Exercise capacity following pediatric heart transplantation: A systematic review

Utility of the 6-Min Walk Test for Assessing Physical Performance in Pediatric Heart Transplant Recipients

BACKGROUND

Physical performance capacity (PPC) of pediatric heart transplant (HT) recipients is reportedly low to normal, and longitudinal follow-up of these patients is recommended. However, no recommendation for a follow-up method is available. In this study, the correlation between the 6-min walk test (6MWT), various clinical parameters, and a physical performance test set was evaluated to develop a simple follow-up tool for PPC.

METHODS

Fifteen pediatric HT patients and 392 historical controls were tested at a median age of 15.4 years. PPC was tested with a 6MWT and a physical performance test set consisting of six different components assessing muscle endurance, strength, speed, and flexibility.

RESULTS

Controls outperformed recipients across all test domains except the leg lift and sit-and-reach test. The 6MWT distance correlated well with the physical performance test set results; the correlations were with leg lift (rs = 0.622, p = <0.05), repeated squatting (rs = 0.851, p = <0.001, sit-up (rs = 0.738, p = <0.05), back extension (rs = 0.747, p ≤ 0.001), and total physical performance capacity (rs = 0.873, p = <0.001). Indexed 6MWT results or total physical performance capacity set had no statistically significant associations with any of the clinical parameters tested.

CONCLUSION

Our study supports recent findings suggesting that the 6MWT is a suitable method for longitudinal follow-up in children with HT. We recommend performing the 6MWT annually in these patients, to be used to motivate and encourage them to enhance their physical activity.

Chronotropic Response to Exercise is Decreased in Patients With Congenital Heart Disease Compared to Cardiomyopathy Following Pediatric Heart Transplantation

BACKGROUND

Two common indications for pediatric heart transplantation are congenital heart disease and cardiomyopathy. Prior studies suggest differences in chronotropy on cardiopulmonary exercise testing outcomes depending on indication for heart transplantation. We aimed to determine whether the number of pretransplant sternotomies is associated with differences in heart rate response during exercise testing.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of our institutional pediatric heart transplant data between 2004 and 2022 was performed. Patients were categorized by indication for transplantation into a cardiomyopathy (CM) group if they had a congenital or acquired cardiomyopathy or a congenital heart disease (CHD) group including all other forms of congenital cardiac anatomic abnormalities.

RESULTS

CHD patients (n = 40) differed from CM patients (n = 53) by mean number of sternotomies prior to transplant (2.4 ± 1.8 vs. 0.5 ± 0.9, p < 0.001). There were no significant differences in echocardiographic function or catheterization hemodynamics. In cardiopulmonary exercise testing performance, the congenital heart disease group had a significantly higher resting heart rate (91.8 ± 11.2 vs. 86.4 ± 10.2 bpm, p = 0.019), lower percent predicted age-predicted maximal heart rate achieved (78.3 ± 8.5% vs. 83.2 ± 11.4%, p = 0.032), and lower heart rate reserve (68.6 ± 19.8 vs. 84.4 ± 24.0 bpm, p = 0.001) despite a similar age and average time from transplantation. Regression analysis confirmed number of pretransplant sternotomies as a main predictor of heart rate metrics.

CONCLUSIONS

There is greater chronotropic incompetence in patients who underwent transplantation due to congenital heart disease compared to cardiomyopathy. The groups differ significantly by number of sternotomies, potentially supporting the hypothesis that prior surgical disruption of cardiac innervation may cause decreased chronotropic response to exercise following transplantation.

Brazilian Guideline for Exercise Testing in Children and Adolescents - 2024

CLASSES OF RECOMMENDATION

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

Effect of body mass index on exercise capacity following pediatric heart transplantation

BACKGROUND

Obesity and impaired exercise tolerance following heart transplantation increase the risk of post-transplant morbidity and mortality. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of body mass index on markers of exercise capacity in pediatric heart transplant recipients and compare this effect with a healthy pediatric cohort.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of cardiopulmonary exercise test data between 2004 and 2022 was performed. All patients exercised on a treadmill using the Bruce protocol. Inclusion criteria included patients aged 6-21 years, history of heart transplantation (transplant cohort) or no cardiac diagnosis (control cohort) at the time of testing, and a maximal effort test. Patients were further stratified within these two cohorts as underweight, normal, overweight, and obese based on body mass index groups. Two-way analyses of variance were performed with diagnosis and body mass index category as the independent variables.

RESULTS

A total of 250 exercise tests following heart transplant and 1963 exercise tests of healthy patients were included. Heart transplant patients across all body mass index groups had higher resting heart rate and lower maximal heart rate, heart rate recovery at 1 min, exercise duration, and peak aerobic capacity (VO2peak). Heart transplant patients in the normal and overweight body mass index categories had higher VO2peak and exercise duration when compared to underweight and obese patients.

CONCLUSION

Underweight status and obesity are strongly associated with lower VO2peak and exercise duration in heart transplant patients. Normal and overweight heart transplant patients had the best markers of exercise capacity.

Age-specific determinants of reduced exercise capacity in youth after heart transplant: A longitudinal cohort study

Background

Although prior studies show that children have impaired exercise capacity after heart transplant, the age-specific determinants of this phenomenon are not well understood. We examine exercise capacity and its associations in school-age and adolescent youth post-heart transplant.

Methods

This retrospective cohort study of heart transplant patients who completed a cardiopulmonary exercise test between 1999 and 2018 includes 332 tests on 104 patients younger than 18 years. Tests were stratified into those by school-aged children (5-11 years old) and adolescents (12-17). The primary outcome was peak oxygen consumption; secondary outcomes were anaerobic threshold and peak power production. Potential determinants included age at transplant, diagnosis, and laboratory and invasive hemodynamic measurements.

Results

All exercise capacity outcomes for patients post-transplant regardless of age were significantly reduced compared to the predicted performance of age and sex-matched controls. Percent predicted median peak oxygen consumption (62.63, 95% confidence interval (CI) 59.18, 66.07), anaerobic threshold (66.52, 95%CI 62.24, 70.81), and peak power production (54.00, 95%CI 50.56, 57.44) were reduced. Younger age at transplant and a higher peak heart rate were independently associated with increased peak oxygen consumption across age groups. Elevated wedge pressure and brain natriuretic peptide predicted decreased exercise capacity in adolescents.

Conclusions

Youth after heart transplant have significantly reduced exercise capacity. Younger age at transplant and higher peak heart rate predict increased exercise capacity throughout childhood. Indicators of congestion predict decreased exercise capacity in adolescents. These findings should encourage deeper attention to the relationship between exercise physiology and the social context of children after transplant.

Let's get physical: Aerobic capacity, muscle strength, and muscle endurance after pediatric heart transplantation

BACKGROUND

Pediatric heart (HTx) and kidney transplant (KTx) recipients may have lower physical fitness than healthy children. This study sought to quantify fitness levels in transplant recipients, investigate associations to clinical factors and quality of life, and identify whether a quick, simple wall-sit test is feasible as a surrogate for overall fitness for longitudinal assessment.

METHODS

Aerobic capacity (6-min walk test, 6MWT), normalized muscle strength, muscle endurance, physical activity questionnaire (PAQ), and quality of life (PedsQL™) were prospectively assessed in transplanted children and matched healthy controls.

RESULTS

Twenty-two HTx were compared to 20 controls and 6 KTx. 6MWT %predicted was shorter in HTx (87.2 [69.9-118.6] %) than controls (99.9 [80.4-120] %), but similar to KTx (90.3 [78.6-115] %). Muscle strength was lower in HTx deltoids (6.15 [4.35-11.3] kg/m2) and KTx quadriceps (9.27 [8.65-19.1] kg/m2) versus controls. Similarly, muscle endurance was lower in HTx push-ups (28.6 [0-250] %predicted), KTx push-ups (8.35 [0-150] %predicted), HTx curl-ups (115 [0-450] %predicted), and KTx wall-sit time (18.5 [10.0-54.0] s) than controls. In contrast to HTx with only 9%, all KTx were receiving steroid therapy. The wall-sit test significantly correlated with other fitness parameters (normalized quadriceps strength R = .31, #push-ups R = .39, and #curl-ups R = .43) and PedsQL™ (R = .36).

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to controls, pediatric HTx and KTx have similarly lower aerobic capacity, but different deficits in muscle strength, likely related to steroid therapy in KTx. The convenient wall-sit test correlates with fitness and reported quality of life, and thus could be a useful easy routine for longitudinal assessment.

Endothelium-Derived Dopamine and 6-Nitrodopamine in the Cardiovascular System

The review deals with the release of endothelium-derived dopamine and 6-nitrodopamine (6-ND) and its effects on isolated vascular tissues and isolated hearts. Basal release of both dopamine and 6-ND is present in human isolated umbilical cord vessels, human popliteal vessels, nonhuman primate vessels, and reptilia aortas. The 6-ND basal release was significantly reduced when the tissues were treated with Nω-nitro-l-arginine methyl ester and virtually abolished when the endothelium was mechanically removed. 6-Nitrodopamine is a potent vasodilator, and the mechanism of action responsible for this effect is the antagonism of dopamine D2-like receptors. As a vasodilator, 6-ND constitutes a novel mechanism by which nitric oxide modulates vascular tone. The basal release of 6-ND was substantially decreased in endothelial nitric oxide synthase knockout (eNOS-/-) mice and not altered in neuronal nitric oxide synthase knockout (nNOS-/-) mice, indicating a nonneurogenic source for 6-ND in the heart. Indeed, in rat isolated right atrium, the release of 6-ND was not affected when the atria were treated with tetrodotoxin. In the rat isolated right atrium, 6-ND is the most potent endogenous positive chronotropic agent, and in Langendorff's heart preparation, it is the most potent endogenous positive inotropic agent. The positive chronotropic and inotropic effects of 6-ND are antagonized by β1-adrenoceptor antagonists at concentrations that do not affect the effects induced by noradrenaline, adrenaline, and dopamine, indicating that blockade of the 6-ND receptor is the major modulator of heart chronotropism and inotropism. The review proposes that endothelium-derived catecholamines may constitute a major mechanism for control of vascular tone and heart functions, in contrast to the overrated role attributed to the autonomic nervous system.

Evaluating a Telemedicine Video Game-Linked High-Intensity Interval Training Exercise Programme in Paediatric Heart Transplant Recipients

Paediatric heart transplant recipients (HTRs) have reduced exercise capacity, physical activity (PA), health-related quality of life (HRQoL), and self-efficacy towards PA. Exercise interventions have demonstrated improvements in exercise capacity and functional status in adult HTRs, with a specific emerging interest in the role of high-intensity interval training (HIIT). Studies of exercise interventions in paediatric HTRs have been limited and nonrandomized to date. HIIT has not yet been evaluated in paediatric HTRs. We thus seek to evaluate the safety and feasibility of a randomized crossover trial of a 12-week, home-based, video game-linked HIIT intervention using a cycle ergometer with telemedicine and remote physiological monitoring capabilities (MedBIKE) in paediatric HTRs. The secondary objective is to evaluate the impact of the intervention on (1) exercise capacity, (2) PA, (3) HRQoL and self-efficacy towards PA, and (4) sustained changes in secondary outcomes at 6 and 12 months after intervention. After a baseline assessment of the secondary outcomes, participants will be randomized to receive the MedBIKE intervention (12 weeks, 36 sessions) or usual care. After the intervention and a repeated assessment, all participants will cross over. Follow-up assessments will be administered at 6 and 12 months after the MedBIKE intervention. We anticipate that the MedBIKE intervention will be feasible and safely yield sustained improvements in exercise capacity, PA, HRQoL, and self-efficacy towards PA in paediatric HTRs. This study will serve as the foundation for a larger, multicentre randomized crossover trial and will help inform exercise rehabilitation programmes for paediatric HTRs.

Enhancing a Rehabilitation Pathway for Pediatric Heart Transplant Recipients: An Improvement Project to Increase Adherence, Satisfaction, and Outcomes

AIMS

To refine a cardiac rehabilitation pathway for pediatric heart transplant recipients; assess clinician knowledge and adherence to the program; and evaluate patient outcomes.

METHODS

The center has utilized a rehabilitation pathway for pediatric heart transplant recipients. Challenges in practice include access to centers, lack of data tracing, and adherence to the pathway. The quality initiative focused on program refinements: implementation of text templates to improve data collection, collection of the Pediatric Cardiac Quality of Life Inventory (PCQLI), Functional Independence Measure (WeeFIM) and Child Occupational Self-Assessment (COSA), development of an outreach program, and creation of an educational program for therapists to increase content knowledge and improve clinician satisfaction.

RESULTS

In the evaluation of rehabilitation follow-up post-transplant, there was no statistical significance between the pre- and post-implementation groups. After the implementation of the refined pathway, there was an increase in the completion of the six-minute walk test post-transplant (p = 0.048). Clinicians' responses post educational session noted familiarity with the pathway (88%), documentation (78.8%), and outcome measures (97%). Results of outcomes noted improvement in six-minute walk distances and a decrease in the rate of perceived exertion post-transplant. To ensure future pathway adherence, clinical support should be implemented, and key players identified to maintain sustainability.

Rehabilitation in Pediatric Heart Failure and Heart Transplant

Survival of pediatric patients with heart failure has improved due to medical and surgical advances over the past decades. The complexity of pediatric heart transplant patients has increased as medical and surgical management for patients with congenital heart disease continues to improve. Quality of life in patients with heart failure and transplant might be affected by the impact on functional status that heart failure, heart failure complications or treatment might have. Functional areas affected might be motor, exercise capacity, feeding, speech and/or cognition. The goal of rehabilitation is to enhance and restore functional ability and quality of life to those with physical impairments or disabilities. Some of these rehabilitation interventions such as exercise training have been extensively evaluated in adults with heart failure. Literature in the pediatric population is limited yet promising. The use of additional rehabilitation interventions geared toward specific complications experienced by patients with heart failure or heart transplant are potentially helpful. The use of individualized multidisciplinary rehabilitation program that includes medical management, rehabilitation equipment and the use of physical, occupational, speech and feeding therapies can help improve the quality of life of patients with heart failure and transplant.

Physical activity and its correlates in a pediatric solid-organ transplant population

PA has been shown to have benefits in SOT patients. Studies assessing physical activity levels and its correlates in a pediatric solid-organ transplant population are limited. The aim of this study was to assess PA levels and identify baseline and contemporaneous factors that contribute to PA in a pediatric SOT population. A retrospective cross-sectional review was performed on 58 pediatric transplant patients (16 heart, 29 kidney, and 13 liver transplant). PA was measured by PAQ-C or PAQ-A. Demographics, baseline, and contemporaneous factors were collected. There were no significant differences in baseline and contemporaneous characteristics between heart, kidney, and liver transplant recipients. SOT recipients were 15.2 [12.3-17.3] years old at time of completing the PAQ. Median PAQ score was 2.2 [1.7-2.9]. There were no significant differences in PAQ scores between organ transplant type or between genders. Lower PAQ score was associated with sensory disability (9 vs 49 without disability; P = <.01) and age at time of completing the PAQ (r = -.50, P = <.01). These results suggest that older age at time of completing the PAQ and presence of sensory disability may influence PA levels in the pediatric SOT population.

Effect of high-intensity interval training in young heart transplant recipients: results from two randomized controlled trials

Background

Little is known about the effect of exercise in young heart transplant recipients, and results on group level is lacking. This study summarizes the findings of the youngest participants in two previous randomized controlled trials.

Method

This is a hypothesis-generating study reporting the main results from the youngest participants in two larger randomized controlled trials investigating the effect of high-intensity interval training (HIT). The article summarizes the main results from 28 young participants (< 40 year of age) who have participated in two previous studies which evaluated the effect of HIT vs. controls in adult heart transplant recipients. One of the studies included de novo heart transplant recipients and the other included maintenance heart transplant recipients.All study tests were performed in-hospital, in the specialist health care setting, but the exercise intervention was carried out locally, in cooperation with the primary health care. In both studies the exercise intervention lasted for 9-12 months. In one study, HIT (85-95% of peak effort) was compared to controls (no specific intervention), and in the other study HIT was compared to moderate, continuous exercise (MICT, 60-80% of peak effort). The main outcome measure was peak oxygen uptake (VO_2peak) and a secondary endpoint was muscle strength.

Results

The summarized findings from the youngest heart transplant recipients in these two studies demonstrated mainly that the improvement in peak oxygen uptake among the younger recipients (< 40 years) was much larger (4.7 vs. 1.2 ml/kg/min and 7.0 vs. 2.2 ml/kg/min) compared to the improvement among the older recipients (≥ 40 years), and in accordance with results from adult heart transplant populations: HIT, compared to MICT, induced the largest improvement in peak oxygen consumption, also in the younger heart transplant recipients.

Conclusions

These results suggest that young heart transplant recipients have a greater effect of HIT than of MICT and may also suggest that younger recipients benefit more from high-intensity interval training than their older co-patients. However, larger randomized studies focusing on the young heart transplant population is strongly needed to confirm this hypothesis.

Trial registration

Clinical trial registrations: NCT01796379 and NCT01091194.

Healthy Hearts via Live Videoconferencing: An Exercise and Diet Intervention in Pediatric Heart Transplant Recipients

Background

Pediatric heart transplant recipients have high‐risk cardiovascular profiles that can affect their long‐term outcomes; however, promoting exercise and healthy diet has not been a major focus in the field. The objective of this study was to test the feasibility and impact of a supervised exercise and diet intervention delivered via live videoconferencing in this population.

Methods and Results

Patients 8 to 19 years of age at least 1 year post heart transplantation were enrolled. The 12‐ to 16‐week intervention phase included live video–supervised exercise (×3/week) and nutrition (×1/week) sessions. The 12‐ to 16‐week maintenance phase included ×1/week live video–supervised exercise and nutrition sessions and ×2/week self‐directed exercise sessions. Cardiac, vascular, nutritional, and functional health indices were obtained at baseline, after intervention, and after maintenance. Fourteen patients (median age, 15.2; interquartile range, 14.3–16.7 years) at a median of 3.3 (interquartile range, 1.5–9.7) years after heart transplant completed the intervention. Patients attended 89.6±11% of exercise and 88.4±10% of nutrition sessions during the intervention and 93.4±11% of exercise and 92.3±11% of nutrition sessions during maintenance. After intervention, body mass index percentile (median, −27%; P=0.02), endothelial function (median, +0.29; P=0.04), maximum oxygen consumption (median, +2 mL/kg per minute; P=0.002). Functional Movement Screening total score (median, +2.5; P=0.002) and daily consumption of saturated fat (median, −6 g; P=0.02) improved significantly. After maintenance, improvements in maximum oxygen consumption (median, +3.2 mL/kg per minute; P=0.02) and Functional Movement Screening total score (median, +5; P=0.002) were sustained.

Conclusions

In pediatric heart transplant recipients, a live video–supervised exercise and diet intervention is feasible. Our results demonstrate excellent adherence with significant improvements in cardiovascular and functional health.

Clinical Trial Registration

URL: http://www.clinicaltrials.gov. Unique identifier: NCT02519946.

Chronotropic incompetence in paediatric heart transplant recipients with prior congenital heart disease

BACKGROUND

Cardiopulmonary exercise testing has been used to measure functional capacity in children who have undergone a heart transplant. Cardiopulmonary exercise testing results have not been compared between children transplanted for a primary diagnosis of CHD and those with a primary diagnosis of cardiomyopathy despite differences in outcomes. This study is aimed to compare cardiopulmonary exercise testing performance between these two groups.

METHODS

Patients who underwent heart transplant with subsequent cardiopulmonary exercise testing at least 6 months after transplant at our institution were identified. They were then divided into two groups based on primary cardiac diagnosis: CHD or cardiomyopathy. Patient characteristics, echocardiograms, cardiac catheterisations, outcomes, and cardiopulmonary exercise test results were compared between the two groups.

RESULTS

From the total of 35 patients, 15 (43%) had CHD and 20 (57%) had cardiomyopathy. Age at transplant, kidney disease, lung disease, previous rejection, coronary vasculopathy, catheterisation, and echocardiographic data were similar between the groups. Mean time from transplant to cardiopulmonary exercise testing, exercise duration, and maximum oxygen consumption were similar in both groups. There was a difference in heart rate response with CHD heart rate response of 63 beats per minute compared to cardiomyopathy group of 78 (p = 0.028). Patients with CHD had more chronotropic incompetence than those with cardiomyopathy (p = 0.036).

CONCLUSION

Primary diagnosis of CHD is associated with abnormal heart rate response and more chronotropic incompetence compared to those transplanted for cardiomyopathy.