Vocal Nodules: Evolution From Childhood to Postpuberty

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the behavior of vocal nodules from childhood to postpuberty.

METHODS

Adolescents aged 15 years or older who presented vocal nodules in childhood were included and underwent the same evaluations performed in childhood. They answered a questionnaire about vocal symptoms, treatments, habits, and vocal abuse. They were submitted to videolaryngoscopy, auditory-perceptual, and acoustic vocal assessments.

RESULTS

In total, 31 adolescents (15-18 years), 23 boys, eight girls, mean age in childhood and postpuberty: girls (10.25 ± 1.85, 16.75 ± 1.3); boys (10.08 ± 1.34, 15.95 ± 1.87), without statistical difference between childhood and postpuberty (P > 0.05).

SYMPTOMS

four boys (12.9%) and three girls (9.67%) maintained dysphonia postpuberty. Videolaryngoscopy: nodules were not detected after puberty. Minor alterations: hyperemia (n-2), edema (n-1), posterior glottic cleft (n-1), and microweb (n-1).

TREATMENTS

vocal therapy (n-18), microsurgery (n-8), and no treatment (n-5). There was a significant difference in the acoustic (maximum phonation time, f0, jitter, pitch perturbation quotient, shimmer, amplitude perturbation quotient, and Student t test) and acoustic perceptive parameters (Mann-Whitney rank sum test) between the moments (childhood and postpuberty). In the comparison between the treatments (Shapiro-Wilk and Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests) just for shimmer parameter, there was a statistical difference, being more significant in surgery and speech therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

After puberty, we observed a reduction in vocal symptoms, as well as an improvement in videolaryngoscopic findings and in auditory and acoustic perceptive vocal parameters. In the comparison between the treatments just for shimmer parameter, there was a statistical difference, being more significant in surgery and speech therapy.

Voice outcomes following surgical treatment for pediatric vocal fold nodules: A systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to systematically review the literature to determine outcomes following surgical treatment of pediatric vocal fold nodules.

METHODS

Studies with patients ≤18 years with nodules who underwent surgery were reviewed for dysphonia improvement and recurrence in PubMed, EMBASE, Medline, CINAHL, Cochrane, Scopus, and Web of Science databases, searched from inception to November 1, 2022 using PRISMA guidelines. Non-English studies and case reports were excluded. Two evaluators independently reviewed each abstract and article. Heterogeneity and bias across studies were evaluated and meta-analysis was performed.

RESULTS

The literature search yielded 655 articles; 145 underwent full-text screening and eight were selected for systematic review and meta-analysis. There were 311 children with nodules, aged 2-18 years, with male-to-female ratio of 3.6:1. There were no surgical complications. Voice therapy was inconsistently reported. Follow-up time ranged from 1 month to 10 years. One study concluded that neither surgery nor voice therapy was effective, while five studies concluded that dysphonia improved with surgery. Voice grading by GRBAS, objective voice measures, and lesion size were improved following surgery, when reported. Meta-analysis of six studies demonstrated improvement in dysphonia in 90% of children post-operatively (95% CI: 74-99%). Meta-analysis of four studies showed that recurrence occurred in 19% of children (95% CI: 13-23%).

CONCLUSION

This systematic review suggests possible post-operative improvement in dysphonia for pediatric patients with vocal fold nodules; however, study measures, methods, and surgery utilized were heterogeneous and results should be interpreted cautiously. In order to better understand surgical outcomes, future studies should include standardized definition of nodules and objective measures of voice.

Effects of voice therapy in children with vocal fold nodules: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Vocal fold nodules (VFNs) are the main cause of paediatric dysphonia. Voice therapy is recommended as the preferable treatment option for VFNs in children.

AIM

The aim of this systematic review is to provide an overview of the existing literature concerning the effects of voice therapy in children with VFNs.

METHODS & PROCEDURES

This systematic literature review was developed following the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), MEDLINE (via PubMed) and Embase were searched and the grey literature was checked. The search strategy was based on three concepts: VFNs, voice therapy and children. Two examiners independently determined article eligibility and extracted all relevant data from the included studies. The methodological quality of the included study was assessed using the QualSyst tool.

MAIN CONTRIBUTIONS

By identifying, evaluating and summarizing the results of all relevant studies about voice therapy in paediatric VFNs, this systematic review makes the available evidence more accessible to voice therapists, otolaryngologists and other relevant stakeholders.

CONCLUSIONS & IMPLICATIONS

24 studies were included in this systematic review. Eight studies (8/24) reported a significant improvement for at least one outcome parameter after voice therapy. However, five papers (5/24) could not demonstrate significant changes after voice therapy. All studies that did not test for significance (11/24) found improvements for one or more outcome parameters. The overall quality of the included studies is adequate (55%). In sum, there is some evidence that voice therapy is effective in children with VFNs, but further well-designed research, especially randomized controlled trials, is necessary to confirm these results.

WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS

What is already known on the subject Voice therapy is preferable in children with VFNs because of the phonotraumatic nature of the nodules and the associated high recurrence rate after phonosurgery. Most voice therapists in clinical practice offer an eclectic voice therapy programme, consisting of direct and indirect voice therapy techniques. What this study adds to existing knowledge This systematic review provides a clear overview of the available evidence concerning the effects of voice therapy in paediatric VFNs. There is some evidence that voice therapy is an effective treatment option in children with VFNs, but well-designed research is scarce on this subject. What are the potential or actual clinical implications of this work? This review shows that effectiveness studies with strong designs are very scarce in children with VFNs. Clinicians should be aware that few therapy techniques have been thoroughly investigated in this population. However, this review may guide voice therapists when creating a treatment plan for a child with VFNs because it identifies, evaluates and summarizes the results of all relevant individual studies about voice therapy in paediatric VFNs. Voice therapy seems to be effective in treating paediatric patients with VFNs, given the fact that a considerable number of included studies report significant improvements after voice therapy. Both direct and indirect therapy approaches appear to have a positive effect on the phonation of children with VFNs.

The Effect of the Mother's Participation in Therapy on Children with Vocal Fold Nodules

OBJECTIVES

Vocal fold nodules (VFN) are a bilateral epithelial thickening of the membranous vocal folds. In this study, children with VFN and their mothers took part in voice therapy. We then compared acoustic analyzes and subjective evaluations to those in previous literature to determine whether voice therapy is more effective for children with VFN when their mothers also take part in therapy.

METHODS

Children aged eight to 12 years who were diagnosed with bilateral VFN between January 2018 and January 2020 were included in this study. Participating children diagnosed with bilateral VFN were divided into two groups based on the wishes and cooperation of their families. Group 1 consisted of 16 patients; Group 2 included 17 patients. The children in Group 1 received voice therapy alone; children in Group 2 took part in therapy with their mothers. For all participants, the average fundemental frequency (F0), jitter percentages, shimmer percentages, maximum phonation time (MPT) and s/z ratios were measured. Pediatric voice handicap index (p-VHI) values were calculated as well.

RESULTS

The two groups' measures pre-treatment and post-treatment were compared. Except for p-VHI, no significant difference was observed between the two groups. However, p-VHI post-treatment was significantly lower in Group 2 than in Group 1.

CONCLUSIONS

Involving the families and even teachers of children with VFN in voice therapy can increase the effectiveness of therapy. The family's involvement increases the child's motivation in therapy. The mother's presence during therapy, supporting the child or even doing the work with the child, can be a very important source of motivation for the child, who may already be tired from school and other activities. Thus, the mother's involvement increases the child's compliance with and interest in therapy.

Maximum and Minimum Phonatory Glottal Area before and after Treatment for Vocal Nodules

Background: Vocal fold nodules (VFNs) are a challenge for otolaryngologists. Glottal area (GA) waveform analysis is an examination method used for assessing vocal fold vibration and function. However, GA in patients with VFNs has rarely been studied. This study investigated the maximum and minimum GA in VFN patients using modern waveform analysis combining ImageJ software and videostroboscopy. Methods: This study enrolled 42 patients newly diagnosed with VFN, 15 of whom received voice therapy and 27 of whom underwent surgery. Acoustic parameters and maximum phonation time (MPT) were recorded, and patients completed the Chinese Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI-C10) before and after treatment. After videostroboscopy examination, the maximum and minimum GAs were calculated using ImageJ software. The GAs of patients with VFNs before and after surgery or voice therapy were analyzed. Results: The MPTs of the patients before and after voice therapy or surgery did not change significantly. VHI-C10 scores decreased after voice therapy but the decrease was nonsignificant (14.0 ± 8.44 vs. 9.40 ± 10.24, p = 0.222); VHI-C10 scores were significantly decreased after surgery (22.53 ± 7.17 vs. 12.75 ± 9.84, p = 0.038). Voice therapy significantly increased the maximum GA (5.58 ± 2.41 vs. 8.65 ± 3.17, p = 0.012) and nonsignificantly decreased the minimum GA (0.60 ± 0.73 vs. 0.21 ± 0.46, p = 0.098). Surgery nonsignificantly increased the maximum GA (6.34 ± 3.82 vs. 8.73 ± 5.57, p = 0.118) and significantly decreased the minimum GA (0.30 ± 0.59 vs. 0.00 ± 0.00, p = 0.036). Conclusion: This study investigated the GA of patients with VFNs who received voice therapy or surgery. The findings indicated that voice therapy significantly increased maximum GA and surgery significantly decreased minimum GA. GA analysis could be applied to evaluate the efficacy of voice therapy, and it may help physicians to develop precise treatment for VFN patients (either by optimizing voice therapy or by performing surgery directly).

Surgical and therapeutic advances in the management of voice problems in children and young people

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The current article reviews advances in both the assessment of paediatric voice disorders, as well as surgical, medical and therapeutic treatments.

RECENT FINDINGS

It is important to evaluate the impact of a voice disorder from both the parent and child perspective. Outpatient laryngoscopy with stroboscopy is very possible even in young children; however, high-speed ultrasound is a plausible alternative. High-speed videolaryngoscopy, videokymography and dynamic computed tomography, offer potential for augmenting the assessment of vocal fold vibratory characteristics in children. The evidence to support the efficacy of both indirect and direct voice therapy interventions is growing. The management of vocal fold palsy has advanced to include laryngeal reinnervation. Intubation injury with/without surgical intervention offers challenge and gives rise to voice disorders that may be lifelong.

SUMMARY

Although assessment and management practices of paediatric voice disorders closely follow those applied to adults, there are important differences and a developmental approach is required when considering both surgical and therapeutic management. Children can benefit from both indirect and direct therapy treatments following an ear, nose and throat assessment which utilizes paediatric instrumentation and considers the health of the entire airway. Underlying medical contributory factors should be explored and treated. Voice disorders due to congenital and acquired changes of the vocal tract may be amenable to surgery.

Vocal nodules management

Vocal fold nodules present the voice clinic team with a number of clinical dilemmas which are not as simple as previously thought. The definition, aetiology, prevalence and diagnosis are all poorly understood. Furthermore, treatment evidence for both behavioural and surgical approaches is weak. This paper reviews the published evidence pertaining to all of these aspects. Specific areas of uncertainty that remain include poorly defined nomenclature, the natural history of paediatric vocal nodules, the establishment of criteria to measure successful treatment, optimal configuration of speech therapy regimens and the rationale for surgical intervention. The authors suggest the development of evidence-based guidelines for UK practice.