Current Practice in the Management of Pulmonary Nodules Detected on Computed Tomography Chest Scans

Recommendations to Improve Management of Incidental Pulmonary Nodules in Canada: Expert Panel Consensus

Introduction: Incidental pulmonary nodules (IPN) are common radiologic findings, yet management of IPNs is inconsistent across Canada. This study aims to improve IPN management based on multidisciplinary expert consensus and provides recommendations to overcome patient and system-level barriers. Methods: A modified Delphi consensus technique was conducted. Multidisciplinary experts with extensive experience in lung nodule management in Canada were recruited to participate in the panel. A survey was administered in 3 rounds, using a 5-point Likert scale to determine the level of agreement (1 = extremely agree, 5 = extremely disagree). Results: Eleven experts agreed to participate in the panel; 10 completed all 3 rounds. Consensus was achieved for 183/217 (84.3%) statements. Panellists agreed that radiology reports should include a standardized summary of findings and follow-up recommendations for all nodule sizes (ie, <6, 6-8, and >8 mm). There was strong consensus regarding the importance of an automated system for patient follow-up and that leadership support for organizational change at the administrative level is of utmost importance in improving IPN management. There was no consensus on the need for standardized national referral pathways, development of new guidelines, or establishing a uniform picture archiving and communication system. Conclusion: Canadian IPN experts agree that improved IPN management should include standardized radiology reporting of IPNs, standardized and automated follow-up of patients with IPNs, guideline adherence and implementation, and leadership support for organizational change. Future research should focus on the implementation and long-term effectiveness of these recommendations in clinical practice.

Incidental pulmonary nodule management in Canada: exploring current state through a narrative literature review and expert interviews

Background and Objective

Incidental pulmonary nodules (IPNs) are common and increasingly detected with the overall rise of radiologic imaging. Effective IPN management is necessary to ensure lung cancer is not missed. This study aims to describe the current landscape of IPN management in Canada, understand barriers to optimal IPN management, and identify opportunities for improvement.

Methods

We performed a narrative literature review by searching biomedical electronic databases for relevant articles published between January 1, 2010, and November 22, 2023. To validate and complement the identified literature, we conducted structured interviews with multidisciplinary experts involved in the pathway of patients with IPNs across Canada. Interviews between December 2021 and May 2022 were audiovisual recorded, transcribed, and thematically analyzed.

Key Content and Findings

A total of 1,299 records were identified, of which 37 studies were included for analysis. Most studies were conducted in Canada and the United States and highlighted variability in radiology reporting of IPNs and patient management, and limited adherence to recommended follow-up imaging. Twenty experts were interviewed, including radiologists, respirologists, thoracic surgeons, primary care physicians, medical oncologists, and an epidemiologist. Three themes emerged from the interviews, supported by the literature, including: variability in radiology reporting of IPNs, suboptimal communication, and variability in guideline adherence and patient management.

Conclusions

Despite general awareness of guidelines, there is inconsistency and lack of standardization in the management of patients with IPNs in Canada. Multidisciplinary expert consensus is recommended to help overcome the communication and operational barriers to a safe and cost-effective approach to this common clinical issue.

A Collaborative Emergency Medicine and Radiology Pulmonary Nodule Program: Identification of Associated Efficacy and Outcomes

PURPOSE

Incidental radiologic findings are commonplace, but the episodic nature of emergency department (ED) care makes it challenging to ensure that patients obtain appropriate follow-up. Rates of follow-up range from 30% to 77%, with some studies demonstrating that more than 30% have no follow-up at all. The aim of this study is to describe and analyze the outcomes of a collaborative emergency medicine and radiology initiative to establish a formal workflow for the follow-up of pulmonary nodules identified during ED care.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis was performed of patients referred to the pulmonary nodule program (PNP). Patients were divided into two categories: those with follow-up and those who do not have post-ED follow-up. The primary outcome was determining follow-up rates and outcomes, including patients referred for biopsy. The characteristics of patients who completed follow-up compared with those lost to follow-up were also examined.

RESULTS

A total of 574 patients were referred to the PNP. Initial follow-up was established in 390 (69.1%); 30.8% were considered lost to follow-up, and more than half of these patients did not respond to initial contact. There were minimal differences in characteristics between patients in these two categories. Of the 259 patients who completed PNP follow-up, 26 were referred for biopsy (13%).

CONCLUSIONS

The PNP provided effective transitions of care and potentially improved patient health care. Strategies to further enhance follow-up adherence will provide iterative improvement of the program. The PNP provides an implementation framework for post-ED pulmonary nodule follow-up in other health care systems and can be modified for use with other incidental diagnostic findings.

Utility of FDG PET/CT for assessment of lung nodules identified during low dose computed tomography screening

BACKGROUND

Many clinical guidelines recommend FDG PET/CT for the evaluation of pulmonary nodules ≥8 mm detected during low dose computed tomography (LDCT) lung cancer screening. However, its added value in this setting requires confirmation. We evaluated the clinical utility of FDG PET/CT, including incidental findings, during the evaluation of lung nodules detected on LDCT screening.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study was performed among 75 patients who completed FDG PET/CT between January 2010 and December 2017, after lung nodules > 8 mm had been detected on LDCT lung cancer screening. We report demographic variables, characteristics of the initial nodules on LDCT and FDG PET/CT, incidental findings on FDG PET/CT, as well as further work up performed and the influence of FDG PET/CT findings on management.

RESULTS

Nodules were reported to be benign on FDG PET/CT in 38/75 (50.6%) patients. Physicians chose either radiological follow-up or no further work up in all 38. FDG PET/CT was indeterminate or suggested malignancy in 37 (49.3%) patients. Biopsy was performed in 32 (86%) of these patients. Incidental findings on FDG PET/CT were reported in 37/75 (49%) patients. Further work-up of incidental findings was performed in 21/75 (28%) of patients.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, for majority of individuals with lung nodules identified during LDCT lung cancer screening, FDG PET/CT results were able to guide physicians in choosing between routine follow up or invasive biopsies. Conversely, 28% of these patients required additional investigations to address incidental findings.

[Pulmonary Nodules/Lung Cancer Comprehensive Management Mode: Design and Application]

背景与目的

早期筛查是有效降低肺癌死亡率的重要方式, 然而我国尚缺乏统一、有效的肺癌早期筛查标准与手段。本研究基于四川大学华西医院构建的肺结节/肺癌患者全程管理平台, 将肺结节早期筛查纳入肺癌规范诊疗体系, 以期实现提升肺癌患者生存率。

方法

建立三大研究队列：健康人群筛查队列、肺结节患者队列、肺癌患者队列, 系统、持续收集、分析各队列人群临床诊疗相关大数据。初步计划对肺结节早期筛查效果进行验证。

结果

该平台初步以2015年1月1日-2019年12月31日华西医院40岁以上职工2, 836人作为实施对象, 共诊断66例肺癌, 均经外科手术切除确诊为早期肺癌65例, 1例肺癌伴脑转移。

结论

肺结节/肺癌患者全程管理项目可实现肺结节高效筛查、随访与诊疗, 未来全程管理模式将全面覆盖华西医疗系统, 发挥区域带动作用。