Value of DNA analysis in addition to cytological testing in the diagnosis of malignant pleural effusions

BMVC test, an improved fluorescence assay for detection of malignant pleural effusions

The diagnosis of malignant pleural effusions is an important issue in the management of malignancy patients. Generally, cytologic examination is a routine diagnostic technique. However, morphological interpretation of cytology is sometimes inconclusive. Here an ancillary method named BMVC test is developed for rapid detection of malignant pleural effusion to improve the diagnostic accuracy at low cost. A simple assay kit is designed to collect living cells from clinical pleural effusion and a fluorescence probe, 3,6-Bis(1-methyl-4-vinylpyridinium) carbazole diiodide (BMVC), is used to illuminate malignant cells. The fluorescence intensity is quantitatively analyzed by ImageJ program. This method yields digital numbers for the test results without any grey zone or ambiguities in the current cytology tests due to intra-observer and inter-observer variability. Comparing with results from double-blind cytologic examination, this simple test gives a good discrimination between malignant and benign specimens with sensitivity of 89.4% (42/47) and specificity of 93.3% (56/60) for diagnosis of malignant pleural effusion. BMVC test provides accurate results in a short time period, and the digital output could assist cytologic examination to become more objective and clear-cut. This is a convenient ancillary tool for detection of malignant pleural effusions.

Efficacy of two fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) probes for diagnosing malignant pleural effusions

It is difficult to differentiate tumor cells in pleural fluid from reactive benign mesothelium. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) can increase diagnostic accuracy. Two hundred pleural fluid samples were analyzed by using FISH probes for chromosomes 11 and 17. Histological analysis was used to diagnose cancer. Clinical, radiological, and histological data were used to exclude malignancy. Eighty-two pleural effusion samples had positive cytology, 51 were benign, and 67 were atypical, but inconclusive. The 82 positive cases were confirmed to be malignant. Among the 51 negative cytology cases, videothoracoscopy-guided pleural biopsy revealed malignancy in three; aneuploid cells were detected by FISH in all cases. In 43 of the 67 cases with inconclusive cytology, malignancy was confirmed based on histology and fluorescence in situ hybridization. One case of parapneumonic effusion with no evidence of cancer during clinical follow-up had a suspicious cytology and positive fluorescence in situ hybridization result. The remaining 23 cases had no histological, radiological, clinical, or genetic evidence of malignancy. This study demonstrated that cytogenetic analysis of fresh pleural fluid samples using only two FISH probes is a valuable ancillary method for the identification of malignant pleural effusion, particularly in cases in which oncotic cytology is inconclusive.

Image analysis and flow cytometric DNA studies of benign and malignant body cavity fluids: reappraisal of the role of current methods in the differential diagnosis of reactive versus malignant conditions

Cytologic examination of body fluids is commonly performed in the clinical laboratory. Determination of the presence of malignancy may sometimes be difficult. In this study, we prospectively studied 60 body fluids with a panel of antibodies, including MOC-31, epithelial membrane antigen, carcinoembryonic antigen, B72.3, keratin, desmin, and CA-125. DNA and S-phase studies were performed both by flow cytometry and image analysis. Thirty-seven fluids were classified as benign and 23 were classified as malignant. The sensitivity of the antibodies for identification of carcinoma in descending order of percentage detection rate were MOC-31 (95%), epithelial membrane antigen (93%), B72.3 (84%), and carcinoembryonic antigen (80%). Desmin stained mesothelial cells in all cases. CA-125 gave similar results but was less specific. Flow cytometry detected 14 of 20 malignant fluids and image analysis 17 of 23 by identifying an aneuploid population. Benign reactive mesothelial cells were not aneuploid. Tetraploidy due to reactive mesothelial cells was found in 9 of 37 body fluids. Their S-phase fraction was low (average, 3.2%). Tetraploidy in malignant cells was distinguished from the reactive mesothelial cells by high S-phase (average, 25.95). S-phase had some use as a discriminating factor, because no benign reactive cases had more than 17%. However, 7 of 23 malignant cases had a value below 17%. DNA analysis by image was more sensitive and specific than flow. Either may be used when immunocytochemistry is nondiagnostic or cannot be performed.

FDG PET of pleural effusions in patients with non-small cell lung cancer

OBJECTIVE

We determined the ability of 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) to differentiate benign and malignant pleural effusions in patients with non-small cell lung cancer.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Over a 6-year period, we reviewed all patients with primary non-small cell lung cancer and a pleural effusion on staging CT who underwent FDG PET. We examined 25 patients (18 men and seven women; age range, 37-86 years; mean age, 65 years). FDG PET revealed positive findings if pleural activity was greater than background mediastinal activity; FDG PET revealed negative findings if pleural activity was the same as or less than background mediastinal activity. Results of FDG PET were correlated with pathologic diagnosis determined with thoracentesis or pleural biopsy.

RESULTS

All patients had effusions on the same side as the primary tumor. Twenty-two patients had a malignant pleural effusion confirmed with thoracentesis (n = 19) or biopsy (n = 3). FDG PET revealed positive findings in 21 patients and negative findings in one. Three patients had no evidence of malignancy in the pleural space determined with cytologic findings (n = 2) or biopsy results (n = 1). FDG PET uptake revealed positive findings in one of these patients and negative findings in two. Therefore, of 22 patients with positive findings on FDG PET, 21 had pleural metastases, and of three patients with negative findings on FDG PET, one had metastases. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, and accuracy of FDG PET for detecting pleural metastases were 95%, 67%, 95%, 67%, and 92%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This study suggests that FDG PET may be useful in improving staging evaluation in patients with non-small cell lung cancer and a pleural effusion. Increased pleural FDG uptake usually indicates pleural metastases; however, because the number of benign effusions studied was small, the relevance of negative findings on FDG PET in this setting is uncertain.

[Pleurisy: diagnostic and therapeutic management]

Diagnosis of pleural effusion is difficult in children. The etiologies are numerous; however, infectious agents are more frequent. Thoracocentesis proves to be the first-line diagnostic tool. Light's criteria are the best for distinguishing whether the effusion is a transudate or an exudate. If the patient has an exudative pleural effusion, other tests are indicated to determine the etiology and in some cases the treatment: macroscopic appearance, cytology and differential white cell count (level of glucose, lactate dehydrogenase, adenosine deaminase, pH, bacterial cultures). Others investigations--biopsy of pleura by thoracoscopy or video-assisted thoracoscopy, bronchofibroscopy, CT scan--are sometimes useful. Intrapleural instillation of urokinase appears to be useful and safe. Evaluation is necessary for video-assisted thoracoscopy used early.

Clinical value of DNA image cytometry in effusions with atypia

Malignant cells in serosal effusions provide essential information about the extent of malignant disease. The main aim of this study was to examine the additional diagnostic value of DNA image cytometry for cases with uncertainty in the cytological diagnosis. In addition, the feasibility of automated nuclei detection was investigated. Out of 457 cases, 33 samples in 32 patients were diagnosed with "atypia" (probably benign) and 21 as "suspicious for malignancy." DNA image cytometry was performed on these 54 cases and on an additional group of 14 cytologically malignant cases. The results show that automatic classification is useful for separation of control cells, i.e., lymphocytes and neutrophilic granulocytes from other mononuclear cells. In 21 cases an insufficient number of control cells were measured. Seventy-two percent of the cytologic malignant cases were aneuploid. In contrast, in none of the cases with "atypia" and in only 2 of the cases "suspicious for malignancy" was aneuploidy present (2 of the remaining 32, 6%). From the cases with follow-up, a malignancy in the pleural fluid was present in 2 out of 17 cases with "atypia" and in 5 out of 10 with a "suspicious for malignancy" cytologic diagnosis, respectively. In conclusion, the additional diagnostic value of DNA image cytometry in cases with a cytological diagnosis of "atypia" or "suspicious for malignancy" is limited. Diagn. Cytopathol. 1999;21:112-116.

Useful tests on the pleural fluid in the management of patients with pleural effusions

Examination of the pleural fluid is useful in establishing the etiology of a pleural effusion. Transudative pleural effusions can be differentiated from exudative pleural effusions by measuring the levels of protein and lactic acid dehydrogenase in the pleural fluid and serum. If a patient clinically appears to have a transudative pleural effusion, but the pleural fluid meets exudative criteria, demonstration that the albumin levels is more than 1.2 gm/dl higher in the serum than in the pleural fluid provides evidence that the effusion is transudative. The gross appearance of the pleural fluid should always be noted. Other tests that routinely should be obtained on exudative pleural fluids are Gram stain and cultures, cell counts and differential, glucose, amylase, lactic acid dehydrogenase, cytology, and a marker for tuberculous pleuritis. The diagnosis of tuberculous pleuritis is strongly suggested by a pleural fluid adenosine deaminase level above 45 IU/L or a gamma interferon level above 3.7 U/ml.

Cytologic features of mycobacterial pleuritis: logistic regression and statistical analysis of a blinded, case-controlled study

Tuberculous pleural effusions are characterized by lymphocytosis; the significance of mesothelial cells is uncertain, as are the cytologic features in concurrent human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection. This blinded study compared 38 culture-positive pleural fluids (6 HIV+) with 38 controls from benign exudative processes. Logistic regression analysis selected mature lymphocytes as most predictive of positive culture, and mesothelial cells and eosinophils as negative predictors. Mesothelial cells were scant (< 10% of nucleated cells) in 36/38 cases with mycobacteria (sensitivity 95%); if these cell were > 10%, tuberculosis was virtually ruled out in HIV- patients. Specificity was maximized (82%) when mesothelial cells < 10% were combined with lymphocytes > 50%; positive predictive value with this combination was 76%, but was raised to 96% if moderate/marked cellularity was also identified. Among tuberculosis cases, reactive mesothelial cells differentiated HIV+ from HIV- patients; there was no other significant difference.

Interphase cytogenetics reveals a high incidence of aneuploidy and intra-tumour heterogeneity in breast cancer

The occurrence of aberrations involving chromosomes 11 and 17 in malignant tissues of breast cancer patients has not yet been studied systematically. Using fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) with centromere-specific probes, we determined chromosome 11 and 17 status in interphase nuclei from primary and/or metastatic breast cancer cells. In all cancerous specimens obtained from 30 patients, FISH identified cells with clonal chromosomal abnormalities, with aneuploidy rates ranging from 6% to 92% (median 59%). There was a gain of centromeric signals for chromosome 11, most likely corresponding to hyperploidy; aberrations of chromosome 17 in specimens from 26 patients (87%) were hyperploid as well; however, four cases (13%) showed loss of chromosome 17 centromeres. All specimens contained heterogeneous aneuploid cell populations with excessive gain of signals in some cases. The pattern of aneuploidy did not appear to correlate with tumour grade/stage and was comparable in primary tumours and corresponding metastatic axillary lymph nodes, indicative of genetic instability early in tumour development. Screening with a panel of FISH probes may lead to enhanced sensitivity and specificity in detecting malignant cells, as demonstrated in this study with effusions which could not be conclusively interpreted as being malignant by cytological criteria.