Effects of an accelerated rehabilitation program after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with combined semitendinosus-gracilis autograft and a ligament augmentation device

Synthetic augmentation in ACL reconstruction may reduce re-rupture rates and increase return-to-sport rates: A systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Synthetic augmentation (SA) in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) aims to enhance graft durability, but its benefits remain unclear. To evaluate whether SA in ACLR improves return-to-sport (RTS) rates, reduces graft failure, enhances patient-reported outcomes (PROs) and varies in effectiveness across materials and techniques.

METHODS

A systematic search of five databases was conducted until February 2025. Comparative studies were pooled using Hedges' random-effects meta-analysis with subgroup analysis based on materials and publication year. Non-comparative studies were analysed narratively. Risk of bias was assessed using the Risk of Bias in Non-randomised Studies of Interventions and the Cochrane risk-of-bias tools for randomised studies. Grades of Recommendation, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) approach was used to assess the certainty of evidence.

RESULTS

Forty-seven studies were included (n = 4289): 7 randomised and 40 non-randomised studies (21 comparative; 19 non-comparative). SA systems included InternalBrace (FiberTape, 16 studies), Ligament Augmentation and Reconstruction System (polyester, 5), Ligament Augmentation Device (polyethylene, 18) and other materials (8). GRADE assessment showed moderate-certainty evidence for improved mid-term RTS rate from eight studies (odds ratio [OR]: 1.58; 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.12-2.22; N = 716; I2 = 0%; p = 0.01). Internal brace showed a reduction in re-rupture rates in the long-term (OR: 0.17, 95% CI: 0.04-0.64; N = 218; I2 = 0%; p = 0.01); however, pooled analysis of all techniques showed no statistically significant difference. Contemporary studies showed a better return to sport rates with SA. PROs showed no clinically meaningful differences. Non-comparative studies showed low graft failure rates (<8.7% for InternalBrace; <16.4% for other SA), high RTS rates (>90% for InternalBrace; >56.7% for other SA) and satisfactory PROs.

CONCLUSIONS

SA, particularly InternalBrace, may improve RTS rates and reduce re-rupture risk, though PROs remain inconclusive. Findings are limited by a moderate-to-serious risk of bias, emphasising the need for high-quality research.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Difference of Knee Strength Recovery Between Revision and Primary ACL Reconstruction

Different grafting procedures are available to restore knee stability after revision anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. We compared knee strength recovery between ACL revision surgery and primary reconstruction. One hundred and ten patients with ACL revision surgery were matched with 110 patients with primary reconstruction based on the graft procedure. The isokinetic knee strength had been assessed for the first 9 months post-surgery. Knee laxity, function, and activity score were also evaluated. Limb symmetry index for knee extensor and flexor strength was not different at 4-, 6- and 9-months post-surgery between revision surgery and primary reconstruction. These results depended on ipsilateral or contralateral graft choice. Ipsilateral hamstring tendon (HT) and contralateral bone-patellar-tendon-bone (BPTB) graft procedures were similar for a revision of a BPTB graft failure. Contralateral HT procedure was better than ipsilateral BPTB procedure for a revision of a HT graft failure. The early recovery of isokinetic knee strength after ACL revision surgery regardless of the HT or BPTB procedures, was similar to the recovery after primary ACL reconstruction with the same graft technique. These results apparently depended on a temporary quadriceps arthrogenic muscle inhibition and on a persistent donor site morbidity, concerning the new and the previous grafts, respectively.

Arthrofibrosis risk factors after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Introduction

Knee arthrofibrosis is a disabling complication after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLr). Different risk factors have been studied but are still controversial because of a diagnosis made only during reoperations for the treatment of the stiffness, which underestimates the occurrence rate. We aimed to confirm risk factors of arthrofibrosis after ACLr in case of clinically made diagnoses.

Methods

Ninety-two athletes with clinically diagnosed arthrofibrosis, complicating a primary ACLr, were compared to 482 athletes with ACLr without any complications. Usually considered risk factors were studied: age under 18, female, Body Mass Index (BMI ≥ 25), high sport level, time from ACL injury to ACLr < 1 month, Bone-Patella-Tendon-Bone surgical procedure (BPTB), meniscal repair, and intensive rehabilitation. Binary logistic regression was carried out to confirm or refute these risk factors.

Results

Female, time from ACL injury to ACLr < 1 month, BPTB procedure, meniscal repair, and BMI ≥ 25 were not confirmed as risk factors. Previous competitive sport level assessed by Tegner score was the only risk factor identified, OR: 3.56 (95%IC: 2.20-5.75; p = 0.0001). Age < 18, OR: 0.40 (95%IC: 0.19-0.84; p = 0.015) and inpatient rehabilitation program, OR: 0.28 (95%IC: 0.17-0.47; p = 0.0001), were protective factors.

Discussion

Competitive athletes are at risk of arthrofibrosis after ACLr and should benefit from protective inpatient rehabilitation program.

Therapeutic Patient Education after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: Evaluation of the Knowledge and Certitudes with a Self-Report Questionnaire

Therapeutic education aims to help patients acquire skills and knowledge, and to improve psychosocial aspects to manage chronic disease. After anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR), only 35 to 60% of the patients are able to go back to their previous sport. Return to sport depends on the motivation of the patient. No therapeutic education has already been proposed. We aimed to evaluate the effect of therapeutic education sessions on knowledge improvement during inpatient rehabilitation after ACLR, compared to patients operated with the same surgical technic, but who had no therapeutic education because of outpatient rehabilitation. Sessions were performed by a multidisciplinary team. The evaluation of the knowledge was performed with a true or false 12-items self-report questionnaire. Fifty-four patients were studied and compared to 54 patients with no therapeutic education. The educated and the non-educated groups were comparable. The number of correct answers increased from 73% before therapeutic education to 95% at the end of the hospitalization (p < 0.001). This improvement persisted over time with 91.5% of correct answers at four months (p = 0.94). The non-educated group had 70% of correct answers. This was significantly lower than the results obtained from the educated group at four months (p < 0.001). It was comparable to the result obtained before therapeutic education (p = 0.91). Therapeutic patient education performed during hospitalization for rehabilitation enables patients to have a better knowledge of the stages from rehabilitation to return to sport and the risks of complication after ACLR.

Recovery After ACL Reconstruction in Male Versus Female Adolescents: A Matched, Sex-Based Cohort Analysis of 543 Patients

Background:

Differences in postoperative recovery after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) between men and women have been demonstrated in the adult population. Sex-based differences have been incompletely investigated in adolescents, which represent the subpopulation most affected by ACL injury.

Purpose/Hypothesis:

The purpose of this study was to compare the 6-month postoperative functional recovery after ACLR between adolescent boys and girls. It was hypothesized that significant differences in postoperative strength, dynamic balance, and functional hop test performance would be seen between the sexes.

Study Design:

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods:

Included in this study were athletes aged 12 to 19 years with closed or closing growth plates who underwent ACLR with hamstring autograft between May 2014 and May 2018 at a single institution. All athletes had undergone strength and functional testing between 5 and 8 months postoperatively. Exclusion criteria were previous knee surgery (contralateral or ipsilateral knee), concomitant injury/surgery other than meniscal tear/repair, allograft supplementation, and incomplete medical records. The limb symmetry index (LSI) for strength (measured with handheld dynamometer), as well as dynamic Y-balance and functional hop test performance, was compared between groups. To account for differences in physical characteristics between the sexes, 1-way between-group multivariate analysis of covariance was used to analyze the data.

Results:

Overall, 543 patients (211 boys, 332 girls) were included. There was no significant difference in age, body mass index, incidence of concomitant meniscal pathology, use of regional anesthesia, or time to functional testing between cohorts. Female athletes demonstrated a statistically significantly greater deficit in quadriceps strength LSI compared with male athletes (boys, +3.4%; girls, –2.3%; P = .011). Both male and female athletes demonstrated 33% hamstring strength deficits, with no statistically significant sex-based differences in dynamic balance or functional hop testing.

Conclusion:

Female athletes demonstrated greater quadriceps strength deficits than male athletes at 6 months after ACLR with hamstring autograft. Severe hamstring strength deficits persisted in both male and female patients at this time point. The correlation of such deficits to risk of ACL retear warrants continued study in the adolescent population and may support a delay in return to sports, which has been suggested in the more recent literature.

Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Using Autologous Hamstrings Augmented With the Ligament Augmentation and Reconstruction System Versus Hamstrings Alone: A Comparative Cohort Study

BACKGROUND

Few studies have reported the return-to-sports (RTS) rate in patients after augmentation of autologous anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) with the Ligament Augmentation and Reconstruction System (LARS).

PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS

The purpose of this study was to compare postoperative outcomes in patients who underwent ACLR with single-bundle 4-strand hamstring autograft either without augmentation (HA-ACLR group) or with LARS augmentation (AUG-ACLR group). It was hypothesized that clinical outcomes and RTS rates would be better in the AUG-ACLR group at the 1-year follow-up, with similar outcomes in both cohorts by 2 years.

STUDY DESIGN

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.

METHODS

Patients who underwent ACLR between April 2014 and December 2017 were included in the current comparative study if they were skeletally mature and had 1- and 2-year follow-up outcomes; patients with concomitant meniscal surgery were also included. Included were 66 patients with AUG-ACLR (mean age, 26.8 years; 67% male) and 130 patients with HA-ACLR (mean age, 27.5 years; 61% male). Subjective outcome measures included the International Knee Documentation Committee Subjective Knee Evaluation Form, Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score, Lysholm scale, Tegner activity scale, and the Noyes sports activity rating scale. Objective measures included knee laxity, maximal isokinetic knee flexion and extension strength, and the results of 4 functional hop tests.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences between the study groups in age, sex distribution, body mass index, time to surgery, or number of concurrent meniscal surgeries. At the 1-year follow-up, the AUG-ACLR group had a significantly higher Tegner score (P = .001) and rates of RTS (P = .029) and return to preinjury level of sport (P = .003) compared with the HA-ACLR group. At the 2-year follow-up, there were no differences in these measures between groups. There were no between-group differences in other subjective outcomes, knee laxity, or strength and hop test results at either postoperative time point. There were also no differences in rerupture rates or other complications between the groups.

CONCLUSION

Patients with AUG-ACLR had higher 1-year postoperative Tegner scores and rates of RTS and preoperative sport level compared with the HA-ACLR group. The 2-year rerupture rate for the AUG-ACLR group was low, and no intra-articular inflammatory complications were noted.

Arthrogenic muscle inhibition and return to sport after arthrofibrosis complicating anterior cruciate ligament surgery

Arthrofibrosis is a devastating complication after Anterior Cruciate Ligament reconstruction (ACLr) characterized by a muscle weakness secondary to an arthrogenic muscle inhibition process. The loss of knee isokinetic strength due to arthrogenic muscle inhibition may be more important after arthrofibrosis, compared to an ACLr population with no complication. The isokinetic strength deficit [Limb Symmetry Index (LSI) at 60 and 180°/s of angular speed] was measured at 4, 7 and 12 post-operative months. Knee function, return to running and return to sport were evaluated. A comparison of the Quadriceps and the Hamstring LSI between patients with arthrofibrosis and those without post-operative complication was performed according to time and taking into consideration the type of surgical procedure. 539 primary ACLr patients were assessed. The arthrofibrosis group presented at 4, 7 and 12 post-operative months a Quadriceps LSI significantly lower compared to the control group, without influence of the graft procedure (LSI: 38, 53, 68% vs 63, 73, 85% at 60°/s, respectively). The Hamstring LSI was significantly lower at 4 and 7 post-operative months, but comparable at 12 months with an influence of the Hamstring procedure. Knee function was significantly lower at 4 and 7 post-operative months. Few arthrofibrosis ACLr patients returned to running at 7 post-operative months (6.8% vs 69.9%; p < .0001). An important and durable Quadriceps muscle weakness occurred after arthrofibrosis, whatever the type of graft procedure. This is explained by an Arthrogenic muscle inhibition which compromised the return to sport at the same level until 12 post-operative months. HighlightsAn important and durable quadriceps muscle weakness occurred after arthrofibrosis.The arthrogenic muscle inhibition was significant on the operated side independently of the type of the graft procedure.Arthrogenic muscle inhibition compromised the return to sport at the same level until 12 post-operative months.

[Postoperative knee : Tips and pitfalls for the interpretation of ACL surgery]

The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is the most important restraint against anterior tibial subluxation and provides stability in flexion, extension and internal rotation as well as varus and valgus stress. Certain sports activities, such as soccer, rugby, skiing, and dancing increase the risk of ACL injuries. The decision for surgical treatment is primarily clinically based under consideration of multiple factors, such as age, body habitus, gender and specific physical activities. There are numerous different techniques for ACL reconstruction each with advantages and disadvantages. The radiologist and the clinician should be familiar with the different appearances of ACL grafts on postoperative imaging depending on the time interval between arthroscopy and imaging. This article reviews the anatomy of the ACL and the most common ACL reconstruction techniques and discusses the normal postoperative findings and complications of ACL reconstruction based on different imaging techniques.

One in 5 Athletes Sustain Reinjury Upon Return to High-Risk Sports After ACL Reconstruction: A Systematic Review in 1239 Athletes Younger Than 20 Years

CONTEXT

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (ACLR) is frequently performed in patients younger than 20 years whose goal is to return to sport (RTS). Varying reinjury rates have been reported, and the factors responsible are unclear. Studies differ with regard to age, graft type, surgical techniques, postoperative rehabilitation, RTS guidelines, and methods used to determine ACL failures.

OBJECTIVE

To determine RTS rates; the effect of participation in high-risk sports, sex, and graft type on ACL reinjury rates; and whether objective test criteria before RTS correlate with lower reinjury rates.

DATA SOURCES

A systematic review of the literature from inception to May 31, 2019, was conducted using the PubMed and Cochrane databases.

STUDY SELECTION

Studies on transphyseal ACLR in athletes <20 years old with a minimum mean follow-up of 2 years that reported reinjury rates, the number that RTS, and detailed the type of sport were included.

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 4.

RESULTS

A total of 1239 patients in 8 studies were included; 87% returned to sport and 80% resumed high-risk activities. Of the patients, 18% reinjured the ACL graft and/or the contralateral ACL. Nine percent of patellar tendon autografts and 15% of hamstring autografts failed (odds ratio [OR], 0.52; P = 0.002). Of reinjuries, 90% occurred during high-risk sports. Male patients had a significantly higher rate of ACL graft failure than female patients (OR, 1.64; P = 0.01). There was no sex-based effect on contralateral ACL injuries. Only 1 study cited objective criteria for RTS.

CONCLUSION

A high percentage of athletes returned to sport, but 1 in 5 suffered reinjuries to either knee. Male patients were more likely to reinjure the ACL graft. Objective criteria for RTS were rarely mentioned or not detailed. The need for testing of knee stability, strength, neuromuscular control, agility, and psychological measures before RTS remains paramount in young athletes.

Which criteria are used to clear patients to return to sport after primary ACL reconstruction? A scoping review

OBJECTIVE

To describe the criteria used to clear athletes to return to sport (RTS) following primary ACL reconstruction.

DESIGN

Scoping review.

DATA SOURCES

MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL and SPORTDiscus electronic databases were searched using keywords related to ACL and RTS.

ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA

Prospective or retrospective studies reporting at least one RTS criterion for athletes who had primary ACL reconstruction with an autograft.

RESULTS

In total, 209 studies fulfilled the inclusion criteria. RTS criteria were categorised into six domains: time, strength, hop testing, clinical examination, patient-report and performance-based criteria. From the 209 included studies, time was used in 178 studies (85%), and in 88 studies (42%) was the sole RTS criterion. Strength tests were reported in 86 studies (41%). Sixteen different hop tests were used in 31 studies (15%). Clinical examination was used in 54 studies (26%), patient report in 26 studies (12%) and performance-based criteria in 41 studies (20%).

SUMMARY

Time and impairment-based measures dominated RTS criteria, despite sport being a complex physical and biopsychosocial activity with demands across all aspects of function. Time was included as a criterion in 85% of studies, and over 80% of studies allowed RTS before 9 months. Whether RTS tests are valid-do they predict successful RTS?-is largely unknown.

Return to Play and Player Performance After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury in Elite Australian Rules Football Players

Background:

Australian Rules football is a highly aerobic and anaerobic game that at times requires players to perform cutting or pivoting maneuvers, potentially exposing them to anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury. At present, there are limited data available addressing the impact of ACL injury on return to play and preinjury form after ACL reconstruction.

Purpose:

To determine the prevalence of ACL injury and the incidence of further ACL injury, and to consider player return to play and return to preinjury form after ACL reconstruction. It was hypothesized that elite-level Australian Football League (AFL) players do not return to preinjury form until, at minimum, 2 years after returning to play.

Study Design:

Case series; Level of evidence, 4.

Methods:

A retrospective analysis was undertaken on a cohort of elite AFL players who injured their ACL between 1990 and 2000. Return to play after ACL reconstruction was determined by the mean number of ball disposals, or release of the ball by the hand or foot, at 1, 2, and 3 years after return to play and compared with preinjury form. Associations between player and injury characteristics, method of reconstruction, and outcomes (return to play, preinjury form, and further ACL injury) were examined.

Results:

During the included seasons, a total of 2723 AFL players were listed. Of these, 131 (4.8%) sustained an ACL injury, with 115 players eligible for inclusion. Of 115 players, 26% did not return to elite competition, while 28% of those who did return experienced further ACL injury. The adjusted mean number of disposals (± standard error of the mean) was significantly lower at 1 year (12.21 ± 0.63; P = .003), 2 years (12.09 ± 0.65; P = .008), and 3 years (11.78 ± 0.77; P = .01) after return to play compared with preinjury (14.23 ± 0.67). On average, players did not return to preinjury form by 3 years (P < .01). Players aged 30 years or older were less likely to return to play compared with younger players (P = .0002), moderate-weight players were more likely to return to play compared with lighter-weight players (P = .007), and there were significantly increased odds of not returning to play if the dominant side was injured (odds ratio, 0.10; 95% CI, 0.03-0.34; P = .0002).

Conclusion:

On average, AFL players do not return to their preinjury form after ACL injury and reconstruction, a common injury in this sporting population. This along with the high occurrence of reinjury highlights the career-threatening nature of ACL injury for elite AFL players.

Rehabilitation Principles of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstructed Knee: Twelve Steps for Successful Progression and Return to Play

The rehabilitation process begins immediately after injury to the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). The goal of preoperative rehabilitation is to prepare the patient for surgery. Current rehabilitation programs focus on strengthening exercises and proprioceptive and neuromuscular control drills to provide a neurologic stimulus. It is also important to address preexisting factors, especially for the female athlete, that may predispose to future injury, such as hip and hamstring weakness. Our goal in the rehabilitation program is to restore full, unrestricted function and to assist the patient to return to 100% of the preinjury level while achieving excellent long-term outcomes.

Stem cell therapy: a promising biological strategy for tendon-bone healing after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Tendon-bone healing after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is a complex process, impacting significantly on patients' prognosis. Natural tendon-bone healing usually results in fibrous scar tissue, which is of inferior quality compared to native attachment. In addition, the early formed fibrous attachment after surgery is often not reliable to support functional rehabilitation, which may lead to graft failure or unsatisfied function of the knee joint. Thus, strategies to promote tendon-bone healing are crucial for prompt and satisfactory functional recovery. Recently, a variety of biological approaches, including active substances, gene transfer, tissue engineering and stem cells, have been proposed and applied to enhance tendon-bone healing. Among these, stem cell therapy has been shown to have promising prospects and draws increasing attention. From commonly investigated bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (bMSCs) to emerging ACL-derived CD34+ stem cells, multiple stem cell types have been proven to be effective in accelerating tendon-bone healing. This review describes the current understanding of tendon-bone healing and summarizes the current status of related stem cell therapy. Future limitations and perspectives are also discussed.

Isokinetic Identification of Knee Joint Torques before and after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

The aim of this study was to evaluate the serial change of isokinetic muscle strength of the knees before and after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) in physically active males and to estimate the time of return to full physical fitness. Extension and flexion torques were measured for the injured and healthy limbs at two angular velocities approximately 1.5 months before the surgery and 3, 6, and 12 months after ACLR. Significant differences (p ≤ 0.05) in peak knee extension and flexion torques, hamstring/quadriceps (H/Q) strength ratios, uninvolved/involved limb peak torque ratios, and the normalized work of these muscles between the four stages of rehabilitation were identified. Significant differences between extension peak torques for the injured and healthy limbs were also detected at all stages. The obtained results showed that 12 months of rehabilitation were insufficient for the involved knee joint to recover its strength to the level of strength of the uninvolved knee joint. The results helped to evaluate the progress of the rehabilitation and to implement necessary modifications optimizing the rehabilitation training program. The results of the study may also be used as referential data for physically active males of similar age.

Relationship between quadriceps strength and patellofemoral joint chondral lesions after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

BACKGROUND

The incidence of the patellofemoral joint chondral lesions after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) is disturbingly high. Few studies have assessed the factors affecting patellofemoral joint chondral lesions postoperatively.

HYPOTHESIS

The recovery of quadriceps strength after ACLR could be associated with patellofemoral joint cartilage damage.

STUDY DESIGN

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.

METHODS

A total of 88 patients who underwent arthroscopic anatomic double-bundle ACLR with hamstring autografts received second-look arthroscopy at the time of metal staple removal at an average of 24.1 months (range, 12-51 months) postoperatively. All patients underwent standardized isokinetic strength testing for bilateral quadriceps and hamstrings 1 to 2 days before second-look arthroscopy. The patients were divided into 2 groups: Patients in group 1 had a ≥20% deficit on the peak torque measures for quadriceps compared with that of the contralateral knee, whereas those in group 2 had a <20% deficit on peak torque. Cartilage status at the patellofemoral joint and tibiofemoral joint were evaluated by second-look arthroscopy and the Outerbridge classification. Other assessments included the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) score, Tegner and Lysholm scores, side-to-side difference on KT-2000 arthrometer, and range of motion.

RESULTS

There were 42 patients included in group 1 and 46 patients in group 2. The mean postoperative quadriceps peak torque of the involved knee compared with the contralateral knee was 70% (range, 57%-80%) in group 1 and 95% (range, 81%-116%) in group 2. For all patients, a significant worsening was seen in the patellar and trochlear cartilage (P = .030 and <.001, respectively) but not at the medial or lateral tibiofemoral joint after ACLR. A significant worsening in the status of both patellar and trochlear cartilage was seen after ACLR in group 1 (P = .013 and =.011, respectively) and of trochlear cartilage in group 2 (P = .006). Significantly fewer severe chondral lesions of the patella were found in group 2 than in group 1 (proportion of patients whose cartilage grade worsened: 26% vs 48%, P < .05; difference in cartilage grade: 0.09 vs 0.62, P < .05). There was no significant difference for trochlear chondral worsening between the 2 groups. No significant differences were detected between the 2 groups in terms of hamstring strength; Lysholm, Tegner, and IKDC scores; KT-2000 arthrometer anterior laxity; or range of motion.

CONCLUSION

Greater than 80% recovery of quadriceps strength after ACLR is associated with less severe patellar cartilage damage at short-term follow-up.

Synthetic devices for reconstructive surgery of the cruciate ligaments: a systematic review

PURPOSE

The role of synthetic devices in the management of the cruciate ligament-injured knee remains controversial. The aim of this systematic review was to assess the safety and efficacy of synthetic devices in cruciate ligament surgery.

METHODS

A systematic review of the electronic databases Medline, Embase, and The Cochrane Library (issue 1, 2014) on January 13, 2014, was performed to identify controlled and uncontrolled trials. Trials that assessed the safety and efficacy of synthetic devices for cruciate ligament surgery were included. The main variables assessed included rates of failure, revision, and noninfective effusion and synovitis. Patient-reported outcome assessments and complications were also assessed where reported.

RESULTS

From 511 records screened, we included 85 articles published between 1985 and 2013 reporting on 6 synthetic devices (ligament augmentation and reconstruction system [Ligament Augmentation and Reconstruction System (LARS; Surgical Implants and Devices, Arc-sur-Tille, France)]; Leeds-Keio [Xiros (formerly Neoligaments), Leeds, England]; Kennedy ligament augmentation device [3M, St Paul, MN]; Dacron [Stryker, Kalamazoo, MI]; Gore-Tex [W.L. Gore and Associates, Flagstaff, AZ]; and Trevira [Telos (limited liability company), Marburg, Germany]). The heterogeneity of the included studies precluded meta-analysis. The results were analyzed by device and then type of reconstruction (anterior cruciate ligament [ACL]/posterior cruciate ligament [PCL]/combined ACL and PCL). The lowest cumulative rates of failure were seen with the LARS device (2.6% for ACL and 1% for PCL surgery). The highest failure rate was seen in the Dacron ACL group (cumulative rate, 33.6%). Rates of noninfective synovitis and effusion ranged from 0.2% in the LARS ACL group to 27.6% in the Gore-Tex ACL group. Revision rates ranged from 2.6% (LARS) to 11.8% (Trevira-Hochfest; Telos). Recent designs, specifically the LARS, showed good improvement in the outcome scores. The mean preoperative and postoperative Lysholm knee scores were 54 and 88, respectively; the mean preoperative and postoperative Tegner activity scale scores were 3.3 and 6, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Preliminary results for newer-generation devices, specifically the LARS, show lower reported rates of failure, revision, and sterile effusion/synovitis when compared with older devices.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, systematic review of Level II through IV studies.

Return to sport following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Rates of return to pre-injury sport following anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction are less than might be expected from standard outcome measures and there appears to be a rapid decline in sporting participation after two to three years. There are many factors that influence whether an individual will return to sport following this type of surgery. They include not only surgical details and rehabilitation, but also social and psychological factors, as well as demographic characteristics. Age is of particular importance with older patients being less likely to resume their pre-injury sport. It is important that future research clearly identify the pre-injury characteristics of the study cohort when investigating return to sport, and also that there is consistent and precise terminology used to report rates of return to sporting activities. Little is known about how to determine when it is safe to return to sport following ACL reconstruction or how to predict whether an athlete will be able to successfully return to sport. Finally, it needs to be recognised that return to sport following ACL reconstruction is associated with a risk of further injury and the development of osteoarthritis.

Rate of force development as an adjunctive outcome measure for return-to-sport decisions after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

STUDY DESIGN

Descriptive, prospective, longitudinal single-cohort study.

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the rate of force development to 30% (RFD(30)), 50% (RFD(50)), and 90% (RFD(90)) of maximal voluntary isometric contraction (MVIC) as an adjunct outcome measure for determining readiness for return to sport following an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction.

BACKGROUND

One criterion of full recovery following an ACL reconstruction is the ability to achieve 85% or 90% of the maximal strength of the contralateral limb. However, the time required to develop muscular strength in many types of daily and sports activities is considerably shorter than that required to achieve maximal strength. Therefore, in addition to maximal strength, neuromuscular functions such as RFD should also be considered in the definition of recovery.

METHODS

Forty-five male professional soccer players who underwent an ACL reconstruction were recruited. Assessment with the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) Subjective Knee Evaluation Form, Tegner score, and KT1000 instrumented arthrometer was performed postinjury/prereconstruction and at 6 and 12 months after ACL reconstruction. MVIC, RFD(30), RFD(50), and RFD(90) testing was performed preinjury, as part of standard preseason assessment, and at 6 and 12 months post-ACL reconstruction.

RESULTS

The average MVIC value 6 months postreconstruction was 97% of the preinjury average value. In contrast, at 6 months, the RFD(30), RFD(50), and RFD(90) values were 80% (P = .04), 77% (P = .03), and 63% (P = .007), respectively, of the preinjury values. The mean RFD values for the reconstructed knee attained or exceeded 90% of the preinjury mean values only at the 12-month post-ACL reconstruction assessment (RFD(30), P = .86; RFD(50), P = .51; RFD(90), P = .56).

CONCLUSION

Despite the near recovery of MVIC strength to preinjury levels, there were still significant deficits in RFD at 6 months post-ACL reconstruction. An RFD similar to the preinjury RFD was achieved at 12 months post-ACL reconstruction, following a rehabilitation program focusing on muscle power. These results suggest that, following an ACL reconstruction, RFD criteria may be a useful adjunct outcome measure for the decision to return athletes to sports. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2012;42(9):772-780, Epub 19 July 2012. doi:10.2519/jospt.2012.3780.

Recent advances in the rehabilitation of anterior cruciate ligament injuries

Rehabilitation following anterior cruciate ligament surgery continues to change, with the current emphasis being on immediate weight bearing and range of motion, and progressive muscular strengthening, proprioception, dynamic stability, and neuromuscular control drills. The rehabilitation program should be based on scientific and clinical research and focus on specific drills and exercises designed to return the patient to the desired functional goals. The goal is to return the patient's knee to homeostasis and the patient to his or her sport or activity as safely as possible. Unique rehabilitation techniques and special considerations for the female athlete will also be discussed. The purpose of this article is to provide the reader with a thorough scientific basis for anterior cruciate ligament rehabilitation based on graft selection, patient population, and concomitant injuries.

Accelerated versus nonaccelerated rehabilitation after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a prospective, randomized, double-blind investigation evaluating knee joint laxity using roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis

BACKGROUND

The relationship between the biomechanical dose of rehabilitation exercises administered after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction and the healing response of the graft and knee is not well understood.

HYPOTHESIS

After ACL reconstruction, rehabilitation administered with either accelerated or nonaccelerated programs produces the same change in the knees' 6 degrees of freedom, or envelope, laxity values.

STUDY DESIGN

Randomized controlled trial; Level of evidence, 1.

METHODS

Patients who underwent ACL reconstruction with a bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft were randomized to rehabilitation with either accelerated (19 week) or nonaccelerated (32 week) programs. At the time of surgery, and then 3, 6, 12, and 24 months later, the 6 degrees of freedom knee laxity values were measured using roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis and clinical, functional, and patient-oriented outcome measures.

RESULTS

Eighty-five percent of those enrolled were followed through 2 years. Laxity of the reconstructed knee was restored to within the limits of the contralateral, normal side at the time of surgery (baseline) in all participants. Patients in both programs underwent a similar increase in the envelope of knee laxity over the 2-year follow-up interval (anterior-posterior translation 3.2 vs 4.5 mm, and coupled internal-external rotations 2.6° vs 1.9° for participants in the accelerated and nonaccelerated programs, respectively). Those who underwent accelerated rehabilitation experienced a significant improvement in thigh muscle strength at the 3-month follow-up (P < .05) compared with those who participated in nonaccelerated rehabilitation, but no differences between the programs were seen after this time interval. At the 2-year follow-up, the groups were similar in terms of clinical assessment, patient satisfaction, function, proprioception, and isokinetic thigh muscle strength.

CONCLUSION

Rehabilitation with the accelerated and nonaccelerated programs administered in this study produced the same increase in the envelope of knee laxity. A majority of the increase in the envelope of knee laxity occurred during healing when exercises were advanced and activity level increased. Patients in both programs had the same clinical assessment, functional performance, proprioception, and thigh muscle strength, which returned to normal levels after healing was complete. For participants in both treatment programs, the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) assessment of quality of life did not return to preinjury levels.

Change in posture control after recent knee anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction?

The aim of this study was to compare statical postures of a knee anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) population with a healthy control population. Thirty-five patients (age 25.5 +/- 5.8 years) were compared at 15 days after an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with 35 healthy, age and sex-matched subjects. Bilateral and unilateral postures were studied according to various stances, knee extension and 20 degrees knee flexion with opened and closed eyes, using a stabilometric platform. A comparison with the non-ACLR limb and the healthy limbs of the control population was carried out. The ACLR subjects present with the following: (i) a significant change in two-legged stance, i.e. distances covered by the centre of pressure projection are significantly increased; (ii) a postural alteration during the ACLR one-legged stance with knee extension and opened eyes in comparison with the non-ACLR limb; (iii) an incapacity for certain ACLR subjects to perform one-legged stance on the non-ACLR limb when there is no visual compensation. Only 11.4% (95% CI: 0.9-21.9%) and 42.8% (95% CI: 26.3-59.3%) of ACLR subjects are capable of maintaining correctly a one-legged stance posture with closed eyes on both sides (knee extension and flexion, respectively). The identification of the ACLR knee limb is possible from the one-legged stance postural test in knee extension and opened eyes condition. Because of a change in two-legged balance and of the incapacity for certain ACLR subjects to maintain one-legged stance with closed eyes, a central origin explaining the abnormalities of postural control is suggested.

Effects of running retraining after knee anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to analyze the effect of running retraining on the recovery of the knee's functional and muscular properties after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction.

METHODS

Eighty-five athletes who had undergone ACL reconstruction surgery were selected randomly to receive, or not to receive, controlled running training based on interval training and speed exercises. The effect of retraining was measured by the evolution of the knee's isokinetic strength deficit and progress (at angular speeds of 60 and 180 degrees /s), the knee laxity parameters and the score on the Lysholm Knee Scale from the 4th to the 6th month after the surgery. Forty subjects were retrained and compared with 40 control-group subjects. The effect of the retraining program was studied in terms of the type of ACL reconstruction and the effect of time.

RESULTS

After retraining, no difference was found for isokinetic knee strength deficit and progress, knee laxity and Lysholm Knee Score. The isokinetic strength deficit was influenced mainly by the type of ACL reconstruction.

CONCLUSION

It would seem that running retraining has an insufficient effect on the muscular and functional recovery after ACL reconstruction, despite the fact that this type of training is well-tolerated.

Dynamic restraint capacity of the hamstring muscles has important functional implications after anterior cruciate ligament injury and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to investigate the relation between knee functionality of anterior cruciate ligament deficient (ACLD) and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) patients and hamstring antagonist torque generated during resisted knee extension.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional.

SETTING

Laboratory based.

PARTICIPANTS

Male ACLD subjects (n=10) (18-35 y) and 27 matched males who had undergone ACLR (14 patella tendon [PT] grafts and 13 combined semitendinosus/gracilis tendon grafts).

INTERVENTIONS

Not applicable.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Knee functionality was rated (0- to 100-point scale) by using the Cincinnati Knee Rating System. Using electromyography data from the semitendinosus (ST) and biceps femoris muscles, we created a mathematical model to estimate the opposing torque generated by the hamstrings during isokinetic knee extension in 10 degrees intervals from 80 degrees to 10 degrees knee flexion.

RESULTS

Pearson product-moment correlations revealed that more functional ACLD subjects generated significantly (P<.05) higher hamstring antagonist torque throughout knee extension. In contrast, more functional PT subjects produced significantly lower hamstring antagonist torque at 80 degrees to 70 degrees knee flexion, whereas no significant associations were found between hamstring antagonist torque and knee functionality for the ST/gracilis tendon subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

An increased hamstring antagonist torque generated by the more functional ACLD subjects, reflective of increased hamstring contractile force, is thought to represent a protective mechanism to compensate for mechanical instability. The restoration of anterior knee stability through ACLR negates the need for augmented hamstring antagonist torque.

[Return to pivot-contact sports after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: patellar tendon or hamstring autografts]

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY

The purpose of this study was to compare outcome at 12 months and return of pivot-contact sports in male subjects having undergone anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using a patellar tendon or four-strand hamstring autografts.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Sixty male athletes underwent arthroscopic ligament reconstruction using either a patellar graft or a hamstring graft. The two groups were comparable for age (25+/-6 years), height (177+/-5cm), weight (74+/-8kg), pivot-contact sports, and level of sports activity. The two groups were reviewed at four, six and 12 months. The Lysholm and Tegner scores were noted and isokinetic tests were performed (60 and 180 degrees /s). The comparison was completed at twelve months with the single-legged hop test, instrumental laximetry (KT-1000) and the Arpege and IKDC 2000 scores. Return to pivot-contact sports at the same level was assessed at last follow-up after having been encouraged at the nine-month check-up.

RESULTS

At twelve months, the function scores (IKDC 2000, Lysholm: 99.4+/-5 versus 98+/-5, Tegner: 6.8+/-1 versus 6.5+/-1) and single-legged hop test (94+/-5% versus 95+/-7%) were comparable. Instrumental laxity measurements however demonstrated greater laxity with the hamstring graft (2.7+/-0.4mm versus 1.8+/-0.3mm, p=0.02). A knee extension deficit was observed for the patellar technique (10+/-8%, p<0.01). A knee flexion deficit was observed for the hamstring technique (11+/-14%, p<0.01). Return to pivot-contact sports at the same level was comparable and concerned 53% [95%CI 41-66] of the knees after hamstring ligament reconstruction and 56.6% [44-68] of the knees after patellar ligamentoplasty.

CONCLUSION

The two techniques of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction were found to be equivalent in terms of return to pivot-contact sports at the same level. It was noted however that this resumed sports activity was possible for only one out of two subjects despite the systematic medical and surgical surveillance and selection of subjects free of any complication.

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with quadrupled semitendinosus tendon - minimum 6 year clinical and radiological follow-up

This clinical study evaluates the minimum 6 year follow-up clinical, functional, radiological and isometric results after arthroscopic reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) with quadrupled semitendinosus tendon autograft (femoral endobutton and tibial suture disc fixation). Seventy out of 85 operated patients (lost to follow-up 17%) with an average age of 34.3 years could be clinically examined at a mean follow-up time of 6 years and 4 months after surgery. Results revealed a high subjective satisfaction rate of 93%. The preoperative activity level could be maintained in 71% of the patients. The Lysholm score showed very good and good results in 85% with a mean of 83.6%. Normal or nearly normal results on the IKDC score were reported in 85% of the patients. The KT-1000 arthrometer stability testing showed a difference of less than 3 mm compared to the contralateral knee in 75% of the patients. Five patients (7%) had a graft failure during follow-up time. There were no or only mild degenerative changes at the radiographic evaluation in 85% of the patients. In 15% of the patients a femoral and in 40% a tibial tunnel widening of more than 50% was observed, however without a relevance for the clinical and functional status. Midterm results obtained in this study after arthroscopic ACL reconstruction with the quadrupled semitendinosus tendon confirm the outcomes in the literature after shorter follow-up periods that provide very good and good subjective, functional and stability results in about 80-85% of the patients. This surgical technique can be recommended for the active patient with ACL deficiency. However, patients must be informed that activity level cannot always be maintained and a failure rate of 5-10% must be taken into account in the longer term when decision for surgery is made.

Contralateral limb strength deficits after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using a hamstring tendon graft

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to determine whether current post-operative rehabilitation protocols return the strength of the contralateral uninjured limb knee flexors and extensors after an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction to those of an uninjured control group.

METHODS

Subjects with a hamstring tendon ACL reconstruction (n=12) were compared to an active control group (n=30). Comprehensive bilateral knee flexor and extensor isovelocity strength testing was performed (five speeds, 5-95 degrees , concentric and eccentric contractions).

FINDINGS

After hamstring tendon ACL reconstruction and rehabilitation, bilateral strength normalization (within 10% of the contralateral limb) is achieved by the knee extensors but not the knee flexors. When compared to the uninjured control group, large and statistically significant strength deficits were demonstrated in the knee extensors and knee flexors of both the anterior cruciate ligament reconstructed (extensors 24.8%; flexors 26.8%) and the contralateral uninjured (extensors 21%; flexors 13.5%) limbs.

INTERPRETATION

These findings suggest that improvement can be made in knee flexor rehabilitation after ACL reconstruction and limit the validity of the use of a contralateral leg as a rehabilitation endpoint or as a control in the ACL reconstructed population.

A test battery for evaluating hop performance in patients with an ACL injury and patients who have undergone ACL reconstruction

The purpose of this study was to develop a test battery of hop tests with high ability to discriminate (i.e. high test-retest reliability, sensitivity, specificity and accuracy) between the hop performance of the injured and the uninjured side in patients with an ACL injury and in patients who have undergone ACL reconstruction. Five hop tests were analysed: three maximum single hop tests and two hop tests while developing fatigue. Fifteen healthy subjects performed the five hop tests on three separate occasions in a test-retest design. Thirty patients, mean 11 months after an ACL injury and 35 patients, mean 6 months after ACL reconstruction were tested. ICC values ranged from 0.85 to 0.97 for the five hop tests, indicating that all the tests had high test-retest reliability. Sixty-seven percent to 100% of the healthy subjects had normal symmetry (i.e. <10% side-to-side difference) in the five hop tests. Abnormal symmetry in the five hop tests ranged from 43 to 77% for patients with an ACL injury and from 51 to 86% for patients who had undergone ACL reconstruction respectively. The three tests with the highest ability to discriminate hop performance were chosen for the test battery; they were the vertical jump, the hop for distance and the side hop. The test battery revealed a high level of sensitivity and accuracy in patients with an ACL injury (87 and 84%) and in patients who had undergone ACL reconstruction (91 and 88%), when at least one of the three tests was classified as abnormal. To summarise, the test battery consisting of both maximum single hop performances: the vertical jump and the hop for distance and hop performance while developing fatigue: the side hop, produced high test-retest reliability, sensitivity and accuracy. Further, the test battery produced higher values compared with any of the three hop tests individually revealing that only one out of ten patients had restored hop performance 11 months after an ACL injury and 6 months after ACL reconstruction. It is concluded that this test battery showed a high ability to discriminate between the hop performance of the injured and the uninjured side both in patients with an ACL injury and in patients who have undergone ACL reconstruction.

Development of a strength test battery for evaluating leg muscle power after anterior cruciate ligament injury and reconstruction

A more sports-specific and detailed strength assessment has been advocated for patients after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury and reconstruction. The purpose of this study was to develop a test battery of lower extremity strength tests with high ability to discriminate between leg power development on the injured and uninjured sides in patients after ACL injury and in patients who have undergone ACL reconstruction. Twenty-three patients were tested 6 months after ACL injury and 44 patients were tested 6 months after ACL reconstruction. Twenty-four of the 44 patients were operated on using a hamstrings graft and 20 patients were operated on using a patellar tendon graft. All the patients performed a test battery of three strength tests for each leg in a randomised order. The three strength tests were chosen to reflect quadriceps and hamstring muscular power in a knee-extension and a knee-flexion test (open kinetic chain) and lower-extremity muscular power in a leg-press test (closed kinetic chain). There was a higher sensitivity for the test battery to discriminate abnormal leg power compared with any of the three strength tests individually. Nine out of ten patients after ACL reconstruction and six out of ten of the patients after ACL injury exhibited abnormal leg power symmetry using the test battery. Thus, this test battery had high ability in terms of discriminating between the leg power performance on the injured and uninjured side, both in patients with an ACL injury and in patients who have undergone ACL reconstruction. It is concluded that a test battery consisting of a knee-extension, knee-flexion and leg-press muscle power test had high ability to determine deficits in leg power 6 months after ACL injury and reconstruction. Only a minority of the patients had restored leg muscle power. The clinical relevance is that the test battery may contribute to the decision-making process when deciding whether and when patients can safely return to strenuous physical activities after an ACL injury or reconstruction.

Réentraînement à l'effort entre le quatrième et le sixième mois après ligamentoplastie de genou au DIDT : comparaison de la pratique de la bicyclette et de la pratique du footing avec un groupe témoin non réentraîné

OBJECTIVE

To study the effect of cycling or running retraining between 4 and 6 months after patients underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with hamstring grafting (Semitendinosus-Gracilis) compared with that in patients who had the same surgery but were untrained.

METHOD

Patients who had undergone surgery for an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction by the same surgeon who used hamstring grafting were included if they were free of knee pain 4 months after the surgery. After giving consent, patients were randomized to receive controlled retraining (cycling or running 3 times a week) or not. The effect of retraining was measured by the evolution of the knee isokinetic peak torque at 60 degrees/s and 180 degrees/s 6 months after surgery.

RESULTS

Fifteen patients were retrained with cycling (GI), 17 with running (GII) and 15 patients did not retrain (GIII). Before retraining, the 3 groups had the same peak torque deficit, measured at an angular speed of 60 degrees/s and 180 degrees/s, for knee extensors (GI: 33+/-11% and 27+/-8%; GII: 30+/-13% and 24+/-10%; GIII: 31+/-15% and 24+/-13%, respectively) and knee flexors (GI: 26+/-11% and 20+/-13%; GII: 20+/-14% and 17+/-13%; GIII: 19+/-15% and 14+/-15%, respectively). After retraining, progress measured at 60 degrees /s of knee extensors and flexors on the operated knees was 18+/-9% and 16+/-10% for GI, 16+/-9% and 11+/-11% for GII and 12+/-15% and 8+/-12 for GIII, respectively. Progress measured at 180 degrees /s followed the same evolution. After comparison of the 3 groups, any significant difference was put in relief according to the type of retraining.

CONCLUSION

Retraining after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction is necessary for patients to practice their previous sport. In our study, aerobic cycling or running between 4 and 6 months after surgery did not improve peak torque in the operated knee extensors and flexors. However, these 2 types of retraining are well-tolerated.

Factors associated with decreased muscle strength after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with hamstring tendon grafts

PURPOSE

To identify factors associated with decreased muscle strength and activity after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction with semitendinosus-gracilis tendon (ST-G) grafts.

TYPE OF STUDY

Retrospective review.

METHODS

Eighty-five patients who underwent ACL reconstruction with ST-G grafts were evaluated at a mean of 44.4 months after surgery. Patients underwent isokinetic testing, physical examination, radiographs, instrumented laxity testing, and Lysholm, Cincinnati, and International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) ratings. Cartilage and meniscal pathology at surgery was reviewed. Strength group 1 (n = 30) showed greater than 20% deficits in strength; strength group 2 (n = 55) had less than 20% strength deficits. Activity group 1 (n = 60) maintained their IKDC activity level at final follow-up relative to preinjury level; activity group 2 (n = 25) decreased activity by 1 or more levels.

RESULTS

With all patients combined, there was less than a 4% difference in mean hamstring and quadriceps strength between the reconstructed and contralateral legs at follow-up. Knee flexion deficits were associated with decreased hamstring strength. Subjective giving way and squatting/kneeling discomfort were associated with decreased quadriceps strength. Patients in strength group 1 were more likely to have squatting/kneeling discomfort and lower Cincinnati Function scores. Activity group 2 had a longer interval from injury to surgery and more chondromalacia at surgery. At follow-up, activity group 2 had lower subjective scores and was more likely to have pain, swelling, giving way, and flexion deficits. Activity group 2 also had greater deficits in quadriceps strength.

CONCLUSIONS

Articular cartilage injury and meniscal pathology were not associated with decreased muscle strength. ACL reconstruction with ST-G grafts has a 38% incidence of squatting/kneeling pain that occurs secondary to patellofemoral crepitus, harvest site symptoms, and tibial hardware sensitivity.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, therapeutic, case series, no control group.

[Differences in the rehabilitation period following two methods of anterior cruciate ligament replacement: semitendinosus/gracilis tendon vs ligamentum patellae]

In this study we have analyzed outcome during the early rehabilitation period phase following two different methods of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction: ligamentum patellae (LP) and semitendonosus/gracilis tendon (SG) based reconstruction. This study included 40 patients treated by each method, examined 6 weeks and 3, 6 and 12 months after surgery. Patients in the SG group showed significantly better Lysholm scores at 6 and 12 months, Tegner Activity Scale scores at 3 months, and pain profile assessments at 6 weeks and 3 months than those in the LP group. Significant differences were observed in LP group in range-of-motion at 6 weeks and 3 and 6 months post-surgery. Stability tests revealed no significant differences between patients in the two groups. SG-based reconstruction of the ACL thus demonstrated advantages over LP-based reconstruction regarding pain and function, while LP-based reconstruction was associated with an earlier return of motion.

Rehabilitation after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a prospective, randomized, double-blind comparison of programs administered over 2 different time intervals

BACKGROUND

There are adverse effects associated with immobilization of the knee after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, yet very little is known about how much activity will promote adequate rehabilitation without permanently elongating the graft, producing graft failure, or creating damage to articular cartilage.

HYPOTHESIS

Rehabilitation with either an accelerated or nonaccelerated program produces no difference in anterior-posterior knee laxity, clinical assessment, patient satisfaction, functional performance, and the synovial fluid biomarkers of articular cartilage metabolism.

STUDY DESIGN

Randomized controlled clinical trial; Level of evidence, 1.

METHODS

Twenty-five patients who tore their anterior cruciate ligament were enrolled and underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Patients were randomized to accelerated rehabilitation or nonaccelerated rehabilitation. At the time of surgery and 3, 6, 12, and 24 months later, measurements of anterior-posterior knee laxity, clinical assessment, patient satisfaction, functional performance, and cartilage metabolism were completed.

RESULTS

At the 2-year follow-up, there was no difference in the increase of anterior knee laxity relative to the baseline values that were obtained immediately after surgery between the 2 groups (2.2-mm vs 1.8-mm increase relative to the normal knee). The groups were similar in terms of clinical assessment, patient satisfaction, activity level, function, and response of the bio-markers. After 1 year of healing, synthesis of collagen and turnover of aggrecan remained elevated in both groups.

CONCLUSION

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with a bone-patellar tendon-bone graft followed by either accelerated or nonaccelerated rehabilitation produces the same increase of anterior knee laxity. Both programs had the same effect in terms of clinical assessment, patient satisfaction, functional performance, and the biomarkers of articular cartilage metabolism. There is concern that the cartilage biomarkers remained elevated for an extended period.

Return to official Italian First Division soccer games within 90 days after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a case report

STUDY DESIGN

Case report.

BACKGROUND

To present the rehabilitative course, decision-making, and clinical milestones that allowed a top-level professional soccer player to return to full competitive activity 90 days after surgery.

CASE DESCRIPTION

The patient was a 35-year-old forward player who sustained an isolated complete tear of the left anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) in the midst of the competitive 2001-2002 season. He was in contention for a position on the Italian World Cup Team that was to be played 135 days after his injury, only if he demonstrated that he could return to play at the highest level before the team was selected. The patient underwent an arthroscopically assisted ACL reconstruction with a double-loop semitendinosus-gracilis autograft 4 days after the injury. Eight days after surgery he began rehabilitation at a rate of 2 sessions a day, 5 days a week, plus 1 session every Saturday morning. These sessions were performed in a pool for aquatic exercises, in a gymnasium for flexibility, coordination, and strength exercises, and on a soccer field for recovery of technical and tactical skills, with continuous monitoring of training intensity.

OUTCOMES

The surgical technique and the progressive rehabilitation program allowed the patient to play for 20 minutes in an official First Division soccer game 77 days after surgery and to play a full game 90 days after surgery. Eighteen months postsurgery, the player had participated in 62 First Division matches, scoring 26 times, and had received no further treatment for his knee.

DISCUSSION

This case report suggests that early return to high-level competition after ACL reconstruction is possible in some instances. Some factors that may have favored the early return include optimal physical fitness before surgery, a strong psychological determination, an isolated ACL lesion, a properly placed and tensioned graft, a personalized progression of volume and intensity of exercise loads, and an appropriate density of rehabilitative training consisting of a mix of gymnasium, pool, and field exercises.

Hamstring and quadriceps strength balance in normal and hamstring anterior cruciate ligament-reconstructed subjects

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate and characterize the agonist-antagonist strength balance (hamstring/quadriceps [H/Q] ratio and dynamic control ratio [DCR]) about the knee specific to velocity, range of motion, and contraction type. We hypothesized that there would be systematic variation in the H/Q ratio and DCR based on knee joint angle, angular velocity, and contraction type. We also hypothesized that these ratios would be altered in the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL)-reconstructed group in favor of protecting the ACL graft (relative knee flexor strength when strain on the ACL is the greatest).

DESIGN

Cross-sectional design.

SETTING

A tertiary care sport medicine clinic.

PATIENTS OR PARTICIPANTS

Sixteen subjects more than 1 year after hamstring tendon ACL reconstruction were compared with 30 active uninjured control subjects.

INTERVENTIONS

Isokinetic strength testing was performed over 5 degrees to 95 degrees knee joint range of motion, 5 angular velocities (50, 100, 150, 200, 250 degrees/s), for concentric and eccentric contractions.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

Angle and velocity-matched H/Q ratio maps and DCR maps were produced for each group. Difference maps allowed quantification of the differences between the groups.

RESULTS

Angle and velocity-matched H/Q ratio maps demonstrated systematic variation based on joint angle, velocity, and contraction type for both the control (H/Q, approximately 0-1.42; DCR, approximately 0-1.57) and the ACL-reconstructed group (H/Q, approximately 0-1.33; DCR, approximately 0-1.35). Difference maps demonstrate regional (angle and velocity-specific) alteration in the ratio between the ACL-reconstructed and control groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Specific imbalances were demonstrated in the ACL-reconstructed group compared with control. In high knee flexion angles, the low H/Q ratio may represent a compromised ability of the hamstrings to stabilize the knee joint throughout the full range of motion. Near full knee extension shifts in favor of the knee flexors may represent an attempt to stabilize the knee at the angle of greatest ACL strain. These finding have implications for graft donor site selection and postoperative rehabilitation as well as provide insight into the neuromuscular control of the knee.

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with a four-strand hamstring tendon autograft

BACKGROUND

In this study, we analyzed the clinical outcomes at a minimum of two years following reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament with use of a four-strand hamstring tendon autograft in patients who had presented with a symptomatic torn anterior cruciate ligament.

METHODS

One hundred and twenty-two consecutive patients who had an isolated, symptomatic anterior tibial subluxation associated with rupture of the anterior cruciate ligament were treated with reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament with a four-strand autologous semitendinosus-gracilis tendon graft. One surgeon performed all of the operations. Prior to surgery and at the follow-up examination, physical findings and functional scores were recorded and knee radiographs were analyzed. Following surgery, a six-month rehabilitation regimen was implemented.

RESULTS

Eighty-five patients (70%) were available for follow-up, which included physical examination, scoring of function, KT-1000 arthrometric testing, and radiographs, at a mean of twenty-eight months. Seventy-six (89%) of the patients had negative Lachman and pivot shift tests. The mean Lysholm score improved from 55 points preoperatively to 91 points at the time of follow-up (p < 0.01). The mean Tegner score improved from 5 to 6 points (p < 0.01). Sixty-five patients had <3 mm of knee translation on arthrometric testing, but six patients with marked laxity were not tested. Three patients (4%) had a positive pivot shift test but had no history of additional trauma to the knee. Six patients (7%) had a traumatic rupture of the graft, occurring at a mean of 10.7 months postoperatively. Assessment of the follow-up radiographs demonstrated no evidence of progressive degenerative change compared with the appearance on the preoperative radiographs. However, tunnel expansion was noted in all patients. The tibial tunnel expanded a mean of 17% (range, 0% to 32%), and the femoral tunnel expanded a mean of 29% (range, 0% to 40%).

CONCLUSIONS

Reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament with use of a four-strand hamstring tendon autograft eliminated anterior tibial subluxation in 89% of patients who were examined at a minimum of two years postoperatively. The overall rate of failure was 11%. The functional knee scores were significantly increased at the time of follow-up, but these results did not correlate with the results of knee arthrometric testing.

Recent advances in the rehabilitation of isolated and combined anterior cruciate ligament injuries

The rehabilitation process begins immediately following ACL injury, with emphasis on reducing swelling and inflammation; improving motion; regaining quadriceps control; allowing immediate weight-bearing; and restoring full passive knee extension and, gradually, flexion. The goal of preoperative rehabilitation is to prepare the patient mentally and physically for surgery. Once the ACL surgery is performed, it is important to alter the rehab program based on the type of graft used and any concomitant procedures performed. This will aid in preventing several postoperative complications, such as loss of motion, patellofemoral pain, graft failure, and muscular weakness. The goal of this article has been to provide an overview of the application and the scientific basis for formulating a rehabilitation protocol following ACL surgery. For an athlete to return to competition, it is imperative that he or she regain muscular strength and neuromuscular control in their injured leg while maintaining static stability. In the past, rehabilitation programs attempted to prepare the athlete for return to sports by using resistance exercise alone. Current rehabilitation programs focus not only on strengthening exercises, but also on proprioceptive and neuromuscular control drills in order to provide a neurologic stimulus so that the athlete can regain the dynamic stability needed in athletic competition. We believe that it is important to use this approach not only possible causes that might predispose the individual to future injury.

The effect of soft-tissue graft fixation in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction on graft-tunnel motion under anterior tibial loading

PURPOSE

To compare the motion of an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) replacement graft within the femoral bone tunnel (graft- tunnel motion) when a soft-tissue graft is secured either by a titanium button and polyester tape (EndoButton fixation; Acufex, Smith & Nephew, Mansfield, MA) or by a biodegradable interference screw (Biointerference fixation; Endo-fix; Acufex, Smith & Nephew) An additional purpose was to evaluate the effect of the graft-tunnel motion on the kinematics of ACL-reconstructed knees and in situ force of the ACL replacement graft.

TYPE OF STUDY

Biomechanical experiment using an in vitro animal model.

METHODS

ACL reconstruction with a flexor tendon autograft was performed in 8 cadaveric knees of skeletally mature goats. The knee kinematics and the in situ force in the ACL replacement graft in response to anterior tibial loads were evaluated using the robotic/universal force-moment sensor testing system. The longitudinal and transverse graft-tunnel motion during anterior tibial loading was determined based on radiographic measurements parallel and perpendicular to the femoral bone tunnel, respectively.

RESULTS

In response to an anterior tibial load of 100 N, the longitudinal graft-tunnel motion for EndoButton fixation and Biointerference fixation was 0.8 +/- 0.4 mm and 0.2 +/- 0.1 mm, respectively (P <.05), whereas the transverse graft-tunnel motion was 0.5 +/- 0.2 mm and 0.1 +/- 0.1 mm, respectively (P <.05). Furthermore, the anterior tibial translation for EndoButton fixation (5.3 +/- 1.2 mm) was also significantly larger than that for Biointerference fixation (4.2 +/- 0.9 mm) (P <.05). With both fixations, however, no significant difference between the in situ forces in the ACL replacement graft and that in the intact ACL could be detected.

CONCLUSIONS

EndoButton fixation of a soft-tissue graft via an elastic material resulted in significantly larger graft-tunnel motion, and consequently, greater anterior knee laxity compared with more rigid fixation using an interference screw closer to the intra-articular entrance of the bone tunnel. In terms of force distribution, the ACL replacement graft in both fixations still functioned as a primary restraint to an anterior tibial load close to the intact ACL.

Current Australian trends in rehabilitation following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

This study documented the current approaches to rehabilitation following anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction by Australian orthopaedic surgeons. A two-page questionnaire was mailed to the 40 members of the Australian Knee Society to obtain information regarding (1) pre-operative requirements; (2) immediate post-operative requirements; and (3) the timing of the introduction of rehabilitation phases and return to sport following ACL reconstruction. The response rate of practising surgeons was 95%. Twenty-two surgeons (61%) regularly performed both hamstring tendon (HS) and patellar tendon (PT) ACL reconstruction. Eighty-three percent had a standard rehabilitation protocol, and of these, 23% had separate protocols for the two graft types. There were no significant differences between the responses for the two graft types for any question. Approximately three-quarters of surgeons (HS: 75%, PT: 78%) had specific pre-operative requirements. Most surgeons (HS: 96%, PT: 93%) had specific post-operative requirements. Physiotherapy was routinely used by 96% and 93% of surgeons for HS and PT grafts, respectively, commencing at a mean of 2 weeks post-operatively for HS grafts and a mean of 1.5 weeks for PT grafts. Progression through rehabilitation and the timing of return to various levels of sporting activity was similar for both graft types. Few surgeons used strength testing (HS: 25%, PT: 23%) or knee arthrometry (HS: 22%, PT: 17%) prior to return to sport and the use of a brace was rarely recommended for return to sport (HS: 7%, PT: 3%). The results of this survey indicate little variation in the post-operative management of HS and PT ACL reconstruction among members of the Australian Knee Society. Future research should, however, be directed towards the rate of progression through rehabilitation, as this was shown to be more conservative than other recent reports.

Design and implementation of a neuromuscular training program following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Neuromuscular training programs are increasingly integrated into clinical practice for lower extremity rehabilitation. A few rehabilitation programs have been evaluated for patients with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency and for injury prevention, but there is limited scientific evidence of the effect of neuromuscular training following ACL reconstruction. Therefore, a neuromuscular training program was developed for patients after ACL reconstruction. The objective of the neuromuscular training was to improve the ability to generate a fast and optimal muscle firing pattern, to increase dynamic joint stability, and to relearn movement patterns and skills necessary during activities of daily living and sports activities. The main areas considered when designing the postoperative rehabilitation program after ACL reconstruction were: ACL graft healing and ACL strain values during exercises, proprioception and neuromuscular control, and clinical studies on the effect of neuromuscular training programs. The rehabilitation program consists of balance exercises, dynamic joint stability exercises, jump training/plyometric exercises, agility drills, and sport-specific exercise. The patients exercise 3 times a week for 6 months. The scientific and clinical evidence for the rehabilitation program are described and the main exercises in the program are outlined.

Predicting physical therapy visits needed to achieve minimal functional goals after arthroscopic knee surgery

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective, cross-sectional regression modeling.

OBJECTIVE

To predict physical therapy visits following arthroscopic knee surgery.

BACKGROUND

The number of physical therapy visits required to achieve a set of specific minimal-level goals (full knee extension, straight leg raise, normalized gait pattern, bicycle pedaling, and independent home exercises) that are related to decreased complication rates has not previously been modeled.

METHODS AND MEASURES

A multiple regression model to predict postoperative physical therapy visits was developed using subject demographics and 2 simple clinical measures, degree of straight leg raise lag and total range of motion. All data were collected from 148 patient charts. Model validity was examined by the predicted residual sum of squares technique and a second independent sample of 157 charts.

RESULTS

Diagnosis group, surgery group, and range of motion were the significant variables predicting visits in the final model (R2 = 0.384). Results of model validation analyses using predicted residual sum of squares technique (R2 = 0.346) and the second set of data (R2 = 0.282) were satisfactory. Analysis of residuals (difference of observed and predicted visits) showed prediction of the number of physical therapy visits within 3 visits for approximately 75% of the cases in both sets of data.

CONCLUSIONS

Using the model to predict physical therapy visits following arthroscopic knee surgery was more accurate than using diagnosis alone, except for lateral retinacular release. This study demonstrates how regression models could be used to explain variance in physical therapy visits for a given set of minimal functional goals.

Effectiveness of lateral slide exercise in an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction rehabilitation home exercise program

STUDY DESIGN

Two-group repeated measures design using a sample of convenience of subjects with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstructive surgery.

OBJECTIVES

To determine the effect of incorporating one specific weight-bearing exercise (lateral slide exercise using a slide board) into an ACL reconstruction home exercise program.

BACKGROUND

Reduced clinic visits have increased the importance of home exercise programs in knee ligament reconstruction rehabilitation. Few studies have been conducted to test the efficacy of specific exercises as part of a home-based treatment program on subjects who have undergone ACL reconstruction.

METHODS AND MEASURES

Fourteen subjects who underwent patella tendon autograft reconstruction on one of their ACLs were studied. Testing consisted of the following 4 measurements: peak isometric knee extension torque, peak isometric knee flexion torque, maximum lateral step height, and lateral step-up repetitions to fatigue. Subjects were pretested at 8 weeks after surgery and were randomly placed into either a control or experimental group. The postsurgical rehabilitation was similar for both groups, except the experimental group incorporated lateral slide exercise into their home exercise program. All subjects were re-evaluated 14 weeks after surgery.

RESULTS

A 2-way repeated measure ANOVA (group by test session), and posthoc testing revealed significant improvements in the slide group for quadricep strength (101.9 +/- 31.3 N m to 140.5 +/- 31.3 N m of torque), while the control group showed no significant increase (125.1 +/- 61.7 N m to 125.8 +/- 45.1 N m of torque). Lateral step height also improved in the slide group (from 22.9 +/- 5.3 cm to 28.7 +/- 5.6 cm), while the control group showed no increase (20.0 +/- 4.5 cm to 20.7 +/- 3.4 cm). Both groups increased in lateral step-up repetitions to fatigue.

CONCLUSION

Including lateral slide exercise in a home exercise program after ACL reconstruction appears to improve knee extension strength.

Knee strength deficits after hamstring tendon and patellar tendon anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to examine the strength of the knee flexors and knee extensors after two surgical techniques of ACL reconstruction and compare them to an age and activity level matched control group.

METHODS

Twenty-four subjects who had undergone ACL reconstruction greater than 1 yr previously were placed into one of two groups according to autograft donor site: patellar tendon (BPB; N = 8) and hamstring (H; N = 16), and compared with an active, control group (N = 30). Knee flexor and extensor strength was evaluated using isovelocity dynamometry (5 speeds, eccentric and concentric, 5-95 degrees ROM). Strength maps were used to graphically analyze strength over a broad operational domain of the neuromuscular system. Average strength maps were determined for each autograft group and compared with controls. A difference map (control minus graft group) and confidence (t-test) maps were used to quantitatively identify strength deficits.

RESULTS

The combined ACL group (N = 24) revealed a global 25.5% extensor strength deficit, with eccentric regional (angle and velocity matched) deficits up to 50% of control. Strength deficits covered over 86% of the sampled strength map area (P < 0.01). These knee extensor strength deficits are greater than previously reported. In addition, the BPB group demonstrated a concentric, low velocity, knee extensor strength deficit at 60-95 degrees that was not observed in the H group. Significant graft site dependent, regional knee flexor deficits of up to 50% of control were observed for the H group.

CONCLUSIONS

Strength deficits localized to specific contraction types and ranges of motion were demonstrated between the ACL and control groups that were dependent upon autograft donor site. Postoperative rehabilitation protocols specific to these deficits should be devised.

Natural history of a hamstring tendon autograft used for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in a sheep model

The purpose of this study was to describe the histologic structure of the intraarticular segment of a semitendinosus tendon autograft used for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction over the first year after surgery. We performed an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in a single hindlimb of 11 sheep using a doubled semitendinosus tendon autograft secured to the femur with an endoscopic button and polyester tape and to the tibia with sutures tied around a screw. The histologic structure of the intraarticular segment of the graft at 4, 8, 12, 24, and 52 weeks after surgery was compared with that of the normal semitendinosus tendon and anterior cruciate ligament. The random collagen fiber orientation progressed to a longitudinal orientation from the peripheral to the central areas of the graft over the initial 12 weeks after surgery. A uniform sinusoidal crimp pattern similar to that seen in the normal anterior cruciate ligament was identified under polarized light in nearly one-half of each graft by 24 weeks. Further maturation was noted at 52 weeks. Graft necrosis was not evident at any time period. This study showed that semitendinosus tendon autografts transform into a histologic structure similar to that of the normal anterior cruciate ligament over the initial year after surgery, as has been described for patellar tendon grafts.

Intraarticular anterior cruciate ligament graft placement on the average most isometric line on the femur. Does it reproducibly restore knee kinematics?

In the past, there has been a plausible hypothesis that anterior cruciate ligament graft placement at isometric sites, such that the tibial and femoral attachment sites remain equidistant from each other throughout knee range of motion, would increase the likelihood of a satisfactory outcome. For a given tibial placement we wanted to determine whether placing the graft on the average of the most isometric femoral line, a fixed distance from the outlet of the intercondylar notch, would return normal laxity to all knees. The three-dimensional kinematics of seven cadaveric knees were measured for angles from full extension to 90 degrees of flexion at 15 degrees increments. Physiologic levels of quadriceps muscle forces were applied to the intact knee, after transection of the anterior cruciate ligament, and after ligament reconstruction with a patellar tendon graft. On average, the reconstruction was found to return anterior-posterior translation, internal-external rotation, and varus-valgus rotation to levels not significantly different from those of the intact knee. However, the ranges of the translation and rotations were large. Placing the graft on the average most isometric femoral line did not restore knee laxity to normal in all knees. This supports the need to customize graft placement in each knee at the time of surgery.

The ligament augmentation device: an historical perspective

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury is the most common ligament injury in the knee, and a significant number of patients may develop progressive instability and disability despite aggressive rehabilitation. Various materials have been used for its reconstruction. These include autografts, allografts, prosthetic ligaments, and synthetic augmentation of the biological tissue. The concept of ligament augmentation device (LAD) arose from the observation that biological grafts undergo a phase of degeneration and loss of strength before being incorporated. The LAD is meant to protect the biological graft during this vulnerable phase. However, it provokes an inflammatory reaction in the knee, and has been found to delay maturation of autogenous graft in humans. In experimental situations, the LAD has been found to share loads in a composite graft. It has also been found to be substantially stronger than the biological graft. However, in clinical situations no significant advantages have been observed with the use of LAD to augment patellar tendon or hamstring reconstruction of the chronic ACL-deficient knee or in the acute setting to augment repair of the torn ACL. There are very few reports of the use of LAD in reconstruction of the posterior cruciate ligament, and again these do not suggest any advantage in its use. Insertion of the LAD implies the introduction of a foreign material into the knee, has been associated with complications such as reactive synovitis and effusions, and may also be associated with an increased risk of infection. At present, there is no evidence that its routine use should be advocated in uncomplicated reconstructions of the ACL using biological grafts.