Advanced Ultrasound Techniques for Differentiation of Benign Versus Malignant Thyroid Nodules: A Review

ABSTRACT

Grayscale ultrasound (US) is decisive in stratifying which thyroid nodules benefit from fine-needle aspiration to evaluate for malignancy. Unfortunately, a significant percentage of nodules remain indeterminate.Herein, we review the clinical considerations and diagnostic accuracy of advanced US, Doppler US, contrast-enhanced US, and US elastography techniques in the evaluation of indeterminate nodules.We conclude that these techniques may be used in combination with grayscale US to improve the assessment of lesion vascularity and tissue property.

Reliability of strain elastography using in vivo compression in the assessment of the uterine cervix during pregnancy

Objective To determine the reproducibility of the mean strain value in various cervical areas and new elastographic parameters for measuring cervical stiffness evaluated by strain elastography using in vivo compression generated by internal organ movement. Methods A prospective observational study (140 singleton pregnant women; 15-33 weeks of gestation) was performed at two tertiary centers. Cervical strain was evaluated using E-cervix™ elastography. The mean strain levels of various cervical areas [internal os (IOS), external os (EOS) and endocervical area] and several new parameters [i.e. the ratio of the strain level of IOS and EOS, elasticity contrast index (ECI), and hardness ratio] were assessed twice by two independent examiners. The inter-observer and intra-observer variances were calculated using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) with a 95% confidence interval (CI). Bland-Altman (B-A) analysis was also performed. Results The median gestational age was 24.0 weeks, and the mean cervical length (CL) was 3.8 cm. The intra-observer and inter-observer ICCs of the mean strain levels of the specified cervical area and new elastographic parameters were statistically significant (P < 0.001, all); the intra-observer ICC was 0.639-0.725, and the inter-observer ICC was 0.538-0.718. Conclusion The reproducibility of elastographic parameter measurements using in vivo compression is improvable.

Effect of the location and size of thyroid nodules on the diagnostic performance of ultrasound elastography: A retrospective analysis

OBJECTIVES

Ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration biopsies are recommended for the detection of suspicious thyroid nodules. However, the best approach regarding suspicious ultrasound features for thyroid nodules is still unclear. This study aimed to evaluate the effect of location and size of thyroid nodules on the diagnostic performance of strain ultrasound elastography. In addition, this study evaluated whether ultrasound elastography predicts malignancy in thyroid nodules.

METHODS

Data regarding the size, depth, and distance from the carotid artery of nodules, the elasticity contrast index, and the nature of nodules were analyzed.

RESULTS

There was no significant difference in the depth (p=0.092) and the distance from the carotid artery (p=0.061) between benign and suspicious nodules. Suspicious nodules were smaller than benign nodules (p<0.0001, q=23.84) and had a higher elasticity contrast index (p<0.0001, q=21.05). The depth of nodules and the size of the nodule were not associated with the correct value of the elasticity contrast index (p>0.05 for both). The diagnostic performance of ultrasound elastography was not affected by the distance of the nodules from the carotid artery if they were located ≥15 mm from the carotid artery (p=0.5960). However, if the suspicious nodules were located <15 mm from the carotid artery, the diagnostic accuracy was hampered (p=0.006).

CONCLUSIONS

The strain ultrasound elastography should be carefully evaluated when small thyroid nodules are located near the carotid artery.

The Value of Elasticity Contrast Index in the Differential Diagnosis of Thyroid Solid Nodules

OBJECTIVES

To assess the clinical value of elasticity contrast index (ECI) in differentiating malignant thyroid nodules from benign ones.

METHODS

Conventional ultrasound and elastography with pulsation of the carotid artery used as the compression source were retrospectively reviewed on 175 patients (143 females and 32 males; mean ± SD age, 45.17 ± 11.45 years) with 236 solid nodules (113 malignant and 123 benign). All nodules were confirmed by fine-needle aspiration or surgery to be accurately diagnosed. Elasticity contrast index values were computed and used to quantify local stiffness contrast within a nodule as determined with elastography. Elasticity contrast index values between the malignant and benign groups were compared and then related with pathological results. Diagnostic performance of this method was evaluated with use of the receiver operating characteristic curve.

RESULTS

Mean ± SD ECI values for malignant thyroid nodules were significantly greater than those for benign nodules (3.67 ± 1.20 vs 1.80 ± 0.74, P < 0.01). Area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of ECI values was 0.907 (95% confidence interval, 0.867-0.948), and the best cutoff point was 2.16, leading to a sensitivity of 90.3%, specificity of 82.9%, positive predictive value of 83.7% and negative predictive value of 91.2%.

CONCLUSIONS

Elasticity contrast index values can serve as a useful parameter in the differential diagnosis of solid thyroid nodules. With the use of ECI values, objective quantitative information on the tumor stiffness can be achieved to improve diagnostic confidence.

Comparison of the application of B-mode and strain elastography ultrasound in the estimation of lymph node metastasis of papillary thyroid carcinoma based on a radiomics approach

PURPOSE

B-mode ultrasound (B-US) and strain elastography ultrasound (SE-US) images have a potential to distinguish thyroid tumor with different lymph node (LN) status. The purpose of our study is to investigate whether the application of multi-modality images including B-US and SE-US can improve the discriminability of thyroid tumor with LN metastasis based on a radiomics approach.

METHODS

Ultrasound (US) images including B-US and SE-US images of 75 papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) cases were retrospectively collected. A radiomics approach was developed in this study to estimate LNs status of PTC patients. The approach included image segmentation, quantitative feature extraction, feature selection and classification. Three feature sets were extracted from B-US, SE-US, and multi-modality containing B-US and SE-US. They were used to evaluate the contribution of different modalities. A total of 684 radiomics features have been extracted in our study. We used sparse representation coefficient-based feature selection method with 10-bootstrap to reduce the dimension of feature sets. Support vector machine with leave-one-out cross-validation was used to build the model for estimating LN status.

RESULTS

Using features extracted from both B-US and SE-US, the radiomics-based model produced an area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) [Formula: see text] 0.90, accuracy (ACC) [Formula: see text] 0.85, sensitivity (SENS) [Formula: see text] 0.77 and specificity (SPEC) [Formula: see text] 0.88, which was better than using features extracted from B-US or SE-US separately.

CONCLUSIONS

Multi-modality images provided more information in radiomics study. Combining use of B-US and SE-US could improve the LN metastasis estimation accuracy for PTC patients.

Non-Invasive Identification of Vulnerable Atherosclerotic Plaques Using Texture Analysis in Ultrasound Carotid Elastography: An In Vivo Feasibility Study Validated by Magnetic Resonance Imaging

The aims of this study were to quantify the textural information of strain rate images in ultrasound carotid elastography and evaluate the feasibility of using the textural features in discriminating stable and vulnerable plaques with magnetic resonance imaging as an in vivo reference. Ultrasound radiofrequency data were acquired in 80 carotid plaques from 52 patients, mainly in the longitudinal imaging view, and axial strain rate images were estimated with an ultrasound carotid elastography technique based on an optical flow algorithm. Four textural features of strain rate images-contrast, homogeneity, correlation and angular second moment-were derived based on the gray-level co-occurrence matrix in plaque regions to quantify the deformation distribution pattern. Conventional elastographic indices based on the magnitude of the absolute strain rate, such as the maximum, mean, median, standard deviation and 99th percentile of the axial strain rate, were also obtained for comparison. Composition measurement with magnetic resonance imaging identified 30 plaques as vulnerable and the other 50 as stable. The four textural features, as well as the magnitude of strain rate images, significantly differed between the two groups of plaques. The best performing features for plaque classification were found to be the contrast and 99th percentile of the absolute strain rate, with a comparative area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.81; a slightly higher maximum accuracy of plaque classification can be achieved by the textural feature of contrast (83.8% vs. 81.3%). The results indicate that the use of texture analysis in plaque classification is feasible and that larger local deformations and higher level of complexity in deformation patterns (associated with the elastic or stiffness heterogeneity of plaque tissues) are more likely to occur in vulnerable plaques.

Feasibility Study of Texture Analysis Using Ultrasound Shear Wave Elastography to Predict Malignancy in Thyroid Nodules

Textural analysis of ultrasound shear wave elastography (SWE) was evaluated to discriminate benign and malignant thyroid nodules. Sixteen papillary thyroid cancers and 89 benign hyperplastic nodules in 105 patients underwent SWE using four static pre-compression levels. Fifteen gray level co-occurrence matrix textural features and six absolute SWE indices were computed from SWE images. Diagnostic performances of each SWE index for malignancy were calculated and compared using the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC), and optimal models were generated at each pre-compression level. The optimal model comprised two SWE textural features at the highest pre-compression level, which attained AUC, sensitivity and specificity of 0.973, 97.5% and 90.0%, respectively. By comparison, absolute SWE indices attained AUC of 0.709 as well as 18.8% sensitivity and 95.8% specificity. These preliminary results suggest SWE textural analysis can distinguish benign and malignant thyroid nodules and SWE spatial heterogeneity is greater in malignant nodules.

Thyroid nodule parameters influencing performance of ultrasound elastography using intrinsic compression

The influence of nodule parameters on the diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound (US) elastography in differentiating thyroid nodules was evaluated. One hundred seventy-six nodules (83 benign, 93 malignant) from 156 patients were included. Conventional B-mode and elastography examinations were performed. External compression with a transducer was not applied, as the pulsation from the carotid artery was used. Three nodule parameters (size, depth and distance to the carotid artery) were measured. The elasticity contrast index, in which increases with the stiffness of the nodules, was correlated with distance to the carotid artery (correlation coefficient = 0.283 in all nodules and 0.415 in malignant nodules, p < 0.01 in both groups). The diagnostic accuracy of elastography was significantly associated with a nodule's distance to the carotid artery (p < 0.05). No significant correlation was found between the diagnostic accuracy of elastography and the other parameters. Elastography results for nodules close to the carotid artery should be interpreted with caution.

Elastography can effectively decrease the number of fine-needle aspiration biopsies in patients with calcified thyroid nodules

When calcification, frequently found in both benign and malignant nodules, is present in thyroid nodules, non-invasive differentiation with ultrasound becomes challenging. The goal of this study was to evaluate the utility of elastography in differentiating calcified thyroid nodules. Consecutive patients (165 patients with 196 nodules) referred for fine-needle aspiration who had undergone both ultrasound elastography and B-mode examinations were analyzed retrospectively. Calcification was present in 45 benign and 20 malignant nodules. On 65 calcified nodules, elastography had 95% sensitivity, 51.1% specificity, 46.3% positive predictive value and 95.8% negative predictive value in detecting malignancy. Twenty-three of 45 benign calcified nodules were correctly diagnosed with elastography compared with 4 of 45 by B-mode ultrasound. Although it is difficult to differentiate benign and malignant calcified thyroid nodules solely with B-mode ultrasound, elastography has the potential to reduce the number of fine-needle aspiration biopsies performed on calcified nodules.

Qualitative ultrasound elastography assessment of benign thyroid nodules: Patterns and intra-observer acquisition variability

PURPOSE

To report and evaluate qualitative elastography patterns by using gray-scale and Doppler ultrasound (US) in patients presenting with benign thyroid nodules and to evaluate the reproducibility of US elastography examinations.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Institutional review board approval was obtained, and all patients provided informed consent. Over a 3-month time period, all consecutive adult patients were referred to our institution to undergo a thyroid nodule fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) procedure. Patients presenting with benign cytology according to the Bethesda 2008 classification were prospectively enrolled in the study. Each thyroid nodule was assessed by using gray-scale, Doppler US, and elastography acquisitions by a single operator (A. L.). Multiple elastography acquisitions per thyroid nodule were performed and elastography scorings of the nodules were compared with each other.

RESULTS

Nineteen patients (16 women and 3 men, mean age 58 years) with 22 thyroid nodules were included in the present study. Elastographic patterns 1, 2, and 3 were reported (23% nodules showed pattern 3). The elastography pattern showed a strong variability in 13 nodules (59%). The elastography acquisition result variability involved the "malignant" pattern 3 in 36% of cases.

CONCLUSION

Almost one-third of benign thyroid nodules displayed pattern 3 on qualitative US elastography. The intra-observer variability of the benign thyroid elastography scoring is wide, thus limiting the thyroid nodule US examination accuracy. In FNAB-proven benign thyroid nodules, elastography pattern 3 is frequent and cannot be used as a strong indicator of thyroid malignancy.

Ultrasound elastography in the head and neck. Part I. Basic principles and practical aspects

Ultrasound elastography (USE) is a rapidly developing field of imaging that measures and displays tissue elasticity or stiffness properties using ultrasound. In recent years, real-time USE modes have appeared on commercially available clinical ultrasound machines, stimulating an explosion of research into potential oncologic and non-oncologic clinical applications of USE. Preliminary evidence suggests that USE can differentiate benign and malignant conditions accurately in several different tissues. This article presents an overview of the basic principles of different USE technologies that are currently under investigation in the head and neck region. In addition, more practical aspects pertaining to the optimal performance of USE at this site are discussed.

Ultrasound elastography in the head and neck. Part II. Accuracy for malignancy

Ultrasound elastography (USE) describes a variety of ultrasound-based imaging techniques that measure tissue stiffness properties, and is currently under intense investigation for tissue characterization in several anatomic sites. This article summarizes the evidence regarding the accuracy of USE for malignancy in the head and neck. Currently, most published data pertains to small pilot studies with varied methodologies. Encouragingly, most studies have documented promising results for USE in terms of high accuracy for malignancy in thyroid nodules and cervical lymph nodes, which have surpassed conventional sonographic criteria. However, a minority of studies have documented opposite findings. USE seems to be suboptimal for salivary malignancies, and some evidence suggests that USE does not provide useful diagnostic information compared with conventional ultrasonography for miscellaneous neck masses. Further larger studies are required to validate these findings although, in view of the predominance of highly optimistic results for thyroid nodules and cervical lymph nodes, USE may become a useful ancillary technique in the routine diagnostic work-up of lesions in these tissues in the near future.

Standardized Ultrasound Report for Thyroid Nodules: The Endocrinologist's Viewpoint

BACKGROUND

Ultrasonography (US) plays a crucial role in the diagnostic management of thyroid nodules, but its widespread use in clinical practice might generate heterogeneity in ultrasound reports.

OBJECTIVES

The aims of the study were to propose (a) a standardized lexicon for description of thyroid nodules in order to reduce US reports of interobserver variability and (b) a US classification system of suspicion for thyroid nodules in order to promote a uniform management of thyroid nodules.

METHODS

RELEVANT PUBLISHED ARTICLES WERE IDENTIFIED BY SEARCHING MEDLINE AT PUBMED COMBINING THE FOLLOWING SEARCH TERMS: ultrasonography, thyroid, nodule, malignancy, carcinoma, and classification system. Results were supplemented with our data and experience.

RESULTS

A STANDARDIZED US REPORT SHOULD ALWAYS DOCUMENT POSITION, EXTRACAPSULAR RELATIONSHIPS, NUMBER, AND THE FOLLOWING CHARACTERISTICS OF EACH THYROID LESION: shape, internal content, echogenicity, echotexture, presence of calcifications, margins, vascularity, and size. Combining the previous US features, each thyroid nodule can be tentatively classified as: malignant, suspicious for malignancy, borderline, probably benign, and benign.

CONCLUSIONS

We propose a standardized US report and a tentative US classification system that may become helpful for endocrinologists dealing with thyroid nodules in their clinical practice. The proposed classification does not allow to bypass the required cytological confirmation, but may become useful in identifying the lesions with a lower risk of neoplasm.