Cation components of Mueller-Hinton agar affecting testing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa susceptibility to gentamicin

Evaluation of 10 brands of pre-poured Mueller-Hinton agar plates for EUCAST disc diffusion testing

OBJECTIVES

Mueller-Hinton agar (MHA) is recommended by EUCAST and CLSI for disc diffusion antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST). We have previously investigated the quality of dehydrated MHA from several manufacturers. In this study, we evaluated the performance of 10 commercial brands of pre-poured MHA plates.

METHODS

AST was performed according to EUCAST methodology and results analysed against targets and ranges in EUCAST quality control (QC) tables. MHA plates from different brands were tested in triplicate against four non-fastidious QC strains. The agar depth and pH were measured for all products.

RESULTS

The best performance was observed for MHA from Becton Dickinson (BBL MHA II), bioMérieux (MHE agar) and Hardy Diagnostics, for which >97% of zone diameters were within QC ranges and >60% on target ±1 mm. The poorest performance was seen for plates from HiMedia (MHA and MHA No. 2), where 20 and 18% of readings were outside the QC ranges, respectively. The differences in pH and agar depth of the products were small and mostly within EUCAST specifications.

CONCLUSIONS

The accuracy and reproducibility of disc diffusion AST depends on standardised procedures and high-quality discs and media. The performance among 10 brands of pre-poured MHA plates differed significantly. The results indicate a poorer performance for pre-poured commercial plates as compared to in-house prepared plates from dehydrated powder of corresponding brands in our previous study. Manufacturers and clinical laboratories have a shared responsibility for the quality of AST. EUCAST provide QC criteria to be used both by manufacturers and laboratories.

Synergy between tobramycin and trivalent chromium ion in electrochemical control of Pseudomonas aeruginosa

We recently demonstrated that the effectiveness of tobramycin (Tob), an aminoglycoside, against antibiotic-tolerant persister cells of Pseudomonas aeruginosa can be enhanced by electrochemical factors generated from direct currents (DC). Supplementation of Ni(II), Cr(III) and Fe(II) during carbon-mediated DC treatment revealed that these metal cations promote killing of persister cells in the presence of tobramycin, which led to our hypothesis that specific interactions between Tob and some metal ions contribute to the synergistic killing of persister cells. In this study, the interactions between selected metal cations and Tob were investigated using (1)H-(13)C HSQC NMR. Increase in the concentration of Cr(III) (in the form of [CrCl2(H2O)4](+)) in solutions containing Tob was found to shift the HSQC NMR peaks of Tob to new positions, suggesting the formation of a Cr(III)-Tob complex. Crystal field effects and electrochemical properties of the complex were further studied using UV-visible spectroscopy and cyclic voltammetry, which led to the finding that the Cr(III)-Tob complex has increased affinity with negatively charged nucleic acids. These findings are helpful for understanding the mechanism of electrochemical control of bacterial cells and for developing more effective antimicrobial therapies based on aminoglycosides and electrochemical species released from various metallic biomaterials.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

Medical device associated infections present a major challenge to healthcare and the quality of life of affected individuals. This problem is further exacerbated by the emergence of multidrug resistant pathogens. Thus, alternative methods for microbial control are urgently needed. Recently, we reported synergy between tobramycin and low-level electrochemical currents generated using stainless steel electrodes in killing bacterial persister cells, a dormant population with high-level intrinsic tolerance to antibiotics. In this article, we describe how electrically-induced interaction between aminoglycosides and certain metal cations enhance the potency of tobramycin in bacterial killing. The findings will help design new methods for controlling infections through electrochemical disruption of cellular function and associated drug resistance.

Comparison of inhibitory and bactericidal activities and postantibiotic effects of LY333328 and ampicillin used singly and in combination against vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecium

One hundred ninety-five individual vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecium (VRE) isolates from five upstate New York hospitals were studied for antimicrobial susceptibilities to LY333328, quinupristin-dalfopristin, teicoplanin, ampicillin, and gentamicin. LY333328 was the most active antibiotic against VRE. The effect of media and methods on the antibacterial activity of LY333328, its synergy with ampicillin, and the postantibiotic effects (PAE) of LY333328 and ampicillin were evaluated. In microdilution tests, the MIC of LY333328 at which 90% of the isolates were inhibited (MIC90) was 2 microg/ml in Mueller-Hinton II (MH II) broth and 1 microg/ml in brain heart infusion (BHI) broth. In contrast, on MH II agar the MIC90 was 4 microg/ml and on BHI agar it was >16 microg/ml. Bactericidal activity was observed for most strains at concentrations from 8 to >/=133 times the MIC of the tube macrodilution in MH II broth. A bactericidal effect of LY333328 plus ampicillin was demonstrated in time-kill studies, but there was great strain-to-strain variability. By the MH II agar dilution method, bacteristatic synergy (defined as a fractional inhibitory concentration of <0.5) with LY333328 and ampicillin was demonstrated for 61% of the strains tested. Under similar conditions, there was synergy with LY333328 and quinupristin-dalfopristin or gentamicin for 27 and 15% of the strains tested, respectively. The PAE of LY333328 was prolonged (23.0 h at 10 times the MIC). However, 50% normal pooled human serum decreased the PAE to 12.2 h at 10 times the MIC. Test conditions and media had a considerable effect on VRE susceptibilities to LY333328. The prolonged PAE of LY333328, a potent new bactericidal glycopeptide, and its synergy with ampicillin in a large proportion of strains suggest that further evaluation of this drug in pharmacokinetic studies and experimental infections, including those with VRE, is warranted.

Influence of pulmonary surfactant on in vitro bactericidal activities of amoxicillin, ceftazidime, and tobramycin

The influence of a natural pulmonary surfactant on antibiotic activity was investigated to assess the possible use of exogenous surfactant as a vehicle for antibiotic delivery to the lung. The influence of surfactant on the bactericidal activity of amoxicillin was tested against Staphylococcus aureus and Streptococcus pneumoniae, and the influence of surfactant on the activities of ceftazidime and tobramycin was tested against Klebsiella pneumoniae, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, S. aureus, and S. pneumoniae. In vitro antibiotic activity was determined by killing curve studies in media with and without surfactant. Amoxicillin and ceftazidime activities were not changed in the presence of surfactant, except for a decreased killing rate of S. pneumoniae by ceftazidime in medium with additional rabbit serum. In contrast, killing curves with low concentrations of tobramycin (0.25x and 1x the MIC) showed a decreased level of activity of tobramycin against all pathogens tested in the presence of surfactant. With higher tobramycin concentrations (4x the MIC) killing rates were decreased less or were unchanged in the presence of surfactant. Concluding from the results of the study, both amoxicillin and ceftazidime can be combined with surfactant without the loss of activity. For mixing surfactant with tobramycin, dosages should be adjusted to overcome the partial inactivation of tobramycin by surfactant.

Macromolecular mechanisms of sputum inhibition of tobramycin activity

Tobramycin, an aminoglycoside antibiotic, is used in the treatment of Pseudomonas aeruginosa infections in cystic fibrosis patients. Tobramycin bioactivity, however, is antagonized by sputum. Glycoproteins (mucins) and high-molecular-weight DNA make up 2 to 3% (P. L. Masson and J. F. Heremans, p. 412-475, In M. J. Dulfano, ed., Sputum: Fundamentals and Clinical Pathology, 1973) and 3 to 10% (W. S. Chernick and G. J. Barbero, Pediatrics 24:739-745, 1959, and R. Picot, I. Das, and L. Reid, Thorax 33:235-242, 1978) of the dry weight of sputum, respectively. tobramycin binds to both mucins and DNA obtained from sputum (R. Ramphal, M. Lhermitte, M. Filliat, and P. Roussel, J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 22:483-490, 1988). In vitro, recombinant human DNase (rhDNase) hydrolyzes high-molecular-weight DNA of > 50 kb within sputum to fragments of 2 to 4 kb. Studying dialyzable tobramycin, we examined drug binding to whole sputum and to "mock sputum," which consisted of porcine gastric mucin and calf thymus DNA. We also studied the effects of rhDNase treatments of sputum, mock sputum, and calf thymus DNA on tobramycin binding. We found that treatments of sputum, mock sputum, and calf thymus DNA with rhDNase did not significantly increase the tobramycin bioactivity within the dialysates; surprisingly, sputum binding of tobramycin was increased by rhDNase. We conclude that rhDNase does not increase the bioactivity of tobramycin in sputum.

Influence of zinc on Pseudomonas aeruginosa susceptibilities to imipenem

Serial dilution susceptibility testing of imipenem against 59 clinical isolates of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, conducted simultaneously on single lots of Difco and BBL Mueller-Hinton agar (MHA), resulted in MICs for 90% of strains tested of 8 and 16 micrograms/ml, respectively. MICs for Escherichia coli, Klebsiella pneumoniae, and Pseudomonas spp. were also higher on BBL MHA. Quantification of the cation content of the two MHAs by atomic absorption spectroscopy demonstrated that the zinc concentration in BBL MHA was 15 times greater than that measured in Difco MHA (2.61 and 0.17 micrograms/ml, respectively). Concentrations of calcium, magnesium, iron, manganese, and copper in the two agars were similar. Addition of zinc to Difco MHA resulted in increases in MICs of imipenem for P. aeruginosa but not in the MICs of ceftazidime or cefpirome for P. aeruginosa (P < 0.01). A lesser zinc effect was seen on the activity of imipenem against E. coli, K. pneumoniae, and Pseudomonas spp. The activities of ceftazidime and cefpirome were similar on both MHAs when tested against all gram-negative organisms in this study. Thus, the effect of zinc in MHA was clearly demonstrated by a significant increase in the MICs of imipenem for P. aeruginosa, and, to a lesser extent, for other gram-negative bacilli.

Comparison of five methods, including the PDM Epsilometer test (E test), for antimicrobial susceptibility testing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa

The antimicrobial susceptibilities of 100 clinical isolates of Pseudomonas aeruginosa to six antipseudomonal antibiotics were tested by five methods: the National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards (NCCLS) methods for broth microdilution, agar dilution, and agar disk diffusion; the Vitek Automicrobic System method (Vitek Systems, Hazelwood, Mo.); and the PDM Epsilometer test (E test) (AB Biodisk, Solna, Sweden). The E test results showed excellent correlation with agar dilution results, with over 90% agreement within 1 doubling dilution between the E test and reference agar dilution MICs for all antimicrobial agents tested. The E test results also showed good correlation with the results from the reference agar disk diffusion method, with 90 to 99% complete agreement and 100% essential agreement on categories for all antibiotics tested (essential agreement is the agreement obtained when minor discrepancies are ignored). Comparison of categories with the E test and broth microdilution methods, using the broth microdilution method as the reference method, gave only 59% complete agreement for gentamicin, with 28 minor discrepancies and 13 very major discrepancies. Some discrepancies were observed between results from the E test and broth methods for gentamicin, with the broth microdilution and Vitek methods giving higher MICs than the E test and other methods using agar. The most recent NCCLS guidelines for broth dilution testing have reduced the recommended levels of cation supplementation, which may enhance future agreement between results for the aminoglycosides and P. aeruginosa on broth and on agar. We found that the E test offers a simple, labor-efficient, and accurate method for MIC determination on an agar medium.

Comparison of the Sceptor Pseudomonas Plus MIC Panel with agar dilution for susceptibility testing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa

The antimicrobial susceptibilities of 100 clinical isolates of Pseudomonas aeruginosa to gentamicin, amikacin, tobramycin, ticarcillin, piperacillin, and ceftazidime were determined by using the Sceptor system (BBL Microbiology Systems, Cockeysville, Md.), and the results were compared with those obtained using the National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards reference agar dilution method. Excellent correlation was observed for the aminoglycosides, with greater than 95% agreement within 1 doubling dilution of the reference agar dilution MIC, while ticarcillin and piperacillin showed lower percent agreement values of 91 and 88%, respectively.

Revision of standards for adjusting the cation content of Mueller-Hinton broth for testing susceptibility of Pseudomonas aeruginosa to aminoglycosides

A multilaboratory study was undertaken to reassess the amount of calcium and magnesium that should be added to Mueller-Hinton broth when testing Pseudomonas aeruginosa against amikacin, gentamicin, isepamicin, netilmicin, and tobramycin. To achieve parity with agar dilution tests, cation-adjusted broth should contain 20 to 25 mg of calcium and 10 to 12.5 mg of magnesium per liter rather than the 50- and 25-mg/liter supplements recommended previously. For quality control of tests with contemporary media, MIC control limits should be adjusted by lowering the current MIC limits by at least 1 doubling-dilution interval.

Impact of pH and cationic supplementation on in vitro postantibiotic effect

Most studies on pharmacodynamic variables in vitro, including the postantibiotic effect (PAE), are performed at pH 7.4 in noncationic-supplemented media, a situation which may differ significantly from the true microenvironment in most infected foci. We studied the impact of five different pH levels (pH 5, 6, 7, 7.4, and 8) on the duration of the PAE, the MIC, and bactericidal activity. Acid pH was found to have in general a deleterious effect on the activity of aminoglycosides and ciprofloxacin against Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, with the MIC being higher, the bactericidal rate being lower, and the PAE being shorter at pH 5 (and to a lesser extent at pH 6) than at more alkaline pH levels. Similar results were observed for imipenem against P. aeruginosa. The PAEs induced by ampicillin against E. coli and dicloxacillin against Staphylococcus aureus were not predictably dependent on the pH, whereas the PAEs induced by ciprofloxacin against S. aureus were longest at either end of the pH spectrum. The bactericidal activity of these agents was, however, pH dependent, being slower at acid pHs. The addition of 50 mg of Ca2+ and 20 mg of Mg2+ per liter of liquid medium at pH 7.4 did not affect the duration of the PAE. Since the pH in abscess cavities may be close to 5, these observations may be of importance for employment of the agents studied in closed or poorly drained infections.

Quality control in antimicrobial disk susceptibility testing: a Belgian multicenter study

A Belgian multicenter trial was conducted to evaluate problems encountered with quality control results of antimicrobial disk susceptibility testing and to compare the performance of BBL disks and Rosco tablets. Over a period of four weeks 18 laboratories daily tested three reference strains against eight antibiotics. A standardised method was used by all participants. For all results together 10.4% and 7.3% of the measurements with BBL disks and Rosco tablets, respectively, were outside the recommended range. Major problems were observed for some specific strain-antibiotic combinations. Standard deviations were similar for both systems; their precision was comparable. The results suggest that cooperation between manufacturers and some reference laboratories could be improved in order to establish optimal quality control limits.

Functions and activities of the Area Committee on Microbiology of the National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards

The Area Committee on Microbiology of the National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards has responsibility for the development of guidelines and standards in the field of clinical microbiology. Through the consensus process, representatives from government, industry, and professional societies have developed standards on antibacterial susceptibility testing (M2, M7, and M11), antimycobacterial susceptibility testing (M24), quality assurance on commercially prepared microbiological culture media (M22), evaluation of production lots of dehydrated Mueller-Hinton agar (M6), and preparation and testing of fetal bovine serum for use as cell culture growth supplement (M25) and guidelines on bactericidal tests (M26), protection of laboratory workers from infections transmitted by blood, body fluids, and tissue (M29), blood film examination for parasites (M15), and development of in vitro susceptibility testing criteria and quality control parameters (M23).

Wide variability in Pseudomonas aeruginosa aminoglycoside results among seven susceptibility testing procedures

Seven commonly used antimicrobial susceptibility testing methods were used to test the susceptibility of 150 isolates of Pseudomonas aeruginosa against gentamicin, tobramycin, amikacin, carbenicillin, and piperacillin. Results were compared with respect to the susceptibility characteristics of the population of isolates as defined by each method. Conventional methods included agar disk diffusion and agar dilution, carried out in accordance with current recommendations of the National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards, as well as broth microdilution testing with cation-supplemented Mueller-Hinton broth (CSMHB). Methods in which instrumentation was used for result determination included the Autobac I, Avantage, Sensititre Autoreader (using a breakpoint panel at 18 h of incubation), and Vitek (AMS-240, using the GNS susceptibility card). When necessary for comparison, MIC data were converted to categorical interpretations (susceptible, intermediate, and resistant). With respect to gentamicin, no significant differences were noted among the results of disk diffusion, broth microdilution, Sensititre Auto breakpoint, or Vitek methods which characterized 60 to 67% of isolates as susceptible, 16 to 22% as intermediate, and 13 to 17% as resistant. In contrast, agar dilution, Autobac, and Avantage, although yielding gentamicin results similar to those of one another, were each significantly different in result reporting from the other four methods above for gentamicin results, and they characterized the Pseudomonas population largely as susceptible (88 to 97%), with 0 to 6% intermediate and only 3% to 6% resistant. More isolates were characterized as being resistant to gentamicin in the Avantage test if an assay broth supplemented with increased amounts of calcium was used. Cation impregnation of Autobac disks did not appreciably change Autobac results. The geometric mean MIC of gentamicin was 4 micrograms/ml lower in the agar dilution method than in the CSMHB microdilution method, despite monitoring of the agar for cation content through performance disk diffusion testing with P. aeruginosa ATCC 27853. Tobramycin activity was greater than gentamicin activity, and susceptibility to tobramycin ranged from 89 to 97%, with few statistically significant differences noted among the seven methods studied. Differences in MIC distribution and geometric mean MIC between agar dilution and CSMHB microdilution testing were minimal and suggested less of a cation influence on tobramycin than gentamicin results. Although amikacin was also more active than gentamicin (83 to 99% of isolates were susceptible), differences in the amikacin results among methods tended to reflect the same trends in reporting as seen with gentamicin testing, with the exception that results of Avantage testing were similar to those of disk diffusion, CSMHB microdilution, Sensititre, and Vitek. A difference in geometric mean MIC of 5 micrograms/ml between CSMHB testing and agar dilution testing suggested the influence of divalent cations on amikacin results. Few highly significant differences were noted among methods when isolates were tested against carbenicillin and piperacillin, except that Avantage piperacillin results (66% susceptible) and Autobac piperacillin results (98% susceptible) were noticeably different from the percent piperacillin susceptibility (range, 85 to 92%) measured by the other methods. Method-dependent variability among aminoglycoside susceptibility results, particularly when testing gentamicin, prevents meaningful comparison of Pseudomonas susceptibility trends among hospitals when different methods are used and promotes confusion and frustration among clinical microbiologists and clinicians owing to the uncertainties of clinical meaning of these data.

Turbidimetric response of Staphylococcus aureus and Enterococcus faecalis to daptomycin

The response to daptomycin of three strains of Staphylococcus aureus (one of which was methicillin-resistant) and a strain of Enterococcus faecalis was investigated by continuous turbidimetric monitoring. Daptomycin caused partial inhibition of bacterial growth at concentrations well below those suppressing growth overnight. The activity of the drug was more than 200-fold greater in the presence of a physiological concentration of calcium (2.5 mmol/l) than in its absence. Variants present in cultures inhibited by daptomycin were shown to exhibit decreased susceptibility to the drug and the susceptibility declined further on repeat exposure; however, there was a slow but incomplete reversion to susceptibility on sequential subculture in drug-free broth. Resistance was difficult to induce when the concentration of calcium in the broth exceeded 2.5 mmol/l.

Influence of cation supplements on activity of netilmicin against Pseudomonas aeruginosa in vitro and in vivo

In vitro studies were performed with 74 Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates which were collected during a multicenter trial. The isolates were obtained from 70 patients who had been treated with netilmicin as the only antipseudomonal antibiotic. Clinically, 83% of the patients were cured or improved, and 64% of the Pseudomonas isolates were eliminated by chemotherapy. The 74 clinical isolates and 38 additional isolates with known mechanisms of aminoglycoside resistance were tested in three separate laboratories by disk diffusion methods and by microdilution tests with three broth media (Mueller-Hinton broth with full, half, and no cation supplements). Isolates that responded to netilmicin therapy and those that failed to respond were all susceptible by the disk test, and most were susceptible by microdilution tests with unsupplemented broth. However, over half of the clinical isolates appeared to be resistant when cations were added to the broth medium. Strains capable of producing enzymes that inactivate netilmicin were resistant by all methods tested. Broth dilution and agar dilution results were most comparable when half of the recommended cation supplements was added to Mueller-Hinton broth. Further consideration should be given to reducing the concentration of cations that are added to Mueller-Hinton broth when netilmicin susceptibility tests are being performed. However, additional studies with other aminoglycosides are needed before appropriate testing conditions can be standardized.

Netilmicin disk susceptibility tests: effect of cations on the MIC correlates

When testing Pseudomonas aeruginosa against netilmicin, MICs were markedly affected by the concentration of cations added to the test medium. A susceptible disk test result (zone greater than or equal to 15 mm) corresponded to MIC less than or equal to 4.0 micrograms/ml in unsupplemented broth, less than or equal to 12 micrograms/ml in broth with half the usual amount of cations and less than or equal to 32 micrograms/ml in broth with the recommended concentration of cations. Tests with 30 micrograms netilmicin disks best predicted susceptibility as determined by MICs in broth without added cations. When the MICs were determined in cation supplemented broth, the number of interpretive discrepancies increased to an unacceptably high level.

Selection of a reference lot of Mueller-Hinton agar

A collaborative study was undertaken to evaluate the performance of currently marketed Mueller-Hinton agars from seven manufacturers by replicate disk diffusion tests with standard quality control strains. Identification of the manufacturers was concealed, and the resulting data were evaluated for the selection of a physical reagent standard against which the performance of future production lots would be tested and made to conform. A medium was selected which was sufficiently close to existing National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards quality control limits that current interpretive criteria would require minimum modification. Two of the seven lots were eliminated from further consideration because the final pHs were outside acceptable limits. The remaining four lots had 96% of mean zone diameters less than or equal to 2 mm from those of the chosen lot and 65% of the means were less than or equal to 1 mm from those of the chosen lot for all 28 antimicrobial agent-organism combinations. Manufacturers then attempted to produce new lots of Mueller-Hinton agar which performed within the prescribed limits of the chosen lot. One lot performed in close conformity with the selected standard, but the overall performance of the media was essentially the same as that of the randomly chosen lots in the initial study. It was concluded that one of the original seven lots demonstrated properties which made it a tentative candidate for a physical reagent standard and that the use of a physical reagent standard in evaluating production lots might aid in stabilizing the performance of Mueller-Hinton agar.

Feasibility study of disk diffusion susceptibility tests with Mueller-Hinton broth solidified with Gelrite, an agar substitute

Feasibility studies were done to determine whether a new agar substitute, Gelrite gellan gum, could be used to prepare a solid Mueller-Hinton medium for disk diffusion susceptibility tests. Mueller-Hinton broth was combined with 0.43% of the gellan gum and 0.75% KCI. The resulting medium had performance characteristics similar to those of Mueller-Hinton agars; however, zones on the gellan gum media tended to be a little larger. Significant differences among Mueller-Hinton broths and among Mueller-Hinton agars from different manufacturers were documented: zones on different lots of the gellan gum were more consistent. The Mueller-Hinton broth-gellan gum medium appears to represent a satisfactory alternative to agar media. However, because somewhat larger zones were seen on the gellan gum plates, further study will be needed to develop quality control limits and interpretive zone size standards for tests on this new medium.

Evaluation of the automicrobic system for susceptibility testing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa to gentamicin, tobramycin, and amikacin

The AutoMicrobic system (AMS; Vitek Systems, Inc., Hazelwood, Mo.) was studied for its ability to produce accurate and precise MIC interpretations for Pseudomonas aeruginosa susceptibility to gentamicin, tobramycin, and amikacin. MICs were determined in parallel on 200 selected P. aeruginosa isolates by using the AMS discrete-integer MIC program AMS p12.ROB for interpretation of the AMS Gram-Negative General Susceptibility Urinary Card, and a reference small-integer broth microdilution test. Parallel AMS and broth microdilution MICs were also replicated for three selected strains of P. aeruginosa for which MICs were representative of the dilution test ranges. For the 200 P. aeruginosa isolates, mean AMS MICs were significantly larger than the reference test mean MICs, coefficients of variation were approximately double those of the reference test, and correlation coefficients were unacceptably low for each antimicrobial agent. MIC replication studies for the three selected P. aeruginosa strains showed comparable AMS and reference mean MICs in the lower portions of the dilution ranges, significantly higher AMS mean MICs in the upper portions, and mean coefficients of variation of 63 and 9.6%, respectively, for replicated AMS and reference MICs. These results indicate that the AMS, in its present stage of development, does not produce acceptable MIC measurements for P. aeruginosa susceptibility to gentamicin, tobramycin, and amikacin.

Evaluation of Mueller-Hinton agar for disk diffusion susceptibility tests

Twelve lots of commercially prepared Mueller-Hinton agar from four medium manufacturers were evaluated for performance with recommended quality control organisms, medium pH, agar depth and uniformity, and characteristics of the zones of inhibition. Only 2 of 12 lots were acceptable for disk diffusion susceptibility tests. Significant problems were observed with the preparation and pouring of the agar media.

Error rates associated with the use of recently proposed breakpoints for testing Pseudomonas aeruginosa versus gentamicin, tobramycin, and amikacin by the standardized disk agar diffusion test

Two hundred fifteen Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates were tested in parallel by the disk agar diffusion test, using a standardized agar preparation, and by a microbroth test, using dilutions differing by small arithmetic increments. For gentamicin, recently proposed breakpoints of resistance (R) less than or equal to 12 mm and susceptibility (S) greater than or equal to 16 mm produced error rates of 20 and 6.8%, respectively. Limiting the error rate for susceptible interpretations to less than or equal to 2% produced a widening of the intermediate zone to include 67.4% of the isolates tested. For tobramycin, the recently proposed breakpoints of R less than or equal to 12 mm and S greater than or equal to 15 mm were associated with error rates of 66.7 and 1.4%, respectively. Breakpoints of R less than or equal to 12 mm and S greater than or equal to 13 mm were demonstrated to be equally effective when the error rate for susceptible interpretations was limited to less than or equal to 2% by error rate-bound analysis. For amikacin, proposed breakpoints of R less than or equal to 14 mm and S greater than or equal to 17 mm were associated with error rates of 27.3 and 3.2%, respectively. Limiting the error rates for susceptible interpretations to less than or equal to 2% required breakpoints of R less than or equal to 14 mm and S greater than or equal to 18 mm. The ability to establish effective susceptibility breakpoints for tobramycin and amikacin appeared not to be related to the disk agar diffusion test process itself but rather to the high degree of susceptibility of the P. aeruginosa population. These findings severely limit the usefulness of the disk agar diffusion procedure for testing P. aeruginosa versus the aminoglycosides. For this purpose, we recommend dilution tests which employ small arithmetic increment schemes.

The in vitro activity of gentamicin, tobramycin and netilmicin against 500 clinical isolates of bacteria. A comparative study using three different test media

The in vitro activities of the three aminoglycoside antibiotics, gentamicin, and tobramycin have been compared against 500 isolates of Enterobacteriaceae, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus. An agar dilution method was employed with three sensitivity media: Iso-Sensitest Agar, Mueller-Hinton Agar and PDM-Antibiotic Sensitivity Medium. All three aminoglycosides were highly active against S. aureus (MIC less than or equal to 0.5 mg/l) and the majority of Enterobacteriaceae (MIC90 approx. 1 mg/l). Tobramycin showed the highest activity against P. aeruginosa (MIC less than or equal to 1 mg/l). No major difference in measured MIC were found on the three media. Gentamicin and netilmicin were somewhat less active against P. aeruginosa on Mueller-Hinton Agar. MICs for tobramycin against Enterobacteriaceae were a little higher on PDM than on the other two agars. Our results show that measured MIC varied very little on the three sensitivity media. All media are suitable for routine use, provided that control strains are employed.

Discrepancies between in vitro activity of and in vivo response to antimicrobial agents

The correlation between in vitro antimicrobial activity and the in vivo response to antimicrobial therapy is affected by multiple host factors, the site and nature of the infection, and the pharmacokinetics of the antimicrobial and its penetration into areas of infection. In certain instances, discrepancies are also caused by methodologically-related variables of in vitro susceptibility tests. Examples of discrepancies between in vitro and in vivo response to antimicrobial are discussed.

Pseudomonas aeruginosa

P. aeruginosa is widely distributed in nature and in the hospital environment with a predilection for moist areas. Its inherent resistance to many antimicrobials and its ability to produce many enzymes contribute to its pathogenic potential as both a primary and a secondary cause of infection. It is easily grown and identified in the microbiology laboratory. However, susceptibility testing remains a problem. Currently, the best approach to treatment is an aminoglycoside and an antipseudomonal beta-lactam antimicrobial. Typing can differentiate strains, but should be reserved for specific epidemiologic problems.

Effect of calcium, magnesium, and zinc on ticarcillin and tobramycin alone and in combination against Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Correlation between in vitro and in vivo test results for synergy between carboxypenicillins and aminoglycosides against Pseudomonas aeruginosa is poor. Although the divalent cation content of culture media is known to affect aminoglycoside susceptibility testing for P. aeruginosa, this effect of divalent cations has not been examined for synergy testing of carboxypenicillin-aminoglycoside interaction against P. aeruginosa. The minimal inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of tobramycin and ticarcillin and the interaction of these drugs in combination were studied by a microtitration method for 36 strains of P. aeruginosa in Mueller-Hinton broth with varying supplements of calcium, magnesium, and zinc. The supplementation of Mueller-Hinton broth to 50 or 100 mg of calcium per liter had a significant effect in increasing the tobramycin MIC (P less than 0.01), as well as decreasing the degree of synergy between ticarcillin and tobramycin (P less than 0.01). Supplementation to 20 mg of magnesium per liter, 1.0 mg of zinc per liter, or both did not significantly affect tobramycin MIC or the interaction of tobramycin and ticarcillin. Supplementation to 50 or 100 mg of calcium per liter rendered any additional effect of magnesium and zinc on aminoglycoside MIC and aminoglycoside-carboxypenicillin interaction negligible. If these results for ticarcillin and tobramycin are confirmed for other carboxypenicillins and aminoglycosides, then the Mueller-Hinton broth used for P. aeruginosa aminoglycoside susceptibility and synergy testing may need to be supplemented only with calcium at a concentration of 50 mg/liter.

Broth microdilution testing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and aminoglycosides: need for employing dilutions differing by small arithmetic increments

The use of dilutions differing by small arithmetic increments was studied as a means for improving the definition and measurement of minimum inhibitory concentrations and precision parameters for testing Pseudomonas aeruginosa versus the aminoglycosides by the broth microdilution test. For five strains of P. aeruginosa versus gentamicin, tobramycin, and amikacin, comparisons were made of minimum inhibitory concentrations which were replicated in parallel by using three microdilution systems: small increment panels prepared by us, modified twofold dilution panels prepared by us, and similar modified twofold dilution panels obtained commercially. The small increment dilutions were prepared to differ by concentrations of 1.0 microgram/ml for gentamicin and tobramycin and by 2.0 micrograms/ml for amikacin. Use of the small increment dilutions resulted in the ability to measure minimum inhibitory concentrations at more closely spaced intervals than those dictated by modified twofold dilution schemes, and confidence limits were significantly improved. The average coefficient of variation for the small increment microdilution test results was 9.5%, with 99.5% of minimum inhibitory concentrations falling within +/- 2 small increment dilutions from their modal values.

Effect of ionized calcium and soluble magnesium on the predictability of the performance of Mueller-Hinton agar susceptibility testing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa with gentamicin

The soluble and ionized calcium and magnesium contents of 18 lots of Mueller-Hinton agar medium from three different manufacturers were analyzed, and the results were correlated with medium performance. A standardized disk diffusion test, with Pseudomonas aeruginosa (ATCC 27853) and a 10-microgram gentamicin disk, served as an indicator of medium performance. Zone diameters correlated well with the ionized calcium values and the sum of the ionized calcium and soluble magnesium values in the different lots (r = -0.88 for both). Zone diameters correlated poorly with ionized magnesium values (r = -0.57), which were best described by a curvilinear relationship. Supplementation of lots of Mueller-Hinton agar medium with equivalent amounts of calcium and magnesium as the chloride, gluconate, or glycerophosphate salts produced identical decreases in zone sizes. Adjustment of deficient lots of Mueller-Hinton agar medium with ionized calcium or soluble magnesium or both (as the gluconate salts), to match the concentrations in lots that provided satisfactory zone sizes (17 to 19 mm), resulted in performance comparable to that of the control lots. Sixteen strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, ranging from resistant to susceptible, responded to cation adjustment in the same manner as the ATCC quality control strain. Satisfactory medium performance can obviously be assured by biological means in aminoglycoside susceptibility testing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa on Mueller-Hinton medium; however, cation adjustment of medium to predetermined levels of ionized calcium and soluble magnesium can now also provide desirable performance levels for P. aeruginosa on Mueller-Hinton medium.