Analysis of tears in patients with atopic keratoconjunctivitis, using flow cytometry

Tear and ocular surface disease biomarkers: A diagnostic and clinical perspective for ocular allergies and dry eye disease

Validated biomarkers to be used as biological tools for managing ocular surface diseases (OSDs) are still an unmet need in daily clinical practice. Many studies have contributed to the already extensive list of candidate biomarkers for these disorders. Dry eye (DE) and ocular allergy (OA) are complex and multifactorial diseases, often coexisting and with overlapping symptoms. The purpose of this review is to present a comprehensive updated revision of the most relevant biomarkers of DE and OA, with an emphasis on quantitative analyses and correlations with clinical parameter data. Analysis of biomarkers common for these pathologies has highlighted an important physiological process. Namely, the interleukin proteins (IL-1α, IL-1β and IL-17), tumour necrotic factor (TNFα) and interferon gamma (IFNγ; Th1-Th7 pathway) and IL-4, IL-5 and IL-13 (Th2 pathway) seem to represent similar inflammatory mechanisms. Moreover, changes in the levels of mucins (MUC1, MUC2, MUC4, MUC5 and MUC16) are common alterations in the tear film mucous layer. We also examine the current state of medical devices and the main limitations to their use in clinical practice. Translational research in biomarkers for clinical practice depends on a feasible transition from the laboratory to the point-of-care. This requires large-scale, coordinated clinical validation campaigns to select the biomarkers with the highest specificity and sensitivity and significant correlation with clinical parameters. Moreover, technical limitations of multiplexed quantitation systems must be overcome to detect and measure the levels of several biomarkers in very small samples. To ensure the future of biomarker research, significant progress is necessary in a number of fields. There is an urgent need for global unification of clinical classification and diagnostics criteria. Widespread integration of proteomic and transcriptomic data is paramount for performing meaningful analyses using appropriate bioinformatics tools and artificial intelligence systems.

Potential Biomarkers for Allergic Conjunctival Diseases

Allergic conjunctival diseases (ACDs) are a group of ocular allergies that include allergic conjunctivitis, atopic keratoconjunctivitis, vernal keratoconjunctivitis, and giant papillary conjunctivitis. Although a large body of information exists on the pathophysiology of ACDs, this has not yet lead to the development of clear recommendations and guidelines for the diagnosis of ACDs or development of conclusive and objective diagnostic tools. Identification of objectively measurable biomarkers that represent the molecular and cellular mechanisms associated with ACDs will be an important step toward achieving these aims. This is a comprehensive review of biological markers that have the potential to become "biomarker(s)" for ACDs and aid in the classification, diagnosis, and development of new therapeutic strategies for these group of allergic conditions.

Leukocyte Distribution in the Open Eye Tears of Normal and Dry Eye Subjects

PURPOSE

Leukocytes accumulate in the eye with sleep, but little is known about the presence or absence of leukocytes in awake, open eye tears. This study sought to compare normal and dry eye subjects for daily variation in open eye leukocyte composition.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ten normal subjects and nine dry eye subjects were enrolled. Subjects were trained for self-collection of tear samples using an ocular surface wash with 5 mL of phosphate buffered saline per eye. Subjects performed washes at awakening, between 8 and 9 am, between 11 am and 12 pm, and between 4 pm and 5 pm on four separate days. Leukocytes were isolated from the wash and were counted with a cell counter before staining with an anti-CD45 antibody and viability stain. Stained leukocytes were then analyzed via flow cytometry. Side scatter characteristics were used to distinguish granulocytes from lymphocytes. Results were interpreted both by time of wash as well as time from awakening.

RESULTS

At awakening, dry eye subjects had approximately twice as many recovered leukocytes and had a statistically significantly higher granulocyte-to-lymphocyte ratio as compared to normals. Leukocytes were rapidly cleared from the eye with a significant decrease in leukocyte counts at the 8 am time point as compared to awakening. Leukocyte counts across all open eye time points appeared to be consistent, with no differences between normal and dry eye subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a low level, constitutively expressed population of leukocytes in the open eye tears of normal and dry eye subjects. Higher levels of granulocytes in dry eye disease subjects warrants further investigation into this population of cells, and their role in homeostasis and dysregulation.

Neutrophil and T-Cell Homeostasis in the Closed Eye

Purpose

This study sought to examine the changes and phenotype of the tear neutrophil and T-cell populations between early eyelid closure and after a full night of sleep.

Methods

Fourteen healthy participants were recruited and trained to wash the ocular surface with PBS for at-home self-collection of ocular surface and tear leukocytes following up to 1 hour of sleep and a full night of sleep (average 7 hours), on separate days. Cells were isolated, counted, and incubated with fluorescently labeled antibodies to identify neutrophils, monocytes, and T cells. For neutrophil analysis, samples were stimulated with lipopolysaccharide (LPS) or calcium ionophore (CaI) before antibody incubation. Flow cytometry was performed.

Results

Following up to 1 hour of sleep, numerous leukocytes were collected (2.6 × 105 ± 3.0 × 105 cells), although significantly (P < 0.005) more accumulated with 7 hours of sleep (9.9 × 105 ± 1.2× 106 cells). Neutrophils (65%), T cells (3%), and monocytes (1%) were identified as part of the closed eye leukocyte infiltration following 7 hours of sleep. Th17 cells represented 22% of the total CD4+ population at the 7-hour time point. Neutrophil phenotype changed with increasing sleep, with a downregulation of membrane receptors CD16, CD11b, CD14, and CD15, indicating a loss in the phagocytic capability of neutrophils.

Conclusions

Neutrophils begin accumulating in the closed eye conjunctival sac much earlier than previously demonstrated. The closed eye tears are also populated with T cells, including a subset of Th17 cells. The closed eye environment is more inflammatory than previously thought and is relevant to understanding ocular homeostasis.

Diagnostic tools in ocular allergy

Ocular allergy (OA) includes a group of common and less frequent hypersensitivity disorders frequently misdiagnosed and not properly managed. The diagnosis of OA is usually based on clinical history and signs and symptoms, with the support of in vivo and in vitro tests when identification of the specific allergen is required. To date, no specific test is available for the diagnosis of the whole spectrum of the different forms of OA. The lack of recommendations on diagnosis of OA is considered a medical need not only for allergists but also for ophthalmologists. This position paper aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the currently available tools for diagnosing OA to promote a common nomenclature and procedures to be used by different specialists. Questionnaires, sign and symptom grading scales, tests, and potential biomarkers for OA are reviewed. We also identified several unmet needs in the diagnostic tools to generate interest, increase understanding, and inspire further investigations. Tools, recommendations, and algorithms for the diagnosis of OA are proposed for use by both allergists and ophthalmologists. Several unmet needs in the diagnostic tools should be further improved by specific clinical research in OA.

Increased risk for herpetic eye disease in patients with allergic conjunctivitis

PURPOSE

To evaluate the risk of ocular surface herpetic eye disease (osHED) in allergic eye disease.

METHODS

We calculated the risk for osHED in 11,205 patients on antiallergic ocular topical agents compared with 453,069 controls based on filled prescriptions for topical acyclovir between 2001 and 2003.

RESULTS

Significantly more allergic patients, of all age groups, received treatment for osHED (p < 0.01). The age and gender adjusted relative risk for allergic patients to suffer an osHED event was 2.31 (95% CI: 1.84-2.90), raising to 3.55 (95% CI: 2.0-6.4) in patients that filled > or = 4 antiallergic prescriptions.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients treated for allergic eye disease have an increased risk of osHED.

Flow-assisted allergy diagnosis: current applications and future perspectives

Physicians predominantly rely upon quantification of serum-specific immunoglobulin E (IgE) and/or skin test to confirm clinically suspected IgE-mediated allergy. However, for various reasons, identification of the offending allergen(s) and potentially cross-reactive structures is not always straightforward. Flow-assisted allergy diagnosis relies upon quantification of alterations in the expression of particular basophilic activation markers. Actually, upon challenge with a specific allergen, basophils not only secrete quantifiable bioactive mediators but also upregulate the expression of different markers which can be detected efficiently by flow cytometry using specific monoclonal antibodies. Currently, the technique has been applied in the investigation of IgE-mediated allergy caused by classical inhalant allergens, food, Hevea latex, hymenoptera venoms and drugs. It is also appreciated; the technique proves valuable in the diagnosis of non-IgE-mediated (anaphylactoid) reactions such drug hypersensitivity and the detection of autoantibodies in certain forms of chronic urticaria. This review will not address immunologic features, characteristics and general pitfalls of flow-assisted analysis of in vitro-activated basophils as summarized elsewhere. After a recapitulation of the principles and some specific technical issues of flow-assisted analysis of in vitro-activated basophils, we principally focus on the current clinical and research applications of the basophil activation tests. Personal experience of both research groups is provided, where appropriate. Finally, a viewpoint on how the field might evolve in the following years is provided.

T-cell characterization in chronic allergic eye disease

Chronic allergic eye disease encompasses several disorders, but it is vernal keratoconjunctivitis (VKC) and atopic keratoconjunctivitis (AKC) that have sight-threatening sequelae. T cells, eosinophils, and mast cells are all found in the conjunctiva, and are thought to play a role in disease pathogenesis. Recently, the conjunctival epithelium has also been considered to play a key role. New and effective therapeutic strategies for the future for these patients depend on achieving a greater understanding of the roles and interactions of the cell populations in these sight-threatening disorders.

Toxic eosinophil granule protein deposition in corneal ulcerations and scars associated with atopic keratoconjunctivitis

PURPOSE

Recurrent or persistent corneal erosions and ulcerations are typical complications of atopic keratoconjunctivitis. Toxic eosinophil granule proteins such as major basic protein (MBP) and eosinophil cationic protein (ECP) may be involved in this pathogenetic process. This study was designed to demonstrate the presence of toxic eosinophil granule proteins in corneal tissue from a patient with corneal complications of atopic keratoconjunctivitis.

DESIGN

Observational case report.

METHODS

Three corneal buttons of a patient with atopic keratoconjunctivitis associated ulcerations or scarring were examined by light microscopy and by immunofluorescence technique.

RESULTS

A linear deposition of eosinophil granular substance was detected subepithelially above Bowman's membrane in all corneal buttons. Indirect immunofluorescence identified this material as MBP and ECP. The deposits were not limited to the area of ulceration, but were also found underneath intact corneal epithelium. Multiple eosinophils were present in the upper corneal stroma. Normal corneas and negative control sections of the pathologic buttons revealed only minimal nonspecific staining at the surface of the epithelium.

CONCLUSIONS

Both MBP and ECP are known to affect human corneal epithelial cell viability and morphology in vitro. Moreover, MBP was shown to inhibit epithelial migration and protein synthesis. These toxic eosinophil proteins may also be responsible for corneal instability, recurrent and persistent corneal epithelial defects and ulcerations in patients with atopic keratoconjunctivitis.

Further studies on the immunopathology of atopic keratoconjunctivitis using flow cytometry

Atopic keratoconjunctivitis (AKC) is an ocular manifestation of systemic hypersensitivity. Although the pathogenesis of AKC is not fully understood, some previous data suggest that a decrease in numbers of suppressor T lymphocyte (Ts) and increase of Th, especially Th2 (the second subgroup of helper T lymphocyte), at the ocular surface may play an important role in the occurrence of the disease. In this study, the percentages of naive-Th (CD4/45RA+) and memory-Th (CD4/29+) cells, and the Th/Ts and memory-Th cells/naive-Th cells ratios were measured in the blood and tear samples of patients with AKC, atopic patients without ocular involvement and normal volunteers, using flow cytometry. Groups were compared using the Mann-Whitney U test. We found that patients with AKC had significantly higher memory-Th cell concentration, and Th/Ts and memory-Th cells/naive-Th cell ratios both in the tear and blood samples compared to normal subjects. While no significant difference existed between the tear samples of the atopic patients without ocular involvement and normal volunteers with respect to the above values, atopic patients had higher percentages of memory-Th cells and higher Th/Ts and memory-Th cells/naive-Th ratios in their blood than normal subjects. The percentages of memory-Th cells, and the Th/Ts and memory-Th cells/naive-Th cell ratios in the tear samples of AKC patients were also found to be higher than that of the atopic patients without ocular involvement, but no significant difference was present between the blood samples of these groups. The percentages of naive-Th cells did not show any significant difference between groups either in tear or blood samples. Since the mean memory-Th cells/naive-Th1 cells ratio in the tear samples of the patients with AKC was higher than in their blood samples, we propose that the localized accumulation of memory-Th2 cells, in addition to the increase of Th/Ts ratios in the external eye may cause AKC in atopic individuals.