Evolution of a multigene family of chorion proteins in silkmoths

Silk moth chorion pseudogenes: hallmarks of genomic evolution by sequence duplication and gene conversion

The part of the genetic locus of the domesticated silk moth, Bombyx mori, in which high cysteine (Hc) chorion genes of late developmental specificity reside contains regions encompassing gene-like sequences which exhibit properties distinct from those of functional Hc genes. One of these regions has been characterized and shown to contain a chorion pseudogene, psi HcB.15, which shares pronounced similarities with a transcribed chorion pseudogene, psi HcB.12/13, which was characterized previously. Both pseudogenes are homologous to HcB chorion genes but bear multiple single nucleotide substitutions and short segmental mutations (insertions and deletions) which introduce translational frame shifts and termination codons in the coding regions. Structural characteristics unique to the two pseudogenes suggest that psi HcB.15 was generated first from a functional HcB gene and gave rise subsequently to psi HcB 12/13 as a result of a sequence duplication event. The two pseudogenes can be distinguished from each other by the presence of distinct regions of similarity to the consensus sequence of functional HcB genes which appear to have arisen from gene-conversion-mediated correctional events. These findings lend support to the hypothesis that chorion pseudogene sequences represent reservoirs of genetic information that participates in the evolution of the chorion locus rather than relics of inactivated genes passively awaiting extinction.

Evolutionary changes in the developmental expression of silkmoth chorion genes and their morphological consequences

Discrete changes in silkmoth choriogenesis have occurred during evolution, as exemplified in the present report in Antheraea polyphemus and Hyalophora cecropia. At the level of morphology, the chorion of A. polyphemus has surface structures, called aeropyle crowns, that are absent from H. cecropia. Aeropyle crowns form during the very late period of choriogenesis and consist of two substructures--lamellae and filler. Filler is present in H. cecropia in greatly reduced amounts. At the level of protein synthesis, overall similarities in the two species are maintained until the very late period of choriogenesis, when synthesis of aeropyle crown components is maximal. In H. cecropia, very late period-specific proteins are reduced in number and abundance. Several of these minor proteins are candidates for E1 and E2, the components of filler. E1 and E2 RNAs are about 35 times more abundant in A. polyphemus, despite very similar gene copy numbers and times of expression in the two species. These results support the hypothesis that evolutionary changes in chorion morphology have resulted from regulatory changes in the expression of chorion genes, either at the level of transcription or mRNA decay. The hypothesis that evolutionary changes in chorion morphology are based on terminal addition onto a preexisting developmental program is discussed.

Evolution of the silk moth chorion gene superfamily: gene families CA and CB

The nucleotide sequences of two developmentally early chorion cDNA clones from Bombyx mori define two distinct proline-rich chorion protein families, which we name CA and CB to indicate their homologies to the previously defined chorion protein families A and B, as well as the developmentally late and cysteine-rich HcA and HcB chorion families. Thus, the chorion gene superfamily has two symmetrical branches, each consisting of three families: the alpha branch (A, CA, HcA families) and the beta branch (B, CB, HcB families). The evolution of the superfamily is discussed.

Diversity in a chorion multigene family created by tandem duplications and a putative gene-conversion event

Two families of high-cysteine chorion proteins in Bombyx mori are encoded in 15 tandemly arranged nonidentical gene pairs. It is assumed that this locus arose by duplication with subsequent sequence divergence. We have compared DNA sequences from two such neighboring pairs of genes in an attempt to understand the manner in which diversity has been generated and/or removed. A high level of sequence identity (91%-99%) was found between the repeats throughout the transcribed and flanking regions, with two significant exceptions. First, in the DNA segment encoding a conserved region of the chorion proteins, ten substitutions were detected in a 39-base-pair region. This localized region of high variability would suggest an intergene conversion-like event. Second, a length difference of 141 base pairs was detected in a region encoding the carboxy-terminal arm of the protein. This difference can be explained by three separate reiterations of single codons (3 base pairs) separated in time by duplication or triplication events.

DNA sequence transfer between two high-cysteine chorion gene families in the silkmoth Bombyx mori

We have previously shown that one type of high-cysteine silkmoth chorion protein (Hc-A) has evolved from the A family of chorion proteins by radical modifications of the NH2-terminal and COOH-terminal polypeptide arms: most of the arm sequences have been deleted, while short cysteine- and glycine-containing repeats have expanded into long arrays. Strikingly similar modifications of the arms have led to the evolution of a second type of high-cysteine protein (Hc-B) from the B family of chorion proteins. It appears that the parallel evolution of these high-cysteine-encoding gene families has not been entirely independent: examination of 3' untranslated regions shows evidence of information transfer between the two families.

Novel B family sequence from an early chorion cDNA library of Bombyx mori

A cDNA library has been constructed from transcripts present during the early stages of choriogenesis in the silk-moth, Bombyx mori. Clones representing novel sequences were selected by screening the library with (i) homotypic cDNA, (ii) rDNA and typical chorion probes of the A and B multigene families and (iii) selected clones from the library, which were positive in step (i) but negative in step (ii); this third step identified clones that hybridized to distinct subsets of the library. The sequence of one such clone was determined and shown to represent a novel subfamily of the B chorion multigene family, exclusively expressed during the early choriogenic period.

Silkmoth chorion multigene families constitute a superfamily: comparison of C and B family sequences

We have characterized a new family of silkmoth chorion genes, called C, which is distinct from previously characterized A and B families. The amino acid compositions of 18 purified C proteins have been determined. Three subgroups are recognized on the basis of compositional similarities and may correspond to distinct gene families or subfamilies. The sequences of two overlapping cDNA clones have been determined in their entirety and shown to correspond to a C-specific sequence. Obvious homology is observed between the middle portions of the C sequence and previously characterized B sequences. By contrast, the arms of the C sequence share no significant similarities either with each other or with the corresponding arms of B sequences. Thus, the same tripartite structure originally observed in A and B family sequences is also present in the C family and may have functional significance. Secondary structure prediction of the C sequence is presented and supports this conclusion. The observed homology between C and B family sequences clearly establishes that silkmoth chorion multigene families constitute a superfamily.

Accepted mutations in a gene family: evolutionary diversification of duplicated DNA

We report and compare the DNA sequences of 14 silkmoth (Antheraea polyphemus) chorion genes, derived from either cDNA or chromosomal DNA clones. Seven of these genes are members of the A multigene family, and seven are members of the B family. Where available, the previously reported (Jones and Kafatos 1980) intronic and extragenic flanking DNA sequences are also considered. Closely related sequences are compared, revealing the types of spontaneous mutations that were fixed during paralogous evolution. Segmental mutations (i.e. mutations other than substitutions) are nearly always interpretable as small duplications or deletions, related to small direct repeats. Segmental mutations are strongly constrained in the coding regions, although they do occur. Nucleotide substitutions also appear to be under selective constraints: relatively few substitutions leading to amino acid replacements are accepted, silent substitutions leading to some codons (especially purine-terminated ones) are disfavored, and different compositional biases are maintained in different parts of the sequences. Other sequence differences can be interpreted as indicative of neutral drift, including most differences in non-coding regions and most T/C transitions in third-base positions. In the non-coding regions, which are thought to be only loosely constrained by selection, transitions are observed more frequently than might be expected: they account for 52% of all substitutions, and they appear to be favored two to threefold over transversions when allowance is made for the skewed base composition of these regions.