A comparison of results after intracapsular enucleation and total extirpation of acoustic tumors

Large vestibular schwannoma treated using a cranial nerve sparing approach with planned subtotal microsurgical resection and stereotactic radiosurgery: meta-analysis and International Stereotactic Radiosurgery Society (ISRS) practice guidelines

INTRODUCTION

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) has become a standard of care for small- to medium- size vestibular schwannomas (VS), while the majority of patients with large VS still require microsurgical resection due to potential consequences of long tract and cranial nerve compression, intracranial hypertension or hydrocephalus.

METHODS

We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature specific to planned subtotal resection for large VSs followed by SRS to the residual tumor to inform clinical practice guideline development. The Medline and Embase databases were used to apply the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) approach to search for manuscripts reporting outcomes for large VSs treated with this paradigm, with a search end date of June 1st 2023. Crude outcomes were pooled using weighted random effects.

RESULTS

12 series met inclusion criteria reporting on treatment outcomes for 677 patients. Overall tumor control was 89.9% (86.9-92.9%, p < 0.001), with tumor stability observed in 43.9% (19.9-68%, p < 0.001) and tumor reduction in 39.9% (57-74.2%, p = 0.02) post-SRS. Facial nerve functional preservation immediately after microsurgery was 88.0% (82.7-93.3%, p < 0.001), improving to 94.4% (91.4-97.4%, p < 0.001) at last follow-up. Cochlear functional preservation immediately after microsurgery was 58.8% (33.2-84.4%, p < 0.001), decreasing to 57.4% (33-81.8%, p < 0.001) at last follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

A cranial nerve sparing approach with planned subtotal microsurgical resection and SRS to the residual tumor achieves high rates of tumor control with highly satisfactory outcome of facial and cochlear functional preservation. Clinical practice consensus recommendations on behalf of the International Stereotactic Radiosurgery Society (ISRS) are also presented.

Surgery combined with radiosurgery of large acoustic neuromas

The treatment of acoustic neuromas has been improved by advancements in microsurgical techniques and in radiosurgery. To further elucidate the degree of clinical improvement, we evaluated the treatment results of a combination of surgery and radiosurgery for large acoustic neuromas.

METHODS

From January 1994 through December 2000, we treated 14 patients with large acoustic neuromas using a combination of surgery and radiosurgery. Of these, 8 were male and 6 were female patients, with an average age of 47 years (range, 18-64). The average maximum diameter of the tumor was 42 mm (range, 30-58 mm). All patients underwent operations using the retrosigmoid approach, and one patient was retreated using the transpetrosal transtentorial approach. The tumors were removed subtotally in thirteen patients and partially in one who had a very large hypervascular acoustic neuroma. There were no mortality and no surgical complications, such as hemorrhage or CSF leakage. Postoperative facial palsy was avoided in 10 patients (71%). Radiosurgery was performed 1 to 6 months (mean, 2.9 months) after surgery. At the time of radiosurgery, the treatment size (mean diameter) became 19.2 mm (range, 9.8-36.1 mm). The average tumor marginal dose was 12.1Gy (range, from 10-14 Gy). The mean follow-up period was 32 months after radiosurgery.

RESULTS

The tumor size decreased in 6 patients, unchanged in 5 patients, and increased in 3 patients. Only 1 patient (7%) with extra large tumor needed surgical resection 1 year after radiosurgery. Excellent facial nerve function (House & Brackmann Grade I or II) was preserved in 12 patients (85.7%) in the final follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

In the case of large acoustic neuromas, subtotal removal and subsequent radiosurgery is one option for maintaining cranial nerve function and long-term tumor growth control.

Radical intracapsular removal of acoustic neurinomas. Long-term follow-up review of 11 patients

Historically, the neurosurgical treatment of large acoustic neurinomas has developed with two principal goals: complete tumor removal and preservation of facial nerve function. A recent goal for small tumors is the preservation of hearing. Out of a personal series of 124 acoustic neurinomas treated over the past 35 years, the senior author has undertaken a radical intracapsular approach in 12 patients with large tumors (greater than 3 cm in diameter). Surgical indications for intracapsular removal included advanced age (five cases), the patient's wish to avoid any risk of facial paralysis (six cases), contralateral facial palsy (one case), and contralateral deafness (one case). Eleven of these 12 patients were available for follow-up review. Tumor recurrence developed in two patients (18%) at 2 and 3 years postoperatively; there were no late recurrences. Four patients died of unrelated causes, 10 to 19 years after surgery. The remaining five patients have survived a mean of 12 years since surgery without recurrence (range 3 to 22 years). Facial function was preserved in nine patients (82%). The results suggest that radical intracapsular removal may be the procedure of choice under certain circumstances and may offer an alternative to focused high-energy radiation.

The impact of continuous electrophysiological monitoring on preservation of the facial nerve during acoustic tumour surgery

Continuous electromyographic (EMG) activity and responses to electrical stimulation of the facial nerve were monitored intraoperatively in 35 patients undergoing primary removal of acoustic neuroma. The rate of anatomical and immediate functional preservation of the facial nerve of these patients was compared with a matched population where a facial nerve stimulator and monitoring of facial muscle contraction by the anaesthetist only was employed. Overall, 94% (n = 33) of facial nerves were preserved anatomically in patients with continuous EMG monitoring, compared with 64% (n = 89) of patients (n = 139) without continuous monitoring. Amongst the 33 cases with anatomical facial nerve preservation, 64% (n = 21) had immediate functional preservation. Immediate functional preservation was only achieved in 39% (n = 35) of anatomically preserved facial nerves (n = 89) where conventional monitoring was used.

Factors influencing the preservation of the facial nerve during acoustic surgery

We reviewed the last 30 acoustic neuromas excised in our department and attempted to find out the factors associated with preservation of the facial and cochlear nerves. While the size of the tumour was the most important factor, vascularity and consistency were both important. Facial and cochlear nerves were preserved in 63% and 10% of the patients respectively. The importance of early diagnosis cannot be overemphasized.

Intracranial repair of interrupted facial nerve in course of operation for acoustic neurinoma by microsurgical technique

The microsurgical refinement of the lateral suboccipital approach is, in our opinion, the most satisfactory operative technique for achieving total removal of acoustic neurinomas of all sizes. In this series of 164 operated cases, large or very large tumours accounted for 64% of the cases (105 patients). The facial nerve was sacrificed in about 19% of the cases. In 81% of the cases the facial nerve was respected (65%) or repaired (16%) by direct intracranial suture performed immediately after tumour removal. Good or fair functional results were obtained in about 65% of the cases by this last procedure, which has to be considered as the treatment of choice for facial nerve repair. The results are compared with those of other series and with those obtained by different nerve substitution procedures.

FACIAL NERVE PRESERVATION BY POSTERIOR FOSSA TRANSMEATAL MICRODISSECTION IN TOTAL REMOVAL OF ACOUSTIC TUMOURS

Images