Antenatal HIV testing: current problems, future solutions. Survey of uptake in one London hospital

Testing HIV positive in pregnancy: A phenomenological study of women's experiences

OBJECTIVE

globally women receive HIV testing in pregnancy; however, limited information is available on their experiences of this potentially life-changing event. This study aims to explore women's experiences of receiving a positive HIV test result following antenatal screening.

DESIGN

a qualitative, phenomenological approach.

SETTING

two public National Health Service (NHS) hospitals and HIV support organisations.

PARTICIPANTS

a purposive sampling strategy was used. Thirteen black African women with a positive HIV result, in England, participated.

METHODS

data were collected using in-depth semi-structured interviews. An interpretive phenomenological approach to data analysis was used.

FINDINGS

the emergent phenomenon was transition and transformation of 'being,' as women accepted HIV as part of their lives. Paired themes support the phenomenon: shock and disbelief; anger and turmoil; stigma and confidentiality issues; acceptance and resilience. Women had extreme reactions to their positive HIV diagnosis, compounded by the cultural belief that they would die. Initial disbelief of the unexpected result developed into sadness at the loss of their old self. Turmoil was evident, as women considered termination of pregnancy, self-harm and suicide. Women felt isolated from others and relationship breakdowns often occurred. Most reported the pervasiveness of stigma, and how this was managed alongside living with HIV. Coping strategies included keeping HIV 'secret' and making their child(ren) the prime focus of life. Growing resilience was apparent with time.

KEY CONCLUSIONS

this study gives midwives unique understanding of the complexities and major implications for women who tested positive for HIV. Women's experiences resonated with processes of bereavement, providing useful insight into a transitional and transformational period, during which appropriate support can be targeted.

IMPLICATIONS

midwives are crucial in improving the experience of women when they test HIV positive and to do this they need to be appropriately trained. Midwives need to acknowledge the social and psychological impact of HIV and pathways should be developed to support early referral for appropriate support.

Mother to infant transmission of HIV

Mother-to-infant transmission is the route by which the vast majority of children acquire HIV. Several refinements in our understanding in how to reduce the risk of transmission have been made in the past year. The risks from prolonged breast feeding, and the protective effects of caesarean section have been clarified. Shorter interventions using antiretroviral drugs are useful in resource-constrained settings. In developed countries, combination antiretroviral therapies to reduce maternal viral loads to below limits of detection are being explored, but there is concern about toxicity particularly of indinavir in pregnancy. Combining interventions can reduce transmission rates to less than 2%.

Social and ethnic inequalities in the offer and uptake of prenatal screening and diagnosis in the UK: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To review studies addressing the question of whether there are social inequalities in either the offer or the uptake of prenatal testing in the UK.

METHOD

Systematic review of studies assessing the offer or uptake of prenatal screening or diagnosis according to social class or ethnic origin. Electronic databases were searched using a strategy developed for a review of inequalities in access to maternity care supplemented with terms specific to prenatal testing. Further papers were identified from reference lists, citation searches and key organizations.

RESULTS

From over 600 identified papers, 41 were potentially relevant. Twenty met the inclusion criteria. The studies included covered screening and/or diagnosis for Down's syndrome, neural tube defects, haemoglobin disorders and HIV. Many studies were limited by small numbers or poor reporting of data and analysis. Six studies reported data on prenatal testing according to women's social class or educational level. None found any significant social inequalities in testing. Some studies suggested that women of South Asian origin might be up to 70% less likely to receive prenatal testing for haemoglobin disorders and Down's syndrome than White women. A small number of studies suggested that South Asian women might be less likely to be offered testing.

CONCLUSIONS

This review provides some evidence of ethnic inequalities in access to prenatal testing. Further research is required to improve our understanding of why testing may not be offered, the reasons for failure to take up testing when offered, and to identify whether there are other social inequalities in access to prenatal testing.

Dropouts in a long-term follow-up study involving voluntary counseling and HIV testing: experience from a cohort of police officers in Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania

BACKGROUND

Results of most population-based studies primarily are derived from people who responded positively and thereby continued to participate in such studies. It is, however, equally important to know the characteristics of study subjects who drop out to learn the reasons that kept them from continuing to participate in the study, especially because they had initially agreed to participate in such a study. In studies with long-term follow-up, reasons for nonresponse may provide invaluable information that may be gathered through continued contact with study subjects who have withdrawn from the study.

OBJECTIVES

To determine characteristics of study participants who withdrew from an ongoing study of police officers, which involved counseling and HIV testing, and to determine reasons for their discontinued participation.

METHODS

Demographic characteristics of a cohort of police officers who had been participating in a study to determine their suitability for HIV vaccine trials were analyzed. Characteristics of those who did not return for the second survey of appointments for HIV testing were compared with those who continued their participation. A randomly selected sample of 132 police officers who did not participate in the second survey of HIV testing were asked why they did not return. Answers were obtained from 84 people who had discontinued their participation.

RESULTS

Of eligible police officers, 2087 (72.1%) responded to the call for follow-up appointments, whereas 807 (27.9%) did not return. Those who did not return to participate in the second survey had significantly higher rates of HIV seropositivity (17.2%) than those who did return (13.5%) (p <.05). The rate of return in unmarried participants was worse (p <.05) than the rate among married participants. Rates of sexual contacts with partners other than their spouses and levels of alcohol consumption did not differ between the two groups. Reasons for dropping out of the study included fear of knowing results of HIV testing in 54.6%, lack of time to continue in 34.5%, and fears about job security in 3.6%.

CONCLUSION

Fears of finding out that one might be seropositive need to be answered at recruitment, and practical arrangements must be made to facilitate further follow-up. A bias for lower incidence might be introduced in vaccine trials if participants thought to be at highest risk for HIV infection discontinue participation.