Prolonged treatment of pulmonary sarcoidosis with corticosteroids

Stable Extent of Recurrently Active Cardiac and Cutaneous Sarcoidosis

Background: Recurrent or persistently active sarcoidosis is a risk factor for permanent organ damage. Whether this damage is due to accumulated focal injuries or progressive disease extent is not known, as the natural history of chronic inflammation in sarcoidosis is poorly characterized. The objective of this study is to determine the pattern of disease in recurrently active sarcoidosis.

Methods: We identified patients with recurrent cardiac sarcoidosis (N = 21) retrospectively from an imaging database, and with recurrent cutaneous sarcoidosis (N = 17) from a prospective registry. The longitudinal patterns of cardiac sarcoidosis were established by findings on cardiac positron emission tomography scans, and of cutaneous sarcoidosis by the validated Cutaneous Sarcoidosis Activity and Morphology Instrument clinical scoring system. Patterns of recurrent disease were compared to baseline findings.

Results: Recurrent sarcoidosis occurred in a nearly identical pattern and distribution as baseline disease, and spread of disease was rarely observed for both cardiac and cutaneous sarcoidosis: 97% of heart segments positive on recurrence scans were positive on baseline scans, and only one new region of facial disease was observed. In some cases, recurrence followed years of apparent remission.

Discussion: Across phenotypes, and across a long period of follow-up, the extent of sarcoidosis was stable in spite of fluctuations in disease activity. For patients with a demonstrated history of recurrent disease affecting critical organs, our findings support the need for long-term follow-up.

Current and emerging strategies for the management of sarcoidosis

Sarcoidosis is a systemic inflammatory disorder of unknown etiology. Although any organ may be involved, the lungs are most frequently affected. The clinical course of the disease is highly variable, with up to two-thirds of untreated patients experiencing spontaneous remission within 12-24 months of onset of symptoms. When therapy is required, corticosteroids are considered standard, but studies demonstrating their ability to modify the long-term outcome in this disease are lacking. Often, the myriad of adverse side effects of corticosteroids necessitate the addition of immunosuppressants, cytotoxic agents or biologic therapies to maintain disease remission. Unfortunately, optimal therapeutic regimens have not been described. Patients who do not respond to therapy often experience progressive fibrotic changes and end-organ damage, which ultimately may result in significant morbidity or death. Agents commonly used to treat patients with sarcoidosis and emerging therapeutic options are discussed.

Outcome in sarcoidosis. The relationship of relapse to corticosteroid therapy

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To determine the demographic, clinical, and radiographic characteristics of corticosteroid-treated patients with sarcoidosis who developed relapse following a period of clinical stability lasting longer than 1 month, and to compare these characteristics with those of a group of patients with sarcoidosis who were not treated.

DESIGN

Historic, concurrent and prospective, nonrandomized, observational study.

SETTING

Ambulatory sarcoidosis clinic in a university city hospital.

PATIENTS

Over a 4-year calendar period, 337 patients with sarcoidosis were prospectively enrolled in a registry. One hundred eighteen patients were assigned to a spontaneous remission group when symptoms resolved without treatment, and 103 were assigned to an induced remission group when symptoms resolved following corticosteroid therapy and successful discontinuation. In 116 patients assigned to a recalcitrant group, therapy could not be stopped for 1 month or more owing to severity of symptoms or lack of compliance. We defined relapse as a recurrence of symptoms of sufficient severity to warrant treatment with corticosteroids, following a remission without treatment lasting greater than 1 month.

INTERVENTION

Patients who were judged to be sufficiently symptomatic to preclude observation without treatment or who failed to respond to conservative treatment with topical or inhaled corticosteroids or nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory agents were treated with systemic corticosteroids at a target dose of 20 mg prednisone per day for 1 year.

MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS

We observed a 74% relapse rate in the induced remission group, but only an 8% relapse rate in the spontaneous remission group (p < 0.01). Relapse occurred with similar frequency in whites and African-Americans (20% vs 28%), despite a lower treatment rate in white patients than in African-Americans (43% vs 76%; p < 0.01). White patients maintained a sustained remission with twice the frequency of African-Americans (58% vs 29%; p < 0.01). During relapse, 40% of chest radiographs showed no change in type, but there was a significant increase in interstitial profusion (p < 0.05). Initial presentation with asymptomatic chest radiographic abnormalities, erythema nodosum, or peripheral adenopathy portended a favorable prognosis, with sustained remission in 60% of such patients lasting 130 +/- 226 months from time of diagnosis. In contrast, patients who presented with musculoskeletal complaints were nine times, and those with symptoms from hepatic involvement were three times more likely to suffer relapse than to sustain remission without receiving corticosteroids. Most relapses (50%) occurred between 2 and 6 months after discontinuing steroid therapy, but late relapse was not unusual, occurring more than 12 months after discontinuing steroid therapy in 20% of patients with induced remission.

CONCLUSIONS

Relapse occurred frequently in patients with sarcoidosis who had been treated with corticosteroids, and rarely occurred in patients who had not been treated with corticosteroids in the past. The striking difference in relapse rate between treated and untreated patients suggests that patients with disease that would later be severe and protracted were almost unerringly identified early in their course. One explanation is that severe presenting symptoms portend a protracted and recurrent course; an alternative explanation is that corticosteroids contributed to the prolongation of the disease by delaying resolution.

The treatment of sarcoidosis

A discouraging conclusion to many years of study of the natural history of sarcoidosis is the realization that the proper word for the course of sarcoidosis is ‘unpredictable’. An impressive lesson of a controlled study was the frequency with which unexpected and dramatic improvement occurred in the placebo group. Although patients with pulmonary infiltration, uveitis and cutaneous sarcoid have a worse prognosis than the asymptomatic patient with hilar adenopathy, many patients in the former category will recover and some in the latter will go on to death.

A trial of prednisone therapy in a small number of patients with disease restricted to the mediastinal and hilar nodes (Stage I) suggests that prednisone treatment in this form of sarcoidosis may minimize dissemination and progression. An extended trial in Stage I sarcoidosis appears warranted. In more disseminated forms of the disease, the effects of corticosteroids seem to be merely palliative: there is no persuasive evidence that their use in pulmonary sarcoidosis averts fibrosis.

Occasionally corticosteroid therapy is contraindicated, poorly tolerated, or ineffective. In such circumstances chlorambucil or methotrexate may be given a trial. It is clear that both drugs exert an antiinflammatory action similar to that of the corticosteroids; in a few instances these agents appear to surpass corticosteroids in effectiveness.