Salvage of Combat Hindfoot Fractures in 2003-2014 UK Military

Comparison of Axial Force Attenuation Characteristics in Two Different Lower Extremity Anthropomorphic Test Devices

INTRODUCTION

Any type of boot or footwear is designed to attenuate and distribute loading to the bottom of the foot. Anthropomorphic test device (ATDs) are used to assess potential countermeasures against these loads. The specific aims of this study were to compare and quantify force attenuation characteristics as a function of input energy for Hybrid-III and Mil-Lx ATD human surrogates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Two lower leg ATD surrogates (Mil-Lx and Hybrid-III) were tested to investigate the influence of a commercially available military boot on lower extremity force response and assess such differences against previously published postmortem human surrogate studies. The testing apparatus impacted the bottom of the foot using a rigid plate at velocities from 2 to 10 m/s. Tests were conducted on each ATD to obtain axial force response with and without boots as a function of input energy.

RESULTS

Peak forces ranged from 1 to 16.4 kN for the Hybrid-III, and 1 to 8.4 kN for the Mil-Lx for similar input conditions. The average force attenuation for the Hybrid-III at upper and lower load cells was 71% (59%-80%) and 70% (58%-78%). The average attenuation for the Mil-Lx at upper and lower load cells was 20% (13%-28%) and 37% (36%-37%), respectively. At the knee load cell, the attenuated peak loads ranged from 62% to 81% for the Hybrid-III and 16% to 30% for the Mil-Lx.

CONCLUSIONS

Force attenuation characteristics in the booted vs unbooted configuration of the Mil-Lx were significantly different than force attenuation characteristics of the H3 and may better represent in vivo forces during vertical impact injuries, such as IED blasts. Hence for military relevant applications where boots are used, the Mil-Lx may provide a more conservative evaluation of lower extremity protection systems.

Trabecular bone mineral density correlations using QCT: Central and peripheral human skeleton

Musculoskeletal injuries to the lower leg and foot-ankle joint are associated with external mechanical loads resulting from motor vehicle crashes, under body blasts, falls from height, or sports. As an intrinsic material property, the bone mineral density (BMD) is related to bone strength. The clinically recognized biological sites for BMD evaluation are the hip and spine. The focus of this study was to define the correlation between BMD from standard clinical sites (hip and lumbar spine) compared to BMD from non-standard sites (foot-ankle-distal tibia bones). Twenty-one post-mortem human subjects (PMHS) with mean age, height, and mass of 63 ± 11 years, 179 ± 7 cm, and 86 ± 13 kg, respectively were used for analysis. Clinical BMD software (Mindways Software, Inc.) was used for trabecular BMD quantification using quantitative computed tomography (QCT). In quantification of BMD of the foot-ankle-distal tibia (hind foot), the trabecular BMD of the talus (316 ± 86mg/cc) was highest followed by the distal tibia (238 ± 72 mg/cc) and then calcaneus (147 ± 51 mg/cc). To correlate BMD values from foot bone regions with the central skeleton BMD values within the same PMHS, there were 18 lumbar spine and 12 hip BMDs available. The BMD of the distal tibia correlated best with the hip intertrochanter BMD (R² of 0.72). Calcaneus BMD best correlated with the hip femoral neck BMD (R² = 0.64). In summary, the hind foot bone BMD values correlated better with the hip as compared to the lumbar spine BMD from the same PMHS. These findings indicate that, in the absence of a direct measure of foot-bone BMD, hip BMD might be a better predictor of injury risk to hind foot rather than lumbar spine BMD, or alternatively, calcaneal trabecular BMD can be used to predict the risk of injury to hip. Further, these relationships between central and peripheral regions can also be implemented in finite element models for improved failure predictions.

Outcomes following limb salvage after combat hindfoot injury are inferior to delayed amputation at five years

Objectives

The surgical challenge with severe hindfoot injuries is one of technical feasibility, and whether the limb can be salvaged. There is an additional question of whether these injuries should be managed with limb salvage, or whether patients would achieve a greater quality of life with a transtibial amputation. This study aims to measure functional outcomes in military patients sustaining hindfoot fractures, and identify injury features associated with poor function.

Methods

Follow-up was attempted in all United Kingdom military casualties sustaining hindfoot fractures. All respondents underwent short-form (SF)-12 scoring; those retaining their limb also completed the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons Foot and Ankle (AAOS F&A) outcomes questionnaire. A multivariate regression analysis identified injury features associated with poor functional recovery.

Results

In 12 years of conflict, 114 patients sustained 134 fractures. Follow-up consisted of 90 fractures (90/134, 67%), at a median of five years (interquartile range (IQR) 52 to 80 months).

The median Short-Form 12 physical component score (PCS) of 62 individuals retaining their limb was 45 (IQR 36 to 53), significantly lower than the median of 51 (IQR 46 to 54) in patients who underwent delayed amputation after attempted reconstruction (p = 0.0351).

Regression analysis identified three variables associated with a poor F&A score: negative Bohler’s angle on initial radiograph; coexisting talus and calcaneus fracture; and tibial plafond fracture in addition to a hindfoot fracture. The presence of two out of three variables was associated with a significantly lower PCS compared with amputees (medians 29, IQR 27 to 43 vs 51, IQR 46 to 54; p < 0.0001).

Conclusions

At five years, patients with reconstructed hindfoot fractures have inferior outcomes to those who have delayed amputation. It is possible to identify injuries which will go on to have particularly poor outcomes.

Cite this article: P. M. Bennett, T. Stevenson, I. D. Sargeant, A. Mountain, J. G. Penn-Barwell. Outcomes following limb salvage after combat hindfoot injury are inferior to delayed amputation at five years. Bone Joint Res 2018;7:131–138. DOI: 10.1302/2046-3758.72.BJR-2017-0217.R2.

Human Foot-Ankle Injuries and Associated Risk Curves from Under Body Blast Loading Conditions

Under body blast (UBB) loading to military transport vehicles is known to cause foot-ankle fractures to occupants due to energy transfer from the vehicle floor to the feet of the soldier. The soldier posture, the proximity of the event with respect to the soldier, the personal protective equipment (PPE) and age/sex of the soldier are some variables that can influence injury severity and injury patterns. Recently conducted experiments to simulate the loading environment to the human foot/ankle in UBB events (~5ms rise time) with variables such as posture, age and PPE were used for the current study. The objective of this study was to determine statistically if these variables affected the primary injury predictors, and develop injury risk curves. Fifty belowknee post mortem human surrogate (PMHS) legs were used for statistical analysis. Injuries to specimens involved isolated and multiple fractures of varying severity. The Sanders classification was used to grade calcaneus severity and the AO/OTA classification for distal tibia fracture. Injury risk curves were developed using survival regression analysis and covariates were included whenever statistically significant (p<0.05). With peak force as the injury predictor and age and boot as covariates, the model was statistically significant. However, boot use changed the pattern of injury from predominately calcaneus to predominantly tibia. Also, a severity based risk curve showed tolerance differences between calcaneus (minor/major) and tibia (severity-I/ severity- II) injuries. The tibia demonstrated higher tolerance as compared to either minor or major calcaneus injury. These findings can play a vital role in development of safety systems to mitigate injuries to the occupant.