Effect of blood viscosity on the performance of virtually wall-less venous cannulas

AIM

This study was designed to quantify the influence of blood as test medium compared to water in cannula bench performance assessment.

METHODS

An in vitro circuit was set-up with silicone tubing between two reservoirs. The test medium was pumped from the lower reservoir by centrifugal pump to the upper reservoir. The test-cannula was inserted in a silicone tube connected between the lower reservoir and the centrifugal pump. Flow rate and pump inlet-pressure were measured for wall-less versus thin-wall cannula using a centrifugal pump in a dynamic bench-test for an afterload of 40-60 mmHg using two media: blood 10 g/dL and 5.6 g/dL and water 0 g/dL.

RESULTS

The wall-less cannula showed significantly higher flows rates as compared to the thin-wall cannula (control), with both hemoglobin concentrations and water. Indeed, for a target volume of 200-250 mL of blood (Hg 10 g/dL) in the upper reservoir, the cannula outlet pressure (P) was -14 ± 14 mmHg versus -18 ± 11 mmHg for the wall-less and control respectively; the cannula outlet flow rate (Q) was 3.91 ± 0.41 versus 3.67 ± 0.45 L/min, respectively. At the same target volume but with a Hg of 5.7 g/dL, P was -16 ± 12 mmHg versus -19 ± 12 mmHg and Q was 4 ± 0.1 versus 4 ± 0.4 L/min for the wall-less cannula and control respectively. Likewise, P and Q values with water were -1 mmHg versus -0.67 ± 0.58 mmHg and 4.17 ± 0.45 L/min versus 4.08 ± 0.47 L/min for the wall-less and control respectively.

CONCLUSION

Walls-less cannula showed 5.6% less pump inlet-pressure differences calculated between blood and water, as compared to that of thin-wall cannula (-21 times). Flow differences were 6% and 10% for the walls-less and thin-wall cannula respectively. We conclude that testing the cannula performance with water is a good scenario and can overestimate the flow by a 10%. However, superiority for wall-less is preserved with both water and blood.

Prevention of caval collapse during venous drainage for CPB

A new plastic self-expanding Smartcanula (Smartcanula LLC, Lausanne, Switzerland) is designed for central insertion and prevention of caval collapse. The objective of our work is to assess the influence of the new design on atrial chatter. Caval collapse over the entire caval axis, right atrial, hepatic, renal vein, and iliac vein is realized in drainage tubes with holes at 5 cm distance intervals. Smartcanulas with various lengths (26 cm [= right atrial], 34 cm [= hepatic], 43 cm [= renal], and 53 cm [= iliac]) versus two-stage cannulas are compared. Pressure drop (ΔP) is measured using Millar pressure-transducers. Flow rate (Q) is measured using an ultrasonic flow meter. Cannula resistance is defined as the ΔP/Q ratio. Data display and recording are controlled using LabView virtual instruments. At an 88 cm height differential, Q values are 8.69 and 6.8 l/min, and ΔP/Q ratios are 0.63 and 1.28 for the 26-cm Smartcanula and the reference cannula, respectively. The 34-cm Smartcanula showed 8.89 l/min and 0.6 ΔP/Q ratio vs. 7.59 l/min and 0.9 for the control cannula (P < 0.05). The 43-cm and 53-cm Smartcanulas showed Q values of 9.04 and 8.81 l/min, respectively, and ΔP/Q2 ratio of 0.6. The Smartcanula outperforms the two-stage cannula, and direct cannula insertion without guide wire is effective.

Characterizing the impact of minor cannula design modification

OBJECTIVE

Bench evaluation of the hydrodynamic behavior of venous cannulas is a valuable technique for the analysis of their performance during cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB). The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of the internal diameter of the extracorporeal connecting tube of venous cannulas on flow rate (Q), pressure drop (delta P), and cannula resistance (delta P/Q²) values, using a computer assisted test bench.

METHODS

An in vitro circuit was set up with silicone tubing between the test cannula encased in a movable reservoir, and a static reservoir. The delta P, defined as the difference between the drainage pressure and the preload pressure, was measured using high-fidelity Millar pressure transducers. Q was measured using an ultrasonic flowmeter. Data display and data recording were controlled using virtual instruments in a stepwise fashion.

RESULTS

The 27 F smartcanula® with a 9 mm connecting tube diameter showed 17% less resistance compared to that with an 8 mm connecting tube diameter. Q values were 7.22±0.1 and 7.81±0.04 L/min for cannulas with 8 mm and 9 mm connecting tube diameters, respectively. The delta P/Q² ratio values were 72% lower for the Medtronic cannula with a 9 mm connecting tube diameter compared to that with an 8 mm connecting tube diameter. Q values for the Medtronic cannula were 3.94±0.23 and 6.58±0.04 L/min with 8 mm and 9 mm connecting tube diameters, respectively. The 27 F smartcanula® showed 13% more flow rate compared to the 28 F Medtronic cannula using the unpaired Student t-test (p<0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Our results demonstrated that Q was increased but delta P and delta P/Q² values were significantly decreased when the connecting tube diameter was increased for venous cannulas. The connecting tube diameter significantly affected the resistance to liquid flow through the cannula. Smartcanulas® outperform Medtronic cannulas.

Computational model of the fluid dynamics of a cannula inserted in a vessel: incidence of the presence of side holes in blood flow

Vascular access methods, performed by the insertion of cannulae into vessels, may disturb the physiological flow of blood, giving rise to non-physiological pressure variations and shear stresses. To date, the hydrodynamic behaviour of the cannulae has been evaluated comparing their pressure loss-flow rate relationships, as obtained from in vitro experiments using a monodimensional approach; this methodology neither furnish information about the local fluid dynamics nor the established flow field in specific clinical work conditions. Since the shear stress is a critical factor in the design of artificial circulatory devices, more knowledge should be necessary about the local values assumed by the haemodynamic parameters during cannulation. An alternative way to investigate the fluid dynamic as accurately as possible is given by numeric studies. A 3D model of cannula concentrically placed in a rigid wall vessel is presented, with the finite element methodology used to numerically simulate the steady-state flow field in two different venous cannulation case studies, with two cannulae having a central hole and two or four side holes, respectively, with the same boundary conditions. Lower velocity and shear stress peak values have been computed for the model with four side holes upstream of the central hole, in the region of the cannula where the inlet flows meet and towards cannula's outlet, due to the increased flow symmetry and inlet area with respect to the model with two side holes. Starting from the investigation of different cannula designs, numerically assessing the local fluid dynamics, indications can be drawn to support both the design phase and the device optimal clinical use, in order to limit risks of biomechanical origin. Thus the presence of four side holes implied, as a consequence of the greater inlet area and of the increased symmetry, a less disturbed blood flow, together with reduced shear stress values. Furthermore, results show that the numerical simulations furnished useful informations on the interaction between vessel and cannula, e.g. on the fluid dynamics establishing in the free luminal space left, in the vessel, by the inserted cannula.

Potential mechanical blood trauma in vascular access devices: a comparison of case studies

Since vascular access devices may cause disturbances in blood flow, possibly damaging red blood cells (RBCs), the correlated risk of lysis must be assessed. The monodimensional approach for the evaluation of cannulae hydrodynamic behaviour (in vitro measured flow curves) does not furnish information on the local flow field occurring in specific clinical conditions. Researchers consider the prediction of blood trauma, induced by mechanical loading, to optimize the design phase, and to furnish indications on their optimal clinical use. In this study, a model of cannula inserted in a non compliant wall vessel was used as a test bench in a Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) problem. By means of CFD the flow field was 3D analysed to achieve information on velocity and shear stress local values, when cannula is used for inflow and outflow cannulation. A prediction of potential blood corpuscle damage, based on a power law, quantified the potential blood damage. Several numerical simulations, with different cannula/vessel flow rate ratios were provided, to investigate the incidence of local sites in the design on blood damaging potential during cannulation. Several regions appeared to be sensitive to the flow rate not only inside the cannula but also in the space between cannula and vessel, suggesting new indications for the assessment of a quality factor based on the evaluation of induced blood cells injury.

Flexible Angle-Retaining Dual-Stage Venous Cannula

We designed a flexible and angle-retaining dual-stage venous cannula by attachment of a U-shaped stainless steel wire, heat-contracted tube, and synthetic resins. Initial clinical use showed that this cannula has several benefits compared to a conventional fixed-angle cannula for establishing cardiopulmonary bypass for aortic root and coronary artery bypass surgery.

Angle-adjustable sheath for a dual-stage venous cannula

The dual-stage venous cannula is widely used but can obstruct the surgeon's view and interfere with operative procedures in the aortic root. We designed a new stainless steel sheath for a dual-stage venous cannula that enables the cannula to bend and maintain the appropriate angle for the surgical procedures. We suggest that operative procedures in the aortic root can be performed faster during safety cardiopulmonary bypass by use of a dual-stage venous cannula bent by application of this new sheath.

An in vitro evaluation of venous cannula in a simulated partial (femoro-femoral) cardiopulmonary bypass circuit

We designed a study to evaluate three factors (siphon gradient [PH], the right atrial pressure [RAP], and the inferior vena caval flow [IVCF]) to be optimized to maximize the venous drainage flow (DF) during partial cardiopulmonary bypass using eight venous cannulas of three different types and an original model circuit. The relationship between venous DF and the three factors is indicated by the multiple regression equation DF2 = alpha PH + beta RAP + gamma IVCF2 + C, where alpha, beta, and gamma are regression estimates and C is a constant. Multiple regression analysis results showed that DF was positively correlated with PH and RAP and negatively correlated with IVCF. A long cannula with 12 side holes and 60 cm long was considered to be useful to yield the optimal venous drainage flow under the condition of maintenance of the flow balance (DF and ICVF) and the pressure balance (RAP and IVCP) at the zero point. Moreover, this model may allow extensive research in flow dynamics of venous cannula without involving human subjects.