Measurement of pain in children in the emergency department

Use of analgesia in a paediatric accident and emergency department following limb trauma

The objective of this study was to assess analgesic use and the use of a pain scoring system on those children presenting to a paediatric accident and emergency (A&E) department with a history of injury due to trauma. A random sample of patients who presented to a paediatric A&E department over a 6-week period with a history of limb trauma were prospectively studied. Pain severity scores were assessed on arrival and at 10, 30 and 60 minutes using the Douhit Faces Scale and any analgesia given or plaster application was noted. One hundred and seventy-two patients were studied. The median age was 10 years (range 3-13 years) and the majority, 56%, were male. The mean initial pain scores were 2.7 (range 1-4) for boys and 3.0 (range 1-4) for girls. The presenting injuries were 103 upper or lower limb fractures and 69 'soft tissue' injuries. Only 84 (49%) patients received analgesic medication in the department (30% morphine; 70% paracetamol); analgesia was not given to the remaining 88 (51%). Of these, 7 declined analgesia, and 5 had already taken analgesia on arrival to A&E. Despite prompt triage (median time 2 minutes, range 0-10 minutes), the median time from arrival to paracetamol administration was 20 minutes (range 4-105 minutes) and for morphine was 14 minutes (range 2-57 minutes). Pain is a common symptom in patients presenting to A&E. Because children's pain can be particularly difficult to assess, a pain scoring system such as the Douhit Faces Scale can be a useful means of pain assessment in the A&E setting. Despite increased awareness, pain is still under treated in the A&E department.

Improving the delivery of analgesia to children in pain

OBJECTIVES

To improve the time taken for children arriving to the accident and emergency (A&E) department in pain to receive analgesia. Delivery within 30 minutes of triage was taken as an achievable goal.

METHODS

262 children who had received analgesia in the "minor injuries" area of West Middlesex University Hospital A&E department were studied over a four month period. Current practice was indicated over the first two months by retrospectively looking at data from 129 children's A&E cards. A Paediatric Pain Protocol was then introduced and another 133 children's cards studied to see if this had made an improvement. The protocol for those children aged over 4 years differed to that for children aged 4 years and under.

RESULTS

For children aged 4 years and over, the introduction of the protocol significantly increased the number that received analgesia within 30 minutes of triage: 55.3% (n=54) post-protocol versus 34.0% (n=33) pre-protocol (p=0.003). However, for children aged 4 years and under there was no change in the proportion that received analgesia within 30 minutes of triage: 56.7% (n=17) postprotocol versus 59.4% (n=19) pre-protocol (p=0.829).

CONCLUSIONS

The introduction of a simple Paediatric Pain Protocol has improved the time taken to deliver analgesia to children arriving in this A&E department.

Who gives pain relief to children?

OBJECTIVE

To compare pre-hospital parental administration of pain relief for children with that of the accident and emergency (A&E) department staff and to ascertain the reason why pre-hospital analgesia is not being given.

DESIGN/METHODS

An anonymous prospective questionnaire was given to parents/guardians of children < 17 years. The children were all self referred with head injuries or limb problems including burns. The first part asked for details of pain relief before attendance in the A&E department. The second part of the questionnaire contained a section for the examining doctor and triage nurse to fill in. The duration of the survey was 28 days.

RESULTS

Altogether 203 of 276 (74%) of children did not receive pain relief before attendance at the A&E department. Reasons for parents not giving pain relief included 57/203 (28%) who thought that giving painkillers would be harmful; 43/203 (21%) who did not give painkillers because the accident did not happen at home; and 15/203 (7%) who thought analgesia was the responsibility of the hospital. Eighty eight of the 276 (32%) did not have any painkillers, suitable for children, at home. A&E staff administered pain relief in 189/276 (68%).

CONCLUSIONS

Parents often do not give their children pain relief before attending the A&E department. Parents think that giving painkillers may be harmful and often do not have simple analgesics at home. Some parents do not perceive that their child is in pain. Parents require education about appropriate pre-hospital pain relief for their children.