Acquired resistance to Schistosoma japonicum in IgE-deficient SJA/9 mice immunized with irradiated cercariae

Overview: from the horse experimentation by Prof. Akira Fujinami to paramyosin

Professor Akira Fujinami demonstrated for the first time in the world that acquired immunity might be induced against macroparasites such as schistosomes. Since then, vaccination models have been developed using various species of animals, among which the attenuated vaccine model in the mouse has been utilized mostly to clarify immune effector mechanisms and define candidate vaccine molecules. However, further studies are necessary on immune responses to defined parasite molecules in humans, because some discrepancies in immune responses still exist between animals and humans, and apparently genetic influence should be taken into consideration in such studies on defined molecules. Despite of some limitations, vaccine trials in livestock against Schistosoma japonicum may provide useful information for development of vaccines against the other human infections caused by S. mansoni or S. haematobium. In this overview, studies carried out mainly by Japanese investigators towards vaccine development will be described.

Comparison of the vaccine efficacy of gamma-irradiated Schistosoma japonicum cercariae with the defined antigen Sj62(IrV-5) in pigs

Development of a vaccine against Schistosoma japonicum which can protect both man and the domestic animal zoonotic reservoirs of infection would be an invaluable tool in attempts to control this infection in those areas in which conventional control methods have failed to break transmission. The pig is a natural host of S. japonicum and because of its anatomical and immunological similarities to humans, it is a potentially valuable host for studies on S. japonicum in particular and schistosomes in general. Radiation-attenuated cercariae are highly effective in inducing immunity in experimental schistosomosis and there are promising reports of partial protection against schistosomes with recombinant-derived individual antigens. In the present study we have set out to establish a protocol for inducing protection with gamma-irradiated cercariae in pigs and to assess the protective capacity of recombinant and naked DNA formulations of Sj62, a 62kDa region of S. japonicum myosin. The corresponding S. mansoni version or Sj62, recombinant IrV-5, has previously been implicated in irradiated vaccine immunity in S. mansoni infections and has been shown to induce high levels of immunity in a variety of hosts. Groups of pigs were immunised three times at 2-week intervals with 2000 cercariae irradiated at 20krad, with Sj62 as a recombinant (rSj62) incorporated in Freund's adjuvant, a micellar preparation, or as a naked DNA construct. Vaccination with irradiated cercariae did not induce significant anti-Sj62 antibody but following intramuscular challenge with 2000 cercariae, the vaccinated pigs showed >95% resistance as assessed by reduced faecal egg output, worm tissue egg burdens and also reduced septal fibrosis. Immunisation with each of the Sj62 formulations induced significant anti-Sj62 antibody responses, the highest titre (>12,800) being with the Freund's preparation but none of the Sj62-immunised groups showed significant resistance to challenge. The data suggest that Sj62 shows little promise as a vaccine candidate for schistosomosis.

Vaccination of mice with gamma-irradiated Schistosoma japonicum cercariae

gamma-irradiated cercarial vaccines induce high levels of protection in mice against Schistosoma mansoni infection, however, the same has not been well established for S. japonicum. Here we describe vaccination studies in mice with gamma-irradiated S. japonicum cercariae testing the effectiveness of different irradiation doses, number of vaccinations, and mouse strains. In CBA/Ca mice, a single percutaneous exposure to 500 S. japonicum cercariae previously attenuated by 10, 20, 30, 40 or 50 krad gamma-irradiation induced significant, but comparable levels of protection (34-46%) against challenge infection. In a repeat experiment in C57Bl/6 mice, only groups vaccinated with 10 or 20 krad gamma-irradiated cercariae showed statistically significant, but lower levels of resistance (20-24%). Multiple vaccination of CBA/Ca mice with 500 20 krad gamma-irradiated cercariae did not improve the resistance level (40%). Analysis of IgG responses showed no clear correlation between antibody levels and levels of protection. Western blot analysis suggested that recognition of a 200-kDa antigen might be correlated with protection, that antigens of 42 and 50 kDa may be involved in the protection induced by single vaccination, but that different antigens might be protective in single vs multiple vaccinations. Sera from mice vaccinated with gamma-irradiated cercariae recognized many fewer antigens than more protective sera from mice vaccinated with UV-attenuated cercariae. These results suggest that the mouse may not be a suitable host for studies involving gamma-irradiated S. japonicum vaccines.

Schistosoma japonicum myosin: cloning, expression and vaccination studies with the homologue of the S. mansoni myosin fragment IrV-5

The Schistosoma japonicum homologue of the 62 kDa fragment of S. mansoni myosin (SmIrV-5), which has proved highly protective against S. mansoni infection in mice and rats, has been cloned and expressed as the full length 62 kDa equivalent, Sj62, and a truncated 44 kDa version, Sj44. DNA sequencing showed the Sj62 sequence to be 88.4% identical at the nucleic acid level and 96% identical in deduced amino acid sequence to that of SmIrV-5. The recombinant proteins (rSj44 and rSj62) were strongly recognized in Western blotting by sera from mice multiply vaccinated with UV-irradiated S. japonicum cercariae and weakly recognized by S. japonicum chronic infection mouse sera. Unlike SmIrV-5, mouse antisera against the recombinant S. japonicum proteins did not give positive recognition in immunofluorescence assay with the surface of newly transformed schistosomula of the homologous species, S. japonicum, nor did they react with S. mansoni schistosomula. However, the anti-rSj62 sera clearly localized the native antigen to the subtegumental muscle layers in male adult worm sections by immunoelectron microscopy. Vaccination of several groups of mice and/or rats with rSj44 and rSj62 incorporated into different adjuvants induced high titres of specific IgG but in only one experimental group was there a significant reduction in worm burden (27%, P < 0.05). The possible reasons for the disparity between the vaccination results presented here and those demonstrated in experiments using rSm62 (IrV-5) are discussed.