Transduction of cellular neo mRNA by retrovirus-mediated recombination

Non-canonical nematode endogenous retroviruses resulting from RNA virus glycoprotein gene capture by a metavirus

Reverse-transcribing retroviruses exist as horizontally transmitted infectious agents or vertically transmitted endogenous retroviruses (ERVs) resident in eukaryotic genomes, and they are phylogenetically related to the long terminal repeat (LTR) class of retrotransposons. ERVs and retrotransposons are often distinguished only by the presence or absence of a gene encoding the envelope glycoprotein (env). Endogenous elements of the virus family Metaviridae include the insect-restricted Errantivirus genus of ERVs, for which some members possess env, and the pan-eukaryotic Metavirus genus that lacks an envelope glycoprotein gene. Here we report a novel Nematoda endogenous retrovirus (NERV) clade with core retroviral genes arranged uniquely as a continuous gag-env-pro-pol ORF. Reverse transcriptase sequences were phylogenetically related to metaviruses, but envelope glycoprotein sequences resembled those of the Nyamiviridae and Chrysoviridae RNA virus families, suggesting env gene capture during host cell infection by an RNA virus. NERVs were monophyletic, restricted to the nematode subclass Chromadoria, and included additional ORFs for a small hypothetical protein or a large Upf1-like RNA-dependent AAA-ATPase/helicase indicative of viral transduction of a host gene. Provirus LTR identity, low copy number, ORF integrity and segregation of three loci in Meloidogyne incognita, taken together with detection of NERV transcriptional activity, support potential infectivity of NERVs, along with their recent emergence and integration. Altogether, NERVs constitute a new and distinct Metaviridae lineage demonstrating retroviral evolution through sequential heterologous gene capture events.

Hairpin-induced tRNA-mediated (HITME) recombination in HIV-1

Recombination due to template switching during reverse transcription is a major source of genetic variability in retroviruses. In the present study we forced a recombination event in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) by electroporation of T cells with DNA from a molecular HIV-1 clone that has a 300 bp long hairpin structure in the Nef gene (HIV-lhNef). HIV-lhNef does not replicate, but replication-competent escape variants emerged in four independent cultures. The major part of the hairpin was deleted in all escape viruses. In three cases, the hairpin deletion was linked to patch insertion of tRNA^asp, tRNA^glu or tRNA^trp sequences. The tRNAs were inserted in the viral genome in the antisense orientation, indicating that tRNA-mediated recombination occurred during minus-strand DNA synthesis. We here propose a mechanistic model for this hairpin-induced tRNA-mediated (HITME) recombination. The transient role of the cellular tRNA molecule as enhancer of retroviral recombination is illustrated by the eventual removal of inserted tRNA sequences by a subsequent recombination/deletion event.

Strand transfer to the 5' part of a tRNA as a mechanism for retrovirus patch-repair recombination in vivo

By screening for marker-cassette deletion mutants of a murine leukaemia virus-based replication-competent vector, two occurrences of tRNA sequence patch insertions were identified. In one of the cases, 28 nucleotides from the 5' end of tRNA(Lys4) were inserted in the plus-strand orientation, which points to a novel strand-transfer mechanism to tRNAs during reverse transcriptase-mediated retroviral recombination.

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 transductive recombination can occur frequently and in proportion to polyadenylation signal readthrough

One model for retroviral transduction suggests that template switching between viral RNAs and polyadenylation readthrough sequences is responsible for the generation of acute transforming retroviruses. For this study, we examined reverse transcription products of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-based vectors designed to mimic postulated transduction intermediates. For maximization of the discontinuous mode of DNA synthesis proposed to generate transductants, sequences located between the vectors' two long terminal repeats (vector "body" sequences) and polyadenylation readthrough "tail" sequences were made highly homologous. Ten genetic markers were introduced to indicate which products had acquired tail sequences by a process we term transductive recombination. Marker segregation patterns for over 100 individual products were determined, and they revealed that more than half of the progeny proviruses were transductive recombinants. Although most crossovers occurred in regions of homology, about 5% were nonhomologous and some included insertions. Ratios of encapsidated readthrough and polyadenylated transcripts for vectors with wild-type and inactivated polyadenylation signals were compared, and transductive recombination frequencies were found to correlate with the readthrough transcript prevalence. In assays in which either vector body or tail could serve as a recombination donor, recombination between tail and body sequences was at least as frequent as body-body exchange. We propose that transductive recombination may contribute to natural HIV variation by providing a mechanism for the acquisition of nongenomic sequences.

Transduction of cellular sequence by a human immunodeficiency virus type 1-derived vector

During studies examining the rate of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) mutation in a single cycle of replication, the 5' long terminal repeat of one progeny provirus was found to contain an insertion of 147 bp including an entire tRNA sequence as well as an additional 66 bp insertion of nonviral origin. Database searches revealed that 65 of 66 bp aligned with the human CpG island sequence found on chromosomes 6, 14, and 17. Therefore it seems probable that it is of human cellular sequence origin and was transduced by HIV-1. This is the first demonstration that HIV-1 can capture a cellular sequence. The site of integration of the parental provirus was mapped to chromosome 1p32.1. Sequence with homology to the transduced CpG island was not found on chromosome 1, suggesting that the transduced cellular sequence was not linked to the site of viral integration.

Transduction of the human gene FAM8A1 by endogenous retrovirus during primate evolution

Capture of cellular mRNA by mobile elements has been an evolutionary catalyst for the spread of genes and a cause of cancer development. Here we present evidence that an orphan gene, FAM8A1 (family with sequence similarity 8), was captured by a retrovirus, followed by multiple retrotransposition events, during primate evolution between 45 and 58 million years ago. This represents the first record of cellular mRNA transduction in humans. The human gene is localized on chromosome 6p23 with five related pseudogenes (FAM8A2P-A6P), each inserted within a human endogenous retrovirus (HERV). Only the functional FAM8A1 gene is expressed and displays a ubiquitous mRNA and a testis-specific transcript present in the haploid phase of spermatogenesis. The structural features of the FAM8A1 pseudogenes include two short sequences of similarity between the FAM8A1 mRNA and the HERV sequences at both the 5' and 3' integration sites. These hallmarks suggest an alternative model to account for the capture of FAM8A1 cellular mRNA by HERV-K, involving illegitimate recombination events at the two sites of sequence similarity during reverse transcription. Unlike previous models, which assume at least one step of retroviral integration in the genome, our model is consistent with in vitro observations showing that multiple template switches occur among packaged viral transcripts. This leads to the speculation that, in some cases, cellular mRNAs may have been captured through similar processes involved in the retroviral life cycle.

Genetic reassortment and patch repair by recombination in retroviruses

Retroviral particles contain a diploid RNA genome which serves as template for the synthesis of double-stranded DNA in a complex process guided by virus-encoded reverse transcriptase. The dimeric nature of the genome allows the proceeding polymerase to switch templates during copying of the copackaged RNA molecules, leading to the generation of recombinant proviruses that harbor genetic information derived from both parental RNAs. Template switching abilities of reverse transcriptase facilitate the development of mosaic retroviruses with altered functional properties and thereby contribute to the restoration and evolution of retroviruses facing altering selective forces of their environment. This review focuses on the genetic patchwork of retroviruses and how mixing of sequence patches by recombination may lead to repair in terms of re-established replication and facilitate increased viral fitness, enhanced pathogenic potential, and altered virus tropisms. Endogenous retroelements represent an affluent source of functional viral sequences which may hitchhike with virions and serve as sequence donors in patch repair. We describe here the involvement of endogenous viruses in genetic reassortment and patch repair and review important examples derived from cell culture and animal studies. Moreover, we discuss how the patch repair phenomenon may challenge both safe usage of retrovirus-based gene vehicles in human gene therapy and the use of animal organs as xenografts in humans. Finally, the ongoing mixing of distinct human immunodeficiency virus strains and its implications for antiviral treatment is discussed.

Mutations of the kissing-loop dimerization sequence influence the site specificity of murine leukemia virus recombination in vivo

The genetic information of retroviruses is retained within a dimeric RNA genome held together by intermolecular RNA-RNA interactions near the 5' ends. Coencapsidation of retrovirus-derived RNA molecules allows frequent template switching of the virus-encoded reverse transcriptase during DNA synthesis in newly infected cells. We have previously shown that template shifts within the 5' leader of murine leukemia viruses occur preferentially within the kissing stem-loop motif, a cis element crucial for in vitro RNA dimer formation. By use of a forced recombination approach based on single-cycle transfer of Akv murine leukemia virus-based vectors harboring defective primer binding site sequences, we now report that modifications of the kissing-loop structure, ranging from a deletion of the entire sequence to introduction of a single point mutation in the loop motif, significantly disturb site specificity of recombination within the highly structured 5' leader region. In addition, we find that an intact kissing-loop sequence favors optimal RNA encapsidation and vector transduction. Our data are consistent with the kissing-loop dimerization model and suggest that a direct intermolecular RNA-RNA interaction, here mediated by palindromic loop sequences within the mature genomic RNA dimer, facilitates hotspot template switching during retroviral cDNA synthesis in vivo.

Regression of experimental brain tumors with 6-thioxanthine and Escherichia coli gpt gene therapy

The identification of transgenes with antitumor activity is critical to the development of gene therapy of cancer. Retrovirus-mediated transfer of the Escherichia coli gpt gene into rat C6 glioma cells without subsequent selection still inhibited the proliferation of this mixed polyclonal population upon addition of the prodrug, 6-thioxanthine, with an ID50 of 4.1 microM, whereas parental C6 cells were not affected at a concentration of 500 microM. In a time-course assay, effects of the prodrug on the mixed polyclonal cell proliferation required at least 10 days of exposure. In mixed co-cultures, a bystander effect was not present over the first 4 days of prodrug exposure, but required trypsinization of the co-cultures and replating at lower densities. This "modified" bystander assay thus revealed a 50% decrease in C6 cell proliferation, even when the initial ratio of gpt-expressing to parental C6 cells was as low as 1:19. In a nude mouse model of subcutaneous tumors, co-grafts of C6 glioma and gpt-retrovirus producer cells displayed retarded growth upon exposure to 6-thioxanthine (6-TX). In a nude mouse model of intracerebral tumors, grafting of the gpt-retrovirus producer cells leads to an 80% reduction in intracerebral tumor volumes after 6-TX treatment. This reduction results in a 28% increase in the mean time of survival of animals that harbor intracerebral tumors (p < 0.0005). These antitumor effects indicate that the gpt/6-TX enzyme/prodrug pair is a promising alternative to the thymidine kinase gene and ganciclovir combination in the gene therapy of cancer.

cis-active structural motifs involved in specific encapsidation of Moloney murine leukemia virus RNA

We have analyzed the roles of RNA structural motifs located in the 5' part of the Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MuLV) encapsidation domain (Psi region) with regard to their effects on viral replication. Four putative stem-loop structures between the 5' splice donor site and the gag initiation codon have been examined: stem structure A, corresponding to M-MuLV viral nucleotides 211 to 224; stem-loop B, nucleotides 278 to 303; stem-loop C, nucleotides 310 to 352; and stem-loop D, nucleotides 355 to 374. By measuring infectivities, encapsidation and splicing efficiencies, and endogenous reverse transcription levels of motif A, B, C, and D deletion mutants, we identified mutations which affect replication at the encapsidation step. In particular, deletion of all four motifs in a single mutant eliminated encapsidation of viral RNA, while deletion of individual elements moderately reduced the encapsidation efficiencies. Through analysis of different deletion combinations, we found that deletion of the first two motifs (A plus B) reduced both encapsidation and reverse transcription efficiencies, while deletion of the 3' motifs (C plus D) eliminated encapsidation. Interestingly, the C and D motifs both contain a GACG loop sequence and are highly conserved among murine type C retroviruses. Our results indicate that M-MuLV motifs C and D are necessary for efficient encapsidation, and the presence of at least one of these two stem-loops is crucial to encapsidation and virus replication.

The recombination rate is not increased when retroviral RNA is missing an encapsidation sequence

Retroviruses, as a result of the presence of two identical RNA molecules in their virions, recombine at a high rate. When nonhomologous RNA is present in the dimer RNA molecules, nonhomologous recombination occurs, although the rate is only 0.1% of the rate of homologous recombination. We developed a protocol to study transduction of cellular proto-oncogenes in a single cycle of retrovirus replication. The psi sequences is a cis required sequence for packaging viral RNA into viral particles. To test if the rate of nonhomologous recombination increases about 1,000 times when the psi sequence is deleted, as reported by other, we modified vectors we used previously (J. Zhang and H. M. Temin, Science 259:234-238, 1993). Our results indicated that the recombination rate did not undergo the increase of about 1,000 times when the psi sequence of a chimeric RNA was deleted.

A preferred region for recombinational patch repair in the 5' untranslated region of primer binding site-impaired murine leukemia virus vectors

Transduction of primer binding site-impaired Akv murine leukemia virus-based retroviral vectors from the murine packaging cell lines psi-2 and omega E was studied. The efficiency of transduction of the neo marker of all mutated constructs was found to decrease by 5 to 6 orders of magnitude compared with that of the wild-type vector. Thirty-two of 60 transduced proviruses analyzed harbored a primer binding site sequence matching a glutamine tRNA primer. Sequence analysis of the regions flanking the glutamine tRNA primer binding site revealed a distinct pattern of nucleotide differences from the Akv-based vector, suggesting the involvement of a specific endogenous virus-like sequence in patch repair rescue of the primer binding site mutants. The putative recombination partner RNA was found in virions from psi-2 cells as detected by analysis of glutamine tRNA-initiated cDNA and by sequence analysis of regions at or around the glutamine tRNA primer binding site. We propose that the forced recombination of primer binding site mutants involves initial priming on endogenous viral sequences and requires template switching during minus-strand synthesis in the region between the neo gene and the mutated primer binding site to allow correct second-strand transfer in reverse transcription. The system thereby selects for a reverse transcriptase-mediated recombination event in the 5' untranslated region. A panel of sequence differences between the recombination partners in this region has allowed mapping of the site of recombination for each transduction event. Interestingly, the majority of the recombination events were clustered within a narrow, 33-nucleotide region though to be involved in genomic RNA dimerization.

DNA recombination is sufficient for retroviral transduction

Oncogenic retroviruses carry coding sequences that are transduced from cellular protooncogenes. Natural transduction involves two nonhomologous recombinations and is thus extremely rare. Since transduction has never been reproduced experimentally, its mechanism has been studied in terms of two hypotheses: (i) the DNA model, which postulates two DNA recombinations, and (ii) the RNA model, which postulates a 5' DNA recombination and a 3' RNA recombination occurring during reverse transcription of viral and protooncogene RNA. Here we use two viral DNA constructs to test the prediction of the DNA model that the 3' DNA recombination is achieved by conventional integration of a retroviral DNA 3' of the chromosomal protooncogene coding region. For the DNA model to be viable, such recombinant viruses must be infectious without the purportedly essential polypurine tract (ppt) that precedes the 3' long terminal repeat (LTR) of all retroviruses. Our constructs consist of a ras coding region from Harvey sarcoma virus which is naturally linked at the 5' end to a retroviral LTR and artificially linked at the 3' end either directly (construct NdN) or by a cellular sequence (construct SU) to the 5' LTR of a retrovirus. Both constructs lack the ppt, and the LTR of NdN even lacks 30 nucleotides at the 5' end. Both constructs proved to be infectious, producing viruses at titers of 10(5) focus-forming units per ml. Sequence analysis proved that both viruses were colinear with input DNAs and that NdN virus lacked a ppt and the 5' 30 nucleotides of the LTR. The results indicate that DNA recombination is sufficient for retroviral transduction and that neither the ppt nor the complete LTR is essential for retrovirus replication. DNA recombination explains the following observations by others that cannot be reconciled with the RNA model: (i) experimental transduction is independent of the packaging efficiency of viral RNA, and (ii) experimental transduction may invert sequences with respect to others, as expected for DNA recombination during transfection.

The dimerization/packaging sequence is dispensable for both the formation of high-molecular-weight RNA complexes within retroviral particles and the synthesis of proviruses of normal structure

Retroviral particles contain a dimer of two genomic RNA molecules, linked by noncovalent intermolecular bonds. Studies by electron microscopy of viral RNA extracted from virions as well as in vitro studies have implicated a sequence, designated the dimer linkage sequence (DLS), in the dimerization process. The DLS has been localized within a short region encompassing the psi packaging sequence, between nucleotides 212 and 563 for the Moloney murine leukemia retrovirus (MoMLV) RNA. In this report, we show that viral RNAs lacking both the DLS and psi packaging sequences--and even an RNA lacking the first 6,537 nucleotides of MoMLV--can assemble within retroviral particles as high-molecular-weight, slow-migrating, heat-sensitive complexes closely related to those observed for wild-type viral RNAs. Furthermore, we show that proviruses of normal structure are generated upon infection of test cells with retroviral particles which contain the DLS/psi-deleted viral RNAs. These observations demonstrate that the DLS and psi packaging sequences are not essential in cis to form a functional RNA complex for reverse transcription and integration.

A model system for nonhomologous recombination between retroviral and cellular RNA

A current model for the generation of transforming retroviruses proposes that read-through RNAs, containing both viral and cellular sequences, are copackaged with viral genomic RNA. It is, however, possible that a cellular mRNA is occasionally encapsidated into a retroviral particle, even though viral packaging sequences are absent. We have generated recombinant proviruses following copackaging of an avian leukosis viral genomic RNA and a neo-containing RNA completely devoid of retroviral sequences. In these studies, we used the packaging cell line SE21Q1b, which has the unique ability to randomly package cellular mRNA into retroviral particles. We describe 10 recombinants obtained following copackaging of nonhomologous RNAs. Our data show that recombination is not occurring at the DNA level in the parental SE21Q1b cells but is occurring at the RNA level, during reverse transcription. These data further suggest that reverse transcriptase can preferentially jump between templates at short stretches of homology in otherwise unrelated RNAs. We conclude that retroviral sequences are not required for packaged mRNA to be reverse transcribed and to be included in integrated proviruses.

Rate and mechanism of nonhomologous recombination during a single cycle of retroviral replication

Oncogenes discovered in retroviruses such as Rous sarcoma virus were generated by transduction of cellular proto-oncogenes into the viral genome. Several different kinds of junctions between the viral and proto-oncogene sequences have been found in different viruses. A system of retrovirus vectors and a protocol that mimicked this transduction during a single cycle of retrovirus replication was developed. The transduction involved the formation of a chimeric viral-cellular RNA, strand switching of the reverse transcription growing point from an infectious retrovirus to the chimeric RNA, and often a subsequent deletion during the rest of viral DNA synthesis. A short region of sequence identity was frequently used for the strand switching. The rate of this process was about 0.1 to 1 percent of the rate of homologous retroviral recombination.

Characterization of unintegrated retroviral DNA with long terminal repeat-associated cell-derived inserts

We have used a replication-competent shuttle vector based on the genome of Rous sarcoma virus to characterize genomic rearrangements that occur during retrovirus replication. The strategy involved cloning circular DNA that was generated during an acute infection. While analyzing a class of retroviral DNA clones that are greater than full length, we found several clones which had acquired nonviral inserts in positions adjacent to the long terminal repeats (LTRs). There appear to be two distinct mechanisms leading to the incorporation of cellular sequences into these clones. Three of the molecules contain a cell-derived insert at the circle junction site between two LTR units. Two of these molecules appear to be the results of abortive integration attempts, because of which, in each case, one of the LTRs is missing 2 bases at its junction with the cell-derived insert. In the third clone, pNO220, the cellular sequences are flanked by an inappropriately placed copy of the tRNA primer-binding site on one side and a partial copy of the U3 sequence as part of the LTR on the other side. A fourth molecule we characterized, pMD96, has a single LTR with a U5-bounded deletion of viral sequences spanning gag and pol, with cell-derived sequences inserted at the site of the deletion; its origin may be related mechanistically to pNO220. Sequence analysis indicates that all of the cellular inserts were derived from the cell line used for the acute infection rather than from sequences carried into the cell as part of the virus particle. Northern (RNA) analysis of cellular RNA demonstrated that the cell-derived sequences of two clones, pNO220 and pMD96, were expressed as polyadenylated RNA in uninfected cells. One mechanism for the joining of viral and cellular sequences suggested by the structures of pNO220 and pMD96 is recombination occurring during viral DNA synthesis, with cellular RNA serving as the template for the acquisition of cellular sequences.

Homologous recombination of copackaged retrovirus RNAs during reverse transcription

According to prevailing models, the high frequency of recombination in retroviruses occurs during reverse transcription of two genetically different genomes copackaged into virion particles. This view has been tested in our studies of the mechanism of recombination within homologous sequences of two retroviral genomes during a single round of virus replication and in the absence of helper virus. The recombination substrates were Moloney murine leukemia virus-based vectors, each of which contains an altered defective neomycin gene (neo) under the transcriptional control of the 5' long terminal repeat; the 3' sequences of each construct contain either the Moloney murine leukemia virus or simian virus 40 large-T polyadenylation sequence. One neo gene contained a linker insertion mutation at the 5' end (neo minus), and the other contained a deletion and linker insertion at the 3' end (neo delta 3). Each of the mutant neo constructs was introduced into the packaging helper cell line psi 2 by sequential cotransfection, and individual psi 2 double transformants were selected. Supernatant fluids from the cloned psi 2 double transformants were used to infect NIH 3T3 cells, and recombinant neo+ proviruses were detected by their ability to confer G418 resistance during infection of NIH 3T3 cells. Our results show that (i) recombination between a homologous sequence of about 560 bp occurred with a frequency of about 10(-4) per virus replication cycle; (ii) recombination occurred only after the viral RNAs had been packaged into particles, i.e., recombination between the two vector DNAs or between viral RNAs prior to packaging was not detected; and (iii) copackaging of two different genomic RNAs as a heterodimer is a prerequisite for recombination. Furthermore, our results indicate that recombination can occur during the DNA negative-strand synthesis of reverse transcription.

Unusually high frequency of reconstitution of long terminal repeats in U3-minus retrovirus vectors by DNA recombination or gene conversion

Recently, we described a retrovirus vector system with which to study formation of cDNA genes (R. Dornburg and H. M. Temin, Mol. Cell. Biol. 6:2328-2334, 1988; Mol. Cell. Biol. 8:64-72, 1990; J. Virol. 64:886-889, 1990). For these studies, retrovirus vectors were constructed in which the U3 region of the 3' long terminal repeat (LTR) was deleted. After one round of retrovirus replication, such vectors formed a provirus with two U3-minus LTRs. However, the insertion of some additional sequences into such vectors promoted vector rearrangements with an efficiency greater than 95%. Such rearranged vectors behaved like vectors with two wild-type LTRs. Proviruses derived from such vectors were investigated by Southern blot analysis, polymerase chain reaction, and DNA sequencing. We found that the U3 region was reconstituted, resulting in vectors with LTRs like wild-type virus. The sequences that reconstituted the U3 region of the vector LTR were derived from LTR sequences present in the helper cell. Since no retroviral protein coding sequences were detected in infected target cells, recombination of vector sequences with coencapsidated helper cell sequences during reverse transcription seems very unlikely. Thus, it appears that the recombination (or gene conversion) events leading to a vector with reconstituted LTRs occurred at the DNA level. The high frequency of this recombination (or gene conversion) was dependent on internal vector sequences.