Human gamma- to beta-globin gene switching using a mini construct in transgenic mice

Characterization of diverse Cas9 orthologs for genome and epigenome editing

CRISPR-Cas9 systems have revolutionized biotechnology, creating diverse new opportunities for biomedical research and therapeutic genome and epigenome editing. Despite the abundance of bacterial CRISPR-Cas9 systems, relatively few are effective in human cells, limiting the overall potential of CRISPR technology. To expand the CRISPR-Cas toolbox, we characterized a set of type II CRISPR-Cas9 systems from select bacterial genera and species encoding diverse Cas9s. Four systems demonstrated robust and specific gene repression in human cells when used as nuclease-null dCas9s fused with a KRAB domain and were also highly active nucleases in human cells. These systems have distinct protospacer adjacent motifs (PAMs), including AT-rich motifs and sgRNA features orthogonal to the commonly used Staphylococcus aureus and Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9s. Additionally, we assessed gene activation when fused with the p300 catalytic domain. Notably, S. uberis Cas9 performed competitively against benchmarks with promising repression, activation, nuclease, and base editing activity. This study expands the CRISPR-Cas9 repertoire, enabling effective genome and epigenome editing for diverse applications.

Co-Regulated Genes and Gene Clusters

There are many co-regulated genes in eukaryotic cells. The coordinated activation or repression of such genes occurs at specific stages of differentiation, or under the influence of external stimuli. As a rule, co-regulated genes are dispersed in the genome. However, there are also gene clusters, which contain paralogous genes that encode proteins with similar functions. In this aspect, they differ significantly from bacterial operons containing functionally linked genes that are not paralogs. In this review, we discuss the reasons for the existence of gene clusters in vertebrate cells and propose that clustering is necessary to ensure the possibility of selective activation of one of several similar genes.

β-thalassemias: paradigmatic diseases for scientific discoveries and development of innovative therapies

β-thalassemias are monogenic disorders characterized by defective synthesis of the β-globin chain, one of the major components of adult hemoglobin. A large number of mutations in the β-globin gene or its regulatory elements have been associated with β-thalassemias. Due to the complexity of the regulation of the β-globin gene and the role of red cells in many physiological processes, patients can manifest a large spectrum of phenotypes, and clinical requirements vary from patient to patient. It is important to consider the major differences in the light of potential novel therapeutics. This review summarizes the main discoveries and mechanisms associated with the synthesis of β-globin and abnormal erythropoiesis, as well as current and novel therapies.

Persistent fetal gamma-globin expression in adult transgenic mice following deletion of two silencer elements located 3' to the human Agamma-globin gene

Natural deletions of the human gamma-globin gene cluster lead to specific syndromes characterized by increased production of fetal hemoglobin in adult life and provide a useful model to delineate novel cis-acting elements involved in the developmental control of hemoglobin switching. A hypothesis accounting for these phenotypic features assumes that silencers located within the Agamma-to delta-gene region are deleted in hereditary persistence of fetal hemoglobin (HPFH) and deltabeta-thalassemias, leading to failure of switching. In the present study, we sought to clarify the in vivo role of two elements, termed Enh and F, located 3' to the Agamma-globin, in silencing the fetal genes. To this end, we generated three transgenic lines using cosmid constructs containing the full length of the globin locus control region (LCR) linked to the 3.3-kb Agamma-gene lacking both the Enh and F elements. The Enh/F deletion resulted in high levels of Agamma-globin gene expression in adult mice in all single copy lines, whereas, the LCR-Agamma single copy lines which retain the Enh and F elements exhibited complete normal switching of the fetal Agamma-gene. Our study documents directly for the first time the in vivo role of these two gene-proximal negative regulatory elements in silencing the fetal globin gene in the perinatal period, and thus these data may permit their eventual exploitation in therapeutic approaches for thalassemias.

Evidence for a bigenic chromatin subdomain in regulation of the fetal-to-adult hemoglobin switch

During development, human beta-globin locus regulation undergoes two critical switches, the embryonic-to-fetal and fetal-to-adult hemoglobin switches. To define the role of the fetal (A)gamma-globin promoter in switching, human beta-globin-YAC transgenic mice were produced with the (A)gamma-globin promoter replaced by the erythroid porphobilinogen deaminase (PBGD) promoter (PBGD(A)gamma-YAC). Activation of the stage-independent PBGD(A)gamma-globin strikingly stimulated native (G)gamma-globin expression at the fetal and adult stages, identifying a fetal gene pair or bigenic cooperative mechanism. This impaired fetal silencing severely suppressed both delta- and beta-globin expression in PBGD(A)gamma-YAC mice from fetal to neonatal stages and altered kinetics and delayed switching of adult beta-globin. This regulation evokes the two human globin switching patterns in the mouse. Both patterns of DNA demethylation and chromatin immunoprecipitation analysis correlated with gene activation and open chromatin. Locus control region (LCR) interactions detected by chromosome conformation capture revealed distinct spatial fetal and adult LCR bigenic subdomains. Since both intact fetal promoters are critical regulators of fetal silencing at the adult stage, we concluded that fetal genes are controlled as a bigenic subdomain rather than a gene-autonomous mechanism. Our study also provides evidence for LCR complex interaction with spatial fetal or adult bigenic functional subdomains as a niche for transcriptional activation and hemoglobin switching.

The human beta-globin locus control region can silence as well as activate gene expression

Using recombinase-mediated cassette exchange to test multiple transgenes at the same site of integration, we demonstrate a novel chromatin context-dependent silencer activity of the beta-globin locus control region (LCR). This silencer activity requires DNase I hypersensitive sites HS2 and HS3 but not HS4. After silencing, the silenced cassettes adopt a typical closed chromatin conformation (histone H3 and H4 deacetylation, histone H3-K4 methylation, DNA methylation, and replication in late S phase). In the absence of the LCR at the same site of integration, the chromatin remains decondensed. We demonstrate that the LCR is necessary but not sufficient to trigger these chromatin changes. We also provide evidence that this novel silencing activity is caused by transcriptional interference triggered by activation of transcription in the flanking sequences by the LCR.

Sequences in the (A)gamma-delta intergenic region are not required for stage-specific regulation of the human beta-globin gene locus

The human beta-globin locus has been extensively studied as a model of tissue and developmental stage-specific gene expression. Structural mapping of naturally occurring mutations, including transfection and transgenic studies, and the recent finding of intergenic transcripts have suggested that there are cis-acting sequence elements in the (A)gamma-delta intergenic region involved in regulating gamma- and beta-globin gene expression. To determine whether previously identified sequences in the (A)gamma-delta intergenic region are required for appropriate developmental expression of the human beta-globin gene cluster, transgenic mice were generated by transfer of yeast artificial chromosomes containing the entire human beta-globin locus. Three different deletions of the (A)gamma-delta intergenic region were introduced, including (i) deletion of the 750-bp (A)gamma 3' regulatory element ((A)gammae), (ii) deletion of 3.2 kb upstream of the delta-globin gene encompassing pyrimidine-rich sequences and the recently described intergenic transcript initiation site, and (iii) deletion of a 12.5-kb fragment encompassing most of the (A)gamma-delta globin intergenic region. Analysis of multiple transgenic lines carrying these deletion constructs demonstrated that the normal stage-specific sequential expression of the epsilon -, gamma-, and beta-globin genes was preserved, despite deletion of these putative regulatory sequences. These studies suggest that regulatory sequences required for activation and silencing of the human beta-globin gene family during ontogeny reside proximally to the genes and immediately 5' to the human gamma- and beta-globin genes.

Requirements for utilization of CREB binding protein by hypersensitive site two of the beta-globin locus control region

Strong transactivation of the beta-globin genes is conferred by the beta-globin locus control region (LCR), which consists of four erythroid-specific DNase I hypersensitive sites (HS1-HS4). HS2 has a powerful enhancer activity dependent upon tandem binding sites for the erythroid cell- and megakaryocyte-specific transcription factor NF-E2. An important co-activator-mediating transactivation by HS2 is the histone acetyltransferase (HAT) CREB binding protein (CBP). We showed previously that recruitment of a GAL4-CBP fusion protein to HS2 largely bypassed the requirement of the NF-E2 sites for transactivation. To determine whether GAL4-CBP recruitment is sufficient for transactivation, we assessed the importance of cis-elements within HS2. Docking of GAL4-CBP upstream of an Agamma-globin promoter lacking HS2 only weakly activated the promoter, indicating that HS2 components are required for GAL4-CBP-mediated transactivation. Sequences upstream and downstream of the NF-E2 sites were required for maximal GAL4-CBP-mediated transactivation, and HAT catalytic activity of GAL4-CBP was critical. No single factor-binding site was required for GAL4-CBP-mediated transactivation. However, deletion of two sites, a CACC site and an E-box, abolished transactivation in transient and stable transfection assays. These results suggest that NF-E2 recruits CBP as a critical step in transactivation, but additional components of HS2 are required to achieve maximal enhancer activity.

Enhancer activity of HS2 of the human beta-LCR is modulated by distance from the key nucleosome

A class of curved DNA appears universally in eukaryotic genomic DNA at an average distance of approximately 680 bp and shows nucleosome positioning activity by having high affinity for histone core particles in an orientation- and position-dependent manner. Here, we report that the enhancer activity at DNase I hypersensitive site 2 (HS2) of the human beta-globin locus control region (beta-LCR) can be modulated by the curved DNA located at a distance of two nucleosomes from HS2 and that the nucleosome at the curved DNA regulates nearby nucleosome phases as a key nucleosome. Erythroid-specific nucleosome phases which caused deviation of the NF-E2 (p18-p45 dimer) binding site from the nucleosome dyad axis were over-represented when the distance between the key nucleosome and HS2 exceeded 80 bp longer than the original length. At this state, enhancer activity was approximately 50% of that in the original construct, presumably due to reduced binding of transcription factors.

Enhancement of beta-globin locus control region-mediated transactivation by mitogen-activated protein kinases through stochastic and graded mechanisms

Activation of the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) pathway enhances long-range transactivation by the beta-globin locus control region (LCR) (W. K. Versaw, V. Blank, N. M. Andrews, and E. H. Bresnick, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 95:8756-8760, 1998). The enhancement requires tandem recognition sites for the hematopoietic transcription factor NF-E2 within the hypersensitive site 2 (HS2) subregion of the LCR. To distinguish between mechanisms of induction involving the activation of silent promoters or the increased efficacy of active promoters, we analyzed basal and MAPK-stimulated HS2 enhancer activity in single, living cells. K562 erythroleukemia cells stably transfected with constructs containing the human Agamma-globin promoter linked to an enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) reporter, with or without HS2, were analyzed for EGFP expression by flow cytometry. When most cells in a population expressed EGFP, MAPK augmented the activity of active promoters. However, under conditions of silencing, in which cells reverted to a state with no measurable EGFP expression, MAPK activated silent promoters. Furthermore, studies of populations of EGFP-expressing and non-EGFP-expressing cells isolated by flow cytometry showed that MAPK activation converted nonexpressing cells into expressing cells and increased expression in expressing cells. These results support a model in which MAPK elicits both graded and stochastic responses to increase HS2-mediated transactivation from single chromatin templates.

Transcription of the HS2 enhancer toward a cis-linked gene is independent of the orientation, position, and distance of the enhancer relative to the gene

The locus control region (LCR) regulates transcription of the downstream beta-like globin genes 10 to 50 kb away. Among hypersensitive sites HS4, -3, -2, and -1, which define the LCR in erythroid cells, HS2 possesses prominent enhancer function. The mechanism by which the HS2 enhancer and other functional components of the LCR act over the distance is not clear. We have used reverse transcription-PCR and RNase protection assays to analyze the transcriptional statuses of both the endogenous and the transfected HS2 enhancer in erythroid K562 cells. A novel pattern of HS2 enhancer transcription was observed. The endogenous HS2 enhancer was transcribed predominantly in the direction toward the downstream globin genes. The HS2 enhancer in transfected recombinant chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) plasmids was also transcribed predominantly toward the CAT gene, regardless of whether the enhancer was placed (i) in the genomic or reverse genomic orientation, (ii) in a position 5' or 3' to the gene, or (iii) at various distances up to 6 kb from the gene. The orientation, position, and distance independence in gene-tropic transcription of the HS2 enhancer correlates with the observed orientation, position, and distance independence of HS2 enhancer function and suggests that enhancer transcription may play a role in enhancer function.

Synergism between hypersensitive sites confers long-range gene activation by the beta-globin locus control region

The human beta-globin locus control region (LCR) consists of four erythroid-specific DNaseI hypersensitive sites (HSs) at the 5' end of the beta-globin cluster. The LCR functions over a long distance on chromosome 11 to regulate transcription and replication of the beta-globin genes. To determine whether the HSs function independently or as an integrated unit, we analyzed the requirements for long-range transcriptional activation. If the HSs function independently, individual HSs would be expected to have long-range activity. In contrast, if long-range activity requires multiple HSs, individual HSs would have a limited functional distance. HS2, HS3, and a miniLCR containing multiple HSs, were separated from a gamma-globin promoter by fragments of phage lambda DNA. After stable transfection into K562 cells, HS2 had strong enhancer activity, but only when positioned close to the promoter. HS3 also had strong enhancer activity, although it was weaker than HS2 and more sensitive to the spacer DNA. The miniLCR had the strongest enhancer activity and functioned even at a distance of 7.3 kb. A model is proposed in which synergistic interactions between HSs confer long-range activation by creating a stable LCR nucleoprotein structure, which is competent for recruiting chromatin-modifying enzymes. These enzymes would mediate the well-characterized activity of the LCR to modulate chromatin structure.

Regulation of the myeloid-cell-expressed human gp91-phox gene as studied by transfer of yeast artificial chromosome clones into embryonic stem cells: suppression of a variegated cellular pattern of expression requires a full complement of distant cis elements

Identifying the full repertoire of cis elements required for gene expression in mammalian cells (or animals) is challenging, given the moderate sizes of many loci. To study how the human gp91-phox gene is expressed specifically in myeloid hematopoietic cells, we introduced yeast artificial chromosome (YAC) clones and derivatives generated in yeast into mouse embryonic stem cells competent to differentiate to myeloid cells in vitro or into mouse chimeras. Fully appropriate regulation was recapitulated with a 130-kb YAC containing 60 and 30 kb of 5' and 3' flanking sequences, respectively. Immunodetection of human gp91-phox protein revealed uniform expression in individual myeloid cells. The removal of upstream sequences led to decreased overall expression which reflected largely a variegated pattern of expression, such that cells were either "on" or "off," rather than pancellular loss of expression. The proportion of clones displaying marked variegation increased with progressive deletion. DNase I mapping of chromatin identified two hypersensitive clusters, consistent with the presence of multiple regulatory elements. Our findings point to cooperative interactions of complex regulatory elements and suggest that the presence of an incomplete set of elements reduces the probability that an open chromatin domain (or active transcriptional complex) may form or be maintained in the face of repressive influences of neighboring chromatin.

Sheltering of gamma-globin expression from position effects requires both an upstream locus control region and a regulatory element 3' to the A gamma-globin gene

Integration position-independent expression of human globin transgenes in transgenic mice requires the presence of regulatory elements from the beta-globin locus control region (LCR) in the transgene construct. However, several recent studies have suggested that, while clearly necessary, such elements are not by themselves sufficient to realize this effect. In the case of the human fetal gamma-globin genes, previous results have indicated that additional regulatory information required for sheltering of gamma-globin transgene expression from position effects may reside downstream from the A gamma gene. To investigate this possibility, we established 17 lines of transgenic mice carrying constructs comprising a micro-LCR (microLCR) element, an A gamma-globin gene fragment, and a variable length of 3' sequence information beyond the A gamma 3' HindIII site. gamma-Globin expression during development was studied in 170 individual F2 progeny from these lines. We find that gamma-globin expression becomes sheltered from position effects when the normally position-sensitive microLCR-A gamma construct is extended by 600 bp beyond the 3' HindIII site to include a previously identified regulatory sequence (the A gamma-globin enhancer), the functional significance of which in vivo had heretofore been unclear. The results suggest that the mechanism whereby an upstream LCR achieves sheltering of globin gene expression from position effects involves cooperation with a gene-proximal regulatory element distinct from the promoter region.

Silencing of human fetal globin expression is impaired in the absence of the adult beta-globin gene activator protein EKLF

Globin genes are subject to tissue-specific and developmental stage-specific regulation. A switch from human fetal (gamma)-to adult (beta)-globin expression occurs within erythroid precursor cells of the adult lineage. Previously we and others showed by targeted gene disruption that the zinc finger gene, erythroid Krüppel-like factor (EKLF), is required for expression of the beta-globin gene in mice, presumably through interaction with a high-affinity binding site in the proximal promoter. To examine the role of EKLF in the developmental regulation of the human gamma-globin gene we interbred EKLF heterozygotes (+/-) with mice harboring a human beta-globin yeast artificial chromosome transgene. We find that in the absence of EKLF, while human beta-globin expression is dramatically reduced, gamma-globin transcripts are elevated approximately 5-fold. Impaired silencing of gamma-globin expression identifies EKLF as the first transcription factor participating quantitatively in the gamma-globin to beta-globin switch. Our findings are compatible with a competitive model of switching in which EKLF mediates an adult stage-specific interaction between the beta-globin gene promoter and the locus control region that excludes the gamma-globin gene.

Analysis of developmental switching in transgenic mice with 5' and 3' deletions in the human beta globin gene

Our interest in the cis-acting elements that promote the up-regulation of the beta globin gene has led to a systematic deletion analysis of portions of the beta globin gene in the context of the HS2 and gamma globin gene using transgenic mice. In constructs that delete the 5' region to only 265 bp, high-level, erythroid-specific expression was observed. Further deletion to 122 bp, however, results in significantly reduced expression levels. A substitution of a minilocus control region for the single HS2 site was also produced, resulting in increased beta globin expression over that seen with the HS2 alone. These results are consistent with the presence of an enhancer-like element between -122 and -265. In addition, a construct in which the entire beta globin gene promoter was replaced by a thymidine kinase promoter was tested. Interestingly, no expression was detected in these transgenic mice. This may indicate the requirement for an erythroid-specific promoter to drive this gene. Finally, the 3' region of the beta globin gene was deleted in order to examine the effect of a previously defined 3' enhancer region. With deletion of this region, the expression of the human beta globin gene in transgenic mice is unchanged relative to the parental constructs.

Conservation of the sizes of 53 introns and over 100 intronic sequences for the binding of common transcription factors in the human and mouse genes for type II procollagen (COL2A1)

Over 11,000 bp of previously undefined sequences of the human COL2A1 gene were defined. The results made it possible to compare the intron structures of a highly complex gene from man and mouse. Surprisingly, the sizes of the 53 introns of the two genes were highly conserved with a mean difference of 13%. After alignment of the sequences, 69% of the intron sequences were identical. The introns contained consensus sequences for the binding of over 100 different transcription factors that were conserved in the introns of the two genes. The first intron of the gene contained 80 conserved consensus sequences and the remaining 52 introns of the gene contained 106 conserved sequences for the binding of transcription factors. The 5'-end of intron 2 in both genes had a potential for forming a stem loop in RNA transcripts.

Cloning and functional characterization of LCR-F1: a bZIP transcription factor that activates erythroid-specific, human globin gene expression

DNase I hypersensitive site 2 (HS 2) of the human beta-globin Locus Control Region (LCR) directs high level expression of the beta-globin gene located 50 kilobases downstream. Experiments in cultured cells and in transgenic mice demonstrate that duplicated AP1-like sites in HS 2 are required for this powerful enhancer activity. A cDNA clone encoding a basic, leucine-zipper protein that binds to these sites was isolated and designated Locus Control Region-Factor 1 (LCR-F1). This protein is a member of a new family of regulatory factors that contain a 63 amino acid 'CNC domain' overlapping the basic region. This domain is approximately 70% identical in the Drosophila Cap N Collar (CNC) protein, NF-E2 and LCR-F1. LCR-F1 transactivates an HS 2/gamma-globin reporter gene over 170-fold in transient transfection experiments specifically in erythroid cells. These results suggest that LCR-F1 may be a critical factor involved in LCR-mediated, human globin gene expression.

Developmental regulation of human gamma-globin genes in transgenic mice

We report results showing that several gamma gene promoter elements participate in the developmental control of gamma-globin genes. Four gamma gene constructs with 5' truncated at -141, -201, -382, and -730 of the A gamma gene promoter linked to a micro locus control region (microLCR) cassette were used for production of transgenic mice and analysis of gamma gene expression during development. Mice carrying a microLCR -141 A gamma construct displayed downregulation of gamma gene expression in the adult stage of development, indicating that the proximal promoter contains elements participating in gamma gene silencing. Mice carrying a microLCR -201 A gamma or a microLCR -382 A gamma construct displayed high gamma gene expression in the fetal stage of development and complete loss of gamma gene downregulation in the adult stage, suggesting that the -141 to -201 gamma gene sequence contains elements which upregulate gamma gene expression and are dominant over the negative element 3' to -141. Extension of the promoter to -730 resulted in reappearance of gamma gene downregulation, suggesting that the -382 to -730 sequences contain an adult-stage-specific silencer. gamma gene expression in the microLCR -201 A gamma and the microLCR -382 A gamma transgenic mice was copy number dependent. All the microLCR -730 A gamma transgenic mice expressed gamma mRNA; however, gamma gene expression was copy number independent, indicating that levels of gamma gene expression were modulated by the surrounding chromatin. Our results suggest that multiple elements participate in gamma gene silencing. The findings in the microLCR-201 A gamma and microLCR -382 A gamma transgenic mice are interpreted to indicate that the LCR interacts not only with the minimal gamma gene promoter but also with sequences of the upstream promoter. We postulate that gamma gene downregulation is achieved when the interaction between LCR and the upstream promoter is disturbed by the silencer located in the -382 to -730 region. We propose that gamma gene silencing is achieved by the combined effect of negative elements located 3' to -141, the negative element located between -382 and -730, and the competition by the beta gene promoter during the adult stage of development.

Developmental regulation of human gamma-globin genes in transgenic mice

We report results showing that several gamma gene promoter elements participate in the developmental control of gamma-globin genes. Four gamma gene constructs with 5' truncated at -141, -201, -382, and -730 of the A gamma gene promoter linked to a micro locus control region (microLCR) cassette were used for production of transgenic mice and analysis of gamma gene expression during development. Mice carrying a microLCR -141 A gamma construct displayed downregulation of gamma gene expression in the adult stage of development, indicating that the proximal promoter contains elements participating in gamma gene silencing. Mice carrying a microLCR -201 A gamma or a microLCR -382 A gamma construct displayed high gamma gene expression in the fetal stage of development and complete loss of gamma gene downregulation in the adult stage, suggesting that the -141 to -201 gamma gene sequence contains elements which upregulate gamma gene expression and are dominant over the negative element 3' to -141. Extension of the promoter to -730 resulted in reappearance of gamma gene downregulation, suggesting that the -382 to -730 sequences contain an adult-stage-specific silencer. gamma gene expression in the microLCR -201 A gamma and the microLCR -382 A gamma transgenic mice was copy number dependent. All the microLCR -730 A gamma transgenic mice expressed gamma mRNA; however, gamma gene expression was copy number independent, indicating that levels of gamma gene expression were modulated by the surrounding chromatin. Our results suggest that multiple elements participate in gamma gene silencing. The findings in the microLCR-201 A gamma and microLCR -382 A gamma transgenic mice are interpreted to indicate that the LCR interacts not only with the minimal gamma gene promoter but also with sequences of the upstream promoter. We postulate that gamma gene downregulation is achieved when the interaction between LCR and the upstream promoter is disturbed by the silencer located in the -382 to -730 region. We propose that gamma gene silencing is achieved by the combined effect of negative elements located 3' to -141, the negative element located between -382 and -730, and the competition by the beta gene promoter during the adult stage of development.

Germ-line transmission and developmental regulation of a 150-kb yeast artificial chromosome containing the human beta-globin locus in transgenic mice

Sequential expression of the genes of the human beta-globin locus requires the formation of an erythroid-specific chromatin domain spanning > 200 kb. Regulation of this gene family involves both local interactions with proximal cis-acting sequences and long-range interactions with control elements upstream of the locus. To make it possible to analyze the interactions of cis-acting sequences of the human beta-globin locus in their normal spatial and sequence context, we characterized two yeast artificial chromosomes (YACs) 150 and 230 kb in size, containing the entire beta-globin locus. We have now successfully integrated the 150-kb YAC into the germ line of transgenic mice as a single unrearranged fragment that includes the locus control region, structural genes, and 30 kb of 3' flanking sequences present in the native locus. Expression of the transgenic human beta-globin locus is tissue- and developmental stage-specific and closely follows the pattern of expression of the endogenous mouse beta-globin locus. By using homology-directed recombination in yeast and methods for the purification and transfer of YACs into transgenic mice, it will now be feasible to study the physiological role of cis-acting sequences in specifying an erythroid-specific chromatin domain and directing expression of beta-globin genes during ontogeny.

Regulated expression of the human beta globin gene in transgenic mice requires an upstream globin or nonglobin promoter

Transgenic mice have been used extensively to study elements governing the erythroid-specific developmental switch from human fetal gamma to human adult beta globin. Previous work demonstrated that a small construct composed of hypersensitive site 2 (HS2) of the locus control region (LCR) linked to the gamma and beta globin genes (HS2-gamma-beta) is sufficient for correct tissue and temporal expression of these genes, whereas HS2-beta alone is inappropriately expressed in the embryo. Two models, which are not mutually exclusive, have been proposed to explain these results and those of other constructs in transgenic mice. One model emphasizes the conserved polarity in the globin locus and suggests a distance effect whereby the beta globin gene must be removed from the LCR/HS2 to prevent an early and incorrect activation of this gene in the embryonic compartment. A second hypothesis proposes a competition between the gamma and beta globin gene promoters for interaction with the LCR/HS2. The active gamma globin gene promoter positioned between the LCR/HS2 and the beta globin gene thereby interacts with the HS2 elements early in erythroid development and is expressed until a change in putative stage-specific nuclear factors makes an interaction with the adult beta globin gene more favorable. In an effort to test the competition model, a construct has been prepared in which a small deletion was produced in the promoter region of the gamma globin gene while in the context of the HS2-gamma-beta plasmid. Analysis of this construct in transgenic mice reveals a constitutive unregulated expression of the human beta globin gene during erythroid development. To determine if this competition effect is specific for globin genes, a heterologous reporter gene has been substituted for the gamma globin gene in the construct HS2-gamma-beta. In this case, the beta globin gene exhibits correct developmental expression. This data is consistent with a model in which transcription from a promoter upstream of the beta globin gene in some manner protects this adult gene from activation by the LCR/HS2 during early development.

Role of gene order in developmental control of human gamma- and beta-globin gene expression

To determine the effect of gene order on globin gene developmental regulation, we produced transgenic mice containing two tandemly arranged gamma- or beta-globin or gamma beta- and beta gamma-globin genes linked to a 2.5-kb cassette containing sequences of the locus control region (LCR). Analysis of constructs containing two identical gamma or beta genes assessed the effect of gene order on globin gene expression, while analysis of constructs containing tandemly arranged gamma and beta genes assessed any additional effects of the trans-acting environment. When two gamma genes were tandemly linked to the LCR, expression from the proximal gamma gene was three- to fourfold higher than expression from the distal gamma gene, and the ratio of proximal to distal gene expression remained unchanged throughout development. Similarly, when two beta genes were tandemly linked to the LCR, the proximal beta gene was predominantly expressed throughout development. These results indicate that proximity to LCR increases gene expression, perhaps by influencing the frequency of interaction between the LCR and globin gene promoters. An arrangement where the gamma gene was proximal and the beta gene distal to the LCR resulted in predominant gamma-gene expression in the embryo. When the order was reversed and the gamma gene was placed distally to the LCR, gamma-gene expression in the embryo was still up to threefold higher than expression of the LCR-proximal beta gene. These findings suggest that the embryonic trans-acting environment interacts preferentially with the gamma genes irrespective of their order or proximity to the LCR. We conclude that promoter competition rather than gene order plays the major role in globin gene switching.

Transgenic mice containing a 248-kb yeast artificial chromosome carrying the human beta-globin locus display proper developmental control of human globin genes

Transgenic mice were generated using a purified 248-kb yeast artificial chromosome (YAC) bearing an intact 82-kb human beta-globin locus and 148 kb of flanking sequence. Seventeen of 148 F0 pups were transgenic. RNase protection analysis of RNA isolated from the blood of 13 gamma- and beta-globin-positive founders showed that only the human beta-globin gene was expressed in the adult founders. Studies of F1 and F2 fetuses demonstrated that the genes of the beta-locus YAC displayed the proper developmental switches in beta-like globin gene expression. Expression of epsilon- and gamma-globin, but not beta-globin, was observed in the yolk sac, there was only minor gamma and mostly beta expression in the 14-day liver, and only beta mRNA in the blood of the adult animals. Structural data showed that the locus was intact. These results indicate that it is now possible to dissect regulatory mechanisms within the context of an entire locus in vivo by using the ability to perform mutagenesis efficiently in yeast via homologous recombination, followed by purification of the altered YAC and its introduction into mice.

Role of gene order in developmental control of human gamma- and beta-globin gene expression

To determine the effect of gene order on globin gene developmental regulation, we produced transgenic mice containing two tandemly arranged gamma- or beta-globin or gamma beta- and beta gamma-globin genes linked to a 2.5-kb cassette containing sequences of the locus control region (LCR). Analysis of constructs containing two identical gamma or beta genes assessed the effect of gene order on globin gene expression, while analysis of constructs containing tandemly arranged gamma and beta genes assessed any additional effects of the trans-acting environment. When two gamma genes were tandemly linked to the LCR, expression from the proximal gamma gene was three- to fourfold higher than expression from the distal gamma gene, and the ratio of proximal to distal gene expression remained unchanged throughout development. Similarly, when two beta genes were tandemly linked to the LCR, the proximal beta gene was predominantly expressed throughout development. These results indicate that proximity to LCR increases gene expression, perhaps by influencing the frequency of interaction between the LCR and globin gene promoters. An arrangement where the gamma gene was proximal and the beta gene distal to the LCR resulted in predominant gamma-gene expression in the embryo. When the order was reversed and the gamma gene was placed distally to the LCR, gamma-gene expression in the embryo was still up to threefold higher than expression of the LCR-proximal beta gene. These findings suggest that the embryonic trans-acting environment interacts preferentially with the gamma genes irrespective of their order or proximity to the LCR. We conclude that promoter competition rather than gene order plays the major role in globin gene switching.

Enhancer-dependent transcription of the epsilon-globin promoter requires promoter-bound GATA-1 and enhancer-bound AP-1/NF-E2

We analyzed epsilon-globin transcription in erythroid cells and in erythroid extracts to determine the requirements for enhancer-dependent expression of this gene. Mutations that abolished GATA-1 binding at a single position in the promoter prevented interaction with enhancers, whereas elimination of a second more distal promoter GATA-1 site had no effect. Deletion or mutation of the GATA-1 sites in either the human beta-globin locus control region DNase-hypersensitive site II enhancer or the chicken beta A/epsilon-globin enhancer did not diminish the ability of the enhancers to interact with the promoter. In contrast, mutation of the AP-1/NF-E2 sites in these enhancers resulted in elimination of enhancement. In vitro transcription of these constructs was promoter dependent and was not sensitive to abolition of GATA-1 binding in the promoter, consistent with the role of GATA-1 solely as a mediator of the enhancer effect. Thus, GATA-1 regulates the response of the epsilon-globin gene to enhancers through a specific site in the promoter and requires enhancer AP-1/NF-E2 binding to transduce the enhancer effect on transcription.

Enhancer-dependent transcription of the epsilon-globin promoter requires promoter-bound GATA-1 and enhancer-bound AP-1/NF-E2

We analyzed epsilon-globin transcription in erythroid cells and in erythroid extracts to determine the requirements for enhancer-dependent expression of this gene. Mutations that abolished GATA-1 binding at a single position in the promoter prevented interaction with enhancers, whereas elimination of a second more distal promoter GATA-1 site had no effect. Deletion or mutation of the GATA-1 sites in either the human beta-globin locus control region DNase-hypersensitive site II enhancer or the chicken beta A/epsilon-globin enhancer did not diminish the ability of the enhancers to interact with the promoter. In contrast, mutation of the AP-1/NF-E2 sites in these enhancers resulted in elimination of enhancement. In vitro transcription of these constructs was promoter dependent and was not sensitive to abolition of GATA-1 binding in the promoter, consistent with the role of GATA-1 solely as a mediator of the enhancer effect. Thus, GATA-1 regulates the response of the epsilon-globin gene to enhancers through a specific site in the promoter and requires enhancer AP-1/NF-E2 binding to transduce the enhancer effect on transcription.

A DNA insertional mutation results in microphthalmia in transgenic mice

Transgenic mice were produced by microinjection of a human A gamma-globin gene construct containing site 2 of the locus control region and the A gamma-globin gene with its 3' enhancer sequence. One transgenic mouse line (5'HS2 gamma en91) displayed an altered phenotype when the insertion event of this transgenic line was homozygous. These animals lack the normal pigmentation seen in their hemizygous and non-transgenic littermates, thus appearing white with unpigmented eyes. In addition, their eyes are underdeveloped, consistent with the phenotype associated with mutations at the microphthalmia (mi) locus. Backcrosses of transgenic mice with mi mutant mice result in phenotypes showing a lack of complementation, demonstrating that the site of transgene insertion is allelic with mi. Electron microscopic analysis of hair follicles and culturing of melanocytes from the skin of transgenic animals reveals an absence of cutaneous melanocytes in homozygotes and aberrant growth and morphology of the melanocytes isolated from hemizygous animals. The results presented here summarize the effects of this new allele of the mi locus.

Activation of the beta-globin locus control region precedes commitment to the erythroid lineage

The beta-globin locus control region (LCR) is characterized by erythroid-specific DNase I hypersensitive sites and is involved in the chromatin organization, transcriptional potentiation, developmental regulation, and replication timing of the entire beta-globin gene cluster. When and how the LCR is first activated during erythropoiesis is not known. Here we analyze the chromatin structure of the LCR during early hematopoietic differentiation using nontransformed, multipotential, growth factor-dependent, murine hematopoietic progenitor cells. We show that LCR hypersensitive sites characteristic of erythroid cells are present in three independent multilineage progenitors [FDCP (factor-dependent cell, Paterson)-mix A4, B6SUtA, and LyD9] under conditions of self-renewal. Induction of differentiation down a nonerythroid pathway causes a progressive loss of hypersensitivity in the LCR. These results show that the beta-globin LCR is in an active chromatin configuration prior to erythroid commitment and indicate a significant role for selective gene repression in lineage specification.