MMR profile and microsatellite instability status in colorectal mucinous adenocarcinoma with synchronous metastasis: a new clue for the clinical practice

MLH1 gene promoter methylation status partially overlaps with CpG methylator phenotype (CIMP) in colorectal adenocarcinoma

BACKGROUND

RAS/BRAF mutations, mismatch DNA repair complex deficiency (MMRd)/microsatellite instability (MSI), and CpG methylator phenotype (CIMP) are key molecular actors in colorectal carcinogenesis. To date, conflicting evidence about the correlations between these molecular features has been reported.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospectively selected cohort of 123 CRCs was divided into 3 groups based on the molecular characteristics: MMR proficient (MMRp)/BRAF p.V600E mutated (BRAFmut), MMRd/BRAFmut, and MMRd/BRAF wild type (BRAFwt). MLH1 promoter (pMLH1) methylation status was assessed by pyrosequencing. For 82 samples the CIMP phenotype was evaluated using the EpiTect® MethyLight kit.

RESULTS

The MMRd/BRAFmut group showed a higher pMLH1 methylation rate compared to both the MMRd/BRAFwt and the MMRp/BRAFmut groups. Overall, the two MMRd groups had a higher methylation rate compared to the MMRp cases independently from the mutational status of BRAF (p-value <0.0001). The MMRd/BRAFmut group was characterized by a 90.0 % of CIMP high (CIMP-H) tumors of which 97.2 % were pMLH1 methylated. Instead, the MMRd/BRAFwt group presented 50.0 % of CIMP-H adenocarcinomas.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrates that pMLH1 hypermethylation, MMRd, BRAFmut and CIMP phenotype do not completely overlap in CRC. These findings further refine the knowledge on the molecular landscape of CRC and may have critical implications also for the clinical management of the disease.

The Day-To-Day Practice of MMR and MSI Assessment in Colorectal Adenocarcinoma: What We Know and What We Still Need to Explore

BACKGROUND

The DNA mismatch repair (MMR) system is a highly preserved protein complex recognizing short insertions, short deletions, and single base mismatches during DNA replication and recombination. MMR protein status is identified using immunohistochemistry. Deficit in one or more MMR proteins, configuring deficient MMR status (dMMR), leads to frameshift mutations particularly clustered in microsatellite repeats. Thus, microsatellite instability (MSI) is the epiphenomenon of dMMR. In colorectal cancer (CRC), MMR/MSI status is a biomarker with prognostic and predictive value of resistance to 5-fluorouracil and response to immune checkpoint inhibitor therapy.

SUMMARY

In this Review, we describe the challenges the practicing pathologist may face in relation to the assessment of MMR/MSI status and any open issues which still need to be addressed, focusing on pre-analytic issues, pitfalls in the interpretation, and technical aspects of the different assays.

KEY MESSAGES

The current methods of detecting dMMR/MSI status have been optimized for CRCs, and whether these techniques can be applied to all tumor and specimen types is still not fully understood. Following the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), tissue/site agnostic drug approval of pembrolizumab for advanced/metastatic MSI tumors, MMR/MSI status in gastrointestinal tract is a common request from the oncologist. In this setting, several issues still need to be addressed, including criteria for sample adequacy.

Diagnostic performance of Idylla MSI test in colorectal cancer biopsies

Universal testing for microsatellite instability (MSI) is recommended in colorectal cancer (CRC) to screen for Lynch syndrome and to guide optimal treatment and follow-up of the patients. Especially in neoadjuvant setting, where immuno-oncological treatments have recently shown excellent responses, identification of MSI status at biopsy is a prerequisite. Idylla MSI test offers a rapid and automated test to assess MSI-status from formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tumor tissue sections. In this study, we compared the performance of the Idylla MSI test to mismatch repair (MMR) protein immunohistochemistry (IHC) using 117 CRC biopsies with previously known deficient MMR status. The concordance between Idylla and IHC was 99.0% (95/96) for biopsies with the recommended ≥ 20% tumor cell content. Further, 85.7% (18/21) of suboptimal CRC biopsy specimens (tumor cell content 5-15%) were diagnosed as MSI. Overall, we identified four discrepant cases of which three had tumor cell content less than 20%, explaining the discordant result. Our study shows that the Idylla MSI test offers a competent tool for MSI screening in CRC biopsy specimens.

Impact of DNA mismatch repair proteins deficiency on number and ratio of lymph nodal metastases in colorectal adenocarcinoma

BACKGROUND

Approximately 15 % of colorectal adenocarcinomas (CRCs) are characterized by an altered expression of DNA mismatch repair (MMR) proteins (i.e. MMR deficiency [MMRd]). Lymph node ratio (LNR) represents one of the most important prognostic markers in non-advanced CRCs. No significant data are available regarding LNR distribution depending on MMR status.

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY

The aim of the present work was to compare pathological and clinical characteristics of MMRd tumors versus MMR proficient (MMRp) cases. Particular attention was paid to how these molecular sub-groups relate to the LNR.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A mono-Institutional series of 1037 consecutive surgically treated stage I-IV CRCs were retrospectively selected and data were obtained from pathological reports. Cases were characterized for MMR/MSI status by means of immunohistochemistry or for microsatellite instability (MSI) analysis.

RESULTS

MMRd/MSI tumors (n = 194; 18.7 %) showed significant differences in comparison to MMRp lesions for sex (female prevalence 50.5 % vs 40.7 %; p = 0.013), age (74.2 vs 69.2; p < 0.001), location (right side; p < 0.001), diameter (larger than MMRp; p < 0.001), growth pattern (expansive pattern of growth; p < 0.001), peri- (p = 0.0002) and intra-neoplastic (p = 0.0018) inflammatory infiltrate, presence of perineural invasion (p < 0.001), stage (lower stage at presentation; p < 0.001), grade (higher prevalence of high-grade tumors; p < 0.001), and LNR (lower; p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

MMRd/MSI tumors are a distinct molecular CRC subtype characterized by a significantly lower LNR in comparison to MMRp lesions. These data further support the prognostic impact of MMRd/MSI status in early-stage CRCs.

Clinical Testing for Mismatch Repair in Neoplasms Using Multiple Laboratory Methods

Background: A deficiency in DNA mismatch repair function in neoplasms can be assessed by an immunohistochemical (IHC) analysis of the deficiency/loss of the mismatch repair proteins (dMMR) or by PCR-based methods to assess high microsatellite instability (MSI-H). In some cases, however, there is a discrepancy between the IHC and MSI analyses. Several studies have addressed the issue of discrepancy between IHC and MSI deficiency assessment, but there are limited studies that also incorporate genetic/epigenetic alterations. Methods: In this single-institution retrospective chart-review study, we reviewed 706 neoplasms assessed between 2015 and 2021. All eligible neoplasms were assessed by IHC testing, MSI analysis by PCR-based assay, and tumor-normal paired next-generation sequencing (NGS) analysis. Eighty percent of neoplasms with MLH1 protein loss had a concurrent MLH1 promoter methylation analysis. Mutation data for MMR genes, IHC, MSI analysis, and tumor histology were correlated with each other. Results: Fifty-eight (8.2%) of 706 neoplasms had MSI-H by PCR and/or dMMR by IHC. Of the 706 analyzed neoplasms, 688 neoplasms (98%) had concordant results: MSI-H/dMMR (n = 44), microsatellite-stable (MSS)/proficient MMR (pMMR) (n = 625), and MSI-Low (L)/pMMR (n = 19). Of the remaining 18 neoplasms, 9 had a major discordance: MSS/loss of MSH2 and MSH6 (n = 3), MSS/loss of MSH6 (n = 2), MSS/Loss of MLH1 and PMS2 (n = 1), and MSI-High/pMMR (n = 3). In total, 57% of cases with dMMR and 61% of cases with MSI-H had a null mutation of an MMR gene mutation (or methylation of the MLH1 promoter), whereas this figure was 1% for neoplasms with a normal IHC or MSI pattern (p < 0.001). Among 9 cases with major discordance between MSI and IHC, only 3 cases (33%) had an underlying genetic/epigenetic etiology, whereas 37 (76%) of 49 cases with MSI-H and/or dMMR and without major discordance had an underlying genetic abnormality (p = 0.02). Discussion: For most neoplasms, IHC and PCR-based MSI testing results are concordant. In addition, an underlying genetic abnormality (a null mutation of an MMR gene or MLH1 promoter methylation) was attributable to dMMR and/or MSI-H findings. For neoplasms with major discordance in IHC and MSI testing, the addition and integration of NGS results and MLH1 promoter methylation analyses can be beneficial for resolving borderline cases, thereby facilitating patient management.

Microsatellite Instable Colorectal Adenocarcinoma Diagnostics: The Advent of Liquid Biopsy Approaches

The introduction of immunotherapy has revolutionized the oncological targeted therapy paradigm. Microsatellite instability (MSI) identifies a subgroup of colorectal cancers (CRCs) which respond to treatment with immune checkpoint inhibitors. Tissue biopsy is currently the gold standard for the assessment of MSI/Mismatch Repair deficiency (MMRd) by means immunohistochemistry or molecular assays. However, the application of liquid biopsy in the clinic may help to overcome several limitations of tissue analysis and may provide great benefit to the diagnostic scenario and therapeutic decision-making process. In the context of MSI/MMRd CRC, the use of liquid biopsy may allow to establish MSI/MMR status if tissue sampling cannot be performed or in case of discordant tissue biopsies. Liquid biopsy may also become a powerful tool to monitor treatment response and the onset resistance to immunotherapy over time and to stratify of MSI/MMRd patients according to their risk of relapse and metastases. The aim of this review is to summarize the main technical aspects and clinical applications, the benefits, and limitations of the use of liquid biopsy in MSI/MMRd colorectal cancer patients.