Transcription of adenovirus 2 major late and peptide IX genes under conditions of in vitro nucleosome assembly

The transformation of the DNA template in RNA polymerase II transcription: a historical perspective

The discovery of RNA polymerases I, II, and III opened up a new era in gene expression. Here I provide a personal retrospective account of the transformation of the DNA template, as it evolved from naked DNA to chromatin, in the biochemical analysis of transcription by RNA polymerase II. These studies have revealed new insights into the mechanisms by which transcription factors function with chromatin to regulate gene expression.

Preferential 5-Methylcytosine Oxidation in the Linker Region of Reconstituted Positioned Nucleosomes by Tet1 Protein

Tet (ten-eleven translocation) family proteins oxidize 5-methylcytosine (mC) to 5-hydroxymethylcytosine (hmC), 5-formylcytosine (fC), and 5-carboxycytosine (caC), and are suggested to be involved in the active DNA demethylation pathway. In this study, we reconstituted positioned mononucleosomes using CpG-methylated 382 bp DNA containing the Widom 601 sequence and recombinant histone octamer, and subjected the nucleosome to treatment with Tet1 protein. The sites of oxidized methylcytosine were identified by bisulfite sequencing. We found that, for the oxidation reaction, Tet1 protein prefers mCs located in the linker region of the nucleosome compared with those located in the core region.

Evidence for an RNA polymerization activity in axolotl and Xenopus egg extracts

We have previously reported a post-transcriptional RNA amplification observed in vivo following injection of in vitro synthesized transcripts into axolotl oocytes, unfertilized (UFE) or fertilized eggs. To further characterize this phenomenon, low speed extracts (LSE) from axolotl and Xenopus UFE were prepared and tested in an RNA polymerization assay. The major conclusions are: i) the amphibian extracts catalyze the incorporation of radioactive ribonucleotide in RNase but not DNase sensitive products showing that these products correspond to RNA; ii) the phenomenon is resistant to α-amanitin, an inhibitor of RNA polymerases II and III and to cordycepin (3′dAMP), but sensitive to cordycepin 5′-triphosphate, an RNA elongation inhibitor, which supports the existence of an RNA polymerase activity different from polymerases II and III; the detection of radiolabelled RNA comigrating at the same length as the exogenous transcript added to the extracts allowed us to show that iii) the RNA polymerization is not a 3′ end labelling and that iv) the radiolabelled RNA is single rather than double stranded. In vitro cell-free systems derived from amphibian UFE therefore validate our previous in vivo results hypothesizing the existence of an evolutionary conserved enzymatic activity with the properties of an RNA dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp).

Hepatocyte nuclear factor 3 relieves chromatin-mediated repression of the alpha-fetoprotein gene

The alpha-fetoprotein gene (AFP) is tightly regulated at the tissue-specific level, with expression confined to endoderm-derived cells. We have reconstituted AFP transcription on chromatin-assembled DNA templates in vitro. Our studies show that chromatin assembly is essential for hepatic-specific expression of the AFP gene. While nucleosome-free AFP DNA is robustly transcribed in vitro by both cervical (HeLa) and hepatocellular (HepG2) carcinoma extracts, the general transcription factors and transactivators present in HeLa extract cannot relieve chromatin-mediated repression of AFP. In contrast, preincubation with either HepG2 extract or HeLa extract supplemented with recombinant hepatocyte nuclear factor 3 alpha (HNF3alpha), a hepatic-enriched factor expressed very early during liver development, is sufficient to confer transcriptional activation on a chromatin-repressed AFP template. Transient transfection studies illustrate that HNF3alpha can activate AFP expression in a non-liver cellular environment, confirming a pivotal role for HNF3alpha in establishing hepatic-specific gene expression. Restriction enzyme accessibility assays reveal that HNF3alpha promotes the assembly of an open chromatin structure at the AFP promoter. Combined, these functional and structural data suggest that chromatin assembly establishes a barrier to block inappropriate expression of AFP in non-hepatic tissues and that tissue-specific factors, such as HNF3alpha, are required to alleviate the chromatin-mediated repression.

The nucleosome: a powerful regulator of transcription

Nucleosomes provide the architectural framework for transcription. Histones, DNA elements, and transcription factors are organized into precise regulatory complexes. Positioned nucleosomes can facilitate or impede the transcription process. These structures are dynamic, reflecting the capacity of chromatin to adopt different functional states. Histones are mobile with respect to DNA sequence. Individual histone domains are targeted for posttranslational modifications. Histone acetylation promotes transcription factor access to nucleosomal DNA and relieves inhibitory effects on transcriptional initiation and elongation. The nucleosomal infrastructure emerges as powerful contributor to the regulation of gene activity.

The H3/H4 tetramer blocks transcript elongation by RNA polymerase II in vitro

We have investigated transcript elongation efficiency by RNA polymerase II on chromatin templates in vitro. Circular plasmid DNAs bearing purified RNA polymerase II transcription complexes were assembled into nucleosomes using purified histones and transient exposure to high salt, followed by dilution and dialysis. This approach resulted in nucleosome assembly beginning immediately downstream of the transcription complexes. RNA polymerases on these nucleosomal templates could extend their 15- or 35-nucleotide nascent RNAs by only about 10 nucleotides in 15 min, even in the presence of elongation factors TFIIF and SII. Efficient transcript elongation did occur upon dissociation of nucleosomes with 1% sarkosyl, indicating that the RNA polymerases were not damaged by the high salt reconstitution procedure. Since the elongation complexes were released by sarkosyl but not by SII, these complexes apparently did not enter the arrested conformation when they encountered nucleosomes. Surprisingly, elongation was no more efficient on nucleosomal templates reconstituted only with H3/H4 tetramers, even in the presence of elongation factors and/or competitor DNA at high concentration. Thus, in a purified system lacking nucleosome remodeling factors, not only the core histone octamer but also the H3/H4 tetramer provide an nearly absolute block to transcript elongation by RNA polymerase II, even in the presence of elongation factors.

Facilitated binding of TATA-binding protein to nucleosomal DNA

BINDING of the TATA-binding protein (TBP) to the TATA box is required for transcription from many eukaryotic promoters in gene expression. Regulation of this binding is therefore likely to be an important determinant of promoter activity. Incorporation of the TATA sequence into nucleosomes dramatically reduces transcription initiation, presumably because of stereochemical constraints on binding of general transcription factors. Biochemical and genetic studies imply that cellular factors such as yeast SWI/SNF are required for activator function and might alter chromatin structure. One step that could be regulated during the activation process is TBP binding in chromatin 12, 13. We show here that binding of TBP to the TATA sequence is severely inhibited by incorporation of this sequence into a nucleosome. Inhibition can be overcome by ATP-dependent alterations in nucleosomal DNA structure mediated by hSWI/SNF, a putative human homologue of the yeast SWI/SNF complex. Additionally, the orientation of the TATA sequence relative to the surface of the histone core affects the access of TBP. We propose that the dynamic remodelling of chromatin structure to allow TBP binding is a key step in the regulation of eukaryotic gene expression.

Role of chromatin structure in the regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II

Recent studies on chromatin have concentrated on the relationship between its structure and gene activity. This topic, which addresses the fundamental mechanisms by which genes are expressed, has become a controversial issue, and the present data support the hypothesis that the structure of chromatin is an important component of transcriptional regulation. Notwithstanding, the complexity of this problem suggests that the current models are probably only a rough approximation of the truth.

Nucleosome disruption at the yeast PHO5 promoter upon PHO5 induction occurs in the absence of DNA replication

Activation of the PHO5 gene in S. cerevisiae by phosphate starvation was previously shown to be accompanied by the disappearance of four positioned nucleosomes from the promoter. To investigate the mechanism, we replaced the PHO80 gene, a negative regulator of PHO5, by a temperature-sensitive allele. As a consequence, PHO5 can be activated in the presence of phosphate by a temperature shift from 24 degrees C to 37 degrees C. Under these conditions, the promoter undergoes the same chromatin transition as in phosphate-starved cells. Disruption of the nucleosomes by the temperature shift also occurs when DNA replication is prevented. Nucleosomes re-form when the temperature is shifted from 37 degrees C back to 24 degrees C in nondividing cells. Glucose is required for the disruption of the nucleosomes during the temperature upshift, not for their re-formation during the temperature downshift. These experiments prove that DNA replication is not required for the transition between the nucleosomal and the non-nucleosomal state at the PHO5 promoter.

Characterization of a novel promoter structure and its transcriptional regulation of the murine laminin B1 gene

Expression of the laminin B1 gene is known to be induced late during the differentiation of F9 cells by retinoic acid (RA) and dibutyryl cAMP. The involvement of retinoic acid receptors (RARs) has been demonstrated recently in the late induction of laminin B1 gene expression, although the precise regulatory mechanism is not known. In this study, we have reconstituted an efficient in vitro transcription system using F9 nuclear extracts and defined the core promoter structure of the murine laminin B1 gene. The laminin B1 gene was shown to lack a TATA box. The level of the in vitro transcription of the laminin B1 gene was determined by at least three regions between the transcription initiation sites and -100. The most distal region (from -89 to -69) contained three GC boxes. The second region (from -62 to 47) contained a direct repeat of TG(C/A)GCA motif. The proximal region (from -45 to -11) contained another direct repeat of CCTCCCT(C/A)GG motif. A deletion of any one of the three regions respectively decreased the level of transcription to about 20% of wild type DNA. The protein binding analyses revealed that F9 cells contain a factor(s) binding to the TG(C/A)GCA repeat, which was also found in HeLa cells. Together with the observation that the 5' ends of the laminin B1 mRNA from the differentiated F9 cells were identical to those from the undifferentiated F9 cells, it was concluded that the three regions identified here constitute the core promoter of the laminin B1 gene.

DNA supercoiling facilitates the assembly of transcriptionally active chromatin on the adenovirus major late promoter

Assembly of nucleosomes on the adenovirus major late promoter blocked initiation of transcription by RNA polymerase II. However, the formation of transcription preinitiation complexes prevented subsequent assembly of promoter sequences into nucleosomes and allowed transcription on the chromatin templates. When the formation of preinitiation complexes was in competition with nucleosome assembly, transcription on linear or relaxed closed circular DNA was inactivated by nucleosome assembly over the promoter region. However, transcription on partially supercoiled DNA (mean superhelical density of -0.036) remained active because the rapid formation of preinitiation complexes prevented subsequent assembly of promoter sequences into nucleosomes.

Promoter sequence containing (CT)n.(GA)n repeats is critical for the formation of the DNase I hypersensitive sites in the Drosophila hsp26 gene

We have analyzed P-element-transformed lines carrying hsp26/lacZ transgenes with various deletions and substitutions within the Drosophila melanogaster hsp26 promoter region in order to identify the sequences required for the formation of the DNase I hypersensitive sites (DH sites). DH sites are generally found associated with promoters and enhancer elements of active and inducible eukaryotic genes, and are thought to be nucleosome-free regions of DNA that interact with regulatory proteins and the transcriptional machinery. There are two major DH sites located within the promoter region of the hsp26 gene, centered at -50 and at -350 (relative to the hsp26 transcription start site). The sequences from -135 to -85, which contain (CT)n.(GA)n repeats, contribute significantly to the formation of the DH sites in the hsp26 promoter region. Deletion or substitution of this (CT)n region drastically reduces the accessibility of the DNA at these sites to DNase I. This reduction in accessibility was quantified by measuring the susceptibility of the DNA within nuclei to cleavage at a restriction site within the DH site. In addition to the (CT)n region and the promoter at -85 to +11 (region P), one of two other regions must be present for effective creation of the DH sites: sequences between -351 and -135 (region A), or sequences between +11 and +632 (region D). Disruption of the wild-type chromatin structure, as assayed by the loss of accessibility to the DH sites, is correlated with a decrease in inducible transcriptional activity, even when the TATA box and heat shock regulatory elements are present in their normal positions.

Chromatin as an essential part of the transcriptional mechanism

The increasingly detailed biochemical definition of the protein complexes that regulate gene transcription has led to the re-emergence of questions about the role of histones. Much recent evidence suggests that transcriptional activation requires that transcription factors successfully compete with histones for binding to promoters, and that there may be more than one mechanism by which this is achieved.

Yeast histone H4 N-terminal sequence is required for promoter activation in vivo

To search for histone domains that may regulate transcription in vivo, we made deletions and amino acid substitutions in the histone N-termini of S. cerevisiae. Histone H4 N-terminal residues 4-23, which include the extremely conserved, reversibly acetylated lysines (at positions 5, 8, 12, and 16), were found to encompass a region required for the activation of the GAL1 promoter. Deletions in the H4 N-terminus reduce GAL1 activation 20-fold. This effect is specific to histone H4 in that large deletions in the N-termini of H2A, H2B, and H3 do not similarly decrease induction. Activation of the PHO5 promoter is reduced approximately 4- to 5-fold by these H4 deletions. Mutations in histone H4 acetylation sites and surrounding residues can cause comparable and, in some cases, even greater effects on induction of these two promoters. We postulate that the H4 N-terminus may interact with a component of the transcription initiation complex, allowing nucleosome unfolding and subsequent initiation.

Activation domains of stably bound GAL4 derivatives alleviate repression of promoters by nucleosomes

GAL4 derivatives containing an activation domain alleviated repression of a promoter during nucleosome assembly. A GAL4 derivative lacking an activation domain stably bound the promoter during nucleosome assembly but was not sufficient to preserve promoter function. The activation domain of GAL4 derivatives was essential for preserving promoter function, and thus the transcriptional stimulatory activity attributable to these activation domains increased dramatically during nucleosome assembly. Furthermore, promoter-bound activation domains allowed the formation of preinitiation complexes after nucleosome assembly. Finally, GAL4 derivatives containing activation domains significantly stimulated transcription through bacterially produced yeast TFIID only from nucleosome-assembled templates. These data indicate that acidic activation domains stimulate transcription by enhancing the ability of basal transcription factors to compete with nucleosomes for occupancy of the promoter.

The nucleoskeleton and the topology of transcription

Transcription is conventionally believed to occur by passage of a mobile polymerase along a fixed template. Evidence for this model is derived almost entirely from material prepared using hypotonic salt concentrations. Studies on subnuclear structures isolated using hypertonic conditions, and more recently using conditions closer to the physiological, suggest an alternative. Transcription occurs as the template moves past a polymerase attached to a nucleoskeleton; this skeleton is the active site of transcription. Evidence for the two models is summarised. Much of it is consistent with the polymerase being attached and not freely diffusible. Some consequences of such a model are discussed.

Changes in DNA topology can modulate in vitro transcription of certain RNA polymerase III genes

The role of DNA supercoiling in eukaryotic gene expression is not fully understood. The objective of this study was to examine the regulation of in vitro chromatin assembly by topological alterations in the DNA template using a cell-free extract from Xenopus laevis oocytes (S-150). The results suggest that input DNA topology may be a determining factor in controlling the transcriptional activity of the Xenopus tRNA and one particular 5S gene. When the input topology is supercoiled, high levels of transcription are observed, whereas input relaxed DNA is transcribed to a much lower extent. Transcription from an input relaxed template is stimulated by the addition of supercoiled nonspecific, vector DNA. Furthermore, in direct competition experiments, supercoiled DNA molecules were shown to be transcriptionally dominant over relaxed DNA molecules. Taken together, these data suggest that the efficiency with which a repressor or activator binding protein interacts with DNA may be significantly influenced by the topological status of its target. We demonstrate that modulation of reaction parameters which alter the normal topological processing events catalyzed by the S-150 can dramatically influence the level of gene expression.

Statistical positioning of nucleosomes by specific protein-binding to an upstream activating sequence in yeast

Arrays of nucleosomes were positioned with respect to the GAL1-GAL10 intergenic region inserted into Saccharomyces cerevisiae minichromosomes. Deletions of DNA flanking the upstream activation sequence left the array unaltered, showing that nucleosome positioning was not a consequence of sequence-specific histone-DNA interactions but depended on proximity to the galactose-responsive upstream activation sequence (UASG). Replacement of the upstream activation sequence by synthetic oligonucleotides with different protein-binding properties identified a short sequence within this region that is responsible for the ordered array. This sequence overlaps a binding site for GAL4 protein, a positive regulator of transcription, but exerts its effect on chromatin structure independently of GAL4, probably through binding a novel factor that is not GAL-specific.

Transcriptional regulation by the immediate early protein of pseudorabies virus during in vitro nucleosome assembly

An in vivo transcriptional activator, the immediate early protein (IE) of pseudorabies virus, potentiates the activity of the major late promoter in a reconstituted chromatin assembly system where the assembly of preinitiation complexes is in competition with the assembly of promoter sequences within nucleosomes. IE function requires the simultaneous action of TFIID and results in the formation of stable preinitiation complexes within nucleosome-assembled templates. IE is unable to reverse nucleosome-mediated repression, once established, or to further increase the activity of previously activated templates. These results indicate that IE stimulates TFIID binding to promoter sequences, effectively competing with nucleosomes, during chromatin reconstitution. The specific implications for IE function in vivo and the general implications for cellular gene regulation are discussed.

Binding of transcription factor TFIID to the major late promoter during in vitro nucleosome assembly potentiates subsequent initiation by RNA polymerase II

A plasmid containing the major late promoter was assembled into nucleosomes in a Xenopus oocyte extract, isolated by gel filtration, and found to be refractory to transcription initiation in vitro. However, exposure of the promoter to HeLa nuclear extract or to a mixture of isolated transcription factors prior to nucleosome assembly prevented nucleosome-mediated repression of the promoter. Inactivation or elimination of the TATA box-binding factor (TFIID) abolished the ability of these treatments to preserve promoter function. Preincubation with TFIID alone prevented repression and resulted in TFIID being sequestered into the nucleosome-assembled templates. Preincubation with all the transcription factors resulted in the assembly of nucleosome templates containing a near complete preinitiation complex, which required only the addition of TFIIE for transcription initiation.