Renal cold storage followed by transplantation impairs proteasome function and mitochondrial protein homeostasis

Cold Storage Followed by Transplantation Induces Immunoproteasome in Rat Kidney Allografts: Inhibition of Immunoproteasome Does Not Improve Function

Key Points

Cold storage (CS) increases the severity of graft dysfunction in a time-dependent manner, and prolonged CS decreases animal survival. CS plus transplant increases iproeasome levels/assembly in renal allografts; IFN-γ is a potential inducer of the iproteasome. Inhibiting iproteasome ex vivo during renal CS did not confer graft protection after transplantation.

Background

It is a major clinical challenge to ensure the long-term function of transplanted kidneys. Specifically, the injury associated with cold storage (CS) of kidneys compromises the long-term function of the grafts after transplantation. Therefore, the molecular mechanisms underlying CS-related kidney injury are attractive therapeutic targets to prevent injury and improve long-term graft function. Previously, we found that constitutive proteasome function was compromised in rat kidneys after CS followed by transplantation. Here, we evaluated the role of the immunoproteasome (i proteasome), a proteasome variant, during CS followed by transplantation.

Methods

Established in vivo rat kidney transplant model with or without CS containing vehicle or iproteasome inhibitor (ONX 0914) was used in this study. The i proteasome function was performed using rat kidney homogenates and fluorescent-based peptide substrate specific to β 5i subunit. Western blotting and quantitative RT-PCR were used to assess the subunit expression/level of the i proteasome (β 5i) subunit.

Results

We demonstrated a decrease in the abundance of the β 5i subunit of the i proteasome in kidneys during CS, but β 5i levels increased in kidneys after CS and transplant. Despite the increase in β 5i levels and its peptidase activity within kidneys, inhibiting β 5i during CS did not improve graft function after transplantation.

Summary

These results suggest that the pharmacologic inhibition of immunoproteasome function during CS does not improve graft function or outcome. In light of these findings, future studies targeting immunoproteasomes during both CS and transplantation may define the role of immunoproteasomes on short-term and long-term kidney transplant outcomes.

Identification of Differentially Expressed Genes in Cold Storage-associated Kidney Transplantation

BACKGROUND

Although it is acknowledged that ischemia-reperfusion injury is the primary pathology of cold storage-associated kidney transplantation, its underlying mechanism is not well elucidated.

METHODS

To extend the understanding of molecular events and mine hub genes posttransplantation, we performed bulk RNA sequencing at different time points (24 h, day 7, and day 14) on a murine kidney transplantation model with prolonged cold storage (10 h).

RESULTS

In the present study, we showed that genes related to the regulation of apoptotic process, DNA damage response, cell cycle/proliferation, and inflammatory response were steadily elevated at 24 h and day 7. The upregulated gene profiling delicately transformed to extracellular matrix organization and fibrosis at day 14. It is prominent that metabolism-associated genes persistently took the first place among downregulated genes. The gene ontology terms of particular note to enrich are fatty acid oxidation and mitochondria energy metabolism. Correspondingly, the key enzymes of the above processes were the products of hub genes as recognized. Moreover, we highlighted the proximal tubular cell-specific increased genes at 24 h by combining the data with public RNA-Seq performed on proximal tubules. We also focused on ferroptosis-related genes and fatty acid oxidation genes to show profound gene dysregulation in kidney transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

The comprehensive characterization of transcriptomic analysis may help provide diagnostic biomarkers and therapeutic targets in kidney transplantation.

Effect of PERLA®, a new cold-storage solution, on oxidative stress injury and early graft function in rat kidney transplantation model

BACKGROUND

The composition of organ preservation solutions is crucial for maintaining graft integrity and early graft function after transplantation. The aim of this study is to compare new organ preservation solution PERLA® with the gold standard preservation solution University of Wisconsin (UW) regarding oxidative stress and early graft injury.

METHODS

In order to assess oxidative stress after cold storage, kidney grafts have been preserved for 18 h at 4° C in either UW solution or PERLA® solution and then assessed for oxidative stress injury (protocol 1). To assess kidney injuries and oxidative stress after reperfusion, rat kidneys were harvested, stored in cold UW or in PERLA® solutions for 18 h at 4 °C and then transplanted heterotopically for 6 h (protocol 2). PERLA® is a high Na+/low K+ solution including PEG-35 (1 g/L), trimetazidine (1 µM), carvedilol (10 µM) and tacrolimus (5 µM).

RESULTS

Our results showed that preservation of kidneys in PERLA® solution significantly attenuates oxidative stress parameters after cold storage and reperfusion. We found a significant decrease in oxidative damage indicators (MDA, CD and CP) and a significant increase in antioxidant indicators (GPx, GSH, CAT, SOD and PSH). Moreover, PERLA® solution decreased kidney injury after reperfusion (creatinine, LDH and uric acid).

CONCLUSION

PERLA® solution was more effective than UW storage solution in preserving rat's kidney grafts.

Normal Proteasome Function Is Needed to Prevent Kidney Graft Injury during Cold Storage Followed by Transplantation

Kidney transplantation is the preferred treatment for end-stage kidney disease (ESKD). However, there is a shortage of transplantable kidneys, and donor organs can be damaged by necessary cold storage (CS). Although CS improves the viability of kidneys from deceased donors, prolonged CS negatively affects transplantation outcomes. Previously, we reported that renal proteasome function decreased after rat kidneys underwent CS followed by transplantation (CS + Tx). Here, we investigated the mechanism underlying proteasome dysfunction and the role of the proteasome in kidney graft outcome using a rat model of CS + Tx. We found that the key proteasome subunits β5, α3, and Rpt6 are modified, and proteasome assembly is impaired. Specifically, we detected the modification and aggregation of Rpt6 after CS + Tx, and Rpt6 modification was reversed when renal extracts were treated with protein phosphatases. CS + Tx kidneys also displayed increased levels of nitrotyrosine, an indicator of peroxynitrite (a reactive oxygen species, ROS), compared to sham. Because the Rpt6 subunit appeared to aggregate, we investigated the effect of CS + Tx-mediated ROS (peroxynitrite) generation on renal proteasome assembly and function. We treated NRK cells with exogenous peroxynitrite and evaluated PAC1 (proteasome assembly chaperone), Rpt6, and β5. Peroxynitrite induced a dose-dependent decrease in PAC1 and β5, but Rpt6 was not affected (protein level or modification). Finally, serum creatinine increased when we inhibited the proteasome in transplanted donor rat kidneys (without CS), recapitulating the effects of CS + Tx. These findings underscore the effects of CS + Tx on renal proteasome subunit dysregulation and also highlight the significance of proteasome activity in maintaining graft function following CS + Tx.

Mitochondria-Derived Reactive Oxygen Species Contribute to Synergistic Interaction of Diabetes and Hypertension in Causing Chronic Kidney Injury

Diabetes (DM) and hypertension (HTN) are major risk factors for chronic kidney injury, together accounting for >70% of end-stage renal disease. The combination of DM and HTN significantly accelerates development of renal injury; however, the underlying mechanisms of this synergy are still poorly understood. This study assessed whether mitochondria (MT) dysfunction is essential in developing renal injury in a rat model with combined DM and HTN. Type 1 DM was induced in Wistar rats by streptozotocin (STZ). HTN was induced six weeks later by inter-renal aorta constriction between the renal arteries, so that right kidneys were exposed to HTN while left kidneys were exposed to normotension. Kidneys exposed to DM or HTN alone had only mild glomerular injury and urinary albumin excretion (UAE). In contrast, kidneys exposed to DM plus 8 weeks HTN had significantly increased UAE and glomerular structural damage with reduced glomerular filtration rate. Marked increases in MT-derived reactive oxygen species (ROS) were also observed in right kidneys exposed to HTN+DM. We further tested whether treatment with MT-targeted antioxidant (MitoTEMPO) after the onset of HTN attenuates renal injury in rats with DM+HTN. Results show that kidneys in DM+AC+MitoTEMPO rats had lower UAE, less glomerular damage, and preserved MT function compared to untreated DM+AC rats. Our studies indicate that MT-derived ROS play a major role in promoting kidney dysfunction when DM is combined with HTN. Preserving MT function might be a potential therapeutic approach to halt the development of renal injury when DM coexists with HTN.

Cold Storage Followed by Transplantation Induces Interferon-Gamma and STAT-1 in Kidney Grafts

Cold storage (CS)-mediated inflammation, a reality of donor kidney processing and transplantation, can contribute to organ graft failure. However, the mechanisms by which this inflammation is perpetuated during and after CS remain unclear. Here, we examined the immunoregulatory roles of signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT) family proteins, most notably STAT1 and STAT3, with our in vivo model of renal CS and transplant. Donor rat kidneys were exposed to 4 h or 18 h of CS, which was then followed by transplantation (CS + transplant). STAT total protein level and activity (phosphorylation) were evaluated via Western blot analysis and mRNA expression was tabulated using quantitative RT-PCR after organ harvest on day 1 or day 9 post-surgery. In vivo assays were further corroborated via similar analyses featuring in vitro models, specifically proximal tubular cells (human and rat) as well as macrophage cells (Raw 264.7). Strikingly, gene expression of IFN-γ (a pro-inflammatory cytokine inducer of STAT) and STAT1 were markedly increased after CS + transplant. STAT3 dephosphorylation was additionally observed after CS, a result suggestive of dysregulation of anti-inflammatory signaling as phosphorylated STAT3 acts as a transcription factor in the nucleus to increase the expression of anti-inflammatory signaling molecules. In vitro, IFN-γ gene expression as well as amplification of downstream STAT1 and inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS; a hallmark of ischemia reperfusion injury) was remarkably increased after CS + rewarming. Collectively, these results demonstrate that aberrant induction of STAT1 is sustained in vivo post-CS exposure and post-transplant. Thus, Jak/STAT signaling may be a viable therapeutic target during CS to mitigate poor graft outcomes when transplanting kidneys from deceased donors.

Mild Therapeutic Hypothermia Protects from Acute and Chronic Renal Ischemia-Reperfusion Injury in Mice by Mitigated Mitochondrial Dysfunction and Modulation of Local and Systemic Inflammation

Renal ischemia-reperfusion (IR) injury can lead to acute kidney injury, increasing the risk of developing chronic kidney disease. We hypothesized that mild therapeutic hypothermia (mTH), 34 °C, applied during ischemia could protect the function and structure of kidneys against IR injuries in mice. In vivo bilateral renal IR led to an increase in plasma urea and acute tubular necrosis at 24 h prevented by mTH. One month after unilateral IR, kidney atrophy and fibrosis were reduced by mTH. Evaluation of mitochondrial function showed that mTH protected against IR-mediated mitochondrial dysfunction at 24 h, by preserving CRC and OX-PHOS. mTH completely abrogated the IR increase of plasmatic IL-6 and IL-10 at 24 h. Acute tissue inflammation was decreased by mTH (IL-6 and IL1-β) in as little as 2 h. Concomitantly, mTH increased TNF-α expression at 24 h. One month after IR, mTH increased TNF-α mRNA expression, and it decreased TGF-β mRNA expression. We showed that mTH alleviates renal dysfunction and damage through a preservation of mitochondrial function and a modulated systemic and local inflammatory response at the acute phase (2–24 h). The protective effect of mTH is maintained in the long term (1 month), as it diminished renal atrophy and fibrosis, and mitigated chronic renal inflammation.

Proximal Tubule p53 in Cold Storage/Transplantation-Associated Kidney Injury and Renal Graft Dysfunction

Kidney injury associated with cold storage/transplantation is a primary factor for delayed graft function and poor outcome of renal transplants. p53 contributes to both ischemic and nephrotoxic kidney injury, but its involvement in kidney cold storage/transplantation is unclear. Here, we report that p53 in kidney proximal tubules plays a critical role in cold storage/transplantation kidney injury and inhibition of p53 can effectively improve the histology and function of transplanted kidneys. In a mouse kidney cold storage/transplantation model, we detected p53 accumulation in proximal tubules in a cold storage time-dependent manner, which correlated with tubular injury and cell death. Pifithrin-α, a pharmacologic p53 inhibitor, could reduce acute tubular injury, apoptosis and inflammation at 24 h after cold storage/transplantation. Similar effects were shown by the ablation of p53 from proximal tubule cells. Notably, pifithrin-α also ameliorated kidney injury and improved the function of transplanted kidneys in 6 days when it became the sole life-supporting kidney in recipient mice. in vitro, cold storage followed by rewarming induced cell death in cultured proximal tubule cells, which was accompanied by p53 activation and suppressed by pifithrin-α and dominant-negative p53. Together, these results support a pathogenic role of p53 in cold storage/transplantation kidney injury and demonstrate the therapeutic potential of p53 inhibitors.

Overexpression of MnSOD Protects against Cold Storage-Induced Mitochondrial Injury but Not against OMA1-Dependent OPA1 Proteolytic Processing in Rat Renal Proximal Tubular Cells

Kidneys from deceased donors undergo cold storage (CS) preservation before transplantation. Although CS is a clinical necessity for extending organ quality preservation, CS causes mitochondrial and renal injury. Specifically, many studies, including our own, have shown that the triggering event of CS-induced renal injury is mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mROS). Here, we explored the role of OMA1-depedent OPA1 proteolytic processing in rat kidney proximal tubular epithelial (NRK) cells in an in vitro model of renal CS (18 h), followed by rewarming (6 h) (CS + RW). The involvement of mROS was evaluated by stably overexpressing manganese superoxide dismutase (MnSOD), an essential mitochondrial antioxidant enzyme, in NRK cells. Western blots detected rapid OPA1 proteolytic processing and a decrease in ATP-dependent cell viability in NRK cells subjected to CS + RW compared to control cells. Small interfering RNA (siRNA) knockdown of OMA1 reduced proteolytic processing of OPA1, suggesting that OMA1 is responsible for OPA1 proteolytic processing during CS + RW-induced renal injury. Overexpression of MnSOD during CS + RW reduced cell death, mitochondrial respiratory dysfunction, and ATP-dependent cell viability, but it did not prevent OMA1-dependent OPA1 processing. These data show for the first time that OMA1 is responsible for proteolytically cleaving OPA1 in a redox-independent manner during renal cell CS.

Aberrant activation of the complement system in renal grafts is mediated by cold storage

Aberrant complement activation leads to tissue damage during kidney transplantation, and it is recognized as an important target for therapeutic intervention. However, it is not clear whether cold storage (CS) triggers the complement pathway in transplanted kidneys. The goal of the present study was to determine the impact of CS on complement activation in renal transplants. Male Lewis and Fischer rats were used, and donor rat kidneys were exposed to 4 h or 18 h of CS followed by transplantation (CS + transplant). To study CS-induced effects, a group with no CS was included in which the kidney was removed and transplanted back to the same rat [autotransplantation (ATx)]. Complement proteins (C3 and C5b-9) were evaluated with Western blot analysis (reducing and nonreducing conditions) and immunostaining. Western blot analysis of renal extracts or serum indicated that the levels of C3 and C5b-9 increased after CS + transplant compared with ATx. Quite strikingly, intracellular C3 was profoundly elevated within renal tubules after CS + transplant but was absent in sham or ATx groups, which showed only extratubular C3. Similarly, C5b-9 immunofluorescence staining of renal sections showed an increase in C5b-9 deposits in kidneys after CS + transplant. Real-time PCR (SYBR green) showed increased expression of CD11b and CD11c, components of complement receptors 3 and 4, respectively, as well as inflammatory markers such as TNF-α. In addition, recombinant TNF-α significantly increased C3 levels in renal cells. Collectively, these results demonstrate that CS mediates aberrant activation of the complement system in renal grafts following transplantation.NEW & NOTEWORTHY This study highlights cold storage-mediated aberrant activation of complement components in renal allografts following transplantation. Specifically, the results demonstrate, for the first time, that cold storage functions in exacerbation of C5b-9, a terminal cytolytic membrane attack complex, in renal grafts following transplantation. In addition, the results indicated that cold storage induces local C3 biogenesis in renal proximal cells/tubules and that TNF-α promotes C3 biogenesis and activation in renal proximal tubular cells.

The BK activator NS11021 partially protects rat kidneys from cold storage and transplantation-induced mitochondrial and renal injury

Kidneys from deceased donors used for transplantation are placed in cold storage (CS) solution during the search for a matched recipient. However, CS induces mitochondrial and cellular injury, which exacerbates renal graft dysfunction, highlighting the need for therapeutic interventions. Using an in vitro model of renal CS, we recently reported that pharmacological activation of the mitochondrial BK channel (mitoBK) during CS protected against CS-induced mitochondrial injury and cell death. Here, we used an in vivo syngeneic rat model of renal CS (18 hr) followed by transplantation (24 hr reperfusion) (CS+Tx) to similarly evaluate whether addition of a mitoBK activator to the CS solution can alleviate CS+Tx-induced renal injury. Western blots detected the pore-forming α subunit of the BK channel in mitochondrial fractions from rat kidneys, and mitoBK protein expression was reduced after CS+Tx compared to sham surgery. The addition of the BK activator NS11021 (3 μM) to the CS solution partially protected against CS+Tx-induced mitochondrial respiratory dysfunction, oxidative protein nitration, and cell death, but not acute renal dysfunction (SCr and BUN). In summary, the current preclinical study shows that pharmacologically targeting mitoBK channels during CS may be a promising therapeutic intervention to prevent CS+Tx-induced mitochondrial and renal injury.

Targeting Mitochondria during Cold Storage to Maintain Proteasome Function and Improve Renal Outcome after Transplantation

Kidney transplantation is the preferred treatment for end-stage kidney disease (ESKD). Compared to maintenance dialysis, kidney transplantation results in improved patient survival and quality of life. Kidneys from living donors perform best; however, many patients with ESKD depend on kidneys from deceased donors. After procurement, donor kidneys are placed in a cold-storage solution until a suitable recipient is located. Sadly, prolonged cold storage times are associated with inferior transplant outcomes; therefore, in most situations when considering donor kidneys, long cold-storage times are avoided. The identification of novel mechanisms of cold-storage-related renal damage will lead to the development of new therapeutic strategies for preserving donor kidneys; to date, these mechanisms remain poorly understood. In this review, we discuss the importance of mitochondrial and proteasome function, protein homeostasis, and renal recovery during stress from cold storage plus transplantation. Additionally, we discuss novel targets for therapeutic intervention to improve renal outcomes.

Protein Kinase C-δ Mediates Kidney Tubular Injury in Cold Storage-Associated Kidney Transplantation

BACKGROUND

Kidney injury associated with cold storage is a determinant of delayed graft function and the long-term outcome of transplanted kidneys, but the underlying mechanism remains elusive. We previously reported a role of protein kinase C-δ (PKCδ) in renal tubular injury during cisplatin nephrotoxicity and albumin-associated kidney injury, but whether PKCδ is involved in ischemic or transplantation-associated kidney injury is unknown.

METHODS

To investigate PKCδ's potential role in injury during cold storage-associated transplantation, we incubated rat kidney proximal tubule cells in University of Wisconsin (UW) solution at 4°C for cold storage, returning them to normal culture medium at 37°C for rewarming. We also stored kidneys from donor mice in cold UW solution for various durations, followed by transplantation into syngeneic recipient mice.

RESULTS

We observed PKCδ activation in both in vitro and in vivo models of cold-storage rewarming or transplantation. In the mouse model, PKCδ was activated and accumulated in mitochondria, where it mediated phosphorylation of a mitochondrial fission protein, dynamin-related protein 1 (Drp1), at serine 616. Drp1 activation resulted in mitochondrial fission or fragmentation, accompanied by mitochondrial damage and tubular cell death. Deficiency of PKCδ in donor kidney ameliorated Drp1 phosphorylation, mitochondrial damage, tubular cell death, and kidney injury during cold storage-associated transplantation. PKCδ deficiency also improved the repair and function of the renal graft as a life-supporting kidney. An inhibitor of PKCδ, δV1-1, protected kidneys against cold storage-associated transplantation injury.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that PKCδ is a key mediator of mitochondrial damage and renal tubular injury in cold storage-associated transplantation and may be an effective therapeutic target for improving renal transplant outcomes.

Specific BK Channel Activator NS11021 Protects Rat Renal Proximal Tubular Cells from Cold Storage-Induced Mitochondrial Injury In Vitro

Kidneys from deceased donors used for transplantation are placed in cold storage (CS) solution during the search for a matched recipient. However, CS causes mitochondrial injury, which may exacerbate renal graft dysfunction. Here, we explored whether adding NS11021, an activator of the mitochondrial big-conductance calcium-activated K⁺ (mitoBK) channel, to CS solution can mitigate CS-induced mitochondrial injury. We used normal rat kidney proximal tubular epithelial (NRK) cells as an in vitro model of renal cold storage (18 h) and rewarming (2 h) (CS + RW). Western blots detected the pore-forming α subunit of the BK channel in mitochondrial fractions from NRK cells. The fluorescent K⁺-binding probe, PBFI-AM, revealed that isolated mitochondria from NRK cells exhibited mitoBK-mediated K⁺ uptake, which was impaired ~70% in NRK cells subjected to CS + RW compared to control NRK cells maintained at 37 °C. Importantly, the addition of 1 μM NS11021 to CS solution prevented CS + RW-induced impairment of mitoBK-mediated K⁺ uptake. The NS11021–treated NRK cells also exhibited less cell death and mitochondrial injury after CS + RW, including mitigated mitochondrial respiratory dysfunction, depolarization, and superoxide production. In summary, these new data show for the first time that mitoBK channels may represent a therapeutic target to prevent renal CS-induced injury.

Cold Storage Increases Albumin and Advanced Glycation-End Product-Albumin Levels in Kidney Transplants: A Possible Cause for Exacerbated Renal Damage

Prolonged cold storage (CS) of kidneys is associated with poor renal outcome after transplantation (Tx). We recently showed that in rats (Lewis), proteasome and renal function were severely compromised in kidney transplants subjected to CS (CS/Tx) as compared with those without CS exposure (autotransplanted [ATx]).

A Cycle of Altered Proteasome and Reactive Oxygen Species Production in Renal Proximal Tubular Cells

Aims

An intricate relationship exists between the mitochondrial function and proteasome activity. Our recent report showed in a rat model of renal transplantation that mitochondrial dysfunction precedes compromised proteasome function and this results in a vicious cycle of mitochondrial injury and proteasome dysfunction. In this study, we studied whether reactive oxygen species (ROS) has a role in proteasome alteration in renal cells and vice versa.

Methods

We used the genomic and pharmacologic approach on rat normal kidney proximal tubular (NRK) cell lines. First, we knocked down β5 or Rpt6 subunit of the proteasome using small interfering RNA (siRNA) in NRK cells. We also treated NRK cells with Bortezomib, a proteasome inhibitor, and peroxynitrite (a potent ROS).

Results

Studies with RNA interference showed increased mitochondrial ROS following knockdown of β5 or Rpt6 subunit in NRK cells. Similarly, pharmacological inhibition of the proteasome in NRK cells using Bortezomib also showed an increase of mitochondrial ROS in a dose-dependent manner. Next, exposing NRK cells to different concentrations of peroxynitrite provided evidence that the higher levels of peroxynitrite exposure decreased the key subunits (β5 and α3) of the proteasome in NRK cells.

Conclusion

Our results suggest that proteasome inhibition/downregulation increases ROS, which then impairs proteasome subunits in renal proximal tubular cells.