The comparative in vitro killing activity of tea tree oil versus permethrin on Demodex folliculorum of rosacea patients

In Vitro Lethal Effects of Benzyl Benzoate Concentrations of 25%, 10%, and 5% on Demodex folliculorum Mites: An Experimental Study With a Control Group

BACKGROUND

Demodex mites have been implicated in the pathogenesis of many dermatologic diseases, especially rosacea. Although many case reports have been published about the treatment of skin diseases caused by Demodex folliculorum mite, no relevant treatment algorithm has been developed so far. In this context, we investigated the lethal effects of different doses of benzyl benzoate on this mite.

OBJECTIVE

To compare the lethal effects of 3 different doses of benzyl benzoate on Demodex folliculorum mites with those of a control group consisting of immersion oil.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Waste samples collected from rosacea patients were included in the study. Four different groups of 20 mites were formed. Each group was exposed to 5%, 10%, and 25% concentrations of benzyl benzoate, respectively. Immersion oil was used as a negative control group. The movements of the mites were monitored with a digital microscope. The time to death of the mites was recorded.

RESULTS

The mean time to death of mites was 26 ± 2,9, 120 ± 7.6, and 168 ± 15 min after application of benzyl benzoate at concentrations of 25%, 10%, and 5%, respectively. The mean time to death of mites in immersion oil applied as a negative control group was 192 ± 6.4 min. Among the study groups, only the 25% benzyl benzoate group had a statistically significantly shorter mean time to death compared to the control group (p = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

While low concentrations of benzyl benzoate were ineffective in the treatment of demodicosis, benzyl benzoate at high concentrations, e.g., 25%, was found to be effective in its treatment.

Investigation of the in-vitro lethal effect of spilanthol on demodex and finding the most effective dose

Demodex species are associated with many dermatological diseases, so an acaricidal agent that is effective against them and safe for skin applications may benefit many diseases. This study aims to investigate the anti-demodex potential of spilanthol, a product obtained from the Spilanthes Acmella plant, by determining the minimal effective dose for the first time in the literature. Demodex mites were obtained from 70 patients with standard superficial skin biopsy. Spilanthol extract was used at 1%, 2%, 3%, 4%, and 5%. Standard immersion oil was used for the negative control, and permethrin 5% was used for the positive control group. The dependent variable is the survival time of the mite. Comparisons with the negative control group, the anti-demodex effect demonstrated itself in all groups, creating a statistically significant difference (p < 0.001). The positive control group, had 3%, 4%, and 5% spilanthol rates which were very similar to the results with 5% permethrin (p > 0.05). Higher concentrations than 3% did not make any additional contribution to survival times. This is the first attempt to show the dose-dependent acaricidal effect of spilanthol on demodex mites. Even the 3% dose shows similar results to 5% permethrin, and no additional effect increase was observed at higher doses. Therefore, in vivo, studies may be planned with a 3% spilanthol dose for further studies.

Comparison of in vitro Killing Effect of Thai Herbal Essential Oils, Tea Tree Oil, and Metronidazole 0.75% versus Ivermectin 1% on Demodex folliculorum

Background

Abnormal proliferation of Demodex mites causes a skin disorder called demodicosis and has been linked to rosacea. The development of alternative therapy against Demodex mites is currently required. The ability to kill Demodex mites of Thai herbal essential oils has never been explored. This study aimed to study and compare the in vitro killing effect of Thai herbal essential oils, tea tree oil, and metronidazole 0.75% with ivermectin 1% on D. folliculorum.

Materials and Methods

D. folliculorum mites were collected from the wastes of diagnostic standardized skin surface biopsy samples of demodicosis and rosacea patients for the trial. The microscopic evaluation started immediately after the mites were exposed to immersion oil (negative control), Thai herbal essential oils, tea tree oil, metronidazole 0.75%, and ivermectin 1% (positive control). The survival times of ten mites from each test agent were compared.

Results

The efficacy of Thai herbal essential oils and other test agents can be arranged in order as follows: lemongrass oil > sweet basil oil > clove oil > tea tree oil > lesser galangal oil > ginger oil, kaffir lime oil, peppermint oil > citronella oil > galangal oil > cajeput oil > ivermectin 1% > metronidazole 0.75%.

Conclusion

This current study demonstrated the in vitro killing efficacy on D. folliculorum: Thai herbal essential oils, Tea tree oil > ivermectin 1% > metronidazole 0.75%. Thai herbal essential oils have the potential to be an adjuvant or alternative therapy against Demodex mites. Further in vivo studies are necessary to determine the treatment efficacy and side effects.

Antiparasitic Activity of Tea Tree Oil (TTO) and Its Components against Medically Important Ectoparasites: A Systematic Review

Ectoparasites are pathogens that can infect the skin and cause immense pain, discomfort, and disease. They are typically managed with insecticides. However, the fast-emerging antimicrobial resistance and the slow rate of development of new bio-actives combined with environmental and health concerns over the continued use of neurotoxic insecticides warrant newer and alternative methods of control. Tea tree oil (TTO), as an alternative agent, has shown remarkable promise against ectoparasites in recent studies. To our knowledge, this is the first systematic review to assess preclinical and clinical studies exploring the antiparasitic activity of TTO and its components against clinically significant ectoparasites, such as Demodex mites, scabies mites, house dust mites, lice, fleas, chiggers, and bed bugs. We systematically searched databases, including PubMed, MEDLINE (EBSCOhost), Embase (Scopus), CENTRAL, Cochrane Library, CINAHL, ScienceDirect, Web of Science, SciELO, and LILACS in any language from inception to 4 April 2022. Studies exploring the therapeutic activity of TTO and its components against the ectoparasites were eligible. We used the ToxRTool (Toxicological data reliability assessment) tool, the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) critical appraisal tools, and the Jadad scale to assess the methodological qualities of preclinical (in vitro and in vivo) studies, non-randomised controlled trials (including cohort, case series, and case studies), and randomised controlled trials, respectively. Of 497 identified records, 71 studies were included in this systematic review, and most (66%) had high methodological quality. The findings of this review revealed the promising efficacy of TTO and its components against ectoparasites of medical importance. Most importantly, the compelling in vitro activity of TTO against ectoparasites noted in this review seems to have translated well into the clinical environment. The promising outcomes observed in clinical studies provide enough evidence to justify the use of TTO in the pharmacotherapy of ectoparasitic infections.

Comparison of in vitro Killing Effect of N, N-Diethyl-Meta-Toluamide (DEET) versus Permethrin on Demodex folliculorum

Background

There is no single effective treatment for demodicosis; successful treatment requires a multimodal approach. Relapse or recurrence of demodicosis is relatively high, making the therapy challenging. Several reports have documented the successful treatment of demodicosis with acaricidal agents, which aimed at reducing the excessive number of Demodex mites and improving the patients' symptoms. Reports of irritation and resistance to topical acaricidal agents have led to the search for effective alternative treatments.

Materials and Methods

A total of 100 standardized skin surface biopsy (SSSB) biopsy slides from 100 patients with demodicosis were randomly divided into five groups, each with 20 slides exposed to immersion oil, N, N-diethyl-meta-toluamide (DEET) 5%, 10%, 20%, and permethrin 1%, respectively. The microscopic evaluation started immediately after the test agents exposed the mites. The survival time (ST) was defined as the interval between the first exposure of Demodex folliculorum to the test agents to the time the movements ceased.

Results

The differences between the median ST of DEET 5% (44 min), 10% (22 min), and 20% (14 min) were significant when compared to the negative control group (240 min) with p<0.001, <0.001, <0.001, respectively. While the median ST of permethrin 1% (42 min) was not significantly different from the median ST of DEET 5% (p=0.7395).

Conclusion

This study demonstrated the dose-related acaricidal effect of DEET on D. folliculorum. The survival times of DEET 5%, 10%, and 20% were significantly shorter than the negative control (immersion oil). DEET 5% had a comparable in vitro killing effect as permethrin 1%. Further in vivo studies are necessary to determine the clinical efficacy in patients with demodicosis.