Determination of the frequency of retroviral recombination between two identical sequences within a provirus

Identification, molecular cloning, and analysis of full-length hepatitis C virus transmitted/founder genotypes 1, 3, and 4

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is characterized by persistent replication of a complex mixture of viruses termed a “quasispecies.” Transmission is generally associated with a stringent population bottleneck characterized by infection by limited numbers of “transmitted/founder” (T/F) viruses. Characterization of T/F genomes of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) has been integral to studies of transmission, immunopathogenesis, and vaccine development. Here, we describe the identification of complete T/F genomes of HCV by single-genome sequencing of plasma viral RNA from acutely infected subjects. A total of 2,739 single-genome-derived amplicons comprising 10,966,507 bp from 18 acute-phase and 11 chronically infected subjects were analyzed. Acute-phase sequences diversified essentially randomly, except for the poly(U/UC) tract, which was subject to polymerase slippage. Fourteen acute-phase subjects were productively infected by more than one genetically distinct virus, permitting assessment of recombination between replicating genomes. No evidence of recombination was found among 1,589 sequences analyzed. Envelope sequences of T/F genomes lacked transmission signatures that could distinguish them from chronic infection viruses. Among chronically infected subjects, higher nucleotide substitution rates were observed in the poly(U/UC) tract than in envelope hypervariable region 1. Fourteen full-length molecular clones with variable poly(U/UC) sequences corresponding to seven genotype 1a, 1b, 3a, and 4a T/F viruses were generated. Like most unadapted HCV clones, T/F genomes did not replicate efficiently in Huh 7.5 cells, indicating that additional cellular factors or viral adaptations are necessary for in vitro replication. Full-length T/F HCV genomes and their progeny provide unique insights into virus transmission, virus evolution, and virus-host interactions associated with immunopathogenesis.

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infects 2% to 3% of the world’s population and exhibits extraordinary genetic diversity. This diversity is mirrored by HIV-1, where characterization of transmitted/founder (T/F) genomes has been instrumental in studies of virus transmission, immunopathogenesis, and vaccine development. Here, we show that despite major differences in genome organization, replication strategy, and natural history, HCV (like HIV-1) diversifies essentially randomly early in infection, and as a consequence, sequences of actual T/F viruses can be identified. This allowed us to capture by molecular cloning the full-length HCV genomes that are responsible for infecting the first hepatocytes and eliciting the initial immune responses, weeks before these events could be directly analyzed in human subjects. These findings represent an enabling experimental strategy, not only for HCV and HIV-1 research, but also for other RNA viruses of medical importance, including West Nile, chikungunya, dengue, Venezuelan encephalitis, and Ebola viruses.

Recombination can lead to spurious results in retroviral transduction with dually fluorescent reporter genes

Fluorescent proteins are routinely employed as reporters in retroviral vectors. Here, we demonstrate that transduction with retroviral vectors carrying a tandem-dimer Tomato (TdTom) reporter produces two distinct fluorescent cell populations following template jumping due to a single nucleotide polymorphism between the first and second Tomato genes. Template jumping also occurs between repeated sequences in the Tomato and green fluorescent protein (GFP) genes. Thus, proper interpretation of the fluorescence intensity of transduced cells requires caution.

Multiple protein domains mediate interaction between Bcl10 and MALT1

Bcl10 and MALT1 are essential mediators of NF-kappaB activation in response to the triggering of a diverse array of transmembrane receptors, including antigen receptors. Additionally, both proteins are translocation targets in MALT lymphoma. Thus, a detailed understanding of the interaction between these mediators is of considerable biological importance. Previous studies have indicated that a 13-amino acid region downstream of the Bcl10 caspase recruitment domain (CARD) is responsible for interacting with the immunoglobulin-like domains of MALT1. We now provide evidence that the death domain of MALT1 and the CARD of Bcl10 also contribute to Bcl10-MALT1 interactions. Although a direct interaction between the MALT1 death domain and Bcl10 cannot be detected via immunoprecipitation, FRET data strongly suggest that the death domain of MALT1 contributes significantly to the association between Bcl10 and MALT1 in T cells in vivo. Furthermore, analysis of point mutants of conserved residues of Bcl10 shows that the Bcl10 CARD is essential for interaction with the MALT1 N terminus. Mutations that disrupt proper folding of the Bcl10 CARD strongly impair Bcl10-MALT1 interactions. Molecular modeling and functional analyses of Bcl10 point mutants suggest that residues Asp(80) and Glu(84) of helix 5 of the Bcl10 CARD directly contact MALT1. Together, these data demonstrate that the association between Bcl10 and MALT1 involves a complex interaction between multiple protein domains. Moreover, the Bcl10-MALT1 interaction is the second reported example of interactions between a CARD and a non-CARD protein region, which suggests that many signaling cascades may utilize CARD interactions with non-CARD domains.

Pausing during reverse transcription increases the rate of retroviral recombination

Retroviruses package two copies of genomic RNA into viral particles. During the minus-sense DNA synthesis step of reverse transcription, the nascent DNA can transfer multiple times between the two copies of the genome, resulting in recombination. The mechanism for this process is similar to the process of obligate strand transfers mediated by the repeat and primer binding site sequences. The location at which the DNA 3' terminus completely transfers to the second RNA strand defines the point of crossover. Previous work in vitro demonstrated that reverse transcriptase pausing has a significant impact on the location of the crossover, with a proportion of complete transfer events occurring very close to pause sites. The role of pausing in vivo, however, is not clearly understood. By employing a murine leukemia virus-based single-cycle infection assay, strong pausing was shown to increase the probability of recombination, as reflected in the reconstitution of green fluorescent protein expression. The infection assay results were directly correlated with the presence of strong pause sites in reverse transcriptase primer extension assays in vitro. Conversely, when pausing was diminished in vitro, without changing the sequence of the RNA template involved in recombination, there was a significant reduction in recombination in vivo. Together, these data demonstrate that reverse transcriptase pausing, as observed in vitro, directly correlates with recombination during minus-sense DNA synthesis in vivo.

Generation of a packaging cell line for prolonged large-scale production of high-titer HIV-1-based lentiviral vector

BACKGROUND

A stable packaging cell line facilitates large-scale lentivirus vector manufacture. However, it has been difficult to produce clinical-scale HIV-1-based lentiviral vectors using a packaging cell line, in part due to toxicity of packaging genes, and gene silencing that occurs during the long culture period necessary for sequential addition of packaging constructs.

METHODS

To avoid these problems, we developed a three-level cascade gene regulation system designed to remove tetracycline transactivator (tTA) from cytomegalovirus immediate early promoter (CMV)-controlled expression to reduce cytotoxicity from constitutive expression of tTA and leaky expression of packaging genes. We also performed a one-step integration of the three packaging plasmids to shorten the culture time for clonal selection.

RESULTS

Although leaky expression of p24 and vector production still occurred despite the three-level regulation system, little cytotoxicity was observed and producer cells could be expanded for large-scale production. Producer cells yielded remarkably stable vector production over a period greater than 11 days with the highest titer 3.5 x 10(7) transducing units (TU)/ml and p24 300 ng/ml, yielding 2.2 x 10(11) TU and 1.8 milligram (mg) p24 from one cell factory. No replication-competent lentivirus (RCL) was detected. Long-term analysis demonstrated that, although the cells are genetically stable, partial gene silencing occurs after 2-3 months in culture; however, the one-step construct integration allowed prolonged vector production before significant gene silencing. Concentrated vector resulted in 90% transduction in CD4+ lymphocytes at 20 TU per cell. CD34+ progenitor cells were transduced at 41-46% efficiency, and long-term initiating culture (LTC-IC) was transduced at 45-51%.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate for the first time HIV-1-based lentiviral vector production on the large scale using a packaging cell line.

Each genomic RNA in HIV-1 heterozygous virus generate new virions

Retrovirus are unique because they present two complete copies of the genomic RNA in each virion. It is believed that only one proviral DNA is formed from the two genomic RNAs. To check this hypothesis, we constructed two deleterious HIV-1 variants in gag gene which upon transfection in Cos-1 cells were able, by complementation, to form heterozygous viruses, used to infect MT4 cells in a plaque assay. Analysis of the proviral DNA of the eight plaques obtained indicated that five were recombinants between the two deleterious mutants. Three other plaques showed three bands corresponding to the reverse transcription of both strands of one heterozygous virion and to the recombination of the two genomes. These results demonstrate that the two genomic RNAs in HIV-1 heterozygous virions could be used in the generation of new viruses. This mechanism permits the recovery of deleterious mutants and enhances the evolutive potential of HIV-1.

Expression and recombination of the EGFP and EYFP genes in lentiviral vectors carrying two heterologous promoters

BACKGROUND

Expressing two genes in the progeny of stem and progenitor cells that are transduced with a unique viral vector is desirable in certain situations. We tested the ability of two lentiviral vectors to transduce human cells of hematopoietic origin and concomitantly express two reporter genes, either EGFP (enhanced green fluorescent protein) and DsRed2, or EGFP and EYFP (enhanced yellow fluorescent protein), from two internal promoters.

METHODS

The vectors were generated from the pTRIP deltaU3 EF1alpha EGFP lentiviral vector. Following transduction of hematopoietic and non-hematopoietic cell lines, we performed FACS, PCR and Southern blot analyzes to quantify transduction, integration efficiencies and size of integrated lentiviral vectors, respectively.

RESULTS

The detection of DsRed2 fluorescence appeared unexpectedly low in human cells of hematopoietic origin. Alternatively, a modification in the flow cytometry assay allowed us to distinguish between the two overlapping fluorescence signals emitted by EGFP and EYFP, when transduced cells were excited with a 488-nm laser beam. However, the low frequency of double-positive EGFP+ EYFP+ cells, and the existence of single-positive, mostly EGFP- EYFP+, cells, prompted us to search for recombinations in the vector sequence. Southern blotting of DNA obtained from transduced cells indeed demonstrated that recombination had occurred between the two closely related EGFP and EYFP sequences.

DISCUSSION

These observations suggest that recombination occurred within the EGFP and EYFP genes, which differ by only four amino acids. We conclude that the insertion of two highly homologous sequences into a lentiviral backbone can favor recombination.

Effects of unpaired nucleotides within HIV-1 genomic secondary structures on pausing and strand transfer

Reverse transcriptase-mediated RNA displacement synthesis is required for DNA polymerization through the base-paired stem portions of secondary structures present in retroviral genomes. These regions of RNA duplex often possess single unpaired nucleotides, or "bulges," that disrupt contiguous base pairing. By using well defined secondary structures from the human immunodeficiency virus, type 1 (HIV-1), genome, we demonstrate that removal of these bulges either by deletion or by introducing a complementary base on the opposing strand results in increased pausing at specific positions within the RNA duplex. We also show that the HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein can increase synthesis through the pause sites but not as efficiently as when a bulge residue is present. Finally, we demonstrate that removing a bulge increases the proportion of strand transfer events to an acceptor template that occur prior to complete replication of a donor template secondary structure. Together our data suggest a role for bulge nucleotides in enhancing synthesis through stable secondary structures and reducing strand transfer.

Stable expression of three genes from a tricistronic retroviral vector containing a picornavirus and 9-nt cellular internal ribosome entry site elements

Retroviral vectors are used widely to deliver heterologous genes into cells. In order to express three genes from a single RNA molecule, a retroviral vector that contains two divergent internal ribosome entry site (IRES) sequences has been constructed successfully. To eliminate the high frequency of recombination within a mulicistronic retrovirus vector, a 9-nt segment of a cellular mRNA IRES and a picornaviral IRES were used, since these two IRES sequences have minimal sequence homology. After a single round of replication, most cells infected with this vector stably expressed the three genes while approximately 40% of cells infected with another tricistronic retroviral vector that contains two copies of an identical IRES sequence lost expression of the gene located between these two sequences.

Intramolecular recombinations of Moloney murine leukemia virus occur during minus-strand DNA synthesis

Retroviral recombination can occur between two viral RNA molecules (intermolecular) or between two sequences within the same RNA molecule (intramolecular). The rate of retroviral intramolecular recombination is high. Previous studies showed that, after a single round of replication, 50 to 60% of retroviral recombinations occur between two identical sequences within a Moloney murine leukemia virus-based vector. Recombination can occur at any polymerization step within the retroviral replication cycle. Although reverse transcriptase is assumed to contribute to the template switches, previous studies could not distinguish between changes introduced by host RNA polymerase II (Pol II) or by reverse transcriptase. A cell culture system has been established to detect the individual contribution of host RNA Pol II, host DNA polymerase or viral reverse transcriptase, as well as the recombination events taking place during minus-strand DNA synthesis and plus-strand DNA synthesis in a single round of viral intramolecular replication. Studies in this report demonstrate that intramolecular recombination between two identical sequences during transcription by host RNA Pol II is minimal and that most recombinations occur during minus-strand DNA synthesis catalyzed by viral reverse transcriptase.

Effects of varying sequence similarity on the frequency of repeat deletion during reverse transcription of a human immunodeficiency virus type 1 vector

Genetic recombination contributes to human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) diversity, with homologous recombination being more frequent than nonhomologous recombination. In this study, HIV-1-based vectors were used to assay the effects of various extents of sequence divergence on the frequency of the recombination-related property of repeat deletion. Sequence variation, similar in degree to that which differentiates natural HIV-1 isolates, was introduced by synonymous substitutions into a gene segment. Repeated copies of this segment were then introduced into assay vectors. With the use of a phenotypic screen, the deletion frequency of identical repeats was compared to the frequencies of repeats that differed in sequence by various extents. During HIV-1 reverse transcription, the deletion frequency observed with repeats that differed by 5% was 65% of that observed with identical repeats. The deletion frequency decreased to 26% for repeats that differed by 9%, and when repeats differed by 18%, the deletion frequency was about 5% of the identical repeat value. Deletion frequencies fell to less than 0.3% of identical repeat values when genetic distances of 27% or more were examined. These data argue that genetic variation is not as inhibitory to HIV-1 repeat deletion as it is to the corresponding cellular process and suggest that, for sequences that differ by about 25% or more, HIV-1 recombination directed by sequence homology may be no more frequent than that which is homology independent.

Evidence for retroviral intramolecular recombinations

As a consequence of being diploid, retroviruses have a high recombination rate. Naturally occurring retroviruses contain two repeat sequences (R regions) flanking either end of their RNA genomes, and recombination between these two R regions occurs at a high rate. We deduced that recombination may occur between two sequences within the same RNA molecule (intramolecular) as well as between sequences present within two separate RNA molecules (intermolecular). Intramolecular recombination would usually result in a deletion within the progeny provirus. In this report, we demonstrate that intramolecular recombination between two identical sequences occurred within a chimeric RNA vector. In addition, high rates of recombination between two identical sequences within the same RNA molecule resulted mostly from intramolecular recombination.

Retroviral recombination is temperature dependent

Two conflicting in vitro observations suggest that retroviral recombinations are temperature dependent. Ouhammouch & Brody (Nucleic Acids Research 20, 5443–5450, 1992) suggested that retroviral recombination rates should increase as temperature increases. However, Shimomaye & Salvato (Gene Analysis Techniques 6, 25–28, 1989) and Brooks et al. (Biotechniques 19, 806–812, 814–815, 1985) found that at low temperature the tightly folded structure of RNAs may hinder reverse transcription proceeding along the RNA template, which increases its chance of dissociating from the template; therefore, raising the reaction temperature was the simplest way to overcome template secondary structure and prevent premature termination of cDNA synthesis. In this report, two vectors based on murine leukaemia virus (MLV) were constructed. The first contained two mutated gfp genes in tandem positions. The upstream gfp gene encoded a mutation at its 3′ end, while the downstream gfp gene encoded a mutation at its 5′ end. The recombination that occurred between the two mutated gfp genes restored a functional gfp gene. The cells that contained the functional gfp gene were green when observed under a fluorescence microscope. The second MLV vector contained a functional gfp gene with two identical sequences flanking either end. A recombination that occurred between the two identical sequences resulted in deletion of the gfp gene. Cells containing the vector with the gfp deletion were colourless or clear when observed under the microscope. Using these two vectors, we have demonstrated that retroviral recombination is temperature dependent and the rate of recombination decreases as temperature is raised from 31 to 43 °C.