Differential pp40I kappa B-beta inhibition of DNA binding by rel proteins

An optimal range of transcription potency is necessary for efficient cell transformation by c-Rel to ensure optimal nuclear localization and gene-specific activation

c-Rel is overexpressed in several B-cell lymphomas and c-rel gene overexpression can transform primary chicken lymphoid cells and induce tumors in animals. Although c-Rel is generally a stronger transcriptional activator than its viral derivative v-Rel, its oncogenic activity is significantly weaker. Among the mutations acquired during c-Rel's evolution into v-Rel are deletion of c-Rel's transactivation domain 2 (cTAD2) and mutations in cTAD1. Given the critical role of the Rel TADs in cell transformation, we investigated how mutations in c-Rel's cTAD1 and cTAD2 contribute to its oncogenicity and that of v-Rel. Mutations in cTAD2 noticeably increased c-Rel's transforming activity by promoting its nuclear localization and gene-specific transactivation, despite an overall decrease in kappaB site-dependent transactivation potency. Conversely, substitution of vTAD by cTAD1 increased v-Rel's transactivation and transforming efficiencies, whereas its substitution by the stronger cTAD2 compromised activation of mip-1beta but not irf-4 and was detrimental to cell transformation. These results suggest that the Rel TADs differentially contribute to gene-specific activation and that an optimal range of transcription potency is necessary for efficient transformation. These findings may have important implications for understanding how Rel TAD mutations can lead to a more oncogenic phenotype.

Divergent C-terminal transactivation domains of Rel/NF-κB proteins are critical determinants of their oncogenic potential in lymphocytes

rel/nf-kappaB genes are amplified, overexpressed, or constitutively activated in many human hematopoietic tumors; however, the molecular mechanisms by which they contribute to tumorigenesis remain to be determined. Here, we explored the oncogenic potential of cellular Rel/NF-kappaB proteins in vitro and in vivo. We show that overexpression of wild-type mouse and human c-rel genes suffices to malignantly transform primary spleen cells in stringent soft agar assays and produce fatal tumors in vivo. In contrast relA and a constitutively active form of IKKbeta did not. Importantly, a hybrid RelA protein with its C-terminal transactivation domain substituted by that of v-Rel was potently oncogenic in vitro and in vivo. The transactivation domain of v-Rel selectively conferred an oncogenic phenotype upon the Rel homology domain (RHD) of RelA, but not to the more divergent RHDs of p50/NF-kappaB1, p52/NF-kappaB2, or RelB. Collectively, our results highlight important differences in the intrinsic oncogenic activity of mammalian c-Rel and RelA proteins, and indicate that critical determinants of their differential oncogenicity reside in their divergent transactivation domains. These findings provide experimental evidence for a role of mammalian Rel/NF-kappaB factors in leukemia/lymphomagenesis in an in vivo animal model, and are consistent with the implication of c-rel in many human lymphomas.

Multiple mutations contribute to the oncogenicity of the retroviral oncoprotein v-Rel

The avian Rev-T retrovirus encodes the v-Rel oncoprotein, which is a member of the Rel/NF-kappaB transcription factor family. v-Rel induces a rapidly fatal lymphoma/leukemia in young birds, and v-Rel can transform and immortalize a variety of avian cell types in vitro. Although Rel/NF-kappaB transcription factors have been associated with oncogenesis in mammals, v-Rel is the only member of this family that is frankly oncogenic in animal model systems. The potent oncogenicity of v-Rel is the consequence of a number of mutations that have altered its activity and regulation: for example, certain mutations decrease its ability to be regulated by IkappaBalpha, change its DNA-binding site specificity, and endow it with new transactivation properties. The study of v-Rel will continue to increase our knowledge of how cellular Rel proteins contribute to oncogenesis by affecting cell growth, altering cell-cycle regulation, and blocking apoptosis. This review will discuss biological and molecular activities of v-Rel, with particular attention to how these activities relate to structure - function aspects of the Rel/NF-kappaB transcription factors.

Ikappa Balpha functions through direct contacts with the nuclear localization signals and the DNA binding sequences of NF-kappaB

We have determined the binding energies of complexes formed between Ikappa Balpha and the wild type and mutational variants of three different Rel/NF-kappaB dimers, namely, the p50/p65 heterodimer and homodimers of p50 and p65. We show that although a common mode of interaction exists between the Rel/NF-kappaB dimers and Ikappa Balpha, IkappaB alpha binds the NF-kappaB p50/p65 heterodimer with 60- and 27-fold higher affinity than the p50 and p65 homodimers, respectively. Each of the three flexibly linked segments of the rel homology region of Rel/NF-kappaB proteins (the nuclear localization sequence, the dimerization domain, and the amino-terminal DNA binding domain) is directly engaged in forming the protein/protein interface with the ankyrin repeats and the carboxyl-terminal acidic tail/PEST sequence of Ikappa Balpha. In the cell, Ikappa Balpha functions to retain NF-kappaB in the cytoplasm and inhibit its DNA binding activity. These properties are a result of the direct involvement of the nuclear localization sequences and of the DNA binding region of NF-kappaB in complex with Ikappa Balpha. A model of the interactions in the complex is proposed based on our observations and the crystal structures of Rel/NF-kappaB dimers and the ankyrin domains of related proteins.

IkappaBalpha overexpression delays tumor formation in v-rel transgenic mice

We have previously shown that transgenic mice expressing the oncoprotein v-Rel under the control of a T cell-specific promoter develop T cell lymphomas. Tumor formation was correlated with the presence of p50/v-Rel and v-Rel/v-Rel nuclear kappaB-binding activity. Since experimental evidence has led to the suggestion of a potential tumor suppressor activity for IkappaBalpha, we have studied the role of IkappaBalpha in the transforming activity of v-Rel by overexpressing IkappaBalpha in v-rel transgenic mice. Overexpression of IkappaBalpha in v-rel transgenic mice resulted in an extended survival, and the development of cutaneous T cell lymphomas of CD8(+)CD4(-) phenotype. These phenotypic alterations were associated with a dramatic reduction of p50/v-Rel, but not v-Rel/v-Rel nuclear DNA binding activity and an increased expression of the intercellular adhesion molecule 1. Our results indicate that v-Rel homodimers are active in transformation and that the capacity of v-Rel-containing complexes to escape the inhibitory effect of IkappaBalpha may be a key element in its transforming capability.

The v-rel oncogene promotes malignant T-cell leukemia/lymphoma in transgenic mice

The oncogene product from the avian reticuloendotheliosis virus strain T, v-Rel, is a member of the Rel/ NF-kappa B family of transcription factors. The mechanism by which v-Rel induces oncogenic transformation remains unclear. Several attempts to transform mammalian cells with v-Rel have failed, suggesting that v-Rel transformation may be a species-specific event. However, here we demonstrate that v-Rel, but not a truncated c-Rel, expressed under the control of the lck promoter, efficiently induced malignancies in transgenic mice. Most of the animals died before 10 months of age and developed immature, multicentric aggressive T-cell leukemia/lymphomas. Most tumors contain CD4+CD8+ cells or CD4-CD8+ cells, which have an immature rather than a mature peripheral phenotype. No tumor development was observed in control littermates and transgenic mice expressing a truncated form of c-Rel. Tumor formation was correlated with the presence of constitutive p50/v-Rel DNA binding activity and overexpression of several kappa B-regulated genes in v-rel transgenic thymocytes. However, v-Rel is also transforming in transgenic thymocytes lacking p50, indicating that p50/v-Rel heterodimer formation is not essential for the transforming activity of v-Rel. The transforming activity of v-Rel in p50 null mice has been identified as v-Rel/v-Rel homodimers. Since tumors represent immature T-lymphocytes, constitutive v-Rel expression appears to be leukemogenic at earlier stages of T-cell development. These v-Rel mice should aid in the study of lymphoma development, T-cell development and NF-kappa B regulation.

PEST-dependent cytoplasmic retention of v-Rel by I(kappa)B-alpha: evidence that I(kappa)B-alpha regulates cellular localization of c-Rel and v-Rel by distinct mechanisms

Association of c-Rel with the inhibitor of kappaB-alpha (IkappaB-alpha) protein regulates both cellular localization and DNA binding. The ability of v-Rel, the oncogenic viral counterpart of avian c-Rel, to evade regulation by p40, the avian IkappaB-alpha protein, contributes to v-Rel-mediated oncogenesis. The yeast two-hybrid system was utilized to dissect Rel:IkappaB-alpha interactions in vivo. We find that distinct domains in c-Rel and v-Rel are required for association with p40. Furthermore, while the ankyrin repeat domain of p40 is sufficient for association with c-Rel, both the ankyrin repeat domain and the PEST domain are required for association with v-Rel. Two amino acid differences between c-Rel and v-Rel that are principally responsible for PEST-dependent association of v-Rel with p40 were identified. These same amino acids were principally responsible for PEST-dependent cytoplasmic retention of v-Rel by p40. The presence of mutations in c-Rel that were sufficient to confer PEST-dependent association of the mutant c-Rel protein with p40 did not increase the weak oncogenicity of c-Rel. However, the introduction of these two c-Rel-derived amino acids into v-Rel markedly reduced the oncogenicity of v-Rel. Deletion of the NLS of either c-Rel or v-Rel did not abolish association with p40, but did confer PEST-dependent association of c-Rel with p40. Surprisingly, deletion of the nuclear localization signal in v-Rel did not affect oncogenicity by v-Rel. Analysis of several mutant c-Rel and v-Rel proteins demonstrated that association of Rel proteins with p40 is necessary but not sufficient for cytoplasmic retention. These results are not consistent with the hypothesis that p40 regulates cellular localization of v-Rel and c-Rel by the same mechanism. Rather, these results support the hypothesis that p40 regulates cellular localization of v-Rel and c-Rel by distinct mechanisms.

Mutations in the DNA-binding and dimerization domains of v-Rel are responsible for altered kappa B DNA-binding complexes in transformed cells

The c-rel proto-oncogene encodes a member of the Rel/NF-kappa B family of transcription factors. The oncogenic viral form, v-rel, transduced by avian reticuloendotheliosis virus T, induces lymphoid tumors. v-Rel transformation may be mediated directly by binding of v-Rel to cognate DNA sites, resulting in altered gene expression, and/or indirectly by releasing Rel/NF-kappa B transcription factors from cytoplasmic retention molecules, resulting in their translocation to the nucleus and the inappropriate expression of genes under kappa B control. v-Rel-transformed cell lines of different phenotypes contained v-Rel as well as endogenous kappa B DNA-binding proteins in nuclear extracts. Kinetic analysis with avian leukosis virus-transformed B-cell lines expressing v-Rel or c-Rel indicated that the presence of endogenous kappa B DNA-binding proteins in the nucleus is temporally correlated with the relocalization of v-Rel to the cytoplasm. Supershift analysis of these DNA-binding complexes revealed that v-Rel was present in all of the nuclear DNA-binding complexes heterodimerized with c-Rel, NF-kappa B1, and other proteins. In contrast, c-Rel-transformed cells exhibited a less-complex pattern of nuclear kappa B DNA-binding complexes, and the nuclear appearance of these endogenous complexes was not observed. Studies with c-/v-Rel hybrids suggest that the induction of the endogenous kappa B DNA-binding complexes is the result of the mutations in the C-terminal region of the Rel homology (RH) domain of v-Rel. Moreover, v-Rel differed from c-Rel in its DNA-binding specificity. The altered DNA-binding specificity of v-Rel was associated with mutations located in the N-terminal part of the RH domain of v-Rel. These results suggest that two different regions of v-Rel (both located in the RH domain) influence the formation of kappa B DNA-binding complexes differently.

Tumor necrosis factor-alpha-dependent activation of a RelA homodimer in astrocytes. Increased phosphorylation of RelA and MAD-3 precede activation of RelA

Rel proteins are important intracellular mediators of cytokine-induced signal transduction. To understand how cytokines affect different cell populations in the brain, we have characterized Rel activation in astrocytes. A RelA homodimer is uniquely activated in cytokine-stimulated astrocytes. Cytokine-dependent phosphorylation of the RelA inhibitor MAD-3 occurred on discrete peptides prior to its dissociation from RelA. A transient hyperphosphorylation of RelA was also induced. Antioxidant treatment inhibited both RelA activation and phosphorylation of the RelA.MAD-3 complex. These results demonstrate that cytokine-dependent activation of the RelA homodimer involves phosphorylation of both RelA and its associated inhibitor. The sole activation of a RelA homodimer suggests that cytokines will activate a unique set of Rel-regulated genes in astrocytes.

The relocalization of v-Rel from the nucleus to the cytoplasm coincides with induction of expression of Ikba and nfkb1 and stabilization of I kappa B-alpha

The v-Rel oncogene induces the expression of major histocompatibility complex class I and II proteins and the interleukin-2 receptor more efficiently than does c-Rel (R. Hrdlicková, J. Nehyba, and E. H. Humphries, J. Virol. 68:308-319, 1994). The kinetics with which these immunoregulatory receptors are induced in B- and T-lymphoid cell lines and chicken embryo fibroblast cultures expressing c-Rel or v-Rel have been examined. v-Rel induced the expression of major histocompatibility complex classes I and II and interleukin-2 receptor more efficiently than did c-Rel at later times after infection. In all three cell types, this increased efficiency was accompanied by a shift in the majority of v-Rel from the nucleus of the cytoplasm. The concomitant relocalization of v-Rel was also demonstrated during the in vitro transformation of spleen cells. The translocation coincided with increased steady-state levels of I kappa B-alpha. Coninfection by retroviral vectors expressing v-Rel, I kappa B-alpha, or NF-kappa B1 demonstrated that either I kappa B-alpha can contribute to the shift of v-Rel to the cytoplasmic compartment. The induction of nfkb1 and Ikba mRNA and the stabilization of I kappa B-alpha by v-Rel were shown to be responsible for these effects. In comparison with c-Rel, the expression of v-Rel was associated with lower levels of transcription of these genes. However, the ability of v-Rel to stabilize I kappa B-alpha remained unchanged. The ability of v-Rel to stabilize I kappa B-alpha but poorly induce Ikba mRNA expression relative to c-Rel may play a role in regulating gene expression, thereby leading to transformation.

A mutant v-rel with increased ability to transform B lymphocytes

We observed that two strains of REV-T differ in the ability to transform bursal cells in vitro. REV-TW, with v-rel derived from a well-characterized clone and considered the prototype of the wild type, fails to generate colonies in soft agar. In contrast, REV-S2A3, derived from the S2A3 cell line, readily transforms bursal cells. With PCR, a 1,591-bp fragment containing v-rel from the REV-S2A3 provirus was cloned into plasmid pREV-0. Except for the absence of v-rel, pREV-0 is identical to pREV-TW. Five clones of pREV-PCR, each produced by an independent amplification, were obtained. The REV-PCR viruses displayed the strong transforming phenotype of REV-S2A3. Two mutations were identified in the 5' region of v-rel from REV-PCR1 to REV-PCR5: a silent mutation and a G-to-T transversion, changing the alanine at position 40 to serine. To confirm the relevance of this amino acid substitution, a 478-bp fragment containing the mutations was exchanged between REV-TW and REV-PCR1. Only the mutant viruses were able to form large colonies of bursal cells in liquid culture and to generate bursal cell colonies in soft agar. When tested on splenocytes, the wild-type viruses induced predominantly non-B-cell colonies while the mutant viruses gave origin mainly to B-cell colonies. The above results indicate that the substitution of serine for alanine at position 40 of v-Rel enhances the ability of REV-T to transform B lymphocytes in vitro. This mutation is close to the DNA-binding region, and the variant v-Rel oncoprotein shows increased kappa B-binding activity, thus confirming the relevance of this property for transformation.

Evolution of the oncogenic potential of v-rel: rel-induced expression of immunoregulatory receptors correlates with tumor development and in vitro transformation

v-rel is a viral oncogene that evolved from turkey c-rel, an NF-kappa B-related transcription factor. Numerous structural alterations record the evolutionary selection of v-rel and distinguish it from c-rel. To evaluate the biological significance of these alterations, we constructed a set of five c/v-rel hybrids in which three mutation clusters (c-Rel amino acids 1 to 97,222 to 302, and 328 to 598) were differentially distributed. These constructs, in addition to parental v-rel and c-rel and two C-terminal deletion mutants of c-rel, were expressed from a retroviral vector. An analysis of cells infected with each of the nine viruses revealed that mutations in all three domains contributed to the ability of v-rel to induce two endogenous c-rel target genes, major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I and class II, in the B-cell line DT95 as well as MHC class II in normal splenocytes. The analysis revealed a strong nonlinear correlation between the ability of a Rel protein to induce expression of MHC proteins and its capacity to produce splenic tumors and establish in vitro transformation. This correlation is consistent with the hypothesis that v-rel transforms by constitutively altering expression of genes regulated by c-rel and in this way simulates events associated with immune response-linked proliferation of cells of hematopoietic origin. Further, the 16 carboxy-terminal amino acids of c-Rel were identified as a domain responsible for producing a cytotoxic and/or cytostatic effect in DT95. Because this effect is likely to differentially influence induction of MHC expression and tumorigenesis/transformation, it may represent one factor that contributes to the nonlinearity of their correlation.

Transformation of avian fibroblasts overexpressing the c-rel proto-oncogene and a variant of c-rel lacking 40 C-terminal amino acids

The v-rel oncogene was derived from the c-rel proto-oncogene, which encodes a transcriptional activator. Expression of v-rel transforms avian hematopoietic cells and fibroblasts. Here we report that overexpression (via a replication-competent retroviral vector) of full-length c-Rel as well as a 40-amino-acid, carboxy-terminal deletion construct of c-Rel (c-Rel delta) resulted in the morphological transformation of chicken embryo fibroblasts (CEFs). Subcellular localization of Rel polypeptides in these transformed cells as determined by immunofluorescence and immunoprecipitation revealed their presence in both the nucleus and the cytoplasm, with the majority of Rel polypeptides showing cytoplasmic localization. Cytoplasmic localization could be due to interaction with I kappa B molecules, and in fact, the overexpression of c-Rel or the C-terminal deletion construct of c-Rel resulted in an increase in the levels of mRNA encoding the avian I kappa B protein pp40 and the avian homolog of the NF-kappa B protein, p105. However, expression of v-Rel resulted in the induction of pp40 mRNA only. While c-Rel was a weak activator of kappa B-mediated transcription of a reporter construct in transformed CEFs, v-Rel and c-Rel delta were transcriptional repressors. However, in spite of these differences, all of these proteins resulted in the transformation of CEFs.

In vivo evolution of c-rel oncogenic potential

The c-rel proto-oncogene belongs to the NF-kappa B/rel and I kappa B gene families, which regulate several inducible processes, including self-defense/repair and embryogenesis. Transduction of the c-rel transcription factor by the avian retrovirus resulted in the formation of a highly oncogenic virus, reticuloendotheliosis virus strain T (REV-T), that encodes the oncogene v-rel. To examine the oncogenic potential of c-rel, we inserted it into a REV-T-based retroviral vector, rescued virus [REV-C(CSV)], and infected 1-day-old chicks. All birds developed tumors, and all cell lines established from REV-C-induced tumors expressed c-rel proteins that lacked C-terminal sequences. These proteins, responsible for both in vivo and in vitro cell proliferation, were apparently selected for their oncogenic potential. In order to examine the cooperation of C-terminal deletions with other oncogenic alterations in vivo, point mutations present in the N-terminal and middle regions of v-rel were analyzed by a similar protocol. The data obtained support four conclusions. (i) c-rel proteins bearing any of three single-amino-acid mutations present in the N-terminal portion of v-rel were sufficiently oncogenic to induce tumor development in the absence of additional mutations. (ii) Combining a mutation from the N-terminal region of v-rel with a deletion of the C-terminal sequences of c-rel increases the oncogenicity of the protein in an additive manner. (iii) Mutations present in the middle of v-rel cooperated synergistically with C-terminal deletions to produce highly transforming viruses. (iv) Deletion of c-rel produced a variety of transforming rel proteins with sizes that extended from 42 to 65 kDa. The most frequently isolated rel deletion was 62 kDa in size. To examine the basis for the selection of different rel mutants, their ability to induce immunoregulatory surface receptors was analyzed. The data revealed a correlation between the induction capacity of these mutants and their corresponding contribution to in vivo tumorigenic potential. Moreover, an analysis of the subcellular localization of different rel proteins revealed an inverse correlation between the size of the protein and the proportion in the nucleus of lymphoid cells.

Heterologous C-terminal sequences disrupt transcriptional activation and oncogenesis by p59v-rel

Members of the NF-kappa B/rel family of transcription factors are regulated through a trans association with members of a family of inhibitor proteins, collectively known as I kappa B proteins, that contain five to eight copies of a 33-amino-acid repeat sequence (ankyrin repeat). Certain NF-kappa B/rel proteins are also regulated by cis-acting ankyrin repeat-containing domains. The C terminus of p105NF-kappa B, the precursor of the 50-kDa subunit of NF-kappa B, contains a series of ankyrin repeats; proteolytic removal of this ankyrin domain is necessary for the manifestation of sequence-specific DNA binding and nuclear translocation of the N-terminal product. To investigate the structural requirements important for regulation of different NF-kappa B/rel family members by polypeptides containing ankyrin repeat domains, we have constructed a p59v-rel:p105NF-kappa B chimeric protein (p110v-rel-ank). The presence of C-terminal p105NF-kappa B-derived sequences in p110v-rel-ank inhibited nuclear translocation, sequence-specific DNA binding, pp40I kappa B-alpha association, and oncogenic transformation. Sequential truncation of the C-terminal ankyrin domain of p110v-rel-ank resulted in the restoration of nuclear translocation, DNA binding, and pp40I kappa B-alpha association but did not restore the oncogenic properties of p59v-rel. The presence of 67 C-terminal p105NF-kappa B-derived amino acids was sufficient to inhibit both transcriptional activation and oncogenic transformation by p59v-rel. These results support a model in which activation of gene expression by p59v-rel is required for its ability to induce oncogenic transformation.