Evaluation of Level of Agreement in Bordetella Species Identification in Three U.S. Laboratories during a Period of Increased Pertussis

Comparison of Bordetella species identification among differing rt-PCR assays in the United States

In the United States, the general laboratory method for diagnosing pertussis, caused by Bordetella pertussis, is real-time PCR (rt-PCR) targeting insertion sequence 481 (IS481). Other Bordetella species (parapertussis, holmesii, and bronchiseptica) can also cause a pertussis-like syndrome, and some commercial laboratory assays include the insertion sequence 1001 (pIS1001) that can detect B. parapertussis/B. bronchiseptica (BppBb). Because IS481 exists in B. pertussis and B. holmesii, current commercial assays cannot differentiate these two species. We used a multiplex rt-PCR assay containing species-specific targets to Bordetella to evaluate clinical specimens detected as B. pertussis/B. holmesii (BpBh) or BppBb by commercial laboratories. A sample of 3,984 clinical specimens positive for IS481 or pIS1001 from two commercial laboratories during 2012-2019 were re-tested at CDC. Agreement of Bordetella species between the CDC and commercial laboratory assays, and the proportion of commercial laboratory specimens that were non-B. pertussis by CDC's assay was assessed. Overall agreement in Bordetella species detection and identification between the CDC and commercial lab assays was 85%. Agreement for identifying B. pertussis was 87% for 3,663 BpBh specimens and 98% for identifying B. parapertussis in 310 BppBb specimens. CDC's assay detected B. holmesii in 55/3,984 (1.4%) specimens. Most discrepant results (410/490, 82%) were BpBh specimens interpreted as indeterminate B. pertussis at CDC. We found a small portion of B. holmesii in a sample of IS481-positive clinical specimens originally identified by commercial laboratory rt-PCR assays, suggesting that commercial PCR assays are a reliable diagnostic tool for correctly identifying Bordetella species in most patients with suspected pertussis.

IMPORTANCE

When testing specimens collected from patients with suspected pertussis, large-scale commercial laboratories in the United States employ an IS481-based assay that cannot differentiate between Bordetella pertussis and Bordetella holmseii. The level of B. holmesii causing pertussis-like illness in the United States is not well-understood given that only B. pertussis is nationally notifiable. After re-testing with a multiplex, species-specific rt-PCR assay, our data show low levels of B. holmesii identified in a sample of IS481-positive clinical specimens originally identified by commercial laboratory rt-PCR assays. These results reinforce the validity of large-scale commercial rt-PCR testing as a reliable diagnostic tool for pertussis in the United States.

Detection of Bordetella spp. in children with pertussis-like illness from 2018 to 2024 in China

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the role of Bordetella pertussis (B. pertussis), B. parapertussis, B. holmesii, and B. bronchiseptica on pertussis resurgence in China, particularly the sharp rise since the latest winter.

METHODS

Nasopharyngeal swabs collected from children with pertussis-like illness from January 2018 to March 2024 were cultured to detect B. pertussis, B. parapertussis, B. holmesii, and B. bronchiseptica, and tested for all of these except for B. bronchiseptica using a pooled real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) kit targeting insertion sequences ptxS1, IS481, IS1001, and hIS1001.

RESULTS

Out of the collected 7732 nasopharyngeal swabs, 1531 cases tested positive for B. pertussis (19.8%, 1531/7732), and 10 cases were positive for B. parapertussis (0.1%, 10/7732). B. holmesii and B.bronchiseptica were not detected. The number of specimens and the detection rate of B. pertussis were 1709 and 26.9% (459/1709) in 2018, 1936 and 20.7% (400/1936) in 2019, which sharply declined to 308 and 11.4% (35/308) in 2020, 306 and 4.2% (13/306) in 2021, and then notably increased to 754 and 17.6% (133/754) in 2022, 1842 and 16.0% (295/1842) in 2023, 877 and 22.3% (196/877) in the first quarter of 2024. The proportion of children aged 3 to less than 6 years (preschool age) and 6 to 16 years (school age) in pertussis cases increased significantly during the study period, especially the proportion of school-aged children increased from 2.0% (9/459) in 2018 to 40.8% (80/196) in 2024.

CONCLUSIONS

B. pertussis was the predominant pathogen among children with pertussis-like illness in China, with sporadic detection of B. parapertussis and no detection of B. holmesii or B.bronchiseptica. The preschool and school-age children are increasingly prevalent in B. pertussis infection cases, which may be associated with the latest rapid escalation of pertussis outbreak.

Strengthening Bordetella pertussis genomic surveillance by direct sequencing of residual positive specimens

Whole-genome sequencing (WGS) of microbial pathogens recovered from patients with infectious disease facilitates high-resolution strain characterization and molecular epidemiology. However, increasing reliance on culture-independent methods to diagnose infectious diseases has resulted in few isolates available for WGS. Here, we report a novel culture-independent approach to genome characterization of Bordetella pertussis, the causative agent of pertussis and a paradigm for insufficient genomic surveillance due to limited culture of clinical isolates. Sequencing libraries constructed directly from residual pertussis-positive diagnostic nasopharyngeal specimens were hybridized with biotinylated RNA "baits" targeting B. pertussis fragments within complex mixtures that contained high concentrations of host and microbial background DNA. Recovery of B. pertussis genome sequence data was evaluated with mock and pooled negative clinical specimens spiked with reducing concentrations of either purified DNA or inactivated cells. Targeted enrichment increased the yield of B. pertussis sequencing reads up to 90% while simultaneously decreasing host reads to less than 10%. Filtered sequencing reads provided sufficient genome coverage to perform characterization via whole-genome single nucleotide polymorphisms and whole-genome multilocus sequencing typing. Moreover, these data were concordant with sequenced isolates recovered from the same specimens such that phylogenetic reconstructions from either consistently clustered the same putatively linked cases. The optimized protocol is suitable for nasopharyngeal specimens with diagnostic IS481 Ct < 35 and >10 ng DNA. Routine implementation of these methods could strengthen surveillance and study of pertussis resurgence by capturing additional cases with genomic characterization.

A pangenome approach-based loop-mediated isothermal amplification assay for the specific and early detection of Bordetella pertussis

Despite widespread vaccination, Bordetella pertussis continues to cause pertussis infections worldwide, leaving infants at the highest risk of severe illness and death, while people around them are likely the main sources of infection and rapidly spread the disease. Rapid and less complex molecular testing for the specific and timely diagnosis of pertussis remains a challenge that could help to prevent the disease from worsening and prevent its transmission. We aimed to develop and validate a colorimetric loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) assay using a new target uvrD_2 informed by the pangenome for the specific and early detection of B. pertussis. Compared to that of multitarget quantitative polymerase chain reaction (multitarget qPCR) using a large clinical DNA specimen (n = 600), the diagnostic sensitivity and specificity of the uvrD_2 LAMP assay were 100.0% and 98.6%, respectively, with a 99.7% degree of agreement between the two assays. The novel colorimetric uvrD_2 LAMP assay is highly sensitive and specific for detecting B. pertussis DNA in nasopharyngeal swabs and showed similar diagnostic accuracy to complex and high-cost multitarget qPCR, but it is faster, simpler, and inexpensive, which makes it very helpful for the reliable and timely diagnosis of pertussis in primary health care and resource-limited settings.

Pertussis among patients with clinically compatible illness in the Amhara Regional State, Ethiopia

BACKGROUND

Pertussis is an acute respiratory tract disease caused by Bordetella pertussis. In 2014, 24.1 million pertussis cases, resulting in 160,700 deaths, were estimated to have occurred worldwide. This study aimed to determine the epidemiology of pertussis among patients with clinically compatible illness who visited selected hospitals in the Amhara Regional State of Ethiopia.

METHODS

A cross-sectional study design was used to review pertussis patients with clinically compatible illness. Nasopharyngeal swabs were collected from 515 patients from July 2018 through February 2019. DNA was extracted from all nasopharyngeal swabs and samples were analyzed using real-time (RT-) PCR. Crude and adjusted odds ratios with corresponding 95% confidence intervals were estimated using bivariable and multivariable logistic regression analysis, respectively.

RESULTS

The overall prevalence of Bordetella species among the study participants was 156 of 515 (30.3%) [95% CI = 26.4-34.6] as determined by Bordetella RT-PCR, including: 65 (41.7%) B. pertussis, 89 (57.1%) indeterminate B. pertussis, one (0.6%) Bordetella holmesii and one (0.6%) Bordetella parapertussis.

CONCLUSIONS

This study found that pertussis is potentially endemic and a common health problem among patients visiting health institutions in the Amhara Regional State of Ethiopia. More data regarding pertussis in Ethiopia could inform development of effective prevention strategies.

Virus Coinfection is a Predictor of Radiologically Confirmed Pneumonia in Children with Bordetella pertussis Infection

Introduction

This study aimed to prospectively investigate the burden of pertussis in southeast Chinese children hospitalized with lower respiratory tract infection (LRTI) during a pertussis outbreak and to compare the outcomes of Bordetella pertussis infection with or without virus coinfections.

Methods

Children < 24 months of age hospitalized with LRTI were prospectively enrolled from January 2017 to December 2019. Demographic and clinical information were recorded, and respiratory tract samples were tested for the presence of B. pertussis and ten common viruses by polymerase chain reaction (PCR).

Results

Bordetella pertussis PCR was positive in 6.1% (202/4287) of the patients. Only 146 (72.3%) B. pertussis infections met the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention case definition for pertussis. Among the 202 subjects with B. pertussis infections, 81 (40.1%) were coinfected with at least 1 respiratory virus, with human rhinovirus being the most commonly detected virus (25.7%). No differences in clinical severity were observed between children with single B. pertussis infection and those with virus coinfection [odds ratio (OR) 0.75; 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.39–1.44]. However, children with virus coinfection were significantly more likely to present with radiologically confirmed pneumonia than those with a single B. pertussis infection (OR 2.62; CI 1.39–4.91).

Conclusions

Bordetella pertussis infection contributed to a high proportion of LRTI hospitalizations among southeast Chinese children. There were no significant differences in clinical severity between children with virus coinfection and single B. pertussis infection, although children coinfected with virus coinfection presented with pneumonia more frequently than those with single B. pertussis infection.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1007/s40121-020-00376-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Conserved Patterns of Symmetric Inversion in the Genome Evolution of Bordetella Respiratory Pathogens

Whooping cough (pertussis), primarily caused by Bordetella pertussis, has resurged in the United States, and circulating strains exhibit considerable chromosome structural fluidity in the form of rearrangement and deletion. The genus Bordetella includes additional pathogenic species infecting various animals, some even causing pertussis-like respiratory disease in humans; however, investigation of their genome evolution has been limited. We studied chromosome structure in complete genome sequences from 167 Bordetella species isolates, as well as 469 B. pertussis isolates, to gain a generalized understanding of rearrangement patterns among these related pathogens. Observed changes in gene order primarily resulted from large inversions and were only detected in species with genomes harboring multicopy insertion sequence (IS) elements, most notably B. holmesii and B. parapertussis While genomes of B. pertussis contain >240 copies of IS481, IS elements appear less numerous in other species and yield less chromosome structural diversity through rearrangement. These data were further used to predict all possible rearrangements between IS element copies present in Bordetella genomes, revealing that only a subset is observed among circulating strains. Therefore, while it appears that rearrangement occurs less frequently in other species than in B. pertussis, these clinically relevant respiratory pathogens likely experience similar mutation of gene order. The resulting chromosome structural fluidity presents both challenges and opportunity for the study of Bordetella respiratory pathogens.IMPORTANCE Bordetella pertussis is the primary agent of whooping cough (pertussis). The Bordetella genus includes additional pathogens of animals and humans, including some that cause pertussis-like respiratory illness. The chromosome of B. pertussis has previously been shown to exhibit considerable structural rearrangement, but insufficient data have prevented comparable investigation in related species. In this study, we analyze chromosome structure variation in several Bordetella species to gain a generalized understanding of rearrangement patterns in this genus. Just as in B. pertussis, we observed inversions in other species that likely result from common mutational processes. We used these data to further predict additional, unobserved inversions, suggesting that specific genome structures may be preferred in each species.

Clinical evaluation and validation of laboratory methods for the diagnosis of Bordetella pertussis infection: Culture, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and anti-pertussis toxin IgG serology (IgG-PT)

Introduction

The appropriate use of clinically accurate diagnostic tests is essential for the detection of pertussis, a poorly controlled vaccine-preventable disease. The purpose of this study was to estimate the sensitivity and specificity of different diagnostic criteria including culture, multi-target polymerase chain reaction (PCR), anti-pertussis toxin IgG (IgG-PT) serology, and the use of a clinical case definition. An additional objective was to describe the optimal timing of specimen collection for the various tests.

Methods

Clinical specimens were collected from patients with cough illness at seven locations across the United States between 2007 and 2011. Nasopharyngeal and blood specimens were collected from each patient during the enrollment visit. Patients who had been coughing for ≤ 2 weeks were asked to return in 2–4 weeks for collection of a second, convalescent blood specimen. Sensitivity and specificity of each diagnostic test were estimated using three methods—pertussis culture as the “gold standard,” composite reference standard analysis (CRS), and latent class analysis (LCA).

Results

Overall, 868 patients were enrolled and 13.6% were B. pertussis positive by at least one diagnostic test. In a sample of 545 participants with non-missing data on all four diagnostic criteria, culture was 64.0% sensitive, PCR was 90.6% sensitive, and both were 100% specific by LCA. CRS and LCA methods increased the sensitivity estimates for convalescent serology and the clinical case definition over the culture-based estimates. Culture and PCR were most sensitive when performed during the first two weeks of cough; serology was optimally sensitive after the second week of cough.

Conclusions

Timing of specimen collection in relation to onset of illness should be considered when ordering diagnostic tests for pertussis. Consideration should be given to including IgG-PT serology as a confirmatory test in the Council of State and Territorial Epidemiologists (CSTE) case definition for pertussis.

Trends in Pertussis Diagnostic Testing in the United States, 1990 to 2012

BACKGROUND

Reports of pertussis have been increasing in the US since the 1990s, and pertussis diagnostics have evolved during that time. Here, we describe temporal changes in pertussis diagnostic practices in the US during 1990 to 2012 and discuss potential implications.

METHODS

Pertussis cases reported through the National Notifiable Diseases Surveillance System during 1990 to 2012 were included in this analysis. Laboratory results were stratified by test type, case classification, age group and case-patient state of residence.

RESULTS

This analysis included 291,290 cases with 64% (n = 186,766) reporting at least 1 pertussis laboratory result. Culture and direct fluorescent antibody were the primary results reported during the early 1990s; however, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) surpassed all other test types during the late 1990s and 2000s. By 2012, more than 91% of cases with known results were tested using PCR, either alone or in combination with another test type. Before 2005, Massachusetts reported 71% of serology results, but an increasing number of states reported serologic results during 2005 to 2012. When stratified by age group, overall testing trends persist. As of 2012, culture confirmation is used infrequently across all ages, whereas the use of serology increases with age and is most prevalent among adults aged ≥ 20 years.

CONCLUSIONS

PCR has become the primary diagnostic method, and serologic assays now are used in a majority of states. Epidemiologic trends must be considered in the context of changing diagnostic tests, and modifications to surveillance case definitions should be considered to better reflect current testing practices.

Validation of a loop-mediated isothermal amplification assay for rapid diagnosis of pertussis infection in nasopharyngeal samples

OBJECTIVE

To develop and validate a novel loop-mediated amplification (LAMP) assay for rapid diagnosis (<1 hour) of whooping cough in nasopharyngeal samples versus the gold standard: real-time PCR.

METHODS

The study included all nasopharyngeal samples (n = 213) collected from children with clinical suspicion of pertussis admitted to Children's University Hospital Sant Joan de Déu (Barcelona, Spain) during July-December 2014. Fresh samples were routinely analyzed by real-time PCR and stored for retrospective LAMP analysis, following an easy 30 minute DNA extraction step by Chelex-100.

RESULTS

Performance results of the LAMP assay were: linearity, 10(5)-10(1) CFU/ml; Limit of Detection, 2 CFU/ml; precision (mean CV), 7.38%; diagnostic sensitivity, 96.55%; diagnostic specificity, 99.46%; time to detection, 12-30 minutes.

CONCLUSION

The new test was shown to be 2.5-fold faster than real-time PCR while maintaining similar levels of analytical and clinical performance. Therefore it could become a useful diagnostic tool for molecular point-of-care testing.

Laboratory-based surveillance of pertussis using multitarget real-time PCR in Japan: evidence for Bordetella pertussis infection in preteens and teens

Between January 2013 and December 2014, we conducted laboratory-based surveillance of pertussis using multitarget real-time PCR, which discriminates among Bordetella pertussis, Bordetella parapertussis, Bordetella holmesii and Mycoplasma pneumoniae. Of 355 patients clinically diagnosed with pertussis in Japan, B. pertussis, B. parapertussis and M. pneumoniae were detected in 26% (n = 94), 1.1% (n = 4) and 0.6% (n = 2), respectively, whereas B. holmesii was not detected. It was confirmed that B. parapertussis and M. pneumoniae are also responsible for causing pertussis-like illness. The positive rates for B. pertussis ranged from 16% to 49%, depending on age. Infants aged ≤ 3 months had the highest rate (49%), and children aged 1 to 4 years had the lowest rate (16%, p < 0.01 vs. infants aged ≤ 3 months). Persons aged 10 to 14 and 15 to 19 years also showed high positive rates (29% each); the positive rates were not statistically significant compared with that of infants aged ≤ 3 months (p ≥ 0.06). Our observations indicate that similar to infants, preteens and teens are at high risk of B. pertussis infection.

Laboratory Diagnosis of Pertussis

The introduction of vaccination in the 1950s significantly reduced the morbidity and mortality of pertussis. However, since the 1990s, a resurgence of pertussis has been observed in vaccinated populations, and a number of causes have been proposed for this phenomenon, including improved diagnostics, increased awareness, waning immunity, and pathogen adaptation. The resurgence of pertussis highlights the importance of standardized, sensitive, and specific laboratory diagnoses, the lack of which is responsible for the large differences in pertussis notifications between countries. Accurate laboratory diagnosis is also important for distinguishing between the several etiologic agents of pertussis-like diseases, which involve both viruses and bacteria. If pertussis is diagnosed in a timely manner, antibiotic treatment of the patient can mitigate the symptoms and prevent transmission. During an outbreak, timely diagnosis of pertussis allows prophylactic treatment of infants too young to be (fully) vaccinated, for whom pertussis is a severe, sometimes fatal disease. Finally, reliable diagnosis of pertussis is required to reveal trends in the (age-specific) disease incidence, which may point to changes in vaccine efficacy, waning immunity, and the emergence of vaccine-adapted strains. Here we review current approaches to the diagnosis of pertussis and discuss their limitations and strengths. In particular, we emphasize that the optimal diagnostic procedure depends on the stage of the disease, the age of the patient, and the vaccination status of the patient.