Lactate dehydrogenases of Atlantic hagfish: physiological and evolutionary implications of a primitive heart isozyme

Surviving anoxia: the maintenance of energy production and tissue integrity during anoxia and reoxygenation

The development of anoxia within tissues represents a significant challenge to most animals because of the decreased capacity for aerobic ATP production, the associated loss of essential cellular functions and the potential for detrimental tissue oxidation upon reoxygenation. Despite these challenges, there are many animals from multiple phyla that routinely experience anoxia and can fully recover. In this Review, we integrate knowledge gained from studies of anoxia-tolerant species across many animal taxa. We primarily focus on strategies used to reduce energy requirements, minimize the consequences of anaerobic ATP production and reduce the adverse effects of reactive oxygen species, which are responsible for tissue damage with reoxygenation. We aim to identify common strategies, as well as novel solutions, to the challenges of anoxia exposure. This Review chronologically examines the challenges faced by animals as they enter anoxia, as they attempt to maintain physiological function during prolonged anoxic exposure and, finally, as they emerge from anoxia. The capacity of animals to survive anoxia is also considered in relation to the increasing prevalence of anoxic zones within marine and freshwater environments, and the need to understand what limits survival.

Contractile function of the excised hagfish heart during anoxia exposure

Pacific hagfish, Eptatretus stoutii, can recover from 36 h of anoxia and their systemic hearts continue to work throughout the exposure. Recent work demonstrates that glycogen stores are utilized in the E. stoutii heart during anoxia but that these are not sufficient to support the measured rate of ATP production. One metabolic fuel that could supplement glycogen during anoxia is glycerol. This substrate can be derived from lipid stores, stored in the heart, or delivered via the blood. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of glycerol on the contractile function of the excised E. stoutii heart during anoxia exposure. When excised hearts, perfused with metabolite free saline (mf-saline), were exposed to anoxia for 12 h, there was no difference in heart rate, pressure generation (max-dP), rate of contraction (max-dP/dt_sys), or rate of relaxation (max-dP/dt_dia) compared to hearts perfused with mf-saline in normoxia. However, hearts perfused with saline containing glycerol (gly-saline) in anoxia had higher max-dP, max-dP/dt_sys, and max-dP/dt_dia than hearts perfused with mf-saline in anoxia. Tissue levels of glycerol increased when hearts were perfused with gly-saline in normoxia, but not when perfused with gly-saline in anoxia. Anoxia exposure did not affect the activities of triglyceride lipase, glycerol kinase, or glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase. This study suggests that glycerol stimulates cardiac function in the hagfish but that it is not derived from stored lipids. How glycerol may stimulate contraction is not known. This could be as an energy substrate, as an allosteric factor, or a combination of the two.

Evolutionary implications of the cDNA sequence of the single lactate dehydrogenase of a lamprey

All vertebrates other than lampreys exhibit multiple loci encoding lactate dehydrogenase +ADL-LDH; (S)-lactate:NAD+ oxidoreductase, EC 1.1.1.27+BD. Of these loci, Ldh-A is expressed predominantly in muscle, Ldh-B is expressed predominantly in heart, and Ldh-C (where present) exhibits different tissue-restricted patterns of expression depending on the taxon. To examine the relationship of the single LDH of lampreys to other vertebrate LDHs, we have determined the cDNA sequence of the LDH of the sea lamprey Petromyzon marinus and compared it to previously published sequences from bacteria, plants, and vertebrates. The lamprey sequence exhibits a mixture of features of both LDH-A and LDH-B at the amino acid level that may account for its intermediate kinetic properties. Both distance and maximum parsimony analyses strongly reject a relationship of lamprey LDH with mammalian LDH-C but do not significantly distinguish among remaining alternative phylogenetic hypotheses. Evolutionary parsimony analyses suggest that the lamprey LDH is related to Ldh-A and that the single locus condition has arisen as a result of the loss of Ldh-B (prior to the appearance of Ldh-C). The collection of LDH sequences for further studies of the evolution of the vertebrate LDH gene family will be facilitated by the PCR approach that we have used to obtain the lamprey sequence.

The lactate dehydrogenase of the icefish heart: biochemical adaptations to hypoxia tolerance

Cardiac lactate dehydrogenase from the hemoglobin- and myoglobin-free antarctic icefish has been purified by affinity chromatography. Structural and kinetic properties of the enzyme were found close or identical to those of its skeletal muscle counterpart and other M-type lactate dehydrogenases. A model involving a dual oxidative-anaerobic metabolism of the icefish heart is proposed.

Lactate dehydrogenase isozymes in the trunk and cardiac muscles of an antarctic teleost fish,Notothenia neglecta Nybelin

The distribution and kinetics of lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) isozymes in the red and white trunk muscles, and cardiac muscle of an antarctic teleost fish (Notothenia neglecta Nybelin) have been studied. Pyruvate inhibition of LDH in all three muscle types is very low, being less than 50% even at a concentration of 60mM pyruvate. Activity versus pyruvate concentration profiles are not significantly different for LDH in all three muscle types. The Michaelis constant (Km) for pyruvate was not significantly different for all three LDH's. Raising the assay temperature caused an increase in Km of similar form in all three muscle types, while Km was lowest at the lowest assay temperature (-1°C). When samples were run on a polyacrylamide gel, the bands stained specifically for LDH activity appeared at identical positions as those of the H2M2 band of the standards.It would appear therefore that the LDH isozyme found in the red and white trunk muscle ofN. neglecta is identical to that in cardiac muscle. This fact is discussed in relation to the physiological ecology of antaretic fishes, and the metabolic constraints imposed by their habitat, including their apparent low capacity for utilising glycolytic fuels.

Lactate dehydrogenases in Antarctic and temperate fish species

1. The kinetics of lactate dehydrogenase (both forward and back reaction) in cardiac and skeletal muscle of an Antarctic teleost have been compared with a temperate teleost of comparable morphology and ecology. 2. In both species the forward reaction (pyruvate to lactate) is maximally activated at 2.5-4 mM pyruvate and inhibited above this level. 3. The Michaelis constant (Km) for pyruvate is not significantly different between muscle types or between species when measured at their normal environmental temperature. 4. Km for pyruvate varies with temperature in a positive direction. 5. The back reaction (lactate to pyruvate) is maximally activated by 12-16 mM lactate but only in skeletal muscle of the antarctic species is there inhibition above this level. 6. The Km for lactate is significantly (P less than 0.05) lower in the Antarctic fish cardiac muscle. 7. While the two species are morphologically and ecologically similar, differences at the biochemical level are discussed with respect to environmental temperature range and conservation of enzymic characteristics.

Lactate dehydrogenase from Lampetra planeri is composed of chains of unique type which show intermediate properties between the heart and the muscle isozymes of vertebrates

1. Like other lamprey species, Lampetra planeri displays LDH chains of a single type. Since lampreys are more related to vertebrates than myxines, which do have usual A and B monomers, we suspect that either a gene inactivation or a gene loss occurred in the former group. 2. The characterization of the enzyme gave interesting results. From the standpoint of its affinity for ion exchangers, it behaves as if it is composed of A-type chains. 3. From the standpoint of substrate and product inhibition, it resembles much more closely the B containing isozyme. 4. Since literature reports that the other known single-chained LDH's from lampreys are definitely of the A type, we suggest the possibility that L. planeri enzyme underwent some orthologous evolution which brought it to resemble the heart isozyme.

Immunochemical evidence that the single lactate dehydrogenase of lampreys is more similar to LDHB4 than to LDHA4 of hagfish

The tetrameric lactate dehydrogenases (LDH) of vertebrates contain several different subunits that arose by gene duplication. While the A and B subunits occur in all classes of gnathostomes, the enzymes of agnathans appear to represent two stages in the evolution of vertebrate LDH. Lampreys of the family Petromyzontidae have a single enzyme classified as LDHA4, while hagfish possess both A and B subunits which form only the two homopolymers LDHA4 and LDHB4. It is generally assumed that the original vertebrate LDH was an A4 type, that duplication to give the B subunit occurred prior to the divergence of lampreys and hagfish, and that modern lampreys subsequently lost expression of the B gene. Lactate dehydrogenases were purified from representatives of all three lamprey families, and it was confirmed that members of the Mordaciidae and Geotriidae also possess single tetrameric LDH enzymes containing one subunit type. The kinetic properties of the lamprey LDH enzymes were compared with the LDH homopolymers of hagfish, skate, and sardine. These properties did not allow the lamprey enzymes to be unequivocally identified as either LDHA4 or LDHB4. Immunochemical titration using antisera against lamprey and hagfish LDH homopolymers demonstrated that the lamprey LDH enzymes showed greater immunochemical similarity to LDHB4 than to LDHA4 of hagfish. It is concluded that there is little evidence for the claim that the original vertebrate LDH was an A4 rather than B4 type.

Properties of muscle phosphorylase b from a hagfish, Paramyxine atami

Phosphorylase b was purified to homogeneity from the muscle of a hagfish (Paramyxine atami), as judged by electrophoretic and immunological criteria. The purified enzyme was partially but not fully activated by AMP, and its conversion into the a form resulted in a three-fold increase in activity. The enzyme was stimulated by SO4(2-), and kinetic experiments showed that SO4(2-) markedly increased the affinity of enzyme toward substrates: in the presence and absence of 0.35 M SO4(2-), the apparent Km values of hagfish phosphorylase b were 0.04 and 1.3% for glycogen, 8.7 and 66 mM for glucose 1-phosphate, and 0.05 and 1.0 mM for AMP, respectively. Electrophoretic and immunological data indicated that the hagfish possessed a single molecular form of phosphorylase, like the lamprey. Some immunological relatedness between the hagfish enzyme and the enzyme from lamprey or skate was demonstrated.

An apparent progressive and recurrent evolutionary restriction in tissue expression of a gene, the lactate dehydrogenase-C gene, within a family of bony fish (Salmoniformes: Umbridae)

Unexpectedly large differences in the tissue patterns of lactate dehydrogenase-C (Ldh-C) gene regulation were observed among species of fish within the family Umbridae (Salmoniformes). Normally, all the species within a family or order of advanced fishes exhibit the same, tissue-restricted pattern of L-lactate dehydrogenase C4 isozyme synthesis--either eye- or liver-restricted expression, but not both. However, within the Umbridae the more anciently derived species had a more generalized (primitive) tissue expression, whereas the more recently derived species had a more tissue-restricted expression, predominating in the eye. Given the relative divergence times among the species estimated by genetic distance (using 51 protein-coding loci), divergence from the presumed primitive expression of the Ldh-C gene appears to have been proceeding more rapidly in some species lineages than others. This narrowing of Ldh-C gene tissue regulatory specificity within the family Umbridae is similar to the general trend observed over much greater evolutionary times within the class of bony fishes. The results support the hypothesis of repeated evolutionary canalizations of Ldh-C gene regulation from the generalized tissue expression in more primitive species to a predictable tissue-restricted expression (in either eye or liver) in advanced species. Furthermore, in the Umbridae, this progressive restriction of tissue expression of isozymes has taken place during the evolution of both the Ldh-C and Ldh-B genes. These evolutionary trends in the regulation of isozyme-locus tissue expression in the bony fishes are consistent with either an intrinsically conditioned trend of change in gene regulation or with a response to natural selection.

Genetic structure of natural populations of the red-spotted newt, Notophthalmus viridescens

Genetic variation is described at 15 loci in 2 neotenic and 12 nonneotenic populations of red-spotted newts. Though high levels of genetic similarity (I = 0.990) were found among all populations, allele frequencies at six of the eight most polymorphic loci show significant heterogeneity across populations. Change in allele frequencies at two of these loci (Pep-2 and Ldh-1) is significantly correlated with latitude. Interspecific homologies are established for newt peptidases based on substrate specificities and lactate dehydrogenases based on tissue distribution, thermal stability, and kinetic properties. Nonneotenic populations are highly variable (H = 0.157) and neotenic populations are only slightly, but significantly, less variable (H = 0.120). The high levels of heterozygosity detected in nonneotenic populations may result from large effective population size and/or environmental heterogeneity. The unexpectedly high heterozygosity values obtained for the neotenic populations may indicate adult dispersal or the presence of some previously undetected red efts at these localities. In any case, a major change in life history has apparently had little effect on the genetic structure of these populations.

Regulation of glycolysis in lizards: kinetic studies on liver pyruvate kinase and phosphofructokinase from Lacerta galloti

Kinetic studies were carried out on pyruvate kinase and phosphofructokinase from the lizard Lacerta galloti. Pyruvate kinase is inhibited by ATP and activated by fructose 1,6-biphosphate giving an hyperbolic saturation curve for ATP without the activator which becomes sigmoidal at saturating concentrations of fructose 1,6-biphosphate, giving a moderate cooperativity with a Hill coefficient of h = 1.72. Binding of fructose 1,6-biphosphate to pyruvate kinase was studied as protection effect against thermal denaturation, this being the most suitable ligand tested to avoid the loss of activity. Phosphofructokinase is inhibited by ATP at millimolar range and activated by AMP and by fructose 2,6-biphosphate, AMP being the more efficient activator.

Cardiac metabolism in the Myxinidae: physiological and phylogenetic considerations

Cardiac muscle hearts of Atlantic hagfish continuously function under hypoxic conditions that would lead to cardiac failure in most other vertebrates. Contractile performance of hagfish systemic hearts is resistant to anoxia and respiratory poisons but shows a significant decrement when carbohydrate catabolism is blocked by 0.5 mM iodoacetic acid. Enzyme activity profiles of hagfish ventricle reveal a robust capacity for glycolysis of carbohydrate in comparison to that for general aerobic metabolism and catabolism of alternate metabolic fuels. Isolated working hagfish ventricles preferentially oxidize radiolabeled glucose even when fatty acid fuels are present in the incubation medium. Work output of the isolated ventricular preparation is maintained only in the presence of exogenous glucose. The results indicate that energy metabolism of the hagfish myocardium is predominantly carbohydrate-based and that energy demand of the tissue can be sustained by anaerobic glycolysis during extended periods of extreme hypoxia. Cardiac metabolism of this primitive species is compared with that of hearts from higher vertebrates and an evolutionary hypothesis relating cardiac workload to preferred metabolic fuel is discussed.