Trends in Racial-Ethnic Disparities in Adult Mental Health Treatment Use From 2005 to 2019

Health-related social needs mitigate ethnoracial inequities in patient-reported mental health

PURPOSE

To characterize the relationship between ethnoracial identity, health-related social needs (HRSNs), and mental health (MH), and to examine the mediating role of HRSNs on the relationship between MH and ethnoracial identity.

METHODS

Data from 30,437 adults who were seeking care within Mass General Brigham integrated health system in United States and had completed PROMIS Global Health within three years of their most recent HRSNs screening between March 1, 2018 and January 31, 2023 were included. The presence and magnitude of PROMIS Global MH score differences for six ethnoracial groups (White non-Hispanic, White Hispanic, Black (Hispanic and non-Hispanic), Asian non-Hispanic, Other non-Hispanic and Other Hispanic (includes Asian Hispanic) was assessed. Regression-based mediation analyses were used to examine mediating role of four HRSNs (food insecurity, housing instability, transportation barriers and inability to pay for housing utilities) on relationship between ethnoracial identity and MH.

RESULTS

Compared to White Non-Hispanic patients, ethnoracial minorities had worse MH, after adjusting for age, sex, education, employment, marital status, comorbidities, and insurance type. This relationship remained statistically significant (p < 0.001) for White Hispanic, Asian non-Hispanic and Other non-Hispanic patients, where HRSNs mediated 57%, 88% and 70% of the relationship between ethnoracial identity and MH respectively. For Blacks and Other Hispanic patients, HRSNs fully mediated this relationship.

CONCLUSION

Disparities in MH may be driven by structural racism and experiences of racism that result in differentials in HRSNs, rather than ethnoracial identity. Efforts directed at measuring and addressing the HRSNs, in addition to structural factors are critical to achieving MH equity.

Help-seeking at the intersection of race and age: Perceived need and treatment access for depression in the United States

Race/ethnicity and age are well-documented factors that influence help-seeking variables for adults with depression, yet the intersection of race/ethnicity and age on help-seeking is less known. The present study examined the intersection of race/ethnicity (comparing racial minority groups to White adults) and age on perceived need, treatment access, and unmet need for mental health services among adults with a past-year major depressive episode (N = 35,033) using data from the 2010-2019 waves of the National Survey on Drug Use and Health. After controlling for age, Black (OR = 0.50), Hispanic (OR = 0.50), Pacific Islander (OR = 0.23), and Asian (OR = 0.39) respondents had lower odds of perceiving need (p's < .001); Black (OR = 0.62), Asian (OR = 0.62), Hispanic (OR = 0.77), and multiracial respondents (OR = 0.75) had lower odds of accessing treatment (p's < .05); and Black (OR = 1.38) and Hispanic (OR = 1.19) respondents had higher odds of reporting an unmet need (p's < .05). After controlling for race, younger and older adults had lower odds of perceiving a need (p's < .05) compared to middle-aged adults. Younger adults had lower odds of accessing treatment and higher odds of experiencing an unmet need (p's < .001). An interaction revealed that Black adults were less likely to perceive need than White adults (p < .001), and this gap was especially large among younger members of both groups (p = .020). These results extend previous research by highlighting the intersection of race/ethnicity and age on help-seeking, with implications for culturally competent and age-appropriate interventions, while emphasizing the need for racial/age equity in the mental health care system.

Demographic variation in preferred sources for suicide prevention and mental health crisis services among U.S. adults

Introduction

Recent federal policy initiatives (e.g., 988 Lifeline, Certified Community Behavioral Health Clinics) aim to increase access to mental health crisis services. The objective of this study was to determine the prevalence and correlates of U.S. adults reporting being "very likely" to reach out to different sources if they/a loved one were experiencing suicidality or a mental health crisis.

Methods

A nationally representative Ipsos KnowledgePanel survey of 5,058 U.S. adults (response rate = 55.0 %) in English and Spanish was conducted in June 2023. Multivariable logistic regression models assessed the reported likelihood of reaching out to five different sources of support in a crisis, controlling for past 30-day psychological distress and demographic characteristics.

Results

One-in-four respondents (27.8 %; 95 % CI = 26.5 %, 29.0 %) were very likely to reach out to a crisis line and 33.6 % (95 % CI = 32.3 %, 34.9 %) were very likely to reach out to a mental health professional. A friend/family member was the most frequently identified source of support (44.7 %; 95 % CI = 43.4 %, 46.1 %). After adjustment, people of younger ages, male gender, and identifying as Republican had significantly lower odds of reporting being very likely to reach out to a crisis line and mental health professional. Black and Hispanic respondents had significantly higher odds of reporting being very likely to reach out to a crisis line and someone in their religious network than non-Hispanic Whites.

Conclusions

Most U.S. adults report not being very likely to reach out to a crisis line or mental health professional if experiencing suicidality/crisis, although variation across demographic groups exists.

The Relationship of Chronic Disease Burden and Racial-Ethnic Disparities in Depression Treatment

BACKGROUND

Chronic disease and depression are closely related, and depression, if left untreated, can worsen physical disease symptoms. Furthermore, treating depression can improve patient outcomes. Generally, treatment for depression is lower in minority groups.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to determine the relationship between chronic disease burden and depression treatment and whether that relationship differs between white to non-white patient visits to primary care physicians.

DESIGN

We conducted a quantitative secondary data analysis using data from 2014-2019 National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NAMCS).

PARTICIPANTS

Visits by adults with depression to primary care physicians (n = 3832).

MAIN MEASURES

Logistic regressions estimated the odds of medication treatment, mental health counseling treatment, and any treatment.

KEY RESULTS

Visits by patients with 3 or more chronic conditions had 1.39 times the odds of receiving medication treatment (p-value = 0.06). However, when examining treatment by race, visits by white patients with 1-2 chronic conditions had 3.04 times the odds of receiving mental health treatment (p-value = 0.09) compared to visits by non-white patients and 2.09 times the odds of receiving any treatment (p-value = 0.08) compared to visits by non-white patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Although not significant at the p < .05 level, the results suggest that the odds of depression treatment is greater during visits by patients with multiple co-occurring chronic conditions compared to visits by people without chronic conditions. It appears that this effect is larger for visits by white patients compared to visits by non-white patients. Further research is needed to confirm these findings and determine how this association impacts minorities distinctly and what could be the reason behind the disparity. These findings could help physicians be aware of ongoing disparities in depression treatment and provide more equitable depression treatment.

The Role of Black Churches in Promoting Mental Health for Communities of Socioeconomically Disadvantaged Black Americans

OBJECTIVE

Churches in socioeconomically disadvantaged neighborhoods serve as safe havens in many Black communities. Churches provide faith and charitable services but often have limited resources to address the mental health needs of their communities. This article reports on a collaborative effort, driven by members of a Black church, to understand mental health needs, coping strategies, and resilience factors in a community of socioeconomically disadvantaged Black Americans.

METHODS

A community-based participatory research effort was established among a church, a community mental health organization, clinicians, and researchers to interview and survey individuals residing near the church.

RESULTS

The sample consisted of 59 adults, most of whom were ages 46-65 years, men (N=34, 58%), and unemployed (N=46, 78%). Mean scores on the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (9.2±7.7) and Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7 scale (9.4±6.7) were almost three times higher than those reported by studies of other Black populations in the United States. Five themes emerged: prolonged poverty and daily exposure to violence trigger emotional distress, mental health stigma affects help seeking, spirituality promotes mental relief and personal recovery, spirituality helps in coping with poverty and unsafe neighborhoods, and church-based programs are needed.

CONCLUSIONS

Uptake of traditional mental health services was low, and reliance on faith and resource distribution by the church was high. Church-led interventions are needed to promote mental health at the individual and community levels. Mental health stigma, and negative attitudes toward mental health promotion in the community, may be addressed by integrating traditional mental health services in church-based recreational and leisure activities.

Preliminary Effectiveness of a Therapist-Supported Digital Mental Health Intervention in Reducing Suicidal Ideation

Suicidal ideation (SI) is a significant public health concern with increasing prevalence. Therapist-supported digital mental health interventions (DMHI) are an emergent modality to address common mental health problems like depression and anxiety, although less is known about SI. This study examined SI trajectories among 778 patients who participated in a therapist-supported DMHI using multilevel models during and up to 6-months post-treatment. Estimates of associated suicide attempts and deaths by suicide were calculated using published data linking PHQ-9-assessed SI to records of suicide attempts and deaths by suicide. The proportion of participants reporting no SI significantly increased between baseline and end-of-treatment (78.02% to 91.00%). Effect sizes of SI changes between baseline and end-of-treatment, 3-month, and 6-month follow-ups were 0.33 (95%CI = 0.27-0.38), 0.32 (95%CI = 0.27-0.38), and 0.32 (95%CI = 0.27-0.38), respectively. Results also indicated an estimated 30.49% reduction (95%CI = 25.15%-35.13%) in suicide attempts and death by suicide across treatment. This study provides preliminary evidence of the effectiveness of a therapist-supported DMHI in reducing SI.

Racial and ethnic trends in mental health service utilisation and perceived unmet need in the USA

BACKGROUND

Two decades ago, the Surgeon General issued a report highlighting concerning disparities in mental healthcare among racial and ethnic minority populations. The present study characterised national trends in mental health treatment utilisation by race and ethnicity across a 13-year period.

METHODS

Nationally representative data were drawn from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health from 2008 through 2020 (unweighted n=4 41 993). Trends in mental health treatment utilisation and perceived unmet treatment need among individuals with and without psychiatric illness were stratified by race and ethnicity.

RESULTS

Logistic regression analyses revealed most racial/ethnic minority groups were less likely to receive treatment than white individuals, regardless of mental health status. Treatment utilisation increased among those with (annual per cent change (APC)=0.83, 95% CI=0.41 to 1.26) and without psychiatric illness (APC=1.39, 95% CI=0.53 to 2.26). Among individuals with psychiatric illness, treatment use increased among white (APC=0.88, 95% CI=0.51 to 1.24), Hispanic (APC=2.12, 95% CI=0.70 to 3.57) and black adults (APC=1.07, 95% CI=0.11 to 2.04). White (APC=1.88, 95% CI=0.86 to 2.91) and Hispanic (APC=2.45, 95% CI=0.02 to 4.93) individuals without psychiatric illness also saw increased treatment use. Although increases in perceived unmet treatment need were observed for all racial and ethnic groups except blacks and Native Americans with psychiatric illness, rates remained low across all groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Although national rates of mental health treatment utilisation have risen, this was almost entirely observed among white and Hispanic individuals with and without psychiatric illness, highlighting the limited progress made towards eliminating disparities in care.