Anatomical anterior and posterior reconstruction for scapholunate dissociation: preliminary outcome in ten patients

One-Year Outcomes of the Anatomical Front and Back Reconstruction for Scapholunate Dissociation

PURPOSE

Anatomical front and back (ANAFAB) reconstruction addresses the critical volar and dorsal ligaments associated with scapholunate dissociation. We hypothesized that patients with symptomatic, chronic, late-stage scapholunate dissociation would demonstrate improvements in all radiographic parameters and patient-reported outcomes (PROMs) after ANAFAB reconstruction.

METHODS

From 2018 to 2021, 21 ANAFAB reconstructions performed by a single surgeon were followed prospectively, with 20 patients having a minimum follow-up of 12 months. In total, 17 men and four women were included, with an average age of 49 years. Three patients had modified Garcia-Elias stage 3 disease, eight stage 4, seven stage 5, and three stage 7. ANAFAB reconstruction of intrinsic and extrinsic ligament stabilizers was performed using a hybrid synthetic tape/tendon graft in a transosseous reconstruction. Pre- and postoperative radiographic parameters, grip, pinch strength, the Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation, PROMIS Upper Extremity Function, and PROMIS Pain Interference outcome measures were compared.

RESULTS

Mean follow-up was 17.9 months (range: 12-38). Radiographic parameters were improved at follow-up, including the following: scapholunate angle (mean 75.3° preoperatively to 69.2°), scapholunate gap (5.9-4.2 mm), dorsal scaphoid translation (1.2-0.2 mm), and radiolunate angle (13.5° to 1.8°). Mean Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation scores for pain and function decreased from 40.6 before surgery to 10.4. We were unable to detect a significant difference in grip or pinch strength or radioscaphoid angle with the numbers tested. There were two minor complications, and two complications required re-operations, one patient who was converted to a proximal row carpectomy for failure of fixation, and one who required tenolysis/arthrolysis for arthrofibrosis.

CONCLUSIONS

At 17.9-month average follow-up, radiographic and patient-reported outcome parameters improved after reconstruction of the critical dorsal and volar ligament stabilizers of the proximal carpal row with the ANAFAB technique.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Open Volar STT Ligament Reconstruction to Augment the Mathoulin's Arthroscopic Dorsal Capsuloligamentous Reconstruction: Technique Description and Case Reports

Background  The results of Mathoulin's arthroscopic dorsal capsuloligamentous reconstruction (ADCLR) are excellent in many patients with scapholunate instability, though less consistently good in higher grade instabilities. The purpose of this article is to describe a novel technique of volar scaphotrapeziotrapezoid (STT) reconstruction which may be used to augment rotational control of the scaphoid, in conjunction with the ADCLR, for use in European Wrist Arthroscopy Society (EWAS) grade IV/V instabilities. Description of Technique  Following completion of ADCLR, the STT joint is approached through the flexor carpi radialis sheath. The palmaris longus tendon is harvested. Fluoroscopy is used to site guide wires for tunnel placement in the distal scaphoid and the proximal trapezium; 3.5-mm tunnels are overdrilled in both bones, to a depth of 8 mm. The palmaris graft is then anchored in the scaphoid tunnel with a mini-DX SwiveLock anchor. The graft is tensioned, then anchored in the trapezium tunnel with another anchor. Patients and Methods  We retrospectively selected two young men heavy manual workers who had this procedure more than 12 months previously for scapholunate instability, with static radiographic abnormalities and a drive through sign (EWAS grade V). The patients were reviewed after 12 months, for assessment of visual analog scale, quick disabilities of the arm, shoulder, and hand, and patient-rated wrist/hand evaluation scores, range of motion, and grip strength. Results  Both patients had marked improvements of wrist comfort and function at 1 year, and were able to return to their normal duties at work and complete all activities of daily living with minimal symptoms. Conclusion  This volar STT reconstruction may expand the success of the Mathoulin's ADCLR into higher grade instabilities.

Anatomical front and back reconstruction sustains radiographic alignment: a comparison to three-ligament tenodesis

Multiple techniques exist to reconstruct the scapholunate interosseous ligament, though none have demonstrated superiority. This study compares 1-year radiographic outcomes of the three-ligament tenodesis and the anatomical front and back reconstruction. All patients who underwent reconstruction of their scapholunate interosseous ligament at one institution with either anatomical front and back reconstruction or three-ligament tenodesis between 2011 and 2020 were retrospectively reviewed. At 52-week follow-up, anatomical front and back reconstruction maintained a statistically significant improvement in scapholunate gap, corrected radiolunate angle and dorsal scaphoid translation, while three-ligament tenodesis demonstrated no sustained improvement in any parameter. The improvement in dorsal scaphoid translation was significantly greater for patients undergoing anatomical front and back reconstruction compared with three-ligament tenodesis at the 16-weeks postoperative timepoint (-1.0 mm, -0.3 mm). Anatomical front and back reconstruction demonstrates sustained improvement in radiographic outcomes at 1 year when compared with three-ligament tenodesis. By addressing both volar and dorsal critical ligament restraints, adoption of anatomical front and back reconstruction for advanced stage scapholunate interosseous ligament injuries should be considered.Level of evidence: IV.

Scapholunate Instability: Diagnosis and Management - Classification and Treatment Considerations - Part 2

Intervention for scapholunate instability is aimed at halting the degenerative process by restoring ligament integrity and normalizing carpal kinematics. Part 1 of this Current Concepts article reviewed the anatomy, kinematics, and biomechanical properties of the scapholunate ligament as well as its critical stabilizers. In this section, we provide a foundation for understanding the spectrum of scapholunate ligament instability and incorporate meaningful new anatomical insights that influence treatment considerations. These updates clarify the importance of the critical stabilizers of the scapholunate interval, ligament-specific considerations in scapholunate ligament reconstruction, and the risks of ligament disinsertion when surgically exposing the dorsal wrist. We propose a ligament-based treatment algorithm based on the stage of injury, degree and nature of ligament damage, and presence of arthritic changes.

Osteolysis After Augmented Scapholunate Ligament Reconstruction: A Report of 3 Cases

CASE

Augmented scapholunate ligament reconstruction using polyether ether ketone anchors and ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene synthetic tape has the theoretical advantage of improved stability, avoidance of K-wire fixation, and the potential for earlier mobilization. We present 3 cases of scaphoid and lunate osteolysis/fragmentation, operative and histologic findings at reoperation, and the sequelae of this technique.

CONCLUSION

If planning to use suture anchors and synthetic tapes in small carpal bones, we recommend advising patients about the risk of osteolysis and monitoring closely patients who complain of pain with motion after surgery.

All-Dorsal Arthroscopic Ligamentoplasty (ADAL) in Scapholunate Instability Management: Surgical Technique

In advanced scapholunate instability, a scapholunate repair by open or arthroscopic ligamentoplasty is indicated. Although the radiographic results and functional scores are more or less satisfactory for open ligamentoplasty, it is often responsible for a decrease in joint amplitude postoperatively. Arthroscopic techniques are therefore of great interest, since they respect the joint capsule, but they remain technically difficult and demanding surgeries, requiring a good deal of experience in arthroscopy and using bone tunnels that are potentially a source of complications, as well as pinning to the palmar side of the wrist, which is potentially dangerous for the palmar structures of the wrist. We present a surgical technique of scapholunate ligamentoplasty under arthroscopy, focusing only on the dorsal scapholunate complex: all-dorsal arthroscopic ligamentoplasty. The advantages of all-dorsal arthroscopic ligamentoplasty are that it requires little material, does away with palmar approaches, and focuses only on the dorsal side, simplifying surgery and avoiding the creation of bone tunnels potentially at risk of fracture or avascular necrosis.

Collapse after Carpal Bone Tunneling. An Underreported Complication?

PURPOSE

To report the complication of carpal bone tunnel collapse in scapholunate reconstruction.

METHODS

The authors present six cases of carpal collapse or bone necrosis after bone tunneling for ligamentous reconstruction, three in the scaphoid bone and three in the lunate.

RESULTS

All six cases were secondary to ligament reconstruction for chronic scapholunate dissociations, none of which had preoperative structural scaphoid or lunate deformities.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the incidence of this occurrence is unknown, the consequences could be substantial; therefore, patients should be warned of this possibility when discussing complications of ligament reconstruction for chronic scapholunate instability requiring the creation of a bone tunnel.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic V.

InternalBrace for Intercarpal Ligament Reconstruction

Scapholunate and lunotriquetral instability are common causes of chronic, debilitating wrist pain and functional impairment. In the setting of subacute or chronic injuries with predynamic or dynamic instability, the ideal surgical approach remains unclear. In January 2020 the authors started enrolling patients with predynamic and dynamic instability in an Institutional Review Board-approved prospective study, aimed at meticulously studying outcomes using the all-dorsal InternalBrace reconstruction technique. The all-dorsal technique described herein is straightforward, efficient, and easy to learn, with early outcomes equivalent or superior to those of other techniques.

Arthroscopy-Assisted Scapholunate Reconstruction With Internal Brace Augmentation

Various surgical techniques exist to repair or reconstruct complete scapholunate (SL) interosseous ligament tears, including capsulodesis, static or dynamic tenodesis, ligament reconstruction with tendon graft, bone-retinaculum-bone reconstruction, and the reduction and association of the scaphoid and lunate (RASL) procedure. The choice of surgical technique depends on arthroscopic assessment using the Geissler classification and European Wrist Arthroscopy Society staging of SL injury. This article describes arthroscopy-assisted extracapsular SL reconstruction using free tendon graft and internal brace augmentation for the treatment of unrepairable complete SL interosseous ligament tears.

Long-term Results of the Treatment of Scapholunate Instability with Dynamic Extensor Carpi Radialis Brevis Tenodesis

Scapholunate dissociation is the most common form of carpal instability. This retrospective case series aimed to assess long-term results obtained by treating scapholunate instability with dynamic tenodesis using the entire extensor carpi radialis brevis tendon, which is detached from the base of the third metacarpal, rerouted in the third extensor compartment, and fixed at the distal portion of the scaphoid to maintain reduced rotatory subluxation.

Methods

Nine patients with scapholunate instability were treated. We reviewed eight patients with a mean follow-up of 12 years. One subgroup of four patients was affected by static scapholunate instability, and the other by dynamic scapholunate instability. Disability of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand score, Patient Rated Wrist Evaluation score, modified Mayo score, and radiographs were used to determine functional and anatomical outcomes.

Results

Excellent functional results did not correlate with radiological outcome in patients with static scapholunate instability. In this subgroup, scapholunate angle and gap and radiolunate angle improved in average but remained in the pathologic range. In only one of these patients, osteoarthritis was observed. In the subgroup of patients affected by dynamic instability, very good functional outcomes correlate with radiological results, except in one patient who developed arthritic changes.

Conclusions

Dynamic tethering of the scaphoid with the extensor carpi radialis brevis tendon might be indicated in the treatment not only in patients affected by dynamic scapholunate instability but also in patients with static instability. Prospective studies with a larger number of patients are required to evaluate this method.

Current Concepts in Scapholunate Instability Without Arthritic Changes

Scapholunate instability (SLI) is the most common carpal instability described. SLI leads to a degenerative arthritic pattern known as scapholunate advanced collapse (SLAC). Diagnosis of SLI can be challenging in pre-dynamic and dynamic stages. CT arthrogram, MR arthrogram and dynamic fluoroscopy are helpful in diagnosis while arthroscopy remains the gold standard. SLI is a multi-ligament injury, which involves not only the scapholunate interosseous ligament (SLIL) but also the extrinsic carpal ligaments. Hence, it is better described as an injury compromising the 'dorsal scapholunate(dSLL) complex'. A repair can be attempted for acute SLI presenting within 6 weeks of injury. Reconstruction is the mainstay of treatment for chronic SLI without degenerative changes. Multiple repair techniques have been described which include capsulodesis and tenodesis procedures. The clinical outcomes of the techniques have improved over the years. However, a common problem of all these techniques is the lack of long-term data on the outcomes and deteriorating radiological parameters over time. SLI staging is an important factor to be considered in choosing the reconstruction techniques for a better outcome. Currently, there is a trend towards more biological and less invasive techniques. Regardless of the technique, it is important to preserve the nerve supply of the dorsal capsuloligamentous structures of the wrist. Arthroscopic techniques being minimally invasive have the advantage of less collateral damage to the capsuloligamentous structures. Rehabilitation involves a team approach where a protected dart thrower's motion is allowed after a period of immobilization. Strengthening SL-friendly muscles and inhibiting SL-unfriendly muscles is a key principle in rehabilitation.

Wide arthroscopic dorsal capsuloligamentous repair in patients with severe scapholunate instability

A conventional arthroscopic capsuloligamentous repair is a reliable surgical solution in most patients with scapholunate instability. However, this repair does not seem to be sufficient for more advanced injuries. The aim of this study was to evaluate the functional results of a wide arthroscopic dorsal capsuloligamentous repair (WADCLR) in the management of severe scapholunate instability. This was a prospective single-centre study undertaken between March 2019 and May 2021. The primary outcome was the evaluation of the reduction of the radiological deformity and the functional outcomes after WADCLR. A secondary outcome was the evaluation of the effectiveness of this technique in patients with the most severe instability (European Wrist Arthroscopy Society (EWAS) stage 5). The patients were reviewed postoperatively at three, six, and 12 months. The study included 112 patients (70 male and 42 female). Their mean age was 31.6 years (16 to 55). A total of three patients had EWAS stage 3A injuries, 12 had stage 3B injuries, 29 had stage 3C injuries, 56 had stage 4 injuries, and 12 had stage 5 injuries. There was a significant improvement of the radiological signs in all patients with a return to normal values. There was also a significant improvement in all aspects of function except for flexion, in which the mean increase was negligible (0.18° on average). There was also a significant improvement in all criteria for patients with a stage 5 injury, except for some limitation of extension, flexion, and radial and ulnar deviation, although these showed a trend towards improvement (except for flexion). WADCLR is a minimally invasive, easy, and reproducible technique with few complications, offering a clear improvement in function and a reduction in the radiological deformity at one year postoperatively.

Scapholunate instability: why are the surgical outcomes still so far from ideal?

The wrist is a universal joint with intrinsic and extrinsic ligaments that function and fail as ligamentous complexes. Those related to scapholunate instability (SLI) include the dorsal scapholunate complex (DSLC), volar radiolunate complex and scaphotrapeziotrapezoid complex. Together the DSLC, scaphoid and lunate create an 'acetabulum' for the capitate, with the dorsal intercarpal ligament being a labrum to contain the capitate. SLI results from failure of the DSLC, typically from its scaphoid attachments. Failure of the lunate and or triquetral attachments increases the instability. DSLC failure leads to radioscaphoid instability, which is the symptomatic clinical problem. SLI reconstruction with open surgery and trans-osseous tendon graft techniques have been challenging. We discuss a biological arthroscopic approach to identify, mobilize and debride the disrupted DSLC. This ligament/capsular/periosteum sheet is then advanced and secured to the debrided footprint. Thereby reconstituting the acetabulum, labrum and scaphoid stability.

InternalBrace for Intercarpal Ligament Reconstruction

SUMMARY

Intercarpal ligament injuries such as scapholunate and lunotriquetral tears are common causes of wrist pain. There is no shortage of surgical techniques to address these injuries, nor is there a lack of literature exploring this topic. However, research progress has not led to a consensus regarding the optimal management of subacute and chronic injuries without articular wear. The senior author (K.C.C.) has performed the spectrum of reconstructive techniques, including dorsal and volar approaches, tendon weaves, ligament tenodesis procedures, reduction and association procedures, and bone-ligament-bone techniques. In the absence of convincing, consistent outcomes, the authors began investigating a novel all-dorsal reconstructive technique using the Arthrex InternalBrace system. The complexity and unpredictable outcomes associated with traditional ligament tenodesis procedures led them to adopt the all-dorsal InternalBrace technique as their primary reconstructive approach. The authors have performed more than 20 procedures with this technique since 2019. In an average tourniquet time of under 60 minutes, they are able to achieve predictable carpal stabilization, pain relief, and restoration of motion. This is the preferred reconstructive approach of the senior author.

CMC Mimickers: Differential Diagnosis and Work-Up for Radial-Sided Wrist Pain

In patients with radial-sided wrist pain, a myriad of possible etiologies exists and as such, a detailed history, examination, and, where indicated, imaging is obtained to try and aid with its diagnosis. The purpose of this article is to provide an overview of radial-sided wrist pain, diagnostic modalities and discuss current treatment options. More detailed information is out-of-scope for this article and if needed, we would guide the reader to seek out other selected texts, as indicated.

Traumatic Nondissociative Carpal Instability: A Case Series

PURPOSE

We report 8 cases of acute or subacute unilateral nondissociative carpal instability (CIND) in the context of nondisplaced scaphoid fractures.

METHODS

Eight patients from 3 centers developed abnormal volar intercalated segment instability (VISI) or dorsal intercalated segment instability (DISI) following the diagnosis of a nondisplaced scaphoid fracture. An operative inspection in each patient confirmed intact scapholunate and lunotriquetral interosseous ligaments. We outline the demographic characteristics of our patient cohort, radiologic and operative findings of CIND-DISI and CIND-VISI, and the outcomes of acute and delayed treatment.

RESULTS

Two patients were diagnosed with CIND-DISI and 6 with CIND-VISI associated with ipsilateral nondisplaced scaphoid fractures. The average time from injury to diagnosis of CIND was 11 weeks, and the mean clinical and radiographic follow-up was 18 months. Rapid healing of the scaphoid fractures was achieved in all patients (4 open reduction internal fixation, 4 cast). All patients underwent surgery to improve proximal carpal row alignment: in 3 of the 4 patients who were diagnosed and treated surgically within 12 weeks of injury, the radiolunate angle (RLA) was successfully restored. A contracture release and ligament repair or reconstruction with tendon graft 12 or more weeks following injury was unsuccessful in restoring proximal row alignment in all 4 patients. Two patients in the delayed treatment group required secondary surgery for partial fusion.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on the arthroscopic, imaging, and operative findings, we propose that the ligamentous restraints to CIND-VISI are dorsal at the radiocarpal joint and volar at the midcarpal joint. Conversely, the ligamentous restraints to CIND-DISI are dorsal at the midcarpal joint and volar at both the radiocarpal and midcarpal joints. In our series, a delayed diagnosis and late reconstructive surgery were associated with no improvement in RLA. We recommend early recognition of traumatic CIND and prompt treatment of injured ligaments prior to the development of a fixed deformity.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic V.

Comparative Analysis of 3 Techniques of Scapholunate Reconstruction for Dorsal Intercalated Segment Instability

PURPOSE

The combination of scaphoid rotatory subluxation, dorsal intercalated segment instability, and dorsal scaphoid translation (DST) constitutes stage 5 scapholunate dissociation in the modified classification system of Garcia-Elias. The purpose of this study was to compare the static radiographic outcomes of reduction and association of the scaphoid and lunate (RASL), three-ligament tenodesis (TLT), and anatomic front and back (ANAFAB) reconstructions for stage 5 scaphoid and lunate malrotation and translation.

METHODS

Stage 5 scapholunate dissociation was created in 15 fresh-frozen specimens by cutting the scapholunate interosseous ligament, long radiolunate ligament, dorsal intercarpal ligament, and scaphotrapeziotrapezoid ligament complex. Specimens were randomized to receive 1 of the 3 reconstructive techniques. Radiolunate angle (RLA), scapholunate angle, scapholunate gap, and DST were measured in static fluoroscopic posteroanterior and lateral views in 3 conditions: baseline, injured, and reconstructed.

RESULTS

Reduction and association of the scaphoid and lunate showed an improved correction of scapholunate gap compared with TLT and ANAFAB. Anatomic front and back demonstrated an improved correction in RLA and scapholunate angle compared with RASL but not TLT. When the reconstruction was compared with baseline, there was a persistent lunate extension for TLT (RLA and scapholunate angle) and RASL (RLA); however, no significant difference in any parameter was found with ANAFAB. Anatomic front and back significantly improved DST, whereas TLT and RASL did not.

CONCLUSIONS

In this cadaveric model of scapholunate dissociation with dorsal intercalated segment instability and DST, each of the 3 repairs had different effects on carpal posture and alignment. While only RASL statistically improved scapholunate gap, only ANAFAB significantly improved DST. Both TLT and RASL improved radiographic parameters; however, each had a persistent increase in the lunate extension following reconstruction.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

It may be prudent to consider different reconstructive techniques for different stages of scapholunate instability. Anatomic front and back, a repair that addresses both dorsal and volar ligament stabilizers, provides improved reduction of dorsal intercalated segment instability and DST in stage 5 scapholunate dissociation.

The Biomechanical Effects of Augmentation With Flat Braided Suture on Dorsal Intercarpal Ligament Capsulodesis for Scapholunate Instability

PURPOSE

Selecting treatment for scapholunate (SL) instability is notoriously difficult. Many methods of reconstruction have been described, but no procedure demonstrates clear superiority. New methods proposed use internal bracing (IB) with suture anchors and flat braided suture (FBS), alone or as an augmentation with tendon autograft for SL ligament injuries. Our goal was to use computed tomography (CT) to analyze alignment of the SL joint after 3 different modes of fixation of SL instability: after reconstruction with IB incorporating either tendon autograft or the dorsal intercarpal ligament (DICL), or DICL capsulodesis without FBS.

METHODS

Ten fresh-frozen, matched-pair, forearm-to-hand specimens were used. Serial sectioning of the SL stabilizing ligaments was performed and the SL interval was measured with CT. We reconstructed the SL ligament with DICL capsulodesis alone (DICL) or with IB augmented with either tendon autograft (IB plus T) or DICL (DICL plus IB). The SL interval was measured with CT. Specimens underwent 500 weighted cycles on a jig and were reimaged. Differences in SL interval after repair and cycling were compared.

RESULTS

Dorsal intercarpal ligament capsulodesis augmented with IB best maintained the SL interval before and after cycling. Dorsal intercarpal ligament capsulodesis alone was inferior to DICL plus IB and IB plus T both before and after cycling.

CONCLUSIONS

Dorsal intercarpal ligament capsulodesis augmented with IB appears to maintain better SL joint reduction than IB with tendon autograft.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

This work serves as a necessary step for further study of the biomechanical strength and clinical application of FBS technology in the reconstruction of SL instability. Flat braided suture augmentation of DICL capsulodesis may provide another option to consider for reconstruction of SL instability.

Scapholunate ligament 360° procedure

AIMS

The purpose was to evaluate early clinical, patient-reported, and radiological outcomes of the scapholunate ligament 360° tenodesis (SL 360) technique for treatment of scapholunate (SL) instability.

METHODS

We studied the results of nine patients (eight males and one female with a mean age of 44.7 years (26 to 55)) who underwent the SL 360 procedure for reducible SL instability between January 2016 and June 2019, and who were identified from retrospective review of electronic medical records. Final follow-up of any kind was a mean of 33.7 months (12.0 to 51.3). Clinical, radiological, and patient-reported outcome data included visual analogue scale (VAS) for pain, Quick Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (QuickDASH), Mayo Wrist Score (MWS), and Patient-Rated Wrist Examination (PRWE). Means were analyzed using paired t-test.

RESULTS

Before surgery, patients with SL instability were significantly impaired with respect to wrist flexion, extension, and grip strength (mean flexion, 51° (20° to 85°) vs 73° (45° to 90°); mean extension, 46° (15° to 70°) vs 66° (45° to 80°); mean grip strength, 25 kg (20 to 31) vs 50 kg (35 to 68) compared to the unaffected side). The mean SL gap (4.9 mm (2.3 to 7.3) vs 2.1 mm (1.6 to 2.9)) and mean SL angle (71° (59° to 105°) vs 50° (38° to 64°) were also significantly greater in the affected wrist. At final follow-up, there was mean improvement regarding clinical, radiological, and functional outcomes comparing preoperative to final postoperative values for the VAS for pain scale, QuickDASH, MWS, PRWE, and SL gap and SL angle.

CONCLUSION

In our small series, the SL 360 procedure for reducible SL instability has favourable early clinical, patient-reported, and radiological outcomes at a mean of 33.7 months (12.0 to 51.3). The suture tape and tendon construct confers robust stability, permitting earlier mobilization without the inherent disadvantages of Kirschner wire stabilization. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2021;103-B(5):939-945.