Peritoneal Dialysis in Asia: An External Perspective

There are almost 30 000 patients maintained on peritoneal dialysis (PD) in Asia, representing about 8% of all Asian dialysis patients. The largest numbers of PD patients are in Japan and China, but the highest PD penetration is in Hong Kong, Korea, and Singapore. Notable features of PD in Asia include the varying rates of use across the different countries. The reasons for this are reviewed here, with particular emphasis on the significance of whether dialysis providers are predominantly private or public. The excellent rates of both patient and technique survival in the richer Asian countries are also examined and interpreted in the context of recent data showing that Asian patients living in North America have generally superior survival on dialysis and better compliance with PD than their Caucasian counterparts. It is concluded that the healthier baseline health status in South East Asian patients, in particular, contributes to their impressive outcomes. The approach to both clearance and ultrafiltration is less aggressive in Asian countries than in the West. Studies looking at the relationship between clearance and clinical outcome in Asia are reviewed and it is concluded that the benefits of higher clearances have been harder to show than in North America because of the relatively better outcomes of the patients. The concern about sclerosing encapsulating peritonitis in Japan particularly is emphasized. The Hong Kong model of dialysis delivery with its high use of PD and the arguments for and against it are also reviewed.

Setting up a Continuous Ambulatory Peritoneal Dialysis Training Program

Continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) training programs have become fundamental patient education programs in renal centers providing peritoneal dialysis (PD) services. Several key topics must be addressed in setting up a CAPD training program:

• Health care and organizational issues • Multidisciplinary team approach • Evidence-based practice • Pre-training patient assessment • Patient training • Program evaluation

The PD nurses should identify key learning objectives for patient training. The essential elements of CAPD training are the training content and schedule, training assessment, and teaching methods. Program set-up also includes establishing a back-up system and follow-up protocols, which are essential for continuity of care in renal patients. Outcomes such as rates of peritonitis and exit-site infection, unplanned readmission, and patient satisfaction are all important indicators when the results of CAPD training programs are reviewed. The development and successful implementation of a cost-effective CAPD training program has a significant impact on patient outcomes in the renal specialty.

How to Have a Successful Peritoneal Dialysis Program

The proportion of end-stage renal disease patients on continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) has increased by twofold in Hong Kong over last two decades, accounting for 80% of the entire dialysis population. Our encouraging outcome results—a 2-year actuarial patient survival of 83%, and a 2-year technique survival of 72.8%—further testify to the success of CAPD in our territory. A relatively constant successful outcome has been achieved despite an increasing prevalence of diabetes mellitus and an aging population. The present review postulates the reasons behind our success. Apart from reimbursement policy, technique-related factors, and center effects, inherent patient factors—including baseline survival advantage of Chinese patients, genetic difference, cardiovascular risk factors, and possibly lower dialysis volume requirement and compliance—are thought to be contributory. As for the future, more efforts are needed to further improve the technique survival rate and the nutritional status, psychosocial well-being, and rehabilitation of CAPD patients. Judicious assessment of peritoneal dialysis adequacy and preservation of residual renal function should be constantly exercised to tailor treatment to the needs of Chinese CAPD patients.

ASPD: A Prospective Study of Adequacy in Asian Patients on Long Term, Small Volume, Continuous Ambulatory Peritoneal Dialysis

Background

The impact of small solute clearance on patient survival in continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) is not yet solidified. Previously, we demonstrated that CAPD using small volume (6 L) daily exchanges provides adequate dialysis for most Asian patients.

Methods

We conducted a prospective, long-term observational study to determine the optimal dialysis adequacy that may provide better patient survival for Asian patients who receive small-volume CAPD. We recruited 294 patients. The initial CAPD regime was 3 x 2-L exchanges daily. The same regime was maintained unless there was significant loss of ultrafiltration or fluid retention despite the use of hypertonic dialysate.

Results

Median study period was 38.9 (range 5 – 76.5) months, with 81% and 27% of patients remaining in the study at 24 and 48 months respectively. The overall survival rates at 2 and 4 years were 94.0% and 74.8% respectively. Our long-term data revealed that survival rate was related to Kt/V values. Survival rates were significantly higher for patients with total Kt/V > 2.0 than for patients with Kt/V < 1.7 ( p = 0.02). The former group had lower body mass index and higher residual renal function and peritoneal Kt/V than the latter group. On analysis using Cox proportional hazards regression models, cardiovascular disease (CVD), lower urine volume, and higher body mass index were independent predictors of mortality. Patients with higher renal Kt/V had a significantly lower risk of mortality (RR = 0.018, p = 0.01) after adjusting for the effects of CVD and diabetes mellitus.

Conclusion

Our data recommend that 1.7 be the minimal target for total Kt/V in patients on long-term CAPD. Patients with high body mass index, low residual urine volume, and significant CVD need close monitoring.

Is there a survival advantage in Asian peritoneal dialysis patients?

Over the last decade, epidemiological surveys and qualitative research literature have demonstrated and validated a better survival in the Asian peritoneal dialysis population. This review summarizes the current understanding of Asian peritoneal dialysis patient survival and attempts to scrutinize the supposed survival advantage of this population group. We outlined the published peritoneal dialysis survival data from a literature search, with reference to dialysis patient cohorts from 1983 through 2002 for prevalent cases and 1980 through 2002 for incident patients. Two-year and 5-year patient survival rates in excess of 80% and 60% respectively were demonstrated in Asian countries, which compared favorably with the CANUSA, ADEMEX and most Caucasian series. Better end-stage renal disease patient survival is apparent despite a dialysis adequacy disadvantage, for reasons yet to be identified. As is the case of other racial disparities in medical care, such a difference is a product of more than biological differences and include budgetary barrier, health care system and geographic variation, physician bias and statistical pitfalls. Particular efforts should therefore be made to explore the underlying reason(s) for the Asian peritoneal dialysis patient survival advantage. Alternative approach and guidelines to peritoneal dialysis delivery in Asia might be warranted.

Dissociation between dialysis adequacy and Kt/V

Since the initiation of dialysis, nephrologists have sought an index (or indices) for the adequacy of toxic solute removal. This quest has been characterized by a gradual shift in thinking, ending with a preference for dynamic parameters such as clearances normalized for body size (Kt/V). The threshold Kt/V, however, has changed over the years. While present guidelines suggest 1.2 with single-pool kinetics, higher levels might be proposed in the future. In spite of the known relation between Kt/V and survival, the accuracy of this parameter as a representative of the removal of the whole spectrum of compounds that are responsible for uremia is problematic. Kt/V only assesses the removal of a water-soluble compound from the body water through mostly hydrophilic membranes to the dialysate water. Furthermore, the small size of urea means that convective and/or diffusive transfer through a given semipermeable membrane is unlikely to be representative of larger molecules, especially if dialyzers with a small pore size are applied. Urea kinetics are also poorly representative of the removal of small protein-bound molecules and intracellular solutes with cell membrane-limited clearance. Finally, it should be realized that the Kt/V concept has been developed in a specific population, that is, a group of renal failure patients with few comorbidities, submitted to short intermittent hemodialysis with small-pore bioincompatible membranes very likely using dialysate of lower quality than that used today. Kt/V might well become less accurate and useful in predicting outcomes as different dialysis conditions are pursued, such as dialysis with biocompatible and/or large-pore membranes, (ultra) pure dialysate, alternative time frames, high levels of convection, and/or in populations with a different distribution of body mass.

Independent effects of residual renal function and dialysis adequacy on actual dietary protein, calorie, and other nutrient intake in patients on continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis

Previous studies have suggested that the cross-sectional relationship observed between total solute clearance (Kt/V) and dietary protein intake (DPI) in patients undergoing dialysis is possibly mathematical in origin. A cross-sectional study on 242 patients undergoing continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) was performed to determine the differential effects of dialysis adequacy and residual renal function (RRF) on actual dietary intake. All patients underwent a 7-d food frequency questionnaire to quantify daily dietary protein, calorie (DCI), and other nutrient intake, subjective global assessment (SGA), and collection of 24-h dialysate and urine for total (PD and renal) Kt/V and RRF. Patients were categorized into three groups: I (n = 94), total Kt/V >/=1.7 and GFR >0.5 ml/min per 1.73 m(2); II (n = 58), total Kt/V >/=1.7 but GFR <0.5 ml/min per 1.73 m(2); and III (n = 90), total Kt/V <1.7. Sixty-nine percent versus 62% versus 42% of group I versus II versus III patients were well nourished according to SGA (P = 0.004). DPI (1.23 [0.47] versus 1.12 [0.49] versus 0.99 [0.40] g/kg per d; P = 0.002) and DCI (27.3 [8.9] versus 23.8 [8.6] versus 23.0 [8.2] kcal/kg per d; P = 0.002) showed significant decline across the three groups. Intake of other nutrients, including carbohydrate, fat, fatty acids, and cholesterol was higher for group I compared with groups II and III. Adjusting for age, gender, weight, and diabetes, every 1 ml/min per 1.73 m(2) increase in GFR was associated with a 0.838-fold increase in DCI (95% confidence interval to interval, 0.279 to 1.397; P = 0.003) and a 0.041-fold increase in DPI (95% confidence interval, 0.009 to 0.072; P = 0.012), whereas every 0.25-unit increase in total (PD and renal) Kt/V was associated with a 0.570-fold increase in DCI (95% confidence interval, 0.049 to 1.092; P = 0.032) and a 0.052-fold increase in DPI (95% confidence interval, 0.023 to 0.081; P = 0.001). Greater small-solute clearances are associated with better dietary intake and better nutrition. The study confirmed significant and independent effect of RRF, but not PD solute clearance, on actual DPI, DCI, and other nutrient intake in patients on CAPD.

Health-related quality of life among dialysis patients in Seattle and Aichi

We used the 36-item Short-Form Health Survey to compare health-related quality of life (HRQOL) between 104 dialysis patients in Seattle, WA, and 2,178 patients in Aichi, JAPAN: Compared with Aichi patients, Seattle patients had lower scores on three scales related to physical HRQOL: Physical Functioning (PF; P = 0.03), Role-Physical (RP; P = 0.004), and Vitality (VT; P < 0.001). However, scores related to mental HRQOL were higher for Seattle patients compared with those of Aichi patients, which included scores for Role-Emotional (RE; P = 0.005) and Mental Health (MH; P < 0.001). Scores for Bodily Pain, General Health Perception, and Social Functioning did not differ significantly between the two groups. These differences persisted even after potential confounding factors were controlled for. However, after taking into account national norm data for the United States and Japan, differences in PF and VT disappeared, whereas differences in RP, RE, and MH persisted. These results suggest that the higher scores for PF and VT in Aichi patients were partly explained by the higher physical HRQOL of the Japanese general population. Although these data may not be representative of the total dialysis populations in the United States and Japan, they suggest potential differences in HRQOL between patients in the two countries. Additional research is needed to confirm these results and understand the factors associated with these differences. The findings suggest the need for further attention to the physical limitations of US dialysis patients and the mental health of Japanese dialysis patients.

Adequacy of peritoneal dialysis

The National Kidney Foundation-Dialysis Outcomes Quality Initiatives guidelines have standardized many aspects of treating end-stage renal disease patients with peritoneal dialysis in an attempt to improve overall patient outcome. While recommending certain total solute clearance goals, the guidelines have also pointed out deficiencies in our knowledge base and precipitated many controversies. Some of these controversies have been resolved while others may have been interpreted wrongly, unnecessarily resulting in transfer of patients from peritoneal dialysis to hemodialysis due to "failure to meet adequacy targets" even when doing well clinically. This report reviews the rationale for the original guidelines and their subsequent modification. It also outlines a rational approach toward prescription modification based on peritoneal physiology. Specific solute clearance target goals discussed are the modifications for continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) and cycler peritoneal dialysis (CCPD), and a review of what solute clearance targets subsequent guidelines from other countries have used. Some examples are as follows: new guidelines suggest that solute clearance goals for creatine clearance should differ for low and low-average transporters than for high and high-average transporters (weekly clearance of 50 and 60 1/1.73 m(2), respectively) while Kt/V targets remain unchanged. Also discussed is the rationale for having the same target for patients on CCPD with a mid-day exchange as those for patients on CAPD. We are also reminded that solute clearance is only one aspect of "adequate" dialysis-blood pressure and volume control are equally important, and ways to maintain euvolemia and blood pressure control are discussed in the context of prescription management.

Changes of cytokine profiles during peritonitis in patients on continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis

Continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) has emerged as an important dialysis treatment modality worldwide. One of the major complications is bacterial peritonitis, which may result in subsequent technique failure because of loss of peritoneal clearance or peritoneal fibrosis. Bacterial peritonitis leads to the release of proinflammatory cytokines from resident and infiltrating cells in the peritoneal cavity. We studied 35 patients undergoing CAPD with acute bacterial peritonitis. All patients treated with antibiotics for 2 weeks after the clinical diagnosis of peritonitis had a good recovery. Peritoneal dialysate effluent (PDE) was collected on days 1, 3, 5, 10, 21, and 42 after the start of treatment. Cell populations were monitored by flow cytometry. PDE levels of interleukin-1beta (IL-1), IL-6, transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta), and basic fibroblast growth factor (FGF) were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Gene transcription of TGF-beta in macrophages from PDE was measured by quantitative polymerase chain reaction. Bacterial peritonitis was associated with a sharp increase in total cell and neutrophil counts (400-fold) in PDE up to 3 weeks after peritonitis despite clinical remission (P < 0.0001). There was an increased absolute number of macrophages during the first 3 weeks despite the reduced percentage of macrophages among total cells in PDE compared with noninfective PDE. There was a progressive increase in the percentage of mesothelial cells or dead cells in the total cell population in PDE over the entire 6-week period. PDE levels of IL-1, IL-6, TGF-beta, and FGF increased markedly on day 1 before their levels decreased gradually. PDE levels of these cytokines or growth factors were significantly greater than those in noninfective PDE (n = 76) throughout the study period (P < 0.01). Similarly, TGF-beta complementary DNA (cDNA) molecules per macrophage were significantly greater than those of macrophages in noninfective PDE throughout this period (P < 0.01). There was no significant correlation between PDE levels of TGF-beta and TGF-beta cDNA molecules per macrophage, suggesting that peritoneal macrophages are not the only source of TGF-beta in PDE. We conclude there is an active release of proinflammatory cytokines and sclerogenic growth factors through at least 6 weeks despite apparent clinical remission of peritonitis. The peritoneal cytokine networks after peritonitis may potentially affect the physiological properties of the peritoneal membrane.