Pattern electroretinogram and peripheral colour contrast thresholds in ocular hypertension and glaucoma: comparison and correlation of results

Electrophysiology and colour: a comparison of methods to evaluate inner retinal function

PURPOSE

Several methods are routinely used in the clinic to diagnose and monitor diseases of inner retinal function. In this study, we compare four such methods in patients with diabetes and glaucoma, to determine correlations between their results and to determine which method is most sensitive for detecting disease.

METHODS

Twenty control subjects, 12 patients with early glaucoma and eight patients with diabetes mellitus, were enrolled in the study. All underwent four examinations: transient pattern electroretinogram (PERG), multifocal pattern electroretinogram (mfPERG), chromatic contrast threshold measurements (protan and tritan), and blue-on-yellow short-wavelength automated perimetry (SWAP).

RESULTS

For the total cohort of 40 subjects, the results show a significant correlation between the amplitudes of the PERG and those of the mfPERG, as well as between the tritan contrast thresholds and the SWAP MD. Furthermore, ROC analyses reveal that colour contrast thresholds could significantly distinguish between the patient and the control group. Glaucoma patients alone could also be distinguished.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that the methods compared in this study show correlations between their results if they are testing same pathway or underling cells, and that the colour contrast threshold is the most sensitive method to detect early functional deficits in diabetic and glaucoma patients.

A control experiment for studies that show improved visual sensitivity with intraocular pressure lowering in glaucoma

PURPOSE

Contrast sensitivity sometimes increases in patients with open-angle glaucoma when intraocular pressure (IOP) is decreased. Although often interpreted as demonstrating reversible glaucoma-induced dysfunction, this result, if true, could simply reflect a general relationship between sensitivity and IOP in visual mechanisms unaffected by glaucoma. To investigate this relationship, we test the hypothesis that reducing IOP in eyes without glaucoma (ocular hypertension) does not increase perimetric contrast sensitivity.

DESIGN

Comparative case series.

PARTICIPANTS

A total of 692 participants drawn from the Ocular Hypertension Treatment Study (OHTS) (22 clinical centers).

METHODS

Commercially available topical ocular hypotensive medications.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Post hoc analysis of IOP and perimetric contrast sensitivity (mean deviation [MD] and pattern standard deviation [PSD]) both at baseline (0 months, immediately before ocular antihypertensive therapy) and at 6-month review. An additional 618 control eyes from OHTS that did not receive treatment were examined over the same period. Data from the second phase of OHTS also were examined, and control eyes then received treatment.

RESULTS

Treated eyes had a decrease in IOP at 6 months (5.1 mmHg, P<0.001) but no significant change in MD (0.04 decibels [dB], P = 0.59) or PSD (0.03 dB, P = 0.19), relative to controls. A similar decrease in IOP was found for eyes that began treatment in the second phase of OHTS, but no significant change in MD or PSD.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite using a large sample size, we found no relationship between perimetric contrast sensitivity and IOP reduction in ocular hypertension, which suggests that previous sensitivity changes seen in patients with glaucoma, if true, are indicative of reversible glaucoma-induced dysfunction rather than a general relationship between sensitivity and IOP in visual mechanisms unaffected by glaucoma.

Pattern Electroretinography Changes in Patients with Established or Suspected Primary Open Angle Glaucoma

PURPOSE

To assess pattern electroretinogram (PERG) changes in patients with established or suspected primary open angle glaucoma (POAG).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Transient PERG using LV Prasad eye electrodes were performed in 76 normal, 32 glaucomatous and 22 glaucoma suspect eyes. The P50 amplitude, N95 amplitude and P50 latency were analyzed. The results were further analyzed with receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and discriminant function analysis (DFA).

RESULTS

The P50 and N95 amplitude of the POAG and glaucoma suspect groups were significantly reduced. There was significant shortening in the P50 latency in the POAG and glaucoma suspect groups. DFA using the P50 amplitude, N95 amplitude and P50 latency waveform parameters showed a sensitivity and specificity of 76.67 and 88.57% respectively.

CONCLUSION

Pattern ERG demonstrated significant changes in POAG patients and suspects. ROC curves for the three wave parameters demonstrated that N95 amplitude was the better indicator for diagnosis of POAG when used individually. How to cite this article: Ganekal S, Dorairaj S, Jhanji V. Pattern Electroretinography Changes in Patients with Established or Suspected Primary Open Angle Glaucoma. J Current Glau Prac 2013;7(2):39-42.

Visual-Evoked Response, Pattern Electroretinogram, and Psychophysical Magnocellular Thresholds in Glaucoma, Optic Atrophy, and Dyslexia

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to compare visual-evoked response (VEP) pattern electroretinogram (PERG) and psychophysical thresholds to the same stimulus, designed to be optimal for the magnocellular system, in suspects and patients with early glaucoma, patients with optic nerve disease, dyslexic children, and age-matched controls.

METHODS

Stimuli were low spatial frequency sinusoidal luminance profile gratings abruptly phase reversing at 7.14 Hz. Electrophysiological recordings were made at 50%, 30%, 20%, 10%, and 5% contrast. Threshold was the lowest contrast evoking a clear response at the stimulus frequency. Three independent judges scored the traces. Psychophysical thresholds were obtained by ascending and descending method of limits. VEPs and PERGs to International Society for Clinical Electrophysiology of Vision (ISCEV) standards and to increasing spatial frequencies were obtained as parvocellular specific controls. Patients were diagnosed independently by the referring professionals.

RESULTS

Parvocellular-specific responses were normal, except in cases with explicable visual acuity loss. The judges scores correlated highly (> 0.9). VEPs and PERGs correlated highly and each correlated less well with psychophysics in normals, glaucoma, and dyslexia but the opposite occurred in optic nerve disease. VEPs had the lowest normal values and least variance (all adults < 5%, children < 10%, PERGs < 20%). In glaucoma, VEP magnocellular deficits occurred in 85% of recently diagnosed positive cases, 48% of high-risk suspects, 39% of low-risk suspects, and ocular hypertensives. Approximately 28% of dyslexics had VEP magnocellular deficits. PERG losses were less frequent. There was a clear dichotomy and low correlations between psychophysics and electrophysiology both within and between groups. Psychophysical threshold elevations were absent in all glaucoma groups, often large in optic atrophy and small (2.5%) but highly significant in dyslexia.

CONCLUSION

Contrast thresholds to magnocellular-specific stimuli are consistent in cortex and retina. VEPs are more reliable. Psychophysics seems to tap different mechanisms. VEPs are very sensitive to early glaucoma. The lack of VEP loss in dyslexia suggests the other losses are artifactual. Further research is needed to see if stimuli even more like the frequency-doubling technology are more useful clinically.

Mid-peripheral pattern electrical retinal responses in normals, glaucoma suspects, and glaucoma patients

AIMS

Reliance on intraocular pressure, optic nerve cupping changes, nerve fibre layer integrity, and visual field changes may delay treatment of glaucoma since irreversible changes may have already occurred at the time of diagnosis. Abnormal pattern electrical retinal responses (PERR or PERG) have been demonstrated in patients with ocular hypertension (no visual field changes) and glaucoma when visual stimulation was presented to the central field. Since glaucomatous visual field changes tend to occur first in the mid-periphery, the use of PERR outside of the central field may offer an earlier indication of glaucomatous involvement.

METHODS

Glaucoma suspects and glaucoma patients were derived from a university practice. Normal subjects were recruited from non-patient volunteers. Alternating bar gratings were presented in the supranasal, supratemporal, infratemporal, and infranasal visual field. Six spatial frequencies, from 0.25 to 6.0 cycles per degree, were used for normal volunteers; three spatial frequencies, from 0.38 to 1.5 cycles per degree, were presented to suspects and glaucoma patients. Time of onset of the first negative (N35) and first positive peak (P50) and the amplitude consisting of the absolute difference between the first negative peak and first positive peak (P50 amplitude) are reported. Age corrected values were determined for normals, suspects, and glaucoma patients for each spatial frequency and for each quadrant in the visual field.

RESULTS

Mean P50 amplitudes from normal subjects showed spatial tuning in all quadrants with reduced low frequency attenuation. Normals demonstrated a small decline in amplitude with age. Glaucoma patients demonstrated an age corrected reduction in amplitude and early implicit times. Glaucoma suspects had values between those of normal and glaucoma subjects. P50 amplitudes were weakly correlated with increasing cup to disc diameter ratio. A glaucoma patient with asymmetric visual field loss demonstrated significant diminution of the PERR bilaterally.

CONCLUSION

The PERR, using mid-peripheral stimulation, may be a sensitive tool for the early detection of glaucoma. Further refinements can speed clinical data acquisition and enhance signal to noise ratio.

Peripheral colour contrast thresholds in ocular hypertension and glaucoma

PURPOSE

To evaluate a new test for peripheral colour contrast sensitivity as a tool for early diagnosis of glaucoma.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Peripheral colour contrast sensitivity was measured by a computer and colour monitor system developed by Arden and co-workers. The monitor displays an annulus subtending 25 degrees at the retina. During the test, 45 degrees of the annulus is removed in one of four quadrants. The patient is asked to identify this quadrant, first at suprathreshold levels and then as the colour contrast between the annulus and the background is varied in order to establish the threshold for identification. The tested colours were varied along the protan, deutan and tritan colour confusion axes, respectively. Thirty-three normal subjects, 22 glaucoma patients and 69 ocular hypertensive patients were examined. The ocular hypertensive patients were divided into a low risk group, a medium risk group and a high risk group.

RESULTS

The colour contrast thresholds for the glaucoma group and the high risk ocular hypertensive group were significantly (p < 0.001) higher for all three colour axes compared with the normal group. There were also significant (p < 0.05-0.001) differences for all axes between the glaucoma group on the one hand and the ocular hypertensive low risk group on the other hand. There were, however, overlaps in colour contrast thresholds between all groups.

CONCLUSION

Although there is a large and statistically significant difference in average colour contrast thresholds between normals and glaucoma patients, it was difficult to find an appropriate cut-off point to separate the two groups. Further studies must clarify the influence of early stages of common diseases such as cataract, diabetes and age-related maculopathy on colour contrast sensitivity.

PCR-SSCP analysis of the glucocorticoid-responsive element of the atrial natriuretic peptide gene in familial primary open-angle glaucoma

1. Familial primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) is a heterogeneous disease of unknown aetiology and the elucidation of the underlying genetic mechanisms contributing to phenotypic expression will be essential if earlier diagnosis of at-risk individuals and more specific medical treatment can be achieved. In a significant percentage of patients with POAG, intraocular pressure increases in response to topical ocular glucocorticoids. 2. Atrial natriuretic peptide (ANP) assists in the regulation of intraocular pressure levels and binding of the glucocorticoid receptor dimer to the glucocorticoid-responsive element in intron 2 of the ANP gene has been shown to increase ANP mRNA levels in vitro. We amplified and examined this sequence in the ANP gene by PCR-SSCP analysis in 100 patients with familial POAG and in 60 normal control subjects. No base alterations in the amplified product were found. 3. Thus, the present study found no evidence for an alteration in the sequence of the glucocorticoid-responsive element of the ANP gene that could alter ANP gene transcription in patients with familial POAG. The mechanism responsible for the increase in intraocular pressure levels in response to glucocorticoids is most likely independent of the glucocorticoid-responsive element in the ANP gene.

Diabetes can alter the interpretation of visual dysfunction in ocular hypertension

PURPOSE

The authors examined the influences of diabetes on the results of visual function testing in patients with ocular hypertension (OHT).

METHODS

Color vision (desaturated D-15), contrast sensitivity together with both transient and steady-state pattern electroretinogram (PERG) findings from patients with documented OHT were examined in a historic cohort study. All patients were examined at least four times (mean, 7.8 examinations) during a follow-up period that ranged from 1.5 to 4 years. Only individuals who maintained normal visual fields throughout the follow-up period were included in this analysis. The sample included 158 patients with OHT. Of these patients, 32 were African-American and 23 had a history of noninsulin-dependent diabetes with no evidence of retinopathy (by ophthalmoscopy). Normative data were obtained from a control group that included 65 white subjects with normal vision who did not have diabetes and who were similar in age to the patients in the OHT group.

RESULTS

Color vision, contrast sensitivity, and PERG results were reduced significantly in patients with diabetes and OHT relative to control subjects. Patients with OHT who did not have diabetes did not have similar abnormalities. Color vision and PERG results also were reduced significantly in patients with diabetes and OHT relative to those with OHT who did not have diabetes. Only the steady-state PERG was reduced in African-American patients with OHT (relative to both control subjects and white patients with OHT).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with diabetes and OHT have significantly greater color vision, contrast sensitivity and PERG abnormalities than patients with OHT without diabetes. Race factors do not play a major role in these differences. Screening for diabetes is recommended before drawing conclusions from the results of these types of functional tests in patients with OHT.

Color axis evaluation of the Farnsworth Munsell 100-hue test in primary open-angle glaucoma and normal-pressure glaucoma

BACKGROUND

It was the aim of the present study to analyze a separate color-axis evaluation of the Farnsworth Munsell 100-hue test (FM 100) in primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) and normal pressure glaucoma (NPG).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

One eye of each of 112 individuals (age 35-65 years, visual acuity > 20/28, myopia < -7.5 D) was included. The groups consisted of 62 normal subjects and 50 glaucoma patients (33 POAG and 17 NPG). We evaluated the FM 100 overall error score and the error scores of the protan, deutan and tritan axes. The results were compared with perimetric (Octopus G1 mean defect) and morphometric data of the optic disc.

RESULTS

All error scores were significantly higher in the glaucoma group than in the normal group. In an age-related evaluation, differences were significant in age groups above 45 years. No significant differences were found between the POAG and NPG groups. The sensitivity of the overall score to identify glaucoma was 62% (specificity 80%). In the glaucoma group the overall score and the protan score increased significantly with the mean defect (r > 0.3, P < 0.01). Several scores increased slightly with decreasing neuroretinal rim area, but not on a significant level. Separate color-axis evaluations did not show any stronger correlations and did not reveal any differences between POAG eyes and NPG eyes. This was true even for the tritan axis error.

CONCLUSIONS

Although FM 100 error scores are higher in glaucoma eyes and increase with glaucomatous damage, they do not separate well. In the sample of this study, separate color-axis evaluation did not improve the diagnostic value. With the FM100 a different pattern of color vision defects in POAG and NPG eyes could not be detected.