The RicAFT (YmcA-YlbF-YaaT) complex carries two [4Fe-4S]2+ clusters and may respond to redox changes

Pleiotropic hubs drive bacterial surface competition through parallel changes in colony composition and expansion

Bacteria commonly adhere to surfaces where they compete for both space and resources. Despite the importance of surface growth, it remains largely elusive how bacteria evolve on surfaces. We previously performed an evolution experiment where we evolved distinct Bacilli populations under a selective regime that favored colony spreading. In just a few weeks, colonies of Bacillus subtilis showed strongly advanced expansion rates, increasing their radius 2.5-fold relative to that of the ancestor. Here, we investigate what drives their rapid evolution by performing a uniquely detailed analysis of the evolutionary changes in colony development. We find mutations in diverse global regulators, RicT, RNAse Y, and LexA, with strikingly similar pleiotropic effects: They lower the rate of sporulation and simultaneously facilitate colony expansion by either reducing extracellular polysaccharide production or by promoting filamentous growth. Combining both high-throughput flow cytometry and gene expression profiling, we show that regulatory mutations lead to highly reproducible and parallel changes in global gene expression, affecting approximately 45% of all genes. This parallelism results from the coordinated manner by which regulators change activity both during colony development-in the transition from vegetative growth to dormancy-and over evolutionary time. This coordinated activity can however also break down, leading to evolutionary divergence. Altogether, we show how global regulators function as major pleiotropic hubs that drive rapid surface adaptation by mediating parallel changes in both colony composition and expansion, thereby massively reshaping gene expression.

Formation of a stable RNase Y-RicT (YaaT) complex requires RicA (YmcA) and RicF (YlbF)

In Bacillus subtilis, the RicT (YaaT), RicA (YmcA), and RicF (YlbF) proteins, which form a stable ternary complex, are needed together with RNase Y (Rny) to cleave and thereby stabilize several key transcripts encoding enzymes of intermediary metabolism. We show here that RicT, but not RicA or RicF, forms a stable complex with Rny and that this association requires the presence of RicA and RicF. We propose that RicT is handed off from the ternary complex to Rny. We show further that the two iron-sulfur clusters carried by the ternary Ric complex are required for the formation of the stable RicT-Rny complex. We demonstrate that proteins of the degradosome-like network of B. subtilis, which also interact with Rny, are dispensable for processing of the gapA operon. Thus, Rny participates in distinct RNA-related processes, determined by its binding partners, and a RicT-Rny complex is likely the functional entity for gapA mRNA maturation. IMPORTANCE The action of nucleases on RNA is universal and essential for all forms of life and includes processing steps that lead to the mature and functional forms of certain transcripts. In Bacillus subtilis, it has been shown that key transcripts for energy-producing steps of glycolysis, for nitrogen assimilation, and for oxidative phosphorylation, all of them crucial processes of intermediary metabolism, are cleaved at specific locations, resulting in mRNA stabilization. The proteins required for these cleavages in B. subtilis [Rny (RNase Y), RicA (YmcA), RicF (YlbF), and RicT (YaaT)] are broadly conserved among the firmicutes, including several important pathogens, hinting that regulatory mechanisms they control may also be conserved. Several aspects of these regulatory events have been explored: phenotypes associated with the absence of these proteins have been described, the impact of these absences on the transcriptome has been documented, and there has been significant exploration of the biochemistry and structural biology of Rny and the Ric proteins. The present study further advances our understanding of the association of Ric proteins and Rny and shows that a complex of Rny with RicT is probably the entity that carries out mRNA maturation.

Formation of a stable RNase Y-RicT (YaaT) complex requires RicA (YmcA) and RicF (YlbF)

In Bacillus subtilis , the RicT (YaaT), RicA (YmcA) and RicF (YlbF) proteins, which form a stable ternary complex, are needed together with RNase Y (Rny), to cleave and thereby stabilize several key transcripts encoding enzymes of intermediary metabolism. We show here that RicT, but not RicA or RicF, forms a stable complex with Rny, and that this association requires the presence of RicA and RicF. We propose that RicT is handed off from the ternary complex to Rny. We show further that the two iron-sulfur clusters carried by the ternary Ric complex are required for the formation of the stable RicT-Rny complex. We demonstrate that proteins of the degradosome-like network of B. subtilis , which also interact with Rny, are dispensable for processing of the gapA operon. Thus, Rny participates in distinct RNA-related processes, determined by its binding partners, and a RicT-Rny complex is likely the functional entity for gapA mRNA maturation.

IMPORTANCE

The action of nucleases on RNA is universal and essential for all forms of life and includes processing steps that lead to the mature and functional forms of certain transcripts. In B. subtilis it has been shown that key transcripts for energy producing steps of glycolysis, for nitrogen assimilation and for oxidative phosphorylation, all of them crucial processes of intermediary metabolism, are cleaved at specific locations, resulting in mRNA stabilization. The proteins required for these cleavages in B. subtilis (Rny (RNase Y), RicA (YmcA), RicF (YlbF) and RicT (YaaT)) are broadly conserved among the firmicutes, including in several important pathogens, hinting that regulatory mechanisms they control may also be conserved. Several aspects of these regulatory events have been explored: phenotypes associated with the absence of these proteins have been described, the impact of these absences on the transcriptome has been documented, and there has been significant exploration of the biochemistry and structural biology of Rny and the Ric proteins. The present study further advances our understanding of the association of Ric proteins and Rny and shows that a complex of Rny with RicT is probably the entity that carries out mRNA maturation.

Y-Complex Proteins Show RNA-Dependent Binding Events at the Cell Membrane and Distinct Single-Molecule Dynamics

Bacteria are dependent on rapid alterations in gene expression. A prerequisite for rapid adaptations is efficient RNA turnover, with endonuclease RNase Y playing a crucial role in mRNA stability as well as in maturation. In Bacillus subtilis, RNase Y in turn interacts with the so-called “Y-complex” consisting of three proteins, which play important functions in sporulation, natural transformation and biofilm formation. It is thought that the Y-complex acts as an accessory factor in RNase Y regulation but might also have independent functions. Using single-molecule tracking, we show that all three Y-complex proteins exhibit three distinct mobilities, including movement through the cytosol and confined motion, predominantly at membrane-proximal sites but also within the cell center. A transcriptional arrest leads to a strong change in localization and dynamics of YmcA, YlbF and YaaT, supporting their involvement in global RNA degradation. However, Y-complex proteins show distinguishable protein dynamics, and the deletion of yaaT or ylbF shows a minor effect on the dynamics of YmcA. Cell fractionation reveals that YaaT displays a mixture of membrane association and presence in the cytosol, while YlbF and YmcA do not show direct membrane attachment. Taken together, our experiments reveal membrane-associated and membrane-independent activities of Y-complex proteins and a dynamic interplay between them with indirect membrane association of YmcA and YlbF via YaaT.

Heme A Synthase Deficiency Affects the Ability of Bacillus cereus to Adapt to a Nutrient-Limited Environment

The branched aerobic respiratory chain in Bacillus cereus comprises three terminal oxidases: cytochromes aa3, caa3, and bd. Cytochrome caa3 requires heme A for activity, which is produced from heme O by heme A synthase (CtaA). In this study, we deleted the ctaA gene in B. cereus AH187 strain, this deletion resulted in loss of cytochrome caa3 activity. Proteomics data indicated that B. cereus grown in glucose-containing medium compensates for the loss of cytochrome caa3 activity by remodeling its respiratory metabolism. This remodeling involves up-regulation of cytochrome aa3 and several proteins involved in redox stress response—to circumvent sub-optimal respiratory metabolism. CtaA deletion changed the surface-composition of B. cereus, affecting its motility, autoaggregation phenotype, and the kinetics of biofilm formation. Strikingly, proteome remodeling made the ctaA mutant more resistant to cold and exogenous oxidative stresses compared to its parent strain. Consequently, we hypothesized that ctaA inactivation could improve B. cereus fitness in a nutrient-limited environment.

Role of Glutamate Synthase in Biofilm Formation by Bacillus subtilis

Bacillus subtilis forms robust biofilms in the presence of large amounts of carbon sources, such as glycerol. However, little is known about the importance of the metabolic systems, or the relationship between metabolic systems and regulatory systems, involved in biofilm formation. Glutamate synthase, encoded by gltAB, is an enzyme that converts 2-ketoglutarate (a tricarboxylic acid [TCA] cycle intermediate) and glutamine into glutamate, which is a general amino group donor in metabolism. Here, we show that a ΔgltA mutant exhibited early arrest of biofilm formation in complex medium containing glycerol. This phenotype was not due to glutamate auxotrophy. Consistent with its biofilm formation phenotype, the ΔgltA mutant exhibited an early decrease in expression of the epsA and tapA operons, which are responsible for production of biofilm matrix polymers. This resulted from decreased activity of their regulator, Spo0A, as evidenced by reduced expression of other Spo0A-regulated genes in the ΔgltA mutant. The ΔgltA mutation prevented biofilm formation only in the presence of large amounts of glycerol. Moreover, limited expression of citrate synthase (but not other TCA enzymes) restored biofilm-forming ability to the ΔgltA mutant. These results indicate that the ΔgltA mutant accumulates an inhibitory intermediate (citrate) in the TCA cycle in the presence of large amounts of glycerol. The ΔgltA mutant formed biofilms when excess iron was added to the medium. Taken together, the data suggest that accumulation of citrate ions by the ΔgltA mutant causes iron shortage due to chelation, which prevents activation of Spo0A and causes defective biofilm formation.IMPORTANCE Bacillus subtilis, a model organism for bacterial biofilm formation, forms robust biofilms in a medium-dependent manner. Although the regulatory network that controls biofilm formation has been well studied, the importance of the underlying metabolic systems remains to be elucidated. The present study demonstrates that a metabolic disorder in a well-conserved metabolic system causes accumulation of an inhibitory metabolic intermediate that prevents activation of the system that regulates biofilm formation. These findings increase our understanding of the coordination between cellular metabolic status and the regulatory networks governing biofilm formation.

Dynamic Membrane Localization of RNase Y in Bacillus subtilis

All living organisms must degrade mRNA to adapt gene expression to changing environments. In bacteria, initiation of mRNA decay generally occurs through an endonucleolytic cleavage. In the Gram-positive model organism Bacillus subtilis and probably many other bacteria, the key enzyme for this task is RNase Y, which is anchored at the inner cell membrane. While this pseudocompartmentalization appears coherent with translation occurring primarily at the cell periphery, our knowledge on the distribution and dynamics of RNase Y in living cells is very scarce. Here, we show that RNase Y moves rapidly along the membrane in the form of dynamic short-lived foci. These foci become more abundant and increase in size following transcription arrest, suggesting that they do not constitute the most active form of the nuclease. This contrasts with RNase E, the major decay-initiating RNase in E. coli, where it was shown that formation of foci is dependent on the presence of RNA substrates. We also show that a protein complex (Y-complex) known to influence the specificity of RNase Y activity in vivo is capable of shifting the assembly status of RNase Y toward fewer and smaller complexes. This highlights fundamental differences between RNase E- and RNase Y-based degradation machineries.

Metabolic turnover of mRNA is fundamental to the control of gene expression in all organisms, notably in fast-adapting prokaryotes. In many bacteria, RNase Y initiates global mRNA decay via an endonucleolytic cleavage, as shown in the Gram-positive model organism Bacillus subtilis. This enzyme is tethered to the inner cell membrane, a pseudocompartmentalization coherent with its task of initiating mRNA cleavage/maturation of mRNAs that are translated at the cell periphery. Here, we used total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (TIRFm) and single-particle tracking (SPT) to visualize RNase Y and analyze its distribution and dynamics in living cells. We find that RNase Y diffuses rapidly at the membrane in the form of dynamic short-lived foci. Unlike RNase E, the major decay-initiating RNase in Escherichia coli, the formation of foci is not dependent on the presence of RNA substrates. On the contrary, RNase Y foci become more abundant and increase in size following transcription arrest, suggesting that they do not constitute the most active form of the nuclease. The Y-complex of three proteins (YaaT, YlbF, and YmcA) has previously been shown to play an important role for RNase Y activity in vivo. We demonstrate that Y-complex mutations have an effect similar to but much stronger than that of depletion of RNA in increasing the number and size of RNase Y foci at the membrane. Our data suggest that the Y-complex shifts the assembly status of RNase Y toward fewer and smaller complexes, thereby increasing cleavage efficiency of complex substrates like polycistronic mRNAs.

Structure-Function Studies of the Bacillus subtilis Ric Proteins Identify the Fe-S Cluster-Ligating Residues and Their Roles in Development and RNA Processing

In Bacillus subtilis, the RicA (YmcA), RicF (YlbF), and RicT (YaaT) proteins accelerate the phosphorylation of the transcription factor Spo0A, contributing to genetic competence, sporulation, and biofilm formation, and are also essential for the correct maturation of several protein-encoding and riboswitch RNAs. These proteins form a stable complex (RicAFT) that carries two [4Fe-4S]+2 clusters. We show here that the complex is a 1:1:1 heterotrimer, and we present the X-ray crystal structures of a RicAF heterotetramer and of a RicA dimer. We also demonstrate that one of the Fe-S clusters (cluster 1) is ligated by cysteine residues donated exclusively by RicT and can be retained when the RicT monomer is purified by itself. Cluster 2 is ligated by C167 from RicT, by C134 and C146 located near the C terminus of RicF, and by C141 at the C terminus of RicA. These findings imply the following novel arrangement: adjacent RicT residues C166 and 167 ligate clusters 1 and 2, respectively, while cluster 2 is ligated by cysteine residues from RicT, RicA, and RicF. Thus, the two clusters must lie close to one another and at the interface of the RicAFT protomers. We also show that the cluster-ligating cysteine residues, and therefore most likely both Fe-S clusters, are essential for cggR-gapA mRNA maturation, for the regulation of ricF transcript stability, and for several Ric-associated developmental phenotypes, including competence for transformation, biofilm formation, and sporulation. Finally, we present evidence that RicAFT, RicAF, and RicA and the RicT monomer may play distinct regulatory roles in vivoIMPORTANCE The RicA, RicF, and RicT proteins are widely conserved among the firmicute bacteria and play multiple roles in Bacillus subtilis Among the phenotypes associated with the inactivation of these proteins are the inability to be genetically transformed or to form biofilms, a decrease in sporulation frequency, and changes in the stability and maturation of multiple RNA species. Despite their importance, the molecular mechanisms of Ric protein activities have not been elucidated and the roles of the two iron-sulfur clusters on the complex of the three proteins are not understood. To unravel the mechanisms of Ric action, molecular characterization of the complex and of its constituent proteins is essential. This report represents a major step toward understanding the structures of the Ric proteins, the arrangement and roles of the Fe-S clusters, and the phenotypes associated with Ric mutations.

Protein lysine acetylation plays a regulatory role in Bacillus subtilis multicellularity

Protein lysine acetylation is a post-translational modification that alters the charge, conformation, and stability of proteins. A number of genome-wide characterizations of lysine-acetylated proteins, or acetylomes, in bacteria have demonstrated that lysine acetylation occurs on proteins with a wide diversity of functions, including central metabolism, transcription, chemotaxis, and cell size regulation. Bacillus subtilis is a model organism for studies of sporulation, motility, cell signaling, and multicellular development (or biofilm formation). In this work, we investigated the role of global protein lysine acetylation in multicellular development in B. subtilis. We analyzed the B. subtilis acetylome under biofilm-inducing conditions and identified acetylated proteins involved in multicellularity, specifically, swarming and biofilm formation. We constructed various single and double mutants of genes known to encode enzymes involved in global protein lysine acetylation in B. subtilis. Some of those mutants showed a defect in swarming motility while others demonstrated altered biofilm phenotypes. Lastly, we picked two acetylated proteins known to be important for biofilm formation, YmcA (also known as RicA), a regulatory protein critical for biofilm induction, and GtaB, an UTP-glucose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase that synthesizes a nucleotide sugar precursor for biosynthesis of exopolysaccharide, a key biofilm matrix component. We performed site-directed mutagenesis on the acetylated lysine codons in ymcA and gtaB, respectively, and assayed cells bearing those point mutants for biofilm formation. The mutant alleles of ymcA(K64R), gtaB(K89R), and gtaB(K191R) all demonstrated a severe biofilm defect. These results indicate the importance of acetylated lysine residues in both YmcA and GtaB. In summary, we propose that protein lysine acetylation plays a global regulatory role in B. subtilis multicellularity.

Maturation of polycistronic mRNAs by the endoribonuclease RNase Y and its associated Y-complex in Bacillus subtilis

Endonucleolytic cleavage within polycistronic mRNAs can lead to differential stability, and thus discordant abundance, among cotranscribed genes. RNase Y, the major endonuclease for mRNA decay in Bacillus subtilis, was originally identified for its cleavage activity toward the cggR-gapA operon, an event that differentiates the synthesis of a glycolytic enzyme from its transcriptional regulator. A three-protein Y-complex (YlbF, YmcA, and YaaT) was recently identified as also being required for this cleavage in vivo, raising the possibility that it is an accessory factor acting to regulate RNase Y. However, whether the Y-complex is broadly required for RNase Y activity is unknown. Here, we used end-enrichment RNA sequencing (Rend-seq) to globally identify operon mRNAs that undergo maturation posttranscriptionally by RNase Y and the Y-complex. We found that the Y-complex is required for the majority of RNase Y-mediated mRNA maturation events and also affects riboswitch abundance in B. subtilis In contrast, noncoding RNA maturation by RNase Y often does not require the Y-complex. Furthermore, deletion of RNase Y has more pleiotropic effects on the transcriptome and cell growth than deletions of the Y-complex. We propose that the Y-complex is a specificity factor for RNase Y, with evidence that its role is conserved in Staphylococcus aureus.

ClpC and MecA, components of a proteolytic machine, prevent Spo0A-P-dependent transcription without degradation

In Bacillus subtilis, a proteolytic machine composed of MecA, ClpC and ClpP degrades the transcription factor ComK, controlling its accumulation during growth. MecA also inhibits sporulation and biofilm formation by down-regulating spoIIG and sinI, genes that are dependent for their transcription on the phosphorylated protein Spo0A-P. Additionally, MecA has been shown to interact in vitro with Spo0A. Although the inhibitory effect on transcription requires MecA's binding partner ClpC, inhibition is not accompanied by the degradation of Spo0A, pointing to a previously unsuspected regulatory mechanism involving these proteins. Here, we further investigate the MecA and ClpC effects on Spo0A-P-dependent transcription. We show that MecA inhibits the transcription of several Spo0A-P activated genes, but fails to de-repress several Spo0A-P repressed promoters. This demonstrates that MecA and ClpC do not act by preventing the binding of Spo0A-P to its target promoters. Consistent with this, MecA by itself has no effect in vitro on the transcription from PspoIIG while the addition of both MecA and ClpC has a strong inhibitory effect. A complex of MecA and ClpC likely binds to Spo0A-P on its target promoters, preventing the activation of transcription. Thus, components of a degradative machine have been harnessed to directly repress transcription.