Deformity and Clinical Outcomes Following Operative Correction of Charcot Foot: A New Classification With Implications for Treatment

Surgical management of the diabetic foot: The current evidence

The prevalence of diabetes mellitus and its associated complications, particularly diabetic foot pathologies, poses significant healthcare challenges and economic burdens globally. This review synthesises current evidence on the surgical management of the diabetic foot, focusing on the interplay between neuropathy, ischemia, and infection that commonly culminates in ulcers, infections, and, in severe cases, amputations. The escalating incidence of diabetes mellitus underscores the urgency for effective management strategies, as diabetic foot complications are a leading cause of hospital admissions among diabetic patients, significantly impacting morbidity and mortality rates. This review explores the pathophysiological mechanisms underlying diabetic foot complications and further examines diabetic foot ulcers, infections, and skeletal pathologies such as Charcot arthropathy, emphasising the critical role of early diagnosis, comprehensive management strategies, and interdisciplinary care in mitigating adverse outcomes. In addressing surgical interventions, this review evaluates conservative surgeries, amputations, and reconstructive procedures, highlighting the importance of tailored approaches based on individual patient profiles and the specific characteristics of foot pathologies. The integration of advanced diagnostic tools, novel surgical techniques, and postoperative care, including offloading and infection control, are discussed in the context of optimising healing and preserving limb function.

Evaluation of Adjuvant Antibiotic Loaded Injectable Bio-Composite Material in Diabetic Foot Osteomyelitis and Charcot Foot Reconstruction

The management of diabetic foot osteomyelitis (DFO) is extremely challenging with high amputation rates reported alongside a five-year mortality risk of more than fifty percent. We describe our experience in using adjuvant antibiotic-loaded bio-composite material (Cerament) in the surgical management of DFO and infected Charcot foot reconstruction. We undertook a retrospective evaluation of 53 consecutive patients (54 feet) who underwent Gentamicin or Vancomycin-loaded Cerament application during surgery. The feet were categorised into two groups: Group 1, with infected ulcer and DFO, managed with radical debridement only (n = 17), and Group 2, requiring reconstruction surgery for infected and deformed Charcot foot. Group 2 was further subdivided into 2a, with feet previously cleared of infection and undergoing a single-stage reconstruction (n = 19), and 2b, with feet having an active infection managed with a two-stage reconstruction (n = 18). The mean age was 56 years (27-83) and 59% (31/53) were males. The mean BMI was 30.2 kg/m² (20.8-45.5). Foot ulcers were present in 69% (37/54) feet. At a mean follow-up of 30 months (12-98), there were two patients lost to follow up and the mortality rate was 11% (n = 5). The mean duration of post-operative systemic antibiotic administration was 20 days (4-42). Thirteen out of fifteen feet (87%) in group 1 achieved complete eradication of infection. There was a 100% primary ulcer resolution, 100% limb salvage and 76% bony union rate within Group 2. However, five patients, all in group 2, required reoperations due to problems with bone union. The use of antibiotic-loaded Cerament resulted in a high proportion of patients achieving infection clearance, functional limb salvage and decrease in the duration of postoperative antibiotic therapy. Larger, preferably randomised, studies are required to further validate these observations.

The Modern Treatment of Charcot Foot Arthropathy

The National Institute of Health now estimates that there are well over 37 million persons with diabetes in the United States alone, a number well over 11 per cent of our population. The associated multiple organ system disease is responsible for more than 327 billion dollars in direct and indirect medical costs and more than 140,000 lower extremity amputations yearly in the United States. Because healthcare professionals have begun to appreciate the economic and pathologic burden that diabetes imparts on our society, there has been a growth in both the understanding and treatment of the responsible pathologic disorders. The goal of this monograph is to provide an evidence-supported foundation to better understand the pathophysiology that leads to the development of neuropathic (Charcot) foot arthropathy and provide insight into developing a treatment plan for addressing this complex disease process that presents in a highly comorbid patient population.

No effect of preoperative ulceration on outcomes of tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis

BACKGROUND

Tibiotalocalcaneal (TTC) arthrodesis is a commonly performed operation for complex hindfoot pathology, but the effect of preoperative ulceration on TTC outcomes has been debated. This study aims to examine infection rates in patients undergoing TTC arthrodesis with internal fixation with and without concomitant hindfoot ulceration.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective review of 31 patients who underwent a TTC arthrodesis between June 2016 and February 2021 with a fellowship-trained foot and ankle surgeon at an academic medical center. Nine (29.0%) patients had preoperative ulceration. Mean follow-up duration was 1.49 (range, 0.51-4.28) years. Other data collected included demographics, comorbidities, surgical approach, fixation method, and complication and reoperation rates.

RESULTS

There was no difference in overall complication (ulcer [U]=66.7%, no ulcer [NU]=50.0%; p = .397), infection (U=33.3%, NU=31.8%; p = .935), or reoperation (U=55.6%, NU=27.3%; p = .135) rates between groups.

CONCLUSIONS

TTC arthrodesis with internal fixation appears to be a reasonable treatment method for patients with a preoperative ulcer.

Amputation and mortality frequencies associated with diabetic Charcot foot arthropathy: a meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Five-year mortality and amputation frequencies after new-onset diabetic ulceration have been reported up to 55% and 74%, respectively. for patients with lower-extremity amputation. Following Charcot arthropathy, these frequencies were reported with wide variations. The aim of this meta-analysis is to provide a quantitative evaluation of amputation and mortality frequencies in a diabetic patient with a Charcot foot arthropathy.

METHODS

Electronic search strategy was applied on Medline, Web of Science, Cochrane Library and Google Scholar since inception to December 2021. Extracted data included study design, sample and patients characteristics, diabetes type and duration, lab results, ulcers at diagnosis, co-morbidities and follow up period. Meta-analysis reporting random-effects values was used to generate the weights results.

RESULTS

A total of 16 studies were included in the quantitative meta-analysis with a pooled sample of 2250 patients with 2272 Charcot feet. Two studies including 255 patients yielded a 1-year mortality frequency of 4% (95% CI = 0.018-0.065). Seven studies including 1706 patients reported a 5-year mortality frequency of 24.5% (95% CI = 0.172-0.326, I² = 88.5%). Four studies including 277 patients yielded a seven plus year mortality frequency of 16% (95% CI = 0.065-0.289, I² = 84.3%). Ten studies including 871 foot yielded an amputation frequency of 15% (95% CI = 0.067-0.258, I² = 93.6%) where 9% where major amputations (95% CI = 0.062-0.127, I² = 60%) and 5% were minor amputations (95% CI = 0.004-0.126, I² = 94.7%) CONCLUSION: Diabetic Charcot arthropathy yields marked risk of amputation and mortality. However, mortality frequencies were unexpectedly lesser compared to those related to the published frequencies associated with diabetic foot ulcers.

Coronal Hindfoot Alignment in Midfoot Charcot Neuroarthropathy

Coronal plane hindfoot malalignment produces abnormal compensatory forces within the midfoot and forefoot. The primary aim of this study is to compare radiographic hindfoot alignment in patients with a midfoot Charcot event, and identify patterns associated with breakdown. A retrospective review of 43 patients (48 limbs) with midfoot Charcot neuroarthropathy were compared between the coronal hindfoot alignments and Charcot joint involvement. Coronal hindfoot alignment was classified as neutral (n = 15), valgus (n = 16), and varus (n = 17) utilizing the Saltzman hindfoot alignment radiograph. Charcot joint breakdown was classified as isolated tarsometatarsal joint (n = 8), combination of tarsometatarsal and naviculocuneiform joints (n = 22), and midtarsal joints including talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joints (n = 18). Patients exhibiting varus hindfoot alignment had 5.8 times greater risk of breakdown at the tarsometatarsal and naviculocuneiform joints (odds ratio 5.8, 95% confidence interval 1.7-22.9, p < .01). Hindfoot varus induces external rotation of the talus, resulting in compensation through the naviculocuneiform and tarsometatarsal joint, which correlates with our findings of a 6-fold increase in naviculocuneiform and tarsometatarsal joint collapse. Patients exhibiting valgus hindfoot alignment had 27 times greater risk of breakdown at the midtarsal joint (odds ratio 27.0; 95% confidence interval 5.6-207.0, p < .01). Hindfoot valgus induces internal rotation of the talonavicular joint, which correlates with our findings of a 27-fold increase in midtarsal joint breakdown. Varus and valgus hindfoot alignment are associated with different midfoot injury patterns, which may have implications in surgical management and allow for focused surveillance in neuropathic patients presenting with early-stage clinical findings consistent with Charcot neuroarthropathy.

Nonoperative Treatment of Charcot Neuro-osteoarthropathy

Conservative treatment of Charcot neuro-osteoarthropathy (CN) aims to retain a stable, plantigrade, and ulcer-free foot, or to prevent progression of an already existing deformity. CN is treated with offloading in a total contact cast as long as CN activity is present. Transition to inactive CN is monitored by the resolution of clinical activity signs and by resolution of bony edema in MRI. Fitting of orthopedic depth insoles, orthopedic shoes, or ankle-foot orthosis should follow immediately after offloading has ended to prevent CN reactivation or ulcer development.

Quality of Life Improvement Following Reconstruction of Midtarsal Charcot Foot Deformity: A Five Year Follow-Up

BACKGROUND

There is increasing interest in reconstruction of diabetes-associated Charcot foot arthropathy with the goal of improving quality of life.

METHODS

Twenty-four patients who completed the Short Musculoskeletal Function Assessment (SMFA) at baseline and one year following Charcot foot reconstruction were contacted and asked to complete the survey at five years following surgery.

RESULTS

Fourteen of the 24 patients completed the SMFA preoperatively, one year following surgery and five years postoperatively. Two patients underwent below knee amputation in the interim. Improvement was noted in all domains measured by the SMFA, with a statistically significant improvement in difficulty with daily activities at five years.

CONCLUSION

Correction of non-plantigrade Charcot foot arthropathy results in clinically meaningful improvement in health-related quality of life at both one and five years postoperatively, including independence with daily activities. The improvement is maintained when reevaluated at five years. This supports the modern paradigm shift towards reconstruction of this deformity. Level of Evidence: III.

Inappropriate antibiotic administration in the setting of Charcot arthropathy: A case series and literature review

AIMS

Differentiating Charcot neuropathic osteoarthropathy (CN) from infection is challenging. The diagnosis of CN is often missed or delayed, resulting in inappropriate and delayed treatment. We hypothesized that the misdiagnosis of CN results in inappropriate antibiotic prescriptions and explore the sequelae of unnecessary antibiotic use.

METHODS

A retrospective review of patient electronic medical records from January 2010 to December 2017 was conducted for those diagnosed with CN after being referred to an orthopaedic foot and ankle specialist.

RESULTS

Our review showed 58 of 103 (56%) patients received antibiotics on the date, or within the next 7 days, of referral to foot and ankle orthopaedic specialist. The antibiotic of choice given on referral were as follows: Sulfamethoxazole/Trimethoprim 18 of 58 (31%), doxycycline 13 of 58 (22%), clindamycin 13 of 58 (22%), cephalexin 9 of 58 (16%), minocycline 5 of 58 (9%).

CONCLUSION

Missed diagnoses for CN are common and result in complications stemming from inappropriate treatment, delays in appropriate therapy, and may accelerate antibiotic resistance. Misdiagnosis of CN contributes to the inappropriate use of prescription antibiotics.

Predictive Radiographic Values for Foot Ulceration in Persons with Charcot Foot Divided by Lateral or Medial Midfoot Deformity

Background: To identify differences in radiographic outcomes in weight-bearing lateral X-ray to predict the probability of ulceration in patients with midfoot Charcot neuroarthropathy (CN) differentiated by lateral and medial column deformities. Methods: Thirty-five patients who suffered from CN midfoot deformity participated in this 1 year prospective study in a specialized diabetic foot unit. Lateral talar-first metatarsal angle, calcaneal pitch, and cuboid height were performed by digital radiographs in the weight-bearing lateral view. Patients were followed up for 1 year or until an ulcer ulceration event occurred in the midfoot region. Results: ROC analyses showed that all patients with medial pattern deformity that developed a midfoot ulcer had a lateral talar-first metatarsal angle greater (negative) than −27.5 degrees (°). All patients with lateral pattern deformity that developed a midfoot ulcer had a calcaneal pitch greater (more negative) than −5° and a cuboid height greater (more negative) than −1.5°. Conclusions: Lateral talar-first metatarsal angle was the greatest predictor of midfoot ulceration, with greater than −27.5° measurement correlating with ulceration occurrence in patients with medial deformity. Calcaneal pitch and cuboid height were the greatest predictors of midfoot ulceration with greater than −5 and −1.5°, respectively in patients with CN lateral deformity.

A fully automatic system to assess foot collapse on lateral weight-bearing foot radiographs: A pilot study

BACKGROUND

Foot collapse is primarily diagnosed and monitored using lateral weight-bearing foot x-ray images. There are several well-validated measurements which aid assessment. However, these are subject to inter- and intra-user variability.

OBJECTIVE

To develop and validate a software system for the fully automatic assessment of radiographic changes associated with foot collapse; automatically generating measurements for calcaneal tilt, cuboid height and Meary's angle.

METHODS

This retrospective study was approved by the Health Research Authority (IRAS 244852). The system was developed using lateral weight-bearing foot x-ray images, and evaluated against manual measurements from five clinical experts. The system has two main components: (i) a Random Forest-based point-finder to outline the bones of interest; and (ii) a geometry-calculator to generate the measurements based on the point positions from the point-finder. The performance of the point-finder was assessed using the point-to-point error (i.e. the mean absolute distance between each found point and the equivalent ground truth point, averaged over all points per image). For assessing the performance of the geometry-calculator, linear mixed models were fitted to estimate clinical inter-observer agreement and to compare the performance of the software system to that of the clinical experts.

RESULTS

A total of 200 images were collected from 79 subjects (mean age: 56.4 years ±12.9 SD, 30/49 females/males). There was good agreement among all clinical experts with intraclass correlation estimates between 0.78 and 0.86. The point-finder achieved a median point-to-point error of 2.2 mm. There was no significant difference between the clinical and automatically generated measurements using the point-finder points, suggesting that the fully automatically obtained measurements are in agreement with the manually obtained measurements.

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed system can be used to support and automate radiographic image assessment for diagnosing and managing foot collapse, saving clinician time, and improving patient outcomes.

Long-term follow-up of conservative treatment of Charcot feet

BACKGROUND

Charcot arthropathy (CN) can ultimately lead to limb loss despite appropriate treatment. Initial conservative treatment is the accepted treatment in case of a plantigrade foot. The aim of this retrospective study was to investigate the mid- to long-term clinical course of CN initially being treated conservatively, and to identify risk factors for reactivation and contralateral development of CN as well as common complications in CN.

METHODS

A total of 184 Charcot feet in 159 patients (median age 60.0 (interquartile range (IQR) 15.5) years, 49 (30.1%) women) were retrospectively analyzed by patient chart review. Rates of limb salvage, reactivation, contralateral development and common complications were recorded. Statistical analysis was performed to identify possible risk factors for limb loss, CN reactivation, contralateral CN development, and ulcer development.

RESULTS

Major amputation-free survival could be achieved in 92.9% feet after a median follow-up of 5.2 (IQR 4.25, range 2.2-11.25) years. CN recurrence occurred in 13.6%. 32.1% had bilateral CN involvement. Ulcers were present in 72.3%. 88.1% patients were ambulating in orthopaedic footwear without any further aids. Presence of Diabetes mellitus was associated with reactivation of CN, major amputation and ulcer recurrence. Smoking was associated with ulcer development and necessity of amputations.

CONCLUSIONS

With consistent conservative treatment of CN with orthopaedic footwear or orthoses, limb preservation can be achieved in 92.9% after a median follow-up of 5.2 years. Patients with diabetic CN are at an increased risk of developing complications and CN reactivation. To prevent ulcers and amputations, every effort should be made to make patients stop smoking.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III, long-term retrospective cohort study.

Staged Percutaneous Treatment of a Complete Lisfranc Dislocation Secondary to Charcot Arthropathy: A Case Report

CASE

A 36-year-old woman with diabetic neuropathy presented with complete dorsal dislocation of the midfoot secondary to Charcot arthropathy. She was treated in a staged fashion with a Taylor spatial butt frame to distract and reduce the midfoot followed by percutaneous preparation of the tarsometatarsal (TMT) joints and fixator-assisted fusion. The arthrodesis healed successfully with maintenance of function at the 30-month follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Staged treatment with a Taylor spatial frame can be used successfully to treat complete TMT dislocations in the setting of Charcot arthropathy. Complications are not uncommon and must be addressed appropriately.

Correction of Foot Deformities from Charcot Arthropathy with the Taylor Spatial Frame: A 7-14-year Follow-up

Charcot arthropathy related foot and ankle deformities are a serious challenge. Surgical treatment of these deformities is now well established. Conventional surgical treatment includes extensive surgical exposure, excision of bone, acute correction and internal fixation, which is not always appropriate in presence of active ulceration, infection and poor bone quality. A minimally invasive approach to osteotomies and gradual correction of deformities using a circular frame are proving helpful in minimizing the complications. Taylor Spatial Frame (TSF) hexapod with its various modules is well suited for a range of foot and ankle deformities. We have advocated minimally invasive targeted hind and mid foot osteotomies and gradual correction with Taylor Spatial Frame (TSF) in 10 patients with recurrent ulceration and deformity. There are 2 female and 8 male patients in this cohort. Appropriate TSF module was chosen for each patient– a long bone module for ankle and hindfoot deformities (4 patients) and a forefoot 6x6 butt frame (6 patients) for foot deformities. An osteotomy through the midfoot was performed in all chronic stable foot deformity cases. In the ankle and hindfoot deformities, a combination of soft tissue distraction correction of equinus and acute correction of hindfoot deformity through a calcaneal osteotomy, were used. Our outcome measures are complete healing of the ulcers and resolution of infection, clinically plantigrade foot and ability to wear regular or diabetic footwear. Complications included eight episodes of pin infection that responded to oral antibiotics only and two pin breakages. We achieved ulcer and infection free plantigrade feet that fit in to regular or diabetic footwear in 9 out of 10 patients. 9 patients remain ulcer and infection free at a minimum of 7 years and maximum of 14 years follow up. Taylor Spatial Frame treatment provides an alternative to conventional surgery in high-risk complex Charcot neuroarthropathy foot and ankle deformities.

How to cite this article: Lahoti O, Abhishetty N, Shetty S. Correction of Foot Deformities from Charcot Arthropathy with the Taylor Spatial Frame: A 7–14-year Follow-up. Strategies Trauma Limb Reconstr 2021;16(2):96–101.

The Charcot Reconstruction Preoperative Prognostic Score's Evaluation with Complication Rate and Functional Outcome

BACKGROUND

Charcot's neuroarthropathy (CN) treatment is still controversial, and the results are controversial. Owing to patient comorbidities, surgical intervention carries a high risk of complications. Thus, foreseeing the possible results of planned treatment is crucial. We retrospectively evaluated the Charcot Reconstruction Preoperative Prognostic Score (CRPPS) in patients with surgically treated CN.

METHODS

Twenty-two feet of 20 patients were included in the study. Two groups were formed according to their CRPPS. Twelve patients with values less than 4 were defined as group A, and eight patients with values of 4 or greater were defined as group B. Mean follow-up was 61 months (range, 5-131 months). Groups were compared according to American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) scores, Foot and Ankle Disability Index (FADI) scores, and complication rates.

RESULTS

Group A and B mean AOFAS scores were 76.83 (range, 71-85) and 70.5 (range, 20-85), respectively. All of the patients were improved according to AOFAS and FADI scores, but no correlation was found with the CRPPS. None of the group A patients required additional intervention, but five patients in group B underwent revision surgery. No amputations were performed.

CONCLUSIONS

The CRPPS is focused on feasibility. The data needed to fill the scoring system is easily obtainable from medical records even retrospectively, and the score is helpful to predict a patient's outcome after CN-related surgery. Herein, CRPPS values of 4 or greater were related to high complication rates and lower functional outcomes.

Risk Reduction and Perioperative Complications in Patients With Diabetes and Multiple Medical Comorbidities Undergoing Charcot Foot Reconstruction

BACKGROUND

Modern patient safety programs focus on medical optimization of patients prior to surgery, regional anesthesia when possible, and hospitalist-orthopedic co-management during the perioperative period.

METHODS

Eighty-five consecutive patients with diabetes and multiple medical comorbidities underwent surgical reconstruction for acquired deformities secondary to Charcot foot arthropathy with circular ring fixation between 2016 and 2019. All patients participated in a standardized risk reduction program that included medical optimization prior to surgery, regional anesthesia whenever possible, and hospitalist-orthopedic co-management during the perioperative period. Charts were retrospectively reviewed for medical comorbidities, complications, and length of stay. The American College of Surgeons (ACS) National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP) Risk Calculator was used to retrospectively calculate their predicted perioperative risk.

RESULTS

On multivariable analysis, longer lengths of stay were associated with low preoperative hemoglobin values (rate ratio [RR], 1.36; P = .01) and congestive heart failure (RR, 1.42; P = .02). There were 22 (26%) complications, though only 10 (12%) were serious. These included acute kidney injury (n = 6), sepsis (n = 2), 1 cardiac event, and 1 pulmonary embolism. Overall, the accuracy of predicting a complication using the ACS NSQIP Risk Calculator was 74% (95% CI, 63%-85%), which was comparable to the accuracy of predicting a complication using only patients' congestive heart failure and pin-tract infection statuses (c = 74%, 95% CI, 62%-86%).

DISCUSSION

Medical optimization of patients with diabetes and multiple medical comorbidities prior to elective complex reconstruction orthopedic surgery allows the surgery to be performed with a predictable risk for perioperative complications. Preoperative anemia and congestive heart failure are associated with longer hospitalizations in this patient group. The ACS NSQIP Risk Calculator appears to be a reliable predictor of complications during the perioperative period. This study demonstrates that reconstructive surgery in this complex patient population can be accomplished with a reasonable exposure to perioperative risk.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, retrospective case series.

A Systematic Review of Angular Deformities in Charcot Neuroarthropathy

Charcot neuroarthropathy of the foot and ankle is associated with periarticular deformities and progressive radiographic changes. There have been studies analyzing the radiographic angulations and deformity progression in Charcot neuroarthropathy deformity. The aim of this paper is to provide systematic review of studies that evaluate foot and ankle radiographic parameters in patients with Charcot neuroarthropathy. A multidatabase search including, medline, EMBASE, Google Scholar, Cochrane Library, Clinicaltrials.gov and reference lists of included studies, was performed from 1980 to 2020. A total of 7 articles were included that analyzed radiographic angulations in Charcot neuroarthropathy deformity. The articles could be categorized into nonoperative angulation measurements, and pre- versus postoperative angulation measurements. The presence of ulcerations and the severity of the Charcot neuroarthropathy deformity were found to result from predominantly sagittal plane deformity. The deformity initiates with medial column collapse and progresses to continual lateral column collapse. Surgical intervention resulting in immediate postoperative improvement in angular measurements, however, without beaming of both the medial and lateral column, there was recurrence of the lateral column deformity. This systematic review of articles analyzing angular deformities in Charcot neuroarthropathy patients, demonstrates the progressive sagittal plane breakdown patterns of Charcot as well as the benefits of surgical intervention.

Success and Survivorship Following Charcot Reconstruction: A Review of 151 Cases

Charcot neuroarthropathy is a debilitating condition that frequently leads to skeletal deformity and pedal ulceration in the insensate foot. Results are often poor and no clear guidelines for surgical management exist. Additionally, amputation rates vary widely making it difficult to accurately inform patients of risks. Few studies have assessed outcomes to identify patients for whom reconstruction is likely to fail. The literature is limited, with small sample sizes and mortality infrequently addressed. We performed a retrospective observational study of patients with Charcot neuroarthropathy to assess overall amputation and mortality rates at 30 days, 1 year, and 3 years postreconstruction and evaluated associated risk factors. Rates of infection, re-ulceration, and return to walking were also assessed. We identified 151 patients over a 5-year period. Demographic and clinical characteristics were collected. Descriptive statistics, Cox proportional hazard model, and logistic regression were used. Overall, 22 (14.6%) patients died, and 23 (15.2%) patients advanced to limb amputation postoperatively. End-stage renal disease, peripheral vascular disease, reconstruction during active phase Charcot process, and reconstruction at the ankle or subtalar joint were all associated with poor outcomes. The risk of mortality was 2.5 times higher in patients with end-stage renal disease, and 3.4 times higher among patients with peripheral vascular disease. Patients with ankle or subtalar joint reconstruction were 70% less likely to return to walking compared to medial column reconstruction. Due to these findings, we suggest that patients with such comorbidities be advised of increased risk for complications including failure to return to walking, amputation, and death.

Charcot Arthropathy of Foot and Ankle: Radiographic and Clinical Patterns with Related Outcomes

PURPOSE

Our aim is to retrospectively review and evaluate the patterns of affection of Charcot arthropathy of foot and ankle.

METHODS

Two hundred twenty-eight patients (235 feet) with post-acute Charcot were reviewed and classified anatomically through plain radiographs into type I and type II based on single or multiple regions affected, respectively. Type I included ankle, Lisfranc (tarsometatarsal), naviculocuneiform, forefoot, and hindfoot which includes one of the following: talonavicular joint, calcaneocuboid joint, or calcaneus. Type II included peritalar, perinavicular, mid-tarsal Charcot, or any other combination. Both types were further classified into four stages (A, stable with no deformity; B, stable with deformity; C, unstable; and D, deformity/instability with associated mechanical ulcers).

RESULTS

The most common type was type IIC (27.2%) followed by type IID (18.3%), while types IA and IIA represented the least common types (3.4% and 3.8%, respectively). Types IA and IIA were managed conservatively. All patients in types IC, ID, IIB, IIC, and IID and the majority of type IB received fusion surgery to achieve stability and correction of deformity. Type II D had the highest complication rate (30%). Five patients ended up with amputation, and all were stage IID.

CONCLUSION

Affection of single region has better prognosis than affection of two or more regions. Stage A has the best prognosis and can be managed conservatively provided good diabetes control. Surgery is indicated in all cases of types IC, ID, IIB, IIC, and IID to achieve stability and correction of deformity and prevent complications. Mechanical ulcer (stage D) carries the worst prognosis and highest complication rate.

The use of circular frame external fixation in the treatment of ankle/hindfoot Charcot Neuroarthropathy

Charcot Neuroarthropathy (CN) of the ankle/hindfoot is a devastating condition that results in a loss of alignment, bony malleolar protrusions and frequently leads to ulceration, infection, and amputation. Major limb amputations in this patient population has a 5-year mortality rate approximating 39%-68%. The treatment goal for CN of the ankle/hindfoot is to provide stability with a plantigrade foot that is infection free, shoeable and allows independent weight bearing. The use of a circular frame external fixator is often required when treating patients with CN of the ankle/hindfoot because they often present late with deformity, soft tissue compromise and infection which are contraindications to primary internal fixation. These patients require urgent surgical attention to salvage the limb or risk amputation. In this narrative review article we will discuss the indications, management options, surgical technique, evidence and describe our experience in the use of circular frame external fixation in patients with ankle/hindfoot Charcot Neuroarthropathy.

The "Balgrist Score" for evaluation of Charcot foot: a predictive value for duration of off-loading treatment

OBJECTIVE

To develop a new magnetic resonance imaging(MRI) scoring system for evaluation of active Charcot foot and to correlate the score with a duration of off-loading treatment ≥ 90 days.

METHODS

An outpatient clinic database was searched retrospectively for MRIs of patients with active Charcot foot who completed off-loading treatment. Images were assessed by two radiologists (readers 1 and 2) and an orthopedic surgeon (reader 3). Sanders/Frykberg regions I-V were evaluated for soft tissue edema, bone marrow edema, erosions, subchondral cysts, joint destruction, fractures, and overall regional manifestation using a score according to degree of severity (0-3 points). Intraclass correlations (ICC) for interreader agreement and receiver operating characteristic analysis between MR findings and duration of off-loading-treatment were calculated.

RESULTS

Sixty-five feet in 56 patients (34 men) with a mean age of 62.4 years (range: 44.5-85.5) were included. Region III (reader 1/reader 2: 93.6/90.8%) and region II (92.3/90.8%) were most affected. The most common findings in all regions were soft tissue edema and bone marrow edema. Mean time between MRI and cessation of off-loading-treatment was 150 days (range: 21-405). The Balgrist Score was defined in regions II and III using soft tissue edema, bone marrow edema, joint destruction, and fracture. Interreader agreement for Balgrist Score was excellent: readers 1/2: ICC 0.968 (95% CI: 0.948, 0.980); readers 1/2/3: ICC 0.856 (0.742, 0.917). A cutoff of ≥ 9.0 points in Balgrist Score (specificity 72%, sensitivity 66%) indicated a duration of off-loading treatment ≥ 90 days.

CONCLUSION

The Balgrist Score is a new MR scoring system for assessment of active Charcot foot with excellent interreader agreement. The Balgrist Score can help to identify patients with off-loading treatment ≥ 90 days.

The role of genetic factors and monocyte-to-osteoclast differentiation in the pathogenesis of Charcot neuroarthropathy

Charcot neuroarthropathy is a chronic, progressive condition of the skeletal system that affects some patients with diabetic neuropathy. It results in progressive destruction of bones of the foot and disorganisation of pedal joints and ligaments. Effective prevention and treatment for Charcot neuroarthropathy remain a challenge. Currently, there are no reliable repeatable markers to identify patients with diabetes who are at higher risk of developing Charcot neuroarthropathy. The pathogenesis underlying the development of Charcot neuroarthropathy also remains unclear. In this review, we provide an overview of the history, prevalence, symptoms, risk factors, diagnostics and treatment of Charcot neuroarthropathy. We also discuss the potential for OPG and RANKL gene variants to act as predictive markers for the development of Charcot neuroarthropathy. Finally, we summarise the latest research on the role of monocyte-to-osteoclast differentiation in the development of acute Charcot neuroarthropathy.

Treatment of Ankle and Hindfoot Charcot Arthropathy

It is now well accepted that diabetic patients with clinically and radiographically nonplantigrade Charcot foot arthropathy are best managed with correction of the acquired deformity. Several investigations have demonstrated a high probability for a favorable clinical outcome when the deformity is in the midfoot. Unstable deformity at the subtalar or ankle joints portends a far worse clinical outcome. The goal of this discussion was to describe the author's approach to this highly challenging clinical problem.

Surgical treatment of midfoot Charcot neuroarthropathy with osteomyelitis in patients with diabetes: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

A wide range of clinical presentations of Charcot neuroarthropathy of the foot with concomitant osteomyelitis in patients with diabetes has been described. Existing literature provides an equally diverse list of treatment options. The purpose of this systematic review was to assess the outcomes specifically for the surgical management of midfoot Charcot neuroarthropathy with osteomyelitis in patients with diabetes.

METHOD

A systematic review was conducted by three independent reviewers using the following databases and search engines: Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), Cochrane Library, EMBASE (Excerpta Medica dataBASE), Google Scholar, Ovid, PubMed and Scopus. Search terms used were: Charcot neuroarthropathy, osteoarthropathy, neuro-osteoarthropathy, neurogenic arthropathy, osteomyelitis, midfoot, foot, ankle, diabetes mellitus, ulceration, wound, infection, surgical offloading, diabetic reconstruction, internal fixation, external fixation. Studies meeting the following criteria were included: English language studies, studies published from 1997-2017, patients with diabetes mellitus surgically treated for Charcot neuroarthropathy of the midfoot (specified location) with concomitant osteomyelitis, with or without internal and/or external fixation, follow-up period of six months or more postoperatively, documentation of healing rates, complications, and need for revisional surgery. Studies which were entirely literature reviews, descriptions of surgical-only technique and/or cadaveric studies, patients without diabetes, studies that did not specify location of osteomyelitis and Charcot neuroarthropathy, and treatment proximal to and including Chopart's/midtarsal joint specifically talonavicular, calcaneocuboid, subtalar, ankle were excluded.

RESULTS

A total of 13 selected studies, with a total of 114 patients with diabetes of which 56 had surgical treatment for midfoot Charcot neuroarthropathy with osteomyelitis, met the above inclusion criteria and were used for data extraction.

CONCLUSION

Surgical intervention for midfoot Charcot neuroarthropathy with osteomyelitis in patients with diabetes demonstrated a relatively high success rate for a range of procedures including debridement with simple exostectomy, arthrodesis with or without internal or external fixation, and advanced soft tissue reconstruction. However, this systematic review emphasises the need for larger, better designed studies to investigate the efficacy and failure rates of surgical treatment in this group of patients.

Tibia Fracture in Staged Limb Salvage Using External Ring Fixation and Intramedullary Nailing: A Report of Two Cases

Limb salvage for Charcot's neuroarthropathy has been shown to have high complication and failure rates. The aim of our report of two cases it to present a unique complication encountered with staged limb salvage for Charcot's neuroarthropathy. In two cases, patients developed delayed tibial shaft fracture associated with previous wire placement despite insertion of locked intramedullary nail fixation that spanned the delayed fracture. Both patients experienced fractures following advancement of weight after definitive fixation. In both patients, there was noted complication with the sites of the pins and revision of external fixation before fracture. In each case, the fracture was within the construct of the intramedullary fixation and successfully treated with an extended course of nonweightbearing. Complications of external fixation and intramedullary fixation are well reported within the literature; however, tibia fracture is rare. Based on these cases, it would seem prudent to recognize the risk of delayed pin-site complications and ensure adequate length of intramedullary fixation to span the potential areas of stress.

Orthoplastic Approach for Surgical Treatment of Diabetic Foot Ulcers

Diabetic foot ulcers remain a challenge to practitioners and costly to health care systems. They range from simple to complex and many treatment options are available. By following standard wound care protocols to ensure adequate blood supply, infection control, debridement, wound management, and offloading many diabetic foot ulcers heal in a timely fashion. For those that do not, an underlying foot and ankle musculoskeletal abnormality must be suspected and treated concomitantly with soft tissue treatment. This article presents a systematic orthoplastics approach for surgical treatment of diabetic foot ulcers using the soft tissue reconstructive ladder and the musculoskeletal reconstructive matrix.

Charcot Reconstruction: Understanding and Treating the Deformed Charcot Neuropathic Arthropathic Foot

With worsening diet and increasing prevalence of diabetes, patient encounters with Charcot neuropathic arthropathy (CNA) are expected to increase. Without intervention, the pathology progresses with further subluxation/dislocation and fracture, placing soft tissues at risk of preulceration or formal ulceration, infection, and potentially major amputation. The need to avoid amputation is of paramount importance. Although a formal single eradicating tool for CNA is lacking, there is capacity to intervene in ways that may curtail the pace of destruction. This article reviews understanding of the disease process and provides guidance to surgical reconstruction of the deformity.

Ankle fusion following failed initial treatment of complex ankle fractures in neuropathic diabetics

BACKGROUND

Unstable ankle fractures in diabetics with peripheral neuropathy have an increased risk of postoperative complications, often leading to amputation. Primary ankle arthrodesis has been suggested as an alternative when acceptable reduction and mechanical stabilization cannot be obtained.

METHODS

Over a fourteen year period, thirteen diabetic patients with peripheral neuropathy underwent an attempt at primary ankle arthrodesis following the early post-fracture development of acute neuropathic (Charcot) deformity of the ankle after sustaining a low energy unstable ankle fracture. Eight patients with open wounds and osteomyelitis underwent single stage debridement of the osteomyelitis and primary ankle fusion with an ankle fusion construct circular external fixator. Five patients without evidence of infection underwent primary arthrodesis with a retrograde locked intramedullary nail used for fixation. A successful clinical outcome was achieved with either successful radiographic arthrodesis or stable pseudarthrosis, when community ambulation was achieved with commercially-available therapeutic footwear and a short ankle orthosis.

RESULTS

Eight of the thirteen patients achieved a successful clinical outcome at a mean follow-up of 48 (range 12-136) months following the initial surgery. Three achieved clinical stability following a second surgery and one following a third. One patient with radiographic nonunion expired due to unrelated causes. One patient underwent transtibial amputation due to persistent infection. Of the five patients with failure of radiographic union, three successfully ambulated in the community with a short ankle orthosis. Postoperative complications included wound and pin-site infection, infected nonunion, chronic wounds, and tibial stress fracture.

CONCLUSION

In spite of the high risk for complications and initial failure, primary ankle fusion is a reasonable option for diabetic neuropathic patients who develop acute neuropathic arthropathy following ankle fracture.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV retrospective case series.

Foot Shape and Asymmetry in the Charcot Foot: Assessment Using the Foot Posture Index

BACKGROUND

Charcot neuroarthropathy (CN), or the Charcot foot, is a complication usually associated with diabetes that frequently results in changes in foot shape and structure that have an effect on function and risk of ulceration. This study aimed to assess foot shape and asymmetry in CN using the Foot Posture Index (FPI-6).

METHODS

Case notes of patients with CN seen in a diabetic orthotic clinic were reviewed, and available FPI-6 data were analyzed. A comparison group of patients with diabetes without CN was also identified. Groups were compared according to published ranges of foot posture and asymmetry using the Fisher exact test.

RESULTS

Twenty-seven patients with CN with 28 affected feet and a comparison group of 27 patients with diabetes only were identified. There was large variation in FPI-6 scores in affected (1 to 12) and unaffected (-1 to 10) feet. Mean scores for affected feet (6.82) and unaffected feet (5.05) differed significantly (P = .005). Considering all FPI-6 scores as positive numbers to indicate mean absolute difference between affected and unaffected feet, CN-affected feet differed by a mean of 3.00 points from unaffected feet. Patients in the CN group were less likely to have asymmetry in the normal range than the comparison group (P = .0146).

CONCLUSIONS

This study provides new data on foot shape after CN. Patients with CN have feet that are significantly asymmetrical, and the affected foot may be more pronated or supinated. Feet affected by CN are characterized by shape, which is more frequently outside the normal range. The FPI-6 may be suitable for more widespread use in assessment and outcome measurement.

Deformity and Clinical Outcomes Following Operative Correction of Charcot Ankle

BACKGROUND:

Deformity associated with Charcot foot arthropathy leads to a poor quality of life in affected individuals. Deformity in the midfoot appears to be predictive of clinical outcomes following operative correction. The goal of this retrospective study was to determine if that same methodology could be applied to patients treated for Charcot foot arthropathy involving the ankle joint.

METHODS:

Fifty-six consecutive patients underwent operative reconstruction of Charcot foot deformity involving the ankle joint by a single surgeon over a 14-year period. Preoperative patient characteristics and tibiotalar alignment, were recorded. Surgical treatment included single-stage debridement of active infection and ankle arthrodesis with application of a circular external fixator when infection was present (39 of 56, 69.6%) or retrograde locked intramedullary nailing in the absence of infection (17 of 56, 30.3%). Clinical outcomes were graded based on limb salvage, resolution of infection and chronic wounds, and the ability to ambulate with therapeutic footwear or accommodative orthoses. The average follow-up was 7.5 (range 1.1-14.0) years.

RESULTS:

One patient died at 134.3 weeks following surgery of unrelated causes and 8 underwent amputation. Twenty-eight of 56 patients (50.0%) achieved a favorable (excellent or good) clinical outcome. There was no significant association between pre- or postoperative alignment and clinical outcomes. Insulin-dependent diabetics were approximately 3 times more likely to have a poor clinical outcome.

CONCLUSIONS:

Operative correction of Charcot deformity involving the ankle joint was associated with a high complication rate and risk for failure. The lessons learned from this highly comorbid patient population with complex deformities can be used as a benchmark for applying modern surgical techniques.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE:

Level IV, case series.

Salient features and outcomes of Charcot foot - An often-overlooked diabetic complication: A 17-year-experience at a diabetic center in Bangkok

BACKGROUND

Charcot foot is a rare but a serious diabetic condition. Recognition of this often overlooked condition to provide timely and proper management is important for a better prognosis. Limited data on Charcot foot was available in Asians.

AIMS

The aim of this study is to describe salient features and outcomes of Charcot foot in Thai patients.

METHOD

We presented our experience of 40 cases of Charcot foot patients who were treated from 2000 to 2016 at Theptarin Hospital, Bangkok, Thailand.

RESULTS

A total of 40 Charcot foot patients were identified (13 acute, 27 chronic; mean age 58.7 ± 10.2 years; duration of diabetes 18.0 ± 8.8 years; T2DM 95%). The average serum HbA1c level was 9.2 ± 1.9%. While acute Charcot foot was frequently misdiagnosed as cellulitis in almost one-third of patients, osteomyelitis was a leading cause of misdiagnosis in 15% of chronic Charcot foot patients. Ulcer-free rate at 6 and 12 months were observed in 60% and 58% of patients, respectively. The mortality rate was 13% during a median follow-up period of 57 months. Only 61% of the patients resumed walking normally while almost one-fourth of them were wheelchair-bound.

CONCLUSIONS

Charcot foot in Thai patients mainly developed in long-standing poorly controlled type 2 diabetes with neuropathy, and presented late in the course of the disease. It was often misdiagnosed resulting in improper management and poor outcome which included amputation.