Rapid determination of clonality by detection of two closely-linked X chromosome exonic polymorphisms using allele-specific PCR

Clonal hematopoiesis in hematological disorders: Three different scenarios

Clonality studies can establish the single-cell origin of tumors and thus differentiate clonal malignant and premalignant processes from reactive polyclonal processes. Detection of clonal cells may be based on direct tracking of cell lineage-specific sequences or disease-specific somatic mutations identifying the clonal population. Historically, clonal hematopoiesis was defined using the principle of X-chromosome inactivation based on observation that in circulating clonal cells, only one of the active chromosomes was expressed. In myeloproliferative neoplasms (MPNs) virtually all circulating erythrocytes, platelets, and granulocytes are products of single mutated stem cells that preferentially differentiate into the myeloid rather than lymphoid lineage. Thus, clonal differentiated myeloid cells co-exist in circulation with polyclonal long-lived T lymphocytes that originated before the MPN-initiating somatic clonal event. Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) starts in a differentiating B cell, but other lymphoid lineages and myeloid cells remain polyclonal. Normal T and B cells co-exist with the CLL clone, but are diluted by the massively expanded CLL population, which outnumbers the residual normal cells. Clonal hematopoiesis of undetermined potential (CHIP) has been identified by whole-genome sequencing of healthy individuals. These clones contain a specific somatic mutation previously considered to be disease defining but are detected in only a small proportion of circulating leukocytes, and there is no obvious suppression of normal hematopoietic stem cells. However, more studies are needed to properly define these clones, their persistence or disappearance, and their relative propensity for transforming into leukemias, myeloproliferative neoplasms, or other clonal hematological malignancies.

Methylation of AR locus does not always reflect X chromosome inactivation state

Clonality can be established by a lack of mosaicism in a female because of random inactivation of either the maternal or paternal X chromosome early in embryogenesis. The methylation status of CpG sites close to the trinucleotide repeats in exon 1 of the human androgen receptor (AR) X chromosome gene assay (HUMARA) has been used to determine clonality. This HUMARA at times indicated clonal hematopoiesis in healthy elderly women, thus precluding its applicability. We used a clonality assay based on quantitative expression of polymorphic X chromosome genes (qTCA) and found no evidence of clonal hematopoiesis in healthy nonanemic elderly persons. We found instances of discordance between HUMARA results and those obtained by pyrosequencing and qTCA methods, as well as by directly quantifying AR gene expression. To determine the basis of this discrepancy we examined the methylation pattern of the AR locus subject to HUMARA. Notably, we found the extent of DNA methylation to be highly variable at the AR gene in granulocytes of persons with discordant results and also in erythroid burst-forming unit colonies but not in those with clonal hematopoiesis. These data provide the molecular basis of incomplete correlation with the pattern of DNA methylation of this X chromosome AR gene locus.

Genetic complexity of myeloproliferative neoplasms

Oncogenic mutations in JAK2 and MPL genes have recently been identified in myeloproliferative neoplasms (MPNs). In addition to these mutations, cytogenetic aberrations are frequently present at diagnosis but their role in the pathogenesis remains unclear. Two models of MPN pathogenesis have recently emerged based on either a single-hit or a multi-hit concept. The first model proposes that the acquisition of JAK2 mutations is the disease-initiating event, causing both the onset of disease phenotype and establishment of clonal hematopoiesis. The second model postulates the existence of 'pre-JAK2' mutations that establish clonal hematopoiesis before acquisition of JAK2 mutations and onset of disease phenotype. In this review, the two models have been critically evaluated in the context of the latest findings. At present, neither of the two models can be universally applied to all MPN patients due to their genetic heterogeneity. It is likely that the disease pathogenesis in some patients follows the first, and in other patients, the second model. Thus, the somatic mutations in MPN do not seem to be acquired in a predetermined order as seen in other malignancies, but occur randomly. Furthermore, the role of uniparental disomy in MPN and certain aspects of MPN therapy are discussed.

Hematopoiesis is not clonal in healthy elderly women

Clonality assays, based on X-chromosome inactivation, discriminate active from inactive alleles. Skewing of X-chromosome allelic usage, based on preferential methylation of one of the HUMARA alleles, was reported as evidence of clonal hematopoiesis in approximately 30% of elderly women. Using a quantitative, transcriptionally based clonality assay, we reported X-chromosome-transcribed allelic ratio in blood cells of healthy women consistent with random X-inactivation of 8 embryonic hematopoietic stem cells. Furthermore, we did not detect clonal hematopoiesis in more than 200 healthy nonelderly women. In view of the susceptibility of aging hematopoietic stem cells to epigenetic dysregulation, we reinvestigated the issue of clonality in elderly women. Forty healthy women (ages 65-92 years; mean, 81.3 years) were tested by a novel, quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) transcriptional clonality assay. We did not detect clonal hematopoiesis in any of the tested subjects. We also tested DNA from the same granulocyte samples using the methylation-based HUMARA assay, and confirmed previous reports of approximately 30% extensively skewed or monoallelic methylation, in agreement with likely age-related deregulated methylation of the HUMARA gene locus. We conclude that the transcriptionally based X-chromosome clonality assays are suitable for evaluation of clonal hematopoiesis in elderly women.

X-linked clonality testing: interpretation and limitations

Clonality often defines the diseased state in hematology. Clonal cells are genetically homogenous and derived from the same precursor; their detection is based on genotype or phenotype. Genotypic clonality relies on somatic mutations to mark the clonal population. Phenotypic clonality identifies the clonal population by the expression pattern of surrogate genes that track the clonal process. The most commonly used phenotypic clonality methods are based on the X-chromosome inactivation principle. Clonality detection based on X-chromosome inactivation patterns (XCIP) requires discrimination of the active from the inactive X chromosome and differentiation of each X chromosome's parental origin. Detection methods are based on detection of X-chromosome sequence polymorphisms identified by protein isoforms, transcribed mRNA, and methylation status. Errors in interpreting clonality tests arise from stochastic, genetic, and cell selection pressures on the mechanism of X inactivation. Progressive X-chromosome skewing has recently been suggested by XCIP clonality studies in aging hematopoietic cells. This has led to new insights into the pathophysiology of X-linked and autoimmune disorders. Other research applications include combining XCIP clonality testing with genetic clonality testing to identify clonal populations with yet-to-be-discovered genetic changes.

Pediatric patients with essential thrombocythemia are mostly polyclonal and V617FJAK2 negative

Essential thrombocythemia (ET) is rare in children, and little or no information is available about clonality or JAK2 mutations. However, the analyses in this work prove useful for the diagnosis of adult myeloproliferative disorders (MPDs). We evaluated the clonality status and V617FJAK2 mutation in 20 children affected by ET and compared them with 47 consecutive adult ET cases. Clonality was evaluated on the DNA of granulocytes and on the RNA of platelets. V617FJAK2 was analyzed by sequencing tests, allele-specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and digestion by BsaXI. A monoclonal pattern was found in 4 (28.5%) of 14 children and in 45% of informative adults. Heterozygous V617FJAK2 was found less frequently in children than in adults (P < .009). Only 2 girls showed both the V617FJAK2 mutation and a monoclonal pattern; one of them was the only child presenting a major thrombotic complication. In contrast to adults, most children with ET do not show either a clonal disorder or the V617FJAK2 mutation.

Molecular markers for the diagnosis of Philadelphia chromosome negative myeloproliferative disorders

Polycythemia vera, essential thrombocythemia, idiopathic myelofibrosis and chronic myelogenous leukemia have been collectively termed the myeloproliferative disorders due to similarities in their clinical presentation. With the exception of chronic myelogenous leukemia, which is characterized by the presence of the Philadelphia chromosome, the myeloproliferative disorders display no consistent cytogenetic abnormalities. Hence, the diagnosis of Polycythemia vera, essential thrombocythemia and idiopathic myelofibrosis to date relies on clinical criteria. However, several molecular aberrations have been described, which can be used as molecular markers for the diagnosis of these clinical entities. This review outlines the diagnostic assays developed and highlights the advantages and disadvantages of the following markers: (1). Endogenous Erythroid Colonies, (2). Clonality, (3). Reduced c-Mpl protein expression and (4). PRV-1 mRNA over expression.

Discrimination of polycythemias and thrombocytoses by novel, simple, accurate clonality assays and comparison with PRV-1 expression and BFU-E response to erythropoietin

Essential thrombocythemia (ET) and polycythemia vera (PV) are clonal myeloproliferative disorders that are often difficult to distinguish from other causes of elevated blood cell counts. Assays that could reliably detect clonal hematopoiesis would therefore be extremely valuable for diagnosis. We previously reported 3 X-chromosome transcription-based clonality assays (TCAs) involving the G6PD, IDS, and MPP1 genes, which together were informative in about 65% of female subjects. To increase our ability to detect clonality, we developed simple TCA for detecting the transcripts of 2 additional X-chromosome genes: Bruton tyrosine kinase (BTK) and 4-and-a-half LIM domain 1 (FHL1). The combination of TCA established the presence or absence of clonal hematopoiesis in about 90% of female subjects. We show that both genes are subject to X-chromosome inactivation and are polymorphic in all major US ethnic groups. The 5 TCAs were used to examine clonality in 46 female patients along with assays for erythropoietin-independent erythroid colonies (EECs) and granulocyte PRV-1 mRNA levels to discriminate polycythemias and thrombocytoses. Of these, all 19 patients with familial polycythemia or thrombocytosis had polyclonal hematopoiesis, whereas 22 of 26 patients with clinical evidence of myeloproliferative disorder and 1 patient with clinically obscure polycythemia were clonal. Interestingly, interferon alpha therapy in 2 patients with PV was associated with reversion of clonal to polyclonal hematopoiesis. EECs were observed in 14 of 14 patients with PV and 4 of 12 with ET, and increased granulocyte PRV-1 mRNA levels were found in 9 of 13 patients with PV and 2 of 12 with ET. Thus, these novel clonality assays are useful in the diagnosis and follow-up of polycythemic conditions and disorders with increased platelet levels.

Acquired uniparental disomy of chromosome 9p is a frequent stem cell defect in polycythemia vera

OBJECTIVE

Clonal stem cell proliferation and increased erythrocyte mass are hallmarks of the myeloproliferative disorder polycythemia vera (PV). The molecular basis of PV is unknown.

METHODS

We carried out a genome-wide screening for loss of heterozygosity (LOH) and analyzed candidate genes within the LOH loci.

RESULTS

Three genomic regions were identified on chromosomes 9p, 10q, and 11q. The presence of these LOHs in both myeloid and lymphoid cells indicated their stem cell origin. The 9pLOH prevalence is approximately 33% and is the most frequent chromosomal lesion described in PV so far. We report that the 9pLOH is due to mitotic recombination and therefore remains undetectable by cytogenetic analysis. Nineteen candidate genes were selected within the 9pLOH region for sequencing and expression analysis. No mutations were found in these genes; however, unexpectedly, increased expression of the transcription factor NFI-B was detected in granulocytes and CD34(+) cells in PV with 9pLOH. Since a member of the NFI gene family (NFI-X) was reported to result in TGF-beta resistance when overexpressed in vitro (TGF-beta is a known inhibitor of hematopoiesis), we transfected the NFI-B gene to the mouse 32D cell line. We found that overexpression of the NFI-B gene confers TGF-beta resistance in vitro.

CONCLUSIONS

We characterized a new region on chromosome 9p frequently involved in LOH in PV. Analysis of genes within this 9pLOH region revealed increased expression of the NFI-B gene. Our in vitro studies suggest that TGF-beta resistance may be the physiologic mechanism of clonal stem cell expansion in PV.

Clonality analysis of defined cell populations in paraffin-embedded tissue sections by RT-PCR amplification of X-linked G6PD gene

This paper establishes a method of clonality analysis using the reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) to amplify X-linked G6PD transcripts on defined cell populations microdissected from archival, paraffin-embedded tissue sections. Four known monoclonal low-grade B-cell lymphomas from females who were heterozygous (informative) at the 1131 exonic polymorphic locus of the G6PD gene were used to validate the method. Lymphoma and reactive lesions in each case were separated by microdissection. In order to preserve the intact RNA species in the lesion, sections were digested on the slides before microdissection. A one-step RT-PCR was performed with a single pair of primers, one of which contained a mismatched base adjacent to the polymorphic site, to generate a PvuI cutting site. Successful amplification and allele identification by PvuI digestion were achieved from all RNA samples studied. Three of four samples from non-neoplastic reactive lesions showed two bands with equal intensity, representing transcription of the two alleles of the G6PD gene, while the corresponding tumour samples demonstrated a biased intensity in one allele, indicating monoclonality. To assess the method further, the clonal nature of in situ and invasive breast cancers was examined, along with adjacent normal breast tissue and hyperplastic lesions from three informative females from our archives. Apart from the clusters of normal terminal duct-lobular units, all lesions were monoclonal. This result is in agreement with data derived from other X-linked gene studies and loss of heterozygosity (LOH) analyses of pre-invasive breast disease. The results suggest that the clonality analysis method presented here is simple and reliable, and is therefore potentially applicable in a wide range of pathological conditions.

A polymorphism of the X-linked gene IDS increases the number of females informative for transcriptional clonality assays

Studies of clonality have been essential for understanding the hierarchy of hematopoiesis and the biology of malignancies. Most clonality assays are based on the X chromosome inactivation phenomenon in females; these assays detect protein polymorphisms, differences in DNA methylation, or transcripts of the active X chromosome. Assays based on protein polymorphisms or DNA methylation have significant shortcomings. The major disadvantage of transcriptional assays is their limited applicability since only approximately half of females are informative for these studies. We have developed a new transcriptional assay based on an exonic polymorphism of the X-chromosome gene IDS. This gene is located in the same X-chromosome region (Xq28) as G6PD and p55, two genes with exonic polymorphisms for which we previously developed transcriptional assays. We developed non-radioactive PCR-based assays for rapid screening of genotype and determination of clonality. We also report reaction conditions for a quantitative ligase detection assay of IDS allelic transcripts. The frequency of the IDS polymorphism is 46% in Caucasian females and 39% in African-American females; in combination with G6PD and p55, 76% of Caucasian females and 62% of African-American females are informative for these assays. While this gene is highly polymorphic in Caucasian and African-American females, it is not informative in Oriental females. We established that the IDS gene is in linkage equilibrium with G6PD and p55. Unlike methylation-based assays, this assay is suitable for studying clonality in non-nucleated cells such as platelets and reticulocytes. With the discovery of exonic polymorphisms of other X-chromosome genes, all females should eventually be suitable for X-chromosome transcriptional clonality analysis.

The clonal origin and clonal evolution of epithelial tumours

While the origin of tumours, whether from one cell or many, has been a source of fascination for experimental oncologists for some time, in recent years there has been a veritable explosion of information about the clonal architecture of tumours and their antecedents, stimulated, in the main, by the ready accessibility of new molecular techniques. While most of these new results have apparently confirmed the monoclonal origin of human epithelial (and other) tumours, there are a significant number of studies in which this conclusion just cannot be made. Moreover, analysis of many articles show that the potential impact of such considerations as patch size and clonal evolution on determinations of clonality have largely been ignored, with the result that a number of these studies are confounded. However, the clonal architecture of preneoplastic lesions provide some interesting insights --many lesions which might have been hitherto regarded as hyperplasias are apparently clonal in derivation. If this is indeed true, it calls into some question our hopeful corollary that a monoclonal origin presages a neoplastic habitus. Finally, it is clear, for many reasons, that methods of analysis which involve the disaggregation of tissues, albeit microdissected, are far from ideal and we should be putting more effort into techniques where the clonal architecture of normal tissues, preneoplastic and preinvasive lesions and their derivative tumours can be directly visualized in situ.

Field cancerization, clonality, and epithelial stem cells: the spread of mutated clones in epithelial sheets

There has been considerable debate about the origin of human tumours, whether they arise from a single cell and are clonal populations or whether there needs to be some sort of co-operativity between cells for the neoplastic process to begin. Current theories subscribe to the clonal view, where a series of mutations in one cell begins a process of selection and clonal evolution leading to the development of the malignant phenotype. This review approaches this problem by asking how mutated clones, once established, spread through tissues before becoming overtly invasive. While there is substantial evidence in favour of independent origins of each tumour from a unique mutated clone, there are instances where such clones expand and remain cohesive, often involving a large area of tissue. The main example is the movement of mutated clonal crypts through the colorectal epithelium, by the process of crypt fission. In passing, the clonal architecture of early, pre-invasive lesions is examined, often with some surprising results.

Haematopoietic progenitors and signal transduction in polycythaemia vera and primary thrombocythaemia

While significant progress has been made in understanding the cellular defect and molecular basis of polycythaemia vera (PV), elucidation of the primary mutation leading to PV remains elusive. While clinically useful, the PV diagnostic criteria put forward by the Polycythemia Vera Study Group are not based on the pathophysiology of this disorder and in some instances may lead to false diagnosis or may not be sufficient to diagnose an early PV. In diagnostically unclear situations, clinical and laboratory findings must take into account the acquired nature of PV, its clonality, and the presence of endogenous erythroid colony formation in serum-containing media. It is likely that other simpler assays may be developed based on the rapidly emerging knowledge of the cellular pathology of PV. Several intriguing observations of abnormalities pertaining to the erythroid signal transduction have been recently reported; these remain to be validated in other laboratories and to be proven specific for PV. The clinical concept of primary thrombocythaemia (PT) lags behind what we know about PV. While the diagnosis of PT is still based on the exclusion of other known causes of thrombocytosis, new knowledge is emerging. Recent clonality studies of a large number of PT females show that the majority are clonal. It is our belief that thrombocythaemic subjects who are not found to be clonal are those with secondary thrombocytosis. Multiple in vitro-based assays of megakaryocytic and erythroid progenitors have been developed and conflicting data published. It is likely that standardized assays of megakaryocytic progenitors will soon become available and a reproducible PT specific defect will be found. Such a specific test would be of immense diagnostic value in this most elusive of all myeloproliferative disorders.

Leukocyte transfusion-associated granulocyte responses in a patient with X-linked hyper-IgM syndrome

X-linked hyper-IgM syndrome (XHIM) is a severe congenital immunodeficiency caused by mutations in CD154 (CD40 ligand, gp39), the T cell ligand for CD40 on B cells. Chronic or cyclic neutropenia is a frequent complicating feature that heightens susceptibility to severe infections. We describe a patient with a variant of XHIM who produced elevated levels of serum IgA as well as IgM and suffered from chronic severe neutropenia. Eight of ten leukocyte transfusions with cells from a maternal aunt, performed because of mucosal infections, resulted in similar episodes of endogenous granulocyte production. Transfection studies with the mutant CD154 protein indicate that the protein is expressed at the cell surface and forms an aberrant trimer that does not interact with CD40. The data suggest that allogeneic cells from the patient's aunt, probably activated T cells bearing functional CD154, may interact with CD40+ recipient cells to produce maturation of myeloid precursors in the bone marrow.

Rapid detection of genetic mutations using the chemiluminescent hybridization protection assay (HPA): overview and comparison with other methods

The detection of genetic mutations is of paramount importance for the study, diagnosis, and treatment of human genetic disease. Methods of detection generally fall into one of two categories: those to scan for unknown mutations and those to detect known mutations. This review focuses on methods for the detection of known mutations. The hybridization protection assay (HPA) is described in detail. The HPA method utilizes short oligonucleotide probes covalently labeled with a highly chemiluminescent acridinium ester (AE). The assay format is completely homogeneous, requiring no physical separation steps, and can rapidly and sensitively detect all single-base mismatches as well as multiple mismatches, insertions, deletions, and genetic translocations. When very low copy number targets are assayed, HPA is coupled with transcription-mediated amplification (TMA), an isothermal method that amplifies DNA or RNA targets. Other methods that are described for the detection of known mutations include hybridization with sequence-specific oligonucleotides, hybridization to oligonucleotide arrays, allele-specific amplification, ligase-mediated detection, primer extension, and restriction fragment analysis. The advantages and limitations of each of these methods are discussed. Methods to scan for unknown mutations are briefly described.

Angiotensin II stimulates proliferation of normal early erythroid progenitors

Angiotensin II exerts a mitogenic effect in several in vitro models, but a direct effect on erythroid progenitors has not been documented. Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors and losartan, an angiotensin II type 1 receptor (AT1) antagonist, ameliorate posttransplant erythrocytosis, without altering serum erythropoietin levels. We studied erythroid differentiation and the effect of angiotensin II on proliferation of erythroid progenitors by culturing CD34+ hematopoietic progenitor cells in liquid serum-free medium favoring growth of erythroid precursors. Aliquots of cells were collected every third day, and were used for RNA preparation. AT1 mRNA was detected after 6 d. In these same samples, erythroid-specific mRNA (erythropoietin receptor) was also detected. AT1 protein was detected in 7-d-old burst-forming units-erythroid colonies by Western blotting. The CD34+ cell liquid cultures were used to incubate erythroid precursors with angiotensin II from days 6-9. After incubation, cells were transferred to semisolid medium and cultured with erythropoietin. Angiotensin II increased proliferation of early erythroid progenitors, defined as increased numbers of burst-forming units-erythroid colonies. Losartan completely abolished this stimulatory effect of angiotensin II. Moreover, we observed increased numbers of erythroid progenitors in the peripheral blood of posttransplant erythrocytosis patients. Thus, activation of AT1 with angiotensin II enhances erythropoietin-stimulated erythroid proliferation in vitro. A putative defect in the angiotensin II/AT1 pathway may contribute to the pathogenesis of posttransplant erythrocytosis.