Renaturation of Bacillus thermoglucosidasius HrcA repressor by DNA and thermostability of the HrcA-DNA complex in vitro

Feeling the Heat: The Campylobacter jejuni HrcA Transcriptional Repressor Is an Intrinsic Protein Thermosensor

The heat-shock response, a universal protective mechanism consisting of a transcriptional reprogramming of the cellular transcriptome, results in the accumulation of proteins which counteract the deleterious effects of heat-stress on cellular polypeptides. To quickly respond to thermal stress and trigger the heat-shock response, bacteria rely on different mechanisms to detect temperature variations, which can involve nearly all classes of biological molecules. In Campylobacter jejuni the response to heat-shock is transcriptionally controlled by a regulatory circuit involving two repressors, HspR and HrcA. In the present work we show that the heat-shock repressor HrcA acts as an intrinsic protein thermometer. We report that a temperature upshift up to 42 °C negatively affects HrcA DNA-binding activity to a target promoter, a condition required for de-repression of regulated genes. Furthermore, we show that this impairment of HrcA binding at 42 °C is irreversible in vitro, as DNA-binding was still not restored by reversing the incubation temperature to 37 °C. On the other hand, we demonstrate that the DNA-binding activity of HspR, which controls, in combination with HrcA, the transcription of chaperones' genes, is unaffected by heat-stress up to 45 °C, portraying this master repressor as a rather stable protein. Additionally, we show that HrcA binding activity is enhanced by the chaperonin GroE, upon direct protein-protein interaction. In conclusion, the results presented in this work establish HrcA as a novel example of intrinsic heat-sensing transcriptional regulator, whose DNA-binding activity is positively modulated by the GroE chaperonin.

Cooperative Regulation of Campylobacter jejuni Heat-Shock Genes by HspR and HrcA

The heat-shock response is defined by the transient gene-expression program that leads to the rapid accumulation of heat-shock proteins. This evolutionary conserved response aims at the preservation of the intracellular environment and represents a crucial pathway during the establishment of host–pathogen interaction. In the food-borne pathogen Campylobacter jejuni two transcriptional repressors, named HspR and HrcA, are involved in the regulation of the major heat-shock genes. However, the molecular mechanism underpinning HspR and HrcA regulatory function has not been defined yet. In the present work, we assayed and mapped the HspR and HrcA interactions on heat-shock promoters by high-resolution DNase I footprintings, defining their regulatory circuit, which governs C. jejuni heat-shock response. We found that, while DNA-binding of HrcA covers a compact region enclosing a single inverted repeat similar to the so-called Controlling Inverted Repeat of Chaperone Expression (CIRCE) sequence, HspR interacts with multiple high- and low-affinity binding sites, which contain HspR Associated Inverted Repeat (HAIR)-like sequences. We also explored the DNA-binding properties of the two repressors competitively on their common targets and observed, for the first time, that HrcA and HspR can directly interact and their binding on co-regulated promoters occurs in a cooperative manner. This mutual cooperative mechanism of DNA binding could explain the synergic repressive effect of HspR and HrcA observed in vivo on co-regulated promoters. Peculiarities of the molecular mechanisms exerted by HspR and HrcA in C. jejuni are compared to the closely related bacterium H. pylori that uses homologues of the two regulators.

Mechanism of HrcA function in heat shock regulation in Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Molecular chaperones are a conserved family of proteins that are over-expressed in response to heat and other stresses. The regulation of expression of chaperone proteins plays a vital role in pathogenesis of various bacterial pathogens. In M. tuberculosis, HrcA and HspR negatively regulate heat shock protein operons by binding to their cognate DNA elements, CIRCE and HAIR respectively. In this study, we show that M. tuberculosis HrcA is able to bind to its cognate CIRCE DNA element present in the upstream regions of groES and groEL2 operons only with the help of other protein(s). It is also demonstrated that M. tuberculosis HrcA binds to a CIRCE like DNA element present in the upstream region of hrcA gene suggesting its auto-regulatory nature. In addition, we report the presence of a putative HAIR element in the upstream region of groES operon and demonstrate the binding of HspR to it. In vitro, HrcA inhibited the DNA binding activity of HspR in a dose-dependent manner. The current study demonstrates that M. tuberculosis HrcA requires other protein(s) to function, and the heat shock protein expression in M. tuberculosis is negatively regulated jointly by HrcA and HspR.

ClpL is required for folding of CtsR in Streptococcus mutans

ClpL, a member of the HSP100 family, is widely distributed in Gram-positive bacteria but is absent in Gram-negative bacteria. Although ClpL is involved in various cellular processes, such as the stress tolerance response, long-term survival, virulence, and antibiotic resistance, the detailed molecular mechanisms are largely unclear. Here we report that ClpL acts as a chaperone to properly fold CtsR, a stress response repressor, and prevents it from forming protein aggregates in Streptococcus mutans. In vitro, ClpL was able to successfully refold urea-denatured CtsR but not aggregated proteins. We suggest that ClpL recognizes primarily soluble but denatured substrates and prevents the formation of large protein aggregates. We also found that in vivo, the C-terminal D2-small domain of ClpL is essential for the observed chaperone activity. Since ClpL widely contributes to various cellular functions, we speculate that ClpL chaperone activity is necessary to maintain cellular homeostasis.

The hrcA and hspR regulons of Campylobacter jejuni

The human pathogen Campylobacter jejuni has a classic heat shock response, showing induction of chaperones and proteases plus several unidentified proteins in response to a small increase in growth temperature. The genome contains two homologues to known heat shock response regulators, HrcA and HspR. Previous work has shown that HspR controls several heat-shock genes, but the hrcA regulon has not been defined. We have constructed single and double deletions of C. jejuni hrcA and hspR and analysed gene expression using microarrays. Only a small number of genes are controlled by these two regulators, and the two regulons overlap. Strains mutated in hspR, but not those mutated in hrcA, showed enhanced thermotolerance. Some genes previously identified as being downregulated in a strain lacking hspR showed no change in expression in our experiments.

Reduction-sensitive and cysteine residue-mediated Streptococcus pneumoniae HrcA oligomerization in vitro

In both gram-positive and several gram-negative bacteria, the transcription of dnaK and groE operons is negatively regulated by HrcA; however, the mechanism modulating HrcA protein activity upon thermal stress remains elusive. Here, we demonstrate that HrcA is modulated via reduction and oligomerization in vitro. Native-PAGE analysis was used to reveal the oligomeric structure of HrcA. The oligomeric HrcA structure became monomeric following treatment with the reducing agent dithothreitol, and this process was reversed by treatment with hydrogen peroxide. Moreover, the mutant HrcA C118S exhibited reduced binding to CIRCE elements and became less oligomerized, suggesting that cysteine residue 118 is important for CIRCE element binding as well as oligomerization. Conversely, HrcA mutant C280S exhibited increased oligomerization. An HrcA double mutant (C118S, C280S) was monomeric and exhibited a level of oligomerization and CIRCE binding similar to wild type HrcA, suggesting that cysteine residues 118 and 280 may function as checks to one another during oligomer formation. Biochemical fractionation of E. coli cells overexpressing HrcA revealed the presence of HrcA in the membrane fraction. Together, these results suggest that the two HrcA cysteine residues at positions 118 and 280 function as reduction sensors in the membrane and mediate oligomerization upon stress.

Dual regulation of dnaK and groE operons by HrcA and Ca++ in Streptococcus pneumoniae

The dnaK and groE operons in Streptococcus pneumoniae are repressed by HrcA in the presence of Ca(++). However, it is unclear how HrcA and Ca(++) regulate the dnaK and groE operons. This study examined the dual regulation of the dnaK and groE operons in S. pneumoniae by HrcA and Ca(++). At 30 degrees C, the hrcA mutant showed a constitutively higher level of dnaK expression at both the protein and mRNA levels than that of the wild type whereas the level of groEL expression was relatively unchanged. On the other hand, the levels of both dnaK and groEL transcripts were increased after heat shock but the hrcA mutant was not sensitive to heat shock. Immunoblot analysis of the cells pretreated with the Ca(++) chelator, BAPTA-AM, revealed the induction of HrcA and GroEL at both 30 degrees C and 42 degrees C. However, at longer preincubation time with BAPTA-AM, GroEL was further induced but the level of HrcA decreased suggesting that Ca(++) regulates the dnaK and groE operons differently. Overall, Ca(++) and HrcA differentially regulate the transcription of the dnaK and groE operons in S. pneumoniae. These results are expected to contribute to resolving the relationship between DnaK/GroEL expression and the pathogenesis in S. pneumoniae.

ClpL is essential for induction of thermotolerance and is potentially part of the HrcA regulon in Lactobacillus gasseri

Stress-inducible proteins are likely to contribute to the survival and activity of probiotic bacteria during industrial processes and in the gastrointestinal tract. The recently published genome sequence of probiotic Lactobacillus gasseri ATCC 33323 suggests the presence of ClpC, ClpE, ClpL, and ClpX from the Clp ATPase family of stress proteins. The heat-shock response of L. gasseri was studied using 2-D DIGE. A total of 20 protein spots showing significant (p<0.05) increase in abundance after 30 min heat-shock were identified, including DnaK, GroEL, ClpC, ClpE, and ClpL. To study the physiological role of ClpL, one of the most highly induced proteins during heat-shock, its corresponding gene was inactivated. The DeltaclpL mutant strain had growth characteristics that were indistinguishable from wild-type under several stress conditions. However, in the absence of functional ClpL, L. gasseri exhibited drastically reduced survival at a lethal temperature and was unable to induce thermotolerance. Genome sequences indicate that the expression of clp genes in several Lactobacillus species is regulated by HrcA, instead of CtsR, the conserved clp gene regulator of low G+C Gram-positive bacteria. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays using L. gasseri HrcA protein and clpL upstream fragments revealed, for the first time, a direct interaction between HrcA and the promoter of a clp gene from a Lactobacillus.

Expression, purification and characterization of the membrane-associated HrcA repressor protein of Helicobacter pylori

Helicobacter pylori, a microaerophilic, gram-negative bacterium is a human pathogen that colonizes the gastric niche and is associated with several acute and chronic stomach diseases. In order to survive in the gastric environment and become pathogenic, the bacterium relies on a plethora of virulence factors, which also include heat shock proteins. We previously showed that two out of the three operons encoding the major cellular chaperone machineries are transcriptionally repressed by two regulators, HrcA and HspR. Till now, molecular studies aimed at the understanding of the role of each protein in controlling transcription was hampered by toxicity and insolubility of HrcA in heterologous expression systems. Similar problems were encountered by many other groups studying HrcA from different bacteria. In this study, we analyzed the amino acid sequence of HrcA that predicted association of this protein to the inner membrane, which was experimentally verified. Subsequently, we implemented a dedicated induction protocol which enabled the overexpression of the recombinant His-HrcA protein in the soluble fraction of Escherichia coli cells. Moreover, we developed a purification procedure for His-HrcA that allowed us to obtain highly pure preparation of the protein. The functionality of the purified protein was then confirmed with an in vitro DNA-binding assay.

Chlamydial GroEL autoregulates its own expression through direct interactions with the HrcA repressor protein

In the pathogenic bacterium Chlamydia trachomatis, a transcriptional repressor, HrcA, regulates the major heat shock operons, dnaK and groE. Cellular stress causes a transient increase in transcription of these heat shock operons through relief of HrcA-mediated repression, but the pathway leading to derepression is unclear. Elevated temperature alone is not sufficient, and it is hypothesized that additional chlamydial factors play a role. We used DNA affinity chromatography to purify proteins that interact with HrcA in vivo and identified a higher-order complex consisting of HrcA, GroEL, and GroES. This endogenous HrcA complex migrated differently than recombinant HrcA, but the complex could be disrupted, releasing native HrcA that resembled recombinant HrcA. In in vitro assays, GroEL increased the ability of HrcA to bind to the CIRCE operator and to repress transcription. Other chlamydial heat shock proteins, including the two additional GroEL paralogs present in all chlamydial species, did not modulate HrcA activity.

Ca2+-dependent expression of the CIRCE regulon in Streptococcus pneumoniae

DnaK and GroEL play a pivotal role in protein folding, and promote cell proliferation and survival. In Gram-positive and several Gram-negative bacteria, HrcA represses the transcription of dnaK and groE operons by binding to the highly conserved CIRCE (controlling inverted repeat of chaperone expression) operator sequence in the presence of GroEL. HrcA may respond to environmental stress and various other factors that modulate the transcription of the dnaK and groE operons. However, the mechanisms by which these factors modulate the activity of HrcA remain elusive. Here, we show that the thermoresistance of Streptococcus pneumoniae is significantly repressed in the presence of Ca2+. Furthermore, heat shock-induced expression of the CIRCE regulon in S. pneumoniae is repressed in the presence of Ca2+, although to a lesser degree than in the hrcA mutant, strongly suggesting that HrcA inhibits expression of the CIRCE regulon in a Ca2+-dependent manner. Although HrcA does not bind directly to Ca2+, its hydrophobicity is increased in the presence of the metal ion. Taken together, our observations suggest that Ca2+ induces conformational changes, such as exposure of the hydrophobic surfaces of HrcA, which facilitate binding to GroEL. Alternatively, the presence of Ca2+ may facilitate GroEL in interacting freely with HrcA. This, in turn, enhances access to CIRCE and leads to repression of the dnaK and groE operons in S. pneumoniae.

Stress response gene regulation in Chlamydia is dependent on HrcA-CIRCE interactions

HrcA is a transcriptional repressor that regulates stress response genes in many bacteria by binding to the CIRCE operator. We have previously shown that HrcA regulates the promoter for the dnaK heat shock operon in Chlamydia. Here we demonstrate that HrcA represses a second heat shock promoter that controls the expression of groES and groEL, two other major chlamydial heat shock genes. The CIRCE element of C. trachomatis groEL is the most divergent of known bacterial CIRCE elements, and HrcA had a decreased ability to bind to this nonconsensus operator and repress transcription. We demonstrate that the CIRCE element is necessary and sufficient for transcriptional regulation by chlamydial HrcA and that the inverted repeats of CIRCE are the binding sites for HrcA. Addition of a CIRCE element upstream of a non-heat-shock promoter allowed this promoter to be repressed by HrcA, showing in principle that a chlamydial promoter can be genetically modified to be inducible. These results demonstrate that HrcA is the regulator of the major chlamydial heat shock operons, and we infer that the mechanism of the heat shock response in Chlamydia is derepression. However, derepression is likely to involve more than a direct effect of increased temperature as we found that HrcA binding to CIRCE and HrcA-mediated repression were not altered at temperatures that induce the heat shock response.

Targeted inactivation of the hrcA repressor gene in cyanobacteria

To determine if the CIRCE/HrcA system operates in cyanobacteria, we have inactivated the hrcA repressor gene in Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 by gene targeting. In the hrcA mutant, the groESL1 operon and the groEL2 gene, both of which have the CIRCE operator in their upstream regions, were derepressed at 30 degrees C without affecting expression of other major heat-shock genes. However, expression of these groE genes in the mutant was not fully derepressed. Their transcription increased further upon heat shock, and was initiated from the same sites as those used under normal conditions. This suggests that their expression is regulated by at least two different mechanisms, a negative one controlled by HrcA and an unknown positive one. The heat-induced expression of clpB1 and htpG was greatly repressed by the absence of HrcA. The hrcA mutant which constitutively overexpressed GroEL displayed improved cellular thermotolerance and also reduced photobleaching of phycocyanin under heat stress conditions.

Comparative genomics reveal novel heat shock regulatory mechanisms in Staphylococcus aureus and other Gram-positive bacteria

Multiple regulatory mechanisms for coping with stress co-exist in low G+C Gram-positive bacteria. Among these, the HrcA and CtsR repressors control distinct regulons in the model organism, Bacillus subtilis. We recently identified an orthologue of the CtsR regulator of stress response in the major pathogen, Staphylococcus aureus. Sequence analysis of the S. aureus genome revealed the presence of potential CtsR operator sites not only upstream from genes encoding subunits of the Clp ATP-dependent protease, as in B. subtilis, but also, unexpectedly, within the promoter regions of the dnaK and groESL operons known to be specifically controlled by HrcA. The tandem arrangement of the CtsR and HrcA operators suggests a novel mode of dual heat shock regulation by these two repressors. The S. aureus ctsR and hrcA genes were cloned under the control of the PxylA xylose-inducible promoter and used to demonstrate dual regulation of the dnaK and groESL operons by both CtsR and HrcA, using B. subtilis as a heterologous host. Direct binding by both repressors was shown in vitro by gel mobility shift and DNase I footprinting experiments using purified S. aureus CtsR and HrcA proteins. DeltactsR, DeltahrcA and DeltactsRDeltahrcA mutants of S. aureus were constructed, indicating that the two repressors are not redundant but, instead, act together synergistically to maintain low basal levels of expression of the dnaK and groESL operons in the absence of stress. This novel regulatory mode appears to be specific to Staphylococci.

Identification of a helix-turn-helix motif of Bacillus thermoglucosidasius HrcA essential for binding to the CIRCE element and thermostability of the HrcA-CIRCE complex, indicating a role as a thermosensor

In the heat shock response of bacillary cells, HrcA repressor proteins negatively control the expression of the major heat shock genes, the groE and dnaK operons, by binding the CIRCE (controlling inverted repeat of chaperone expression) element. Studies on two critical but yet unresolved issues related to the structure and function of HrcA were performed using mainly the HrcA from the obligate thermophile Bacillus thermoglucosidasius KP1006. These two critical issues are (i) identifying the region at which HrcA binds to the CIRCE element and (ii) determining whether HrcA can play the role of a thermosensor. We identified the position of a helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif in B. thermoglucosidasius HrcA, which is typical of DNA-binding proteins, and indicated that two residues in the HTH motif are crucial for the binding of HrcA to the CIRCE element. Furthermore, we compared the thermostabilities of the HrcA-CIRCE complexes derived from Bacillus subtilis and B. thermoglucosidasius, which grow at vastly different ranges of temperature. The thermostability profiles of their HrcA-CIRCE complexes were quite consistent with the difference in the growth temperatures of B. thermoglucosidasius and B. subtilis and, thus, suggested that HrcA can function as a thermosensor to detect temperature changes in cells.

Functional analysis of the heat shock regulator HrcA of Chlamydia trachomatis

HrcA is a regulator of bacterial heat shock gene expression that binds to a cis-acting DNA element called CIRCE. It has been proposed that HrcA and CIRCE function as a repressor-operator pair. We have purified recombinant HrcA from the pathogenic bacterium Chlamydia trachomatis and have shown that it is a DNA-binding protein that functions as a negative regulator of transcription. HrcA bound specifically to the CIRCE element in a concentration-dependent manner. HrcA repressed the in vitro transcription of a chlamydial heat shock promoter, and this repression was promoter specific. HrcA-mediated repression appears to be dependent on the topological state of the promoter, as repression on a supercoiled promoter template was greater than that on a linearized template. These results provide direct support for the role of HrcA as a transcriptional repressor in bacteria. This is the first report of the in vitro reconstitution of transcriptional regulation in Chlamydia.

Isolation and analysis of mutant alleles of the Bacillus subtilis HrcA repressor with reduced dependency on GroE function

The hrcA gene of Bacillus subtilis codes for a transcriptional repressor protein that negatively regulates expression of the heptacistronic dnaK and the bicistronic groE operon by binding to an operator-element called CIRCE. Recently, we have published data suggesting that the activity of HrcA is modulated by the GroE chaperonin system. Biochemical analyses of the HrcA protein have been hampered so far by its strong tendency to aggregate. Here, a genetic method was used to isolate mutant forms of HrcA with increased activity under conditions of decreased GroE function. One of these mutant forms (HrcA114) containing five amino acid replacements exhibited enhanced solubility when overexpressed. HrcA114 purified under native conditions produced two retarded CIRCE-containing DNA fragments in band shift experiments. The amount of the larger fragment increased after addition of GroEL, GroES, and ATP but decreased when ATP was replaced by the nonhydrolyzable ATP analog ATPgammaS. DNase I footprinting experiments exhibited full protection of the CIRCE element and neighboring nucleotides in an asymmetric way. An in vitro binding assay using affinity chromatography showed direct and specific interaction between HrcA114 and GroEL. All these experimental data are in full agreement with our previously published model that HrcA needs the GroE chaperonin system for activation.