adults with intellectual disabilities and their caregivers, the evidence base for assessment, diagnosis and treatment in this population remains under developed when compared to that of the general population. This review summarises the existing literature on insomnia, sleep disordered breathing, and other common sleep disorders in adults with intellectual disability. Emphasising the existing gaps in our understanding of sleep disorders in adults with intellectual disabilities, we propose strategies to address and mitigate these gaps.

Summary

Sleep disorders are common, yet frequently ignored in adults with intellectual disabilities. To address sleep health inequality gaps, future research should adopt tailored approaches, considering the heterogeneity within the intellectual disability population, including stratification by aetiology and health comorbidities. This is essential to improve the diagnostic accuracy and treatment of sleep disorders in adults with intellectual disability.

Long-term effects of environmental dynamic lighting on sleep-wake rhythm, mood and behaviour in older adults with intellectual disabilities

BACKGROUND

Sleep-wake problems and depressive symptoms are common in people with intellectual disabilities (IDs) and are thought to be related to the unstable sleep-wake rhythm in this population. Previously, we showed that after increasing environmental light exposure, mid-sleep and sleep onset advanced, and mood improved over a period of 14 weeks after installing environmental dynamic light installations in the living room of people with IDs. We invited participants of that short-term study to take part in the current study on sleep-wake rhythm, mood and behaviour in older adults with IDs 1 year after installing environmental dynamic light installations in the common living rooms of six group homes.

METHODS

A pre-post study was performed from October 2017 to February 2019. We included 45 participants (63.5 ± 8.5 years, 67% female) from six group home facilities who provided data at baseline (9, 4 and 1 weeks prior to installing light installations), short term (3, 7 and 14 weeks after installing light installations) and 1 year (54 weeks after installing light installations). Wrist activity was measured with actigraphy (GENEActiv) to derive the primary outcome of interdaily stability of sleep-wake rhythms as well as sleep estimates. Mood was measured with the Anxiety, Depression and Mood Scale. Behaviour was measured with the Aberrant Behaviour Checklist.

RESULTS

One year after installing dynamic lighting, we did not find a change in interdaily stability. Total sleep time decreased (β = -25.40 min; confidence interval: -10.99, -39.82), and sleep onset time was delayed (β = 25.63 min; confidence interval: 11.18, 40.08). No effect on mood or behaviour was found.

CONCLUSIONS

We did not find a change in sleep-wake rhythm, mood or behaviour in older persons with IDs living in care facilities 1 year after installing the light. We did find evidence for a long-term effect on sleep duration and sleep timing. The results have to be interpreted with care as the current study had a limited number of participants. The need for more research on the long-term effects of enhancing environmental light in ID settings is evident.